2aHawaii
General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: eyeeatingfish on October 04, 2021, 08:52:57 PM
-
I can't help but think that if Trump had won the presidency and pushed the vaccine mandates and Biden opposed the mandates that we would see people's positions flipped. I think most Trump supporters would be talking about protecting the community and people should have to get vaccines and progressives would be preaching personal freedom and mistrust of the government. I think in some alternate universe where this happened this forum would be flipped with everyone talking about how safe vaccines were and that democrats were selfish to the safety of society.
I think this would be just another example of a significant lack of ideological consistency. Humans seem more concerned on siding with their tribe than they are with principles. This isn't a commentary about only one political party or one specific issue so it isn't an attach on democrats or republicans.
Thoughts?
-
No
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
No
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
^that
IDGAF what Trump or Biden had/have to say on the matter. Can’t speak for others on the board, but I can imagine there are some that would be biased as noted in the OP.
-
I can't help but think that if Trump had won the presidency and pushed the vaccine mandates and Biden opposed the mandates that we would see people's positions flipped. I think most Trump supporters would be talking about protecting the community and people should have to get vaccines and progressives would be preaching personal freedom and mistrust of the government. I think in some alternate universe where this happened this forum would be flipped with everyone talking about how safe vaccines were and that democrats were selfish to the safety of society.
I think this would be just another example of a significant lack of ideological consistency. Humans seem more concerned on siding with their tribe than they are with principles. This isn't a commentary about only one political party or one specific issue so it isn't an attach on democrats or republicans.
Thoughts?
no
-
^that
IDGAF what Trump or Biden had/have to say on the matter. Can’t speak for others on the board, but I can imagine there are some that would be biased as noted in the OP.
I do think that in some ways this vaccine issue has brought together some people who would normally be on opposite sides of political aisles. So perhaps my prediction is wrong, that this is one of those issues that cross political borders more than usual?
-
I do think that in some ways this vaccine issue has brought together some people who would normally be on opposite sides of political aisles. So perhaps my prediction is wrong, that this is one of those issues that cross political borders more than usual?
To clarify, IDGAF about political borders, or politics in general for this issue. This one is about the principle(s) of the issue.
-
I do think that in some ways this vaccine issue has brought together some people who would normally be on opposite sides of political aisles. So perhaps my prediction is wrong, that this is one of those issues that cross political borders more than usual?
COVID and the vaccines are not political issues. No matter how much the press, government, polls, studies and social media want to make it yet another divisive issue, the "normal" people in this country see it as a medical issue -- something to be decided by the individual and their doctors.
The Dems weaponized COVID to win the election. They were successful, so they figured they could continue to milk the crisis for all it's worth.
You're falling for the bait if you think the party controlling the White House dictates whether people support one side or the other of the vaccine mandates.
Most of the conflict is on social media. The power that be want us to believe that's reality, and that somehow those people represent all of us.
-
I found the Collin Kaepernick story an interesting comparison. He kneeled during the national anthem and caught a lot of flack for it. There were numerous calls for him to be required to stand or be fired. (mostly from people on the ideological right) I find this in contrast to the conservatives who are now protesting a vaccine being required to maintain employment specifically with regards to freedoms. We have the freedom no not be vaccinated against our will or by coercion but not freedom to refrain from standing for the anthem?
-
COVID and the vaccines are not political issues. No matter how much the press, government, polls, studies and social media want to make it yet another divisive issue, the "normal" people in this country see it as a medical issue -- something to be decided by the individual and their doctors.
The Dems weaponized COVID to win the election. They were successful, so they figured they could continue to milk the crisis for all it's worth.
You're falling for the bait if you think the party controlling the White House dictates whether people support one side or the other of the vaccine mandates.
Most of the conflict is on social media. The power that be want us to believe that's reality, and that somehow those people represent all of us.
I am not sure I can agree with your premise. Though the issue of covid may break the mold somewhat I still think we are seeing patterns of sides forming that correlate to political ideologies. I think I would be accurate in saying that democrats are more likely to support vaccine mandates, lockdowns, and masking than republicans.
Furthermore though covid itself is obviously a medical issue, how to deal with it is invariably political. How to fund treatment, whether to force vaccination, whether to lockdown, etc. all end up being political questions. People aren't lining up just taking the advice of the majority of doctors.
-
I found the Collin Kaepernick story an interesting comparison. He kneeled during the national anthem and caught a lot of flack for it. There were numerous calls for him to be required to stand or be fired. (mostly from people on the ideological right) I find this in contrast to the conservatives who are now protesting a vaccine being required to maintain employment specifically with regards to freedoms. We have the freedom no not be vaccinated against our will or by coercion but not freedom to refrain from standing for the anthem?
Much different topic, but your thread. There’s a thread on that somewhere in here. I didn’t really care about him or his act in itself. From what I read and learned about the start was that he was essentially just acting out. Then he later tried to make like by was being all noble about things and later turned about to be a lie (at least if I recall correctly). Almost Jussie Smollet level.
At least for me, it had nothing to do with ideology. Again, principle of the matter. Not politics.
-
I found the Collin Kaepernick story an interesting comparison. He kneeled during the national anthem and caught a lot of flack for it. There were numerous calls for him to be required to stand or be fired. (mostly from people on the ideological right) I find this in contrast to the conservatives who are now protesting a vaccine being required to maintain employment specifically with regards to freedoms. We have the freedom no not be vaccinated against our will or by coercion but not freedom to refrain from standing for the anthem?
Wrong
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
I am not sure I can agree with your premise. Though the issue of covid may break the mold somewhat I still think we are seeing patterns of sides forming that correlate to political ideologies. I think I would be accurate in saying that democrats are more likely to support vaccine mandates, lockdowns, and masking than republicans.
Furthermore though covid itself is obviously a medical issue, how to deal with it is invariably political. How to fund treatment, whether to force vaccination, whether to lockdown, etc. all end up being political questions. People aren't lining up just taking the advice of the majority of doctors.
Science is not about following the majority -- of doctors or anyone else.
It's about facts and decisions that are based on individuals and THEIR doctors -- not people like Fauci.
I've never met Fauci. For him to try and tell me what I need is IMO malpractice.
-
Much different topic, but your thread. There’s a thread on that somewhere in here. I didn’t really care about him or his act in itself. From what I read and learned about the start was that he was essentially just acting out. Then he later tried to make like by was being all noble about things and later turned about to be a lie (at least if I recall correctly). Almost Jussie Smollet level.
At least for me, it had nothing to do with ideology. Again, principle of the matter. Not politics.
This was covered already in another thread a while ago. Pretty sure omni felt the same way, which is what kept it going and very long.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
I am not sure I can agree with your premise. Though the issue of covid may break the mold somewhat I still think we are seeing patterns of sides forming that correlate to political ideologies. I think I would be accurate in saying that democrats are more likely to support vaccine mandates, lockdowns, and masking than republicans.
Furthermore though covid itself is obviously a medical issue, how to deal with it is invariably political. How to fund treatment, whether to force vaccination, whether to lockdown, etc. all end up being political questions. People aren't lining up just taking the advice of the majority of doctors.
I didn't think it was about you agreeing with me. I thought it was about you agreeing with whoever is president based on political affiliation.
-
SNIP
People aren't lining up just taking the advice of the majority of doctors.
Why do you care who someone (other than yourself) bases their personal choice on?
-
This was covered already in another thread a while ago. Pretty sure omni felt the same way, which is what kept it going and very long.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
Oh gosh. Don’t say that name 2 more times. Kinda like Beetlejuice…
-
Much different topic, but your thread. There’s a thread on that somewhere in here. I didn’t really care about him or his act in itself. From what I read and learned about the start was that he was essentially just acting out. Then he later tried to make like by was being all noble about things and later turned about to be a lie (at least if I recall correctly). Almost Jussie Smollet level.
At least for me, it had nothing to do with ideology. Again, principle of the matter. Not politics.
I think Kaepernicks protest was based on a racist political lie but I also didn't care if he didn't want to stand for the anthem. Forced patriotism isn't real patriotism.
To me the comparison is really just about to what extent freedom is the guiding principle.
As for your other question, I didn't intend for this to be another covid/vaccine debate thread. This one is about ideologies and how they interact with political groups, leaders, and triablism.
-
Science is not about following the majority -- of doctors or anyone else.
So science had absolutely no bearing on the vast majority of physicians being vaccinated?
-
I am not sure I can agree with your premise. Though the issue of covid may break the mold somewhat I still think we are seeing patterns of sides forming that correlate to political ideologies. I think I would be accurate in saying that democrats are more likely to support vaccine mandates, lockdowns, and masking than republicans.
Furthermore though covid itself is obviously a medical issue, how to deal with it is invariably political. How to fund treatment, whether to force vaccination, whether to lockdown, etc. all end up being political questions. People aren't lining up just taking the advice of the majority of doctors.
according to one member, we are supposed to listen to the majority...
-
I didn't think it was about you agreeing with me. I thought it was about you agreeing with whoever is president based on political affiliation.
I think that tribalism causes people to choose sides based on what their tribe is doing/saying and that this can be stronger than ideological consistency, science, and maybe even religion.
-
I think Kaepernicks protest was based on a racist political lie but I also didn't care if he didn't want to stand for the anthem. Forced patriotism isn't real patriotism.
To me the comparison is really just about to what extent freedom is the guiding principle.
Dunno about political lie. Maybe. I just don’t think he put a lot of thought into it, at least at first. It wasn’t until he got called out that he made like it was some noble act.
Freedom as guiding principle, I get that. What I hate is politicizing of personal choice. I’ve had folks accuse me of being some sort of uber conservative based on being an avid shooter and firearms owner. Couldn’t be further from the truth. That people try to pigeon hole people makes me ::)
-
Why do you care who someone (other than yourself) bases their personal choice on?
His post now are meant to cause discussion, not much of what he thinks and discuss his train of thought. Although it eventually may lead to that later. Notice how he words the initial ideas.
I dont have time for random discussions just for the hell of it or for fun. To me, thats boring. But to each their own.
So if i do reply, its simple responses and wont get into detail.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
according to one member, we are supposed to listen to the majority...
Can you time stamp that statement? Need to confirm the goal post location in time :rofl:
-
His post now are meant to cause discussion, not much of what he thinks and discuss his train of thought. Although it eventually may lead to that later. Notice how he words the initial ideas.
I dont have time for random discussions just for the hell of it or for fun. To me, thats boring. But to each their own.
So if i do reply, its simple responses and wont get into detail.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
Nah. I get the point. My counterpoint was why does anyone in general care if someone else’s personal choice. I mean I can get why in many cases. Partially rhetorical.
Go ponder 45 vs 9 some more. :rofl:
-
So science had absolutely no bearing on the vast majority of physicians being vaccinated?
"absolutely no bearing on" and "not following the majority" are not synonymous.
#GoalPostInTransit...
-
I think Kaepernicks protest was based on a racist political lie but I also didn't care if he didn't want to stand for the anthem. Forced patriotism isn't real patriotism.
To me the comparison is really just about to what extent freedom is the guiding principle.
As for your other question, I didn't intend for this to be another covid/vaccine debate thread. This one is about ideologies and how they interact with political groups, leaders, and triablism.
Nobody is forcing anyone's "patriotism." Is that really what you think is happening, or do you simply not understand the customs and traditions regarding national symbols?
There's nothing wrong with showing respect for the country in which you're making millions of dollars playing a freaking game.
There's not another country in the world as great as the US. For all our flaws, we do enough things right to offset the bad a thousand times over.
If you go to Japan and bow when greeting someone, are they forcing you to adopt their customs and courtesies, or are you simply showing the person respect according to their culture?
You can show respect for someone or something without acting like an infant. It's not hard to separate one political issue from what the flag and anthem actually stand for.
-
for f8cks sake. What range too far for you too?
-
for f8cks sake. What range too far for you too?
Nah, he brings up better points than the other guy. I just choose not to go into his post for reason I posted above. So since his arguments are better once he makes a statement of opinion, I may further add my $0.02.
Example: We went round and round when red flag laws came about. We both never saw eye to eye.
-
Nobody is forcing anyone's "patriotism." Is that really what you think is happening, or do you simply not understand the customs and traditions regarding national symbols?
That’s the most frustrating part about dealing with people who are under the influence of deconstructionist propaganda. They honestly believe that there is some sort of salvation or promised land waiting for them after they tear the world apart, but they overestimate their own ability to come up with something better and as a result spread misery and death.
Its easy to pick them out these days. So-called “radical thinkers” are obedient servants to an entrenched elite, eager for some crumbs off the table
You don’t see Kaepernick turning down his Nike sponsorship money because of their atrocious human rights record
That’s also why EEF supports medical apartheid and doesn’t understand why we wouldn’t do the same if the script was flipped. All the deconstructionists care about is power and as a result concepts like freedom and liberty seem nonsensical to them. Why would anyone want to be left alone when they could force others to do their will?
You can’t reason with someone like that, just point out the disasters of collectivism and hope people remember why it’s a terrible idea
https://youtu.be/xWRhPf9Qzmw
-
I posted this b4 in the previous thread about Kap and his "protest". If a KKK player wanted to walk into the stadium with a nazi flag or burn a cross on the sideline, would he be allowed to do it? I can guarantee the answer is no. So "free speech" is only allowed by the NFL if you fit the right narrative. And the fact that the 1a is so the government cannot censor you. Private entities can do as they wish. This crumbles the lefts entire story.
-
I think that tribalism causes people to choose sides based on what their tribe is doing/saying and that this can be stronger than ideological consistency, science, and maybe even religion.
Curious, what tribe am I?
Polish jew?, Scottish highlander?
Norman?
I evaluate all people based on how they can help me or oppose me.
That is it. Tribe, race, or what ever doesn't factor in.
Individuals built America. Tribes are on reservations.
Ya'll get it?
Democrats?
:wave:
-
Groveler you are one of the few here who is not in a tribe. And I truly believe you are not in a tribe. :thumbsup:
I don’t think Rocky’s in a tribe, inspector Dave’s not in a tribe, OF is not in a tribe.
Once a person starts to go to the echo chamber, they joined a tribe.
America is turning into 3 tribes: Left, Right and Independent. And Independent is a dying breed.
Just how I see it.
-
America is turning into 3 tribes: Left, Right and Independent. And Independent is a dying breed.
Just how I see it.
We covered this in the election fraud post, but if independents voted for Trump instead of a horse who has no chance of winning, then the DNC would have to cheat that much more, which would be a little more obvious.
-
There's not another country in the world as great as the US. For all our flaws, we do enough things right to offset the bad a thousand times over.
With all due respect Flapp; if you are referring, to the former American Republic, then maybe relatively better than many nations, of the past.
If you are referring, to the current US empire, then it ranks among the most heinous and evil empires the human race has ever seen, in the modern era.
-
We covered this in the election fraud post, but if independents voted for Trump instead of a horse who has no chance of winning, then the DNC would have to cheat that much more, which would be a little more obvious.
It's the American Idol effect.
Voting for Team Biden, Team Trump, Team Hillary, etc. shows a collective mentality -- that you aren't supporting the person as much as belonging to a group (tribe) that supports the person. Sometimes you pick your team based on all the wrong factors. You just like that team because you have been part of that team in other contests.
IN 2016, lots of people voted against Hillary -- many of them by simply not voting for anyone.Team "Anybody but HER!"
This is what happens when most people don't care enough to learn about each candidate independently from the media -- who, BTW, always endorses a candidate. Can't expect unbiased reporting from them, even before the Internet.
Most voters can't articulate why the chose the person they are casting their ballot for. This is why we've devolved into tribes. I'm voting for the guy leading my tribe because I'm part of the tribe. Can't get more Lemming-like than that.
-
With all due respect Flapp; if you are referring, to the former American Republic, then maybe relatively better than many nations, of the past.
If you are referring, to the current US empire, then it ranks among the most heinous and evil empires the human race has ever seen, in the modern era.
It's my opinion.
Imagine the world without a United States of America. Do you think it would be better or worse? Would another world leader have done better? Worse? If Hitler wasn't stopped by the Allies -- in great part by the US -- would Europe be under the heel of a totalitarian dictator to this day? Would Russia have won the Cold War before it even started? Would Japan have annexed the entire region inside the Pacific Rim?
No need to derail this thread. Just a "thought experiment."
Everyone has a right to his/her/its opinion, but not all opinions are right. :geekdanc: :shaka:
-
We covered this in the election fraud post, but if independents voted for Trump instead of a horse who has no chance of winning, then the DNC would have to cheat that much more, which would be a little more obvious.
I voted for Trump and against Mazie and the little guy Schitz and for Blangiardi and Sam Kong.
Independents can go all over the board.
-
His post now are meant to cause discussion, not much of what he thinks and discuss his train of thought. Although it eventually may lead to that later. Notice how he words the initial ideas.
I dont have time for random discussions just for the hell of it or for fun. To me, thats boring. But to each their own.
So if i do reply, its simple responses and wont get into detail.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
I think an understanding of my thought process might help. If I really want to talk about an issue I like to first sort of set out that issue like a debate moderator might. Provide some facts and context to set the groundwork. So for example ask if pinneapple is good on pizza. Then cover that pepperoni is spicy and salty while pinneapple is acidic and sweet.
Then when the discussion gets going I will usually state my opinion. Often I have an opinion though sometimes I don't but just find the discussion itself interesting. I don't like to lead out with just an argument of pineapples on pizza is awesome. If you don't like this type of discussion I totally get it, no judgements on you. My wife has no interest in debates of any kind.
One of the reasons I started this thread is that I have been listening to a number of podcasts about the human brain and how societies interact. This is where I nerd out a little bit but I find it very interesting at just how unobjective the human brain can be and how often tribalism really dictates our thinking. The podcasts have covered a number of studies which illustrate how susceptible to false memories, group think, tribalism, etc. Politics just seems to be such a perfect example of this the way people divide so consistently along political lines and over issues.
-
Curious, what tribe am I?
Polish jew?, Scottish highlander?
Norman?
I evaluate all people based on how they can help me or oppose me.
That is it. Tribe, race, or what ever doesn't factor in.
Individuals built America. Tribes are on reservations.
Ya'll get it?
Democrats?
:wave:
In the sociological sense tribe could really be any sort of a group identity. It could be people from Hawaii, it could be democrats, it could be a religious group, it could be whatever commonality people may be organizing around. The human brain has a rather strong desire to behave in a way that makes one fit within their tribe. Don't cause waves, don't disagree with the leader, don't do anything to "harm" the group.
In Japanese there is a saying that the nail that stands out gets hammered down.
-
Nobody is forcing anyone's "patriotism." Is that really what you think is happening, or do you simply not understand the customs and traditions regarding national symbols?
There's nothing wrong with showing respect for the country in which you're making millions of dollars playing a freaking game.
There's not another country in the world as great as the US. For all our flaws, we do enough things right to offset the bad a thousand times over.
If you go to Japan and bow when greeting someone, are they forcing you to adopt their customs and courtesies, or are you simply showing the person respect according to their culture?
You can show respect for someone or something without acting like an infant. It's not hard to separate one political issue from what the flag and anthem actually stand for.
We can be technical I suppose. Firing you for not getting a vaccine is not forcing you to get a vaccine either, the only actual forced vaccine would be if they strapped you down and jabbed you. When I said forced I did not mean litterally forced, Kaepernick didn't have a gun to his head telling him to stand up for the anthem. We could use the word coerced if you prefer.
My point was that coerced patriotism isn't real patriotism because it wasn't something done out of someone's own free will. Patriotism should be something someone voluntarily chooses because they love the country, not because they will be made fun of or fired for. If I told me wife to say "I love you" or I will throw her out of the house would that mean anything? Of course not.
Does the NFL have the power to make arbitrary rules saying players have to stand during the anthem? Sure, they can make whatever rules they want, but my point was about NFL fans who wanted him to be fired for not standing. How is that significantly different than democrats who want us fired from private businesses if we don't get the vaccine? And not standing for the anthem doesn't even harm anyone. I think, as conservatives, our calls for and respect for personal freedoms should be consistent. If Kaepernick doesn't want to stand because he bought into the lie from BLM or he is doing it as a PR stunt, or whatever might have been going on in his head, then fine. I don't like him or agree with him but I am not going to coerce him to stand.
-
We can be technical I suppose. Firing you for not getting a vaccine is not forcing you to get a vaccine either, the only actual forced vaccine would be if they strapped you down and jabbed you. When I said forced I did not mean litterally forced, Kaepernick didn't have a gun to his head telling him to stand up for the anthem. We could use the word coerced if you prefer.
Poor analogy. The rules already existed in the NFL. Players will rise, cover their hearts with their right hands, and stay silent during the anthem. Intentional disregard for the rules results in fines. The NFL tried to accommodate the "protest" players by allowing them to remain in the locker rooms until after the pregame stuff is over.
NOBODY WAS BEING FORCED TO DO ANYTHING.
Since the NFL balked at firing anyone, your argument is bogus on its face. People have been fired for not getting vaccinated. Massive difference.
I'm not being "technical." I'm stating observable, provable facts.
My point was that coerced patriotism isn't real patriotism because it wasn't something done out of someone's own free will. Patriotism should be something someone voluntarily chooses because they love the country, not because they will be made fun of or fired for. If I told me wife to say "I love you" or I will throw her out of the house would that mean anything? Of course not.
That's not a "point". That's an obfuscation based on an unproven premise. Nobody in the NFL was FORCED to do anything, much less display "patriotism." I explained this, but you ignored me completely. Patriotism is one thing. Showing respect for the nation by standing for 2 minutes is not "forced patriotism." Standing does not imply you are a patriot. Period.
You've answered my question indirectly. You DO NOT understand the customs and traditions regarding national symbols. You are assigning false meanings to the act of standing for the anthem, just like Kap did. He said it was in protest. I didn't see him protest by quitting or donating millions to his "cause". Publicity stunt -- nothing more.
Does the NFL have the power to make arbitrary rules saying players have to stand during the anthem? Sure, they can make whatever rules they want, but my point was about NFL fans who wanted him to be fired for not standing. How is that significantly different than democrats who want us fired from private businesses if we don't get the vaccine? And not standing for the anthem doesn't even harm anyone. I think, as conservatives, our calls for and respect for personal freedoms should be consistent. If Kaepernick doesn't want to stand because he bought into the lie from BLM or he is doing it as a PR stunt, or whatever might have been going on in his head, then fine. I don't like him or agree with him but I am not going to coerce him to stand.
Arbitrary? In whose mind?
The rules existed long before the "BLM Protest" attention whores started. The NFL not only has the power to make the rules, they also decide on the punishment.
Who cares what some NFL fans wanted? Name a player who was fired? Saying some fans wanted it is irrelevant.
Personal freedoms include responsibilities, not just rights. If the rules say stand, he stands. He was offered the option to remain in the locker room. Didn't matter -- he wanted to throw a public tantrum. He doesn't have the right when the air time (not cheap) is paid for by the NFL, the stadiums and the networks. You can't steal someone's megaphone to broadcast your protest on the basis that you have some right. Others have rights, too.
-
We can be technical I suppose. Firing you for not getting a vaccine is not forcing you to get a vaccine either, the only actual forced vaccine would be if they strapped you down and jabbed you. When I said forced I did not mean litterally forced, Kaepernick didn't have a gun to his head telling him to stand up for the anthem. We could use the word coerced if you prefer.
My point was that coerced patriotism isn't real patriotism because it wasn't something done out of someone's own free will. Patriotism should be something someone voluntarily chooses because they love the country, not because they will be made fun of or fired for. If I told me wife to say "I love you" or I will throw her out of the house would that mean anything? Of course not.
Does the NFL have the power to make arbitrary rules saying players have to stand during the anthem? Sure, they can make whatever rules they want, but my point was about NFL fans who wanted him to be fired for not standing. How is that significantly different than democrats who want us fired from private businesses if we don't get the vaccine? And not standing for the anthem doesn't even harm anyone. I think, as conservatives, our calls for and respect for personal freedoms should be consistent. If Kaepernick doesn't want to stand because he bought into the lie from BLM or he is doing it as a PR stunt, or whatever might have been going on in his head, then fine. I don't like him or agree with him but I am not going to coerce him to stand.
When someone being paid millions of dollars can't turn out a decent performance and instead decides to act like a baby, insult the audience, and incite violence on a nationally televised program, it's a whole different ball of wax than joe bus driver being forced to put experimental drugs in his body or starve.
The comparison is entirely disingenuous
This is not tribal warfare, this is class warfare
-
I think an understanding of my thought process might help. If I really want to talk about an issue I like to first sort of set out that issue like a debate moderator might. Provide some facts and context to set the groundwork. So for example ask if pinneapple is good on pizza. Then cover that pepperoni is spicy and salty while pinneapple is acidic and sweet.
Then when the discussion gets going I will usually state my opinion. Often I have an opinion though sometimes I don't but just find the discussion itself interesting. I don't like to lead out with just an argument of pineapples on pizza is awesome. If you don't like this type of discussion I totally get it, no judgements on you. My wife has no interest in debates of any kind.
One of the reasons I started this thread is that I have been listening to a number of podcasts about the human brain and how societies interact. This is where I nerd out a little bit but I find it very interesting at just how unobjective the human brain can be and how often tribalism really dictates our thinking. The podcasts have covered a number of studies which illustrate how susceptible to false memories, group think, tribalism, etc. Politics just seems to be such a perfect example of this the way people divide so consistently along political lines and over issues.
Thats why, to each their own.
Imo ALL wives have no interest in debate. We are wrong and thats that.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
pineapple on pizza sucks...
I think an understanding of my thought process might help. If I really want to talk about an issue I like to first sort of set out that issue like a debate moderator might. Provide some facts and context to set the groundwork. So for example ask if pinneapple is good on pizza. Then cover that pepperoni is spicy and salty while pinneapple is acidic and sweet.
Then when the discussion gets going I will usually state my opinion. Often I have an opinion though sometimes I don't but just find the discussion itself interesting. I don't like to lead out with just an argument of pineapples on pizza is awesome. If you don't like this type of discussion I totally get it, no judgements on you. My wife has no interest in debates of any kind.
One of the reasons I started this thread is that I have been listening to a number of podcasts about the human brain and how societies interact. This is where I nerd out a little bit but I find it very interesting at just how unobjective the human brain can be and how often tribalism really dictates our thinking. The podcasts have covered a number of studies which illustrate how susceptible to false memories, group think, tribalism, etc. Politics just seems to be such a perfect example of this the way people divide so consistently along political lines and over issues.
-
If you don't like this type of discussion I totally get it, no judgements on you. My wife has no interest in debates of any kind.
My guess is that she probably gets disgusted with being gaslit for refusing to consider the horrible authoritarian ideas that you constantly try to slip into the conversation.
"Why don't you consider the benefits of death camps for the unvaccinated, honey? There's always a reasonable compromise. Stop being so irrational."
-
Poor analogy. The rules already existed in the NFL. Players will rise, cover their hearts with their right hands, and stay silent during the anthem. Intentional disregard for the rules results in fines. The NFL tried to accommodate the "protest" players by allowing them to remain in the locker rooms until after the pregame stuff is over.
NOBODY WAS BEING FORCED TO DO ANYTHING.
Since the NFL balked at firing anyone, your argument is bogus on its face. People have been fired for not getting vaccinated. Massive difference.
Red herring. I clearly mentioned the calling for the firing of Kaepernick. The focus was not on NFL rules or actions, remember the theme of this thread. The focus is on inconsistencies in ideologies based on tribal affiliation. Kaepernick picked up a far left talking point when he kneeled in protest and he caught flack from people on the right. I am talking about the ideology of people being free to make choices in their life absent coercion which is then thrown aside for Kaepernick because he wasn't on our side.
I'm not being "technical." I'm stating observable, provable facts.
Then you are nitpicking. I clearly wasn't talking about people having to do things at the barrel of a gun.
That's not a "point". That's an obfuscation based on an unproven premise. Nobody in the NFL was FORCED to do anything, much less display "patriotism." I explained this, but you ignored me completely. Patriotism is one thing. Showing respect for the nation by standing for 2 minutes is not "forced patriotism." Standing does not imply you are a patriot. Period.
So if you attended a sports game in a foreign country would you stand and place your hand over your heart or salute their flag just to show respect to the other country? If you say no because it isn't your country then it clearly isn't just respect and you are back into the territory of patriotism.
And regardless, a forced or coerced sign of respect is equally as meaningless as one of patriotism so my point remains valid.
You've answered my question indirectly. You DO NOT understand the customs and traditions regarding national symbols. You are assigning false meanings to the act of standing for the anthem, just like Kap did. He said it was in protest. I didn't see him protest by quitting or donating millions to his "cause". Publicity stunt -- nothing more.
Arbitrary? In whose mind?
I do understand the customs and traditions regarding national symbols, that is why I know they are arbitrary. There is nothing inherent about standing that shows it is respectful.
Personal freedoms include responsibilities, not just rights. If the rules say stand, he stands. He was offered the option to remain in the locker room. Didn't matter -- he wanted to throw a public tantrum. He doesn't have the right when the air time (not cheap) is paid for by the NFL, the stadiums and the networks. You can't steal someone's megaphone to broadcast your protest on the basis that you have some right. Others have rights, too.
Maybe they should have ignored him then, just saying. He probably got more attention because of all the people butt hurt that he kneeled than if conservatives just ignored him.
Freedoms include responsibilities... like taking steps to reduce the spread of a disease?
-
My guess is that she probably gets disgusted with being gaslit for refusing to consider the horrible authoritarian ideas that you constantly try to slip into the conversation.
"Why don't you consider the benefits of death camps for the unvaccinated, honey? There's always a reasonable compromise. Stop being so irrational."
Now you are just purposefully lying about my arguments.
#1 Not every idea I have brought up is one I supposed, I have told you that multiple times but you can't or refuse to see the difference between talking about an idea and actually supporting it.
#2 Never once did I bring up anything real authoritarian, quit being hyperbolic.
Do you know one of the best ways to defeat a really bad idea from someone else? Reason through their argument, acknowledging the pros but then showing the cons and how it is a bad idea. But you refuse to even entertain the other sides ideas for a second even if just to show where they are bad ideas. You think they will listen to you because you insult them?
As for your reply about Kaepernick, please see my reply to Flapp. The focus was not on NFL rules so much as it was about a response from conservative fans.
-
This thread is going a little too far off the main topic. The Kaepernick example was never meant to bring up that old issue or to attack or defend him, it was just an observation and I don't think we should spend too much time on it. If you feel the Kaepernick incident was not a comparable example, thats fine, we can agree to disagree and move on. Lets try to cover some of the science on the main topic.
There was an interesting study performed on a college campus where the participants would fill out a questionaire and then be told to go to another building for part of the study. Along the way they would encounter an actor wearing either a jacket with either their college's sports team or the logo of a rival college sports team. The results showed that participants who were sports fans were less likely to help out the injured person wearing an opponents jersey and more likely to help out the injured person wearing the same college jersey. IIRC the people who didn't care about sports helped the injured person the same regardless of which logo.
This was an example of how the us vs them can be stronger than the belief that an injured person should be helped. The tribal identity in this case was a sports team. And there have been other studies that looked at issues surrounding sports. For example judging whether referees made the right calls: If referee makes a call it should either be correct or incorrect, and all that matters are the facts of the play right? Yet you don't often see both teams or fans agreeing agreeing or disagreeing with the referee at the same rate. If the call benefits your team you are more likely to say it was a good call than the other team and vice versa. This tribal loyalty is stronger than an objective look at the referee's call.
-
pineapple on pizza sucks...
Haha, I knew someone would bite onto that one.
But come to think about it, that could be an interesting study.
Inform people that Biden likes pineapple pizza and Trump hates pineapple pizza then ask them whether they like pinneapple on pizza and also ask whether they are republican democrat or independent. It would be interesting to see if there was any significant difference between self identified republicans and democrats as to whether they like pineapple on pizza.
-
Do you know one of the best ways to defeat a really bad idea from someone else? Reason through their argument, acknowledging the pros but then showing the cons and how it is a bad idea.
Some ideas are so unreasonable and dangerous that to entertain them is to give them a foothold of legitimacy that they do not deserve.
When you compare me with a terrorist for standing up for my rights then there is no middle ground. You are my enemy, and you are the enemy of everything this country is supposed to stand for.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FZscriarQJg
-
Red herring. I clearly mentioned the calling for the firing of Kaepernick. The focus was not on NFL rules or actions, remember the theme of this thread. The focus is on inconsistencies in ideologies based on tribal affiliation. Kaepernick picked up a far left talking point when he kneeled in protest and he caught flack from people on the right. I am talking about the ideology of people being free to make choices in their life absent coercion which is then thrown aside for Kaepernick because he wasn't on our side.
And I CLEARLY posted that this is a red herring and IRRELEVANT because he was not IN FACT fired. What some fans and others may have called for is not a valid point unless you have evidence it was only one political affiliation ("tribe") doing so.
Then you are nitpicking. I clearly wasn't talking about people having to do things at the barrel of a gun.
Please show me where I said you were talking about people having to do things at the barrel of a gun.
So if you attended a sports game in a foreign country would you stand and place your hand over your heart or salute their flag just to show respect to the other country? If you say no because it isn't your country then it clearly isn't just respect and you are back into the territory of patriotism.
Each service has variations on how to show respect in various situations and settings. If it's a US color guard, and the foreign country's anthem is played, the colors of the US color guard, be it an Army or other ceremonial flag, will be dipped, and all uniformed personnel will render THE SAME respect they would for the US anthem. If that includes a salute, then that will be rendered.
If I were attending as a civilian, the same rules apply. If I stand and cover for the US anthem, I do the same for the foreign anthem.
Variations occur if the event includes military units in parade formation where the commanders of the marching units render honors -- the rest of the unit does not unless commanded to.
Short answer -- you refuse to acknowledge the difference between "respect" and "patriotism" when discussing national symbols. You're like a broken record piling on story after story with no real foundation. So, yes, I would stand and cover my heart for a foreign nation's anthem. In the US, foreign anthems are played first (if more than one, in alphabetical order of country names), and the US anthem always last. In other countries, the rules are set by the host country.
And regardless, a forced or coerced sign of respect is equally as meaningless as one of patriotism so my point remains valid.
One ......... more .........time .......
Nobody is being FORCED!
Polly want a cracker?
I do understand the customs and traditions regarding national symbols, that is why I know they are arbitrary. There is nothing inherent about standing that shows it is respectful.
WRONG.
36 US Code § 301 - National anthem -- Not arbitrary., but law.
https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/36/301
Maybe they should have ignored him then, just saying. He probably got more attention because of all the people butt hurt that he kneeled than if conservatives just ignored him.
Freedoms include responsibilities... like taking steps to reduce the spread of a disease?
He got the attention because Social Media, MSM and Leftist Progressive Socialist Liberals used the story to further divide the nation. I didn't give a rat's ass about the story, but the media blew it way out of proportion.
When other athletes saw it was an attention getter, they jumped on the band wagon.
In this day and age, you don't have to be able to do anything to get attention. You just have to be a victim of something that the Left champions (Like BLM). They will raise you up as a celebrity and make you famous if you aren't already.
Kap milked the gravy train for as long as the victimhood cow would give.
Where is Kap and BLM now? Did Cops suddenly stop killing innocent unarmed blacks? Did Kap succeed in fixing the problem by taking a knee?
Last I checked, crime, including murders, are at an all time high in many places.
Oh, that's right. Kap no longer has a paid-for nationally televised platform from which to show his ass in public. :rofl:
-
This thread is going a little too far off the main topic. The Kaepernick example was never meant to bring up that old issue or to attack or defend him, it was just an observation and I don't think we should spend too much time on it. If you feel the Kaepernick incident was not a comparable example, thats fine, we can agree to disagree and move on. Lets try to cover some of the science on the main topic.
There was an interesting study performed on a college campus where the participants would fill out a questionaire and then be told to go to another building for part of the study. Along the way they would encounter an actor wearing either a jacket with either their college's sports team or the logo of a rival college sports team. The results showed that participants who were sports fans were less likely to help out the injured person wearing an opponents jersey and more likely to help out the injured person wearing the same college jersey. IIRC the people who didn't care about sports helped the injured person the same regardless of which logo.
This was an example of how the us vs them can be stronger than the belief that an injured person should be helped. The tribal identity in this case was a sports team. And there have been other studies that looked at issues surrounding sports. For example judging whether referees made the right calls: If referee makes a call it should either be correct or incorrect, and all that matters are the facts of the play right? Yet you don't often see both teams or fans agreeing agreeing or disagreeing with the referee at the same rate. If the call benefits your team you are more likely to say it was a good call than the other team and vice versa. This tribal loyalty is stronger than an objective look at the referee's call.
Not sure how the tribal thing came up. But are you grasping at herd mentality?
I think you are trying to make connections based on what you assume for many on this board. Then you started grasping at straws to try to make a point by attempting to provoke thought based on your assumptions/profile of folks here.
Are there folks on the ends of the spectrum? Yeah, in more ways than one that I have observed. That's the thing with generalities and trying to throw a blanket over groups.
-
It's my opinion.
Imagine the world without a United States of America. Do you think it would be better or worse? Would another world leader have done better? Worse? If Hitler wasn't stopped by the Allies -- in great part by the US -- would Europe be under the heel of a totalitarian dictator to this day? Would Russia have won the Cold War before it even started? Would Japan have annexed the entire region inside the Pacific Rim?
No need to derail this thread. Just a "thought experiment."
Everyone has a right to his/her/its opinion, but not all opinions are right. :geekdanc: :shaka:
Flapp, I know my views are controversial; but I consider you and most on this forum, as the last generation, of old-school American patriots, that truly loved and served, what they thought was the American republic.
Yes; even though transitioning, to what I and many other Americans now recognize America, as the US empire; the former American republic did play a major positive role, in modern World history, as you correctly pointed out. However, with your generation, being the last bastion, of what was the American republic, the future, of what you loved, will be the current US imperial Power Okole served by today's younger brainwashed subject-citizens, as I often refer, to a particular hi-tech someone, on this forum.
You are one, of the most knowledgeable members, here. Hence, understand that I sometimes need, to joust words with you, in order, to keep my sword, as sharp as yours. :geekdanc: :shaka:
-
Flapp, I know my views are controversial; but I consider you and most on this forum, as the last generation, of old-school American patriots, that truly loved and served, what they thought was the American republic.
Yes; even though transitioning, to what I and many other Americans now recognize America, as the US empire; the former American republic did play a major positive role, in modern World history, as you correctly pointed out. However, with your generation, being the last bastion, of what was the American republic, the future, of what you loved, will be the current US imperial Power Okole served by today's younger brainwashed subject-citizens, as I often refer, to a particular hi-tech someone, on this forum.
You are one, of the most knowledgeable members, here. Hence, understand that I sometimes need, to joust words with you, in order, to keep my sword, as sharp as yours. :geekdanc: :shaka:
"but I consider you and most on this forum, as the last generation, of old-school American patriots, that truly loved and served, what they thought was the American republic."
Very well stated.
As a father, a grandfather, uncle, and
Mentor, I've done my best, but nobody gets out of here
alive and the kids will carry on as they see fit.
Frankly if they fuck it up, they suffer, I'm dead,
At that point, I don't care about anything anymore.
:thumbsup:
-
Not sure how the tribal thing came up. But are you grasping at herd mentality?
I once googled "tribadism" and something really bad ass came up. NSFW
-
Learn something new everyday.
“commonly known by its scissoring position,”
Tribadism. Gonna try use that in my next scrabble game. Hope somebody challenges and looks it up.
Can imagine if it slipped into a spelling bee.
Can you provide the definition?
Can you use it in a sentence ?
-
Flapp, I know my views are controversial; but I consider you and most on this forum, as the last generation, of old-school American patriots, that truly loved and served, what they thought was the American republic.
Yes; even though transitioning, to what I and many other Americans now recognize America, as the US empire; the former American republic did play a major positive role, in modern World history, as you correctly pointed out. However, with your generation, being the last bastion, of what was the American republic, the future, of what you loved, will be the current US imperial Power Okole served by today's younger brainwashed subject-citizens, as I often refer, to a particular hi-tech someone, on this forum.
You are one, of the most knowledgeable members, here. Hence, understand that I sometimes need, to joust words with you, in order, to keep my sword, as sharp as yours. :geekdanc: :shaka:
I appreciate the sentiment.
Yes,. the US has changed these past few decades. The radicals of the 60s grew up and got government jobs. Their successors became lawyers and journalists. We find ourselves with the script flipped.
"The man" used to be the fat cats in Washington running the country as corporations dictated. Now, the Liberals are in charge, running the country for the Liberal corporations like Big Tech.
It's the same people, only one group has seized power from the previous group. Not talking Dems vs. GOP as much as Liberal-Progressive-Communist-Leftist vs. Conservatives & moderates. We have extreme forces pulling us in the direction of where the USSR was trying to go" a collectivist society where the needs of the individual no longer exist outside of how those who contribute to the state get rewarded.
I see your arguments about the Republic vs. Empire. I just don't agree that the US is doing it any differently than any other 1st world contemporary nation. The rules and playing field have changed, and so have the tactics needed to win.
I think this giant debt hole the nation's leaders are digging will soon come back to bite us. Economic strength will replace military strength as the measure of a Super Power. If we continue to be irresponsible fiscally, we will need 12 more years of Trump-quality business acumen to pull us out of this nose dive.
I haven't written the country off, but I do see us having another Great Depression soon. Can't keep borrowing money to cover up incompetent or willfully destructive policies.
-
Learn something new everyday.
“commonly known by its scissoring position,”
Tribadism. Gonna try use that in my next scrabble game. Hope somebody challenges and looks it up.
Can imagine if it slipped into a spelling bee.
Can you provide the definition?
Can you use it in a sentence ?
^^^^^He googled it. Hahahahahhaa
-
"but I consider you and most on this forum, as the last generation, of old-school American patriots, that truly loved and served, what they thought was the American republic."
Very well stated.
As a father, a grandfather, uncle, and
Mentor, I've done my best, but nobody gets out of here
alive and the kids will carry on as they see fit.
Frankly if they fuck it up, they suffer, I'm dead,
At that point, I don't care about anything anymore.
:thumbsup:
You say that now. Just wait until you're reincarnated.
They say you come back as a "lesser being."
That should include "Democrat." :shake:
-
There's a "herd mentality" experiment where people were asked to identify which length of string or something was shorter than the other one.
Everyone in the room was in on the setup except for the "subject."
Everyone picked the longer string and said it was the shorter one. The subject could plainly see that this was the longer of the two. However, instead of picking the one he knew to be correct, which would imply all the others got it wrong, he picked the longer string as well.
This is a phenomenon observed almost 2 centuries ago, and it was incorporated in the children's story "The Emperor's New Clothes." All the adults pretended to see what they were told was reality. It took an innocent child to tell the truth.
It's much easier to travel the same direction as the herd, school, or whatever group than it is to go against the flow.
By the way, after one of the people in on the string experiment chose the right string, the subject was 30% more likely to pick the right one, too. Sometimes it only takes one other person to confirm your beliefs for you to act on them. If no one is brave enough to trust their own eyes, society will follow the crowd off the nearest cliff.
Now do vaccines, "consensus," and "majority."
-
Had another recent experiment. 10 people in a doctors waiting room and 1 person walks in (the subject). When a beep went off, everyone stood up. They wanted to see how long before the subject also took part in standing up. Some asked why is everyone standing and the reply was IDK.
-
Had another recent experiment. 10 people in a doctors waiting room and 1 person walks in (the subject). When a beep went off, everyone stood up. They wanted to see how long before the subject also took part in standing up. Some asked why is everyone standing and the reply was IDK.
Look up studies on how Japanese and other asian countries are pros at waiting in lines. I've witnessed some of that first hand in numerous visits. Folks waiting in line for a Disney ride fast pass, but the machine was broken. My buddy's wife (hapa, but fluent Japanese) luckily asked and clarified. There were folks waiting in line and many just lined up behind them.
-
Look up studies on how Japanese and other asian countries are pros at waiting in lines. I've witnessed some of that first hand in numerous visits. Folks waiting in line for a Disney ride fast pass, but the machine was broken. My buddy's wife (hapa, but fluent Japanese) luckily asked and clarified. There were folks waiting in line and many just lined up behind them.
I'm no follower. So I ask if this is the line for X. I actually get joy at the Longs I go to. There is a line marker set up movie theater style. About 5 self check out and 1 human register. Almost all the time there is a line, I see 1 or no people at the self check out, even though the open light is on at the top of them. The lone cashier is ringing someone up. So I just bypass everyone and go to the self check out. Then the light bulb goes on and people follow. This could be seen as a dick move, but not my problem they cannot figure stuff out.
What does irritate me about Jap tourist is they do not know how to wait at a crosswalk for the light to change. Many are often waiting on the road, just off the curb. And they like to stand in the middle of clothing store walk ways, even when not looking at clothes. Dated a chick that worked at Abercrombie and walking into the store to where she was, always had Jap tourist in the way. But they are very apologetic when you say excuse me. "Sumimasen...sumimasen" with the head nod for each time the word was said is their reply.
-
I'm no follower. So I ask if this is the line for X. I actually get joy at the Longs I go to. There is a line marker set up movie theater style. About 5 self check out and 1 human register. Almost all the time there is a line, I see 1 or no people at the self check out, even though the open light is on at the top of them. The lone cashier is ringing someone up. So I just bypass everyone and go to the self check out. Then the light bulb goes on and people follow. This could be seen as a dick move, but not my problem they cannot figure stuff out.
What does irritate me about Jap tourist is they do not know how to wait at a crosswalk for the light to change. Many are often waiting on the road, just off the curb. And they like to stand in the middle of clothing store walk ways, even when not looking at clothes. Dated a chick that worked at Abercrombie and walking into the store to where she was, always had Jap tourist in the way. But they are very apologetic when you say excuse me. "Sumimasen...sumimasen" with the head nod for each time the word was said is their reply.
I learned my first month in Hawaii about Japanese etiquette when in public. On the sidewalks of Waikiki, they just walk straight toward their destination. If they bump into someone, there's no "Excuse me", "Sorry" or any other apology.
Then I went to Tokyo. Ten times more crowded than Waikiki. If they apologized every time they bumped into someone, they'd never get anywhere! Crowded conditions basically turned them into automatons (robots) when in public trying to get somewhere. That attitude carries over when they come here apparently.
They might nod when you say "Excuse me" to get past them, but they wouldn't bat an eye if you brushed past them without a word, as that's the norm.
Different strokes ....
As for following people for no reason ... My mom used to wear a T-Shirt that said, "Don't follow me. I'm lost, too!" We got her that because she had this knack about causing lines to form. At the county fair, she'd pick a ride or exhibit because nobody was in line for it. As soon as she got in line, there would be 10-15 more people lined up behind her. It happened pretty much every time. She asked one of the ride operators if they'd consider paying her a percentage of the ride's revenue if she'd keep lining up to ride! :rofl:
So, yeah. Nobody in line -- less chance anyone will come over to wait. Put a few people in line, and others will think there must be a good reason to be there.
-
I learned my first month in Hawaii about Japanese etiquette when in public. On the sidewalks of Waikiki, they just walk straight toward their destination. If they bump into someone, there's no "Excuse me", "Sorry" or any other apology.
Then I went to Tokyo. Ten times more crowded than Waikiki. If they apologized every time they bumped into someone, they'd never get anywhere! Crowded conditions basically turned them into automatons (robots) when in public trying to get somewhere. That attitude carries over when they come here apparently.
They might nod when you say "Excuse me" to get past them, but they wouldn't bat an eye if you brushed past them without a word, as that's the norm.
Different strokes ....
Taiwan is the same. People bump you all the time, but it's all G cause you're in their way and preventing them from going from point A to B. And if you bump them, they don't mind cause that means they're in your way from going to point B. At least Taiwan doesn't have the crazy crowded trains like Japan does. But it does look like a fun job. I would yell "RAMMING SPEED" all day.
So only after visiting Taiwan, do I now understand the concept. Guess it's popular in other Asian countries as well. If you pull that here in HI, dem are fighting words, so to say.
-
Taiwan is the same. People bump you all the time, but it's all G cause you're in their way and preventing them from going from point A to B. And if you bump them, they don't mind cause that means they're in your way from going to point B. At least Taiwan doesn't have the crazy crowded trains like Japan does. But it does look like a fun job. I would yell "RAMMING SPEED" all day.
So only after visiting Taiwan, do I now understand the concept. Guess it's popular in other Asian countries as well. If you pull that here in HI, dem are fighting words, so to say.
We always tried to avoid the trains around Tokyo during commuting hours. I bet the sardines are laughing!
My buddy showed us the easiest method for buying train tickets. Get the cheapest one they offer. When you get to your stop, go to the fare machine, and it'll tell you how much more you owe from your purchase point to that station. We walked past tons of people trying to calculate their fares before buying a ticket. That directly correlates to the herd mentality topic brought up here. They were doing what all the people in front of them were doing. We found a more efficient method and bypassed the lines. :geekdanc:
-
Some ideas are so unreasonable and dangerous that to entertain them is to give them a foothold of legitimacy that they do not deserve.
Thats exactly the argument people use to censor free speech, I don't think that is your intent though. I will say that I disagree with your sentiment though.
When you compare me with a terrorist for standing up for my rights then there is no middle ground. You are my enemy, and you are the enemy of everything this country is supposed to stand for.
I never said you were anything like a terrorist, utterly false, however I do apologize if that was the impression you got.
-
Thats exactly the argument people use to censor free speech.
I never said you were anything like a terrorist, utterly false.
Nobody said "Censorship." He's saying that to entertain dangerous ideas, thus giving them legitimacy next to ideas that are not dangerous, is how those ideas become mainstream and deceptively benign.
Look at how the Socialist ideas have crept into our society. History shows us the utter failure when such ideas are implemented, yet academically, people still try to justify its legitimacy.
Here we are, with a Bernie Sanders Socialist Regime on the doorsteps of the White House, and people think "It has to be better than what we have," because they just don't want to study history.
Censor him? No. Make him President? Hell no!
-
And I CLEARLY posted that this is a red herring and IRRELEVANT because he was not IN FACT fired. What some fans and others may have called for is not a valid point unless you have evidence it was only one political affiliation ("tribe") doing so.
Like I said, I was comparing the calling for his firing to the calling of unvaccinated being fired.
Please show me where I said you were talking about people having to do things at the barrel of a gun.
I already went over this when I covered force vs coercion.
Short answer -- you refuse to acknowledge the difference between "respect" and "patriotism" when discussing national symbols.
I don't refuse to acknowledge that they are different, just the difference is not relevant to my point. Coerced patriotism, love, respect, etc. none of them are real when they are coerced. You were too focused on how they are not all the same thing to see the point was about the coercion.
WRONG.
36 US Code § 301 - National anthem -- Not arbitrary., but law.
https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/36/301
LOL, thats just arbitrary written into law!
-
Not sure how the tribal thing came up. But are you grasping at herd mentality?
I think you are trying to make connections based on what you assume for many on this board. Then you started grasping at straws to try to make a point by attempting to provoke thought based on your assumptions/profile of folks here.
Are there folks on the ends of the spectrum? Yeah, in more ways than one that I have observed. That's the thing with generalities and trying to throw a blanket over groups.
I think tribalism and herd mentality are somewhat related but I don't think I am talking about herd mentality.
I tried to come up with an example which to me illustrated the phenomenon but apparently others don't see it. So either I am seeing something that isn't a contradiction or other people can't see it is a contradiction due to the nature of tribalism. I guess the problem with using such examples is that they lack the data of studies necessary to prove or disprove them as real examples. Another example I was pondering was the reactions when Obama bowed to a foreign Arab leader vs when Bush held hands with a foreign Arab leader but again we lack quantitative data as far as I can tell and they aren't perfect 1 for 1 comparisons.
I find it interesting though when situations occur where you would expect a standard political divide on an issue based on tendencies among those political identifications. So the capitol got overrun and suddenly democrats who had wanted to defund the police sounded like republicans with strong support for the police and strong prison sentences. Or when covid hit, conservatives who usually tout the free market started to sound like liberals when they became so skeptical of big pharma.
I do think that this can be something hard to study because it isn't exactly something flattering. We like to think we are all individuals and free thinkers so even just the suggestion that we fall pre to tribalism is something we don't want to consider or admit. I don't think politics escapes this tribalism whether it is a general political identity or surrounding a specific candidate like Trump and Biden. Just trying to bring up this subject in the realm of politics has obviously roused strong feelings. It is hard to even bring up an example without people running to battle-stations. My suggestion that peoples positions on the vaccine and masking would be switched if the politicians positions were switched on its face ends up being insulting because it suggests we aren't really that free thinking.
I must acknowledge that with politics people don't always fall into easily defined lines where they agree on everything. Even this board here has a spectrum of views about gun rights even though I think we all generally favor gun rights.
-
Nobody said "Censorship."
I know. Irrelevant.
He's saying that to entertain dangerous ideas, thus giving them legitimacy next to ideas that are not dangerous, is how those ideas become mainstream and deceptively benign.
A difference yes but not a significant one for my point.
Look at how the Socialist ideas have crept into our society. History shows us the utter failure when such ideas are implemented, yet academically, people still try to justify its legitimacy. Here we are, with a Bernie Sanders Socialist Regime on the doorsteps of the White House, and people think "It has to be better than what we have," because they just don't want to study history.
This is likely a problem which will never truly go away, we will have to educated each generation about the dangers of full socialism to keep people from falling into its attractive trap. But we won't just do that by pointing at the worst examples and just trying to make people feel dumb for considering it, they will just think they can do it better. Just telling them it is too dangerous to even entertain isn't going to accomplish anything.
-
There's a "herd mentality" experiment where people were asked to identify which length of string or something was shorter than the other one.
Everyone in the room was in on the setup except for the "subject."
Everyone picked the longer string and said it was the shorter one. The subject could plainly see that this was the longer of the two. However, instead of picking the one he knew to be correct, which would imply all the others got it wrong, he picked the longer string as well.
This is a phenomenon observed almost 2 centuries ago, and it was incorporated in the children's story "The Emperor's New Clothes." All the adults pretended to see what they were told was reality. It took an innocent child to tell the truth.
It's much easier to travel the same direction as the herd, school, or whatever group than it is to go against the flow.
By the way, after one of the people in on the string experiment chose the right string, the subject was 30% more likely to pick the right one, too. Sometimes it only takes one other person to confirm your beliefs for you to act on them. If no one is brave enough to trust their own eyes, society will follow the crowd off the nearest cliff.
Now do vaccines, "consensus," and "majority."
Very good examples Flapp, thank you for adding that to the conversation.
-
I think tribalism and herd mentality are somewhat related but I don't think I am talking about herd mentality.
I tried to come up with an example which to me illustrated the phenomenon but apparently others don't see it. So either I am seeing something that isn't a contradiction or other people can't see it is a contradiction due to the nature of tribalism. I guess the problem with using such examples is that they lack the data of studies necessary to prove or disprove them as real examples. Another example I was pondering was the reactions when Obama bowed to a foreign Arab leader vs when Bush held hands with a foreign Arab leader but again we lack quantitative data as far as I can tell and they aren't perfect 1 for 1 comparisons.
I find it interesting though when situations occur where you would expect a standard political divide on an issue based on tendencies among those political identifications. So the capitol got overrun and suddenly democrats who had wanted to defund the police sounded like republicans with strong support for the police and strong prison sentences. Or when covid hit, conservatives who usually tout the free market started to sound like liberals when they became so skeptical of big pharma.
I do think that this can be something hard to study because it isn't exactly something flattering. We like to think we are all individuals and free thinkers so even just the suggestion that we fall pre to tribalism is something we don't want to consider or admit. I don't think politics escapes this tribalism whether it is a general political identity or surrounding a specific candidate like Trump and Biden. Just trying to bring up this subject in the realm of politics has obviously roused strong feelings. It is hard to even bring up an example without people running to battle-stations. My suggestion that peoples positions on the vaccine and masking would be switched if the politicians positions were switched on its face ends up being insulting because it suggests we aren't really that free thinking.
I must acknowledge that with politics people don't always fall into easily defined lines where they agree on everything. Even this board here has a spectrum of views about gun rights even though I think we all generally favor gun rights.
Tribadism
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
The only tribes that matter:
Tribe 1- The Swamp
Tribe 2- Violent Extremists (now defined as anyone who disagrees with The Swamp)
https://www.activistpost.com/2021/10/militia-violent-extremists-added-to-a-growing-list-of-9-violent-domestic-extremists-groups.html
-
I was thinking about some other examples of this that show how supporting your tribe matters more than objectivity. And I don't think it is a concious choice to ignore the truth but a sincere subconscious inability to see outside of what tribes tell people to think. Studies have shown there is a high resistance to going against a tribe. If humans were really objective we would expect to see opinions and beliefs about these issues spread across race, religion, politics, etc but we don't. Additionally I think we see people tending to lineup the same way on sub issues to a large issue, so for example we don't usually find anti covid vaccine people who are pro mask but anti lockdowns and vice versa. People seem to line up relatively neatly instead of having varying unique opinions.
Again these are just examples of this phenomenon, not trying to hold a discussion on any of these issues. Additionally these are just observations of mine, not quantitative data.
#1. The breakdown of who thinks Trump lost legitimately or it was stolen. Pretty clear lines from what I have seen, the strong supporters all seem to think the election was stolen and the people hardcore against Trump all think he lost legitimately. I have never met a Democrat who thought Trump's election was stolen and I have never met a hardcore Trump supporter who thought Trump lost legitimately.
#2 Responses to covid, masks, and the vaccine. Here I think the lines are not as clean but from what I have observed divisions seem relatively consistent along certain tribal lines.
#3 Gun rights. The liberals tend to think the 2nd amendment means one thing and the conservatives tend to think it means something different.
-
so it's only groupthink and it's not possible that more than a few people came to the same conclusion?
I was thinking about some other examples of this that show how supporting your tribe matters more than objectivity. And I don't think it is a concious choice to ignore the truth but a sincere subconscious inability to see outside of what tribes tell people to think. Studies have shown there is a high resistance to going against a tribe. If humans were really objective we would expect to see opinions and beliefs about these issues spread across race, religion, politics, etc but we don't. Additionally I think we see people tending to lineup the same way on sub issues to a large issue, so for example we don't usually find anti covid vaccine people who are pro mask but anti lockdowns and vice versa. People seem to line up relatively neatly instead of having varying unique opinions.
Again these are just examples of this phenomenon, not trying to hold a discussion on any of these issues. Additionally these are just observations of mine, not quantitative data.
#1. The breakdown of who thinks Trump lost legitimately or it was stolen. Pretty clear lines from what I have seen, the strong supporters all seem to think the election was stolen and the people hardcore against Trump all think he lost legitimately. I have never met a Democrat who thought Trump's election was stolen and I have never met a hardcore Trump supporter who thought Trump lost legitimately.
#2 Responses to covid, masks, and the vaccine. Here I think the lines are not as clean but from what I have observed divisions seem relatively consistent along certain tribal lines.
#3 Gun rights. The liberals tend to think the 2nd amendment means one thing and the conservatives tend to think it means something different.
-
so it's only groupthink and it's not possible that more than a few people came to the same conclusion?
echo chamber bruh
-
I was thinking about some other examples of this that show how supporting your tribe matters more than objectivity. And I don't think it is a concious choice to ignore the truth but a sincere subconscious inability to see outside of what tribes tell people to think. Studies have shown there is a high resistance to going against a tribe. If humans were really objective we would expect to see opinions and beliefs about these issues spread across race, religion, politics, etc but we don't. Additionally I think we see people tending to lineup the same way on sub issues to a large issue, so for example we don't usually find anti covid vaccine people who are pro mask but anti lockdowns and vice versa. People seem to line up relatively neatly instead of having varying unique opinions.
Again these are just examples of this phenomenon, not trying to hold a discussion on any of these issues. Additionally these are just observations of mine, not quantitative data.
#1. The breakdown of who thinks Trump lost legitimately or it was stolen. Pretty clear lines from what I have seen, the strong supporters all seem to think the election was stolen and the people hardcore against Trump all think he lost legitimately. I have never met a Democrat who thought Trump's election was stolen and I have never met a hardcore Trump supporter who thought Trump lost legitimately.
#2 Responses to covid, masks, and the vaccine. Here I think the lines are not as clean but from what I have observed divisions seem relatively consistent along certain tribal lines.
#3 Gun rights. The liberals tend to think the 2nd amendment means one thing and the conservatives tend to think it means something different.
Your observations are flawed.
There are plenty of people/groups who are pro-mask and anti-lockdown. Your characterization of "pro-mask" is incorrect. People who don't agree with the mandatory closing of businesses tend to also be against mask MANDATES. Big difference between that and being "anti-mask."
Being against mandatory closures and mandatory mask wearing are both consistent with the belief that government does not have the authority to do such things without scientific proof that (1) failing to do so will be worse than doing it, and (2) the individual freedom to choose for themselves must be protected.
Therefore, the "tribe" you are describing values individual choice and liberty over governmental control. Americans are mostly averse to being forced to do anything, even when that thing holds the promise of benefits or preventing negative outcomes.
Ask Edgar Friendly how that works. :thumbsup: :geekdanc:
-
echo chamber bruh
lul
-
so it's only groupthink and it's not possible that more than a few people came to the same conclusion?
If you find conclusions so strongly correlated along certain tribal lines (religion, race, politics, etc) then I would say groupthink is a strong factor.
I think that if this were not the case then you would expect to find more diversity of thought. I think this is also why you find groups with positions that are inconsistent with the ideals of their tribe, loyalty to the tribe is more valued than consistent ideology. Why are people who don't line up with their tribes get attacked? Look at what happens when a democrat doesn't side with the liberal agenda? They eat their own. What happens when a republican doesn't side with Trump? A RINO or worse.
Back in caveman days this may have been a trait that served us well.
-
Your observations are flawed.
There are plenty of people/groups who are pro-mask and anti-lockdown. Your characterization of "pro-mask" is incorrect. People who don't agree with the mandatory closing of businesses tend to also be against mask MANDATES. Big difference between that and being "anti-mask."
Being against mandatory closures and mandatory mask wearing are both consistent with the belief that government does not have the authority to do such things without scientific proof that (1) failing to do so will be worse than doing it, and (2) the individual freedom to choose for themselves must be protected.
Therefore, the "tribe" you are describing values individual choice and liberty over governmental control. Americans are mostly averse to being forced to do anything, even when that thing holds the promise of benefits or preventing negative outcomes.
Ask Edgar Friendly how that works. :thumbsup: :geekdanc:
How many people have you seen who are pro mask mandates but anti lockdown? Of course they exist, I am not saying there is no diversity of thought in this world but I see less of it the more people identify with tribes. I think you find more diversity of thought among the independents.
Look at the liberals who were against the vaccine when Trump was president but now want to force it when Biden is president? Did the science suddenly change? No, the tribe changed and people followed.
Look at how sports fans judge referee calls. They agree with the ones that favor their teams and disagree with the ones that don't.
-
so now you moving goalpost to "strong factor"?
If you find conclusions so strongly correlated along certain tribal lines (religion, race, politics, etc) then I would say groupthink is a strong factor.
I think that if this were not the case then you would expect to find more diversity of thought. I think this is also why you find groups with positions that are inconsistent with the ideals of their tribe, loyalty to the tribe is more valued than consistent ideology. Why are people who don't line up with their tribes get attacked? Look at what happens when a democrat doesn't side with the liberal agenda? They eat their own. What happens when a republican doesn't side with Trump? A RINO or worse.
Back in caveman days this may have been a trait that served us well.
-
The short explanation:
MAGA is motivated by freedom
Liberals are motivated by tyranny
-
How many people have you seen who are pro mask mandates but anti lockdown? Of course they exist, I am not saying there is no diversity of thought in this world but I see less of it the more people identify with tribes. I think you find more diversity of thought among the independents.
Look at the liberals who were against the vaccine when Trump was president but now want to force it when Biden is president? Did the science suddenly change? No, the tribe changed and people followed.
Look at how sports fans judge referee calls. They agree with the ones that favor their teams and disagree with the ones that don't.
Not what I said.
Pro-mask, but anti-lockdown and anti-mask mandate. You're still getting it confused.
-
How many people have you seen who are pro mask mandates but anti lockdown? Of course they exist, I am not saying there is no diversity of thought in this world but I see less of it the more people identify with tribes. I think you find more diversity of thought among the independents.
Look at the liberals who were against the vaccine when Trump was president but now want to force it when Biden is president? Did the science suddenly change? No, the tribe changed and people followed.
Look at how sports fans judge referee calls. They agree with the ones that favor their teams and disagree with the ones that don't.
You're putting too much faith in individuals having the discipline, motivation and education to make their own decisions.
When the PRESS and the DEMOCRAT CANDIDATES/NOMINEES said Trump can't be trusted -- including any vaccine his administration ushers in -- the Liberal masses who follow those political and media leaders agree with them.
When Biden/Harris (allegedly) won the election, and the vaccine was no longer a "Trump win" for the nation, the PRESS and RESIDENT BIDEN did a 180, and the same followers changed their tune. They did not change because the TRIBE got a memo with the day's talking points. They changed because the information being pushed was whatever their leaders told them. And, not coincidentally, the press and big tech censored anyone who had opposing evidence or opinions.
So, it's not tribalism. It's information control. Seeing one "side" switch from an anti-Trump position on vaccines to one which adopts it 100% under Biden shows it's not tribalism. It's control.
There's a big difference between following the crowd and following the people controlling the message.
If the press had focused more on Fauci and less on Trump, the acceptance of the vaccine would have been far greater. The stories they told denigrating "Trump's vaccine" probably did more to persuade people to become "anti-vaccine" than anything else. Will they admit what they did? Will they be held accountable? Never.
-
I can’t speak for others, so I can only speak for myself.
I am not anti mask. I am anti mask mandate. There is no real science that anyone can provide that proves otherwise with any mask less than an N95 type. I fully admit that wearing a mask of any type less than an N95 type might have a very minuscule effect on the virus being transmitted from one person to another. This would only be due to catching actual droplets. But the virus itself FREELY goes right through all mask types of the less than N95 type. But the side effects are so minuscule that the side effects of wearing a mask of a less than an N95 type do not make wearing a mask worth it. IE the side effects of wearing a mask of a less than an 95 type are worse than the ability of the mask to protect you from a virus that cannot be stopped by the mask. You want to wear a mask, or two, go right ahead.
I am not anti social distancing. But I am against mandated social distancing. It only makes sense that distance from an infected person is very effective. But the choice is yours.
I was anti lockdown and completely against it when it began in the Trump era. I bashed Trump for it happening under his watch. I was also correct in assuming it would do the country more harm than good. And I was also correct when I said the lockdown is going to do nothing more than kicking the can down the road. And that it will subside once more people get it themselves and obtain a natural immunity. I was also correct when I said the lockdown would reek havoc on our economy. And it has.
I am also anti vaccine mandate (Not anti vaccine). All mandates of any type are anti American and anti freedom. The vaccine is only for people who choose to take it. And not for those who choose not to. That is freedom of choice. Anything else is against our constitution and against the laws of this country.
Nothing Trump nor Biden nor Fauci can say or do to change the facts of the illegality of the mandates. So in my case it makes no difference what Trump or Biden or Fauci can say or do to change these facts nor my mind. Unfortunately, there are those in this world that hate Trump or Biden so much that they will take the opposite stance. Same goes for those who love them. JMHO
-
so now you moving goalpost to "strong factor"?
No goalpost moved. I never said groupthink was the sole factor at play. The reason I said strong factor was to have a more accurate statement. Its very rare in sociology that you can say an issue is all one thing.
-
So, it's not tribalism. It's information control. Seeing one "side" switch from an anti-Trump position on vaccines to one which adopts it 100% under Biden shows it's not tribalism. It's control.
There's a big difference between following the crowd and following the people controlling the message.
And what, only us conservatives are smart enough to see through that? Its just Democrats being tricked by the media and us republicans aren't stepping in line behind Trump at all?
Again, I am not trying to make this specifically a Trump thing. Trump is very polarizing but this phenomenon isn't only present surrounding Trump. I think it is showing up very strongly surrounding Trump though and not just by Democrats hating Trump but also the level of loyalty Trump has managed to gather despite various things he has said and positions he has taken that are not consistent with conservativism. This topic is not an attack Trump's side or attack Biden's side type of thing, its just observing how tribalism affects the way people think.
I will give another example, gay marriage. Republicans tended to line up against gay marriage just a decade or so ago while democrats were the ones pushing it (generally speaking). The ideologies of conservatism would logically conclude that the government shouldn't get into people's business yet they were the ones resisting against it. Did all the republicans reason through the ideologies of conservatism to come to the conclusion or did they side with the tribe?
-
Not what I said.
Pro-mask, but anti-lockdown and anti-mask mandate. You're still getting it confused.
I know what you said, I was giving a different comparison than you were.
-
And what, only us conservatives are smart enough to see through that? Its just Democrats being tricked by the media and us republicans aren't stepping in line behind Trump at all?
Again, I am not trying to make this specifically a Trump thing. Trump is very polarizing but this phenomenon isn't only present surrounding Trump. I think it is showing up very strongly surrounding Trump though and not just by Democrats hating Trump but also the level of loyalty Trump has managed to gather despite various things he has said and positions he has taken that are not consistent with conservativism. This topic is not an attack Trump's side or attack Biden's side type of thing, its just observing how tribalism affects the way people think.
I will give another example, gay marriage. Republicans tended to line up against gay marriage just a decade or so ago while democrats were the ones pushing it (generally speaking). The ideologies of conservatism would logically conclude that the government shouldn't get into people's business yet they were the ones resisting against it. Did all the republicans reason through the ideologies of conservatism to come to the conclusion or did they side with the tribe?
First of all, I call BS on Gay Marriage. That's got nothing to do with Gay rights. Civil Unions or other similar legal joining of a same sex couple can offer the same legal rights as a traditional marriage. But the Left wanted to push to tear down the tradition, not protect rights. AFAIK, most Conservatives were okay with government-sanctioned unions, but wanted weddings and marriage to remain a tradition that was reserved for a man & woman.
Anyway, I firmly believe that most Conservatives are 1000 times more open minded than Liberals. Liberals talk about tolerance, but they refuse to tolerate the Right wing or conservative members of society.. Think about it. Not all Conservatives blindly follow devout Christian or Republican positions.
-
I know what you said, I was giving a different comparison than you were.
So, you didn't want to address my argument, so you made up one of your own? :wacko:
-
First of all, I call BS on Gay Marriage. That's got nothing to do with Gay rights. Civil Unions or other similar legal joining of a same sex couple can offer the same legal rights as a traditional marriage. But the Left wanted to push to tear down the tradition, not protect rights. AFAIK, most Conservatives were okay with government-sanctioned unions, but wanted weddings and marriage to remain a tradition that was reserved for a man & woman.
Anyway, I firmly believe that most Conservatives are 1000 times more open minded than Liberals. Liberals talk about tolerance, but they refuse to tolerate the Right wing or conservative members of society.. Think about it. Not all Conservatives blindly follow devout Christian or Republican positions.
This phenomenon gets hard to discuss because we can all think of that democrat who supports guns or republican who supports subsidized health care (for example) not everyone fits neatly into these boxes. I don't think this negates the phenomenon though. On any contentious issue regarding issues of fact there is an actual truth of the matter and facts don't neatly follow one side or the other. When it comes to an issue, a political one for example, do you really think conservatives just happen to have all the facts on their sides and the liberals have none? We like to think we are good at seeing the facts and objective yet groups follow ideological lines more than scientific lines. Back to a sports example, a ball was either over the line or it wasn't yet people will divide based on which call they prefer more than which call is right.
I think the data would prove you wrong about conservatives being more open minded than liberals, at least by certain metrics. I am trying to remember a few studies on that very topic and they found that liberals were more open to trying new things and welcoming change while conservatives were more resistant to change and less likely to try new things. (I would have to find the study again to offer more specifics) Now this isn't inherently a good thing or a bag thing, change can be good or it can be bad so it is not a moral judgement on conservatives.
When it comes to the people vocal against the covid vaccine I notice they tend to pick up all the same arguments attacking the vaccines rather than having varrying views. Now perhaps this is more confirmation bias than tribalism but I do think that the two are related. (Being for your own tribe biases you towards information that supports your tribe).
-
I think the data would prove you wrong about conservatives being more open minded than liberals, at least by certain metrics. I am trying to remember a few studies on that very topic and they found that liberals were more open to trying new things and welcoming change while conservatives were more resistant to change and less likely to try new things. (I would have to find the study again to offer more specifics) Now this isn't inherently a good thing or a bag thing, change can be good or it can be bad so it is not a moral judgement on conservatives.
You say the "data" proves me wrong, but you can't remember what that data are? Thanks.
There are no "studies" that can identify actual attitudes when it comes to controversial subjects. How often do you think both sides will lie when they don't want to sound intolerant or unwoke?
You offered an opinion, then eluded to studies that you can't name. Not exactly a good example of sourcing your supporting "data".
-
Here is what's missing from this fishing trip.
Trump fast tracked the vaxx process. So in theory, all his supporters should be OK with getting vaxxed. There were many tweets from TDSers that they won't get jabbed cause Trump is rushing the standard process. Only to get jabbed 6 months later and tweet about it's their duty and blah, blah, blah.
So if someone states you're anti vaxx cause you support Trump, is fishing.
It's possible that Trump supporters know how to think for themselves. And with a vaxx that was never allowed in humans to be all of a sudden OK, even though the tech has been around for decades, shows a red flag. MRNA tech only made it to animal trials prior to covid. It wasn't allowed in human trials until Trump OK'd the fast track.
It's a total toss up on what your party is and if you get vaxxed or not. I know many liberals who are both vaxxed and anti vaxxed, and many conservatives the same. But what I do see is that conservatives are more against being forced to vaxx and liberals are OK with it.
-
You say the "data" proves me wrong, but you can't remember what that data are? Thanks.
There are no "studies" that can identify actual attitudes when it comes to controversial subjects. How often do you think both sides will lie when they don't want to sound intolerant or unwoke?
You offered an opinion, then eluded to studies that you can't name. Not exactly a good example of sourcing your supporting "data".
Do you remember exactly where you learned everything you learned? If you are truly interested in the study I can try to find it for you. I know I learned about it on a science podcast.
As to your second question, this boils down to designing good questionnaires. If you put language that will evoke a bias or a judgement your results will more likely be skewed. This can be mitigated with anonymity, neutral word choice, and better designing of the questions.
-
Here is what's missing from this fishing trip.
Trump fast tracked the vaxx process. So in theory, all his supporters should be OK with getting vaxxed. There were many tweets from TDSers that they won't get jabbed cause Trump is rushing the standard process. Only to get jabbed 6 months later and tweet about it's their duty and blah, blah, blah.
So if someone states you're anti vaxx cause you support Trump, is fishing.
It's possible that Trump supporters know how to think for themselves. And with a vaxx that was never allowed in humans to be all of a sudden OK, even though the tech has been around for decades, shows a red flag. MRNA tech only made it to animal trials prior to covid. It wasn't allowed in human trials until Trump OK'd the fast track.
It's a total toss up on what your party is and if you get vaxxed or not. I know many liberals who are both vaxxed and anti vaxxed, and many conservatives the same. But what I do see is that conservatives are more against being forced to vaxx and liberals are OK with it.
A good analysis.
One of the hard things is to study the questions of "if X had happened then Y would have reacted a different way" because we can't go back in time and reverse situation and let it play out again. Sometimes we can find ways around this when circumstances create pockets, a proxy can be used but it isn't always easy to do.
One curve ball here is that there are the regular anti-vaxers who were against vaccines well before covid and from my understanding these people weren't necessarily conservatives but often liberals. I do think politics has played a role in a lot of the people who are against the covid vaccine but there are certainly many who were against all vaccines well before this so it would be a fallacious argument for someone to conclude that being against vaccines makes one a Trump supporter. The differences between these two groups is significant though it is not always obvious which one they are from simply from hearing that they are against the covid vaccine.
When Trump was fast tracking the mRNA vaccines I don't recall hearing much pushback from conservatives or his supporters. Do you?
I don't think Trump has complete control over his supporters to where he could convince all his supporters to get vaccinated but I do think that if he campaigned for everyone to be vaccinated and said how safe he thought it was that more Trump supporters would get vaccinated.
-
A good analysis.
One of the hard things is to study the questions of "if X had happened then Y would have reacted a different way" because we can't go back in time and reverse situation and let it play out again. Sometimes we can find ways around this when circumstances create pockets, a proxy can be used but it isn't always easy to do.
One curve ball here is that there are the regular anti-vaxers who were against vaccines well before covid and from my understanding these people weren't necessarily conservatives but often liberals. I do think politics has played a role in a lot of the people who are against the covid vaccine but there are certainly many who were against all vaccines well before this so it would be a fallacious argument for someone to conclude that being against vaccines makes one a Trump supporter. The differences between these two groups is significant though it is not always obvious which one they are from simply from hearing that they are against the covid vaccine.
When Trump was fast tracking the mRNA vaccines I don't recall hearing much pushback from conservatives or his supporters. Do you?
I don't think Trump has complete control over his supporters to where he could convince all his supporters to get vaccinated but I do think that if he campaigned for everyone to be vaccinated and said how safe he thought it was that more Trump supporters would get vaccinated.
No push back because we all thought the jab would be optional. But jokes on us. Myself included thought if someone wants to but an expirental drug in their body, then its on them. Now i was coerced to put said expiremental drug in my body.
Had we known what we know now, maybe it wouldnt have been fast tracked. But thats a huge hypothetical.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
Do you remember exactly where you learned everything you learned?
No, but if I'm going to evoke that data to support an argument, I'm sure as heck going to refresh my memory first instead of making a claim I can't immediately back up.
Anybody can make a claim based on "something I remember seeing but can't remember where." If you can't remember where you saw it, how can you be sure you're remembering the facts any better?
I would verify my info, or not mention it at all.
-
I remember seeing studies of remdisivar and 30% of people taking had liver/kidney failure symptoms.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
No push back because we all thought the jab would be optional. But jokes on us. Myself included thought if someone wants to but an expirental drug in their body, then its on them. Now i was coerced to put said expiremental drug in my body.
Had we known what we know now, maybe it wouldnt have been fast tracked. But thats a huge hypothetical.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
I can't think of anything we have learned about covid which would have lead to it not being fast tracked? What are you referring to?
I think calling it experimental is a little bit misleading even it arguably technically true but thats another discussion
-
No, but if I'm going to evoke that data to support an argument, I'm sure as heck going to refresh my memory first instead of making a claim I can't immediately back up.
Anybody can make a claim based on "something I remember seeing but can't remember where." If you can't remember where you saw it, how can you be sure you're remembering the facts any better?
I would verify my info, or not mention it at all.
'
I remember what I learned it just isn't that easy to find a source for something I learned from a radio interview.
I found this link, I don't know if it is the exact one I heard on the interview or not but it is certainly related. It also leads to a discussion on whether conservatives and liberals may actually be wired differently, whether through nurture or nature but that is getting into a whole separate area of study.
https://www.psypost.org/2020/05/new-research-suggests-that-conservatives-and-liberals-show-differences-in-executive-functioning-56867
-
I think that I was having a hard time putting into works the example of this phenomenon I was seeing in the pandemic but I think maybe I have figured out a way to state it.
I have noticed that among those who are against the mandates they tend to repeat all arguments against masking, lockdowns, and the vaccine. By that I mean when if they are taking a negative stance against the government response (masks and vaccines) they seem to take all of the negative views about it. Masks aren't effective, vaccines are too new, ivermectin works, mandates are unconstitutional, vaccines aren't effective, etc etc. In moderates I see more varied positions but in the more conservative side I notice less variance. I never see anyone claim the vaccines are dangerous but also effective for example.
And this isn't a one sided thing either, I see the people who are strongly in favor of the vaccine adopt all of the positive views about the vaccine as well with less willingness to admit anything negative either.
The thing is that I don't think the actual science is all negative or all positive for the vaccine but when battle lines are drawn and people choose sides they seem to adopt all the arguments of the side they have joined. When is science or truth ever that clean where it only favors one side or the other? If humans were all rational thinking beings why would we #1 disagree about the data and #2 arrive at such clean different points of views? For ideological arguments of course differences are understandable but when it comes to data these differences are not understandable, unlike with opinions, these arguments are mostly matters of something that is a factual question. And political ideology seems to correlate with this.
I hope what I am trying to explain makes sense even if you disagree
-
'
I remember what I learned it just isn't that easy to find a source for something I learned from a radio interview.
I found this link, I don't know if it is the exact one I heard on the interview or not but it is certainly related. It also leads to a discussion on whether conservatives and liberals may actually be wired differently, whether through nurture or nature but that is getting into a whole separate area of study.
https://www.psypost.org/2020/05/new-research-suggests-that-conservatives-and-liberals-show-differences-in-executive-functioning-56867
Your comment/opinion was that liberals are more tolerant and openminded than Conservatives.
The studies you offered up to support that "theory" have nothing to do with tolerance and open-mindedness. They have to do with the ability of each to excel at tasks of distinct working memory processes (i.e., inhibition and updating, respectively). In plain language, Conservatives are more focused and are more likely to succeed at response inhibition, whereas Liberals are more likely to succeed at response updating, or taking in changes in the task as they work.
Cognitive flexibility was the premise of the studies. That has nothing to do with social attitudes of acceptance and tolerance. If you try to extrapolate those studies to tolerance, you'll need to find a bridging source to show how that works and how it was studied.
Try again.
-
I think that I was having a hard time putting into works the example of this phenomenon I was seeing in the pandemic but I think maybe I have figured out a way to state it.
I have noticed that among those who are against the mandates they tend to repeat all arguments against masking, lockdowns, and the vaccine. By that I mean when if they are taking a negative stance against the government response (masks and vaccines) they seem to take all of the negative views about it. Masks aren't effective, vaccines are too new, ivermectin works, mandates are unconstitutional, vaccines aren't effective, etc etc. In moderates I see more varied positions but in the more conservative side I notice less variance. I never see anyone claim the vaccines are dangerous but also effective for example.
And this isn't a one sided thing either, I see the people who are strongly in favor of the vaccine adopt all of the positive views about the vaccine as well with less willingness to admit anything negative either.
The thing is that I don't think the actual science is all negative or all positive for the vaccine but when battle lines are drawn and people choose sides they seem to adopt all the arguments of the side they have joined. When is science or truth ever that clean where it only favors one side or the other? If humans were all rational thinking beings why would we #1 disagree about the data and #2 arrive at such clean different points of views? For ideological arguments of course differences are understandable but when it comes to data these differences are not understandable, unlike with opinions, these arguments are mostly matters of something that is a factual question. And political ideology seems to correlate with this.
I hope what I am trying to explain makes sense even if you disagree
but earlier you said "all available data"...
-
I think that I was having a hard time putting into works the example of this phenomenon I was seeing in the pandemic but I think maybe I have figured out a way to state it.
I have noticed that among those who are against the mandates they tend to repeat all arguments against masking, lockdowns, and the vaccine. By that I mean when if they are taking a negative stance against the government response (masks and vaccines) they seem to take all of the negative views about it. Masks aren't effective, vaccines are too new, ivermectin works, mandates are unconstitutional, vaccines aren't effective, etc etc. In moderates I see more varied positions but in the more conservative side I notice less variance. I never see anyone claim the vaccines are dangerous but also effective for example.
And this isn't a one sided thing either, I see the people who are strongly in favor of the vaccine adopt all of the positive views about the vaccine as well with less willingness to admit anything negative either.
The thing is that I don't think the actual science is all negative or all positive for the vaccine but when battle lines are drawn and people choose sides they seem to adopt all the arguments of the side they have joined. When is science or truth ever that clean where it only favors one side or the other? If humans were all rational thinking beings why would we #1 disagree about the data and #2 arrive at such clean different points of views? For ideological arguments of course differences are understandable but when it comes to data these differences are not understandable, unlike with opinions, these arguments are mostly matters of something that is a factual question. And political ideology seems to correlate with this.
I hope what I am trying to explain makes sense even if you disagree
This pretty much sums up my "refer to the past 5 years" concept of why trust the government, media, experts when they've lied for 5 years.
So 1 wants to get vaxxed, that's fine. 1 doesn't want to, that should be fine too. Where the line is crossed is when people are forced to vaxx. And 1 reason why people are against this vaxx is because it's so new. There are unknown what the long term effects are. It's only been injected into humans for a year. Smoking cigarettes once probably won't give you lung cancer. But smoke for 5 years then your odds increase. And there are those who smoke like a chimney for 30 years area have healthy lungs. Smokes is not in the constitution. So the government can regulate as they see fit. I don't want to get further into this specific example, so refer to it as a concept.
People like to also use the regulation of booze. But they are not educated on the amendments, even after they were told to look them up. 1 amendment states booze is illegal (prohibition era, Al Capone). Then a few down it states that each state can make what ever law they want about booze. So drinking and driving laws are allowed per the amendments to the constitution.
So I don't see it as what if Trump was pro vaxx, he pretty much green lighted the process. Even though he never said for people to get vaxxed. Isn't that what's great about him, he never forced it on anyone. He let people make their own choice. He never stopped anyone from getting it either.
-
This whole "argument" is moot because if Trump was still President he wouldn't mandate such measures.
-
So 1 wants to get vaxxed, that's fine. 1 doesn't want to, that should be fine too. Where the line is crossed is when people are forced to vaxx.
Nutshell.
Trump was super proud he pushed to get the vaxx developed and passed faster than any in history.
But I don’t think he would’ve mandated it.
Unless they named the vaxx after him. Then maybe…Get the Trump vaxx. Safest Ever. Super effective. It’s Amazing. :rofl:
Just my opinion.
-
Nutshell.
Trump was super proud he pushed to get the vaxx developed and passed faster than any in history.
But I don’t think he would’ve mandated it.
Unless they named the vaxx after him. Then maybe…Get the Trump vaxx. Safest Ever. Super effective. It’s Amazing. :rofl:
Just my opinion.
If they did name it Trump vaxx, how many would not get it...
barrycare got a name.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
Your comment/opinion was that liberals are more tolerant and openminded than Conservatives.
The studies you offered up to support that "theory" have nothing to do with tolerance and open-mindedness. They have to do with the ability of each to excel at tasks of distinct working memory processes (i.e., inhibition and updating, respectively). In plain language, Conservatives are more focused and are more likely to succeed at response inhibition, whereas Liberals are more likely to succeed at response updating, or taking in changes in the task as they work.
Cognitive flexibility was the premise of the studies. That has nothing to do with social attitudes of acceptance and tolerance. If you try to extrapolate those studies to tolerance, you'll need to find a bridging source to show how that works and how it was studied.
Try again.
I said open minded, I didn't say tolerant.
I also said by certain metrics, meaning that depending on how being open minded is measured and defined.
From the article
"This possibility is important as liberals are more open to experience (Carney et al., 2008) and openness is linked to elevated intelligence (Ackerman & Heggestad, 1997). "
Maybe you are thinking of mindedness differently than I am.
"Perhaps most important, liberals consistently score higher on a personality measure called “openness to experience,” one of the “Big Five” personality traits, which are easily assessed through standard questionnaires. That means liberals tend to be the kind of people who want to try new things, including new music, books, restaurants and vacation spots — and new ideas....
Conservatives, in contrast, tend to be less open — less exploratory, less in need of change — and more “conscientious,” a trait that indicates they appreciate order and structure in their lives. This gels nicely with the standard definition of conservatism as resistance to change — in the famous words of William F. Buckley Jr., a desire to stand “athwart history, yelling ‘Stop!’ ”"
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/liberals-and-conservatives-dont-just-vote-differently-they-think-differently/2012/04/12/gIQAzb1kDT_story.html
Liberals are more likely to welcome in immigrants than conservatives for example. Conservatives are more concerned with safety. (being too open minded obviously can be bad too)
There is some evidence liberals are more open to trying different foods.
https://dietsinreview.com/diet_column/07/conservatives-and-liberals-make-different-food-choices/
Liberals are more likely to use psychedelics
https://www.psypost.org/2017/05/study-finds-people-use-psychedelic-drugs-tend-liberal-48966
-
I said open minded, I didn't say tolerant.
I also said by certain metrics, meaning that depending on how being open minded is measured and defined.
From the article
"This possibility is important as liberals are more open to experience (Carney et al., 2008) and openness is linked to elevated intelligence (Ackerman & Heggestad, 1997). "
Maybe you are thinking of mindedness differently than I am.
"Perhaps most important, liberals consistently score higher on a personality measure called “openness to experience,” one of the “Big Five” personality traits, which are easily assessed through standard questionnaires. That means liberals tend to be the kind of people who want to try new things, including new music, books, restaurants and vacation spots — and new ideas....
Conservatives, in contrast, tend to be less open — less exploratory, less in need of change — and more “conscientious,” a trait that indicates they appreciate order and structure in their lives. This gels nicely with the standard definition of conservatism as resistance to change — in the famous words of William F. Buckley Jr., a desire to stand “athwart history, yelling ‘Stop!’ ”"
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/liberals-and-conservatives-dont-just-vote-differently-they-think-differently/2012/04/12/gIQAzb1kDT_story.html
Liberals are more likely to welcome in immigrants than conservatives for example. Conservatives are more concerned with safety. (being too open minded obviously can be bad too)
There is some evidence liberals are more open to trying different foods.
https://dietsinreview.com/diet_column/07/conservatives-and-liberals-make-different-food-choices/
Liberals are more likely to use psychedelics
https://www.psypost.org/2017/05/study-finds-people-use-psychedelic-drugs-tend-liberal-48966
Those have nothing to do with real life studies. It's purely academic, and the conclusions are based on theories and observations that conform to their own definitions.
I think observing actual Liberals and Conservatives as they interact socially has much more validity than pure academics.
Liberals love to say the woke talking points, but they quickly behave in the opposite manner when they think no one who cares is watching.
-
This pretty much sums up my "refer to the past 5 years" concept of why trust the government, media, experts when they've lied for 5 years.
So 1 wants to get vaxxed, that's fine. 1 doesn't want to, that should be fine too. Where the line is crossed is when people are forced to vaxx. And 1 reason why people are against this vaxx is because it's so new. There are unknown what the long term effects are. It's only been injected into humans for a year. Smoking cigarettes once probably won't give you lung cancer. But smoke for 5 years then your odds increase. And there are those who smoke like a chimney for 30 years area have healthy lungs. Smokes is not in the constitution. So the government can regulate as they see fit. I don't want to get further into this specific example, so refer to it as a concept.
People like to also use the regulation of booze. But they are not educated on the amendments, even after they were told to look them up. 1 amendment states booze is illegal (prohibition era, Al Capone). Then a few down it states that each state can make what ever law they want about booze. So drinking and driving laws are allowed per the amendments to the constitution.
So I don't see it as what if Trump was pro vaxx, he pretty much green lighted the process. Even though he never said for people to get vaxxed. Isn't that what's great about him, he never forced it on anyone. He let people make their own choice. He never stopped anyone from getting it either.
Historically, the vast majority of complications from vaccinations happen relatively quickly after the vaccine is administered. The chance that there is some serious complication that is going to come out a year, 5 years, 10 years from now is exceedingly remote going by the data. I also think that medicine has advanced quite a bit such that based on the ingredients and understanding how biology and chemistry works that scientists have a pretty good idea of the risk levels of new vaccines but I know not everyone has that faith in current science. However I will also admit that I still worry about the potential unknowns of the vaccine I took even though I consider the fear irrational. Given that I totally get why people are hesitant about a new vaccine, it is an understandable reaction.
On that note though, the people who are the test subjects for these vaccines should be given a fair amount of credit. If everyone had the attitude of the vaccine was too new then no one would ever participate in the studies and we would never have new vaccines.
I would be interested if there was a way to study how many people would be vaccinated if mandated vs just educated and encouraged. I feel pretty strongly that there are a lot of people in America who will refuse the vaccine purely on the ground that someone is making them do it. I just don't know whether that amount of people outweigh the number who take it because they don't want to lose their job. I think force was always a bad call. I liked the idea of lotteries, more innovative positive encouragement idea to get people vaccinated.
-
Those have nothing to do with real life studies. It's purely academic, and the conclusions are based on theories and observations that conform to their own definitions.
I think observing actual Liberals and Conservatives as they interact socially has much more validity than pure academics.
Liberals love to say the woke talking points, but they quickly behave in the opposite manner when they think no one who cares is watching.
Are there any "real life studies" which suggest contrary, that conservatives are open minded?
I don't see how everything I posted is purely academic, attitudes towards immigration isn't an academic only issue.
-
Those have nothing to do with real life studies. It's purely academic, and the conclusions are based on theories and observations that conform to their own definitions.
I think observing actual Liberals and Conservatives as they interact socially has much more validity than pure academics.
Liberals love to say the woke talking points, but they quickly behave in the opposite manner when they think no one who cares is watching.
Just the liberals ?
gay conservative scandals (Google. Most can do a better search parameter.)
Pretty open on both sides.
-
Are there any "real life studies" which suggest contrary, that conservatives are open minded?
I don't see how everything I posted is purely academic, attitudes towards immigration isn't an academic only issue.
I consider the videos and interviews from reputable sources to be as reliable as "studies" when it comes to human behavior.
One such report etched in my mind was when a reporter asked several people at the Democrat National Convention in North Carolina if the Democrat platform was one of tolerance, acceptance and inclusion. Everyone was like, "Of course! We welcome everyone no matter your race, sexual orientation, religious beliefs or any other trait that defines you!"
Then the question was asked, "What about Republicans? You know, the GOP? Are they welcome in the party?"
Answers were all similar: "Oh, no. They aren't as tolerant and open minded as we are. We just don't need them in our party."
After repeating the questions and answers to the respondents several times, the light bulbs eventually clicked on, and they realized that their tolerance and inclusiveness were not as broad as they believed.
This is how I predict many of the respondents to "studies" act. They SAY the things they THINK they believe, and the traits the testers look for are based on self-assessment questionnaires.
I'm not trying to say there are existing studies that are better. I'm simply pointing out that the usefulness of the studies you posted are easily disproven with mere observation and simple analysis.
The "stereotype" is that Conservatives are homophobic and racist, yet some of the most hatefully racist and gay-bashing people I know are Liberals. Somehow, these people (some, not all) believe if they join the right tribe, they can do and say whatever they want as long as "the wrong people" aren't listening. Several hot mic statements by prominent Liberals and their supporters come to mind.
-
Liberals are more likely to welcome in ILLEGAL immigrants than conservatives for example.
FIFY
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
Historically, the vast majority of complications from vaccinations happen relatively quickly after the vaccine is administered. The chance that there is some serious complication that is going to come out a year, 5 years, 10 years from now is exceedingly remote going by the data. I also think that medicine has advanced quite a bit such that based on the ingredients and understanding how biology and chemistry works that scientists have a pretty good idea of the risk levels of new vaccines but I know not everyone has that faith in current science. However I will also admit that I still worry about the potential unknowns of the vaccine I took even though I consider the fear irrational. Given that I totally get why people are hesitant about a new vaccine, it is an understandable reaction.
On that note though, the people who are the test subjects for these vaccines should be given a fair amount of credit. If everyone had the attitude of the vaccine was too new then no one would ever participate in the studies and we would never have new vaccines.
I would be interested if there was a way to study how many people would be vaccinated if mandated vs just educated and encouraged. I feel pretty strongly that there are a lot of people in America who will refuse the vaccine purely on the ground that someone is making them do it. I just don't know whether that amount of people outweigh the number who take it because they don't want to lose their job. I think force was always a bad call. I liked the idea of lotteries, more innovative positive encouragement idea to get people vaccinated.
past performance does not guarantee future returns...
-
Historically, the vast majority of complications from vaccinations happen relatively quickly after the vaccine is administered. The chance that there is some serious complication that is going to come out a year, 5 years, 10 years from now is exceedingly remote going by the data. I also think that medicine has advanced quite a bit such that based on the ingredients and understanding how biology and chemistry works that scientists have a pretty good idea of the risk levels of new vaccines but I know not everyone has that faith in current science. However I will also admit that I still worry about the potential unknowns of the vaccine I took even though I consider the fear irrational. Given that I totally get why people are hesitant about a new vaccine, it is an understandable reaction.
On that note though, the people who are the test subjects for these vaccines should be given a fair amount of credit. If everyone had the attitude of the vaccine was too new then no one would ever participate in the studies and we would never have new vaccines.
I would be interested if there was a way to study how many people would be vaccinated if mandated vs just educated and encouraged. I feel pretty strongly that there are a lot of people in America who will refuse the vaccine purely on the ground that someone is making them do it. I just don't know whether that amount of people outweigh the number who take it because they don't want to lose their job. I think force was always a bad call. I liked the idea of lotteries, more innovative positive encouragement idea to get people vaccinated.
Except lotteries didnt work. This was covered already.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
Historically, the vast majority of complications from vaccinations happen relatively quickly after the vaccine is administered. The chance that there is some serious complication that is going to come out a year, 5 years, 10 years from now is exceedingly remote going by the data. I also think that medicine has advanced quite a bit such that based on the ingredients and understanding how biology and chemistry works that scientists have a pretty good idea of the risk levels of new vaccines but I know not everyone has that faith in current science. However I will also admit that I still worry about the potential unknowns of the vaccine I took even though I consider the fear irrational. Given that I totally get why people are hesitant about a new vaccine, it is an understandable reaction.
On that note though, the people who are the test subjects for these vaccines should be given a fair amount of credit. If everyone had the attitude of the vaccine was too new then no one would ever participate in the studies and we would never have new vaccines.
I would be interested if there was a way to study how many people would be vaccinated if mandated vs just educated and encouraged. I feel pretty strongly that there are a lot of people in America who will refuse the vaccine purely on the ground that someone is making them do it. I just don't know whether that amount of people outweigh the number who take it because they don't want to lose their job. I think force was always a bad call. I liked the idea of lotteries, more innovative positive encouragement idea to get people vaccinated.
have you read how long they have been working on mRNA vaccines and the previous success rate?
have you read what happened when they actually tried to use an mRNA vaccine?
-
Are there any "real life studies" which suggest contrary, that conservatives are open minded?
I don't see how everything I posted is purely academic, attitudes towards immigration isn't an academic only issue.
Youre confusing illegal aliens and legal immigration. Conservatives are all for legal immigration. And liberals support illegal immigration. Huge difference.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
Except lotteries didnt work. This was covered already.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
several people reported taking vaxx because of the lottery
bruh, it works, lul
-
have you read how long they have been working on mRNA vaccines and the previous success rate?
have you read what happened when they actually tried to use an mRNA vaccine?
These are not rhetorical. Please look it up and u will understand my replies to u.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
I consider the videos and interviews from reputable sources to be as reliable as "studies" when it comes to human behavior.
One such report etched in my mind was when a reporter asked several people at the Democrat National Convention in North Carolina if the Democrat platform was one of tolerance, acceptance and inclusion. Everyone was like, "Of course! We welcome everyone no matter your race, sexual orientation, religious beliefs or any other trait that defines you!"
Then the question was asked, "What about Republicans? You know, the GOP? Are they welcome in the party?"
Answers were all similar: "Oh, no. They aren't as tolerant and open minded as we are. We just don't need them in our party."
After repeating the questions and answers to the respondents several times, the light bulbs eventually clicked on, and they realized that their tolerance and inclusiveness were not as broad as they believed.
This is how I predict many of the respondents to "studies" act. They SAY the things they THINK they believe, and the traits the testers look for are based on self-assessment questionnaires.
I'm not trying to say there are existing studies that are better. I'm simply pointing out that the usefulness of the studies you posted are easily disproven with mere observation and simple analysis.
The "stereotype" is that Conservatives are homophobic and racist, yet some of the most hatefully racist and gay-bashing people I know are Liberals. Somehow, these people (some, not all) believe if they join the right tribe, they can do and say whatever they want as long as "the wrong people" aren't listening. Several hot mic statements by prominent Liberals and their supporters come to mind.
When many vids are posted of various gatherings of both sides, 1 can make an educated guess which side is more tolerant.
Unless people dont watch these vids, then i guess u will believe the stories that the fake news airs.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
Historically, the vast majority of complications from vaccinations happen relatively quickly after the vaccine is administered. The chance that there is some serious complication that is going to come out a year, 5 years, 10 years from now is exceedingly remote going by the data. I also think that medicine has advanced quite a bit such that based on the ingredients and understanding how biology and chemistry works that scientists have a pretty good idea of the risk levels of new vaccines but I know not everyone has that faith in current science. However I will also admit that I still worry about the potential unknowns of the vaccine I took even though I consider the fear irrational. Given that I totally get why people are hesitant about a new vaccine, it is an understandable reaction.
On that note though, the people who are the test subjects for these vaccines should be given a fair amount of credit. If everyone had the attitude of the vaccine was too new then no one would ever participate in the studies and we would never have new vaccines.
I would be interested if there was a way to study how many people would be vaccinated if mandated vs just educated and encouraged. I feel pretty strongly that there are a lot of people in America who will refuse the vaccine purely on the ground that someone is making them do it. I just don't know whether that amount of people outweigh the number who take it because they don't want to lose their job. I think force was always a bad call. I liked the idea of lotteries, more innovative positive encouragement idea to get people vaccinated.
please show the data that shows this
they unblinded the studies on the vaccines only a few months after initial dosing and gave the placebo group the vaccine, so there is no longer any way to gather data...
-
please show the data that shows this
they unblinded the studies on the vaccines only a few months after initial dosing and gave the placebo group the vaccine, so there is no longer any way to gather data...
I think I have posted links here before. I am trying to find articles covering this issue but in searching I am just getting stuff specific to covid vaccines.
This article touches on it but it does not go deep into the data. I'll have to keep looking for more in depth data.
https://www.uab.edu/news/health/item/12143-three-things-to-know-about-the-long-term-side-effects-of-covid-vaccines
As long as there is still an unvaccinated population there is still a way to look at long term effects. Plus if the placebo group wanted to get the real vaccine, should the be denied?
past performance does not guarantee future returns...
Guarantee? No but it serves as a basis for a reasonable risk assessment.
-
Youre confusing illegal aliens and legal immigration. Conservatives are all for legal immigration. And liberals support illegal immigration. Huge difference.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
I was referencing immigration as a whole, not specifically legal or illegal. You are right conservatives seem to favor legal immigration but on that same line, it is also the liberals who want to provide more assistance and be accommodating to even the legal immigrants where republicans are more likely to want the immigrants to conform to American culture and language.
-
Except lotteries didnt work. This was covered already.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
What do you mean it doesn't work? It didn't increase participation?
If so that would be a surprise to me but if thats really what the data shows then ok. Regardless I prefer positive incentives.
-
I consider the videos and interviews from reputable sources to be as reliable as "studies" when it comes to human behavior.
One such report etched in my mind was when a reporter asked several people at the Democrat National Convention in North Carolina if the Democrat platform was one of tolerance, acceptance and inclusion. Everyone was like, "Of course! We welcome everyone no matter your race, sexual orientation, religious beliefs or any other trait that defines you!"
Then the question was asked, "What about Republicans? You know, the GOP? Are they welcome in the party?"
Answers were all similar: "Oh, no. They aren't as tolerant and open minded as we are. We just don't need them in our party."
After repeating the questions and answers to the respondents several times, the light bulbs eventually clicked on, and they realized that their tolerance and inclusiveness were not as broad as they believed.
This is how I predict many of the respondents to "studies" act. They SAY the things they THINK they believe, and the traits the testers look for are based on self-assessment questionnaires.
I'm not trying to say there are existing studies that are better. I'm simply pointing out that the usefulness of the studies you posted are easily disproven with mere observation and simple analysis.
The "stereotype" is that Conservatives are homophobic and racist, yet some of the most hatefully racist and gay-bashing people I know are Liberals. Somehow, these people (some, not all) believe if they join the right tribe, they can do and say whatever they want as long as "the wrong people" aren't listening. Several hot mic statements by prominent Liberals and their supporters come to mind.
You certainly have a point but I think you are focused on a more limited definition of being open minded where as what I was referencing are more broad measures. You have certainly hit upon at least a subset of liberals who are utterly fraudulent in their claims of tolerance. This example I think would be a sort of exception to the rule.
-
What do you mean it doesn't work? It didn't increase participation?
If so that would be a surprise to me but if thats really what the data shows then ok. Regardless I prefer positive incentives.
Yes, the after studies show it didnt work.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
I was referencing immigration as a whole, not specifically legal or illegal. You are right conservatives seem to favor legal immigration but on that same line, it is also the liberals who want to provide more assistance and be accommodating to even the legal immigrants where republicans are more likely to want the immigrants to conform to American culture and language.
Guess the USA should conform to incoming islam culture? U know women have to cover up, not allowed to work, drive, etc...
Ask Germany how that conformity is working out. If someone comes into a foreign country, they conform to said country, not the other way around. 1 remember when 1 guy who tweets mean things, warnes Germany and other countries about illegals. No one listened. Google "no go zones" in Europe.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
You certainly have a point but I think you are focused on a more limited definition of being open minded where as what I was referencing are more broad measures. You have certainly hit upon at least a subset of liberals who are utterly fraudulent in their claims of tolerance. This example I think would be a sort of exception to the rule.
You have no evidence to support your opinion.
I believe most people, no matter their political affiliation, will lie, obfuscate or sugar coat their opinions, especially if they think the answers will be used to study something like Us vs. Them conclusions. I also think many who go through Liberal Universities have been conditioned to only speak "approved" thoughts. What they really think has been replaced with what they are really supposed to think.
Hard to engineer a questionnaire around that.
-
You have no evidence to support your opinion.
I believe most people, no matter their political affiliation, will lie, obfuscate or sugar coat their opinions, especially if they think the answers will be used to study something like Us vs. Them conclusions. I also think many who go through Liberal Universities have been conditioned to only speak "approved" thoughts. What they really think has been replaced with what they are really supposed to think.
Hard to engineer a questionnaire around that.
The problem is if youre caught in a lie and on the left, the fake news has your back. So no biggie.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
You have no evidence to support your opinion.
False. I posted 3 articles to support my statements
I believe most people, no matter their political affiliation, will lie, obfuscate or sugar coat their opinions, especially if they think the answers will be used to study something like Us vs. Them conclusions. I also think many who go through Liberal Universities have been conditioned to only speak "approved" thoughts. What they really think has been replaced with what they are really supposed to think.
Hard to engineer a questionnaire around that.
The more contentious the subject the better the survey needs to be designed.
-
Guess the USA should conform to incoming islam culture? U know women have to cover up, not allowed to work, drive, etc...
Ask Germany how that conformity is working out. If someone comes into a foreign country, they conform to said country, not the other way around. 1 remember when 1 guy who tweets mean things, warnes Germany and other countries about illegals. No one listened. Google "no go zones" in Europe.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
Where did I ever make the case that we (Americans) should conform to immigrating cultures/groups?
-
Yes, the after studies show it didnt work.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
I will take your word for it. Wouldn't you prefer positive incentives than negative ones though?
-
Where did I ever make the case that we (Americans) should conform to immigrating cultures/groups?
You didnt. I was making a statement with regard to conforming and accommodating.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
I will take your word for it. Wouldn't you prefer positive incentives than negative ones though?
None, thats the correct actions.
The concept ur missing is this was used to get more people to vaxx. And people claimed it worked. When it didnt work.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk