2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: DuckFat on December 11, 2012, 04:56:53 PM

Title: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: DuckFat on December 11, 2012, 04:56:53 PM
http://www.cnn.com/2012/12/11/us/oregon-mall-shooting/?hpt=hp_t1 (http://www.cnn.com/2012/12/11/us/oregon-mall-shooting/?hpt=hp_t1)
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2012/12/11/oregon-mall-shooting/1762473/ (http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2012/12/11/oregon-mall-shooting/1762473/)

Quote
Three people were killed, including the shooter, said Lt. James Rhodes of the Clackamas County Sheriff's Office. One person suffered a traumatic injury, he said. The shooter died of a self-inflicted gunshot, Rhodes said.

I hope this isn't a trend with the malls being full of Christmas shoppers and all.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: Izanagi on December 11, 2012, 05:36:47 PM
i hope this isn't a trend EVER.  I swear obummer is brainwashing people to commit these crimes so he can use it as an "ammunition" for banning guns.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: Bunker on December 11, 2012, 05:42:22 PM
If this sick guy used an assault weapon it's only a matter of time before anti gun groups start screaming louder to ban assault weapons.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: justin1098 on December 11, 2012, 08:09:55 PM
"A woman told CNN affiliate KOIN that she saw a man wearing a hockey mask jogging through Macy's and wielding an assault rifle."

Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: xer 21 on December 11, 2012, 09:01:18 PM
If this sick guy used an assault weapon it's only a matter of time before anti gun groups start screaming louder to ban assault weapons.
and its only a matter of time before people dont care.

if the colorado shooting didnt budge people, this wont.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: SpeedTek on December 11, 2012, 10:22:17 PM
The worst part oregon is a open carry state. Dont know if the mall was a gun free zone.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: Water on December 12, 2012, 03:01:18 AM
The worst part oregon is a open carry state. Dont know if the mall was a gun free zone.
I'm sorry but I dont understand open carry. Yea I get it but you also could just get attacked from behind where the aggressor could just neutralize you or your gun first and then do greater harm later.  He/she could take or maybe use your own gun against you. Basically put unwanted attention on yourself. CCW is way more practical IMO.  I spoke with a retired officer once and he said that every hot call they go to is potentially a gun call... they bringing it to one (since it's obviously on their hip). At least with CCW, the potential attacker doesnt know it... until youre pointing it at him/her.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: Kingkeoni on December 12, 2012, 06:21:27 AM
I'm sorry but I dont understand open carry. Yea I get it but you also could just get attacked from behind where the aggressor could just neutralize you or your gun first and then do greater harm later.  He/she could take or maybe use your own gun against you. Basically put unwanted attention on yourself. CCW is way more practical IMO.  I spoke with a retired officer once and he said that every hot call they go to is potentially a gun call... they bringing it to one (since it's obviously on their hip). At least with CCW, the potential attacker doesnt know it... until youre pointing it at him/her.

+1
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: BananaClip on December 12, 2012, 06:46:32 AM
Again, it took a firearm to stop a firearm.. Yeah, he shot himself but thats what it took.... :-\

Very unfortunate but hopefully there are some who turn pro gun after the obvious.....

+1 on open carry, I agree that it lets the criminal mind plan before doing wrong......
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: Cougar8045 on December 12, 2012, 07:27:44 AM
So what they're saying is, this asshole was basically recreating that level from Call of Duty where you walk all calm and cool through an airport and mow down as many people as possible?  How about instead of banning guns, we ask ourselves how healthy it is for kids to play video games where the kid is put in a level that simulates being an active shooter with the maximum level of realism and detail?
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: ren on December 12, 2012, 07:29:37 AM
I hate that word..."assault rifle" like calling a spoon used by an obese person a "fat spoon"
These people that commit these crimes are just that - crazy criminals. There were two crimes committed in Waipahu just days of each other using hammers.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: macsak on December 12, 2012, 07:37:29 AM
yeah, i was going to bring that up

next thing you know, they will want to ban "assault hammers"

I hate that word..."assault rifle" like calling a spoon used by an obese person a "fat spoon"
These people that commit these crimes are just that - crazy criminals. There were two crimes committed in Waipahu just days of each other using hammers.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: SpeedTek on December 12, 2012, 09:00:47 AM
http://www.oregonlive.com/politics/index.ssf/2012/12/clackamas_town_center_shooting.html (http://www.oregonlive.com/politics/index.ssf/2012/12/clackamas_town_center_shooting.html)

Here they go again........It wont stop a crazed gunman from from getting Hi-Caps. He used a stolen rifle anyway DUH!
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: hnl.flyboy on December 12, 2012, 09:51:33 AM
I'm sorry but I dont understand open carry. Yea I get it but you also could just get attacked from behind where the aggressor could just neutralize you or your gun first and then do greater harm later.  He/she could take or maybe use your own gun against you. Basically put unwanted attention on yourself. CCW is way more practical IMO.  I spoke with a retired officer once and he said that every hot call they go to is potentially a gun call... they bringing it to one (since it's obviously on their hip). At least with CCW, the potential attacker doesnt know it... until youre pointing it at him/her.

Some people aren't old enough to apply for a CCW permit (21 in Oregon).  Oregon allows OC at 18.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: ren on December 12, 2012, 10:00:09 AM
http://www.oregonlive.com/politics/index.ssf/2012/12/clackamas_town_center_shooting.html (http://www.oregonlive.com/politics/index.ssf/2012/12/clackamas_town_center_shooting.html)

Here they go again........It wont stop a crazed gunman from from getting Hi-Caps. He used a stolen rifle anyway DUH!
There's so much speculation when legislators try to pass such bans. Only "if" they didn't have a high cap magazine etc. They forget the criminals already broke a very well known law such as murder. Legislators fail to understand that once laws fail, the only course they have is to empower those that follow the law.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: 230RN on December 12, 2012, 11:27:59 AM
Quote
i hope this isn't a trend EVER.  I swear obummer is brainwashing people to commit these crimes so he can use it as an "ammunition" for banning guns.

You're not the first one to pose that theory, except with respect to anti-gunners in general.  for some weak-minded prople, it only takes an encouraging word or video or whatever to tip them over.  I suspect that's why we have copycat killers.

Quote
Legislators fail to understand that once laws fail, the only course they have is to empower those that follow the law.

+1

Lawmakers are not necessarily intelligent or wise.  All they are for sure, are "electable."  So put the blame where it lies: on the electorate. 

Terry, 230RN

Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: dirsh on December 12, 2012, 01:35:56 PM
If we did have CCW and something like this happened, would it be legal to shoot the guy? What would be the appropriate way to do so or what would YOU do?
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: DuckFat on December 12, 2012, 01:43:20 PM
Same story they always tell
Quote
http://www.cnn.com/2012/12/12/justice/oregon-mall-shooting/index.html (http://www.cnn.com/2012/12/12/justice/oregon-mall-shooting/index.html)
"He was a very loved individual that always seemed as if he had great intentions and a heart of gold. I know that must be hard for people to see/think/understand, but It's the truth. I don't know what caused him to do such a horrendous, terrible thing, but I do hope that somehow, answers will be available to us all."

Philpot said Roberts had recently broken up with a girlfriend and was considering moving to Hawaii. "I just had drinks with him in November, and he had just moved into a new place and was totally stoked about it," she said. "I can't believe he did this."
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: 230RN on December 12, 2012, 03:11:05 PM
dirsh asked,

Quote
If we did have CCW and something like this happened, would it be legal to shoot the guy? What would be the appropriate way to do so or what would YOU do?

I pre-planned this a long time ago when the first of these creeps started shooting up a supermall. When it happened again in Aurora Colorado, I posted it again.

So, once more, here's my pre-planned behavior.

Quote
I don't want to sound bravado-ish, but in my meager "tactical" outlook, I've mentally rehearsed what I would do in a case like this or a mall shooting.  If at all possible, bearing in mind the people in my immediate vicinity, I would at least deliver suppressive fire.  Again, not being macho or heroic, but at my age I would be thinking of hopefully saving a few folks who had their whole lives ahead of them.  Yeah, there may be a case of misidentification, and I myself might get shot by another CCW-er or off-duty cop in the audience, but I predetermined to take my chances on that happening... but, again, at my age....

Maybe something like this should be another addition to everyone's tactical thinking and their "global" situational awareness.  The smoke/gas canisters and the reported flak jacket are a new wrinkle, and I'll have to think about that, now, too, but I've made and awful lot of "lucky" shots in 60 years of shooting... and I love the new laser sights I recently put on my carry pieces.

I'm not sure I conveyed my thinking on this without looking like a mall ninja or a wannabe hero, and I'm sure to be attacked by others for presenting this, but that's the way I started to look at it after an infamous mall shooting a couple of years ago where the a-hole was up on the second level of a mall and fired down at the crowd.

More youthful folks, especially if they have kids, may look at it differently.  In the internet lingo, YMMV.

In another post, where they were talking about rifles being more effective, I added,

Quote
For myself, a handgun with laser sights will have to do.  I mounted lasers on both my carry guns.  And I suspect (tacticians can challenge me on this) that just painting the creep's general area with the laser dot will be pretty effective as a suppressant itself.

Terry, 230RN
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: Bunker on December 12, 2012, 03:12:04 PM
Such a tragedy but sure glad he didn't make it to Hawaii as it says.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: kaneohegrown on December 12, 2012, 03:40:39 PM
Read earlier today, the AR that was used was stolen. Hopefully that tidbit will stop the inevitable rhetoric of "we need stricter gun laws..." or the equally famous "gun show loop holes caused this..."
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: DuckFat on December 12, 2012, 03:49:50 PM
Read earlier today, the AR that was used was stolen. Hopefully that tidbit will stop the inevitable rhetoric of "we need stricter gun laws..." or the equally famous "gun show loop holes caused this..."
It's being reported that he stole the AR-15 from "someone he knew"
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: bass monkey on December 12, 2012, 04:27:26 PM
If we did have CCW and something like this happened, would it be legal to shoot the guy? What would be the appropriate way to do so or what would YOU do?
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: Water on December 12, 2012, 05:02:07 PM
If we did have CCW and something like this happened, would it be legal to shoot the guy? What would be the appropriate way to do so or what would YOU do?
I believe it would be legal.  You are preventing an aggressor from doing further harm.  Just make sure youre positive the gunman is the aggressor and not a CCW protecting him/herself.  Just try get the story straight in that short amount of time and react accordingly. 
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: ren on December 12, 2012, 05:20:03 PM
Read earlier today, the AR that was used was stolen. Hopefully that tidbit will stop the inevitable rhetoric of "we need stricter gun laws..." or the equally famous "gun show loop holes caused this..."
Then the anti-gun argument would be: if that particular gun was banned then the criminal wouldn't have used it. The anti-gun control crowd has an infinitely deep hole of possible scenarios backed up by conjecture.
From the reaction of the shoppers no one seemed compelled to stop this coward (at least from media reports). There was no one with a CCW or open carry weapon on them?
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: Bunker on December 12, 2012, 05:41:49 PM
Then the anti-gun argument would be: if that particular gun was banned then the criminal wouldn't have used it. The anti-gun control crowd has an infinitely deep hole of possible scenarios backed up by conjecture.
From the reaction of the shoppers no one seemed compelled to stop this coward (at least from media reports). There was no one with a CCW or open carry weapon on them?

I would think even if one had a firearm considering the massive crowd and people running in panic, taking a shot unless right up on the gunman could potentially result in additional injuries to innocent people if one missed the intended target or a bystander ran in front of the target while taking a shot. The risk in my opinion would be too high unless practically next to the guy. Not sure if that is how it was but I could imagine mass panic and people running everywhere.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: BananaClip on December 12, 2012, 07:21:11 PM
That dude just simply had no friends......... :-[     

Maybe he didn't get disciplined from his parents enough.......

I got DIRTY LICKENS from my parents growing up so I'm all G...... 

I don't feel entitled like "No ones paying attention to me so lets hurt people...."

Unless he got TOO MUCH lickens from his parents....... :-\
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: GZire on December 12, 2012, 08:14:18 PM
If we did have CCW and something like this happened, would it be legal to shoot the guy? What would be the appropriate way to do so or what would YOU do?



Regardless of CCW or open carry the question to ask is this...........are you in fear of your life/others, fear of maiming, rape or sodomy?  If the answer is yes, then yes you would IMHO be justified.  This doesn't mean that you won't get arrested and questioned and have your firearm(s) confiscated and pay some $$$ to a lawyer to represent you, but yes IMHO it's justified.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: xer 21 on December 12, 2012, 11:48:41 PM
So what they're saying is, this asshole was basically recreating that level from Call of Duty where you walk all calm and cool through an airport and mow down as many people as possible?  How about instead of banning guns, we ask ourselves how healthy it is for kids to play video games where the kid is put in a level that simulates being an active shooter with the maximum level of realism and detail?
one, no, that isnt what they're saying.  you pulled that out of nowhere.

two, dont even start that BS.  blaming video games is just as retarded as blaming guns.  there isnt a thing wrong with video games.  this has been proven time and time again, and yet here we are still grasping at straws and not placing the full blame on the shooter himself.  if it isnt rap music, its metal music, or video games, or violent movies, or a shitty childhood, or, yes, GUNS.  stop this bs, now.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: 42itus on December 13, 2012, 12:06:10 AM
one, no, that isnt what they're saying.  you pulled that out of nowhere.

two, dont even start that BS.  blaming video games is just as retarded as blaming guns.  there isnt a thing wrong with video games.  this has been proven time and time again, and yet here we are still grasping at straws and not placing the full blame on the shooter himself.  if it isnt rap music, its metal music, or video games, or violent movies, or a shitty childhood, or, yes, GUNS.  stop this bs, now.

+1.  with our without video games, we're gonna have nutbags.  I let my son play MW2 and other shooting games.  He knows how to safely treat firearms.  God help me if I'm wrong, but he takes firearms very seriously and has never even joked about the abuse of firearms.  In any event, I've involved him in shooting from a young age and I'm comfortable with my choice.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: xer 21 on December 13, 2012, 12:35:55 AM
i'd also like to point out, that that MW2 scene mentioned, whether you think it was the right thing to include or not, had a point, and wasnt just there for show, and asked questions of the players that few would ever have had the guts to ask.  controversial, yes, but i think it was a brilliant move, and it asked questions about the morality of what the player is participating in, and where the line gets drawn in art.  the intent isnt to allow players to murder a bunch of people, but to have them question at what point does does it get to be too much to allow the player certain freedoms, and to really think about what it is they are simulating when playing the game. 
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: Cougar8045 on December 13, 2012, 07:58:27 AM
one, no, that isnt what they're saying.  you pulled that out of nowhere.

two, dont even start that BS.  blaming video games is just as retarded as blaming guns.  there isnt a thing wrong with video games.  this has been proven time and time again, and yet here we are still grasping at straws and not placing the full blame on the shooter himself.  if it isnt rap music, its metal music, or video games, or violent movies, or a shitty childhood, or, yes, GUNS.  stop this bs, now.
Belay my last.  That's what I'M saying.  Do you have anything to base your statement on?  Doubtful.  Why don't you go pick up a copy of On Killing: The Psychological Cost of Learning to Kill in War and Society, and get back to me when you've learned a thing or two?
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: xer 21 on December 13, 2012, 06:40:08 PM
Belay my last.  That's what I'M saying.  Do you have anything to base your statement on?  Doubtful.  Why don't you go pick up a copy of On Killing: The Psychological Cost of Learning to Kill in War and Society, and get back to me when you've learned a thing or two?
or i could find the hundreds of studies contradicting any opinon that video games foster aggression or violence, but i dont really feel like it.  this debate is so stale it isnt even funny.

the fact is, there hasnt been any conclusive evidence one way or another in terms of video games.  there simply isnt anything there that's really solid evidence.  sopme lean one way,others lean the other.

there's a reason the media has dropped its fervor over the video game/violence link.  its because they realized it was pretty stupid a long time ago.

people just dont pick up a gun and go kill people because they played video games.  at all.  there isnt a link, regardless of what one book might say.  millions and millions of gamers do not go out and kill or hurt people because they do it in a video game. 

it should also be noted that your source of reference here is really dated.  it was first published in 1995.  i dont know if you know your video game history, but that was the SNES/Sega Genesis era.   we didnt even have 3d graphics.  that book is irrelevant.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: new guy on December 13, 2012, 06:48:03 PM
.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: xer 21 on December 13, 2012, 07:00:49 PM
But just cause something is really dated doesn't mean it is automatically irrelevant, right?!? For me I don't think that violent video games CAUSE people to go out and do violent acts but maybe it can desensitize a person who already has a preexisting problem?? Just a thought...
no, but it does meant that it has practically 0 insight on the effects of modern gaming on a human being.  its like using a book written in the 1940's to support a claim that violent movies in the modern era are damaging to people's mental states.  its irrelevant because it is completely ignorant of the modern situation.

games have been getting more violent and more realistic every year for decades now.  the industry is HUGE.  its overtaking Hollywood as the dominant media industry.  yet violent crime keeps dropping.  that doesnt really sound like games have any sort of appreciable affect on violence or aggression.

as per your second thought, yeah, if someone already has aggression issues, or other mental issues, video games may desensitize or aggravate the situation. sure.  but the same can be said of books, movies, music or any form of media that depicts violent situations.  video games arent special. 

to single out video games and ignore the rest of the media is just stupid.  if one has an effect, than everything does.  you cant just pick and choose.  its almost like a media version of the assault weapons ban.  aka, let's pick something that looks scary and that we dont understand, and pretend its more dangerous than other guns/media.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: new guy on December 13, 2012, 07:09:00 PM
.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: xer 21 on December 13, 2012, 07:37:12 PM
Whoa whoa whoa!! Not disagreeing bruddah xer21!! Just wanted to point out that throwing around words around like stupid and irrelevant can really closes off fruitful discussion. Also like you said for every "study" done there are probably an equal amount of studies done that refute the findings. My thing is don't blame outside factors... Let the actor take ultimate responsibility for his or her actions without blaming any "crutches".
if i feel defensive, its because it frustrates me to see someone who is on the side of gun rights, essentially doing to same thing the media does with guns, only with a different scapegoat.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: Cougar8045 on December 13, 2012, 08:40:33 PM
no, but it does meant that it has practically 0 insight on the effects of modern gaming on a human being.  its like using a book written in the 1940's to support a claim that violent movies in the modern era are damaging to people's mental states.  its irrelevant because it is completely ignorant of the modern situation.

games have been getting more violent and more realistic every year for decades now.  the industry is HUGE.  its overtaking Hollywood as the dominant media industry.  yet violent crime keeps dropping.  that doesnt really sound like games have any sort of appreciable affect on violence or aggression.

as per your second thought, yeah, if someone already has aggression issues, or other mental issues, video games may desensitize or aggravate the situation. sure.  but the same can be said of books, movies, music or any form of media that depicts violent situations.  video games arent special. 

to single out video games and ignore the rest of the media is just stupid.  if one has an effect, than everything does.  you cant just pick and choose.  its almost like a media version of the assault weapons ban.  aka, let's pick something that looks scary and that we dont understand, and pretend its more dangerous than other guns/media.
First, the book was updated in 2009.  Hardly seems ignorant of the modern situation, does it? 

Those are exactly the type of people I was referring to, and the media in general is what Grossman credits, with special emphasis on video games.  However, if you're willing to admit that books, movies, etc, could contribute to desensitizing a person to violence, you're on the right track.  But you're wrong to say they're nothing special.  Video games are very special; they're the only form of media where YOU are the one pulling the trigger, vice reading/watching/listening to a story about someone else doing the deed. 

I reacted the same way that you did when I first read the book.  I started playing DOOM when I was about ten; my folks got me Duke Nukem 3D for Christmas when it came out, and I've been a steady consumer of every FPS that's come out since.  I love video games, and I turned out just fine.  I said, "Dave, you're a goddamn hippie."  But stop and think about it.  You have kids spending hours and hours in what amounts to a combat simulator; pretending that would have no effect whatsoever on a developing mind is pretty obtuse. 

You stated twice that video games aren't special, in the same post where you asserted that the industry is HUGE and overtaking Hollywood as the dominant media outlet.  We had gunpowder for 500 years, repeating rifles and pistols for 150 years, and kids didn't start shooting up schools until forty years ago.  Can you explain what happened?  I'm not saying that video games are entirely responsible, because nothing happens in a vacuum, but to claim no effect is stupid. 

Finally, you're drawing a false parallel between guns and video games, here.  We all know the varied and sundry benefits of firearms ownership, so I doubt we need to re-hash them here.  Aside from "they're lots of fun", and understanding that I also enjoy video games, can you state a single tangible benefit offered by violent video games?   
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: DuckFat on December 13, 2012, 10:17:14 PM
Aside from "they're lots of fun", and understanding that I also enjoy video games, can you state a single tangible benefit offered by violent video games?   
Challenge accepted. Reaction time, hand-eye coordination, raised accuracy, etc.
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/02/070220012341.htm (http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/02/070220012341.htm)
I used this while arguing with my mom many years ago. I could also go into economic aspects, online socialization, and revenues donated to charities.
Can you say that there are no benefits?

As for desensitizing effects, troubled individuals do not need to be desensitized, they already are that way. Psychopaths and sociopaths don't function the way most of us do. They don't have emotions, feel no remorse, and perceive the world in a different way.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: GZire on December 14, 2012, 09:42:56 AM
....................You stated twice that video games aren't special, in the same post where you asserted that the industry is HUGE and overtaking Hollywood as the dominant media outlet.  We had gunpowder for 500 years, repeating rifles and pistols for 150 years, and kids didn't start shooting up schools until forty years ago.  Can you explain what happened?  I'm not saying that video games are entirely responsible, because nothing happens in a vacuum, but to claim no effect is stupid..................

Well let's see, for one the number of people going to school now.............compare that to 1940 to 1840 to 1740.  Kinda misleading about statistics.  You give me the raw data and I can present the data in a way to bolster my opinion.  Same thing goes for global warming...........yeah highest temps in recorded history...........oh noes.............but go back a couple of hundred years, thousands of years, etc and guess what you get global warming and cooling.  So the point..........beware of stats and who puts them out.

Now the shootings.......I think it's about accessibility, desensitization, and population.  Accessibility and the parent(s'), negligence in securing firearms.  Desensitization due to population growth.  You go to places with large populations and hold the door open for someone, you might be the only person.  Heck in Inglewood I held the door open for some people and got 0 acknowledgement I was there let alone a thank you.  I go to Hilo this week, 06:15AM standing in the bed of my truck and someone I don't even know tells me howzit.  I think the loss of community/commonality has a lot to do with it.  That and a lack of general parenting ability/care.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: xer 21 on December 14, 2012, 09:53:46 AM
First, the book was updated in 2009.  Hardly seems ignorant of the modern situation, does it? 

Those are exactly the type of people I was referring to, and the media in general is what Grossman credits, with special emphasis on video games.  However, if you're willing to admit that books, movies, etc, could contribute to desensitizing a person to violence, you're on the right track.  But you're wrong to say they're nothing special.  Video games are very special; they're the only form of media where YOU are the one pulling the trigger, vice reading/watching/listening to a story about someone else doing the deed. 

I reacted the same way that you did when I first read the book.  I started playing DOOM when I was about ten; my folks got me Duke Nukem 3D for Christmas when it came out, and I've been a steady consumer of every FPS that's come out since.  I love video games, and I turned out just fine.  I said, "Dave, you're a goddamn hippie."  But stop and think about it.  You have kids spending hours and hours in what amounts to a combat simulator; pretending that would have no effect whatsoever on a developing mind is pretty obtuse. 

You stated twice that video games aren't special, in the same post where you asserted that the industry is HUGE and overtaking Hollywood as the dominant media outlet.  We had gunpowder for 500 years, repeating rifles and pistols for 150 years, and kids didn't start shooting up schools until forty years ago.  Can you explain what happened?  I'm not saying that video games are entirely responsible, because nothing happens in a vacuum, but to claim no effect is stupid. 

Finally, you're drawing a false parallel between guns and video games, here.  We all know the varied and sundry benefits of firearms ownership, so I doubt we need to re-hash them here.  Aside from "they're lots of fun", and understanding that I also enjoy video games, can you state a single tangible benefit offered by violent video games?
does there need to be a tangible benefit?

you're getting very close to arguing for censorship.

let's just ban imagination too.  in my imagination, i can pull the trigger anytime.

video games are a drop in the bucket.  what changed is society as a whole, even before video games.environments kids grow up in today, even without video games, are radically different than they were 50 years ago.  the social norms and expectations, the stresses, and views held by their everyone else are all very different than they used to be. 

and kids started shooting up schools before video games.  there were a bunch of school shootings in the 80's.  unless you're going to suggest that Sonic and Super mario pushed those kids over the edge, the point just doesnt work.  the difference between now and then isnt more violent  video games.  its media coverage.

there were vastly more deaths in the 90's from school shootings compared to the 2000's.  there isnt a tangible link there. 
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: ren on December 14, 2012, 09:57:21 AM
We're losing what made us a great country. Strong values, a sense of nationalism, ethics...replaced by Ainokea and EBT
MY EBT (NOW ON iTUNES) - By @MrEBT & @CaptnHook_Maine (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o64Fz-KW1Dk#ws)

Chapter - It's Free Swipe Yo EBT (Explicit) (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NzspsovNvII#ws)
Title: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: Jl808 on December 14, 2012, 02:14:50 PM
Since we're on this subject, if I may I'd like to add another point of view.

I was big into gaming and it took a conscious and long effort for me to get rid of it as a hobby. I personally think gaming can quickly become a life stealer. A quote from one of my favorite books says "When I was a child, I spoke and thought and reasoned as a child. But when I grew up, I put away childish things. (1 Corinthians 13:11 NLT)". It wasn't until I decided to "grow up" (give up gaming completely) and focus more on life instead of games, did my perspective change.

Unfortunately, a lot of our boys and even men refuse to grow up and continue to act like children through adulthood.  I'm not necessarily saying anyone here specifically is childish since I don't know you guys that well, but the problem is that our society adult males do not grow up and continue to act like kids. Asking the government, the union or their employers to take care of them instead of taking personal responsibility for their lives and for their spouses and children's needs.

In my opinion, this is the root of the problems we are having with the males in our society.  Males are disenfranchised and are distracted by entertainment instead of being adults and being a more responsible person in our community.  How many single moms do we have now in our society?  Where are the guys when the mother of their child and their children need a man in the house?

It's sad. We don't allow folks to teach the bible in school and yet we let the kids read about vampires and witchcraft in school. Harry potter?  Twilight?   They spend all day playing computer games and modeling socially inappropriate behavior that they see on tv.  This morally relativistic societal worldview just isn't bringing us to a better place.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: new guy on December 14, 2012, 03:17:00 PM
.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: xer 21 on December 14, 2012, 04:11:12 PM
Agree that some troubled individuals may already be desensitized, but some troubled individuals may not already be desensitized, right?

Agree that true psychopaths and sociopaths may not function the way most of society does and true psychopaths and sociopaths may have different emotions or inhibitions or perceptions, but not all troubled individuals are psychopaths or sociopaths, right?

and so what?  the solution is censorship on account of the few bad seeds?

why should i be punished because someone else is a psychopath?
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: new guy on December 14, 2012, 04:30:38 PM
.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: Bunker on December 14, 2012, 04:50:43 PM
When you can present your position calmly and rationally, and respectful of the fact that everyone is entitled to their own opinions, even though the opinions may be contrary to your own opinions, I think you stand the greatest chance of persuading someone to open their minds to your position.

The moment you start using blanket statements or words like "stupid" or "irrelevant" to support your position is the moment that your adversary stops listening to your argument and stops hearing the message you are trying to convey.

Just my 2 cents.

Sounds like 2 cents well spent! :thumbsup:
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: xer 21 on December 14, 2012, 04:53:20 PM
I'm talking about censorshbip because if people are going to suggest the video gvames aren't healthy, the next logical step in that thought train is censorship.  I've been seen this stuff being spouted off since columbine commentors blamed Doom and Marilyn Manson.  If you don't believe a form of media is healthy, there is really only one action that can do anything about it and that's some form of censorship.

If I seem defensive, its because this scapegoating sounds far too much like people blaming music, guns or anything else they thought was responsible for someone commiting a tragic crime.  Its bad enough that I have one hobby questioned, I don't need to come here where people know damn well how frustrating that feels and have another innocuous hobby of mine questioned too.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: new guy on December 14, 2012, 06:26:34 PM
.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: DuckFat on December 14, 2012, 06:58:27 PM
Agree that some troubled individuals may already be desensitized, but some troubled individuals may not already be desensitized, right?

Agree that true psychopaths and sociopaths may not function the way most of society does and true psychopaths and sociopaths may have different emotions or inhibitions or perceptions, but not all troubled individuals are psychopaths or sociopaths, right?
I think that depends on what your definition of troubled is. Anyone who would shoot up a mall/school/church/anywhere really should probably be described using a much harsher word, but I used troubled so that may be my error.

To be more clear, anyone would do something like this does not need to be desensitized. They already have the propensity to do so and just need the right trigger to set them off.

If so called desensitizing effects did produce such results then we should have a lot more shootings because millions of people share the same "desensitizing" stimuli.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: Cougar8045 on December 14, 2012, 07:29:52 PM
I'm talking about censorshbip because if people are going to suggest the video gvames aren't healthy, the next logical step in that thought train is censorship.  I've been seen this stuff being spouted off since columbine commentors blamed Doom and Marilyn Manson.  If you don't believe a form of media is healthy, there is really only one action that can do anything about it and that's some form of censorship.

If I seem defensive, its because this scapegoating sounds far too much like people blaming music, guns or anything else they thought was responsible for someone commiting a tragic crime.  Its bad enough that I have one hobby questioned, I don't need to come here where people know damn well how frustrating that feels and have another innocuous hobby of mine questioned too.
No, that's not the next logical step.  That's the end of the logical line, in fact.  I'm not saying that video games are 100% of the answer; a lot of the other things that have been mentioned certainly play a role.  Especially the post about extended childhood--the world is becoming a Never-Never Land where people have their parents to look after them in their childhood, and the benevolent government to look after them in adulthood. 

But getting back to the point, censorship of video games is, as I said, the complete end of the line rather than the next logical step.  We have lots of things that are bad for us, cigarettes, McDonald's, booze, you name it, and they're all completely legal.  However, there is a social stigma that would accompany a parent who fed their child McDonald's every single day.  No such stigma exists for a ten-year old who plays Grand Theft Auto or Modern Warfare for six hours a day.  That's perfectly normal parenting in these United States. 

No one is calling for censorship of your video games, but your strident protests in defense of same suggests that maybe you should get out more.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: xer 21 on December 14, 2012, 07:41:57 PM
but your strident protests in defense of same suggests that maybe you should get out more.
because that was necessary.

i just find the suggestion that a form of media can be responsible for something like this rather insulting.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: clshade on December 15, 2012, 12:52:43 PM
Not sure if anyone has seen this, yet.

Apparently CCW did play a role at the Clackamas shooting.

http://www.kgw.com/news/Clackamas-man-armed-confronts-mall-shooter-183593571.html (http://www.kgw.com/news/Clackamas-man-armed-confronts-mall-shooter-183593571.html)

I used to live across the street from that Mall.
Title: Re: 3 Dead in Oregon Mall Shooting
Post by: East Side Copper on December 15, 2012, 04:34:02 PM
http://easybakegunclub.com/news/1943/Clackamas-Mall-Shooter-Was-Confonted-By-Concealed-.html (http://easybakegunclub.com/news/1943/Clackamas-Mall-Shooter-Was-Confonted-By-Concealed-.html)


here is another story.... JOB well done SIR :thumbsup: