2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: changemyoil66 on December 07, 2022, 09:59:13 AM
-
https://www.staradvertiser.com/2022/12/06/hawaii-news/hpd-chief-urges-community-to-call-911-if-legal-guns-not-concealed/?fbclid=IwAR0fD9PqlGtP2WZSDj6kj_pLGAtAcxvMLX6ehwqgkOFsm5w8sGRvrA3IIP0
-
F Logan
Sent from my SM-G781U using Tapatalk
-
I cant read the rest of the article.
-
HPD chief urges community to call 911 if legal guns not concealed
By Peter Boylan Dec. 6, 2022
If you see a person walking around Oahu with a gun that is visible after the Honolulu Police Department begins issuing concealed-carry weapon licenses, please call 911, Honolulu Police Chief Arthur “Joe” Logan told the Honolulu Star-Advertiser’s “Spotlight Hawaii” livestream program Monday.
Officers will be dispatched and investigate, Logan said, and police will need a physical description of the alleged illegal gun carrier, what was seen, what time, a location and any other information that would aid the investigation.
“Obviously, concealed carry and the definition of ‘conceal’ means that you can’t see it or it is unrecognizable to the average person,” said Logan. “If it is noticed and you can see it, I would ask you to call 911.”
There are about 600 pending applications for CCW licenses on Oahu, and the HPD is processing them in the order in which they were received.
Applications are valid for 90 days to allow for compliance with a long list of background checks, mental health evaluations, live-fire training and other requirements that must be met before HPD issues a card, with the gun owner’s picture on it, that is about the size of a Hawaii driver’s license.
If a gun owner forgets his CCW license, it is considered a misdemeanor criminal offense
Don't miss out on what's happening!
Stay in touch with top news, as it happens, conveniently in your email inbox. Best of all, it's FREE to sign up!
By clicking submit, you agree to Star-Advertiser's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Honolulu is the last county in Hawaii to issue CCW licenses in the wake of the U.S. Supreme Court’s June ruling in New York State Rifle &Pistol Association Inc. v. Bruen. Justices nullified a New York state law limiting who can have a permit to carry a pistol outside of their home.
Logan has said he wants to comply with the high court ruling and that the HPD is not waiting for the city to complete action on Bill 57, which would define “sensitive locations” on Oahu like schools, public transportation and voting centers where guns will be prohibited.
Firearms also would be banned at Hanauma Bay Nature Preserve, the Hawaii Children’s Discovery Center, the Honolulu Aquarium and the Honolulu Zoo. Additionally, armed concealed-carry license holders would have to stay 100 feet from the outer edge of groups of 25 or more people gathered in public spaces and participating in “First Amendment expressive activities.”
The state Legislature is expected to take up the issue of whether to adopt uniform state standards for where guns may be legally carried when it starts a new session in January. Bill 57 passed the first reading at a special City Council meeting Nov. 29, but needs work in committee and must be voted on twice more by the full Council to achieve final passage.
Logan is meeting with each member of the Council to make clear that the law should be as clear as possible so the public understands the rules and police officers know how to enforce them.
“We believe (guns should not be carried) in sensitive places that are logical in nature,” said Logan, listing hospitals and schools and places where “keiki hang out.”
Clearing up questions about what to do if you are legally armed but forced to enter a “sensitive place” through no fault of your own is critical to making the law work.
“The way the language of the law is written is really going to impact how we enforce,” said Logan, using the example of a person legally armed whose spouse needs them to pick up their child at the last minute. “It’s something we need to figure out.”
Police officers are asked to risk their lives every day to keep the community safe and enforce the law, Logan said, and a new regulation regarding deadly weapons has to be clear.
“It becomes a little difficult for us on an enforcement level,” said Logan. “We’re already asking our officers to do a lot.”
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
And in reality the Chief is creating situations where legal gun owners/permit holders can, and with a higher probability, be shot.
Excited citizen calls 911 about a man with a gun. HPD dispatches 4 to 6 officers who are now hyped up about an encounter with a firearm. Do you really think the cops will be calm and rational? They'll be screaming at the GO to drop the weapon, get on the ground, keep your hands where they can see them and so on. The GO is trying to comply and just is saying "I have a permit, let me show you". GO attempts to get wallet and now gets shot by the cops because the rookie starts yelling "GUN GUN GUN".
Yes that's the simplified version, but the process by which there is a high likelihood of occurring. How many stories have you heard of where that scenario plays out?
Sent from my SM-G781U using Tapatalk
-
seems a reasonable thing to do.
-
Smokers better not use one of these in public.
-
And in reality the Chief is creating situations where legal gun owners/permit holders can, and with a higher probability, be shot.
Excited citizen calls 911 about a man with a gun. HPD dispatches 4 to 6 officers who are now hyped up about an encounter with a firearm. Do you really think the cops will be calm and rational? They'll be screaming at the GO to drop the weapon, get on the ground, keep your hands where they can see them and so on. The GO is trying to comply and just is saying "I have a permit, let me show you". GO attempts to get wallet and now gets shot by the cops because the rookie starts yelling "GUN GUN GUN".
Yes that's the simplified version, but the process by which there is a high likelihood of occurring. How many stories have you heard of where that scenario plays out?
Sent from my SM-G781U using Tapatalk
Joking version: Would be a good test of response time for 911. As well as a case study to see if having a big dog would have helped in the situation.
Slightly more serious version: If Karens start calling 911 more often, it will lead to "alarm fatigue". What could go wrong?
-
HPD chief urges community to call 911 if legal guns not concealed
By Peter Boylan Dec. 6, 2022
If you see a person walking around Oahu with a gun that is visible after the Honolulu Police Department begins issuing concealed-carry weapon licenses, please call 911, Honolulu Police Chief Arthur “Joe” Logan told the Honolulu Star-Advertiser’s “Spotlight Hawaii” livestream program Monday.
Officers will be dispatched and investigate, Logan said, and police will need a physical description of the alleged illegal gun carrier, what was seen, what time, a location and any other information that would aid the investigation.
“Obviously, concealed carry and the definition of ‘conceal’ means that you can’t see it or it is unrecognizable to the average person,” said Logan. “If it is noticed and you can see it, I would ask you to call 911.”
There are about 600 pending applications for CCW licenses on Oahu, and the HPD is processing them in the order in which they were received.
Applications are valid for 90 days to allow for compliance with a long list of background checks, mental health evaluations, live-fire training and other requirements that must be met before HPD issues a card, with the gun owner’s picture on it, that is about the size of a Hawaii driver’s license.
If a gun owner forgets his CCW license, it is considered a misdemeanor criminal offense
Don't miss out on what's happening!
Stay in touch with top news, as it happens, conveniently in your email inbox. Best of all, it's FREE to sign up!
By clicking submit, you agree to Star-Advertiser's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Honolulu is the last county in Hawaii to issue CCW licenses in the wake of the U.S. Supreme Court’s June ruling in New York State Rifle &Pistol Association Inc. v. Bruen. Justices nullified a New York state law limiting who can have a permit to carry a pistol outside of their home.
Logan has said he wants to comply with the high court ruling and that the HPD is not waiting for the city to complete action on Bill 57, which would define “sensitive locations” on Oahu like schools, public transportation and voting centers where guns will be prohibited.
Firearms also would be banned at Hanauma Bay Nature Preserve, the Hawaii Children’s Discovery Center, the Honolulu Aquarium and the Honolulu Zoo. Additionally, armed concealed-carry license holders would have to stay 100 feet from the outer edge of groups of 25 or more people gathered in public spaces and participating in “First Amendment expressive activities.”
The state Legislature is expected to take up the issue of whether to adopt uniform state standards for where guns may be legally carried when it starts a new session in January. Bill 57 passed the first reading at a special City Council meeting Nov. 29, but needs work in committee and must be voted on twice more by the full Council to achieve final passage.
Logan is meeting with each member of the Council to make clear that the law should be as clear as possible so the public understands the rules and police officers know how to enforce them.
“We believe (guns should not be carried) in sensitive places that are logical in nature,” said Logan, listing hospitals and schools and places where “keiki hang out.”
Clearing up questions about what to do if you are legally armed but forced to enter a “sensitive place” through no fault of your own is critical to making the law work.
“The way the language of the law is written is really going to impact how we enforce,” said Logan, using the example of a person legally armed whose spouse needs them to pick up their child at the last minute. “It’s something we need to figure out.”
Police officers are asked to risk their lives every day to keep the community safe and enforce the law, Logan said, and a new regulation regarding deadly weapons has to be clear.
“It becomes a little difficult for us on an enforcement level,” said Logan. “We’re already asking our officers to do a lot.”
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
I think his dad was a professor at UH West. Dr. Boylan.
-
Fears over being the subject of an inaccurate 911 call are valid. In fact, it's something often overlooked when people analyze a use-of-force event. 911 callers are rarely held responsible for providing incorrect or misleading information, unless it is blatantly obvious it was a false statement made with some ill intent.
My main concern with the focus on the word "concealed" is that guns can sometimes 'print' without the knowledge of the carrier, even though you have made a reasonable attempt to conceal and keep the weapon concealed. This means someone may call 911 on you and you would have no idea until the police make contact, all because the wind blew a certain way, causing your gun to print. There is just so much relay of information left up to the 911 caller, dispatcher, and responding police, information that you can't possibly know, that will undoubtedly have an affect on the impending encounter. If the caller, dispatcher, or police are excitable in that moment, you could be killed despite making every attempt to be a law-abiding gun carrier. Completely law-abiding gun carriers have been killed by police simply for having a gun (Amir Locke, Atatiana Jefferson, et. al.) because of poor policework or 3rd party 911 calls, so for the Chief to say "oh, just call 911 if you see a gun" is really not inline with the progressive "stop unjustified police use-of-force" movement.
Modify message
-
https://www.facebook.com/watch/live/?ref=watch_permalink&v=693655038941223
-
Fears over being the subject of an inaccurate 911 call are valid. In fact, it's something often overlooked when people analyze a use-of-force event. 911 callers are rarely held responsible for providing incorrect or misleading information, unless it is blatantly obvious it was a false statement made with some ill intent.
My main concern with the focus on the word "concealed" is that guns can sometimes 'print' without the knowledge of the carrier, even though you have made a reasonable attempt to conceal and keep the weapon concealed. This means someone may call 911 on you and you would have no idea until the police make contact, all because the wind blew a certain way, causing your gun to print. There is just so much relay of information left up to the 911 caller, dispatcher, and responding police, information that you can't possibly know, that will undoubtedly have an affect on the impending encounter. If the caller, dispatcher, or police are excitable in that moment, you could be killed despite making every attempt to be a law-abiding gun carrier. Completely law-abiding gun carriers have been killed by police simply for having a gun (Amir Locke, Atatiana Jefferson, et. al.) because of poor policework or 3rd party 911 calls, so for the Chief to say "oh, just call 911 if you see a gun" is really not inline with the progressive "stop unjustified police use-of-force" movement.
Modify message
911 should ask :" Is the person pointing the gun at anyone?". "Is the person threatening anyone?". If the answer is no, then HPD will be there when they get around to it.
I watch Armed Fisherman on YT and he plays the 911 calls with his AR slung and walking to go fishing or is fishing. Dispatch has never asked the above questions.
-
Fears over being the subject of an inaccurate 911 call are valid. In fact, it's something often overlooked when people analyze a use-of-force event. 911 callers are rarely held responsible for providing incorrect or misleading information, unless it is blatantly obvious it was a false statement made with some ill intent.
My main concern with the focus on the word "concealed" is that guns can sometimes 'print' without the knowledge of the carrier, even though you have made a reasonable attempt to conceal and keep the weapon concealed. This means someone may call 911 on you and you would have no idea until the police make contact, all because the wind blew a certain way, causing your gun to print. There is just so much relay of information left up to the 911 caller, dispatcher, and responding police, information that you can't possibly know, that will undoubtedly have an affect on the impending encounter. If the caller, dispatcher, or police are excitable in that moment, you could be killed despite making every attempt to be a law-abiding gun carrier. Completely law-abiding gun carriers have been killed by police simply for having a gun (Amir Locke, Atatiana Jefferson, et. al.) because of poor policework or 3rd party 911 calls, so for the Chief to say "oh, just call 911 if you see a gun" is really not inline with the progressive "stop unjustified police use-of-force" movement.
Modify message
Some jurisdictions have made printing a felony -- similar to brandishing. They take "concealed" very seriously.
Since HI is just now changing policy to actually issue carry licenses, I'm sure printing will be addresses in upcoming laws when the legislature goes back to work.
As for reporting people, I'm more concerned with the anti-gun people (I'm sure there are plenty in this state). They'll be hanging out in malls and on Waikiki benches scanning for anyone they can turn in.
Then there are the intentional calls reporting a gun when the caller knows better...
Walmart: 911 caller 'intentionally lied to police' about
man with toy gun fatally shot in Ohio store
BEAVERCREEK, Ohio — In a lawsuit over the 2014 shooting by police of a Beavercreek
Walmart customer, attorneys for Walmart plan to claim that another customer who called
911 was the cause of the incident and the store should not be held responsible.
Walmart attorneys have filed motions in a wrongful death lawsuit stating that Ronald Ritchie,
the man who first called 911 from the Beavercreek Walmart stating there was a suspicious
man with a gun in the store, was the "legal and proximate cause" of John Crawford III's shooting
death by a Beavercreek police officer on Aug. 5, 2014.
“Ronald Ritchie’s lies are the sole reasons why police came into the (Beavercreek Walmart)
store with their guns drawn,” Walmart attorneys wrote. “Ronald Ritchie intentionally lied to the
police. Ronald Ritchie was not a good Samaritan who was mistaken.”
Crawford, 22, of Fairfield, was shot to death Aug. 5, 2014, by Beavercreek police Officer Sean
Williams after Ritchie told dispatchers a black man was holding a rifle, appeared to be loading
it and waving it near people, including children. Crawford was holding a Crosman MK-177 BB/
pellet rifle he found unpackaged on a store shelf.
“At worst, Ronald Ritchie could have believed he saw Mr. Crawford legally open carry a firearm,
” Walmart contends. “Nevertheless, Ronald Ritchie made the conscious decision to call 911 and
falsely report an act of violence and hostility towards some of the most vulnerable in our society,
mothers and their children, with the clear knowledge that this alleged threat of violence would be
met with armed resistance leading to the detention and/or death of Mr. Crawford.”
Waiting for the first lawsuits here after someone dies from being "S.W.A.T.-ED" as a result of the Chief's comments.
-
Some jurisdictions have made printing a felony -- similar to brandishing. They take "concealed" very seriously.
Since HI is just now changing policy to actually issue carry licenses, I'm sure printing will be addresses in upcoming laws when the legislature goes back to work.
As for reporting people, I'm more concerned with the anti-gun people (I'm sure there are plenty in this state). They'll be hanging out in malls and on Waikiki benches scanning for anyone they can turn in.
Then there are the intentional calls reporting a gun when the caller knows better...
Walmart: 911 caller 'intentionally lied to police' about
man with toy gun fatally shot in Ohio store
Waiting for the first lawsuits here after someone dies from being "S.W.A.T.-ED" as a result of the Chief's comments.
Add in the face of HIFICO whos always on the news. Just wait till a MDA member recognizes him in the street. There should be a penalty for false reporting someone who's not doing anything wrong. See my 911 asking questions like "is he pointing it at anyone". Because we have seen via testimony that at least 1 person will yell and keep yelling GUN GUN GUN like how she sees on TV.
-
Add in the face of HIFICO whos always on the news. Just wait till a MDA member recognizes him in the street. There should be a penalty for false reporting someone who's not doing anything wrong. See my 911 asking questions like "is he pointing it at anyone". Because we have seen via testimony that at least 1 person will yell and keep yelling GUN GUN GUN like how she sees on TV.
The good news is, there are so many video cameras around now (including cell phones), there's a good chance the situation is captured for verification of the 911 caller's report.
If the authorities find a report was fraudulent, the caller needs to be punished severely.
Also, yelling "GUN! GUN! GUN!" around a bunch of people should be seen as an attempt to incite panic -- no different than falsely yelling "FIRE!" in a crowded theater.
-
The good news is, there are so many video cameras around now (including cell phones), there's a good chance the situation is captured for verification of the 911 caller's report.
He may or may not have a bodycam.
-
Philando Castile
-
As for reporting people, I'm more concerned with the anti-gun people (I'm sure there are plenty in this state). They'll be hanging out in malls and on Waikiki benches scanning for anyone they can turn in.
I think that is the idea, legalized "SWATTING" to let those evil firearm owners know who is in charge.
And get rid of as many as possible through a willing HPD.
-
Fuck Logan and HPD as well as this liberal shit hole….. :grrr:
-
Sorry, several people responded but I didn't want to multi-quote to save space.
I'm really worried about "predatory" 911 callers once CCW's are issued. I know what "Plain View" is, but when it comes to concealment, I have no idea what "Ordinary View" is. Does that mean someone's garment has lifted, revealing the firearm? How long has the garment been lifted? Does "printing" mean a firearm has come under "ordinary view"? How does "Stop & Frisk" type law apply to this in regards to "reasonable sus" and "prob cause"?
I understand people don't want CCW'ers "brandishing" or otherwise displaying weapons, but the way the concealment laws work is just too dangerous to lawful gun owners.
-
Sorry, several people responded but I didn't want to multi-quote to save space.
I'm really worried about "predatory" 911 callers once CCW's are issued. I know what "Plain View" is, but when it comes to concealment, I have no idea what "Ordinary View" is. Does that mean someone's garment has lifted, revealing the firearm? How long has the garment been lifted? Does "printing" mean a firearm has come under "ordinary view"? How does "Stop & Frisk" type law apply to this in regards to "reasonable sus" and "prob cause"?
I understand people don't want CCW'ers "brandishing" or otherwise displaying weapons, but the way the concealment laws work is just too dangerous to lawful gun owners.
Technically, the Chief said to report Open Carrying.
That's a lot different than printing while Concealed Carrying.
So, if the Cops show up, as long as you have a carry license and weren't Open Carrying, nothing should happen. The current laws don't address printing or accidentally exposing a concealed firearm.
That might change soon, but as long as you have a license and were not open carrying, this whole issue is a nothing burger.
-
Meanwhile, in this weeks news . . .
Woman hospitalized in serious condition after stabbing in Kaaawa
Elderly man viciously stabbed to death in Kaneohe, suspect at large
Police continue investigation after officers fatally shoot armed man in Waikīkī
HPD: Suspect arrested in connection to Waikiki beating that left 21-year-old dead
-
So, if the Cops show up, as long as you have a carry license and weren't Open Carrying, nothing should happen. The current laws don't address printing or accidentally exposing a concealed firearm.
That might change soon, but as long as you have a license and were not open carrying, this whole issue is a nothing burger.
You are assuming the carrying person lives long enough to do all that.
With the polices shoot first and ask questions later, good luck with that.
-
You are assuming the carrying person lives long enough to do all that.
With the polices shoot first and ask questions later, good luck with that.
see the video from the waikiki police involved shooting the other day...
-
https://www.facebook.com/photo/?fbid=497385725823646&set=a.422659679962918
Conceal carry is here. And you don't need to worry about it.
In the next few weeks, residents will be issued concealed carry permits. It's important that we understand what this means.
Hawaii law separates carrying firearms into two separate categories, open and concealed. Intentionally or not, the media seems to be using the terms interchangeably.
Open carry is what we see police officers and security guards doing. The firearm is in the open, unobstructed from view.
Concealed carry is what private citizens do. The firearm is obstructed from view, not in plain sight.
Government employees, via the media, keep insinuating that people will be walking around openly carrying firearms and that all of a sudden, the public will see guns on the hips of people everywhere. This is simply false. Open carry of firearms is still restricted to those who are employed in the protection of persons or property.
Concealed carry, however, is here. Licensed individuals will be able to carry firearms on their person, hidden from casual viewing. These people have passed background checks, received training, and taken a firearms proficiency test. These people are law-abiding citizens who want to exercise their right to bear arms to defend themselves and their loved ones.
These people are our family, friends, and neighbors. They are our doctors, our dentists, our mechanics, and our teachers. They are not criminals, drug users, or mentally ill. They are the same people you interact with every day without fear.
The media hype over guns on our streets is just that HYPE. With 6% of the country's population having a CCW license, you have nothing to worry about. If you have visited another state, you have interacted with armed citizens.
Law-abiding citizens carrying firearms are not who you should be worried about. The criminal element who are already carrying guns and hurting people are. Instead of worrying about those obeying the law, pressure your government to do better in catching and punishing criminals. That is what will make Hawaii safer.
-
dentists are not doctors...
https://www.facebook.com/photo/?fbid=497385725823646&set=a.422659679962918
Conceal carry is here. And you don't need to worry about it.
In the next few weeks, residents will be issued concealed carry permits. It's important that we understand what this means.
Hawaii law separates carrying firearms into two separate categories, open and concealed. Intentionally or not, the media seems to be using the terms interchangeably.
Open carry is what we see police officers and security guards doing. The firearm is in the open, unobstructed from view.
Concealed carry is what private citizens do. The firearm is obstructed from view, not in plain sight.
Government employees, via the media, keep insinuating that people will be walking around openly carrying firearms and that all of a sudden, the public will see guns on the hips of people everywhere. This is simply false. Open carry of firearms is still restricted to those who are employed in the protection of persons or property.
Concealed carry, however, is here. Licensed individuals will be able to carry firearms on their person, hidden from casual viewing. These people have passed background checks, received training, and taken a firearms proficiency test. These people are law-abiding citizens who want to exercise their right to bear arms to defend themselves and their loved ones.
These people are our family, friends, and neighbors. They are our doctors, our dentists, our mechanics, and our teachers. They are not criminals, drug users, or mentally ill. They are the same people you interact with every day without fear.
The media hype over guns on our streets is just that HYPE. With 6% of the country's population having a CCW license, you have nothing to worry about. If you have visited another state, you have interacted with armed citizens.
Law-abiding citizens carrying firearms are not who you should be worried about. The criminal element who are already carrying guns and hurting people are. Instead of worrying about those obeying the law, pressure your government to do better in catching and punishing criminals. That is what will make Hawaii safer.
-
dentists are not doctors...
That’s per goofy green! :D
-
dentists are not doctors...
In his defense, he did separate the two. :rofl: :rofl:
:wave:
-
Technically, the Chief said to report Open Carrying.
That's a lot different than printing while Concealed Carrying.
So, if the Cops show up, as long as you have a carry license and weren't Open Carrying, nothing should happen. The current laws don't address printing or accidentally exposing a concealed firearm.
That might change soon, but as long as you have a license and were not open carrying, this whole issue is a nothing burger.
If you are carrying concealed per your concealed carry permit, and someone sees that you are carrying (either in plain view like your shirt hiked up, or via printing), that’s grounds for immediate revocation of your permit. Rules of the Chief of Police.
15-12 Definitions
“‘Concealed’ means entirely hidden from view and not discernible by ordinary observation, even if covered by clothing, such that a reasonable person without law enforcement training would be able to detect the presence of a firearm” (emphasis added)
15-27 Revocation
“(1) The following will immediately result in revocation of all of a licensee’s Concealed Licenses:
…
(C) Where a licensee who doesn’t possess an Unconcealed License has been found carrying a firearm that is not concealed.”
Doesn’t say whether responding officers have the authority to immediately revoke the license, take possession of the firearm, etc.
-
If you are carrying concealed per your concealed carry permit, and someone sees that you are carrying (either in plain view like your shirt hiked up, or via printing), that’s grounds for immediate revocation of your permit. Rules of the Chief of Police.
15-12 Definitions
“‘Concealed’ means entirely hidden from view and not discernible by ordinary observation, even if covered by clothing, such that a reasonable person without law enforcement training would be able to detect the presence of a firearm” (emphasis added)
15-27 Revocation
“(1) The following will immediately result in revocation of all of a licensee’s Concealed Licenses:
…
(C) Where a licensee who doesn’t possess an Unconcealed License has been found carrying a firearm that is not concealed.”
Doesn’t say whether responding officers have the authority to immediately revoke the license, take possession of the firearm, etc.
You missed my point.
The Chief's words were "Open Carrying" as it relates to having 911 called. That's not the same as failing to conceal a firearm completely while concealed carrying.
Words mean things. You can't claim someone is open carrying just because the gun was unintentionally 'unconcealed.'
-
Technically, the Chief said to report Open Carrying.
That's a lot different than printing while Concealed Carrying.
So, if the Cops show up, as long as you have a carry license and weren't Open Carrying, nothing should happen. The current laws don't address printing or accidentally exposing a concealed firearm.
That might change soon, but as long as you have a license and were not open carrying, this whole issue is a nothing burger.
That part is what I was talking about. Something WILL happen; it shouldn’t be an arrest, but you can expect to have your license revoked.
-
That part is what I was talking about. Something WILL happen; it shouldn’t be an arrest, but you can expect to have your license revoked.
I don't think that's a guarantee. Just because someone reports you doesn't mean your gun was visible.
Ever have a car crash? Unless the Cops witnessed it, they only write up the report and let the insurance companies hash out blame.
So, without additional witnesses or photo evidence, it'll be hard to justify revoking a license solely on the word of a 911 caller.
-
I don't think that's a guarantee. Just because someone reports you doesn't mean your gun was visible.
Ever have a car crash? Unless the Cops witnessed it, they only write up the report and let the insurance companies hash out blame.
So, without additional witnesses or photo evidence, it'll be hard to justify revoking a license solely on the word of a 911 caller.
Hopefully you’re right, but keep in mind that the definition of “concealed” and the revocation criteria aren’t in the law… they’re in the HPD rules. I think it would be completely up to the Chief to decide if you get revoked or not. Which side do you think he’d come down on in a “he said/Karen said” situation? Sure, you could sue… and if you win, you might get your permit back in a few years.
-
I don't think that's a guarantee. Just because someone reports you doesn't mean your gun was visible.
Ever have a car crash? Unless the Cops witnessed it, they only write up the report and let the insurance companies hash out blame.
So, without additional witnesses or photo evidence, it'll be hard to justify revoking a license solely on the word of a 911 caller.
Yeah, but you see what's gonna happen is...
-911 call reports seeing someone with a gun concealed underneath their clothing, who is, lets say, engaged in a verbal altercation with another person, yet no violence has occurred.
-Dispatcher sends police and the show up.
-As you're leaving (just words were exchanged), they Terry stop you based on the description the caller gave; pat you down for weapons, at which time they feel the "shape of a handgun handle" on the inside of your waistband.
-Now they have probably have probable cause to search you. They lift your shirt and see it is indeed a handgun.
Now, based on those hypothetical facts, what the caller observed is likely to have been true. You did have an "unconcealed handgun", discovered through reasonable search and seizure.
-
Police arriving on below mentioned scenario I think would ask if you are armed at which point you would confirm if true.
They would ask if you have a permit and you would say "yes, do you want to see it ?"
When they say yes, you SLOWLY pull the chain around your neck to pull out your permit. :geekdanc:
No reaching behind you for wallet or reaching in pocket required. :thumbsup:
Personally, I think those without permits should all walk around unarmed with cell phones riding high and bulky concealed beneath shirts. :wacko:
Let all of the "Karen's" make accusations and maybe we could start harassment or false accusation suits to wake them up !
Yeah, but you see what's gonna happen is...
-911 call reports seeing someone with a gun concealed underneath their clothing, who is, lets say, engaged in a verbal altercation with another person, yet no violence has occurred.
-Dispatcher sends police and the show up.
-As you're leaving (just words were exchanged), they Terry stop you based on the description the caller gave; pat you down for weapons, at which time they feel the "shape of a handgun handle" on the inside of your waistband.
-Now they have probably have probable cause to search you. They lift your shirt and see it is indeed a handgun.
Now, based on those hypothetical facts, what the caller observed is likely to have been true. You did have an "unconcealed handgun", discovered through reasonable search and seizure.
-
Police arriving on below mentioned scenario I think would ask if you are armed at which point you would confirm if true.
They would ask if you have a permit and you would say "yes, do you want to see it ?"
When they say yes, you SLOWLY pull the chain around your neck to pull out your permit. :geekdanc:
No reaching behind you for wallet or reaching in pocket required. :thumbsup:
Well, of course! If people behave rationally, everything works out. Problem is, you have people (LE and citizens) who get crazy for no reason. I've had cops yell at me for no reason at all, even when I'm doing them a favor. We've seen countless videos of citizens not obeying verbal commands and being killed.
Personally, I think those without permits should all walk around unarmed with cell phones riding high and bulky concealed beneath shirts. :wacko:
Let all of the "Karen's" make accusations and maybe we could start harassment or false accusation suits to wake them up !
Time to get one of these, and put training pistols in them under a tank top. Not really gonna do it, but would help get the point across about 911 callers and calling for "printing".
(https://www.imfdb.org/images/thumb/2/24/FO-Gold1911s-1.jpg/600px-FO-Gold1911s-1.jpg)
-
Conceal one of these but let it print.
-
the plan is to disarm you. If you don't follow all details of CCW get arrested and charged - you now become a criminal and all your guns are taken away.
-
Police arriving on below mentioned scenario I think would ask if you are armed at which point you would confirm if true.
They would ask if you have a permit and you would say "yes, do you want to see it ?"
When they say yes, you SLOWLY pull the chain around your neck to pull out your permit. :geekdanc:
No reaching behind you for wallet or reaching in pocket required. :thumbsup:
Personally, I think those without permits should all walk around unarmed with cell phones riding high and bulky concealed beneath shirts. :wacko:
Let all of the "Karen's" make accusations and maybe we could start harassment or false accusation suits to wake them up !
Besides all of that, I'm sure Hawaii laws will be "updated" now that CCW is a reality. That may include the requirement to notify any law enforcement officer you interact with that you are carrying a concealed firearm and have a license. No need for any probable cause or 911 descriptions for a search.
Many states have a "duty to inform" law in order to limit the "surprise!" factor should a LEO discover you're armed before being notified by you.
-
I remember seeing a YT video of a cop just losing it at this guy. Their jurisdiction had a "duty to inform" law and the guy never informed the cop that he had a concealed gun and a CCW license. I can't recall as to why the cop stopped the guy (traffic stop) but a few minutes went by then the cop noticed he had a gun under his shirt.
Cop, on discovering he was printing, went ballistic and arrested him while the guys wife was going nuts and yelling why is he being arrested.
My question is, in those jurisdictions is it mandatory for cops to ask people if they have a concealed weapon when doing routine traffic stops or similar interactions.
-
I remember seeing a YT video of a cop just losing it at this guy. Their jurisdiction had a "duty to inform" law and the guy never informed the cop that he had a concealed gun and a CCW license. I can't recall as to why the cop stopped the guy (traffic stop) but a few minutes went by then the cop noticed he had a gun under his shirt.
Cop, on discovering he was printing, went ballistic and arrested him while the guys wife was going nuts and yelling why is he being arrested.
My question is, in those jurisdictions is it mandatory for cops to ask people if they have a concealed weapon when doing routine traffic stops or similar interactions.
Nope. No reason for Cops to ask everyone they pull over for a traffic stop if they are carrying as soon as they interact. If the Cop has them exit the car, of if the Cops want to do a consensual search, THEN they might ask if there are drugs, weapons or large amounts of money in the vehicle.
There are some good videos of how to properly inform a Cop you're carrying. Blurting out, "I have a gun," isn't recommended.
The method I like is to carry an ID wallet that has your drivers license in one window and your carry permit displayed in the other. Once you present your license, the Cop will likely ask if you're carrying your firearm. He'll then calmly ask you to avoid reaching toward your waist unless he asks you to.
This is in Atlanta.
https://youtu.be/FU-Bx-GuKio
https://youtu.be/k6tANLJEmRw
-
These people are law-abiding citizens who want to exercise their right to bear arms to defend themselves and their loved ones.
Anyone, let us know from the law class portion of CCW training.
Can you legally protect loved ones or anyone but yourself with deadly force outside the home in Hawaii ?
I thought it was a duty to call the police but could be wrong. (Under the law)
I’m not even sure you can protect innocents outside the home with a firearm. Only yourself.
I could be wrong but this is a messed up State with a web of tangled laws.
I am NOT a lawyer.
Just watch how you word it I guess before you shut your mouth and wait for your attorney.
-
Can you legally protect loved ones or anyone but yourself with deadly force outside the home in Hawaii ?
I thought it was a duty to call the police but could be wrong. (Under the law)
I know I will protect myself or a loved one, which includes my dogs, with deadly force if I feel life or bodily harm is about to take place. I will do this at any time and any place with whatever weapon I have at my disposal. I will take care about the legal ramifications later. I will be 73 is 4.5 months and the older I get the less I worry about what happens after the event. Of course I hope I am never put in such a situation, but if I am, in my mind, my actions are fully justified.
-
I know I will protect myself or a loved one, which includes my dogs, with deadly force if I feel life or bodily harm is about to take place. I will do this at any time and any place with whatever weapon I have at my disposal. I will take care about the legal ramifications later. I will be 73 is 4.5 months and the older I get the less I worry about what happens after the event. Of course I hope I am never put in such a situation, but if I am, in my mind, my actions are fully justified.
I'm a little younger than you, but not much.
I have the same attitude. Generally speaking it isn't people like us that get hurt.
"The good they die young". Shoot shovel, and shut up.
:shaka:
-
please show me where his words were "open carrying"
You missed my point.
The Chief's words were "Open Carrying" as it relates to having 911 called. That's not the same as failing to conceal a firearm completely while concealed carrying.
Words mean things. You can't claim someone is open carrying just because the gun was unintentionally 'unconcealed.'
-
Anyone, let us know from the law class portion of CCW training.
Can you legally protect loved ones or anyone but yourself with deadly force outside the home in Hawaii ?
I thought it was a duty to call the police but could be wrong. (Under the law)
I’m not even sure you can protect innocents outside the home with a firearm. Only yourself.
I could be wrong but this is a messed up State with a web of tangled laws.
I am NOT a lawyer.
Just watch how you word it I guess before you shut your mouth and wait for your attorney.
Disclaimer: IANAL. I do not give legal advice.
As I understand it, according to HRS 703-305 (Use of force for the protection of other persons), you may use force to defend a third person. The basic test is “if I were that person, would I be justified in using force to defend myself?” based on the criteria in HRS 703-304 (Use of force in self-protection).
Unless you’re 100% sure of what you’re getting into, though, using force (especially deadly force) in defense of a third person is fraught with peril.
I’ll throw in a plug here for Andrew Branca’s “Law of Self-Defense” book. Amazing resource when it comes to using force to defend yourself or someone else.
The Law of Self Defense: The Indispensable Guide to the Armed Citizen https://a.co/d/h3DqG24 (https://a.co/d/h3DqG24)
-
please show me where his words were "open carrying"
The whole situation is dangerously unclear at this point. “Concealed” and “unconcealed” are referenced in the law (HRS 134-9, “Licenses to carry”), but neither term is defined in the law.
The Rules of the Chief of Police define both; “concealed” means your firearm is hidden well enough that somebody without law enforcement training can’t spot that you’re carrying. “Unconcealed” means “not concealed.” If somebody spots your pew, even if you’re just printing, that’s “unconcealed” and grounds for revocation of your license(s).
Worse, they could reasonably charge you with a violation of 134-25 (Place to keep pistol or revolver) and/or 134-26 (Carrying or possessing a loaded firearm on a public highway), both of which are class B felonies.
Incidentally, Hawaii law defines a public highway as “All roads, highways, alleys, streets, ways, lanes, bikeways, bridges, and all other real property highway related interests in the State, opened, laid out, subdivided, consolidated, and acquired and built by the government are declared to be public highways.” That’s pretty much every roadway on the island, to include surface streets. I know because I got a ticket once for an “abandoned vehicle” on a “public highway” for having my car parked in front of my house for more than 24 hours without moving it.
-
The whole situation is dangerously unclear at this point.
Amen to that.
All you future CCW holders. Be careful. Stay safe.
-
Anyone, let us know from the law class portion of CCW training.
Can you legally protect loved ones or anyone but yourself with deadly force outside the home in Hawaii ?
I thought it was a duty to call the police but could be wrong. (Under the law)
I’m not even sure you can protect innocents outside the home with a firearm. Only yourself.
I could be wrong but this is a messed up State with a web of tangled laws.
I am NOT a lawyer.
Just watch how you word it I guess before you shut your mouth and wait for your attorney.
Disclaimer
#IamNotaLibrarian but will embolden what I consider pertinent details IMHO otf the "fine print" of 703-305 and ad a little more clarity to the other answer.
§703-305 Use of force for the protection of other persons. (1) Subject to the provisions of this section and of section 703-310, the use of force upon or toward the person of another is justifiable to protect a third person when:
(a) Under the circumstances as the actor believes them to be, the person whom the actor seeks to protect would be justified in using such protective force; (death, serious bodily injury, kidnapping, rape, or forcible sodomy.)
and
(b) The actor believes that the actor’s intervention is necessary for the protection of the other person.
(2) Notwithstanding subsection (1):
(a) When the actor would be obliged under section 703-304 to retreat, to surrender the possession of a thing, or to comply with a demand before using force in self-protection, the actor is not obliged to do so before using force for the protection of another person, unless the actor knows that the actor can thereby secure the complete safety of such other person;
(b) When the person whom the actor seeks to protect would be obliged under section 703-304 to retreat, to surrender the possession of a thing or to comply with a demand if the person knew that the person could obtain complete safety by so doing, the actor is obliged to try to cause the person to do so before using force in the person’s protection if the actor knows that the actor can obtain the other’s complete safety in that way; and
(c) Neither the actor nor the person whom the actor seeks to protect is obliged to retreat when in the other’s dwelling or place of work to any greater extent than in the actor’s or the person’s own.
§703-310 Provisions generally applicable to justification. (1) When the actor believes that the use of force upon or toward the person of another is necessary for any of the purposes for which such belief would establish a justification under sections 703-303 to 703-309 but the actor is reckless or negligent in having such belief or in acquiring or failing to acquire any knowledge or belief which is material to the justifiability of the actor’s use of force, the justification afforded by those sections is unavailable in a prosecution for an offense for which recklessness or negligence, as the case may be, suffices to establish culpability.
(2) When the actor is justified under sections 703-303 to 703-309 in using force upon or toward the person of another but the actor recklessly or negligently injures or creates a risk of injury to innocent persons, the justification afforded by those sections is unavailable in a prosecution for such recklessness or negligence toward innocent persons.
-
(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20221212/f5e779fbb912419915f19b8f0598c328.jpg)
Sent from my SM-A102U using Tapatalk
-
I know I will protect myself or a loved one, which includes my dogs, with deadly force if I feel life or bodily harm is about to take place. I will do this at any time and any place with whatever weapon I have at my disposal. I will take care about the legal ramifications later. I will be 73 is 4.5 months and the older I get the less I worry about what happens after the event. Of course I hope I am never put in such a situation, but if I am, in my mind, my actions are fully justified.
The older you get, the less a life sentence is a deterrent.
-
seems a reasonable thing to do.
It is the safe answer. Rather than having the public confront someone whose firearm peeks out from under their shirt, call the police and they can investigate.
-
I will be 73 is 4.5 months and the older I get the less I worry about what happens after the event. Of course I hope I am never put in such a situation, but if I am, in my mind, my actions are fully justified.
I'll have to find the shirt and send you one. It said " The older I get the less of a deterrent life in prison is"
-
I'll have to find the shirt and send you one. It said " The older I get the less of a deterrent life in prison is"
I think the quote paraphrased is this
"never pick a fight with an old man, he'll just kill you and leave you in a ditch".
Hawaii police chiefs have picked a fight.
:wave: