2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: Hammer_D_Justice on December 02, 2021, 12:32:58 AM
-
Aloha! I am new here and this is my first post! :shaka:
I have a question regarding the verbiage and interpretation behind HRS 134-25
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0025.htm
Based on the way this is worded, my understanding is that I can transport my firearm between my place of business, residence, or sojourn. If this is indeed correct, my next question would be; is a food truck considered a viable place of business even though it is essentially a vehicle? The one I work at is technically a trailer hitch, but it is in a sketchy part of Waikiki. I am there for about 6-8 hours a day into the evening.
If someone were to want to attack me or threaten my life I would literally have nowhere to run. Besides just having it on me legally, would I be justified in using it in self-defense if there is nowhere for me to run to inside this small food truck?
Mahalo for your time and consideration. I appreciate any and all responses.
-
I'm not a lawyer, and your situation is a little different than most, but I'll take a stab at it.
First, unless you have a carry permit (open or concealed carry), you'll need to transport the pistol in suitable case UNLOADED between your home and place of business -- no different than when driving to the range with a truck full of guns! :geekdanc:
Once you are at your place of business, the law says you can keep the gun loaded. If the truck is parked on a public street or other public area, you won't be able to leave the truck with a loaded gun on you. If on private property, and the owner allows it, you can leave the truck, but not the property.
Once you start driving, the gun has to be unloaded and cased again.
The good news is you can keep magazines or speed loaders for pistols or revolvers loaded with ammo and within reach -- even carried inside the gun case. A gun is unloaded if there is no ammunition in it. That means the ammo in a mag that's not inserted is fine. So, in transit, you can have the pistol and mag in your gun case sitting where you can get to it.
I've seen legal cases on here talking about homeless residents with firearms. Courts have ruled that someone living in a tent or their car have the same rights as those living in houses and condos. Firearms are included. So, there should be no argument that your truck is your legitimate place of business. HRS 134 makes no mention of businesses needing to be any particular place, structure, or even a fixed location.
Having said that, there are limits to where you can designate "place of business." One of the law suits that tried to force Honolulu to issue a carry permit was someone serving summons and other court papers. He wanted to carry for protection, and said his "place of business" was anywhere he needed to be to perform his service. The case never went to a decision, because he moved away. But, I don't think the court would allow someone to carry a loaded pistol in public without a permit even if they were working.
I don't know where you park your truck, but most I see use roadside shoulders and private parking lots. I personally don't see how a brick-and-mortar place of business that is open to the public and may have customers coming and going is any different than your food truck when you're serving customers.
You might be better off consulting a lawyer if you're serious about being armed while working. Someone with access to local case information (LexisNexis?) could find any cases that are similar to your situation. It's always better to know how courts have ruled in the past, so you know for sure how the laws will be interpreted. Most of us can try to interpret the plain language as written, but often definitions of things like "place of business" may have an official definition that could, for example, exclude vehicles as a "place of business".
If all it took to legally carry was to say your vehicle is your place of business, then Uber drivers, cab drivers, and anyone else who drives for a living could carry loaded firearms inside their vehicles no matter where they happen to be working. Seems like a question that needs more that what's available in the statute.
Hope that's semi-helpful. :shaka:
-
To add what Flapp said, also I'm going to assume your lunch wagon doesn't have a restroom in it. Which means you will have to disarm (ammo too) each time you leave it to take a piss if you go somewhere else. Like say across the street to the Starbucks. And while disarmed, you should lock said gun in some kind of safe or lockable drawer. They make mini handgun safes for less than $100 on Amazon.
And again if you get lunch/dinner from somewhere else, you have to disarm again. You cannot bring your gun and ammo, even if locked in a case due to HI's "to and from" law.
With regard to SD, Hawaii's modified castle doctrine extends to your place of business. So you do not need to run as long as you aren't the aggressor and stuff like that. Look up our "use of deadly force" and "use of force" laws.
-
I strongly urge you to buy SD insurance. It will only cost you $30 to $40 a month.
-
Mahalo for your responses! The truck is just a hitch so no engine or anything like that on it which means no restroom and I have a bladder of steel anyway! lol
The road is privately owned so I guess I would have to get permission from the owner before leaving the truck with my firearm on me. If I am then allowed to carry it with me loaded inside the truck, does it matter if it is concealed or open? I would prefer to conceal it mainly because I don't want to freak out any of my customers.
All of the information was extremely helpful and I will do a little more reading and possibly consult a lawyer and the owner of the private property before making any decisions!
I strongly urge you to buy SD insurance. It will only cost you $30 to $40 a month.
Is that self defense insurance? I was looking into USCCA before and now I think I will get some if I do end up carrying it with me at work. Any other recommendations?
-
I like to carry concealed.
Also check your lease agreement, if there's no mention then go for it.
There are various SD insurance available, and last time I looked, not 1 met every requirement. But USCCA checked the most boxes.
-
Mahalo for your responses! The truck is just a hitch so no engine or anything like that on it which means no restroom and I have a bladder of steel anyway! lol
The road is privately owned so I guess I would have to get permission from the owner before leaving the truck with my firearm on me. If I am then allowed to carry it with me loaded inside the truck, does it matter if it is concealed or open? I would prefer to conceal it mainly because I don't want to freak out any of my customers.
All of the information was extremely helpful and I will do a little more reading and possibly consult a lawyer and the owner of the private property before making any decisions!
Is that self defense insurance? I was looking into USCCA before and now I think I will get some if I do end up carrying it with me at work. Any other recommendations?
The more convoluted and complicated the details are, the more chance you'll be creating to cause yourself problems. If you have to unload and case the firearm before heading to work, load it and conceal it in your holster for the time you're at work, and then unload and case it again for the trip home, what are the odds you'll be in a hurry and forget something? You also can't (legally) stop anywhere on the way to or from work with the firearm, even if it's unloaded and locked in your vehicle. Home Depot or Costco are not on the "Places to Keep" list.
If I were to give advise, I'd recommend waiting a month and buying a Taser or two. No need to deal with all the places BS rules, and the purchase process will be much easier. Also, your legal exposure with a less-than-lethal weapon is much smaller. USCCA insurance might still be a wise choice, since they cover criminal and civil legal entanglements for ANY defensive weapon you might use.
Of course, you'll have to think about when you ought to use a Taser versus lethal force. I wouldn't try Tasing someone who's already pointing a loaded gun at me, but if the gun looks like a replica/toy, light him up! :rofl:
If you're mostly concerned about unarmed hoods robbing you or becoming a threat toward your safety, and you don't think they have firearms, the Taser might be the better option for you.
I'm just throwing that out as something to consider, not to dissuade you from looking into the firearm option.
-
Aloha! I am new here and this is my first post! :shaka:
I have a question regarding the verbiage and interpretation behind HRS 134-25
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0025.htm
Based on the way this is worded, my understanding is that I can transport my firearm between my place of business, residence, or sojourn. If this is indeed correct, my next question would be; is a food truck considered a viable place of business even though it is essentially a vehicle? The one I work at is technically a trailer hitch, but it is in a sketchy part of Waikiki. I am there for about 6-8 hours a day into the evening.
If someone were to want to attack me or threaten my life I would literally have nowhere to run. Besides just having it on me legally, would I be justified in using it in self-defense if there is nowhere for me to run to inside this small food truck?
Mahalo for your time and consideration. I appreciate any and all responses.
I have asked this very question but I never get a real solid answer. Most people have frowned on it though, saying that the food truck or taxi is not the place of business. They considered the place of business the physical address where the business is.
So as far as I have read and talked to people it is a bit of a gray area. And the thing is you don't want to be the first one to test it. I read it as being ok and if I were on a jury I would say not guilty but who knows what jury you get or prosecutor. If you wanted to do it I would try to get something in writing from a prosecutor or someone at the police department first because it is a legal defense to a crime if you thought it was not illegal based on information you got from someone in charge of applying the law (can't recall exact wording there)
-
[snip]
If you wanted to do it I would try to get something in writing from a prosecutor or someone at the police department first because it is a legal defense to a crime if you thought it was not illegal based on information you got from someone in charge of applying the law (can't recall exact wording there)
Many have asked the police department for clarification of gun laws. The answer is to ask the State's AG. Prosecutors are part of that department.
What the AG tells people who ask is for them to hire a lawyer, as the AG doesn't give legal advise to the public.
Neither of those agencies are viable options to find out what gun laws mean short of being arrested and being told during your trial.
-
If u have the right lawyer, the AG would drop the charges. They dont want to set precedent for the unconstitutional "places to keep".
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
If u have the right lawyer, the AG would drop the charges. They dont want to set precedent for the unconstitutional "places to keep".
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
Hence the advice on having insurance to cover legal costs.
Rittenhouse is probably wishing he had it, too. :geekdanc:
-
Hence the advice on having insurance to cover legal costs.
Rittenhouse is probably wishing he had it, too. :geekdanc:
I wonder if someone under 18 could buy it? I'm pretty sure his GFM or like donations covered everything, just a guess.
I had a friend at 17 (graduated high school already) try to buy a car. Dealership told him he needs to be 18.
-
I wonder if someone under 18 could buy it? I'm pretty sure his GFM or like donations covered everything, just a guess.
I had a friend at 17 (graduated high school already) try to buy a car. Dealership told him he needs to be 18.
GoFundMe shut down his donation campaign. They just enabled it now that he's been acquitted.
The policy for GFM is they don't allow donations for legal defense costs in criminal cases, because it would be as if they are supporting criminal behavior. They've shutdown many other campaigns in the past seeking funds to pay for lawyers, so it's not really a big deal. They don't appear to pick and choose between this or that legal defense fund.
I believe his lawyers set up independent web pages to solicit donations. I heard they raised around $2M. :geekdanc: :thumbsup:
You have to be 18 in most states to enter into a binding legal contract unless you get your parent/guardian to sign the papers. If the car dealer tried to take a 17 year old to court, the case would be dismissed due to his status as a minor.
-
Many have asked the police department for clarification of gun laws. The answer is to ask the State's AG. Prosecutors are part of that department.
What the AG tells people who ask is for them to hire a lawyer, as the AG doesn't give legal advise to the public.
Neither of those agencies are viable options to find out what gun laws mean short of being arrested and being told during your trial.
At the very least if someone did decide to be the test case then they should document that they consulted the police department and the AG's office and were told that they would not answer the question. This could be used in a defense case to show the accused used due diligence to try and be legal. No one wants to be the test case though, not when it is a felony.
-
At the very least if someone did decide to be the test case then they should document that they consulted the police department and the AG's office and were told that they would not answer the question. This could be used in a defense case to show the accused used due diligence to try and be legal. No one wants to be the test case though, not when it is a felony.
Asking and getting no answer -- one way or another -- isn't a defense. It shows you don't know who to ask. That's all. No trophies are awarded for trying and failing.
If the police or AG actually answered the question, and THEN you get arrested, you'd have a case of malpractice based on the incorrect response.
That's exactly why they refuse to give the public legal advice: liability concerns.
-
Asking and getting no answer -- one way or another -- isn't a defense. It shows you don't know who to ask. That's all. No trophies are awarded for trying and failing.
If the police or AG actually answered the question, and THEN you get arrested, you'd have a case of malpractice based on the incorrect response.
That's exactly why they refuse to give the public legal advice: liability concerns.
I think it could be part of someone's defense. A jury could look at that and take it into account for their decision.
-
I think it could be part of someone's defense. A jury could look at that and take it into account for their decision.
Ignorance of the law is no excuse. That applies even if you tried to get the law interpreted by the government.
In the end, the judge will interpret the law based on the statutes as they apply to the charges and the facts of the case. The judge will instruct the jury on the law's meaning. On that basis alone, the jury will decide if the defendant is guilty or not. If the jury isn't sure what the instructions mean, they can ask the judge for further clarification. I doubt a juror will say, "I think he broke the law the way it was explained in court, but he didn't know what the law was at the time because the government wouldn't provide a legal opinion upon request.
It would be prudent to not act until the law is completely clear in your mind.
So, what's the level of effort needed to demonstrate "I was trying to obey the law, but I could never get a good answer on its meaning?" One letter to HPD firearms section? Two letters to the HPD Chef of Police? Five letters to the AG's office, and 3 to the Governor? How about a few to your elected representatives and Senators? Maybe a letter or email to the DOJ in Washington?
In the end, if you broke the law, your lawyer can argue the law is poorly written, and that's been a valid defense. But, arguing that you made an effort to find out won't carry any weight if the jury thinks you should have continued to ask.before you broke it.
Having said all that, if your lawyer says what you want to do is legal, then it turns out it wasn't, you may or may not have a claim of malpractice. The lawyer has to be held to the same standard as other lawyers -- what's reasonable and expected knowledge of other lawyers.
If the law is debatable or undecided (as in this case), it's not malpractice. Lawyers can't be expected to know laws that are ambiguous or poorly written until a judge interprets them.
-
Ignorance of the law is no excuse. That applies even if you tried to get the law interpreted by the government.
In the end, the judge will interpret the law based on the statutes as they apply to the charges and the facts of the case. The judge will instruct the jury on the law's meaning. On that basis alone, the jury will decide if the defendant is guilty or not. If the jury isn't sure what the instructions mean, they can ask the judge for further clarification. I doubt a juror will say, "I think he broke the law the way it was explained in court, but he didn't know what the law was at the time because the government wouldn't provide a legal opinion upon request.
It would be prudent to not act until the law is completely clear in your mind.
So, what's the level of effort needed to demonstrate "I was trying to obey the law, but I could never get a good answer on its meaning?" One letter to HPD firearms section? Two letters to the HPD Chef of Police? Five letters to the AG's office, and 3 to the Governor? How about a few to your elected representatives and Senators? Maybe a letter or email to the DOJ in Washington?
In the end, if you broke the law, your lawyer can argue the law is poorly written, and that's been a valid defense. But, arguing that you made an effort to find out won't carry any weight if the jury thinks you should have continued to ask.before you broke it.
Having said all that, if your lawyer says what you want to do is legal, then it turns out it wasn't, you may or may not have a claim of malpractice. The lawyer has to be held to the same standard as other lawyers -- what's reasonable and expected knowledge of other lawyers.
If the law is debatable or undecided (as in this case), it's not malpractice. Lawyers can't be expected to know laws that are ambiguous or poorly written until a judge interprets them.
I believe that the concept of detrimental reliance may come into play but I am not entirely sure.
But basically the argument I am making is that the government has no business prosecuting for a law that it cannot or won't offer an explanation on. If they can't say an act is against the law before someone does it, how can they say it is against the law after someone does it? If you never bothered to ask then it would be clear you didn't even try, you were just claiming ignorance. However if you contacted HPD and the AG's office then you can at least show due dillegence. How much is that in a jury's eyes? Who knows.
A private attorney could be paid hundreds of dollars to interpret the law for the individual but that isn't a very good defense either. In a trial a letter from a private attorney saying the thing was legal wouldn't be a trump card to have the charges dropped.
I do think a jury could disregard a judge's interpretation, jury nullification does happen sometimes. But it's quite the gamble
-
I believe that the concept of detrimental reliance may come into play but I am not entirely sure.
But basically the argument I am making is that the government has no business prosecuting for a law that it cannot or won't offer an explanation on. If they can't say an act is against the law before someone does it, how can they say it is against the law after someone does it?
...
That's the point of a trial. The answer is in the name: TRIAL.
trial n.
A proceeding in which opposing parties in a dispute present evidence and make
arguments on the application of the law before a judge or jury.
The prosecutor can charge you with whatever infraction they want, even if it makes no sense. Prosecutors should understand the law, but many times they don't have the experience or case law to show them all the answers. So, they take the defendant to court, and rely on the judge and jury to decide. If they decide the law is too vague, ambiguous, and/or complicated for the reasonable man of average education and intelligence to understand, then the law is deemed inadequate. As such, the prosecutor, who had the burden of proving the elements of the crime based on the statute, failed to meet that burden.
There's no jury nullification needed in that instance. The jury can simply state the law was poorly crafted, which made the prosecutor's job difficult or next to impossible, and enforcement of the law just as difficult.
The law would be self-nullifying. The jury would just have to make it official. If the prosecutor or judge had any brains, they'd dismiss the case and send it to the governor & legislature for revision.
-
is a food truck considered a viable place of business even though it is essentially a vehicle?
If you peruse this Civilbeat article, you will notice that Recreational Vehicles (RV) can serve as places of sojourn as long as they are not parked in public places. Thus, if you enlarge it to hold a toilet, and get the land owner to grant you a place to park, you might be able to remain in this "business" throughout the day, and always maintain close possession of your weapon.
https://www.civilbeat.org/2021/11/denby-fawcett-van-camping-looks-enticing-but-good-luck-finding-a-legal-spot-in-hawaii/ (https://www.civilbeat.org/2021/11/denby-fawcett-van-camping-looks-enticing-but-good-luck-finding-a-legal-spot-in-hawaii/)
Researching case law in HI is a PITA. I do not have a Lexisnexis account, and very few lawyers will give you free advice. The ones who make you pay for advice will hem and haw, and never commit to giving you a solid answer or defensible plan.
An open search of food truck owners who needed to resort to self-defense pulled up this story:
https://fox40.com/news/local-news/stockton-taco-truck-back-in-business-just-one-after-driver-was-shot-in-robbery-attempt/ (https://fox40.com/news/local-news/stockton-taco-truck-back-in-business-just-one-after-driver-was-shot-in-robbery-attempt/)
This took place in Stockton, CA, a state where criminals are a protected class of people :crazy:. The business owner brandished a butcher's knife at the thieves. He was back at work the next day, meaning the cops did not arrest him for attempting to protect himself. Had the truck owner used a gun, the story might have turned out differently.
-
I called the AG and asked for them to define what "residence" is. They said that they do not give legal advice to non government people and that I have to talk to a lawyer. So the people who decide if a places to keep via the residence law was broken or not, will not tell you more specifics. So get arrested and charged and fight it in court to find out type of response. Which is BS. I had called because I was wondering about common areas in condo's or businesses. So the restroom outside of an office, or the lobby/hallway of a condo, etc...
There were others who also asked HPD/AG the definition of a "not readily restore-able 10rd magazine" and they got the same response above. Talk to a lawyer.
The law states "place of business" so a food truck regardless if mobile or not, I would think qualifies as your place of business. But go talk to a lawyer per AG's SOP reply. But once you step outside that truck, say to take a piss, that's even more in question, which I'm leaning toward is not your place of business. So need to disarm.
-
I called the AG and asked for them to define what "residence" is. They said that they do not give legal advice to non government people and that I have to talk to a lawyer. So the people who decide if a places to keep via the residence law was broken or not, will not tell you more specifics. So get arrested and charged and fight it in court to find out type of response. Which is BS. I had called because I was wondering about common areas in condo's or businesses. So the restroom outside of an office, or the lobby/hallway of a condo, etc...
There were others who also asked HPD/AG the definition of a "not readily restore-able 10rd magazine" and they got the same response above. Talk to a lawyer.
The law states "place of business" so a food truck regardless if mobile or not, I would think qualifies as your place of business. But go talk to a lawyer per AG's SOP reply. But once you step outside that truck, say to take a piss, that's even more in question, which I'm leaning toward is not your place of business. So need to disarm.
A "place", in common meaning of the word, is a fixed location. A motor vehicle or trailer would not be a place.
If the food truck is on a parcel of private land, then the "place" would be that land.
As mentioned already, taxis and Uber drivers can't call their vehicles their "place of business." Where they run that business out of -- home, company office, etc. -- would be the place of business.
When we talk about carrying firearms at home, we have the understanding that our home includes the land up to our property line -- outdoors, and outside of any structure. The same applies to a food truck IMO. If the land is larger than the truck, then the business owner could carry outside as long as they remain on that parcel.
I'm not a lawyer, but if there's no law against it, it's legal.
-
That's the point of a trial. The answer is in the name: TRIAL.
The prosecutor can charge you with whatever infraction they want, even if it makes no sense. Prosecutors should understand the law, but many times they don't have the experience or case law to show them all the answers. So, they take the defendant to court, and rely on the judge and jury to decide. If they decide the law is too vague, ambiguous, and/or complicated for the reasonable man of average education and intelligence to understand, then the law is deemed inadequate. As such, the prosecutor, who had the burden of proving the elements of the crime based on the statute, failed to meet that burden.
There's no jury nullification needed in that instance. The jury can simply state the law was poorly crafted, which made the prosecutor's job difficult or next to impossible, and enforcement of the law just as difficult.
The law would be self-nullifying. The jury would just have to make it official. If the prosecutor or judge had any brains, they'd dismiss the case and send it to the governor & legislature for revision.
Thats my point, if someone wants to test the law, their fate may lie in the hands of the jury.
-
Thats my point, if someone wants to test the law, their fate may lie in the hands of the jury.
The appeals courts make many of these calls on the quality and enforceability of laws. Getting a jury verdict is a necessary step to fixing the "root cause."
-
The appeals courts make many of these calls on the quality and enforceability of laws. Getting a jury verdict is a necessary step to fixing the "root cause."
True. Want to volunteer to be the test case?
-
True. Want to volunteer to be the test case?
Not if you're the defense team! :shake: