2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: QUIETShooter on June 01, 2021, 07:33:01 AM
-
Hawaii bans magazines that can hold more than 10 rounds. I believe this is for handguns. Rifles so far there is no ban on hi capacity magazines.
Except:
Rifles that can be modified and categorized as a pistol. Example: Ruger 10/22
Am I correct? Feel free to correct me as this is how I understand it.
Because if I am correct in my understanding of current laws, it seems there are people, suppliers, and gun store owners who don't.
Much appreciation for information enforcing my understanding of current laws or enlightenment as to why I was erroneous in my understanding.
Reason for thread: There are some suppliers that will let me order 20 rd. magazines and some suppliers that claim it is illegal for me to order these magazines. And no, I'm not trying to order 10/22 hi capacity magazines. :shaka:
-
Suppliers erring on the safe side and do not appreciate standard capacity magazines.
Beyond that, there’s been a number of threads on why some LGSs and even online vendors read the laws. If you need links, I’ll find a few and post links when I have more free time.
-
Legally in Hawaii you can't own "assault pistols". Thus there is no such thing. Once a rifle, always a rifle. No conversions according to the ATF. You must purchase a "pistol" receiver or a non labeled receiver and declare it a pistol. And you must register said receiver under your name, after you do so you will no longer be able to own or purchase standard capacity mags.
-
Someone made a 22 USFA Zipp 22 which takes the ruger 10/22 mags. The product was rubbish and not made anymore for years. This gun is not a rifle or assault rifle, it is a pistol. So because of this, the 10/22 mags will fit into a "pistol" and thus anything over 10rds would be illegal. However, HPD has never enforced this.
-
Legally in Hawaii you can't own "assault pistols". Thus there is no such thing. Once a rifle, always a rifle. No conversions according to the ATF. You must purchase a "pistol" receiver or a non labeled receiver and declare it a pistol. And you must register said receiver under your name, after you do so you will no longer be able to own or purchase standard capacity mags.
HI does have a definition for "assault pistol". So there is such a thing because HI's definition states so regardless of what the feds sate. Even if you were to have an illegal assault pistol, you can still own AR standard cap mags, Because current HRS states "fits into a pistol" and not "fits into a pistol and/or assault pistol". This is why they were trying to change the wording to "fits into a firearm" for the last 2 years of rifle mag bans.
-
HI does have a definition for "assault pistol". So there is such a thing because HI's definition states so regardless of what the feds sate. Even if you were to have an illegal assault pistol, you can still own AR standard cap mags, Because current HRS states "fits into a pistol" and not "fits into a pistol and/or assault pistol". This is why they were trying to change the wording to "fits into a firearm" for the last 2 years of rifle mag bans.
Interesting, though if we went with this and you did register an "AR pistol" under your name that would be both state and federal definition of a pistol. And thus "fits into a pistol language" would apply. If you don't own and can't readily own any "AR pistols" then the language wouldn't apply.
-
Interesting, though if we went with this and you did register an "AR pistol" under your name that would be both state and federal definition of a pistol. And thus "fits into a pistol language" would apply. If you don't own and can't readily own any "AR pistols" then the language wouldn't apply.
Read what I posted again. The state defines what an assault pistol (AR pistol) is. So because of this, when current language states "fits into a pistol", they're referring to just a pistol and not an assault pistol.
Focus
-
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=31635.0
-
Legally in Hawaii you can't own "assault pistols". Thus there is no such thing. Once a rifle, always a rifle. No conversions according to the ATF. You must purchase a "pistol" receiver or a non labeled receiver and declare it a pistol. And you must register said receiver under your name, after you do so you will no longer be able to own or purchase standard capacity mags.
what?
that makes no sense whatsoever...
-
what?
that makes no sense whatsoever...
neither do Hawaii firearms laws
-
Legally in Hawaii you can't own "assault pistols". Thus there is no such thing. Once a rifle, always a rifle. No conversions according to the ATF. You must purchase a "pistol" receiver or a non labeled receiver and declare it a pistol. And you must register said receiver under your name, after you do so you will no longer be able to own or purchase standard capacity mags.
You actually can own "assault pistols" in Hawaii. You just have to have a non-detachable magazine, or be single shot. There are work arounds.
-
You actually can own "assault pistols" in Hawaii. You just have to have a non-detachable magazine, or be single shot. There are work arounds.
some people don't understand this...
-
what?
that makes no sense whatsoever...
Some should learn to stay within their swimlane and not post stuff just because they believe it to be true. It’s one thing to post stuff like that in the political threads, but they don’t belong in the technical sections. JMHO
-
You actually can own "assault pistols" in Hawaii. You just have to have a non-detachable magazine, or be single shot. There are work arounds.
Technically, if you follow the workarounds, you will have converted an assault pistol into just a pistol. Once you weld the mag into the magwell, disable the gas system so it's no longer semi-auto, etc., it no longer conforms, or more accurately never did conform, to the definition of "assault pistol."
"Assault pistol" means a semiautomatic pistol that accepts a detachable magazine and has two or more of the following characteristics:
(1) An ammunition magazine that attaches to the pistol outside of the pistol grip;
(2) A threaded barrel capable of accepting a barrel extender, flash suppressor, forward hand grip, or silencer;
(3) A shroud that is attached to or partially or completely encircles the barrel and permits the shooter to hold the firearm with the second hand without being burned;
(4) A manufactured weight of fifty ounces or more when the pistol is unloaded;
(5) A centerfire pistol with an overall length of twelve inches or more; or
(6) It is a semiautomatic version of an automatic firearm;
but does not include a firearm with a barrel sixteen or more inches in length, an antique pistol as defined in this section, or a curio or relic as those terms are used in 18 United States Code section 921(a)(13) or 27 Code of Federal Regulations section 478.11.
§134-8 Ownership, etc., of automatic firearms, silencers, etc., prohibited; penalties. (a) The manufacture, possession, sale, barter, trade, gift, transfer, or acquisition of any of the following is prohibited: assault pistols, except as provided by section 134-4(e); automatic firearms; rifles with barrel lengths less than sixteen inches; shotguns with barrel lengths less than eighteen inches; cannons; mufflers, silencers, or devices for deadening or muffling the sound of discharged firearms; hand grenades, dynamite, blasting caps, bombs, or bombshells, or other explosives; or any type of ammunition or any projectile component thereof coated with teflon or any other similar coating designed primarily to enhance its capability to penetrate metal or pierce protective armor; and any type of ammunition or any projectile component thereof designed or intended to explode or segment upon impact with its target.
I think the terms "AR Pistol" and "Assault Pistol" are being used interchangeably, when, in practice, you can own an AR Pistol, but not a Assault Pistol.
-
Some should learn to stay within their swimlane and not post stuff just because they believe feel it to be true. It’s one thing to post stuff like that in the political threads, but they don’t belong in the technical sections. JMHO
FIFY
-
People smarter than all of us combined have interpreted the Hawaii gun laws regarding > 10rd mags. The reading of the law as written pretty much bans any rifle mag over 10 rds if a pistol that can accept that mag exists. Not "except if that pistol is banned and can't be legally owned here," and not "if you don't own a pistol the mag fits." If you buy a carbine rifle that accepts 17rd or 30rd Glock 9mm mags, it doesn't matter whether or not you own a 9mm Glock. The simple fact that the mag fits a pistol you can buy from a dealer is all that matters.
AR mags have existed in a "grayish area", due to the banning of AR pistols as manufactured. All factory AR pistols have detachable mags. While the most common method of making an AR pistol HI compliant is to epoxy/weld the mag into the magwell, making it impossible to insert a 20rd or 30rd AR mag, it's not the only method to become compliant. As a side note, once you make the mag nondetachable, the 10rd limit no longer applies, so you could weld a 30rd mag into the pistol and be compliant.
The real underlying difference is enforcement. Cops don't seem to care if you have >10rd mags for your AR rifles. So, they don't bother arresting anyone for it. Since it is such an ambiguous statute when you factor in whether or not the Assault Pistol is illegal to possess, not a home-built AR pistol, they prefer to ignore it.
You can make ANY rifle into a pistol at home. I think the lawmakers were more concerned with factory manufactured pistols. Otherwise, why even tie this law to pistols at all? If any receiver can become a pistol, then all rifle mags over 10rds are prohibited.
Handguns have always been involved in crimes more than rifles. So, this 10rd limit was really about handguns. The rifle/handgun tie-in was so you can't possess >10rd mags legally for a rifle while also owning a pistol that the mag can be used in. But, as usual, the lawmakers created a mess rather than detailing what the intent was. I think it would have been better to do as some people (OG) believe already applies. Make possession of the pistol that accepts your rifle mags of >10rds illegal. If all you have that fits your >10rd mag is a rifle, then no problem.
As written, the statute is ambiguous and confusing. We all assume nobody is going to be charged with >10rd mags unless the mags are used in common factory-built pistols, and it's added as an additional charge to other worse ones.
I'm not a lawyer. This is my summation of the AR Mag conundrum. Take it with a grain of salt.
I personally only take 10rd or smaller capacity mags to the range. Can't load more than 5 rds on the rifle range anyway, and the shorter mag doesn't get in the way as much when shooting at the bench.
As for buying online, it's hit or miss. Some don't want to get involved in potential legal problems. Others feel it's on the buyer to know their laws. I've had buyers who shipped 30rd mags for 10 years suddenly stop. It's just how things are.
-
One of the officers that showed up to some anti-gun legislation is retiring.
https://www.kitv.com/story/44011302/hpd-deputy-chief-of-police-to-retire-after-45-years-of-service (https://www.kitv.com/story/44011302/hpd-deputy-chief-of-police-to-retire-after-45-years-of-service)
-
One of the officers that showed up to some anti-gun legislation is retiring.
https://www.kitv.com/story/44011302/hpd-deputy-chief-of-police-to-retire-after-45-years-of-service (https://www.kitv.com/story/44011302/hpd-deputy-chief-of-police-to-retire-after-45-years-of-service)
Rade Vanic will now serve as the interim Chief of Police.
Sounds like someone from the Avenger comics! :geekdanc:
-
Check out the thread I posted above.
One classic comment:
Go to Kokohead and look up and down the line.
Or an HDF range day.
Or a local gun shop other than SEC. (SEC is awesome but strict on their mag interpretation.)
https://gunmagwarehouse.com/
The grey is in that AR’s cannot be registered as a pistol if the mag is detachable.
Therefore, a detachable AR/AK mag cannot be used in a legal pistol in Hawaii.
There are a bunch of AR pistols in Hawaii with fixed (welded) magazines which are no longer detachable.
There is even a thread on how to make one legal and what methods of securing the mag to the receiver are acceptable to HPD. (Again, kind of a crap shoot.)
10-22 mags are a little trickier because of the Ruger Charger and it’s variants.
-
some people don't understand this...
Amazing but Flapp basically explained it fairly well:
AR mags have existed in a "grayish area", due to the banning of AR pistols as manufactured. All factory AR pistols have detachable mags. While the most common method of making an AR pistol HI compliant is to epoxy/weld the mag into the magwell, making it impossible to insert a 20rd or 30rd AR mag, it's not the only method to become compliant. As a side note, once you make the mag nondetachable, the 10rd limit no longer applies, so you could weld a 30rd mag into the pistol and be compliant.
Aiea followed up:
The grey is in that AR’s cannot be registered as a pistol if the mag is detachable.
Therefore, a detachable AR/AK mag cannot be used in a legal pistol in Hawaii.
There are a bunch of AR pistols in Hawaii with fixed (welded) magazines which are no longer detachable.
There is even a thread on how to make one legal and what methods of securing the mag to the receiver are acceptable to HPD. (Again, kind of a crap shoot.)
-
Some should learn to stay within their swimlane and not post stuff just because they believe it to be true. It’s one thing to post stuff like that in the political threads, but they don’t belong in the technical sections. JMHO
Not really, this has been argued many times. See previous posts which might I add said the same thing but perhaps better worded.
-
Amazing but Flapp basically explained it and Aiea followed up:
The grey is in that AR’s cannot be registered as a pistol if the mag is detachable.
Therefore, a detachable AR/AK mag cannot be used in a legal pistol in Hawaii.
There are a bunch of AR pistols in Hawaii with fixed (welded) magazines which are no longer detachable.
There is even a thread on how to make one legal and what methods of securing the mag to the receiver are acceptable to HPD. (Again, kind of a crap shoot.)
That statement is false. If HPD is saying that's their policy, then they are not following the law.
If you don't make the pistol semi-auto (single-shot bolt-action only, where you cycle it by hand), then you've satisfied the definition and made it HI compliant.
-
That statement is false. If HPD is saying that's their policy, then they are not following the law.
If you don't make the pistol semi-auto (single-shot bolt-action only, where you cycle it by hand), then you've satisfied the definition and made it HI compliant.
Its not an "assault rifle/pistol" if its not semi automatic...
-
One thing of note (at least IMO) is what constitutes compliance. Is it per the HRS? Or per someone in HPD Firearms Division?
Law vs implementation. . .
-
Its not an "assault rifle" if its not semi automatic...
Ok. Where is that stated/documented?
-
Its not an "assault rifle" if its not semi automatic...
Who said anything in this thread about assault rifles?
#NoFocus
-
Ok. Where is that stated/documented?
He's babbling about rifles now. :wacko:
The first line of the "Assault pistol" definition states:
"Assault pistol" means a semiautomatic pistol that accepts a detachable magazine and has two or more of the following characteristics:
So, if you disable/never install a gas system in an AR pistol, it's not semi-auto. Therefore, nothing else in the definition applies.
-
Ok. Where is that stated/documented?
The ATF and the federal/state government:
The definition varies among regulating jurisdictions but usually includes semi-automatic firearms with a detachable magazine, a pistol grip and sometimes other features such as a vertical forward grip, flash suppressor or barrel shroud.
You CAN'T own a semi automatic assault pistol in Hawaii. As my original post has stated, truthfully.
You can own a pistol, you can own a assault rifle. You can't own an assault pistol. The definition changes after Hawaii regulations are enforced, to be legal there is no scenario where you get an ar15 style pistol that's semi automatic and can accept detachable mags.
-
He's babbling about rifles now. :wacko:
The first line of the "Assault pistol" definition states:
So, if you disable/never install a gas system in an AR pistol, it's not semi-auto. Therefore, nothing else in the definition applies.
Thanks for realizing this.
The government has made is quite clear over the years that exacting matching is important that's why they arbitrarily say a certain amount of parts must be American, what length it must be, grips and other accessories, etc.
-
i am not arguing what flapp said, i was saying your word salad you posted proves you have nothing to add to the thread...
Amazing but Flapp basically explained it fairly well:
AR mags have existed in a "grayish area", due to the banning of AR pistols as manufactured. All factory AR pistols have detachable mags. While the most common method of making an AR pistol HI compliant is to epoxy/weld the mag into the magwell, making it impossible to insert a 20rd or 30rd AR mag, it's not the only method to become compliant. As a side note, once you make the mag nondetachable, the 10rd limit no longer applies, so you could weld a 30rd mag into the pistol and be compliant.
Aiea followed up:
The grey is in that AR’s cannot be registered as a pistol if the mag is detachable.
Therefore, a detachable AR/AK mag cannot be used in a legal pistol in Hawaii.
There are a bunch of AR pistols in Hawaii with fixed (welded) magazines which are no longer detachable.
There is even a thread on how to make one legal and what methods of securing the mag to the receiver are acceptable to HPD. (Again, kind of a crap shoot.)
-
Not really, this has been argued many times. See previous posts which might I add said the same thing but perhaps better worded.
those posts didn't say the same thing, because they actually made sense and followed the law
"perhaps better worded" is this week's "my bad"...
-
those posts didn't say the same thing, because they actually made sense and followed the law
"perhaps better worded" is this week's "my bad"...
Please show me where I made a mistake in my post or wasn't clear or was not following the law:
Legally in Hawaii you can't own "assault pistols". Thus there is no such thing. Once a rifle, always a rifle. No conversions according to the ATF. You must purchase a "pistol" receiver or a non labeled receiver and declare it a pistol. And you must register said receiver under your name, after you do so you will no longer be able to own or purchase standard capacity mags.
If confused refer to my previous 2 posts.
FYI HPD will not let you do the last part. So you technically can never not be able to own or purchase standard capacity mags.
-
i am not arguing what flapp said, i was saying your word salad you posted proves you have nothing to add to the thread...
Yep. He chose his screen name intentionally, as he believes himself to be omnipotent.
His unintelligible gobbledy goop isn't worth arguing over. We are relegated to becoming OmniGrub whisperers so we can reiterate what he said in understandable English.
It's bad enough when he's wrong and can't articulate, but even worse when he's right. We have to spend our time translating so people don't misunderstand what he sort-of said -- IOW, what he meant to say.
-
The ATF and the federal/state government:
The definition varies among regulating jurisdictions but usually includes semi-automatic firearms with a detachable magazine, a pistol grip and sometimes other features such as a vertical forward grip, flash suppressor or barrel shroud.
You CAN'T own a semi automatic assault pistol in Hawaii. As my original post has stated, truthfully.
You can own a pistol, you can own a assault rifle. You can't own an assault pistol. The definition changes after Hawaii regulations are enforced, to be legal there is no scenario where you get an ar15 style pistol that's semi automatic and can accept detachable mags.
In the HRS. . . :facepalm:
And yes, I am aware of the ATF definition, or attempt at. But does Hawaii follow ATF? All ATF definitions. That's the point. . .
Damn. . .
-
i am not arguing what flapp said, i was saying your word salad you posted proves you have nothing to add to the thread...
Precisely what I was getting at. When he is grasping for answers, he's just looking for stuff that he "feels" backs up his position. In this case, many of us have gone over this dozens of times.
-
Please show me where I made a mistake in my post or wasn't clear or was not following the law:
If confused refer to my previous 2 posts.
FYI HPD will not let you do the last part. So you technically can never not be able to own or purchase standard capacity mags.
"Legally in Hawaii you can't own "assault pistols". Thus there is no such thing. Once a rifle, always a rifle. No conversions according to the ATF. You must purchase a "pistol" receiver or a non labeled receiver and declare it a pistol. And you must register said receiver under your name, after you do so you will no longer be able to own or purchase standard capacity mags. "
nowhere in ATF rules or HRS does it state this...
and the whole post was not clear at all, except for the first sentence
-
"Legally in Hawaii you can't own "assault pistols". Thus there is no such thing. Once a rifle, always a rifle. No conversions according to the ATF. You must purchase a "pistol" receiver or a non labeled receiver and declare it a pistol. And you must register said receiver under your name, after you do so you will no longer be able to own or purchase standard capacity mags. "
nowhere in ATF rules or HRS does it state this...
and the whole post was not clear at all, except for the first sentence
Hpd will not allow you to register an ar15 lower as a pistol lower without modifications to make it not an assault pistol If they did then that rule would technically apply.
-
Hpd will not allow you to register an ar15 lower as a pistol lower without modifications to make it not an assault pistol If they did then that rule would technically apply.
so you made a definitive statement, but then qualify it when challenged with "if they did then that rule would technically apply"
but you are not wrong...
-
For macsak. . .
§134-1 Definitions. As used in this chapter, unless the context indicates otherwise:
"Assault pistol" means a semiautomatic pistol that accepts a detachable magazine and has two or more of the following characteristics
Or do I owe him a "my bad"? ??? ::)
-
Legally in Hawaii you can't own "assault pistols". Thus there is no such thing.
...
By that stellar logic, there should be no penalties in the statute for possession of an assault pistol, because you can't possess something that doesn't exist ("no such thing").
Stop trying to Omni-splain everything. This is NOT your area of expertise (which has yet to be determined).
You can't "legally own" suppressors, short-barrel rifles, pistol mags over 10rds, fully automatic firearms, nor any other NFA controlled item, so I guess none of those exist in the state, either. Try Googling those items as they relate to arrests in Hawaii. I BET YOU there are many stories where these items are "a thing." I know. I checked.
Your perception of reality is still governed by what the courts and lawmakers dictate to you, even though reality and the legal system are often at odds with one another.
-
I just lost 20 minutes of my life I'll never get back.
Poster A
Poster B
Poster A
Poster B
Where's Serena Williams at? She's better to look at for a tennis match and there's no LOVE here
FFS - nobody here does anything illegal. Move along and do what you want. It's your dime to your lawyer if that's where you plan to go
-
For macsak. . .
Or do I owe him a "my bad"? ??? ::)
but at least you are not wrong...
-
but at least you are not wrong...
heads
-
I always wondered why there is a federal law about removing mattress tags. Now I know what tiny demographic made them have to do something that silly. Think of all the scars from the McDonald's coffee burns that clown has. Probably burn himself again tomorrow.
-
By that stellar logic, there should be no penalties in the statute for possession of an assault pistol, because you can't possess something that doesn't exist ("no such thing").
Stop trying to Omni-splain everything. This is NOT your area of expertise (which has yet to be determined).
You can't "legally own" suppressors, short-barrel rifles, pistol mags over 10rds, fully automatic firearms, nor any other NFA controlled item, so I guess none of those exist in the state, either. Try Googling those items as they relate to arrests in Hawaii. I BET YOU there are many stories where these items are "a thing." I know. I checked.
Your perception of reality is still governed by what the courts and lawmakers dictate to you, even though reality and the legal system are often at odds with one another.
If you can't own something then laws based on said ownership don't quite make sense.....doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
-
Suppliers erring on the safe side and do not appreciate standard capacity magazines.
Beyond that, there’s been a number of threads on why some LGSs and even online vendors read the laws. If you need links, I’ll find a few and post links when I have more free time.
Yeah. I ordered some 20 rd. mags from this supplier online and they flagged my order and told me they are canceling my order because they claim it is illegal to ship this particular rifle magazine to hawaii buyers.
Then I found this other supplier and they processed my order no problem.
Started this thread because I was wondering if any of you folks have the same problem. :shaka:
Also want to thank all posters who shared information of "assault pistol" laws and the legalities associated with it, especially in Hawaii.
But yeah, I don't plan to go down that rabbit hole...... ;D
-
If you can't own something then laws based on said ownership don't quite make sense.....doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
You mean like how heroine is illegal to possess, yet there are laws for intent to distribute?
You really do believe laws prevent crime, don't you? (<== Rhetorical. No replies required. Already been down that twisted road.)
-
So is it safe to assume that we can have 30rd AR mags or should we err on the side of caution and not be in possession of them in public shooting spaces?
-
You mean like how heroine is illegal to possess, yet there are laws for intent to distribute?
Called human trafficking if you possess a heroine with intent to distribute English major.
(Prompted by other stupid picking nit posts by this comedian and others)
Yep. He chose his screen name intentionally,
Did you choose all four of your screen names intentionally ? (Flapp, Darmok, MauiD, Moosed)
Who else here has had four screen names ? And why?
And don’t tell me I derailed the thread.
It was so derailed.
Guy asked a direct question. The least we could do is answer it to the best of our ability.
Omni, need a little bit of knowledge to answer though.
DirtyL, Dogman, Mac, and a bunch of other members can answer better than most of us can.
-
So is it safe to assume that we can have 30rd AR mags or should we err on the side of caution and not be in possession of them in public shooting spaces?
Look up and down the line at Kokohead and at gun shops and make a determination.
Playing in grey.
-
Hawaii state law prohibits greater than 10 round detachable pistol magazines unless blocked to hold 10 rounds or less and “not readily restorable.” Possession of illegal magazines is a misdemeanor, one count per magazine, and possession of a handgun with one inserted is a class C felony. There is much debate among gun owners, law enforcement, and dealers over the interpretation of this portion of the statutes when rifle magazines which fit handguns are considered, and the prohibition is generally not enforced.
https://hawaiirifleassociation.org/hawaii-gun-laws/
-
Hawaii state law prohibits greater than 10 round detachable pistol magazines unless blocked to hold 10 rounds or less and “not readily restorable.” Possession of illegal magazines is a misdemeanor, one count per magazine, and possession of a handgun with one inserted is a class C felony. There is much debate among gun owners, law enforcement, and dealers over the interpretation of this portion of the statutes when rifle magazines which fit handguns are considered, and the prohibition is generally not enforced.
https://hawaiirifleassociation.org/hawaii-gun-laws/
That’s the shit. :thumbsup:
-
Look up and down the line at Kokohead and at gun shops and make a determination.
Playing in grey.
I should buy you a beer, sir
-
Check out the thread I posted above.
One classic comment:
Go to Kokohead and look up and down the line.
Or an HDF range day.
Or a local gun shop other than SEC. (SEC is awesome but strict on their mag interpretation.)
https://gunmagwarehouse.com/
The grey is in that AR’s cannot be registered as a pistol if the mag is detachable.
Therefore, a detachable AR/AK mag cannot be used in a legal pistol in Hawaii.
There are a bunch of AR pistols in Hawaii with fixed (welded) magazines which are no longer detachable.
There is even a thread on how to make one legal and what methods of securing the mag to the receiver are acceptable to HPD. (Again, kind of a crap shoot.)
10-22 mags are a little trickier because of the Ruger Charger and it’s variants.
Rifle mags are legal because they tried to ban them twice in the last 2 years. Why ban something if it's already illegal? So refer to my post about the HRS stating "fits into a pistol". Regardless of how someone finds a loop hole and modifies an AR to be some what of an AR pistol, HRS clearly defines what an "assault pistol" is (AR pistol). Once the definition is no longer met by HRS, it is not an assault pistol anymore. Thus rifle mags are legal.
Then refer to my post about the Zipp22 which is a pistol. Even no longer made, it's still a pistol thus 10/22 mags fall into the mag limit category.
For a while, LGS played it safe, but others didn't. Then you have the LGS who only sell standard cap mags to LE. There is no HI law that exempts LGS from doing this. So the worker can be in violation for possessing a standard cap mag as they hand it to the LEO.
-
Yeah. I ordered some 20 rd. mags from this supplier online and they flagged my order and told me they are canceling my order because they claim it is illegal to ship this particular rifle magazine to hawaii buyers.
Then I found this other supplier and they processed my order no problem.
Started this thread because I was wondering if any of you folks have the same problem. :shaka:
Also want to thank all posters who shared information of "assault pistol" laws and the legalities associated with it, especially in Hawaii.
But yeah, I don't plan to go down that rabbit hole...... ;D
Gotcha. Yeah, I've heard of the "flagging order" after the fact and getting cancellation notice/order. Some companies have also changed recently (say in the last 2-3 years). I don't recall encountering cancellation on any of my orders, but I did notice some vendors that I had ordered from in the past had changed policies. As well as some going out of business. :(
Hopefully we can get to a point where standard cap mags become the norm for Hawaii. Not holding my breath, but hopeful.
-
Gotcha. Yeah, I've heard of the "flagging order" after the fact and getting cancellation notice/order. Some companies have also changed recently (say in the last 2-3 years). I don't recall encountering cancellation on any of my orders, but I did notice some vendors that I had ordered from in the past had changed policies. As well as some going out of business. :(
Hopefully we can get to a point where standard cap mags become the norm for Hawaii. Not holding my breath, but hopeful.
Some from HIFICO have sent emails to online stores stated that rifle mags are legal. They showed them the current HRS and the bills that were presented trying to ban rifle mags too.
-
Some from HIFICO have sent emails to online stores stated that rifle mags are legal. They showed them the current HRS and the bills that were presented trying to ban rifle mags too.
Did any of the stores/shops change their stance or policy?
The HRS and proposed revisions can be about as clear as tax law. >:(
-
Did any of the stores/shops change their stance or policy?
The HRS and proposed revisions can be about as clear as tax law. >:(
IDK if any shops/stores changed their stance.
What the HRS bill did was cross out the word "pistol" in the phrase "fits into a pistol" and change it to "firearm". "Fits into a firearm".
Which confirms what I posted above.
-
Legally in Hawaii you can't own "assault pistols". Thus there is no such thing. Once a rifle, always a rifle. No conversions according to the ATF. You must purchase a "pistol" receiver or a non labeled receiver and declare it a pistol. And you must register said receiver under your name, after you do so you will no longer be able to own or purchase standard capacity mags.
Irrelevant, there are pistols which can take rifle magazines that wouldn't qualify as assault pistols. The law doesn't specify whether you own pistols capable of taking the magazine, only whether there are pistols which can take the magazines.
-
Hawaii state law prohibits greater than 10 round detachable pistol magazines unless blocked to hold 10 rounds or less and “not readily restorable.” Possession of illegal magazines is a misdemeanor, one count per magazine, and possession of a handgun with one inserted is a class C felony. There is much debate among gun owners, law enforcement, and dealers over the interpretation of this portion of the statutes when rifle magazines which fit handguns are considered, and the prohibition is generally not enforced.
https://hawaiirifleassociation.org/hawaii-gun-laws/
Yup. According to the law they are technically illegal but never seen it enforced
-
Irrelevant, there are pistols which can take rifle magazines that wouldn't qualify as assault pistols. The law doesn't specify whether you own pistols capable of taking the magazine, only whether there are pistols which can take the magazines.
doesnt really explain why pistol caliber magazines that are curved in a 'banana' shape designed to go into carbines and cannot fit into a pistol arent available for purchase locally or allowed to be shipped into the state.
-
doesnt really explain why pistol caliber magazines that are curved in a 'banana' shape designed to go into carbines and cannot fit into a pistol arent available for purchase locally or allowed to be shipped into the state.
I think that is because our AG sent threatening letters to suppliers and those stores aren't going to risk a legal conflict. It sucks but it is what it is.
I am just happy that they haven't used this law to start banning AR-15 30 round magazines
-
Yup. According to the law they are technically illegal but never seen it enforced
That gun law verbiage is from 2018 as far as I can tell; does anyone know if it has been changed to anything more restrictive to include ARs? Is it legal or not? I assume it's a huge grey area and not such an easy task to say yes or no so definitively.
-
Irrelevant, there are pistols which can take rifle magazines that wouldn't qualify as assault pistols. The law doesn't specify whether you own pistols capable of taking the magazine, only whether there are pistols which can take the magazines.
What pistol takes ar mags that is semi automatic and meets the other "AR" labels? And is that pistol legal in hawaii?
-
What pistol takes ar mags that is semi automatic and meets the other "AR" labels? And is that pistol legal in hawaii?
There are bolt action pistols. I recall seeing a remington 700 pistol and believe it took magazines, not sure if they were AR-15 mags though.
I had this odd idea of making a pump action AR-15 pistol. That would be an example where it wouldn't be assault pistol.
-
What pistol takes ar mags that is semi automatic and meets the other "AR" labels? And is that pistol legal in hawaii?
Show me in the statute where the pistol that can accept a >10rd rifle mag must have a semi-auto action.
That's an assumption, as most pistols that use such capacity mags happen to be semi-auto.
(c) The manufacture, possession, sale, barter, trade, gift, transfer, or acquisition of detachable
ammunition magazines with a capacity in excess of ten rounds which are designed for or capable
of use with a pistol is prohibited. This subsection shall not apply to magazines originally designed
to accept more than ten rounds of ammunition which have been modified to accept no more than
ten rounds and which are not capable of being readily restored to a capacity of more than ten rounds.
"Pistol". Not "semi-auto pistol."
"Pistol" or "revolver" means any firearm of any shape with a barrel less than sixteen inches in length
and capable of discharging loaded ammunition or any noxious gas.
-
And we have gone full circle. Just go back a few pages this exact thing has been argued before.
-
And we have gone full circle. Just go back a few pages this exact thing has been argued before.
By, "we", you mean YOU.
-
By, "we", you mean YOU.
BBBUUUUUURRRNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN :worship: :worship: :worship: :worship:
-
That gun law verbiage is from 2018 as far as I can tell; does anyone know if it has been changed to anything more restrictive to include ARs? Is it legal or not? I assume it's a huge grey area and not such an easy task to say yes or no so definitively.
The law has not been changed, but they tried 2 years in a row. Read my post about "pistol" to "firearm"