2aHawaii
General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: rhayder on April 03, 2023, 09:25:23 PM
-
KINO SPRINGS, Ariz. — Gabriel Cuen-Buitimea was slipping across a rancher’s land near the border with Mexico when the shooting started. “I’m hit,” he said, before his eyes rolled back and he crumpled face down by a mesquite tree.
To the sheriff in rural Santa Cruz County, Ariz., this account, relayed by a witness, and other pieces of the investigation into the shooting death of Mr. Cuen-Buitimea seemed to make the next steps clear. The sheriff’s office arrested George Alan Kelly, the rancher suspected of firing the fatal shot, and charged him with murder.
Then the angry calls started pouring in.
“This is garbage.”
“It’s a travesty of justice.”
“Since when do illegals have rights?”
-
Mr. Cuen-Buitimea, 48, grew up in an adobe house in the impoverished farming village
of Buaysiacobe in the Mexican state of Sonora, according to his relatives and friends
there. He had crossed into the United States illegally and been deported at least three
times between 2011 and 2016, according to court records.
I guess sometimes it takes extreme measures to teach some people to stop doing what they're doing. Until there are consequences, the flood over the US-Mexico border will only continue to worsen.
Don't start nothing, won't be nothing.
-
I guess sometimes it takes extreme measures to teach some people to stop doing what they're doing. Until there are consequences, the flood over the US-Mexico border will only continue to worsen.
Don't start nothing, won't be nothing.
You mean, don't break the law and you reduce bad stuff that may happen to you.
-
You mean, don't break the law and you reduce bad stuff that may happen to you.
If you do not wish to suffer the consequences of your provocative actions,
do not pursue your current course of action.
Taunt implying, "you started it."
https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Don%27t%20start%20nothing%2C%20won%27t%20be%20nothing
-
It's murder if you shoot someone that happens to be on your land. This was not self defense. Sounds like we may need more firearms education and training in this forum.
Are you a lawyer? Do you know and understand every castle doctrine and stand your ground law in every state?
The State of Arizona also justifies the use of lethal force to halt criminal trespass and
other attempted or in progress forcible entry of an occupied dwelling.
https://www.survivalsullivan.com/arizona-castle-doctrine-law/
-
There is no border
(https://imgs.search.brave.com/9UPX5WwkrREvZmvVsJ1VQrgoAjoZiW7NFX1o8mdRbf4/rs:fit:480:270:1/g:ce/aHR0cHM6Ly9tZWRp/YS5naXBoeS5jb20v/bWVkaWEvbDBIbEh6/cG1DcUhCWVlhUjIv/Z2lwaHkuZ2lm.gif)
-
Are you a lawyer? Do you know and understand every castle doctrine and stand your ground law in every state?
https://www.survivalsullivan.com/arizona-castle-doctrine-law/
If you read a little bit further in that blog post, it pretty clearly implies that the law applies only to an occupied dwelling, as in “criminal trespass [of an occupied dwelling] or in progress forcible entry of an occupied dwelling.”
Pretty sure you can’t just open fire on someone simply because they’re on your property, even in Arizona. Haven’t read the actual law yet, though.
-
If you read a little bit further in that blog post, it pretty clearly implies that the law applies only to an occupied dwelling, as in “criminal trespass [of an occupied dwelling] or in progress forcible entry of an occupied dwelling.”
Pretty sure you can’t just open fire on someone simply because they’re on your property, even in Arizona. Haven’t read the actual law yet, though.
You missed the point.
i'm not arguing the legality of the rancher's actions.
I'm contradicting the know-it-all that made the claim:
It's murder if you shoot someone that happens to be on your land. This was not self defense.
My point is that AZ does allow you to use lethal force to protect your property against criminal trespass. You don't need to prove "self defense" to justify it.
-
You missed the point.
i'm not arguing the legality of the rancher's actions.
I'm contradicting the know-it-all that made the claim:
It's murder if you shoot someone that happens to be on your land. This was not self defense.
My point is that AZ does allow you to use lethal force to protect your property against criminal trespass. You don't need to prove "self defense" to justify it.
You may have missed my point. I don’t believe Arizona allows you to use lethal force to protect your property (i.e., land) against criminal trespass. I believe Arizona allows you to use lethal force to protect your occupied dwelling (i.e., your house while occupied) against criminal trespass.
-
You may have missed my point. I don’t believe Arizona allows you to use lethal force to protect your property (i.e., land) against criminal trespass. I believe Arizona allows you to use lethal force to protect your occupied dwelling (i.e., your house while occupied) against criminal trespass.
Whatever.
I was saying you don't have to use "self defense" as a justification. There are situations where you can use force that do not rise to the level of defending yourself.
Then you tell me it only counts for occupied dwellings.
That is irrelevant in the context of limiting your options to self defense.
Get it?
-
Or just link over to the AZ Legislature for the actual law:
13-407. Justification; use of physical force in defense of premises
A. A person or his agent in lawful possession or control of premises is justified in threatening to use deadly physical force or in threatening or using physical force against another when and to the extent that a reasonable person would believe it immediately necessary to prevent or terminate the commission or attempted commission of a criminal trespass by the other person in or upon the premises.
B. A person may use deadly physical force under subsection A only in the defense of himself or third persons as described in sections 13-405 and 13-406.
C. In this section, "premises" means any real property and any structure, movable or immovable, permanent or temporary, adapted for both human residence and lodging whether occupied or not.
https://www.azleg.gov/ars/13/00407.htm
Rather than argue over the wording I provided to make my point, maybe do a little more digging on your own to make sure your point isn't flimsily tethered to the text I posted. Accurate analytics require you start with accurate facts. I used a piece of text from a third party which gave me what I needed. if there's a problem with it, it's because you trusted it to be the definitive and true synopsis of the AZ law.
I used it because sometimes third party regurgitations can be easier to read than the legalese versions posted by the state legislature.
:shaka:
-
Or just link over to the AZ Legislature for the actual law:
https://www.azleg.gov/ars/13/00407.htm
Rather than argue over the wording I provided to make my point, maybe do a little more digging on your own to make sure your point isn't flimsily tethered to the text I posted. Accurate analytics require you start with accurate facts. I used a piece of text from a third party which gave me what I needed. if there's a problem with it, it's because you trusted it to be the definitive and true synopsis of the AZ law.
I used it because sometimes third party regurgitations can be easier to read than the legalese versions posted by the state legislature.
:shaka:
Let’s break that down…
13-407. Justification; use of physical force in defense of premises
A. A person or his agent in lawful possession or control of premises is justified in threatening to use deadly physical force or in threatening or using physical force against another when and to the extent that a reasonable person would believe it immediately necessary to prevent or terminate the commission or attempted commission of a criminal trespass by the other person in or upon the premises. (Emphasis added)
So you can threaten deadly force in response to criminal trespass on one’s premises.
B. A person may use deadly physical force under subsection A only in the defense of himself or third persons as described in sections 13-405 and 13-406. (Emphasis added)
So in response to a criminal trespass, you may only use deadly force in self-defense or justified defense of a third person.
I’ll look up sections 13-405 and 13-406 later… got more important things to do right now.
UPDATE: Looked up 13-405 and 13-406; pretty standard self-defense/defense of a third person statutes. Also read a little bit more about the case; guess what defense it looks like he’s going to bring….?
-
He reached for his waistband. Rancher feared for his life a firearm would be produced by a trespasser acting suspiciously……..
-
Are you a lawyer? Do you know and understand every castle doctrine and stand your ground law in every state?
https://www.survivalsullivan.com/arizona-castle-doctrine-law/
Why do you argue with that shit for brains? No matter what you say to that fuck head he never learns and would argue with a corpse! >:D
-
Let’s break that down…
So you can threaten deadly force in response to criminal trespass on one’s premises.
So in response to a criminal trespass, you may only use deadly force in self-defense or justified defense of a third person.
I’ll look up sections 13-405 and 13-406 later… got more important things to do right now.
UPDATE: Looked up 13-405 and 13-406; pretty standard self-defense/defense of a third person statutes. Also read a little bit more about the case; guess what defense it looks like he’s going to bring….?
The rancher reported hearing gunshots. If he's had armed men trespassing across his land in the past, it would be reasonable to be afraid that other groups using the same path and ignoring signs against trespassing might also be armed.
What matters is that there are situations that allow you to protect property against criminal trespass, not just against a direct threat to your life.
The statute allows for use of force that a reasonable person would use in response to the threat. Let me know how an individual might evaluate a situation where half a dozen people or more trespassing on his property and he's all alone except for his AK-47.
Again, not trying to argue the merits of his defense, just that you are legally allowed to use deadly force against criminal trespassers to defend your property.
What's more important is the US gov't is being negligent allowing mass illegal immigration at the border. They are creating the environment where people living on and near the border are constantly in fear. They can't call the cops and expect a 5 minute response. If they don't protect their land and their lives, who will?
-
Again, not trying to argue the merits of his defense, just that you are legally allowed to use deadly force against criminal trespassers to defend your property.
That’s not what the law says. It says you can THREATEN deadly force, or THREATEN or USE force (not deadly force) to prevent criminal trespass. You may only use deadly force in response to criminal trespass when the requirements of 13-405 or 13-406 are met, which is an imminent threat of deadly force against you or a third person. It may be different if the criminal trespass is happening in an occupied dwelling, but that’s not the case here.
If the group of people on his property had rifles, like he claimed in court papers, and they pointed a rifle at him from 80-100 yards, like he said in his court papers, then he may have a case for self-defense. The part of the law you posted does NOT allow the USE of deadly force to stop a criminal trespass on your ranch outside your dwelling unless the situation already satisfies the requirements for using deadly force in self-defense or defense of a third person.
-
It's murder if you shoot someone that happens to be on your land. This was not self defense. Sounds like we may need more firearms education and training in this forum.
You didn't post an link to the article and what little you posted doesn't contain much in the way of information so its hard for anyone here to determine whether the shooting was justified self defense or not.
It may have been self defense and maybe it wasn't. But yes, this could be avoided by not going on other people's land.
-
That’s not what the law says. It says you can THREATEN deadly force, or THREATEN or USE force (not deadly force) to prevent criminal trespass. You may only use deadly force in response to criminal trespass when the requirements of 13-405 or 13-406 are met, which is an imminent threat of deadly force against you or a third person. It may be different if the criminal trespass is happening in an occupied dwelling, but that’s not the case here.
If the group of people on his property had rifles, like he claimed in court papers, and they pointed a rifle at him from 80-100 yards, like he said in his court papers, then he may have a case for self-defense. The part of the law you posted does NOT allow the USE of deadly force to stop a criminal trespass on your ranch outside your dwelling unless the situation already satisfies the requirements for using deadly force in self-defense or defense of a third person.
So, in a statute that says you can protect your property, you think the subsections that say you can only do so if your life is in danger negate that subsection? Then why have the part about criminal trespass and protecting your premises at all if the same rules apply regardless of the location?
Imagine you're in a wheelchair and a guy runs up to take your backpack (let's call this your property). The guy doesn't display a gun or other weapon, but he likely picked you because you looked like an easy target. You draw your weapon and shoot him. Is that justified? He wasn't threatening your life. He just wanted to take your property.
Is that not justifiable defense of one's property?
Not AZ, but I'm sure similar in statute:
https://youtu.be/LNqx8v8ydhM
-
The account I heard was three men, dressed in tactical gear, carrying AK47s were spotted. They fired on the rancher and his wife. The rancher fired back in their direction. He saw them flee.
He checked the area later and found the dead man and then called the sheriff.
Seems like self defense to me.
-
The account I heard was three men, dressed in tactical gear, carrying AK47s were spotted. They fired on the rancher and his wife. The rancher fired back in their direction. He saw them flee.
He checked the area later and found the dead man and then called the sheriff.
Seems like self defense to me.
Never, ever, call the cops.
:wave:
-
The account I heard was three men, dressed in tactical gear, carrying AK47s were spotted. They fired on the rancher and his wife. The rancher fired back in their direction. He saw them flee.
He checked the area later and found the dead man and then called the sheriff.
Seems like self defense to me.
Seems like it. Depends on the details, including rancher's statement. But imagine that, someone twisting or excluding details to push a narrative. Shows lack of discipline and independent thought to evaluate and get to the facts before spewing judgement. . .
-
Never, ever, call the cops.
:wave:
Good advice. The only time I would call police is if I needed a police report to file an insurance claim. If I......never mind, too much information.
-
The account I heard was three men, dressed in tactical gear, carrying AK47s were spotted. They fired on the rancher and his wife. The rancher fired back in their direction. He saw them flee.
He checked the area later and found the dead man and then called the sheriff.
Seems like self defense to me.
Yep. Seems like it to me also. After all the investigations the truth will be revealed, instead of just assuming guilty just because he was arrested by the sheriff.
Innocent until proven guilty.
Some people are quick to jump to conclusions. Maybe because of their perceived agendas. Critical thinking is lacking nowadays.
Or maybe the OP has a sensitive heart for illegals crossing illegally through properties that clearly states no trespassing. Which is illegal.
-
Yep. Seems like it to me also. After all the investigations the truth will be revealed, instead of just assuming guilty just because he was arrested by the sheriff.
Innocent until proven guilty.
Some people are quick to jump to conclusions. Maybe because of their perceived agendas. Critical thinking is lacking nowadays.
Or maybe the OP has a sensitive heart for illegals crossing illegally through properties that clearly states no trespassing. Which is illegal.
According to the "news", the reason this rancher was arrested is because there was a witness.
So, one illegal alien gets shot, and somehow another illegal in the group (assumption there were no other people living on the rancher's land) who witnessed the shooting winds up in the Sheriff's office giving a statement?
Nothing fishy there. And if the dead man happened to be armed, could the "witness" who was close enough to hear the dying man's last words not have picked up the weapon and run with it?
At least 894 migrants died along the entire southern border in the last federal fiscal year —
a 58% increase from the previous fiscal year, according to the U.S. Border Patrol Missing Migrant Program.
So, when is Biden's arraignment for negligent homicide?
-
So, in a statute that says you can protect your property, you think the subsections that say you can only do so if your life is in danger negate that subsection? Then why have the part about criminal trespass and protecting your premises at all if the same rules apply regardless of the location?
Imagine you're in a wheelchair and a guy runs up to take your backpack (let's call this your property). The guy doesn't display a gun or other weapon, but he likely picked you because you looked like an easy target. You draw your weapon and shoot him. Is that justified? He wasn't threatening your life. He just wanted to take your property.
Is that not justifiable defense of one's property?
Not AZ, but I'm sure similar in statute:
https://youtu.be/LNqx8v8ydhM
The first subsection of the statute says:
13-407. Justification; use of physical force in defense of premises
A. A person or his agent in lawful possession or control of premises is justified in threatening to use deadly physical force or in threatening or using physical force against another when and to the extent that a reasonable person would believe it immediately necessary to prevent or terminate the commission or attempted commission of a criminal trespass by the other person in or upon the premises.
Arizona law says “physical force” and “deadly physical force” are two different things. (“‘Physical force’ means force used upon or directed toward the body of another person… but does not include deadly physical force.;” see section 13-105.)
So subsection A of the statute says that, if you believe it is necessary to prevent or terminate a criminal trespass, you may:
Threaten deadly physical force, or
Threaten or use physical force.
That subsection does not say you can use deadly physical force to prevent or terminate a criminal trespass, only that you can threaten it.
The second paragraph of the statute says:
B. A person may use deadly physical force under subsection A only in the defense of himself or third persons as described in sections 13-405 and 13-406.
So, in order to prevent or terminate a criminal trespass, you may threaten deadly physical force, but to be justified in using deadly physical force in defense of premises, you have to have satisfied the conditions in section 13-405 (self-defense) or section 13-406 (defense of a third person).
The video you linked has nothing to do with this situation; Texas law is very different than Arizona law with respect to use of force to protect property.
-
You didn't post an link to the article and what little you posted doesn't contain much in the way of information so its hard for anyone here to determine whether the shooting was justified self defense or not.
It may have been self defense and maybe it wasn't. But yes, this could be avoided by not going on other people's land.
Even if xhe posted the article, xhe doesnt read past the headline. Cause often what xhe post as links to help xis argument, doesnt help at all due to not reading what is posted.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
KINO SPRINGS, Ariz. — Gabriel Cuen-Buitimea was slipping across a rancher’s land near the border with Mexico when the shooting started. “I’m hit,” he said, before his eyes rolled back and he crumpled face down by a mesquite tree.
To the sheriff in rural Santa Cruz County, Ariz., this account, relayed by a witness, and other pieces of the investigation into the shooting death of Mr. Cuen-Buitimea seemed to make the next steps clear. The sheriff’s office arrested George Alan Kelly, the rancher suspected of firing the fatal shot, and charged him with murder.
Then the angry calls started pouring in.
“This is garbage.”
“It’s a travesty of justice.”
“Since when do illegals have rights?”
The rancher should get a citizens award! Good use of ammo! :thumbsup:
-
The rancher should get a citizens award! Good use of ammo! :thumbsup:
If the man was killed with an AK, it's Russia's fault. :thumbsup:
-
The account I heard was three men, dressed in tactical gear, carrying AK47s were spotted. They fired on the rancher and his wife. The rancher fired back in their direction. He saw them flee.
He checked the area later and found the dead man and then called the sheriff.
Seems like self defense to me.
With as many instances as there are of people crossing over private land it is entirely possible that's a different incident.
But of course, that would be a pretty good defense story... whose to say there wasn't someone with a rifle shooting at you?
-
A soldier in Afghanistan would be charged with murder for shooting someone in the back. This is true even if the person shot was armed. There are some warped concepts of justice displayed here. What ever happened to standing up for law and order?
Our resident war/military expert is back.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
MEXICO CITY (AP) — A Mexican official said Friday that her government thinks Arizona rancher George Alan Kelly should have faced first-degree murder charges for allegedly killing a Mexican migrant who was crossing his property.
An Arizona Justice of the Peace ruled last week that Kelly should face trial on charges of second-degree murder and aggravated assault in the death of Gabriel Cuen-Buitimea at the ranch outside Nogales, Arizona on Jan. 30.
That decision came after prosecutors lowered Kelly’s charge from a single count of first-degree murder, which would have required a finding of premeditated intent to kill, and could have led to a death sentence.
Mexico’s head of consular protection, Vanessa Calva, said Mexico had told U.S. prosecutors that her country believes first-degree charges more accurately describe the circumstances of Cuen-Buitimea’s death.
She said Cuen-Buitimea was unarmed, fleeing and was shot in the back.
Notice how theres no description of the ranchers story or the "witnesses" story.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20230406/3f6548e3a46fe7d1e9b55e3094487828.jpg)
Sent from my moto g power (2021) using Tapatalk
-
cool story, bro...
That is to be handled in court. The state will have to prove 2nd degree murder and they feel they have sufficient evidence to win.
-
Nowadays I don't believe anything off the internet because people just make sh---t up for clickbait.
Most of what pops up as "news" on my browser comes from unknown sources written by unknown people, or worse, written by A.I.
:rofl: :rofl:
-
That is to be handled in court. The state will have to prove 2nd degree murder and they feel they have sufficient evidence to win.
SWWOOOOOOOSSHhhhhh
-
A soldier in Afghanistan would be charged with murder for shooting someone in the back. This is true even if the person shot was armed. There are some warped concepts of justice displayed here. What ever happened to standing up for law and order?
Really? You sure about that?
I mean I am not in the military but I was under the assumption that you can shoot at a retreating enemy.
-
Really? You sure about that?
I mean I am not in the military but I was under the assumption that you can shoot at a retreating enemy.
Depends on the ROE and rules for the use of force (RUF). Given the fact that you could shoot a missile from a helicopter at somebody if it looked like they were burying an IED, I think it was probably OK to shoot an armed insurgent in the back.
-
A soldier in Afghanistan would be charged with murder for shooting someone in the back. This is true even if the person shot was armed. There are some warped concepts of justice displayed here. What ever happened to standing up for law and order?
Really? You sure about that?
I mean I am not in the military but I was under the assumption that you can shoot at a retreating enemy.
Out in the field there are no f**kn rules in war, even if there were such a thing. Only morality guides us in combat.
But if your brothers in arms are in danger, and you are the enemy, guess who holds the short end of the shit stick.....
-
Out in the field there are no f**kn rules in war, even if there were such a thing. Only morality guides us in combat.
But if your brothers in arms are in danger, and you are the enemy, guess who holds the short end of the shit stick.....
To add to that ...
There are 2 kinds of people in an armed conflict: combatants and non-combatants.
if you see someone with an AK-47 driving or running toward you, and you're a uniformed military person, you have to assume that someone is a combatant unless and until they demonstrate otherwise -- throw down their arms, stop where they are, shows they aren't wired with explosives, etc....
The hardest part of today's conflicts is identifying the enemy. Insurgents and rebels don't wear uniforms normally. Also, today's non-combatant could become tomorrow's suicide bomber due to money promised to their families or threats to end their families.
Please, don't explain Rules of Engagement unless you've been there - done that.
-
To add to that ...
There are 2 kinds of people in an armed conflict: combatants and non-combatants.
if you see someone with an AK-47 driving or running toward you, and you're a uniformed military person, you have to assume that someone is a combatant unless and until they demonstrate otherwise -- throw down their arms, stop where they are, shows they aren't wired with explosives, etc....
The hardest part of today's conflicts is identifying the enemy. Insurgents and rebels don't wear uniforms normally. Also, today's non-combatant could become tomorrow's suicide bomber due to money promised to their families or threats to end their families.
Please, don't explain Rules of Engagement unless you've been there - done that.
I wasn't a ground pounder.
but I was issued an M16. though it was locked up in the armory
or bugout Cabana,
My instructions were simple, complete your mission!
It was at my discretion how to do it
and not violate the UCMJ rules.
:popcorn:
-
I wasn't a ground pounder.
but I was issued an M16. though it was locked up in the armory
or bugout Cabana,
My instructions were simple, complete your mission!
It was at my discretion how to do it
and not violate the UCMJ rules.
:popcorn:
The way I look at it, war is chaos. We lose a good percentage of infantry to friendly fire in each conflict.
It's unusual for the ones firing to be tried for a crime unless there's evidence the death was intentional.
Courage Under Fire was a good movie. Shows how messed up things can get when every decision could mean you and your team don't make it.
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0115956/?ref_=nm_flmg_t_33_act
-
The way I look at it, war is chaos. We lose a good percentage of infantry to friendly fire in each conflict.
It's unusual for the ones firing to be tried for a crime unless there's evidence the death was intentional.
Courage Under Fire was a good movie. Shows how messed up things can get when every decision could mean you and your team don't make it.
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0115956/?ref_=nm_flmg_t_33_act
Hey Flapp,
Can you please stop making me waste my time by recommending and making me watch all these good movies that I heard about but never took the time to watch before.
Thanks, Friendo
-
Depends on the ROE and rules for the use of force (RUF). Given the fact that you could shoot a missile from a helicopter at somebody if it looked like they were burying an IED, I think it was probably OK to shoot an armed insurgent in the back.
We blew the crap out of Iraqi armor as they were retreating (they weren't surrendering) so I think Rhaydar has no idea what he is talking about
Good point about the ROE though because that certainly would play a role
-
Hey Flapp,
Can you please stop making me waste my time by recommending and making me watch all these good movies that I heard about but never took the time to watch before.
Thanks, Friendo
That movie has a stellar cast, two overlapping plot lines, and keeps you guessing up until the end.
It's no Saving Private Ryan as far as the combat scenes go, but it's definitely thought-provoking. :thumbsup:
(https://i.imgur.com/Qoi0IxE.gif)
-
Theres an ethics class 1 must take at Anapolis. 1 question was
Youre a pilot with orders to fire and destroy a convoy. What do u do as u approach and they waive a white flag?
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
Theres an ethics class 1 must take at Anapolis. 1 question was
Youre a pilot with orders to fire and destroy a convoy. What do u do as u approach and they waive a white flag?
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
Did they give the "right" answer or was it more just to inspire thought and discussion?
-
it's ok to attack if they "waive" a white flag...
1. to refrain from claiming or insisting on; forgo: to waive one's rank. 2. to relinquish (a right) intentionally: to waive an option. 3. to put aside, esp. for the time; defer or dispense with: to waive formalities.
Theres an ethics class 1 must take at Anapolis. 1 question was
Youre a pilot with orders to fire and destroy a convoy. What do u do as u approach and they waive a white flag?
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
Theres an ethics class 1 must take at Anapolis. 1 question was
Youre a pilot with orders to fire and destroy a convoy. What do u do as u approach and they waive [sic] a white flag?
The correct answer is that the White Flag and Red Cross symbols have been codified in the Hague and Geneva Conventions.
Not only is it a war crime to not honor those symbols, but it is also a war crime to falsely use those symbols to deceive the enemy.
The realistic answer is you have to take it in context. A white flag is useless to an enemy convoy. Surrendering to a pilot in the air is not logical. That leaves the possibility that the convoy is friendly, and the flag is being used to prevent misidentification.
In modern warfare, communications methods are more sophisticated. If the convoy is part of your force, they should have the means to relay their identity and position to the pilot without relying on a white flag.
One of the things that seems to always be a problem is inter-service communications. The Marines seem to have this attitude that they need to be early when executing joint maneuvers. It's some sort of OPSEC mindset. If the enemy gets hold of the plan, changing their arrival times keeps everyone guessing It's not uncommon for the Marines to arrive an hour or more at their anticipated location ahead of when planned. That means the other services quite often mistake forward Marine units for the enemy since they should not yet be there.
These kinds of problems are magnified when allied forces are coordinating the execution of a plan.
Do some reading on friendly fire incidents. Best laid plans ...
-
Hey Flapp,
Can you please stop making me waste my time by recommending and making me watch all these good movies that I heard about but never took the time to watch before.
Thanks, Friendo
Y'all know you can a train a twelve year old kid to fly a helicopter?
or an airplane, or drive a ship.
What a military person in a position of commamd is and does, is and what they trained for, is to
make hard decisions when SHTF.
Personally, I know women don't belong in Combat. most jobs in the military
are not in combat and I'm sure the guys like some clean Pu$$y.
But glamorzing women getting killed, maimed, and raped is not my idea
of femisism or modern military sucess.
:grrr:
-
The correct answer is that the White Flag and Red Cross symbols have been codified in the Hague and Geneva Conventions.
Not only is it a war crime to not honor those symbols, but it is also a war crime to falsely use those symbols to deceive the enemy.
The realistic answer is you have to take it in context. A white flag is useless to an enemy convoy. Surrendering to a pilot in the air is not logical. That leaves the possibility that the convoy is friendly, and the flag is being used to prevent misidentification.
In modern warfare, communications methods are more sophisticated. If the convoy is part of your force, they should have the means to relay their identity and position to the pilot without relying on a white flag.
One of the things that seems to always be a problem is inter-service communications. The Marines seem to have this attitude that they need to be early when executing joint maneuvers. It's some sort of OPSEC mindset. If the enemy gets hold of the plan, changing their arrival times keeps everyone guessing It's not uncommon for the Marines to arrive an hour or more at their anticipated location ahead of when planned. That means the other services quite often mistake forward Marine units for the enemy since they should not yet be there.
These kinds of problems are magnified when allied forces are coordinating the execution of a plan.
Do some reading on friendly fire incidents. Best laid plans ...
Good answer. I would think that as a pilot, one would also have the ability to communicate with his command what he was observing as well and if so should do so rather than just stick to a basic instruction
-
Good answer. I would think that as a pilot, one would also have the ability to communicate with his command what he was observing as well and if so should do so rather than just stick to a basic instruction
i wrote a longer reply but shortened it, since we're getting way off topic.
Pilots have some discretion when it comes to identifying their targets, but they may not have the time. By the time they ask "command', the window to hit it might have closed. The window could be short based on target visibility, defensive measures in response to your attack, whether your mission is part of a larger coordinated objective, etc.
-
Since this is an ethics class, there really is no true right answer. The instructor brought up this thought, what if every time there's a strafing run, the enemy waved a white flag. Then when the plane left, they lowered it. No ones going to charge them for a war crime.
Of course, there would be many factors, but just take this as face value. Like don't worry about war crimes for falsifying a surrender or if there's no surrendering force acceptance in the immediate area.
1 could also ask the above, but just say fog of war and this info is not known in time. Does a pilot follow orders or disobey?
Sorry last off topic post.
-
Since this is an ethics class, there really is no true right answer. The instructor brought up this thought, what if every time there's a strafing run, the enemy waved a white flag. Then when the plane left, they lowered it. No ones going to charge them for a war crime.
Of course, there would be many factors, but just take this as face value. Like don't worry about war crimes for falsifying a surrender or if there's no surrendering force acceptance in the immediate area.
1 could also ask the above, but just say fog of war and this info is not known in time. Does a pilot follow orders or disobey?
Sorry last off topic post.
There's always a right answer to most ethics questions. The problem is, when the decision has to be made in a split second, the decision might not be made using perfect information. That's why we ask these questions before we need to decide. Reviewing a decision long after the event can help prepare for the next time, but we have to rely on our own judgement in that moment. It's why cops have qualified immunity. If they did everything they were trained to do, then any bad results are considered unfortunate but not the cop's fault. E.G. if you are running at a Cop yelling, "Hands up! Don't shoot!" are you really surrendering, or just trying to trick the cop before you are close enough to attack?
-
Flappster,
Didn’t know you taught at Annapolis.
“The correct answer is….” :rofl:
Depends on what the fawk is in the convoy.
If I locked in on a convoy that has SCUDS or whatever the new shi+ is or a convoy with mobile missile launchers, I light ‘em up.
Tanks. Light ‘em up.
I got the orders to back me up.
Bunch of humvees ? Depends if we have intel on what or who they’re carrying.
For some reason I was ordered to hit ‘em.
Just my thinking.
No idea what all these posts have to do with Rancher Charged with Murder in Arizona.
Never mind I see the segue. Law is civilian rules of engagement.
Then we head off into military rules of engagement….and ethics.
De-railed.
Edit: My Bad. Looks like CMO might’ve got her back on track. :thumbsup:
Still like my post though. ;D
-
lots of military guys here.
So I'll say this and they will appreciate it
"kill them all and let God sort it out"
:thumbsup:
Doesn't work for atheiests, but I don't care about them.
-
lots of military guys here.
So I'll say this and they will appreciate it
"kill them all and let God sort it out"
:thumbsup:
Doesn't work for atheiests, but I don't care about them.
Anyone who runs is a V.C.! Anyone who stands still... is a well-disciplined V.C.!
-
Anyone who runs is a V.C.! Anyone who stands still... is a well-disciplined V.C.!
I always disliked that part in the movie.
There is this thing called the UCMJ and you can't do stuff like that.
Ask Lt. Calley about the place called Mi Lai.
:wave:
USA Democrats think our military are butchers when they are the most
professional military in the world( till Obama fuked it up).
>:D
-
My good friend's brother moved to AZ a few years ago. Bought a beautiful 50 acre property right on the Mexican border. He loved it there and told his brother how nice it was. So my friend goes to visit and goes out on the balcony around 0200 to.look at the night sky. He sees about 20 people running through the property. He tells his brother and they start watching at night. Almost every night they see people running through the property. He sold it soon after and moved way more inland, like about 200 miles from the border.
-
I always disliked that part in the movie.
There is this thing called the UCMJ and you can't do stuff like that.
Ask Lt. Calley about the place called Mi Lai.
:wave:
USA Democrats think our military are butchers when they are the most
professional military in the world( till Obama fuked it up).
>:D
All you need to know about the movie is that it was directed by Stanley Kubrick. :crazy:
Full Metal Jacket was not supposed to be a documentary. It's an antiwar film designed to capture the insanity of modern warfare.
Full Metal Jacket is about the abuse of young men, which has been going
on in the military since the start of society. These young men are turned into
killing machines
– Nathan Abrams
https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20220623-full-metal-jacket-and-kubrick-the-ultimate-anti-war-films
-
I always disliked that part in the movie.
There is this thing called the UCMJ and you can't do stuff like that.
Ask Lt. Calley about the place called Mi Lai.
:wave:
USA Democrats think our military are butchers when they are the most
professional military in the world( till Obama fuked it up).
>:D
The few Nam vets that I did speak to about their time there never mentioned stuff like this. But 1 guy did mention how common fragging was.
Many of them also had the saying with regard to getting disciplined for anything "what you gonna do, send me to vietnam?"
-
To add to that ...
There are 2 kinds of people in an armed conflict: combatants and non-combatants.
if you see someone with an AK-47 driving or running toward you, and you're a uniformed military person, you have to assume that someone is a combatant unless and until they demonstrate otherwise -- throw down their arms, stop where they are, shows they aren't wired with explosives, etc....
The hardest part of today's conflicts is identifying the enemy. Insurgents and rebels don't wear uniforms normally. Also, today's non-combatant could become tomorrow's suicide bomber due to money promised to their families or threats to end their families.
Please, don't explain Rules of Engagement unless you've been there - done that.
I have and you are wrong. You don't assume someone is a combatant just because they are walking around with an AK-47.
-
What was the rule about trolling? ???
-
Lots of people are armed. Lots of people will run. They didn't shoot at you. You can't assume they are the enemy and if possible you should detain them not shoot them. They are not a threat. You can't just shoot armed people that run.
ROE. Nuff sed.
-
Sounds like you are the kind of person that would murder a village.
I know the answer, but did you even read what he posted? Once again, you are assuming things that are not being said.
"If your brothers in arms are in danger, and you are the enemy".
You're use of the word "murder" implies that there is no defensive reason for a solder shooting the village. So refer back to what was stated "if your brothers in arms are in danger, AND you are the enemy".
Comprehension is hard....
-
I have and you are wrong. You don't assume someone is a combatant just because they are walking around with an AK-47.
Please show where Flapp said "walking around with an AK-47".
There's a US embassy in Africa that was getting pop shot at. The warlords men there would go as far as to even point their guns at the embassy, but not fire. We warned them not to do this as it would result in further actions by the US. They didn't listen and the ROE changed and anyone who's pointing a gun at the embassy was a combatant (hostile) and use of deadly force was authorized. So here comes Mr. badass pointing his AK at the embassy and an embassy sniper took him out. After that incident, anyone who was walking across the embassy, removed their mag and held their rifle and mag above their head. Then once they passed it, they would insert their mag and carry on.
This was on the History Channel on a show about effective usage of snipers.
-
You got a problem fighting next to someone that was born a man and identifies as a woman?
Where did this comment come from? Please show where he stated this is his problem.
TBH, at this point, I think professional help is needed for you to get because you are seeing things that are not there.
-
Where did this comment come from? Please show where he stated this is his problem.
TBH, at this point, I think professional help is needed for you to get because you are seeing things that are not there.
In his defense about trans military members, he was responding to a comment that included Obama. So ... :-* O0
-
(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20230412/3bc6f757688a244cb94347c867aa954a.jpg)
Sent from my moto g power (2021) using Tapatalk
-
In his defense about trans military members, he was responding to a comment that included Obama. So ... :-* O0
Focus.
Barry aint a tranny. But Big Mike on the other hand...
-
I know the answer, but did you even read what he posted? Once again, you are assuming things that are not being said.
"If your brothers in arms are in danger, and you are the enemy".
You're use of the word "murder" implies that there is no defensive reason for a solder shooting the village. So refer back to what was stated "if your brothers in arms are in danger, AND you are the enemy".
Comprehension is hard....
No can help. He/she/it is the new clueless generation.
-
Sounds like you are the kind of person that would murder a village.
And you sound like a person that would get killed 5 seconds into combat.(and not necessarily by the enemy). Not that you would make it through basic training but with all the woke nonsense going on in the military, you just might and even be made a woke General.
Then you and your comrades can “woke” the enemy to death.
-
The few Nam vets that I did speak to about their time there never mentioned stuff like this. But 1 guy did mention how common fragging was.
Many of them also had the saying with regard to getting disciplined for anything "what you gonna do, send me to vietnam?"
"Many of them also had the saying with regard to getting disciplined for anything "what you gonna do, send me to vietnam?""
I guess you weren't in the military. it reall goes like this
"what you gonna do, take away my birthday and send me to Guam?"
Guam 1975-1977.
Vietnam had pussy.
-
"Many of them also had the saying with regard to getting disciplined for anything "what you gonna do, send me to vietnam?""
I guess you weren't in the military. it reall goes like this
"what you gonna do, take away my birthday and send me to Guam?"
Guam 1975-1977.
Vietnam had pussy.
Iraq, no pussy either. Well more service women were in country compared to Nam, if that counts.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
Iraq, no pussy either. Well more service women were in country compared to Nam, if that counts.
That's a fact. Co-ed military units, especially front line units, have a very high rate of promiscuity.
I roomed with this captain who was just finishing going through a divorce. His wife was also a captain. She was deployed to Saudi Arabia a few months before he deployed. While there, she fell for a major (don't judge -- her husband was a real jerk).
I also found out on my first deployment to Saudi Arabia there was an "emergency unscheduled rotation". A 2Lt female was being shipped home "no notice" after it was discovered by command she had been turning tricks in her hotel room in Riyadh. I don't know what she was charging, but I'm sure the single guys would have been lining up to spend their TDY per diem. :geekdanc:
There were also many married couples assigned to my units who met on active duty -- both enlisted, both officers, or mixed officer-enlisted couples. Crazy how they decided to get married after they never had a chance to date due to fraternization rules. :rofl:
-
Lots of people are armed. Lots of people will run. They didn't shoot at you. You can't assume they are the enemy and if possible you should detain them not shoot them. They are not a threat. You can't just shoot armed people that run.
And how do you know that no one pointed a gun at the rancher?
You are also ignoring the dynamics of combat. Someone can shoot at you, retreat to the next cover then shoot at you again, and repeat. In such a situation you could be justified at shooting them as they flee.
Additionally it is possible to shoot someone in the back due to basic human reaction. If I see someone pointing a gun at me then I raise my gun and begin to fire, they may turn faster than I am able to respond. This has been demonstrated in some police shootings and the person turned so fast, the officer could not stop his action in time and ended up shooting the person in the back.
Bottom line is you are oversimplifying things. There are instances when you could shoot someone running away, it just depends on the circumstances. For you to claim it is never justified is just incorrect.
-
And how do you know that no one pointed a gun at the rancher?
You are also ignoring the dynamics of combat. Someone can shoot at you, retreat to the next cover then shoot at you again, and repeat. In such a situation you could be justified at shooting them as they flee.
Additionally it is possible to shoot someone in the back due to basic human reaction. If I see someone pointing a gun at me then I raise my gun and begin to fire, they may turn faster than I am able to respond. This has been demonstrated in some police shootings and the person turned so fast, the officer could not stop his action in time and ended up shooting the person in the back.
Bottom line is you are oversimplifying things. There are instances when you could shoot someone running away, it just depends on the circumstances. For you to claim it is never justified is just incorrect.
I guess you didn't get the memo that xhe is our new resident military ROE and tactics expert. We are all wrong, xhe is always right.
-
I also found out on my first deployment to Saudi Arabia there was an "emergency unscheduled rotation". A 2Lt female was being shipped home "no notice" after it was discovered by command she had been turning tricks in her hotel room in Riyadh. I don't know what she was charging, but I'm sure the single guys would have been lining up to spend their TDY per diem. :geekdanc:
OIF, crew chief is the new pimp. Usage of the Blackhawk...
-
xhe hasn't served. Doesn't know what a DD214 is.
-
So people driving by in the back of a pickup with weapons and you are going to shoot them for no reason? We need more people like you in Texas. Seriously, you make me believe that we do need more firearm regulation/education/background checks. I did not think that way until I found this forum. You've changed my belief to where I support the current Hawaii laws and think we may need to do more. Your activism is working against you.
"I support the current Hawaii laws and think we may need to do more."
You are an idiot.
:wave:
-
So people driving by in the back of a pickup with weapons and you are going to shoot them for no reason? We need more people like you in Texas. Seriously, you make me believe that we do need more firearm regulation/education/background checks. I did not think that way until I found this forum. You've changed my belief to where I support the current Hawaii laws and think we may need to do more. Your activism is working against you.
So, a pickup truck pulls into your driveway uninvited with 6 men carrying loaded weapons, and you're just going to walk outside and introduce yourself?
You're a special kind of stupid.
Also, how do people in the back of a pickup truck "drive" anywhere? Someone needs to be in the cab, huh?
And the scenario was that the warlords were warned by the embassy to not drive around the compound with loaded weapons or be fired upon.
Nobody was shooting "for no reason." Learn to read.
-
You have lost track of the conversation and have no idea what you are talking about. What country are you in?
Back on topic so some unarmed people are trespassing on your property and you going to shoot them? Got a clue? Please read the words below "unarmed". He claimed he only fired a warning shot.
"Kelly is accused of fatally shooting Gabriel Cuen-Buitimea, an unarmed 48-year-old migrant from Nogales, Mexico. Prosecutors have said Kelly had no basis for intentionally or recklessly firing an AK-47 rifle toward eight or so unarmed migrants about 80 to 100 yards (meters) away."
https://www.fox10phoenix.com/news/arizona-rancher-arraigned-in-mexican-mans-shooting-death (https://www.fox10phoenix.com/news/arizona-rancher-arraigned-in-mexican-mans-shooting-death)
WTF are 'unarnmed people?" You mean probable border jumpers which could be anything from drug runners, human traffickers or illegal aliens? If they had anything with them that could be used as a bludgeon or stabbing weapon, they were not "unarmed." More likely "less well armed" compared to the rancher. :geekdanc:
How does the prosecutor know all 8 were unarmed? Because the ILLEGAL ALIENS told him? Is it not possible that the armed men evaded the rancher and the unarmed people were too scared to run after hearing shots?
So far, no surprises. You don't know what happened, just want to parrot what the prosecutor wants the jury to know.
There's no actual evidence the rancher fired on unarmed people, just testimony from SOME of the people he shot at.
INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILtY
-
So people driving by in the back of a pickup with weapons and you are going to shoot them for no reason? We need more people like you in Texas. Seriously, you make me believe that we do need more firearm regulation/education/background checks. I did not think that way until I found this forum. You've changed my belief to where I support the current Hawaii laws and think we may need to do more. Your activism is working against you.
Nothing u posted is in the reply. Wow, someone is still seeing things that arent there.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
WTF are 'unarnmed people?" You mean probable border jumpers which could be anything from drug runners, human traffickers or illegal aliens? If they had anything with them that could be used as a bludgeon or stabbing weapon, they were not "unarmed." More likely "less well armed" compared to the rancher. :geekdanc:
How does the prosecutor know all 8 were unarmed? Because the ILLEGAL ALIENS told him? Is it not possible that the armed men evaded the rancher and the unarmed people were too scared to run after hearing shots?
So far, no surprises. You don't know what happened, just want to parrot what the prosecutor wants the jury to know.
There's no actual evidence the rancher fired on unarmed people, just testimony from SOME of the people he shot at.
INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILtY
No coyotes either i guess.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
You have lost track of the conversation and have no idea what you are talking about. What country are you in?
Back on topic so some unarmed people are trespassing on your property and you going to shoot them? Got a clue? Please read the words below "unarmed". He claimed he only fired a warning shot.
"Kelly is accused of fatally shooting Gabriel Cuen-Buitimea, an unarmed 48-year-old migrant from Nogales, Mexico. Prosecutors have said Kelly had no basis for intentionally or recklessly firing an AK-47 rifle toward eight or so unarmed migrants about 80 to 100 yards (meters) away."
https://www.fox10phoenix.com/news/arizona-rancher-arraigned-in-mexican-mans-shooting-death (https://www.fox10phoenix.com/news/arizona-rancher-arraigned-in-mexican-mans-shooting-death)
Goal post moved. Business is gonna be good again. Maybe ill buy kokohead range. I mean F35 cost over $100 mil right, so no way city would turn it down.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
So people driving by in the back of a pickup with weapons and you are going to shoot them for no reason? We need more people like you in Texas. Seriously, you make me believe that we do need more firearm regulation/education/background checks. I did not think that way until I found this forum. You've changed my belief to where I support the current Hawaii laws and think we may need to do more. Your activism is working against you.
BTW i guess u failed to read the ENTIRE thing again. Ur reply would mean the background checks for US military command needs work and has zero to do with HI since its a TV SHOW on the History Channel.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
No evidence
No evidence?
You do realize that the government has to find evidence of someone's guilty and not the other way around. The government doesn't get to take you to court and tell you to prove your innocence otherwise you are guilty.
So what is the evidence that the rancher fired without any legal justification?
-
No evidence?
You do realize that the government has to find evidence of someone's guilty and not the other way around. The government doesn't get to take you to court and tell you to prove your innocence otherwise you are guilty.
So what is the evidence that the rancher fired without any legal justification?
That was in our younger days before Obama,
:wacko:
-
No evidence?
You do realize that the government has to find evidence of someone's guilty and not the other way around. The government doesn't get to take you to court and tell you to prove your innocence otherwise you are guilty.
So what is the evidence that the rancher fired without any legal justification?
Maybe the Democrats follow a different set of rules when the defendant is someone they hate:
“No one is above the law, and everyone has the right to a trial to prove innocence."
-- Nancy Pelosi
Pelosi ripped for tweet saying Trump can ‘prove innocence’ at trial
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2023/mar/31/pelosi-ripped-tweet-saying-trump-can-prove-innocen/
-
Maybe the Democrats follow a different set of rules when the defendant is someone they hate:
“No one is above the law, and everyone has the right to a trial to prove innocence."
-- Nancy Pelosi
Pelosi ripped for tweet saying Trump can ‘prove innocence’ at trial
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2023/mar/31/pelosi-ripped-tweet-saying-trump-can-prove-innocen/
2 like minds think alike.
With all the made up replies, maybe Brandon joined the forum?
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
The pelosi's and the biden's of the political world are perfect examples of what happens when career politicians go unchecked.
The knife blade becomes dull when it goes unchallenged. Accountability for actions and deeds go out the window.
-
The reasons Democrats aren't prosecuted as often is because they don't commit the crimes. If they had they would be indicted.
Amazing the people here proclaim innocent until proven guilty yet believe that it is okay to murder an unarmed trespasser.
What world do you live in?
:wacko:
-
The reasons Democrats aren't prosecuted as often is because they don't commit the crimes. If they had they would be indicted.
Amazing the people here proclaim innocent until proven guilty yet believe that it is okay to murder an unarmed trespasser.
Logic has never been used in almost all posting.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
The reasons Democrats aren't prosecuted as often is because they don't commit the crimes. If they had they would be indicted.
Amazing the people here proclaim innocent until proven guilty yet believe that it is okay to murder an unarmed trespasser.
https://www.civilbeat.org/2023/04/ex-hawaii-lawmaker-gets-2-years-in-prison-for-taking-bribes/ (https://www.civilbeat.org/2023/04/ex-hawaii-lawmaker-gets-2-years-in-prison-for-taking-bribes/)
-
The reasons Democrats aren't prosecuted as often is because they don't commit the crimes. If they had they would be indicted.
Amazing the people here proclaim innocent until proven guilty yet believe that it is okay to murder an unarmed trespasser.
https://www.khon2.com/local-news/former-lawmaker-kalani-english-sentenced-40-months/ (https://www.khon2.com/local-news/former-lawmaker-kalani-english-sentenced-40-months/)
-
What world do you live in?
:wacko:
They live in the world of make-believe.
-
Clinton Scandals: A Guide From Whitewater To The Clinton Foundation
https://www.npr.org/2016/06/12/481718785/clinton-scandals-a-guide-from-whitewater-to-the-clinton-foundation
Whitewater, 1992
Travelgate, 1993
Vince Foster Death, 1993
Paula Jones/Monica Lewinsky, 1994
Filegate, 1996
Benghazi, 2012
Clinton Foundation, 2015
Private Email Server, 2015
The story was written in 2016 before the Russia collusion hoax that was designed to smear Trump and divert attention from her illegal mail server.
The story was also before the "tarmac meeting" between USAG Lynch and Bill Clinton just days before Lynch was to announce the outcome of the email server investigation.
Then there are the lies before Congress about her classified emails, destruction of evidence while it was under subpoena, destruction of government records, destruction of government property (smashed tablets and Blackberry devices), copies of her classified emails found on Anthony Weiner's laptop, etc, etc, etc.
Then add in Epstein's "suicide" and the trips Bill took to pedophile island.
Yeah, those Democrats are so much more law-abiding and ethical than the Republicans. And this list is only about TWO Democrats -- a former Governor & President and his First Lady, who was also a Senator, Secretary of State, and close to becoming President herself.
:crazy:
-
See the system works when if they break they law they are prosecuted.
https://www.staradvertiser.com/2021/03/31/hawaii-news/house-panel-suspends-state-rep-sharon-har-dui-inquiry/ (https://www.staradvertiser.com/2021/03/31/hawaii-news/house-panel-suspends-state-rep-sharon-har-dui-inquiry/)
Har is scheduled to appear in criminal court April 20 on suspicion of operating a vehicle under the influence of an intoxicant and for driving without insurance.Har (D, Kapolei-Makakilo) was arrested on the night of Feb. 22 after she was seen driving in the wrong direction on one-way South Beretania Street in Honolulu. Police reports indicated her eyes appeared red and glassy, her speech slightly slurred and that there was a smell of alcohol.
https://www.hawaiipublicradio.org/local-news/2022-01-10/judge-dismisses-dui-charges-against-legislative-representative-sharon-har (https://www.hawaiipublicradio.org/local-news/2022-01-10/judge-dismisses-dui-charges-against-legislative-representative-sharon-har)
HONOLULU — A judge on Monday acquitted a Hawaiʻi lawmaker charged with driving under the influence after police saw her driving the wrong way down a major Honolulu thoroughfare.
State Rep. Sharon Har pleaded not guilty to driving under the influence and went to trial. Her trial before a judge began on Dec. 6, 2021, and resumed Monday, Jan. 10.
After the prosecution rested, her attorney, Howard Luke, sought an acquittal, which he said the judge granted.
Honolulu prosecutors said they are disappointed by the ruling.
The two other charges against Har were dismissed previously, Luke said. A charge of driving the wrong way on a one-way street was dismissed because of a defect in the citation and a charge of no proof of insurance was dismissed because Har wasn't able to pull it up on her phone when she was pulled over but was later able to prove she had insurance, Luke said.
The officer who pulled Har over said he saw her driving the wrong way down Beretania Street in February 2021.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BN_5Nbbr1GY
-
If it's true you should provide the evidence to a grand jury and have them indicted. The problem is you have no evidence and you are unable to cobble together a grand jury willing to indict. Sounds like you don't have any justification for your claims.
Did you even bother to read the story at the link you posted and look at the outcomes?
"Because i dont know anything, thus u are wrong".
Jeanism is back
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
See the system works when if they break they law they are prosecuted. Now shouldn't that work for Republicans and Trumpers also?
"What i mean is a broken clock is right twice a day and that proves im right".
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
I live in reality.. step out of your Maga bubble and come on over. I'll welcome you.
Hahahhahhahhahhahha Jeanism
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
I live in reality.. step out of your Maga bubble and come on over. I'll welcome you.
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
-
If it's true you should provide the evidence to a grand jury and have them indicted. The problem is you have no evidence and you are unable to cobble together a grand jury willing to indict. Sounds like you don't have any justification for your claims.
Did you even bother to read the story at the link you posted and look at the outcomes?
Swoosh!
The outcomes are the entire point of my post, genius.
-
(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20230418/a91bc07916c872d935b4fe0d2aa9d18e.jpg)
Sent from my moto g power (2021) using Tapatalk
-
(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20230418/a91bc07916c872d935b4fe0d2aa9d18e.jpg)
Sent from my moto g power (2021) using Tapatalk
In my mind 2 of the most despicable people on this earth. Along with her boss, Obullsh*t.
-
Who is responsible for the outcomes? You are.
Were you in an accident, or is your brain damage drug induced?
-
Were you in an accident, or is your brain damage drug induced?
Willful ignorance is actually a potent form of psychiatric self harm.