2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: macsak on December 12, 2023, 03:21:15 PM

Title: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: macsak on December 12, 2023, 03:21:15 PM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=afYgukF9kB8
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: oldfart on December 12, 2023, 05:20:54 PM
That's what they did here. Only HPD can certify the instructor.

So therefore, no certification=no instructor=no permit

But you guys knew that right?
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: macsak on December 12, 2023, 05:30:23 PM
it's almost as if i posted it for a reason...

That's what they did here. Only HPD can certify the instructor.

So therefore, no certification=no instructor=no permit

But you guys knew that right?
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: oldfart on December 12, 2023, 06:17:47 PM
it's almost as if i posted it for a reason...
....
You would be surprised how oblivious people are.
Better to over-explain than assume that everyone gets the message.
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: QUIETShooter on December 12, 2023, 06:35:56 PM
Everything is so cryptic here. 

I'm still walking around here with a flashlight. :wave:
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: oldfart on December 12, 2023, 06:48:59 PM
Everything is so cryptic here. 

I'm still walking around here with a flashlight. :wave:
....
I don't know a lot of the slang and acronyms used by kids nowadays.
It's not effective communications.

Use your words.
Say what you mean and mean what you say..
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 12, 2023, 06:52:58 PM
....
I don't know a lot of the slang and acronyms used by kids nowadays.
It's not effective communications.

Use your words.
Say what you mean and mean what you say..

You are talking about the nonsensical ravings of a lunatic mind!
-- Dr. Frederick Frankenstein
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: macsak on December 12, 2023, 06:58:19 PM
fleshlight

Everything is so cryptic here. 

I'm still walking around here with a flashlight. :wave:
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: macsak on December 12, 2023, 06:58:44 PM
heads

....
I don't know a lot of the slang and acronyms used by kids nowadays.
It's not effective communications.

Use your words.
Say what you mean and mean what you say..
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: oldfart on December 17, 2023, 07:07:28 AM
Emergency regulations on concealed weapons instructors recently proposed by the California Department of Justice caused pushback from some law enforcement agencies.
-----------
Warning! Slippery ground ahead!
This kind of legislation should set off all kinds of alarms.
What would be the next instructor to be de-certified?
History teachers? Social studies teachers? They might teach old fashioned traditional things like civil rights.
Maybe metal shop teachers since they could teach people how to make a sharp tool that might hurt someone.

Even cops realize this is not a good idea.
=============
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/proposed-emergency-gun-regulations-on-ccw-instructors-in-california-draws-pushback-from-sheriff-s-association/ar-AA1lBTzt?ocid=socialshare&pc=LCTS&cvid=eb537f06974e4e25b43b8415fe68a6ab&ei=18
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: QUIETShooter on December 17, 2023, 07:20:54 AM
....
I don't know a lot of the slang and acronyms used by kids nowadays.
It's not effective communications.

Use your words.
Say what you mean and mean what you say..

I dunno how many times I had to google to find out what is being said around here..... :rofl:

I mean, how many micro-seconds does one save by typing WTF instead of WHAT THE F*CK.
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: QUIETShooter on December 17, 2023, 07:23:16 AM
Emergency regulations on concealed weapons instructors recently proposed by the California Department of Justice caused pushback from some law enforcement agencies.
-----------
Warning! Slippery ground ahead!
This kind of legislation should set off all kinds of alarms.
What would be the next instructor to be de-certified?
History teachers? Social studies teachers? They might teach old fashioned traditional things like civil rights.
Maybe metal shop teachers since they could teach people how to make a sharp tool that might hurt someone.

Even cops realize this is not a good idea.
=============
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/proposed-emergency-gun-regulations-on-ccw-instructors-in-california-draws-pushback-from-sheriff-s-association/ar-AA1lBTzt?ocid=socialshare&pc=LCTS&cvid=eb537f06974e4e25b43b8415fe68a6ab&ei=18

This seems to be what Hawaii is going to do.  Minus the pushback from law enforcement. ::) ::)
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: astroboy on December 17, 2023, 09:20:46 AM
I heard that the HPD fire arms instructors were trained by the NRA around a year ago.
Can anyone verify this?
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: groveler on December 17, 2023, 11:43:25 AM
Everything is so cryptic here. 

I'm still walking around here with a flashlight. :wave:
"I'm still walking around here with a flashlight"
So you are our Hawaii version of Diogenes?
Good for you!
But I suspect you won't discover too many rational people in this state outside
websites like this one.
Most all have left or given up on the politics here.
 :wave:
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: oldfart on December 17, 2023, 11:47:29 AM
I heard that the HPD fire arms instructors were trained by the NRA around a year ago.
Can anyone verify this?
=========
Just a guess here...
I think every firearms instructor in America has had training from the NRA in some way, shape or form.

The thought of somebody in the police dept dictating that they are the sole certifiers of firearms instruction is just arrogant and insulting.
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: QUIETShooter on December 17, 2023, 12:19:15 PM
Why would a police department feel they are the ones that need to "certify" firearm instructors?

Are they looking for instructors willing to rat out their students?

Because what is the difference between an NRA certified Firearms Instructor and an NRA Certified Firearms Instructor "certified" by a police department?

Inquiring minds want to know.
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: oldfart on December 17, 2023, 03:15:43 PM
Why would a police department feel they are the ones that need to "certify" firearm instructors?

Are they looking for instructors willing to rat out their students?

Because what is the difference between an NRA certified Firearms Instructor and an NRA Certified Firearms Instructor "certified" by a police department?

Inquiring minds want to know.
================
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe that the PD wanted to require firearms instructors to include a portion of their class dedicated to mental health education or something like that.
The theory being that since many firearm deaths are the result of suicide or mental health problems then the instructors will somehow magically persuade a crazy person not to shoot himself (or herself) or anybody else.

ie. the PD wants firearm instructors to be mind readers or at the very least, psychology instructors.
The PD is asking firearms instructors to teach a subject they are not qualified to teach.

An analogy would be to ask your high school drivers-ed teacher to also teach students how to drive an 18 wheel semi or perhaps fly a cessna.

Does that sound about right?
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: zippz on December 17, 2023, 03:54:40 PM
I heard that the HPD fire arms instructors were trained by the NRA around a year ago.
Can anyone verify this?

NRA has a Law Enforcement tract for firearms training and instructors.  Their LE instructor course I believe is a week long while the civilian version is 1 or 2 days.  Most police departments, along with HPD, use this training.

https://le.nra.org/
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 17, 2023, 08:11:37 PM
================
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe that the PD wanted to require firearms instructors to include a portion of their class dedicated to mental health education or something like that.
The theory being that since many firearm deaths are the result of suicide or mental health problems then the instructors will somehow magically persuade a crazy person not to shoot himself (or herself) or anybody else.

ie. the PD wants firearm instructors to be mind readers or at the very least, psychology instructors.
The PD is asking firearms instructors to teach a subject they are not qualified to teach.

An analogy would be to ask your high school drivers-ed teacher to also teach students how to drive an 18 wheel semi or perhaps fly a cessna.

Does that sound about right?
Hifico told them this that it opens the instructor to liability for teaching mental health stuff. As usual, they dont care and probably welcome it.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 17, 2023, 11:14:46 PM
That's what they did here. Only HPD can certify the instructor.

So therefore, no certification=no instructor=no permit

But you guys knew that right?

Have they denied any instructors without good cause?
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 18, 2023, 12:00:01 AM
================
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe that the PD wanted to require firearms instructors to include a portion of their class dedicated to mental health education or something like that.
The theory being that since many firearm deaths are the result of suicide or mental health problems then the instructors will somehow magically persuade a crazy person not to shoot himself (or herself) or anybody else.

ie. the PD wants firearm instructors to be mind readers or at the very least, psychology instructors.
The PD is asking firearms instructors to teach a subject they are not qualified to teach.

An analogy would be to ask your high school drivers-ed teacher to also teach students how to drive an 18 wheel semi or perhaps fly a cessna.

Does that sound about right?

It might not be some in depth training. If it were something as simple as handing out a suicide prevention help phone number then it could be a very reasonable requirement.
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: macsak on December 18, 2023, 04:14:46 AM
focus
they don't even have a system in place
nor have they had a public meeting to discuss said system

oh, and the counties ignored this until hifico told them...

Have they denied any instructors without good cause?
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: QUIETShooter on December 18, 2023, 07:46:24 AM
So......just like the sillouette situation at KokoHead.......


Limbo........


Juuuussst the way they like it. :wave:
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 18, 2023, 08:58:57 AM
It might not be some in depth training. If it were something as simple as handing out a suicide prevention help phone number then it could be a very reasonable requirement.

So would it be OK to have a non mental health professional discuss a required mental health issue in order to buy a handgun.  Then get sued if something with regards to that happens?

This requirement, although simple opens the door to a lawsuit.  Remember, anyone can sue for any reason, but it doesn't mean they can win in court. But defense of a BS lawsuit also cost money and stress.  So now an instructor is open for this.

Do you feel it's constitutional for the state/chief to require this? Your statement said "it could be a very reasonable requirement", which is not a stance on the issue.
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 18, 2023, 10:01:51 AM
It might not be some in depth training. If it were something as simple as handing out a suicide prevention help phone number then it could be a very reasonable requirement.

Handing out a phone number that is completely obtainable on the Internet is not "training."  I highly doubt that's what the law  intended, or else that's what it would say.  Something that simple and easy would be literally included in the statute.

Do you think, even in your plebeian example, instructors won't say something like, "If you or someone you know is feeling suicidal, call this number?"

That alone would constitute giving mental health advice.

Must be nice to live in your little world of make believe.
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 18, 2023, 10:08:26 AM
Handing out a phone number that is completely obtainable on the Internet is not "training."  I highly doubt that's what the law  intended, or else that's what it would say.  Something that simple and easy would be literally included in the statute.

Do you think, even in your plebeian example, instructors won't say something like, "If you or someone you know is feeling suicidal, call this number?"

That alone would constitute giving mental health advice.

Must be nice to live in your little world of make believe.

What is a good thing, if you want to call it that is that the law doesn't state how long or how to give this mental health professional advice.  Just that you gotta teach about the issues (exclude the option to bring in a professional).  But at the same time, for the CCW approval, the instructors have to submit their power point or like slides and course curriculum and their credentials to teach such things.  As well as the written test and answer key.  So why would HPD need this unless they are making the determination of what's good enough to teach.  So I highly doubt that HPD would allow an instructor to just pass out a phone number for the suicide, domestic violence and like hotlines.  But we will see what happens.


*Added info

For the use of force required teaching, some instructors  used their Masaad Ayoob (MAS40) instructor training class.  This was a 40hr course. Which means they had to take off and also fly to another state and book a hotel room. I'm not sure what other CCW instructors used for credentials. But for the mental health stuff, would this mean a similar type of instructor training would have to be done?
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 19, 2023, 09:25:37 PM
So would it be OK to have a non mental health professional discuss a required mental health issue in order to buy a handgun.  Then get sued if something with regards to that happens?

This requirement, although simple opens the door to a lawsuit.  Remember, anyone can sue for any reason, but it doesn't mean they can win in court. But defense of a BS lawsuit also cost money and stress.  So now an instructor is open for this.

Do you feel it's constitutional for the state/chief to require this? Your statement said "it could be a very reasonable requirement", which is not a stance on the issue.

I don't think you would be open to significant liability for passing out a flyer with a phone number. Depending on the extent that is required that could be an avenue for lawsuits. 

As for my personal opinion on the chief's rules, I have serious problems with anytime an administrative agency gets to do what should be the job of lawmakers. Punishments and significant regulations should not be made up by departments but by lawmakers.

There is a strong case to make that this is unconstitutional. The name escapes me but there is, I believe, a case going through the SCOTUS right now that touches on this very issue. Not about guns but something more like the EPA making up rules that have the power of law despite that they are not a legislative body. If they decide that administrative agencies cannot essentially make law that could go to making much of the Rules of the Chief unconstitutional. Crossing my fingers!
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 19, 2023, 09:29:00 PM
  So I highly doubt that HPD would allow an instructor to just pass out a phone number for the suicide, domestic violence and like hotlines.  But we will see what happens.

I am not holding my breath either.

Quote
For the use of force required teaching, some instructors  used their Masaad Ayoob (MAS40) instructor training class.  This was a 40hr course. Which means they had to take off and also fly to another state and book a hotel room. I'm not sure what other CCW instructors used for credentials. But for the mental health stuff, would this mean a similar type of instructor training would have to be done?

I suspect what many firearms instructors would do is farm out the portion of the class to someone licensed/certified to teach on the subject. Unless one is teaching many classes it probably wouldn't make sense to get such an additional certification, depending on how strenuous the requirement of course.
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: oldfart on December 20, 2023, 12:29:24 AM
I am not holding my breath either.

I suspect what many firearms instructors would do is farm out the portion of the class to someone licensed/certified to teach on the subject. Unless one is teaching many classes it probably wouldn't make sense to get such an additional certification, depending on how strenuous the requirement of course.
===========
Let's not mince words here.
The actual intent of these rules is to make it as hard as possible for people to get ANY kind of firearm permit.
Therefore, the vaguer the rule is written, the easier it is to interpret it ANY WAY they want.

I would like to know what genius wrote this ill-conceived proposal before they figured out how it is supposed to be applied.
Furthermore, I would like to know if the person who WROTE these rules has any of the qualifications spelled out in these rules.
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: QUIETShooter on December 20, 2023, 06:33:30 AM
This is just me but I believe the Counties and the State are using delay and deny tactics.
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: oldfart on December 20, 2023, 07:37:48 AM
This is just me but I believe the Counties and the State are using delay and deny tactics.
...
I think that is pretty obvious.
When this whole ccw business started, I had this mental image of Josh green and the police chief running around like ants that just got sprayed.
Problem is they formed a new line of ants and they are looking to crawl up your leg and start biting.
Their strategy is similar to the way ants attack.
Ants quietly crawl up your leg but don't bite until there are a lot of them.
Then they are given a signal and bite all at once. In this way, the animal is overwhelmed with poison.

These legislative rules are similar to ants. The rules have a start date which is the signal to attack.
But now we know they are crawling up your leg so we have to swat them.
Our problem is that ants regroup and form a new line.
The way to get rid of ants is to get rid of the nest.
My house has a lot of ants. I tried spraying and poison bait with only moderate success.
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 20, 2023, 07:47:46 AM
I don't think you would be open to significant liability for passing out a flyer with a phone number. Depending on the extent that is required that could be an avenue for lawsuits. 



Wrong.
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 20, 2023, 07:48:47 AM

I suspect what many firearms instructors would do is farm out the portion of the class to someone licensed/certified to teach on the subject. Unless one is teaching many classes it probably wouldn't make sense to get such an additional certification, depending on how strenuous the requirement of course.

This would mean an additional cost to the already say $200 class, $150 no refund CCW applicaiton, $50 range expenses, etc...
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 20, 2023, 07:50:17 AM
===========
Let's not mince words here.
The actual intent of these rules is to make it as hard as possible for people to get ANY kind of firearm permit.
Therefore, the vaguer the rule is written, the easier it is to interpret it ANY WAY they want.

I would like to know what genius wrote this ill-conceived proposal before they figured out how it is supposed to be applied.
Furthermore, I would like to know if the person who WROTE these rules has any of the qualifications spelled out in these rules.

A right delayed is a right denied, thus unconstitutional.
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 20, 2023, 10:53:10 PM
Wrong.

 ::)
Title: Re: California Trying To Use Mandatory Firearm Training To Violate 2A Rights
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 20, 2023, 10:53:40 PM
This would mean an additional cost to the already say $200 class, $150 no refund CCW applicaiton, $50 range expenses, etc...

Indeed.