2aHawaii
General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: ren on February 05, 2024, 09:36:51 PM
-
https://www.khon2.com/local-news/should-foreigners-be-banned-from-purchasing-land-in-hawaii/
The AG said they have grave concerns regarding the constitutionality and legality of the bill and that as written, it could subject the State to litigation and substantial monetary liability.
Real Estate developer, Peter Savio, supports the bill. He said it does not matter if it’s unconstitutional.
“The issue is, it’s identifying the problem. It’s forcing people to face what they’ve wanted to deny for the last 60 years, that it’s outside demand that’s destroying Hawaii, and we have to control it,” Savio said.
If the bill is passed, it would also require any foreign entity or foreign person that owns land to register.
Awa said it’s about standing up for the people and future of Hawaii.
“So argue the unconstitutionality all you want, this is the right thing to do,” Awa stated.
Now we know why they continue to stomp on our rights
-
The AG has zeroncredibility about whats constitutional.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
Interesting.
Why would it be unconstitutional though? Foreigners are prohibited from doing certain other constitutionally protected activities, I cannot think what would be unconstitutional about this law off the top of my head.
-
https://www.khon2.com/local-news/should-foreigners-be-banned-from-purchasing-land-in-hawaii/
The AG said they have grave concerns regarding the constitutionality and legality of the bill and that as written, it could subject the State to litigation and substantial monetary liability.
Real Estate developer, Peter Savio, supports the bill. He said it does not matter if it’s unconstitutional.
“The issue is, it’s identifying the problem. It’s forcing people to face what they’ve wanted to deny for the last 60 years, that it’s outside demand that’s destroying Hawaii, and we have to control it,” Savio said.
If the bill is passed, it would also require any foreign entity or foreign person that owns land to register.
Awa said it’s about standing up for the people and future of Hawaii.
“So argue the unconstitutionality all you want, this is the right thing to do,” Awa stated.
Now we know why they continue to stomp on our rights
What is unconstitutional about preventing non-US citizens from buying homes and land in the U.S., exactly?
-
What is unconstitutional about preventing non-US citizens from buying homes and land in the U.S., exactly?
The Equal Protection Clause is part of the first section of the Fourteenth Amendment
to the United States Constitution. The clause, which took effect in 1868, provides "nor
shall any State ... deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws."
It mandates that individuals in similar situations be treated equally by the law
Jurisdiction is all that's required. There's no provision that the individual be a citizen, legal resident, etc.
-
Florida has had a similar law. since May and it hasn't been shot down yet.
https://www.cnn.com/2023/06/19/politics/chinese-land-purchases/index.html
-
Florida has had a similar law. since May and it hasn't been shot down yet.
https://www.cnn.com/2023/06/19/politics/chinese-land-purchases/index.html
... yet.
-
Democrats pass laws even though they know the law is unconstitutional.
They also know it is expensive and takes forever to go through the courts.
I've always said you don't need an Army to conquer the USA since we will sell it to you.
Besides the Federal government unconstitutionally is the country's biggest landowner,
and nobody but me complains about that. As far as I'm concerned the Federal
government today is a Foreigner to America.
They are Dermocrats.
I'm an American.
>:D
-
Not the law that concerns me but the blatant disregard of the Constitution.
-
Awa is a solid 2A supporter. He sits on the committee that hears 2A bills in the senate (Rhodes committee) and votes no all the time against these bills.
The left in HI has shown it's disregard for peoples constitutional rights for decades. So why all the complaining now? I have yet to see the AG state a anti 2a bill is unconstitutional. But instead they say things like "we worked very hard to make sure Bruen is followed", such BS.
China has our government in their pocket and since 90% of our lawmakers vote to support anti 2a bills, they also better support this if it's solely about the constitution.
-
BTW, the bill is dead. It's deadline to schedule a hearing was on 2/5.
-
Awa is a solid 2A supporter. He sits on the committee that hears 2A bills in the senate (Rhodes committee) and votes no all the time against these bills.
The left in HI has shown it's disregard for peoples constitutional rights for decades. So why all the complaining now? I have yet to see the AG state a anti 2a bill is unconstitutional. But instead they say things like "we worked very hard to make sure Bruen is followed", such BS.
China has our government in their pocket and since 90% of our lawmakers vote to support anti 2a bills, they also better support this if it's solely about the constitution.
Again it's the blatant disregrad for the Constitution. Besides the issue is not with foreign investors in our housing market its our regulations and supply. We are on a rock. When I was in the market, I wasn't competing against foreign bidders but local buyers.
-
Again it's the blatant disregrad for the Constitution. Besides the issue is not with foreign investors in our housing market its our regulations and supply. We are on a rock. When I was in the market, I wasn't competing against foreign bidders but local buyers.
Depends on the area. I live in Kakaako and talk to the realtors in the area. Many of the Howard Hughes multi million condo units are unoccupied as the owners don't live in HI. Combo of mainland and foreign buyers. 1 guy who ran a gelato shop said the same thing because he thought his location would be busier with all the condo's, but nope, empty condo units.
So we need to go back and HH built the condo's with these types of non-residents in mind, as the average HI person cannot afford a $4 million condo. So if instead HH built a non-luxury condo, then more average people might be able to buy it. But then would HH even bother? The deal he made with the city to get approved for his million dollar condo's was he had to build Ke Kilohana for the people (affordable housing project). Have almost 400 units of all affordable and you get your permit to build all your other luxury condos. Ke Kilohana does have it's share of problems as HH went super cheap on this one and the states "affordable" program isn't. Anyone who qualified 8 years ago would be living paycheck to paycheck going "mortgage broke". And todays "affordable" program is even worst. At least back then, once you qualified, you were grandfathered in, even if you made more 5 years later when the building was finished. Today, you cannot make that much more, so the state changed it. Which means you have to turn down good promotions or careers in order to stay qualified (Kuilei Place is the most current one).
The reason why the property on Kapiolani and Atkinson is still stalled is because it's supposed to be a 400 unit condo with only 17 "affordable" units for the people. The city denied their building permit and said make more. So they increased to 40 units for the people. City said try again. So they went to 80 and the city still said no. Then they went to 100 something and still no. Apparently, .they never paid the right people.
So Flapp posted about the 14th, but how does it apply or even close to allowing foreign citizens to buy land? Or is there another federal code that prohibits this type of ban? I mean, foreign people cannot buy guns, so no 2a right. Are they subject to a fair and speedy trial (as in would they just get deported instead?). I'm sure they do have the 1A right, but how often does HPD check before arresting someone for exercising their 1A if they're foreign or not? Same with the 4th (search and seizure), etc...
This is 1 topic which I never looked into, so I honestly don't know. But what I do know is our government often violates the constitution annually, so what's 1 more time?
-
Buildings are more expensive to maintain than a house. Residents need an elevator, fire sprinklers, common areas such as stairways, lighting etc. Concrete isn't cheap nor is it "environmental". Making a bldg affordable is an oxymoron. In addition, the City Council could have denied all these zoning exemptions and changes. Taking steps back and looking at the entire picture we don't have a robust economy to support these housing prices with a reasonable lifestyle for the average middle class.
But it is no excuse for a person in office to make a statement like that. It deteriorates that person's trust. Peter Savio stated that "we" must control it. Who is "we"? Shall we have a commission that review each real estate transaction? Do we really think a realtor would turn away a foreign buyer with cash? They could have but apparently they didn't.
-
Buildings are more expensive to maintain than a house. Residents need an elevator, fire sprinklers, common areas such as stairways, lighting etc. Concrete isn't cheap nor is it "environmental". Making a bldg affordable is an oxymoron. In addition, the City Council could have denied all these zoning exemptions and changes. Taking steps back and looking at the entire picture we don't have a robust economy to support these housing prices with a reasonable lifestyle for the average middle class.
But it is no excuse for a person in office to make a statement like that. It deteriorates that person's trust. Peter Savio stated that "we" must control it. Who is "we"? Shall we have a commission that review each real estate transaction? Do we really think a realtor would turn away a foreign buyer with cash? They could have but apparently they didn't.
Can you elaborate more which part of the constitution is being violated? I am curious to know as based on the rights that I know about, I don't see that it does.
-
Can you elaborate more which part of the constitution is being violated? I am curious to know as based on the rights that I know about, I don't see that it does.
Don't derail the thread like your fishy friend.
I'm not addressing that at all, my point was a public servant stated that he doesn't care about the Constitution. Pro 2a or not I find that concerning.
OATH OF OFFICE
Section 4. All eligible public officers, before entering upon the duties of their respective offices, shall take and subscribe to the following oath or affirmation: "I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States, and the Constitution of the State of Hawaii, and that I will faithfully discharge my duties as ........................ to the best of my ability." As used in this section, "eligible public officers" means the governor, the lieutenant governor, the members of both houses of the legislature, the members of the board of education, the members of the national guard, State or county employees who possess police powers, district court judges, and all those whose appointment requires the consent of the senate. [Ren and am Const Con 1978 and election Nov 7, 1978; am SB 1440 (1992) and election Nov 3, 1992]
-
Don't derail the thread like your fishy friend.
I'm not addressing that at all, my point was a public servant stated that he doesn't care about the Constitution. Pro 2a or not I find that concerning.
OATH OF OFFICE
Section 4. All eligible public officers, before entering upon the duties of their respective offices, shall take and subscribe to the following oath or affirmation: "I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States, and the Constitution of the State of Hawaii, and that I will faithfully discharge my duties as ........................ to the best of my ability." As used in this section, "eligible public officers" means the governor, the lieutenant governor, the members of both houses of the legislature, the members of the board of education, the members of the national guard, State or county employees who possess police powers, district court judges, and all those whose appointment requires the consent of the senate. [Ren and am Const Con 1978 and election Nov 7, 1978; am SB 1440 (1992) and election Nov 3, 1992]
Is it derailing?
I'm asking what part of the constitution. With knowing what I know as of now, I think the AG is just stating it's "unconstitutional" to kill the bill. Unless someone here can show otherwise with more detail as I don't see how the 14th applies. The reason why I say the AG is full of it is because they have yet to use the word "unconstitutional" during any anti 2a bill. They do use the phrase "this is constitutional" or "this can with stand a constitutional test" and like phrases all the time for anti 2a bills.
I'm asking for your help or Flapps to elaborate more cause I don't understand.
BTW, I'm also against the government getting more involved with anything as I prefer a more libertarian approach. I'm just trying to understand why this bill is unconstitutional. I have yet to make an opinion for or against this bill until I understand if the AG has a good point as I don't trust them.
As for him stating he doesn't care about the constitution, I talked to him over the phone a few times last year and he said he does care about it. He also said phrases like "automatic no vote, it's unconstitutional" when I asked about certain 2a bills.
So I'm wondering if he was in the heat of the moment and using a word that the AG was throwing out there (constitution/unconstitutional). Then there's the say 1 thing like how Trump said "take the guns first, due process later", but action wise, nothing. So Awa made that statement, but if the bill is constitutional, then the statement is more moot. But if it isn't constitutional, then this could be 1 strike against Awa.
Since this is your thread, if you still feel this post is derailing, I won't ask for clarification again and just drop it. I will respect your thread as the OP.
-
Don't derail the thread like your fishy friend.
I'm not addressing that at all, my point was a public servant stated that he doesn't care about the constitution. Pro 2a or not I find that concerning.
OATH OF OFFICE
Section 4. All eligible public officers, before entering upon the duties of their respective offices, shall take and subscribe to the following oath or affirmation: "I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States, and the Constitution of the State of Hawaii, and that I will faithfully discharge my duties as ........................ to the best of my ability." As used in this section, "eligible public officers" means the governor, the lieutenant governor, the members of both houses of the legislature, the members of the board of education, the members of the national guard, State or county employees who possess police powers, district court judges, and all those whose appointment requires the consent of the senate. [Ren and am Const Con 1978 and election Nov 7, 1978; am SB 1440 (1992) and election Nov 3, 1992]
not taking their oath of office seriously makes them madahfackahs in my mind. :grrr:
-
Testimony from the AG
"The Department has grave concerns regarding the constitutionality and legality of
this bill and the potential for this bill, as written, to subject the State to litigation and to
cause the State to incur substantial monetary liability. Among other things, the
Department has concerns grounded in the Commerce Clause of article I, section 8,
clause 3, of the U.S. Constitution; the Equal Protection clauses of the Fourteenth
Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and article I, section 5, of the Hawaii Constitution;
the Takings clauses of the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and article I,
section 20, of the Hawaii Constitution; the Due Process clauses of the Fourteenth
Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and article I, section 5, of the Hawaii Constitution;
article I, section 2 of the Hawaii Constitution; and the federal Fair Housing Act. Many of
these provisions, among other things, would require the State to satisfy onerous meansends legal analyses in litigation and potentially require the State to pay fair market value
for the taking of property to an unknown number of individuals and entities."
Sounds more like they don't want to take the time to litigate any offenders. Again, anti 2a bills, are all constitutional according to the AG.
-
Not much testimony, but those with a financial interest opposed this bill, like the Hawaii Realtor Association and the Commercial Real Estate Development Association.
The HI realtors did mention this violates the Fair Housing Act, which one cannot discriminate based on national origin. FHA is not part of the constitution.
We apply similar things, when I was in banking, we were not allowed to do any business with Iran, Iraq, Cuba, and North Korea as a whole (people included) as it was on some federal law. We even had a sign we posted in the back about it. So how's this any different?
Again, based on very initial/limited research, it sounds like outside money is being used to kill this bill.
-
When I was still working my company was working on the housing projects in Kapolei. Single family homes.
I remember the developer rep telling me that 4 out of the 8 homes in a certain cul-de-sac were bought by the same person. These are new homes, mind you. Person bought 4. One time. :o
Person was from Hong Kong..........
-
When I was still working my company was working on the housing projects in Kapolei. Single family homes.
I remember the developer rep telling me that 4 out of the 8 homes in a certain cul-de-sac were bought by the same person. These are new homes, mind you. Person bought 4. One time. :o
Person was from Hong Kong..........
I met a client recently in Port Lock. All her surrounding neighbors are from China. She's Chinese too, but married to a local haole guy. She mentioned that she hasn't seen anyone in any of the homes in a while.
-
In hindsight why they decided to build affordable housing in the middle of Honolulu - prime real estate - was a dumb idea or a very veiled scheme to line pockets of politicians and others.
The State has lots of land in Barbers Point and laid there for years. The City also has a parcel in Kunia down the street from my home.
-
In hindsight why they decided to build affordable housing in the middle of Honolulu - prime real estate - was a dumb idea or a very veiled scheme to line pockets of politicians and others.
The State has lots of land in Barbers Point and laid there for years. The City also has a parcel in Kunia down the street from my home.
I'm a townie. Lived in Moiliili, Kapahulu, and Kakaako. Very close to places to eat, work, gym, shop, etc...So if there was an affordable housing at BP or Kunia, we would not have bought it. I get irraz sitting in traffic, so to do this daily would not be a good thing (daily morning and after work traffic). We sacrifice square footage for convenience. Plus with a baby, being close to grandparents home is a huge deal. Both are within a 10 min drive.
Our family had a home in Ewa we were going to buy when they were just developing it. My parents cancelled and lost their $5K deposit cause traffic sucked and since I was almost done with high school, it didn't make sense to transfer to Ewa side high school. Our good friend who lived across the street moved there as well. But still went to my high school in town. His family moved back about 5 months later cause he was always late for school and both his parents still worked in town. Luckily, they didn't sell there old place, but instead had his grandparents move in. So they ended up switching, he and his parents moved back to town and grandparents to the Ewa house.
-
You can afford living in town but the State and City can't advertise "affordable" at a Lamborghini dealership. Land is pricier around Honolulu - why? as you stated - convenience. Now if you want affordable there has to be tradeoffs. You want a Bugatti but don't want to pay for it? There's a Kia dealership by the airport.
-
(https://imgs.search.brave.com/7DjqKQcsEm8tm17UkpjmfMffWm-hLEcCDYSPUNhUqsA/rs:fit:860:0:0/g:ce/aHR0cHM6Ly9tZWRp/YTEudGVub3IuY29t/L20vVEhmNmdXU00w/WGdBQUFBQy9sZXQt/dGhlbS1lYXQtY2Fr/ZS1jYWtlLmdpZg.gif)
-
Jurisdiction is all that's required. There's no provision that the individual be a citizen, legal resident, etc.
The constitution doesn't say one has to be a citizen to vote either.
A very strict interpretation of the 14th amendment would re-write a number of laws and case law on what non-citizens would be allowed to do, especially 1st amendment rights (off the top of my head)
-
Don't derail the thread like your fishy friend.
I'm not addressing that at all, my point was a public servant stated that he doesn't care about the Constitution. Pro 2a or not I find that concerning.
OATH OF OFFICE
Section 4. All eligible public officers, before entering upon the duties of their respective offices, shall take and subscribe to the following oath or affirmation: "I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States, and the Constitution of the State of Hawaii, and that I will faithfully discharge my duties as ........................ to the best of my ability." As used in this section, "eligible public officers" means the governor, the lieutenant governor, the members of both houses of the legislature, the members of the board of education, the members of the national guard, State or county employees who possess police powers, district court judges, and all those whose appointment requires the consent of the senate. [Ren and am Const Con 1978 and election Nov 7, 1978; am SB 1440 (1992) and election Nov 3, 1992]
According to the article Awa didn't say he didn't care about the constitution, the article said Real Estate developer Peter Savio made that comment
Awa stated “So argue the unconstitutionality all you want, this is the right thing to do,” Considering that it doesn't actually seem to be unconstitutional, from what I can find, it is a moot point. It would be like him saying he didn't care about the constitutional right to free dolphin rides.
-
Here is my thought.
If we had restrictions on outside investors, maybe my grand babies would still be here.
Maybe I could drive down the street and visit them.
Maybe I could pick them up after school and give them a hug and buy them ice cream.
But I can't do that now,
(https://i.postimg.cc/RhL2w7Bh/vegasbabies.jpg) (https://postimages.org/)
-
The constitution doesn't say one has to be a citizen to vote either.
A very strict interpretation of the 14th amendment would re-write a number of laws and case law on what non-citizens would be allowed to do, especially 1st amendment rights (off the top of my head)
Only someone who doesn't understand the US Constitution, Article I, Section 3, Clause 1, Article I, Section 4, Clause 1, the 15th Amendment, the 19th Amendment, the 24th Amendment, and the 26th Amendment.
In a nutshell, the federal government doesn't hold elections that involve the general population. That duty falls to the states. Only after the polls close and the votes tallied do the states actually vote in the electoral college. The Senate was an exception, where the state legislatures picked their members to be in the US Senate. The 17th Amendment changed that to a popular vote at the state level to match the House elections.
So, in a nutshell, the Constitution doesn't have to specify only citizens may vote, because the Constitution governs the feds. And since the Feds don't hold elections outside of the electoral college, your point is moot.
-
I'll be exercising my Constitutional right at the range this weekend if anyone wants to discuss about the sky being blue.
-
I'll be exercising my Constitutional right at the range this weekend if anyone wants to discuss about the sky being blue.
You're exercising your constitutional privilege. FIFY
-
no to foreign real estate buyers but yes to illegal immigrants
https://mchb.tvisdata.hrsa.gov/Narratives/Overview/a0ac94c0-8538-417e-85c9-da6ac5c06603#:~:text=According%20to%20the%202018%205,majority%20are%20from%20the%20Philippines.
no make sense
-
no to foreign real estate buyers but yes to illegal immigrants
https://mchb.tvisdata.hrsa.gov/Narratives/Overview/a0ac94c0-8538-417e-85c9-da6ac5c06603#:~:text=According%20to%20the%202018%205,majority%20are%20from%20the%20Philippines.
no make sense
Real Estate is an investment scam that’s also used by hostile foreign powers for money laundering and infiltration/subversion
Eventually there will be a devastating crash back to reality wiping out vast amounts of imaginary wealth, but in the meantime at least we can stop speculators and criminal organizations from making the inflation worse.
-
The hearing is rescheduled to later.
-
Here is my thought.
If we had restrictions on outside investors, maybe my grand babies would still be here.
Maybe I could drive down the street and visit them.
Maybe I could pick them up after school and give them a hug and buy them ice cream.
But I can't do that now,
(https://i.postimg.cc/RhL2w7Bh/vegasbabies.jpg) (https://postimages.org/)
This is 1 major reason why we haven't left yet. I want grandparents to spend lots of time with grandchild. My friend in Vegas has 2 kids and her parents lives in Vegas too. The way the 2 kids interact with grandma/grandpa is your normal fun and laughter. WHen they come back to HI and interact with the husbands mom (grandma), it's like she's a total stranger. Zero interaction, laughter, smiling. More like being next to a stranger.
-
This is 1 major reason why we haven't left yet. I want grandparents to spend lots of time with grandchild. My friend in Vegas has 2 kids and her parents lives in Vegas too. The way the 2 kids interact with grandma/grandpa is your normal fun and laughter. WHen they come back to HI and interact with the husbands mom (grandma), it's like she's a total stranger. Zero interaction, laughter, smiling. More like being next to a stranger.
Proximity isn't the main factor.
I lived in the same house with my mother's mom and dad (actually her step-dad). There was very little laughter and fun between us 3 kids and the grandparents. Only my mother took the time to do those things -- playing board games, taking us places, teaching us things, etc. My grandmother was a different person when we traveled, I guess because she was not working 2 jobs and worrying about all the bills. My grandfather basically terrified me. I can't remember him ever having a conversation with me.
So, while presence is important, the real key is whether the adults make the effort to be part of the kids' lives. Many parents who deploy for military duty use daily Skype/Facetime sessions to be with their kids. If you make the effort, it means more than just being in the same room.
-
Only someone who doesn't understand the US Constitution, Article I, Section 3, Clause 1, Article I, Section 4, Clause 1, the 15th Amendment, the 19th Amendment, the 24th Amendment, and the 26th Amendment.
In a nutshell, the federal government doesn't hold elections that involve the general population. That duty falls to the states. Only after the polls close and the votes tallied do the states actually vote in the electoral college. The Senate was an exception, where the state legislatures picked their members to be in the US Senate. The 17th Amendment changed that to a popular vote at the state level to match the House elections.
So, in a nutshell, the Constitution doesn't have to specify only citizens may vote, because the Constitution governs the feds. And since the Feds don't hold elections outside of the electoral college, your point is moot.
So you are saying that a state could allow non-citizens to vote and that would be okay since the constitution governs the feds? Mull that over a bit first, it is a rhetorical question.
The point isn't moot because voting isn't the only issue that arises if you claim that the 14th amendment covers citizens and non-citizens equally. Constitutional rights don't even cover all citizens equally (Children for example)
-
So you are saying that a state could allow non-citizens to vote and that would be okay since the constitution governs the feds? Mull that over a bit first, it is a rhetorical question.
The point isn't moot because voting isn't the only issue that arises if you claim that the 14th amendment covers citizens and non-citizens equally. Constitutional rights don't even cover all citizens equally (Children for example)
Non citizens can buy and own guns in HI.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
Proximity isn't the main factor.
I lived in the same house with my mother's mom and dad (actually her step-dad). There was very little laughter and fun between us 3 kids and the grandparents. Only my mother took the time to do those things -- playing board games, taking us places, teaching us things, etc. My grandmother was a different person when we traveled, I guess because she was not working 2 jobs and worrying about all the bills. My grandfather basically terrified me. I can't remember him ever having a conversation with me.
So, while presence is important, the real key is whether the adults make the effort to be part of the kids' lives. Many parents who deploy for military duty use daily Skype/Facetime sessions to be with their kids. If you make the effort, it means more than just being in the same room.
So he just explained why he made an effort to stay in Hawai'i and you felt it necessary to tell him "this was my experience... Let me tell you how you should live your life based on my opinion."
Mac, how did you ever talk me into coming back to this retarded forum.
-
So he just explained why he made an effort to stay in Hawai'i and you felt it necessary to tell him "this was my experience... Let me tell you how you should live your life based on my opinion."
Mac, how did you ever talk me into coming back to this retarded forum.
please show me where i talked you into coming back to this retarded forum...
-
Mac, how did you ever talk me into coming back to this retarded forum.
There are some conversations worth paying attention to while others are better to skip. Don't OCD read everything or you will go insane.
-
So he just explained why he made an effort to stay in Hawai'i and you felt it necessary to tell him "this was my experience... Let me tell you how you should live your life based on my opinion."
Mac, how did you ever talk me into coming back to this retarded forum.
I never tried to tell anyone how to do anything, much less live their life.
I made a point I thought was relevant. The point (as you seem to have missed it) is:
In today's world of technology, it's not necessary to live down the street from someone
to remain in touch and part of their lives. Nor does living down the street automatically
mean you'll be part of anyone's lives if you don't make the effort. It's a choice more than
uncontrollable circumstances.
Sorry you don't like me, but at least try to argue over what I actually said, not what you think I meant.
You know how choices work, since you made the choice to come back here. Mac didn't make you do anything.
-
Mac, how did you ever talk me into coming back to this retarded forum.
The forum subculture is the problem. Just ignore all the people who lean into it. Then it becomes way less retarded. I admit most of the time its more effort than this forum is worth, so if you choose to leave I dont blame you.
-
The forum subculture is the problem. Just ignore all the people who lean into it. Then it becomes way less retarded. I admit most of the time its more effort than this forum is worth, so if you choose to leave I dont blame you.
I'd be very interested in what "subculture" I was leaning into.
I was referencing a personal observation, but that's more anecdotal than typifying what I know from experience as common to any group or subgroup.
If you're referring to the fact I've only lived in Hawaii for more than 30 years -- almost half my life, and more than half my adult life -- I'd be interested to hear how you view that.
Your comment has me intrigued, and I'd like to understand it more.
-
So he just explained why he made an effort to stay in Hawai'i and you felt it necessary to tell him "this was my experience... Let me tell you how you should live your life based on my opinion."
Mac, how did you ever talk me into coming back to this retarded forum.
There is nothing wrong with telling someone what their personal XP was. Now if we were debating something of fact, like 1+1=2 and he says other wise, then that would be a different issue.
Many things on this forum are posted about ones experience. And there are other things based on logic and facts. The key is to know when to use which one.
-
There is nothing wrong with telling someone what their personal XP was. Now if we were debating something of fact, like 1+1=2 and he says other wise, then that would be a different issue.
Many things on this forum are posted about ones experience. And there are other things based on logic and facts. The key is to know when to use which one.
Don't bother trying to reason with him. He's still harboring some kind of weird animosity toward me even though I've bent over backward to be kind to him.
I chalked it up to a personality conflict rather than him hating my Haole heritage, but I could be wrong.
I didn't want to derail the thread rehashing his previous interactions, so I'll leave it at that.
Some people just want to argue for no reason.
-
Non citizens can buy and own guns in HI.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
Non-citizens don't have full 1st amendment rights. I am trying to remember if there are any other good examples but this is the one that I know off the top of my head.
-
Non-citizens don't have full 1st amendment rights. I am trying to remember if there are any other good examples but this is the one that I know off the top of my head.
Can you find a source for that? Because I think it's wrong.
https://www.maniatislawoffice.com/blog/2018/08/do-non-citizens-have-constitutional-rights/
-
Can you find a source for that? Because I think it's wrong.
https://www.maniatislawoffice.com/blog/2018/08/do-non-citizens-have-constitutional-rights/
The specific example I remember learning about was related to political campaign activities. Here is one breakdown though the law doesn't apply to green card holders. It prohibits giving money or anything of value to a political campaign or political party. (Political contributions fall under first amendment protections) It can also get complicated because of how something of value could be interpreted, if I remember the example correctly someone could pick up and hand out political flyers but not print them.
https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/dos-and-don-ts-for-foreign-nationals-53370/
I also did see mention by politicians that foreign students here on visas who voiced support for Hamas (following Oct 7) could have their visas revoked and deported. I have to dig further into that story to see the legal reasoning behind that and how it wouldn't trample on free speech.
-
The specific example I remember learning about was related to political campaign activities. Here is one breakdown though the law doesn't apply to green card holders. It prohibits giving money or anything of value to a political campaign or political party. (Political contributions fall under first amendment protections) It can also get complicated because of how something of value could be interpreted, if I remember the example correctly someone could pick up and hand out political flyers but not print them.
https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/dos-and-don-ts-for-foreign-nationals-53370/
I also did see mention by politicians that foreign students here on visas who voiced support for Hamas (following Oct 7) could have their visas revoked and deported. I have to dig further into that story to see the legal reasoning behind that and how it wouldn't trample on free speech.
You said "Non-citizens don't have full 1st amendment rights."
Green card holders who don't have dual citizenship in the US or who haven't been naturalized are still "non-citizens" and have full 1A rights.
-
You said "Non-citizens don't have full 1st amendment rights."
Green card holders who don't have dual citizenship in the US or who haven't been naturalized are still "non-citizens" and have full 1A rights.
Don't forget permament resident aliens.
-
Don't forget permament resident aliens.
Do permanent resident aliens not have a green card? i thought they were in the same category when it comes to this topic.
-
Do permanent resident aliens not have a green card? i thought they were in the same category when it comes to this topic.
Idk, went to school with a guy who said hes a PRA, but a year later he got his green card and was showing it off for a few days. He was super proud.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
You said "Non-citizens don't have full 1st amendment rights."
Green card holders who don't have dual citizenship in the US or who haven't been naturalized are still "non-citizens" and have full 1A rights.
Yup. Should have said some non-citizens don't have full 1st amendment rights.
-
Yup. Should have said some non-citizens don't have full 1st amendment rights.
partial? 9%? 50%
-
Yup. Should have said some non-citizens don't have full 1st amendment rights.
Even US citizens don't have "full" 1A rights. Look what HPD did during the Covid lockdowns.
-
The covid lockdowns shows what the future will be like.
Even US citizens don't have "full" 1A rights. Look what HPD did during the Covid lockdowns.
-
Quote from: changemyoil66 on February 12, 2024, 08:41:56 AM
Even US citizens don't have "full" 1A rights. Look what HPD did during the Covid lockdowns.
===============
Did I ever tell you folks about the ticket I got for walking my dawg at the park across the street from my house?
(https://i.postimg.cc/c4hQNbnw/PeeMail.jpg) (https://postimages.org/)
Not joking...I actually got a ticket for walking my dawg, about 50 yards from my house.
(https://i.postimg.cc/05LMhF4s/SMH.gif) (https://postimages.org/)
sorry, this just brought back some bad memories
:stopjack:
-
Quote from: changemyoil66 on February 12, 2024, 08:41:56 AM
Even US citizens don't have "full" 1A rights. Look what HPD did during the Covid lockdowns.
===============
Did I ever tell you folks about the ticket I got for walking my dawg at the park across the street from my house?
(https://i.postimg.cc/c4hQNbnw/PeeMail.jpg) (https://postimages.org/)
Not joking...I actually got a ticket for walking my dawg, about 50 yards from my house.
(https://i.postimg.cc/05LMhF4s/SMH.gif) (https://postimages.org/)
sorry, this just brought back some bad memories
:stopjack:
Next time your doggie makes #2, put the ticket underneath. Then mail to HPD saying payment has been submitted.