2aHawaii
General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: macsak on June 13, 2024, 07:28:51 PM
-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JixxGmp2yKw
-
This debate is a giant nothing burger. We are a democracy and a republic. It is a bunch of tribalism creating division for nothing
-
isn't it specified in the federalist papers?
or maybe you are just adding nuance...
This debate is a giant nothing burger. We are a democracy and a republic. It is a bunch of tribalism creating division for nothing
-
isn't it specified in the federalist papers?
or maybe you are just adding nuance...
We are a nation comprised of individual states. There's the representative republic that is the federal government, and there's the democracy of each state.
People seem to have a mental block when this question comes up. All it takes is a fundamental understanding of the electoral college to see how states democratically select their slate of electors, and how the number of electors per state depends on the size of each state's population.
Trying to boil the US down to a single political label doesn't work. You have to treat the states and the feds as two different animals.
-
isn't it specified in the federalist papers?
or maybe you are just adding nuance...
People are splitting hairs when they claim the USA isn't a democracy and there is no real benefit in doing so. What is the point in this? Trying to convince the soft heads that republicans are good and democrats are bad because democracy sounds like democrat?
I would argue that the most accurate phrase would be a constitutional democratic republic. Just saying a republic is insufficient, after all the USSR was a republic.
When you vote for a representative who then passes laws that is a democracy, more specifically a representative democracy. We have that, therefore saying we are not a democracy is wholly inaccurate.
-
Democracy is two wolves and a sheep deciding what's for dinner.
-
Democracy is two wolves and a sheep deciding what's for dinner.
Democracy is a synonym for "mob rule."
Since when does the majority ever vote themselves less power and the minority more of it?
-
so it's ok when you split hairs, but not ok when others do it?
right...
People are splitting hairs when they claim the USA isn't a democracy and there is no real benefit in doing so. What is the point in this? Trying to convince the soft heads that republicans are good and democrats are bad because democracy sounds like democrat?
I would argue that the most accurate phrase would be a constitutional democratic republic. Just saying a republic is insufficient, after all the USSR was a republic.
When you vote for a representative who then passes laws that is a democracy, more specifically a representative democracy. We have that, therefore saying we are not a democracy is wholly inaccurate.
-
I would argue that the most accurate phrase would be a constitutional democratic republic.
You left out "on paper, I would argue...". Since HI violates the constitution every year and so do other states.
-
so it's ok when you split hairs, but not ok when others do it?
right...
I am not splitting hairs, I am just explaining to address your question to me.
-
You left out "on paper, I would argue...". Since HI violates the constitution every year and so do other states.
Every state and the federal government have violated the constitution at some point. Thats often how case law is made an unenumerated rights are solidified. Violating the constitution doesn't inherently mean we aren't a constitutional form of government.
-
Every state and the federal government have violated the constitution at some point. Thats often how case law is made an unenumerated rights are solidified. Violating the constitution doesn't inherently mean we aren't a constitutional form of government.
Hi chooses to violate the constitution year after year. We aren't talking about 1 oopsie. I mean, it's not like reading what the 2A says is difficult. And with covid, the 1A. I remember a few years ago, there were 47 anti 2a bills and zero bills to keep career criminals behind bars longer.
So would it be OK in your opinion if peoples rights were taken away, as long as they one day, maybe 10 years later, get their day in court? What if HI chose to take all guns away. It's all G right, cause someone will challenge it in court.
The point is, that there should be no or minimal "case law" because peoples rights shouldn't be violated as often in HI. Because IDK if you are aware, but the deck is stacked against the people. It cost big $ to file lawsuits. And what's harder is to find an attorney willing to take on said lawsuit. The state knows this, which is why they push the anti 2a bills year after year. Then their trump card is just change the law, so they don't have to pay much in attorney's fees or damages. There is also zero legal consequences for politicians to take peoples rights away. If someone had $10,000,000 to challenge HI's gun laws, I'll bet most of them will be removed.
But maybe you don't care as much, as you're protected if anti 2a laws get passed. Like if they banned semi auto rifles and standard cap rilfe mags, you don't have to worry unless you quit your job. Sensitive places doesn't law doesn't apply to you. Baton law didn't apply to you because no one in your field was ever arrested for concealing a baton in HI.
-
This debate is a giant nothing burger. We are a democracy and a republic. It is a bunch of tribalism creating division for nothing
A democracy is a government governed by unlimited majority rule, aka mob rule. Officials are elected by the people and laws are created solely by those in power and without limits.
A Republic is a form of democracy that is limited in the types of laws that can be created by some sort of charter, most commonly a constitution, that protects the rights of the citizenry from infringement by both the government and mob rule.
The U.S. is a Constitutional republic that maintains democratic tendencies with regards to elections and the influence of some laws. The U.S. is not a democracy.
Isn't it ironic, then, that the greatest antagonists to our rights are the same ones who refer to our form of government as a democracy and never mention Republic or constitutional Republic? Wonder why that is.
-
^this
i cannot wait for EEF to add nuance...
A democracy is a government governed by unlimited majority rule, aka mob rule. Officials are elected by the people and laws are created solely by those in power and without limits.
A Republic is a form of democracy that is limited in the types of laws that can be created by some sort of charter, most commonly a constitution, that protects the rights of the citizenry from infringement by both the government and mob rule.
The U.S. is a Constitutional republic that maintains democratic tendencies with regards to elections and the influence of some laws. The U.S. is not a democracy.
Isn't it ironic, then, that the greatest antagonists to our rights are the same ones who refer to our form of government as a democracy and never mention Republic or constitutional Republic? Wonder why that is.
-
-
https://youtu.be/rPAmTpydQNY
-
A democracy is a government governed by unlimited majority rule, aka mob rule. Officials are elected by the people and laws are created solely by those in power and without limits.
A Republic is a form of democracy that is limited in the types of laws that can be created by some sort of charter, most commonly a constitution, that protects the rights of the citizenry from infringement by both the government and mob rule.
The U.S. is a Constitutional republic that maintains democratic tendencies with regards to elections and the influence of some laws. The U.S. is not a democracy.
Isn't it ironic, then, that the greatest antagonists to our rights are the same ones who refer to our form of government as a democracy and never mention Republic or constitutional Republic? Wonder why that is.
Great explanation. :thumbsup: I would have messed it up if I had to explain it.
The only explanation I can come up with for your last question in your post is because they are a mob.
And a mob rules.
-
I agree it is a nothing burger.
We are not a democracy we are a republic?
What is a republic?
A republic is a type of democracy.
What type of democracy?
A representative democracy.
What is a representative democracy?
A republic.
What does the GOP want?
A king.
Why do people trash democracy?
Because they want Trump to be king and for the United States to be more like Russia.
What
Reading this was like watching someone's brain fall out of their skull and go bouncing down the stairs
-
(http://cdn.newsapi.com.au/image/v1/66e8e228dc6457bcca4f7c8a945bed88)
-
please show me where in any of these videos or anywhere on this forum said that they want trump to be king...
I agree it is a nothing burger.
We are not a democracy we are a republic?
What is a republic?
A republic is a type of democracy.
What type of democracy?
A representative democracy.
What is a representative democracy?
A republic.
What does the GOP want?
A king.
Why do people trash democracy?
Because they want Trump to be king and for the United States to be more like Russia.
What
-
please show me where in any of these videos or anywhere on this forum said that they want the United States to be more like Russia...
I agree it is a nothing burger.
We are not a democracy we are a republic?
What is a republic?
A republic is a type of democracy.
What type of democracy?
A representative democracy.
What is a representative democracy?
A republic.
What does the GOP want?
A king.
Why do people trash democracy?
Because they want Trump to be king and for the United States to be more like Russia.
What
-
I agree it is a nothing burger.
We are not a democracy we are a republic?
What is a republic?
A republic is a type of democracy.
What type of democracy?
A representative democracy.
What is a representative democracy?
A republic.
What does the GOP want?
A king.
Why do people trash democracy?
Because they want Trump to be king and for the United States to be more like Russia.
What
That's ludicrous. it's the left pushing us into Socialism.
Get a grip on reality and hold on tight.
-
please show me where in any of these videos or anywhere on this forum said that they want trump to be king...
please show me where in any of these videos or anywhere on this forum said that they want the United States to be more like Russia...
still waiting...
It's the right pushing us to fascism. Just like the right wing sympathized with Nazis in favor of fascism against communism and Jewish people, today we have the right sympathizing with Russia, claiming to be fighting against socialism and non-white immigration while calling themselves patriots. The supporters of Hitler in the United States also claimed to be patriots as they plotted to overturn the government and establish Nazi government in the U.S. Trump supporters are following the same plan.
-
What does the GOP want?
A king.
Why do people trash democracy?
Because they want Trump to be king and for the United States to be more like Russia.
What
I don't think you know what a king is.
I don't think you know what Russia is like.
Once again, you're imagining things that aren't there.
-
It's the right pushing us to fascism. Just like the right wing sympathized with Nazis in favor of fascism against communism and Jewish people, today we have the right sympathizing with Russia, claiming to be fighting against socialism and non-white immigration while calling themselves patriots. The supporters of Hitler in the United States also claimed to be patriots as they plotted to overturn the government and establish Nazi government in the U.S. Trump supporters are following the same plan.
What many history books leave out is before the registration and rounding up of of jews, came a gun confiscation. Which party tries year after year to disarm law abiding Americans?
-
Trump has communicated this through his words and actions and since you support him above all others and without any criticism you must agree. Search the forums and you will find people posting things like "Trump Forever!" and more.
So Trump is born of some kind of royal blood? I think it is you who should search online what's a king.
-
More than that. Some think that Trump is their savior sent by God to protect them from the evil U.S. Government. They believe he is being persecuted like Jesus and he is sacrificing himself so the government doesn't come after them. Have you listened to a Trump speech?
So now you're saying some think he's a savior sent by god? Which is it, king or savior? BRB, President, General, Supreme Ruler Ala-Deen is arriving for comment.
Have YOU listened to Trumps speech, then thought with logic what's being done to him?
-
It's the right pushing us to fascism. Just like the right wing sympathized with Nazis in favor of fascism against communism and Jewish people, today we have the right sympathizing with Russia, claiming to be fighting against socialism and non-white immigration while calling themselves patriots. The supporters of Hitler in the United States also claimed to be patriots as they plotted to overturn the government and establish Nazi government in the U.S. Trump supporters are following the same plan.
I didn't realize I was standing in the FICTION section.
Makes sense now.
-
please show me where propaganda that was verified as coming direct from the GRU was posted here
and with proof of verification, not just "shows all the hallmarks of a russian disinformation campaign" like the 51 intelligence officers said about hunter's laptop...
Trump has communicated this through his words and actions and since you support him above all others and without any criticism you must agree. Search the forums and you will find people posting things like "Trump Forever!" and more. Propaganda is repeated here that has been verified as coming direct from the GRU and you accept it as fact when it is obviously a disinformation campaign. Many people here trust the Russian GRU above the U.S. intelligence services.
-
MSNBC
figures you would watch that...
https://youtu.be/xFoYqCJ24Ng
-
If you don't believe that Russia is targeting Republicans in a disinformation campaign especially related to Ukraine then you are more naive than I suspected.
Where did you hear that? Did Hillary pay for another Steele dossier?
-
so that makes twice today in this thread you posted something as fact that you cannot back up
got it...
If you don't believe that Russia is targeting Republicans in a disinformation campaign especially related to Ukraine then you are more naive than I suspected.
-
If you don't believe that Russia is targeting Republicans in a disinformation campaign especially related to Ukraine then you are more naive than I suspected.
That's not evidence. That's a stupid backhanded insult.
-
Why should I back up something that is common knowledge. You fail to support any of your responses. You apparently have the same attitude toward the U.S. Constitution that you selectively choose the parts you want to follow. You support a criminal that has repeatedly violated the U.S. Constitution in the past to be your future leader.
Just because something is "common knowledge" doesn't mean it can't be backed up with supporting sources and evidence.
How prolific a fact is has no bearing on its validity. For example, it was once common knowledge that the Earth is flat. Didn't make it more true simply because more people believed it.
-
It's the right pushing us to fascism. Just like the right wing sympathized with Nazis in favor of fascism against communism and Jewish people, today we have the right sympathizing with Russia, claiming to be fighting against socialism and non-white immigration while calling themselves patriots. The supporters of Hitler in the United States also claimed to be patriots as they plotted to overturn the government and establish Nazi government in the U.S. Trump supporters are following the same plan.
Define/explain what fascism is without googling a definition or throwing out popular talking points based on policies of Hitler/Nazi Germany.
Based on my experience, people who refer correlate Trump to fascism have no idea what fascism really is or looks like.
-
so you have nothing, and then double down with assumptions and what you think are insults
got it...
Why should I back up something that is common knowledge. You fail to support any of your responses. You apparently have the same attitude toward the U.S. Constitution that you selectively choose the parts you want to follow. You support a criminal that has repeatedly violated the U.S. Constitution in the past to be your future leader.
-
Why should I back up something that is common knowledge. You fail to support any of your responses. You apparently have the same attitude toward the U.S. Constitution that you selectively choose the parts you want to follow. You support a criminal that has repeatedly violated the U.S. Constitution in the past to be your future leader.
"common knowledge" is male vs female. But yet here we are that people don't know what that is. So science has to prove XX/XY and yet they won't believe there's a difference.
Which parts of the constitution does one choose to follow? Which part of the constitution was violated by a future leader? I mean I can show you how many DNC violate the 2A, but yet you aren't complaining those leaders are all still in office federally and state level.
-
A democracy is a government governed by unlimited majority rule, aka mob rule. Officials are elected by the people and laws are created solely by those in power and without limits.
A Republic is a form of democracy that is limited in the types of laws that can be created by some sort of charter, most commonly a constitution, that protects the rights of the citizenry from infringement by both the government and mob rule.
The U.S. is a Constitutional republic that maintains democratic tendencies with regards to elections and the influence of some laws. The U.S. is not a democracy.
Isn't it ironic, then, that the greatest antagonists to our rights are the same ones who refer to our form of government as a democracy and never mention Republic or constitutional Republic? Wonder why that is.
A republic is a form of democracy therefore it is a democracy. Being a subset of democracy doesn't mean we are no longer a democracy.
Yes, in extreme forms a democracy could create mob rule, but that is not inherent.
-
please show me where anyone claims to be against democracy?
Right wing fascism has been alive in the US for a long time. You want a definition of fascism but you don't believe the dictionary? You promote authoritarianism. You claim to be against democracy. What would that look like? America First?
(https://cdn.theatlantic.com/thumbor/kE71syfNNyXw4MtnYYvu9pPsKj8=/900x663/media/img/photo/2017/06/american-nazis-in-the-1930sthe-germ/n01_AP370718019/original.jpg)
-
please show me where anyone refused to state they support our democracy or the concept of any democracy in general
They refuse to state that they support our democracy or the concept of any democracy in general. Yet they claim to be patriots.
-
They refuse to state that they support our democracy or the concept of any our democracy in general. Yet they claim to be patriots.
When you say "our" you must mean "your". Meaning you along with your democrat friends.
-
A republic is a form of democracy therefore it is a democracy. Being a subset of democracy doesn't mean we are no longer a democracy.
Yes, in extreme forms a democracy could create mob rule, but that is not inherent.
Bullcrap. You made that up. Your general description does not describe the majority of republics both historically and contemporary.
A republic can be comprised totally of appointed representatives with no "democratic" process to elect them.
In the first century and a half of the US, senators were appointed by the states' legislatures. No "democratic process" for the people to select them.
If there were no elections held for the House of Representatives or the electoral colleges electors, we would be a pure republic without any "democracy" characteristics. State legislatures and Governors would appoint their Representatives, and the President would be selected by those same legislators via the electoral college.
A republic, based on the Latin phrase res publica ('public affair'), is a state in
which political power rests with the public through their representatives—in
contrast to a monarchy.[1][2]
Representation in a republic may or may not be freely elected by the general
citizenry. In many historical republics, representation has been based on personal
status and the role of elections has been limited. This remains true today;
among the 159 states that use the word republic in their official names as of
2017, and other states formally constituted as republics, are states that narrowly
constrain both the right of representation and the process of election.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic
-
Bullcrap. You made that up. Your general description does not describe the majority of republics both historically and contemporary.
A republic can be comprised totally of appointed representatives with no "democratic" process to elect them.
In the first century and a half of the US, senators were appointed by the states' legislatures. No "democratic process" for the people to select them.
If there were no elections held for the House of Representatives or the electoral colleges electors, we would be a pure republic without any "democracy" characteristics. State legislatures and Governors would appoint their Representatives, and the President would be selected by those same legislators via the electoral college.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic
Q pointed it out, why don't you claim he is making up bullcrap too?
From the dictionary:
Republic
a government in which supreme power resides in a body of citizens entitled to vote and is exercised by elected officers and representatives responsible to them and governing according to law
Democracy
a government in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised by them directly or indirectly through a system of representation usually involving periodically held free elections
I stated we are a constitutional democratic republic. Do you disagree with that characterization?
-
Q pointed it out, why don't you claim he is making up bullcrap too?
From the dictionary:
Republic
a government in which supreme power resides in a body of citizens entitled to vote and is exercised by elected officers and representatives responsible to them and governing according to law
Democracy
a government in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised by them directly or indirectly through a system of representation usually involving periodically held free elections
I stated we are a constitutional democratic republic. Do you disagree with that characterization?
The problem is you are consistently limited to what you can quickly Google, rather than reading the works directly related to the development of our government and founding of our nation.
Madison clearly dictated in the Federalist Papers the difference between a Democracy and Republic in relation to the American form of government, while at the same time explaining why our form of government is more correctly identified as a Republic with democracy influences, rather than an actual democracy. This is due to the fact that the latter cannot be successful implemented outside of small numbers/groups of citizens constrained to a localized/centralized area, where the citizenry have direct involvement in the management of state affairs. Conversely, a Republic, with it's elected representatives, facilitates the ability for a larger number of citizens to be represented by their chosen representative, without the constraints of direct involvement necessitated in a democracy-based form of government, thereby facilitating participation over a larger area.
In line with what I already stated, the fundamental difference lies not only in representation and the appointment of an executive (the latter which a democracy doesn't have), but also in that the laws created by representatives are constrained by policies or laws that prevent the majority of citizens or their representatives from infringing on recognized rights of all citizens, again often times clarified in a charter or constitution. Under democracies, no such restrictions exist, with both the majority and/or elected representatives of the majority able to pass laws as they see fit, regardless of how it impacts the minority.
If we were a democracy, there would be no need for a constitution nor the necessity to clearly identify protected rights as all that matters is what the majority or the representatives of the majority want.
So as I already stated, the U.S. is a Republic with democratic tendencies in the election of representatives and in the creation of some laws (i.e. when proposed laws are put on a ballot). Just because voting can be considered "democracy in action", it can be used as justification to identify the United States a democracy. The measures, policies and laws voted on and created by democratically elected representatives are constrained by the laws of the United States; more specifically, the U.S. Constitution, which is the supreme law of the land and supercedes all perspectives and desires of the majority or their representatives, thereby protecting rights FOR ALL.
So no, we don't recognize your CNN word salad talking point of "constitutional democratic republic", as the definition of a Republic already clarifies that its democratic influence lies specifically with the election of representatives by the citizenry.
And if you want to get all butthurt about people calling BS on you and not me, we can drop primary sources for references to justify our claims.
-
Right wing fascism has been alive in the US for a long time. You want a definition of fascism but you don't believe the dictionary? You promote authoritarianism. You claim to be against democracy. What would that look like? America First?
(https://cdn.theatlantic.com/thumbor/kE71syfNNyXw4MtnYYvu9pPsKj8=/900x663/media/img/photo/2017/06/american-nazis-in-the-1930sthe-germ/n01_AP370718019/original.jpg)
We're still waiting for you to clarify what fascism and/or a fascist government is.
They refuse to state that they support our democracy or the concept of any democracy in general. Yet they claim to be patriots.
You are correct in that I do not support your imaginary democracy government of the United States, nor purer forms of democracy, based on what has happened under such forms of government.
Case studies: Socrates and the influence of democracy in the establishment of and justification for socialist and communist-based governments of the 20th century, as well as what transgressed under such governments.
I openly state that I support a Republican form of government, which is what our current form of government is.
-
Q pointed it out, why don't you claim he is making up bullcrap too?
From the dictionary:
Republic
a government in which supreme power resides in a body of citizens entitled to vote and is exercised by elected officers and representatives responsible to them and governing according to law
Democracy
a government in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised by them directly or indirectly through a system of representation usually involving periodically held free elections
I stated we are a constitutional democratic republic. Do you disagree with that characterization?
Democracy word is never mentioned in the constitution or bill of rights. Just sayin...
-
Right wing fascism has been alive in the US for a long time. You want a definition of fascism but you don't believe the dictionary? You promote authoritarianism. You claim to be against democracy. What would that look like? America First?
(https://cdn.theatlantic.com/thumbor/kE71syfNNyXw4MtnYYvu9pPsKj8=/900x663/media/img/photo/2017/06/american-nazis-in-the-1930sthe-germ/n01_AP370718019/original.jpg)
Once again, you never answer the question. Instead you posted the pic below. I would say these types of people are present all over the world and have been since the Nazi party was established. It doesn't mean that said countries operate on their principals currently. I mean if they were so powerful, how did a Barry win?
-
The problem is you are consistently limited to what you can quickly Google, rather than reading the works directly related to the development of our government and founding of our nation.
Madison clearly dictated in the Federalist Papers the difference between a Democracy and Republic in relation to the American form of government, while at the same time explaining why our form of government is more correctly identified as a Republic with democracy influences, rather than an actual democracy. This is due to the fact that the latter cannot be successful implemented outside of small numbers/groups of citizens constrained to a localized/centralized area, where the citizenry have direct involvement in the management of state affairs. Conversely, a Republic, with it's elected representatives, facilitates the ability for a larger number of citizens to be represented by their chosen representative, without the constraints of direct involvement necessitated in a democracy-based form of government, thereby facilitating participation over a larger area.
In line with what I already stated, the fundamental difference lies not only in representation and the appointment of an executive (the latter which a democracy doesn't have), but also in that the laws created by representatives are constrained by policies or laws that prevent the majority of citizens or their representatives from infringing on recognized rights of all citizens, again often times clarified in a charter or constitution. Under democracies, no such restrictions exist, with both the majority and/or elected representatives of the majority able to pass laws as they see fit, regardless of how it impacts the minority.
If we were a democracy, there would be no need for a constitution nor the necessity to clearly identify protected rights as all that matters is what the majority or the representatives of the majority want.
So as I already stated, the U.S. is a Republic with democratic tendencies in the election of representatives and in the creation of some laws (i.e. when proposed laws are put on a ballot). Just because voting can be considered "democracy in action", it can be used as justification to identify the United States a democracy. The measures, policies and laws voted on and created by democratically elected representatives are constrained by the laws of the United States; more specifically, the U.S. Constitution, which is the supreme law of the land and supercedes all perspectives and desires of the majority or their representatives, thereby protecting rights FOR ALL.
So no, we don't recognize your CNN word salad talking point of "constitutional democratic republic", as the definition of a Republic already clarifies that its democratic influence lies specifically with the election of representatives by the citizenry.
And if you want to get all butthurt about people calling BS on you and not me, we can drop primary sources for references to justify our claims.
I never claimed that we were not a republic, I do agree that we are a republic. I also agreed with your statement that a republic is a type of democracy,
The problem with these discussions that I was trying to illustrate by referencing the dictionary is that there can be different meanings to the word democracy, different forms of democracy. Someone claiming that we are not a democracy glosses over all those variations and picks a type. For example, you stated that democracy doesn't have the appointment of an executive but a democracy can have an executive leader (presidential democracy). You also say democracies have no such restrictions that protects the rights of all citizens but again this is incorrect, these exist in a constitutional democracy. You are picking a very narrow definition of democracy. If you need to play semantics to win an inconsequential debate then have fun in your echo chamber.
I don't care if you don't recognize my more accurate label.
-
Democracy word is never mentioned in the constitution or bill of rights. Just sayin...
There are many concepts that are not explicitly mentioned in the constitution, doesn't mean they don't exist. .
-
There are many concepts that are not explicitly mentioned in the constitution, doesn't mean they don't exist. .
Like what? I mean, red flag laws aren' tmentioned, but yet are "constitutional" according to some.
-
you are missing the point completely, as usual
we are a constitutional republic and not a democracy because that is what the framers said, not only in the federalist papers, but also in interviews and speeches at the time
all your "nuance" that you are adding is not applicable. if you need to play semantics to win an inconsequential debate then have fun in your echo chamber...
I never claimed that we were not a republic, I do agree that we are a republic. I also agreed with your statement that a republic is a type of democracy,
The problem with these discussions that I was trying to illustrate by referencing the dictionary is that there can be different meanings to the word democracy, different forms of democracy. Someone claiming that we are not a democracy glosses over all those variations and picks a type. For example, you stated that democracy doesn't have the appointment of an executive but a democracy can have an executive leader (presidential democracy). You also say democracies have no such restrictions that protects the rights of all citizens but again this is incorrect, these exist in a constitutional democracy. You are picking a very narrow definition of democracy. If you need to play semantics to win an inconsequential debate then have fun in your echo chamber.
I don't care if you don't recognize my more accurate label.
-
Like what? I mean, red flag laws aren' tmentioned, but yet are "constitutional" according to some.
You could start with unenumerated rights. Take parental rights for example.
-
you are missing the point completely, as usual
we are a constitutional republic and not a democracy because that is what the framers said, not only in the federalist papers, but also in interviews and speeches at the time
all your "nuance" that you are adding is not applicable. if you need to play semantics to win an inconsequential debate then have fun in your echo chamber...
You are missing the point, as usual. I don't care if the framers didn't use the word democracy because we are, in function, a democracy. It is like you are telling me it isn't an apple because they said a Red Delicious instead of saying apple. Doesn't matter if we call ourselves a democracy or not, we function as one. and a republic is a form of democracy.
You guys are arguing semantics for no real benefit other than to try and sound smarter than people on the left. :wacko:
-
sounds like exactly what you do...
You are missing the point, as usual. I don't care if the framers didn't use the word democracy because we are, in function, a democracy. It is like you are telling me it isn't an apple because they said a Red Delicious instead of saying apple. Doesn't matter if we call ourselves a democracy or not, we function as one. and a republic is a form of democracy.
You guys are arguing semantics for no real benefit other than to try and sound smarter than people on the left. :wacko:
-
You could start with unenumerated rights. Take parental rights for example.
Post the wording in the constitution/bill of rights and then post your example.
-
You are missing the point, as usual. I don't care if the framers didn't use the word democracy because we are, in function, a democracy. It is like you are telling me it isn't an apple because they said a Red Delicious instead of saying apple. Doesn't matter if we call ourselves a democracy or not, we function as one. and a republic is a form of democracy.
You guys are arguing semantics for no real benefit other than to try and sound smarter than people on the left. :wacko:
Could be a tomato, strawberry, fruit punch, strawberry soda, strawberry fruit roll up, etc...
-
Post the wording in the constitution/bill of rights and then post your example.
I just gave you an example. Parental rights, it isn't in the constitution.
-
sounds like exactly what you do...
I go for accuracy. I don't about trying to sound smarter or virtue signaling to a tribe.
-
I just gave you an example. Parental rights, it isn't in the constitution.
You didn't answer the question so I'll help.
Parental rights would fall under the vague category of the 9th amendment. Court cases have also argued that this also falls under the 14th amendment when trying to take someone's child away without "due process". Oh snap, there's that phrase again "due process".
-
I just gave you an example. Parental rights, it isn't in the constitution.
"Parental rights, it isn't in the constitution."
you are right for once but it is here
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life,_Liberty_and_the_pursuit_of_Happiness
Declaration of independence.
A document most Hawaiian Democrats abhor.
It implies that the individual has more rights than the community.
Most Hawaiian citizens are stark raving socialists.
Thankfully most all are confined in Honolulu.
lots in Maui and a few others elsewhere.
>:D
-
there's a difference between accuracy and nitpicking so as not to be incorrect...
I go for accuracy. I don't about trying to sound smarter or virtue signaling to a tribe.
-
there's a difference between accuracy and nitpicking so as not to be incorrect...
accuracy is consistency
-
You didn't answer the question so I'll help.
Parental rights would fall under the vague category of the 9th amendment. Court cases have also argued that this also falls under the 14th amendment when trying to take someone's child away without "due process". Oh snap, there's that phrase again "due process".
Parental rights is a myth, not an actual civil right.
Case in point: public agencies, including public schools, are intentionally refusing to notifiy a student's parents in cases of pregnancy, abortion, transgender affirming care, etc.
if parents had constitutionally protected rights, the government's agencies and schools could not interject themselves into the role of parent while keeping the actual parents or legal guardians uninformed.
-
accuracy is consistency
Not when consistency prevents goal post relocation.
-
Parental rights is a myth, not an actual civil right.
Case in point: public agencies, including public schools, are intentionally refusing to notifiy a student's parents in cases of pregnancy, abortion, transgender affirming care, etc.
if parents had constitutionally protected rights, the government's agencies and schools could not interject themselves into the role of parent while keeping the actual parents or legal guardians uninformed.
I wonder if this is what HRC meant when she said "it takes a village....."
-
Parental rights is a myth, not an actual civil right.
Case in point: public agencies, including public schools, are intentionally refusing to notifiy a student's parents in cases of pregnancy, abortion, transgender affirming care, etc.
if parents had constitutionally protected rights, the government's agencies and schools could not interject themselves into the role of parent while keeping the actual parents or legal guardians uninformed.
Parents rights aren't a black and white thing, it isn't all or nothing. Like most (all?) other rights, a line is drawn. Parents have neither zero rights nor do they have supreme rights.
-
I wonder if this is what HRC meant when she said "it takes a village....."
I think "it takes a village" is just to muddy the waters. By saying it takes a village (which is usually, but not always the case) they can justify more programs, more intervention.
-
Parents rights aren't a black and white thing, it isn't all or nothing. Like most (all?) other rights, a line is drawn. Parents have neither zero rights nor do they have supreme rights.
Got any facts to back up your BS?
Or just making it ujp as you go -- as usual?
Please educate us all on where that line exists, because i think you're just trolling again.
-
Got any facts to back up your BS?
Or just making it ujp as you go -- as usual?
Please educate us all on where that line exists, because i think you're just trolling again.
I figured common sense would answer that for you but here it goes.
You can't kill your child yet you also have rights over your child greater than any other member of the public.
Are you arguing to argue or do you really not see the false dichotomy in your claims?
You ask where the line exists, it depends on the issue, the jurisdiction, etc. It is not some clean universal line. It is an unenumerated right hence not one clearly drawn but inferred and created through case precedence.
-
I figured common sense would answer that for you but here it goes.
You can't kill your child yet you also have rights over your child greater than any other member of the public.
Are you arguing to argue or do you really not see the false dichotomy in your claims?
You ask where the line exists, it depends on the issue, the jurisdiction, etc. It is not some clean universal line. It is an unenumerated right hence not one clearly drawn but inferred and created through case precedence.
Common sense is not a legal concept. Not to be confused with what a reasonable man might interpret the law to mean. Different concepts.
-
I figured common sense would answer that for you but here it goes.
You can't kill your child yet you also have rights over your child greater than any other member of the public.
Are you arguing to argue or do you really not see the false dichotomy in your claims?
You ask where the line exists, it depends on the issue, the jurisdiction, etc. It is not some clean universal line. It is an unenumerated right hence not one clearly drawn but inferred and created through case precedence.
Didnt HI pass or try to pass an assisted suicide law? Im sure no child could sign any waiver, which means the parent would have to sign it, as well as 3 doctors. Thus "killing their child".
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
I figured common sense would answer that for you but here it goes.
You can't kill your child yet you also have rights over your child greater than any other member of the public.
Are you arguing to argue or do you really not see the false dichotomy in your claims?
You ask where the line exists, it depends on the issue, the jurisdiction, etc. It is not some clean universal line. It is an unenumerated right hence not one clearly drawn but inferred and created through case precedence.
We aren't talking about rights of other "members of the public," but rights which government agencies do not recognize.
So, you're telling us parental rights exist, but there's no clearly defined right anywhere in the law. Doesn't sound like a right -- more like an opinion based on assumptions.
You're no better than the libtards who claim everything they want from government is a right.
Healthcare
food
shelter
a guaranteed income without employment
student loan forgiveness
on-demand abortion without limits
climate change agenda items
and on and on.
Just because you believe a right exists doesn't make it so. Unless the constitution or statutes protect said rights, you have no such legal rights.
As far as parental rights, those are enumerated in law not as rights, but as administrative guidelines. You can make medical choices for your children or decide what religion they will be raised in. Those are not rights as much as legal responsibilities and permitted choices in how to raise them. First amendment covers the latter -- religion.
You can't commit murder ... of anyone. So your straw argument doesn't apply as a some kind of reverse parental right -- something a parent can't do. (We won't go into the millions of children killed by their mothers prior to birth.)
Instead of arguing, try understanding for a change. You enjoying giving your 2 cents in every discussion, yet more often than not, you're just posting to feel involved.
-
Q pointed it out, why don't you claim he is making up bullcrap too?
From the dictionary:
Republic
a government in which supreme power resides in a body of citizens entitled to vote and is exercised by elected officers and representatives responsible to them and governing according to law
Democracy
a government in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised by them directly or indirectly through a system of representation usually involving periodically held free elections
I stated we are a constitutional democratic republic. Do you disagree with that characterization?
What you stated was:
A republic is a form of democracy therefore it is a democracy. Being a subset of democracy doesn't mean we are no longer a democracy.
Yes, in extreme forms a democracy could create mob rule, but that is not inherent.
This is demonstrably false based on the FACTS I posted.
Why are you now trying to change your comment to argue about dictionary definitions and "a constitutional democratic republic"? Do you always move goal posts, or is that a tactic you only use here?
Let me spell out why your comment is bullcrap. A republic is a NOT a form of democracy therefore it is NOT a democracy.
Thus far you've not apologized for spewing that bullcrap, so stop whining that you're the only one having bullcrap called on you.
A republic is a representative form of government. That's the ONLY part of your bullcrap you seem to understand.
HOW the representatives are selected MAY be through democratic elections, but in the VAST MAJORITY OF REPUBLICS, they are chosen through other means.
You seem to miss the point that the US government is not the only form a republic may take. While ours has a couple of democratic features in that representatives and electors are voted on to represent the voters, that in no way makes our republic a democracy. Far from it. Electors are party loyalists who MAY cast electoral votes for the candidate that state's popular vote selected. However, the 2016 election showed Hillary having more electors defect from her than any presidential candidate in the past century.
Then there's the case that's happened more than once where the president elected is not the candidate with the most popular votes.
both of those examples blow your theory out of the water that "a republic is a form of democracy". You can't call what we have a democracy when the results defy the poplar vote. It's inconsistent with the definition you posted.
Maybe you should go back and read your posts BEFORE submitting. You might save yourself and the rest of us a whole lot of arguing.
-
We aren't talking about rights of other "members of the public," but rights which government agencies do not recognize.
So, you're telling us parental rights exist, but there's no clearly defined right anywhere in the law. Doesn't sound like a right -- more like an opinion based on assumptions.
You're no better than the libtards who claim everything they want from government is a right.
Healthcare
food
shelter
a guaranteed income without employment
student loan forgiveness
on-demand abortion without limits
climate change agenda items
and on and on.
Just because you believe a right exists doesn't make it so. Unless the constitution or statutes protect said rights, you have no such legal rights.
As far as parental rights, those are enumerated in law not as rights, but as administrative guidelines. You can make medical choices for your children or decide what religion they will be raised in. Those are not rights as much as legal responsibilities and permitted choices in how to raise them. First amendment covers the latter -- religion.
You can't commit murder ... of anyone. So your straw argument doesn't apply as a some kind of reverse parental right -- something a parent can't do. (We won't go into the millions of children killed by their mothers prior to birth.)
Instead of arguing, try understanding for a change. You enjoying giving your 2 cents in every discussion, yet more often than not, you're just posting to feel involved.
Are you making the case that there is no such thing as parental rights? If so you would be wrong, there are multiple legal cases recognizing this unenumerated right.
https://www.americanbar.org/groups/public_interest/child_law/resources/child_law_practiceonline/child_law_practice/vol-35/february-2016/parental-rights-cases-to-know/#:~:text=Santosky%20is%20the%20first%20Supreme%20Court%20case%20to,court%20proceeding%2C%20they%20retain%20constitutionally%20protected%20parental%20rights.
If you want to split hairs by playing silly definition games where you toss out the whole concept of unenumerated rights just so you don't have to concede a point to me then you do you but your opinion isn't in line with reality.
-
What you stated was:
This is demonstrably false based on the FACTS opinion I posted.
Fixed it for you.
-
Fixed it for you.
As you post yet another opinion without offering a shred of supporting information.
:sleeping:
-
As you post yet another opinion without offering a shred of supporting information.
:sleeping:
Just like you?
-
Just like you?
i realize you have a short attention span. Go back and try to read my comments again.
Obviously you either skipped them or have no retention -- or comprehension.
I'm not going to repeat what I said just because you enjoy arguing and lying about me.
-
i realize you have a short attention span. Go back and try to read my comments again.
Obviously you either skipped them or have no retention -- or comprehension.
I'm not going to repeat what I said just because you enjoy arguing and lying about me.
You gave me an explanation of your opinion.
This is all a pointless dispute, even if a republic isn't a form of democracy as Q suggested, the USA is a democracy. It would be false to say we were not democratic just because we are a republic.
-
You gave me an explanation of your opinion.
This is all a pointless dispute, even if a republic isn't a form of democracy as Q suggested, the USA is a democracy. It would be false to say we were not democratic just because we are a republic.
Nobody said that except you just now.
A republic IS NOT a form of democracy.
I gave you documented facts.
Go back and read.
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=53776.msg483408#msg483408
And quit moving goal posts.
A republic is a form of democracy therefore it is a democracy. Being a subset of democracy doesn't mean we are no longer a democracy.
Yes, in extreme forms a democracy could create mob rule, but that is not inherent.
IOW, you believe all republics are democracies (is a form of democracy).
I provided sourced information to the contrary. Most republics on planet Earth who call themselves republics and which have been called republics based on historical fact have little to no democratic processes at all.
Republics can, and do, exist even without democratic characteristics, processes or tendencies.
Therefore, it is not true that "a republic is a form of democracy," nor is it true that "it (a republic) is a democracy." Both of your definitions are false, wrong and/or BS.
To repeat: you made that up.
-
Nobody said that except you just now.
A republic IS NOT a form of democracy.
I gave you documented facts.
Go back and read.
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=53776.msg483408#msg483408
And quit moving goal posts.
IOW, you believe all republics are democracies (is a form of democracy).
I provided sourced information to the contrary. Most republics on planet Earth who call themselves republics and which have been called republics based on historical fact have little to no democratic processes at all.
Republics can, and do, exist even without democratic characteristics, processes or tendencies.
Therefore, it is not true that "a republic is a form of democracy," nor is it true that "it (a republic) is a democracy." Both of your definitions are false, wrong and/or BS.
To repeat: you made that up.
Go scold Q if you have a problem with him saying a republic is a form of democracy.
I don't make things up. Taken from the Miriam Webster dictionary:
Republic
b (1) : a government in which supreme power resides in a body of citizens entitled to vote and is exercised by elected officers and representatives responsible to them and governing according to law.
Sure sounds a lot like a democracy...
Democracy
b: a government in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised by them directly or indirectly through a system of representation usually involving periodically held free elections
well look at that, nearly identical definitions.
Bottom line, the USA is a democracy. It is also a republic.
-
Go scold Q if you have a problem with him saying a republic is a form of democracy.
I don't make things up. Taken from the Miriam Webster dictionary:
Republic
b (1) : a government in which supreme power resides in a body of citizens entitled to vote and is exercised by elected officers and representatives responsible to them and governing according to law.
Sure sounds a lot like a democracy...
Democracy
b: a government in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised by them directly or indirectly through a system of representation usually involving periodically held free elections
well look at that, nearly identical definitions.
Bottom line, the USA is a democracy. It is also a republic.
Fascism is a form of socialism.
Socialism is a form of democracy.
In accordance with EEF's argument, fascism is democracy.
See now dumb that is?
You keep regurgitating the same nonsense day after day with no sources aside from a dictionary definition; same dictionary, mind you, that redefined multiple definitions to coincide with the political agendas of the left.
You failed your debate against multiple individuals because you're pulling opinions out of your ass that you have yet to substantiate with any evidence or primary sources.
You lost, get over it. You're not changing any opinions by constantly posting the same bullshit in every response.
-
You keep regurgitating the same nonsense day after day with no sources aside from a dictionary definition; same dictionary, mind you, that redefined multiple definitions to coincide with the political agendas of the left.
It's difficult for people who have been indoctrinated by corporate media to start thinking for themselves.
Living in Liberal Lala Land means we have a lot of work ahead of us helping others to understand what went wrong after it all falls apart, but that's the only way to make sure it doesn't happen again.
-
Fascism is a form of socialism.
Socialism is a form of democracy.
In accordance with EEF's argument, fascism is democracy.
See now dumb that is?
You keep regurgitating the same nonsense day after day with no sources aside from a dictionary definition; same dictionary, mind you, that redefined multiple definitions to coincide with the political agendas of the left.
You failed your debate against multiple individuals because you're pulling opinions out of your ass that you have yet to substantiate with any evidence or primary sources.
You lost, get over it. You're not changing any opinions by constantly posting the same bullshit in every response.
BBUUUUURRRRNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN (In Travis Kelso voice)
-
Fascism is actually defined as an unholy alliance between the corporations and the state
Mainstream media are actually Fascist News Networks
-
Fascism is a form of socialism.
Socialism is a form of democracy.
In accordance with EEF's argument, fascism is democracy.
See now dumb that is?
You keep regurgitating the same nonsense day after day with no sources aside from a dictionary definition; same dictionary, mind you, that redefined multiple definitions to coincide with the political agendas of the left.
You failed your debate against multiple individuals because you're pulling opinions out of your ass that you have yet to substantiate with any evidence or primary sources.
You lost, get over it. You're not changing any opinions by constantly posting the same bullshit in every response.
So are you backing away from your comment that a republic is a form of democracy?
BTW, fascism is not a form of socialism and socialism is not a form of democracy so yes that was pretty dumb.
Odd you are so quick to dismiss the use of a dictionary given the fact that the issue being debated rests on the very definition of words. But sure, lets toss out Mirriam Webster.
Cambridge
Democracy - A democracy is a country in which power is held by elected representatives.
Republic - a country that is governed by elected representatives and an elected leader
Collins
Democracy is a system of government in which people choose their rulers by voting for them in elections.
A republic is a country where power is held by the people or the representatives that they elect. Republics have presidents who are elected, rather than kings or queens.
Britannica
Democracy 1 a [noncount] : a form of government in which people choose leaders by voting
Republic : a country that is governed by elected representatives and by an elected leader (such as a president) rather than by a king or queen
Need more dictionaries?
-
So are you backing away from your comment that a republic is a form of democracy?
Isn't that what you were arguing over and over?
Are you now blaming Q for you being wrong?
Leave it to you to argue over what someone else may have posted just to argue.
-
Isn't that what you were arguing over and over?
Are you now blaming Q for you being wrong?
Leave it to you to argue over what someone else may have posted just to argue.
Try to pay attention, my main argument was that the USA is both a democracy and a republic.
I agreed with Q's statement that a republic is a form of democracy. You haven't proven me wrong, you only claimed it.
-
Try to pay attention, my main argument was that the USA is both a democracy and a republic.
I agreed with Q's statement that a republic is a form of democracy and I supported my claim. You haven't proven me wrong, you only claim it.
i proved you wrong.
A republic is NOT a democracy -- by definition. The fact that a company changed their definition to envelope how the US operates is irrelevant.
A republic BY definition is a government that does not have a monarch, dictator or tyrant in charge. There are politicians who represent the will of the people (in theory) rather than the will of one ruler. This is normally accomplished by drafting a constitution which details the make-up and function of the representatives.
How those representatives are chosen is where the definition branches out. A democratic republic elects its representatives through a public vote. However, as I already posted, most republics' representatives are selected by the heads of state, by the lawmakers, or simply as a matter of the individual's status.
You're arguing that since a cardinal is a bird, it follows that all birds are cardinals. Just because a few republics incorporate a democratic representative selection process IN NO WAY implies that all republics are a democracy.
Go read the actual source documents, not just the first result on your Google search.
-
i proved you wrong.
A republic is NOT a democracy -- by definition. The fact that a company changed their definition to envelope how the US operates is irrelevant.
A republic BY definition is a government that does not have a monarch, dictator or tyrant in charge. There are politicians who represent the will of the people (in theory) rather than the will of one ruler. This is normally accomplished by drafting a constitution which details the make-up and function of the representatives.
How those representatives are chosen is where the definition branches out. A democratic republic elects its representatives through a public vote. However, as I already posted, most republics' representatives are selected by the heads of state, by the lawmakers, or simply as a matter of the individual's status.
You're arguing that since a cardinal is a bird, it follows that all birds are cardinals. Just because a few republics incorporate a democratic representative selection process IN NO WAY implies that all republics are a democracy.
Go read the actual source documents, not just the first result on your Google search.
You proved nothing.
I took definitions from 4 different dictionaries all making my point. You seem to have selected some other definition of the word republic. (we may be arguing past each other)
Read the source documents? You mean the original use of the word in Latin?
-
You proved nothing.
I took definitions from 4 different dictionaries all making my point. You seem to have selected some other definition of the word republic. (we may be arguing past each other)
Read the source documents? You mean the original use of the word in Latin?
I'm done with you. You just want to argue.
Can't teach a pig to sing.
-
If we were a democracy, wouldn't it state so in the Constitution or like document? What it does state is that we're a republic. Weird how it would state that, but not democracy. I mean, even the Pledge of Allegiance states republic and not democracy.
Definitions can change over time, but the articles of paper that our founding fathers wrote doesn't change.
We can adopt parts of other types of things, but that doesn't make us it. They're going after Trump (political opponent) like how communist do. 1 party controls majority of the media, fact checkers have a agenda and political side, etc...Does that mean the US is a communist country?
-
EEF probably feels that the Constitution is a "living document"...
If we were a democracy, wouldn't it state so in the Constitution or like document? What it does state is that we're a republic. Weird how it would state that, but not democracy. I mean, even the Pledge of Allegiance states republic and not democracy.
Definitions can change over time, but the articles of paper that our founding fathers wrote doesn't change.
We can adopt parts of other types of things, but that doesn't make us it. They're going after Trump (political opponent) like how communist do. 1 party controls majority of the media, fact checkers have a agenda and political side, etc...Does that mean the US is a communist country?
-
EEF probably feels that the Constitution is a "living document"...
Merriam Webster's dictionary is THE authoritative source. Nothing that existed before the latest edition is true.
-
Merriam Webster also defines what an "assault rifle" is and it states semi auto as well as full auto. Gotta trust them right?
-
A Republic, If You Can Keep It
Just Benjamin Franklin's opinion. Nothing we should place any real stock in, because the dictionary has at least one other definition. Pick the one you agree with.
Those who claim that the Constitution provided for democracy as the cornerstone to our political system are historically mistaken. A democracy is an assurance of mob rule, where minority factions lose their liberty through legislation, and when power is consolidated over the subdued masses. This arrangement was intentionally dismissed during the time of ratification. James Madison specifically addressed this issue in The Federalist #10:
“From this view of the subject it may be concluded that a pure democracy, by which I mean a society consisting of a small number of citizens, who assemble and administer the government in person, can admit of no cure for the mischiefs of faction. A common passion or interest will, in almost every case, be felt by a majority of the whole; a communication and concert result from the form of government itself; and there is nothing to check the inducements to sacrifice the weaker party or an obnoxious individual. Hence it is that such democracies have ever been spectacles of turbulence and contention; have ever been found incompatible with personal security or the rights of property; and have in general been as short in their lives as they have been violent in their deaths.”[1]
Later in this essay, Madison illustrated the alternative: “the same advantage which a republic has over a democracy, in controlling the effects of faction, is enjoyed by a large over a small republic, — is enjoyed by the Union over the States composing it.”[2] A republic, according to Madison, “promises the cure for which we are seeking.”[3]
Then serving as James Madison’s coadjutor, John Jay noted: “Pure democracy, like pure rum, easily produces intoxication, and with it a thousand mad pranks and fooleries.”[4] In the Philadelphia Convention, Edmund Randolph said, “in tracing these evils to their origin every man had found it in the turbulence and follies of democracy.”[5]
Alexander Hamilton, the organizer of The Federalist essays, said the following of democracy at New York’s Ratifying Convention of 1788:
“It has been observed that a pure democracy if it were practicable would be the most perfect government. Experience has proved that no position is more false than this. The ancient democracies in which the people themselves deliberated never possessed one good feature of government. Their very character was tyranny; their figure deformity.”[6]
In opposition to democracy, a republic ensures that minority rights are protected. Individuals embody the smallest minority on earth, and are not exceptions to this creed. The individual was supposed to be superior to the collective. Individual rights were recognized, collectivized rights were not.
Franklin wisely understood that the value of liberty necessitated a republican form of government.
Emerging from behind the doors, Benjamin Franklin, a man many knew as “Poor Richard Saunders” approached. When asked by the woman what form the new government would take, Franklin answered shrewdly: “A republic, if you can keep it.”
https://tenthamendmentcenter.com/2014/06/11/a-republic-if-you-can-keep-it/
-
A Republic, If You Can Keep It
Just Benjamin Franklin's opinion. Nothing we should place any real stock in, because the dictionary has at least one other definition. Pick the one you agree with.
https://tenthamendmentcenter.com/2014/06/11/a-republic-if-you-can-keep-it/
No no no, Flapp. Don't quote the Federalist papers or the guy who literally drafted the Constitution.
What matters most is what the Google dictionary defines.
-
Look up what Merriam defines as "male" or "man". Yeah, trust the dictionary.