2aHawaii

General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: hvybarrels on September 16, 2024, 07:23:34 PM

Title: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: hvybarrels on September 16, 2024, 07:23:34 PM
I don't have the skills to pull off something like this, but can really appreciate someone who does.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dlwRrCwNSQY
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: rpoL98 on September 17, 2024, 09:49:50 PM
(https://i.imgur.com/RLiHHrZ.jpg)
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 18, 2024, 12:07:31 PM
I wouldn't really call it a masterclass as he didn't improve the situation but he was good at exercising his rights. The agents weren't very good with their verbal judo either.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 18, 2024, 02:52:03 PM
I wouldn't really call it a masterclass as he didn't improve the situation but he was good at exercising his rights. The agents weren't very good with their verbal judo either.

What do you think in all your whataboutism skills could he have done to "improve" the situation?

How do you know they're agents?  No ID was presented. You of all people should know that showing a gun and some type of badge doesn't make someone law enforcement. 
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 18, 2024, 02:57:44 PM
Good job on not taking part in their true interview purpose. The commentator is right, had a law been broken, he would have been arrested off the bat.  The claimed agents were there to get him to say something so they can get him on something.

I do think that he did say too much though as they would use any slip up he makes to arrest him.  Are any government agents trying to do interviews at known drug houses, gang member areas, drug corners, etc...Seems like that should take priority over something like this if the LEO's weren't corrupt.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 18, 2024, 03:04:49 PM
I wouldn't really call it a masterclass as he didn't improve the situation but he was good at exercising his rights. The agents weren't very good with their verbal judo either.

Why must you nitpick the verbiage used when it's obvious he was speaking rhetorically?

Rhetorical: 
    - Characterized by overelaborate or bombastic rhetoric.
    - Used for persuasive effect

Master class is normally applied to music, where a prominent musician listens to and critiques a student.

Any intelligent person understands the YouTuber didn't intend to suggest the subject of the video was "teaching."

I guess you have to find something to argue about.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 19, 2024, 10:56:31 AM
What do you think in all your whataboutism skills could he have done to "improve" the situation?

How do you know they're agents?  No ID was presented. You of all people should know that showing a gun and some type of badge doesn't make someone law enforcement.

Why do you respond as if I was defending the FBI's actions when I clearly criticized them as well.

You are still using whatboutism incorrectly BTW.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 19, 2024, 10:59:32 AM
Good job on not taking part in their true interview purpose. The commentator is right, had a law been broken, he would have been arrested off the bat.  The claimed agents were there to get him to say something so they can get him on something.

Thought that could be the case you do not know that this is their intent. You have no context other than some alleged post on what they were there investigate.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 19, 2024, 11:02:51 AM
Why must you nitpick the verbiage used when it's obvious he was speaking rhetorically?

Rhetorical: 
    - Characterized by overelaborate or bombastic rhetoric.
    - Used for persuasive effect

Master class is normally applied to music, where a prominent musician listens to and critiques a student.

Any intelligent person understands the YouTuber didn't intend to suggest the subject of the video was "teaching."

I guess you have to find something to argue about.

I am pointing out that the person who took the video did not exhibit the best behavior. You are the one nitpicking my assertion that this was not a master class. I guess you have to find something to argue about. Can't debate any of the substance of what I said so you have to complain about an insignificant comment that it was not a master class.
 :stopjack:
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 19, 2024, 01:14:22 PM
Why do you respond as if I was defending the FBI's actions when I clearly criticized them as well.

You are still using whatboutism incorrectly BTW.

How does my post imply that you're defending them?  BTW, I used the word agents and not FBI as well.

I'm questioning your use of the word agents as no ID was presented.

I asked what else could he have done.  Re-read what I posted.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 19, 2024, 01:16:41 PM
Thought that could be the case you do not know that this is their intent. You have no context other than some alleged post on what they were there investigate.

Yes I do have context. You of all people should know that if there is no arrest, that means there isn't sufficient evidence to arrest someone. So an interview can be done. And what's the purpose of an interview? 

Maybe you are the one who has no context other than some alleged post on what they were there to investigate.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 19, 2024, 01:17:26 PM
I am pointing out that the person who took the video did not exhibit the best behavior. You are the one nitpicking my assertion that this was not a master class. I guess you have to find something to argue about. Can't debate any of the substance of what I said so you have to complain about an insignificant comment that it was not a master class.
 :stopjack:

Maybe you can post what behavior that you think could have been improved on to go with your post.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 19, 2024, 02:25:36 PM
Yes I do have context. You of all people should know that if there is no arrest, that means there isn't sufficient evidence to arrest someone.

There's your problem. Your premise is flawed..

Quote
Maybe you are the one who has no context other than some alleged post on what they were there to investigate.

By all means if you know so much more about what happened than the video shows feel free to share it.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 19, 2024, 02:30:18 PM
How does my post imply that you're defending them? 

Oh I don't know, maybe the mocking sarcasm?

Quote
I'm questioning your use of the word agents as no ID was presented.

I asked what else could he have done.  Re-read what I posted.

So maybe they weren't agents, just people pretending? Maybe it was just an influencer production to get more followers?

As to what else he (the filmer) could have done, he could have stayed calm, not gotten emotional and resorted to insults, could have stated his position without attitude. He gains nothing by behaving in that manner and could cause them to look at him even more.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 19, 2024, 02:36:42 PM
I am pointing out that the person who took the video did not exhibit the best behavior. You are the one nitpicking my assertion that this was not a master class. I guess you have to find something to argue about. Can't debate any of the substance of what I said so you have to complain about an insignificant comment that it was not a master class.
 :stopjack:

Look up nit picking.  i don't think you know what it is, although you could give a master class in nit picking. 

 :rofl: :geekdanc: :stopjack:
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 19, 2024, 02:43:00 PM
Oh I don't know, maybe the mocking sarcasm?

So maybe they weren't agents, just people pretending? Maybe it was just an influencer production to get more followers?

As to what else he (the filmer) could have done, he could have stayed calm, not gotten emotional and resorted to insults, could have stated his position without attitude. He gains nothing by behaving in that manner and could cause them to look at him even more.

Get a grip.

Federal agencies, including the FBI, CONTRACT OUTSIDE BUSINESSES AND LAW ENFORCEMENT to do routine interviews.

This has been the case when interviewing for my own security clearance and being interviewed as references for others'.

The Feds don't have the resources in all locations to do all the legwork needed doing. 

By these people wanting to ask questions and not showing credentials, it tells me their open carried weapons and badges on their belts smacks of local LEOs or private detective agencies, not actual agents.

Would the FBI actually waste time and resources contacting someone about such an innocuous post?  I bet they shuffled it off to the local PD, and they sent a couple of detectives to do the interview.

Just speculating, but it's more grounded in reality than:
"maybe they weren't agents, just people pretending? Maybe it was just an influencer production to get more followers?"

You really add to the discussions when you ask such unsupported questions ...

... said no 2AHawaii member ever.

 :geekdanc:

Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 25, 2024, 11:38:54 AM
Get a grip.

Federal agencies, including the FBI, CONTRACT OUTSIDE BUSINESSES AND LAW ENFORCEMENT to do routine interviews.

This has been the case when interviewing for my own security clearance and being interviewed as references for others'.

The Feds don't have the resources in all locations to do all the legwork needed doing. 

By these people wanting to ask questions and not showing credentials, it tells me their open carried weapons and badges on their belts smacks of local LEOs or private detective agencies, not actual agents.

Would the FBI actually waste time and resources contacting someone about such an innocuous post?  I bet they shuffled it off to the local PD, and they sent a couple of detectives to do the interview.

Just speculating, but it's more grounded in reality than:
"maybe they weren't agents, just people pretending? Maybe it was just an influencer production to get more followers?"

You really add to the discussions when you ask such unsupported questions ...

... said no 2AHawaii member ever.

 :geekdanc:

A background interview is not the same thing as a possible criminal investigation. The FBI is not going to have private background investigators show up and do interviews of this nature.

Why would the FBI "waste" time?
#1. your very wording shows you have already made up your mind so your question isn't seeking a serious answer
#2. Without knowing the facts and circumstances of what they were investigating there is no way to know what they were really investigating or whether it was a waste of time or not. Or perhaps you are familiar with the case and know everything they know?


I do not think it was a social media stunt, that was sarcasm to point out the ridiculousness of them not being actual FBI agents. Swoosh
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 25, 2024, 11:41:08 AM
A background interview is not the same thing as a possible criminal investigation. The FBI is not going to have private background investigators show up and do interviews of this nature.

Why would the FBI "waste" time?
#1. your very wording shows you have already made up your mind so your question isn't seeking a serious answer
#2. Without knowing the facts and circumstances of what they were investigating there is no way to know what they were really investigating or whether it was a waste of time or not. Or perhaps you are familiar with the case and know everything they know?


I do not think it was a social media stunt, that was sarcasm to point out the ridiculousness of them not being actual FBI agents. Swoosh

How would you know what the FBI contracts out?  This is pure speculation and opinion. 

Show where anything you said is FBI policy.

Explain why these "agents" refused to show their credentials.

The video showed you exactly what they were investigating -- a social media post. 

Why do we have to hold your hand and eplain the details in so many threads?
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 25, 2024, 11:43:22 AM
How would you know what the FBI contracts out?  This is pure speculation and opinion. 

Show where anything you said is FBI policy.

You said FBI contracts out now you say I am speculating because I responded using your claim?

I also didn't say anything about FBI policy. Show me where it is FBI policy to contract this type of investigation to a private company.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 25, 2024, 12:16:17 PM
There's your problem. Your premise is flawed..

By all means if you know so much more about what happened than the video shows feel free to share it.

How is my premise flawed? 

The vid clearly explains what your asking. You're just choosing to ignore it cause you don't know how to dig ourself out of the hole.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 25, 2024, 12:23:24 PM
Oh I don't know, maybe the mocking sarcasm?

So maybe they weren't agents, just people pretending? Maybe it was just an influencer production to get more followers?

As to what else he (the filmer) could have done, he could have stayed calm, not gotten emotional and resorted to insults, could have stated his position without attitude. He gains nothing by behaving in that manner and could cause them to look at him even more.

"Oh I don't know, maybe the mocking sarcasm?" If I was using sarcasm, I would have replied with a swooosh as well or something else noting it.  If you don't understand a statement or question, please ask to clarify before replying.  "are you serious, joking, or being sarcastic?" is acceptable.

Now your 2nd sentence is an answer to a question asked.  See how easy that was.  No goal post moving, or swooshing needed.  I'm not saying your answer is right or wrong, but at least it's an straight answer. But to add to your comment about not using insults or attitude, it falls under free speech.  With regard to emotion, some people do get emotional when their rights are being investigated and possibly taken away.  I don't fault him for this as I'm assuming he wasn't prepared for someone to come and investigate him about it.  Like he wasn't prepped hours/days in advance.  And to reply to both, so far, he hasn't been arrested, so what ever he did worked.  We do not know what the result could have been if he refrained from insults, anger, attitude as we dont' have a time machine and he cannot re-do the same interaction.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 25, 2024, 01:07:31 PM
You said FBI contracts out now you say I am speculating because I responded using your claim?

I also didn't say anything about FBI policy. Show me where it is FBI policy to contract this type of investigation to a private company.

You make no sense.  You're the one who said the FBI would not farm out criminal investigations to contractors.

I think you have a hard time accepting that others might be smarter than you believe yourself to be.  You tried to muddy the topic by saying contractors don't do criminal investigations, Where did anyone say a criminal investigation was being pursued?  Not all reports are opened as criminal investigations, especially when something like this particular incident is involved.  It's just a reported social media post that someone decided to report.  Obviously it was harassment by the person reporting it.

Show me where the investigators ever said they were conducting a criminal investigation.

They were there to gather information from the subject, not investigate a specific crime.  That's perfectly valid for a non-special agent to do.

Once the interview report reaches the field office, they can then decide if an actual criminal investigation is warranted.

in this case, it was obvious on its face this was a harassment tactic against free speech, not a criminal investigation.  Had the subject said something to be taken as a threat, or created suspicion that the post was really a threat, then the case would have been given to the FBI criminal investigators.

Again, the FBI doesn't have the manpower to waste on checking out these types of reports.  Do you not watch the news?  The FBI responds to thousands of reports daily, and they aren't all "criminal investigations."  Just following up on reports.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 26, 2024, 12:25:50 PM
How is my premise flawed? 

The vid clearly explains what your asking. You're just choosing to ignore it cause you don't know how to dig ourself out of the hole.

Your premise is flawed because a lack of arrest does not mean there is insufficient evidence to arrest. Cops don't have to arrest you the instant they have PC, they could choose to delay an arrest for all sorts of reasons.

No the video doesn't explain what I asked. The guy taking the video claims it is about a social media post but what did the post say? Was the post he mentioned the same one the agents were there about? The video doesn't explain that so stop pretending you know the whole situation because this guy posted a short video where he makes a couple of vague claims.  Just admit you don't know the answers so you don't dig your hole deeper.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 26, 2024, 12:35:24 PM
"Oh I don't know, maybe the mocking sarcasm?" If I was using sarcasm, I would have replied with a swooosh as well or something else noting it.  If you don't understand a statement or question, please ask to clarify before replying.  "are you serious, joking, or being sarcastic?" is acceptable.

 ::) ::) ::)


Quote
Now your 2nd sentence is an answer to a question asked.  See how easy that was.  No goal post moving, or swooshing needed.  I'm not saying your answer is right or wrong, but at least it's an straight answer. But to add to your comment about not using insults or attitude, it falls under free speech.  With regard to emotion, some people do get emotional when their rights are being investigated and possibly taken away.  I don't fault him for this as I'm assuming he wasn't prepared for someone to come and investigate him about it.  Like he wasn't prepped hours/days in advance.  And to reply to both, so far, he hasn't been arrested, so what ever he did worked.  We do not know what the result could have been if he refrained from insults, anger, attitude as we dont' have a time machine and he cannot re-do the same interaction.

What this guy did was absolutely legal, no question there but I would argue that he still could have handled it better which is why I wouldn't hold his example as that of a master. If I were driving in the road and someone cut me off abruptly I could swerve and brake quickly to avoid impact then give him the middle finger but it wouldn't be the best way to handle the situation.

If he had taken a different tone and tact he could have probably gotten more information from the agents (whoever they were) without inflaming the situation while still not providing any incriminating statements that could be used against him. There are many videos of individuals who calmly and respectfully decline to speak to officers when they don't have to without being confrontational like this guy who I would hold up as a masterclass type event over this guy.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 26, 2024, 12:41:15 PM
You make no sense.  You're the one who said the FBI would not farm out criminal investigations to contractors.

I think you have a hard time accepting that others might be smarter than you believe yourself to be.  You tried to muddy the topic by saying contractors don't do criminal investigations, Where did anyone say a criminal investigation was being pursued?  Not all reports are opened as criminal investigations, especially when something like this particular incident is involved.  It's just a reported social media post that someone decided to report.  Obviously it was harassment by the person reporting it.

Show me where the investigators ever said they were conducting a criminal investigation.

They were there to gather information from the subject, not investigate a specific crime.  That's perfectly valid for a non-special agent to do.

Once the interview report reaches the field office, they can then decide if an actual criminal investigation is warranted.

in this case, it was obvious on its face this was a harassment tactic against free speech, not a criminal investigation.  Had the subject said something to be taken as a threat, or created suspicion that the post was really a threat, then the case would have been given to the FBI criminal investigators.

Again, the FBI doesn't have the manpower to waste on checking out these types of reports.  Do you not watch the news?  The FBI responds to thousands of reports daily, and they aren't all "criminal investigations."  Just following up on reports.

You brought up private contractors that weren't relevant now you say I am muddying the topic?

Do you think this youtuber is being investigated by private armed contractors for a government security clearance? If so just put that out as a possibility

If it wasn't criminal/criminal related then why else would armed officers show up to his home?

What evidence is there that this was an obvious harassment tactic against free speech?
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 26, 2024, 12:56:25 PM
You brought up private contractors that weren't relevant now you say I am muddying the topic?

Do you think this youtuber is being investigated by private armed contractors for a government security clearance? If so just put that out as a possibility

If it wasn't criminal/criminal related then why else would armed officers show up to his home?

What evidence is there that this was an obvious harassment tactic against free speech?

I used to think you had problems with reading comprehension.  Now I see you just like to argue 100% of the time.

Instead of providing a lucid response, you start out  arguing over what i said.  That's again muddying the topic.

Every contractor who works for any law enforcement agency and might have the need to protect themselves is able to carry a gun.  A badge is also available on amazon for FBI Contractors.

You still didn't answer why they refused to show their credentials.

And this is obvious harassment, because the people asking questions left without any answers.  In a  criminal investigation, they would have the right to detain him for an investigation, take him to their office, and conduct the interview while recording it.  Didn't happen.

I never said the harassment started with the agents.  i said someone reported them to the FBI in order to harass him -- not much different that SWATTING someone.  Pure harassment, and the government lets themselves be used by people willing to file a report.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 26, 2024, 01:21:36 PM
Your premise is flawed because a lack of arrest does not mean there is insufficient evidence to arrest. Cops don't have to arrest you the instant they have PC, they could choose to delay an arrest for all sorts of reasons.

No the video doesn't explain what I asked. The guy taking the video claims it is about a social media post but what did the post say? Was the post he mentioned the same one the agents were there about? The video doesn't explain that so stop pretending you know the whole situation because this guy posted a short video where he makes a couple of vague claims.  Just admit you don't know the answers so you don't dig your hole deeper.

It's called logic. Thanks for trying to dig your way out of the hole.

So with regard to this conversation, he broke no law. So no arrest.  Had he broken a law, the "agents" there would have arrested him and not tried to talk to him more.  Or are you saying say he did break a law, they would try to interview him more, even though they have enough evidence to arrest him, then walk away.  Only to return later to arrest him at a later date and time.

I mean, maybe they didn't have the right kind of car to hold a detainee, or maybe the "agent" who flashed a badge and a gun didn't have cuffs.  So you're right, maybe they had to go back to their HQ to get a different car and cuffs, then arrested the guy.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 26, 2024, 01:28:50 PM
It's called logic. Thanks for trying to dig your way out of the hole.

So with regard to this conversation, he broke no law. So no arrest.  Had he broken a law, the "agents" there would have arrested him and not tried to talk to him more.  Or are you saying say he did break a law, they would try to interview him more, even though they have enough evidence to arrest him, then walk away.  Only to return later to arrest him at a later date and time.

I mean, maybe they didn't have the right kind of car to hold a detainee, or maybe the "agent" who flashed a badge and a gun didn't have cuffs.  So you're right, maybe they had to go back to their HQ to get a different car and cuffs, then arrested the guy.

Some people refuse to see the obvious, simple conclusion when they can spend everyone's time debating why your reasoning isn't ironclad.

i walked into a bar, and the bartender was on the floor in a puddle of blood.  Standing over him was a deranged looking man with a knife stabbing him.

In EEF's world, the bartender could have been dead before the man stabbing him found him.  in the absence of contrary FACTS (not hypotheticals or guesses), I tend to go with a reasonable conclusion, not one that's simply argumentative.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 26, 2024, 01:29:01 PM
::) ::) ::)


What this guy did was absolutely legal, no question there but I would argue that he still could have handled it better which is why I wouldn't hold his example as that of a master. If I were driving in the road and someone cut me off abruptly I could swerve and brake quickly to avoid impact then give him the middle finger but it wouldn't be the best way to handle the situation.

If he had taken a different tone and tact he could have probably gotten more information from the agents (whoever they were) without inflaming the situation while still not providing any incriminating statements that could be used against him. There are many videos of individuals who calmly and respectfully decline to speak to officers when they don't have to without being confrontational like this guy who I would hold up as a masterclass type event over this guy.

A master is an expert.  The outcome was that he wasn't arrested (so far).  He also knows what his 1st amendment right is as he was mouthing off to the "agents".  Many people do not know what the 1st amendment is.  There are tons of police audit videos where the cops who take an oath about the Constitution violate the 1st amendment right of someone. I would call his knowledge of the matters as a "master".  Now had you said he didn't win the nice guy award or the calm guy mastery, then OK. He knew how far he could go with his rights and didn't exceed it.

Why would he need more info from the agents? Again, he wasn't arrested and they walked away so no laws broken, so he can keep doing what ever he's doing.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 26, 2024, 01:30:19 PM
Some people refuse to see the obvious, simple conclusion when they can spend everyone's time debating why your reasoning isn't ironclad.

i walked into a bar, and the bartender was on the floor in a puddle of blood.  Standing over him was a deranged looking man still stabbing him.

In EEF's world, the bartender could have been dead before the man stabbing him found him.  I tend to go with a reasonable conclusion, not one that's simply argumentative.

Whataboutism would also argue that the deranged man was pulling the knife out, but dropped it so it went back into the bartender. Then he pulled it out again and it slipped again. So he had to pull it out a 3rd time.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: macsak on September 26, 2024, 01:35:15 PM
#addingnuance

Some people refuse to see the obvious, simple conclusion when they can spend everyone's time debating why your reasoning isn't ironclad.

i walked into a bar, and the bartender was on the floor in a puddle of blood.  Standing over him was a deranged looking man with a knife stabbing him.

In EEF's world, the bartender could have been dead before the man stabbing him found him.  in the absence of contrary FACTS (not hypotheticals or guesses), I tend to go with a reasonable conclusion, not one that's simply argumentative.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 26, 2024, 02:36:39 PM
I used to think you had problems with reading comprehension.  Now I see you just like to argue 100% of the time.

Instead of providing a lucid response, you start out  arguing over what i said.  That's again muddying the topic.

Every contractor who works for any law enforcement agency and might have the need to protect themselves is able to carry a gun.  A badge is also available on amazon for FBI Contractors.

You still didn't answer why they refused to show their credentials.

And this is obvious harassment, because the people asking questions left without any answers.  In a  criminal investigation, they would have the right to detain him for an investigation, take him to their office, and conduct the interview while recording it.  Didn't happen.

I never said the harassment started with the agents.  i said someone reported them to the FBI in order to harass him -- not much different that SWATTING someone.  Pure harassment, and the government lets themselves be used by people willing to file a report.

You accuse me of wanting to argue? I gave my opinion that this guy didn't handle the situation as well as he could have and you started chirping about what a masterclass really was.
You need to do some introspection and stop projecting.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 26, 2024, 02:40:17 PM
It's called logic. Thanks for trying to dig your way out of the hole.

So with regard to this conversation, he broke no law. So no arrest.  Had he broken a law, the "agents" there would have arrested him and not tried to talk to him more.  Or are you saying say he did break a law, they would try to interview him more, even though they have enough evidence to arrest him, then walk away.  Only to return later to arrest him at a later date and time.

I mean, maybe they didn't have the right kind of car to hold a detainee, or maybe the "agent" who flashed a badge and a gun didn't have cuffs.  So you're right, maybe they had to go back to their HQ to get a different car and cuffs, then arrested the guy.

You make a claim based off your "logic" that isn't based in reality but your assumptions of how law enforcement works.

I am not saying anything about their true intent because I have no idea what they know or their reasoning. You however are claiming to know what is the truth while knowing nothing about their investigation beyond some relation to a social media post.

Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 26, 2024, 02:44:06 PM
A master is an expert.  The outcome was that he wasn't arrested (so far).  He also knows what his 1st amendment right is as he was mouthing off to the "agents".  Many people do not know what the 1st amendment is.  There are tons of police audit videos where the cops who take an oath about the Constitution violate the 1st amendment right of someone. I would call his knowledge of the matters as a "master".  Now had you said he didn't win the nice guy award or the calm guy mastery, then OK. He knew how far he could go with his rights and didn't exceed it.

Why would he need more info from the agents? Again, he wasn't arrested and they walked away so no laws broken, so he can keep doing what ever he's doing.


Sure, he walked up to the line and knew where not to cross but he also was confrontational. Maybe this cop is a bad cop and vengeful. Maybe being polite would have caused the cop to move onto the next case but instead the cop comes back digging for something else. Even if the guy taking the video is in the right he still just created a headache for himself.

If I give you the middle finger because it is my legal freedom to do so and you punch me then I am hardly a master of anything. Sure I know my rights but I also have a bloody nose.

Why would he want more information? To see what the agents had on him. Or maybe just to find out why his social media post had gone this far. Had he really been such a master maybe he could have cleared it up for them allowing them to close the case but instead he just gave them ammo to put in their report that he was acting confrontationally. If someone really reported his post as a form of harassment then he might have been able to explain the situation if he were smart enough to establish a better rapport with the agents.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 26, 2024, 03:31:57 PM
You make a claim based off your "logic" that isn't based in reality but your assumptions of how law enforcement works.

I am not saying anything about their true intent because I have no idea what they know or their reasoning. You however are claiming to know what is the truth while knowing nothing about their investigation beyond some relation to a social media post.

Re-read flapps post on the simple answer.  Or where the "agents" there to ask for directions cause they got lost?  That could be a possibility also right in your opinion.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 26, 2024, 03:34:58 PM
You accuse me of wanting to argue? I gave my opinion that this guy didn't handle the situation as well as he could have and you started chirping about what a masterclass really was.
You need to do some introspection and stop projecting.


Wait.  Who started out by giving an opinion on this being a master class?

I wouldn't really call it a masterclass as he didn't improve the situation but he was good at exercising his rights. The agents weren't very good with their verbal judo either.

If calling you out for an opinion that's wrong based on the use of a term is chirping, then call me Jiminy.

 :rofl: :rofl:
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 26, 2024, 03:39:23 PM

Sure, he walked up to the line and knew where not to cross but he also was confrontational. Maybe this cop is a bad cop and vengeful. Maybe being polite would have caused the cop to move onto the next case but instead the cop comes back digging for something else. Even if the guy taking the video is in the right he still just created a headache for himself.

If I give you the middle finger because it is my legal freedom to do so and you punch me then I am hardly a master of anything. Sure I know my rights but I also have a bloody nose.

Why would he want more information? To see what the agents had on him. Or maybe just to find out why his social media post had gone this far. Had he really been such a master maybe he could have cleared it up for them allowing them to close the case but instead he just gave them ammo to put in their report that he was acting confrontationally. If someone really reported his post as a form of harassment then he might have been able to explain the situation if he were smart enough to establish a better rapport with the agents.

How did he create a headache for himself? He wasn't arrested and they left.  A headache would be if he was put in cuffs.  Maybe he took tylenol before this interaction. That's possible right?

Another poor example. U very well know that if someone punches you for giving them the finger, it's called assault.  And that unless the person doing the punching is part of the government, then aren't stopping you from exercising your 1st amendment as who the Bill of Rights is directed toward.. The 1A is so the government cannot censor you.  Individuals or private companies/orgs can do as they please for censorship, but not in the means of assault.  So bad example X2.

So your last paragraph is to talk to someone who might be LEO without an attorney present and risk the chance of incriminating oneself (5th amendment).  How is acting confrontationally more ammo?  Is that breaking the law?  if they were to hold a grudge as some cops tend to do when people know their rights, then he would have a good lawsuit if they came back to retaliate.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 26, 2024, 03:45:36 PM
Re-read flapps post on the simple answer.  Or where the "agents" there to ask for directions cause they got lost?  That could be a possibility also right in your opinion.

EEF:  Master Contrarian

When the subject asked for credentials, and the people questioning him refused with a snarky "You can see our guns and badges" (or however they put it), the "agents" were provoking the subject, not the other way around -- and what the subject did was nowhere near giving them the bird -- a completely stupid analogy.

At that point, it's reasonable to ask them to vacate your property.  They might not receive it well, but to linger and keep asking questions isn't going to deescalate the situation.  It just shows a severe lack of respect for the subject's rights.

Cops are not talking to him to help him.  They are there to get him to admit whether he broke the law.  Period.

It's a fishing expedition, plain and simple.  Getting subjects/suspects to incriminate themselves is an age old tactic.  Best to exercise your rights and say nothing.

Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 26, 2024, 03:49:47 PM
How did he create a headache for himself? He wasn't arrested and they left.  A headache would be if he was put in cuffs.  Maybe he took tylenol before this interaction. That's possible right?

Another poor example. U very well know that if someone punches you for giving them the finger, it's called assault.  And that unless the person doing the punching is part of the government, then aren't stopping you from exercising your 1st amendment as who the Bill of Rights is directed toward.. The 1A is so the government cannot censor you.  Individuals or private companies/orgs can do as they please for censorship, but not in the means of assault.  So bad example X2.

So your last paragraph is to talk to someone who might be LEO without an attorney present and risk the chance of incriminating oneself (5th amendment).  How is acting confrontationally more ammo?  Is that breaking the law?  if they were to hold a grudge as some cops tend to do when people know their rights, then he would have a good lawsuit if they came back to retaliate.

One citizen's exercise of their civil rights is another LEO's "confrontation."

How many videos are on YouTube where Cops are on camera threatening to arrest, or actually arresting, someone for "obstruction" simply by refusing to surrender their legal rights?

Way too many.  Cops don't like it when they give you an order (show me some ID), and are told "no," even though there's no law requiring an ID in that situation.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: macsak on September 26, 2024, 04:28:56 PM
EEF = masterdebater...

EEF:  Master Contrarian

When the subject asked for credentials, and the people questioning him refused with a snarky "You can see our guns and badges" (or however they put it), the "agents" were provoking the subject, not the other way around -- and what the subject did was nowhere near giving them the bird -- a completely stupid analogy.

At that point, it's reasonable to ask them to vacate your property.  They might not receive it well, but to linger and keep asking questions isn't going to deescalate the situation.  It just shows a severe lack of respect for the subject's rights.

Cops are not talking to him to help him.  They are there to get him to admit whether he broke the law.  Period.

It's a fishing expedition, plain and simple.  Getting subjects/suspects to incriminate themselves is an age old tactic.  Best to exercise your rights and say nothing.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 26, 2024, 04:53:48 PM
EEF = masterdebater...

I would like to challenge for that title please. 
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 30, 2024, 12:09:18 PM
If calling you out for an opinion that's wrong based on the use of a term is chirping, then call me Jiminy.


So now you are the opinion nazi? If I say pineapple goes on pizza are you going to fact check me for my "wrong opinion"
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 30, 2024, 12:15:35 PM
How did he create a headache for himself? He wasn't arrested and they left.  A headache would be if he was put in cuffs.  Maybe he took tylenol before this interaction. That's possible right?

The headache comment was within the hypothetical situation of a vengeful LEO. Had the thing I mentioned take place, then he would have created a headache for himself.


Quote
Another poor example. U very well know that if someone punches you for giving them the finger, it's called assault.

Swoosh. The point is that just because you have every legal right to do something doesn't mean it is the smart way of handling the situation.

Quote
So your last paragraph is to talk to someone who might be LEO without an attorney present and risk the chance of incriminating oneself (5th amendment).

I indicated that there were ways he could have talked to them to get more information from them without providing anything incriminating.

Quote
How is acting confrontationally more ammo?

It would depend on the whole picture, without knowing the background I cannot say how or whether it would be giving more ammunition. However if (hypothetical)  the agents were there talking to him based on some tip that he was somehow mentally unstable and dangerous then their observations of his confrontational nature could end up being ammo to use against him.

Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 30, 2024, 12:17:27 PM
EEF = masterdebater...

I humbly decline that gracious title. I have areas for improvement in this regard.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: QUIETShooter on September 30, 2024, 12:24:37 PM
Red Flag laws would turn a simple confrontational argument into a "mentally unstable gun owner person with anger issues and needs to be detained and firearm(s) taken away."
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 30, 2024, 12:33:17 PM
The headache comment was within the hypothetical situation of a vengeful LEO. Had the thing I mentioned take place, then he would have created a headache for himself.


Swoosh. The point is that just because you have every legal right to do something doesn't mean it is the smart way of handling the situation.

I indicated that there were ways he could have talked to them to get more information from them without providing anything incriminating.

It would depend on the whole picture, without knowing the background I cannot say how or whether it would be giving more ammunition. However if (hypothetical)  the agents were there talking to him based on some tip that he was somehow mentally unstable and dangerous then their observations of his confrontational nature could end up being ammo to use against him.

You took time to reply, but nothing of substance like usual.  Thanks for playing.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 30, 2024, 12:35:48 PM
Red Flag laws would turn a simple confrontational argument into a "mentally unstable gun owner person with anger issues and needs to be detained and firearm(s) taken away."

Under EEF's advice, LEO comes to your door to do red flag, you can be friendly because you know, you're getting your 2a right taken away.  You're getting your right to a fair trial taken away.  Your getting your 4th amendment right taken away. But be friendly in case they hold a grudge and you might make the situation worst.
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 30, 2024, 02:12:00 PM
Under EEF's advice, LEO comes to your door to do red flag, you can be friendly because you know, you're getting your 2a right taken away.  You're getting your right to a fair trial taken away.  Your getting your 4th amendment right taken away. But be friendly in case they hold a grudge and you might make the situation worst.

Swoosh
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 30, 2024, 02:12:30 PM
You took time to reply, but nothing of substance like usual.  Thanks for playing.


Or it is beyond your level of comprehension...
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 30, 2024, 02:22:39 PM
Red Flag laws would turn a simple confrontational argument into a "mentally unstable gun owner person with anger issues and needs to be detained and firearm(s) taken away."

Think about it realistically and not just within the context of a red flag type situation.

Imagine you have a dispute with the neighbor. That neighbor makes a false report saying you are mentally dangerous, that you are prone to anger and need to be committed to a mental hospital. Cops come to investigate to see if the report is real and try to talk to you following which they will write a report to document what they saw and did.  You can calmly and politely address them, ask them a few questions and decline to answer certain questions or you can tell them you get off your property, insult them, give them the middle finger, etc. Now imagine a judge and/or a mental health doctor reviews that report in making a decision concerning you, which type of behavior is going to be better for you?

Even if nothing is going to happen in behaving like this youtuber did, there is no benefit for him to behave this way. Well I suppose he may benefit from views on youtube but in terms of dealing with whatever the cops were there for, nothing he did benefitted him in any way. Or am I missing something? Was being confrontational like this a benefit over being calm and polite?

Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 30, 2024, 02:28:42 PM
Think about it realistically and not just within the context of a red flag type situation.

Imagine you have a dispute with the neighbor. That neighbor makes a false report saying you are mentally dangerous, that you are prone to anger and need to be committed to a mental hospital. Cops come to investigate to see if the report is real and try to talk to you following which they will write a report to document what they saw and did.  You can calmly and politely address them, ask them a few questions and decline to answer certain questions or you can tell them you get off your property, insult them, give them the middle finger, etc. Now imagine a judge and/or a mental health doctor reviews that report in making a decision concerning you, which type of behavior is going to be better for you?

Even if nothing is going to happen in behaving like this youtuber did, there is no benefit for him to behave this way. Well I suppose he may benefit from views on youtube but in terms of dealing with whatever the cops were there for, nothing he did benefitted him in any way. Or am I missing something? Was being confrontational like this a benefit over being calm and polite?

Cops are not trained nor qualified to evaluate someone's mental health status.

If the person in your simple hypothetical has not broken a law, there is nothing the Cops can do.  A mental health evaluation can only be ordered by a judge based on observed behavior.

What you are trying to say is that Cops can use anything you say against you to have you detained for a mental health exam.  That's when Cops start using standard words to get anyone they want evaluated -- no different than claiming disturbing the peace or obstruction when there was no law broken to start with.

So, the only way you can help yourself is to say nothing at all.  Don't give the investigating Cops anything to use against you. 

You have NO LEGAL DUTY to assist in any Cop's investigation.  Period. 

If you are being interrogated and detained, availing yourself of the right to remain silent is not to be construed in court as if you are more guilty than a "cooperative suspect."
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 30, 2024, 03:29:55 PM
Think about it realistically and not just within the context of a red flag type situation.

Imagine you have a dispute with the neighbor. That neighbor makes a false report saying you are mentally dangerous, that you are prone to anger and need to be committed to a mental hospital. Cops come to investigate to see if the report is real and try to talk to you following which they will write a report to document what they saw and did.  You can calmly and politely address them, ask them a few questions and decline to answer certain questions or you can tell them you get off your property, insult them, give them the middle finger, etc. Now imagine a judge and/or a mental health doctor reviews that report in making a decision concerning you, which type of behavior is going to be better for you?

Even if nothing is going to happen in behaving like this youtuber did, there is no benefit for him to behave this way. Well I suppose he may benefit from views on youtube but in terms of dealing with whatever the cops were there for, nothing he did benefitted him in any way. Or am I missing something? Was being confrontational like this a benefit over being calm and polite?

So a mental health professional will make a determination solely based on what someone else writes in a report who's not also a mental health professional?
Title: Re: Masterclass in dealing with the FBI
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 30, 2024, 04:17:16 PM
So a mental health professional will make a determination solely based on what someone else writes in a report who's not also a mental health professional?

We allow people with diagnosed mental illnesses to live on their own, mostly homeless.

Then we detain and arrest anyone who doesn't cooperate with a government investigation based on a social media post?

The insanity exists, but it's the system -- not the guy refusing to talk to law enforcement.