2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: K30l4 on January 09, 2013, 08:23:05 AM

Title: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: K30l4 on January 09, 2013, 08:23:05 AM
Can or no can?

http://washingtontimes.com/news/2013/jan/9/biden-executive-orders-action-can-be-taken-guns/
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: ren on January 09, 2013, 08:30:15 AM
With millions of ARs and other firearms in circulation, that would not be a wise choice. Executive orders can only go so far. Checks and balances.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Cougar8045 on January 09, 2013, 08:36:36 AM
No can.  It would lead to his immediate impeachment.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: BUD on January 09, 2013, 08:49:41 AM
No can.  It would lead to his immediate impeachment.

Don't be so sure.  Gun owners are the minority in the equation.  To assume otherwise is dangerous.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Cougar8045 on January 09, 2013, 08:59:47 AM
Don't be so sure.  Gun owners are the minority in the equation.  To assume otherwise is dangerous.
Gun owners are a minority, but those who support the Second Amendment are still in the majority, and this isn't even a Second Amendment thing.  Everyone who's not a dues-paying member of the Brady Campaign would be able to recognize the problem with Obama ordering the confiscation of privately-held property on nothing more than his say-so.  It won't happen. 
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: 230RN on January 09, 2013, 09:01:26 AM
Don't be so sure.  Gun owners are the minority in the equation.  To assume otherwise is dangerous.

We are in the postion that the Founders wanted so desperately to avoid: tyranny of the majority. 

We are no longer a representative republic.  We are a demogoguery where the combined squeaking of three wheels has drowned out the fourth.

People say that multi-party systems don't work well because it takes too much of a coalition to get anything done. 

Sometimes I think "getting nothing done" might be a good idea.

Terry, 230RN
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Cougar8045 on January 09, 2013, 09:02:58 AM
We are in the postion that the Fouders so desperately wanted to avoid: tyranny of the majority. 

We are no longer a representative republic.  We are a demogoguery where the combined sqeaking of three wheels has drowned out the fourth.

People say that multi-party systems con;t work because it takes too much of a coalition to get anything done.  Sometimes I think "getting nothing done" might be a good idea.

Terry, 230RN
I have never been able to see the problem when some newsperson whines about how "this is the least productive Congress in history, in terms of new legislation passed."  I always applaud when I hear that.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Scar16 on January 09, 2013, 09:45:21 AM
Fuck those  guys and everyone else that is for the gun ban. Are they fucking dumb, we will definitely have the next civil war if they ban guns. There are hundreds of thousands of gun owners out there wiling to kill any government officials who try and confiscate their rights to bare arms. Feinstein, Biden, Obama can fuck themselves! I would have never voted for Obama if I knew he was going to do this, hypocrite!
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Cougar8045 on January 09, 2013, 09:50:35 AM
Fuck those  guys and everyone else that is for the gun ban. Are they fucking dumb, we will definitely have the next civil war if they ban guns. There are hundreds of thousands of gun owners out there wiling to kill any government officials who try and confiscate their rights to bare arms. Feinstein, Biden, Obama can fuck themselves! I would have never voted for Obama if I knew he was going to do this, hypocrite!
How did you not see this coming?  I'm not trying to belittle you, I'm honestly curious as to why you thought Obama was a better candidate.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: BUD on January 09, 2013, 09:51:53 AM
Gun owners are a minority, but those who support the Second Amendment are still in the majority, and this isn't even a Second Amendment thing.  Everyone who's not a dues-paying member of the Brady Campaign would be able to recognize the problem with Obama ordering the confiscation of privately-held property on nothing more than his say-so.  It won't happen. 

I am just sayin'.... a few things come to mind like indefinite detention, assasination of American citizens without due process (drone strikes), not to mention the modifications to our "Free Speech" First Ammendment rights.  From what I see, the tide has begun turning and all it takes is a few more whackos to ruin it. 
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Cougar8045 on January 09, 2013, 09:54:50 AM
I am just sayin'.... a few things come to mind like indefinite detention, assasination of American citizens without due process (drone strikes), not to mention the modifications to our "Free Speech" First Ammendment rights.  From what I see, the tide has begun turning and all it takes is a few more whackos to ruin it.
True, but bear in mind also that indefinite detention, drone strikes, and all the rest requires the complicity of the military, a group which voted for Romney over Obama, 70%-30%.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: new guy on January 09, 2013, 09:55:37 AM
.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Cougar8045 on January 09, 2013, 10:00:06 AM
Maybe is it possible that a lot of this pro-gun control controversy might be being used as a "red herring" to distract us from the fact that our economy is on the road to ruin?

Gun control legislation can be sensationalized and exploited by the media to spike sales; discussion of how best to address our lack of control of our fiscal policies... not so much...
This is a good point, and probably pretty close to the x.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: ren on January 09, 2013, 10:02:56 AM
Maybe is it possible that a lot of this pro-gun control controversy might be being used as a "red herring" to distract us from the fact that our economy is on the road to ruin?

Gun control legislation can be sensationalized and exploited by the media to spike sales; discussion of how best to address our lack of control of our fiscal policies... not so much...
I hope so.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: xer 21 on January 09, 2013, 10:06:08 AM
How did you not see this coming?  I'm not trying to belittle you, I'm honestly curious as to why you thought Obama was a better candidate.
to be fair, Obama has had pretty much no part to play in this as of yet.  he's made a couple of speeches, but its the media and the congressmen, most notably Cali and NY democrats that have been taking any actual action.  the fact that biden has, for the millionth time, has to assure people that obama is doing something just shows how much of a no show he's been.


as for the executive order, there is no way its going to take guns.  stop that bullshit. 

he's most likely just going to reform the background checks law to close off the no background checks for private sellers and/or require everything to run through an FFL.  a law which wont be enforceable in states that dont require registration anyways.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Cougar8045 on January 09, 2013, 10:11:04 AM
to be fair, Obama has had pretty much no part to play in this as of yet.  he's made a couple of speeches, but its the media and the congressmen, most notably Cali and NY democrats that have been taking any actual action.  the fact that biden has, for the millionth time, has to assure people that obama is doing something just shows how much of a no show he's been.


as for the executive order, there is no way its going to take guns.  stop that bullshit. 

he's most likely just going to reform the background checks law to close off the no background checks for private sellers and/or require everything to run through an FFL.  a law which wont be enforceable in states that dont require registration anyways.
This is the same thing we heard about him throughout his first term.  It's how we were supposed to console ourselves when he won re-election.  Now you're telling me he has no part in this while his task force reviews what restrictions can be enacted, in addition to an assault weapons and magazine ban.  I suppose you'll tell me he has nothing to with this while his blue-ribbon panel's proposals are being debated in Congress, and you'll continue to assure me he has nothing to do with gun control, even while the autopen signs a new assault weapons ban into law.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: BUD on January 09, 2013, 10:57:00 AM
True, but bear in mind also that indefinite detention, drone strikes, and all the rest requires the complicity of the military, a group which voted for Romney over Obama, 70%-30%.

Well if the military is complicit in the above then....... see what I'm sayin'?  The above are contrary to the Constitution that is sworn to be upheld?  Because they have assaulted several other Constitutional Ammendments they are going to stop at the 2nd?  The only thing I am trying to say is watch your six because we can sit here all day and say it ain't happening but when it does I certainly won't be surprised. 
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: sic_semper_tyrannis on January 09, 2013, 11:04:06 AM
How can ANYONE feign ignorance over Obummer's track record on guns?! All one had to do is research the laws he voted for while a state Senator and the Senator from Illinois. I never voted for this Chicago Marxist piece of shit, because I knew exactly what he was/is: a radical cryptocommunist.

Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: xer 21 on January 09, 2013, 11:07:20 AM
This is the same thing we heard about him throughout his first term.  It's how we were supposed to console ourselves when he won re-election.  Now you're telling me he has no part in this while his task force reviews what restrictions can be enacted, in addition to an assault weapons and magazine ban.  I suppose you'll tell me he has nothing to with this while his blue-ribbon panel's proposals are being debated in Congress, and you'll continue to assure me he has nothing to do with gun control, even while the autopen signs a new assault weapons ban into law.
no, im saying that he's far from the driving force behind any of this, and the fact that biden has to keep telling people they're doing something, indicates to me that obama hasnt really been a part of the process, it has been driven by Congress and the media.  he's been cheering from the sidelines thus far instead of getting into the game.  thus far, he has yet to produce ANYTHING solid from either him or his committee.

and there will be no AWB for the autopen to sign.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Cougar8045 on January 09, 2013, 11:09:15 AM
and there will be no AWB for the autopen to sign.
This part we agree on, but I strongly disagree that he's been sitting on the sidelines.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: hnl.flyboy on January 09, 2013, 11:33:40 AM
Gun owners are a minority, but those who support the Second Amendment are still in the majority, and this isn't even a Second Amendment thing.  Everyone who's not a dues-paying member of the Brady Campaign would be able to recognize the problem with Obama ordering the confiscation of privately-held property on nothing more than his say-so.  It won't happen.

As much as I dislike the ACLU regarding other things, the ACLU will definitely be there to defend us with that too.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Cougar8045 on January 09, 2013, 11:35:56 AM
As was pointed out in the much-read essay on 1389blog.com (http://1389blog.com/2012/12/23/larry-correia-refutes-the-gun-controllers-once-and-for-all/), confiscation will never happen, there will ALWAYS be a grandfather clause, for one simple reason the author explains quite well:

Quote from: Larry Correia
for the sake of math, let’s say that there are only 80 million gun owners, and let’s say that the government decides to round up all those pesky guns once and for all. Let’s be generous and say that 90% of the gun owners don’t really believe in the 2nd Amendment, and their guns are just for duck hunting. Which is what politicians keep telling us, but is actually rather hilarious when you think about how the most commonly sold guns in America are the same detachable magazine semiautomatic rifles I talked about earlier.

So ten percent refuse to turn their guns in. That is 8 million instantaneous felons. Let’s say that 90% of them are not wanting to comply out of sheer stubbornness. Let’s be super generous and say that 90% of them would still just roll over and turn their guns when pressed or legally threatened.   That leaves 800,000 Americans who are not turning their guns in, no matter what. To put that in perspective there are only about 700,000 police officers in the whole country.

Let’s say that these hypothetical 10% of 10% are willing to actually fight to keep their guns. Even if my hypothetical estimate of 800,000 gun nuts willing to fight for their guns is correct, it is still 97% higher than the number of insurgents we faced at any one time in Iraq, a country about the size of Texas.

If you haven't read the linked article, I highly recommend it.  I spend more time than most reading about gun stuff, and this is the most comprehensive, best-written article I've ever seen refuting the idea of gun control.  And for those of you who roll your eyes at the Alex Jones style "1776 WILL RISE AGAIN!" crap, I assure you, the above-quoted portion is but a small portion of a 10,000-word essay.  It is not intended to incite rebellion or stir up discontent, but rather to point out the reality of what confiscation would entail to those who are undecided but leaning toward gun control.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Dblnaknak on January 09, 2013, 12:52:54 PM
Fuck those  guys and everyone else that is for the gun ban. Are they fucking dumb, we will definitely have the next civil war if they ban guns. There are hundreds of thousands of gun owners out there wiling to kill any government officials who try and confiscate their rights to bare arms. Feinstein, Biden, Obama can fuck themselves! I would have never voted for Obama if I knew he was going to do this, hypocrite!

He's not the one doing this. He doesn't have the power to this. It's congress. They have the power. Blame the right people.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: sic_semper_tyrannis on January 09, 2013, 01:03:35 PM
True. It's Congress that writes the laws, however, it takes a radical nut like Obama to sign them into law.

I think the poster was just venting in general about the radical hard left turn that the Demoncrat party has taken in the last 10 years or so. When you have Constitutional illiterates like Harry Reid, Feinstein, Schumer, Pelosi, Warren, Durbin, Sheila Jackson Lee, Maxine Waters, etal., it's very easy to understand the frustrations of those not brainwashed to follow the statist agenda that the Obummer administration is carrying out.

And do you really think these liberal progressive clowns would be dealing with such a touchy subject like guns if they didn't feel confident that the Executive branch had their backs?
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: xer 21 on January 09, 2013, 02:07:09 PM


And do you really think these liberal progressive clowns would be dealing with such a touchy subject like guns if they didn't feel confident that the Executive branch had their backs?
yes, because feintein's being reintroducing the AWB every year since it expired and these bills constantly get brought up.

the only difference now is media coverage and more emotion in the congressional branches.

they never stop their attack, but its generally ineffective in the absence of a galvanizing event.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: bryanhayn on January 09, 2013, 03:52:15 PM
I would have never voted for Obama if I knew he was going to do this, hypocrite!

This is why I no longer vote. Politics is straight bullshit. A vote for ANY candidate is bad for the American citizen.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: roadster99 on January 09, 2013, 04:31:09 PM
Maybe is it possible that a lot of this pro-gun control controversy might be being used as a "red herring" to distract us from the fact that our economy is on the road to ruin?

Gun control legislation can be sensationalized and exploited by the media to spike sales; discussion of how best to address our lack of control of our fiscal policies... not so much...

No, it's BECAUSE the fact that our economy is on the road to ruin that firearms legislation is being talked about on a serious level.  As society decays and the economy falters, cities and counties lose funding.  The ability for local police departments to "control" crime is slowly lost.  I left a link (http://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=5650.0) in another thread that displayed many cities in America in this very type of situation.  Off the top of my head, Detroit is a very good example.  Neighborhoods are forming their own militias to patrol the streets to keep their families and friends safe.  As cities start going bankrupt, the citizens lose their jobs and start getting desperate.  It's said that there are approximately 400 gang members to 1 police officer in the city of Chicago.  Imagine if one day they finally realized that.  As a result of a collapsing economy, people naturally become violent and committing crime becomes daily survival.  Uprisings begin to crop up and that's how revolutions are started.  It's not fair for the government if the citizens have weapons very similar to the ones they have.  They actually might put up a fight.  We wouldn't want that.  Sway public opinion to believe the same way Piers Morgan believes, neighbor turns in neighbor, slowly legislate stricter and stricter laws and eventually, confiscate.  Well, that's the idea, anyway.  I don't think they factored in a small idea called "patriotism."  Small word, big movement. 

BUT...It wouldn't surprise me either if the pro-gun lobby is stirring the pot because they're seeing their stock prices shoot to the moon.  What an easy way to make money.  Lobby for strict talk about gun control, put all your money in stocks like Ruger & S&W then rake in the cash.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Cougar8045 on January 09, 2013, 04:44:40 PM
No, it's BECAUSE the fact that our economy is on the road to ruin that firearms legislation is being talked about on a serious level.  As society decays and the economy falters, cities and counties lose funding.  The ability for local police departments to "control" crime is slowly lost.  I left a link (http://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=5650.0) in another thread that displayed many cities in America in this very type of situation.  Off the top of my head, Detroit is a very good example.  Neighborhoods are forming their own militias to patrol the streets to keep their families and friends safe.  As cities start going bankrupt, the citizens lose their jobs and start getting desperate.  It's said that there are approximately 400 gang members to 1 police officer in the city of Chicago.  Imagine if one day they finally realized that.  As a result of a collapsing economy, people naturally become violent and committing crime becomes daily survival.  Uprisings begin to crop up and that's how revolutions are started.  It's not fair for the government if the citizens have weapons very similar to the ones they have.  They actually might put up a fight.  We wouldn't want that.  Sway public opinion to believe the same way Piers Morgan believes, neighbor turns in neighbor, slowly legislate stricter and stricter laws and eventually, confiscate.  Well, that's the idea, anyway.  I don't think they factored in a small idea called "patriotism."  Small word, big movement. 

BUT...It wouldn't surprise me either if the pro-gun lobby is stirring the pot because they're seeing their stock prices shoot to the moon.  What an easy way to make money.  Lobby for strict talk about gun control, put all your money in stocks like Ruger & S&W then rake in the cash.
Ruger and S&W saw a 25-30% drop in their stock prices after the Newtown shooting.  Everything else in your post makes a lot of sense, though.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: new guy on January 09, 2013, 05:55:43 PM
.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Inspector on January 09, 2013, 06:16:53 PM
This is why I no longer vote. Politics is straight bullshit. A vote for ANY candidate is bad for the American citizen.
That is truly a shame. The reason I say this is because there are some of us who believe that about the BIG 2 political parties. But there are some VERY GOOD Independents out there that are worth voting for IMHO. And if we can get enough people voting Independent then one or both of the Big 2 parties would start listening to the voters. I believe the real problem is that it really doesn't matter which of the Big 2 parties you vote with. You will get the same government heading in the same direction. But start voting in Independents who think for themselves and I think you might see what I am getting at.

Hopefully, next election you might consider exploring the Libertarian and Independent parties. I believe the country can be saved and is worth saving but only if we can get back to basics. And I believe that this is the direction voters need to go. JMHO  :shaka:
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: mln41 on January 09, 2013, 06:59:52 PM
i think he's been quiet until now,  he's reelected so now he has nothing to lose.  I think on something like this he is the one pulling the strings behind the scenes getting everyone else to do the talking and agenda pushing. 
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Bunker on January 09, 2013, 07:14:00 PM
Can or no can?

http://washingtontimes.com/news/2013/jan/9/biden-executive-orders-action-can-be-taken-guns/ (http://washingtontimes.com/news/2013/jan/9/biden-executive-orders-action-can-be-taken-guns/)
Always can but in doing so, can/will it withstand a legal challenge, which will likely be where it ends up.

There have been successful EOs signed by a president directly related to gun control. I'll list four for anyone who believes it can't be done:

1989 - President George H.W. Bush; Banned the importation of dozens of semi-automatic assault rifles that were defined by BATF at the request of President Bush. He started the whole assault ban in the first place by EO.

1994 - President Clinton; Banned importation of ammunition from China.

1998 - President Clinton; In 1997, ordered the Secretary of Treasury to review the the importation of the modified versions of the previously banned AWS that were still being imported legally, then in 1998, the list of banned imports was extended to include more assault weapons, such as variations of the AK-47. The order targeted the importation of guns that were not subjected to the 1994 Assault Weapons Ban.

2001 - President Clinton; Banned the importation of "assault pistols" and tightened licensing rules on gun dealers.

Clinton was accused of overuse or misuse of executive power on gun control issues but the fact is executive authority can be used, and Obama has already signed out over 140 EOs and he is not afraid of being challenged legally.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: DjEROQ on January 09, 2013, 07:57:05 PM
What if all of you are right? What if its a huge coverup or conspiracy and the government is using gun control to hide something? What if some top secret agency planned all this? What if all those situations in the movies were actually inside details of true events?  :crazy: Lol I'm just saying and curious like everyone else and want to know the truth. I'm also more curious to see how confiscation of arms or even a ban will divide this country. From all the texans I've talked to about it says they have a clause in their constitution that will allow them to act as an independent country if they want... Is that true and if so, will other states try to do the same?

 I try to look at the bigger picture and try to look at it from both sides. As a father I'd hope that this wouldn't happen in Hawaii but it has shown signs of it as we'll as violent hostile situations. I must agree with the article earlier in this thread from a Texas rep. That mentioned if the principle had access to a gun would that person be dead? Would there be as much casualties as there were? I would agree that certain school officials should have access to PROPER training and be able to access a firearm if need be in case something like this happens. I'd hope for my kids sake that it can be possible. I'd like to see strict gun control for us in Hawaii anyways... Even tho its ridiculous already just to get a gun, especially a hand gun.  :wtf: anyways I'd like to say thanks for the news and info and knowledge of what's going on out there cause I don't get much info about it in the news... Too busy with trying to keep my fam feed n under a roof  :crazy:  :shaka:
Title: Biden: Obama Will Bypass Congress for Gun Control
Post by: SpeedTek on January 09, 2013, 07:59:11 PM
http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2013/01/09/Biden-Obama-Will-Bypass-Congress-for-Gun-Control (http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2013/01/09/Biden-Obama-Will-Bypass-Congress-for-Gun-Control)
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: nf9648 on January 09, 2013, 08:07:09 PM
I hope so.

I hope he ruins the economy and tries a gun grab, then nobody will have anything to lose and we can fix this once and for all.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Cougar8045 on January 09, 2013, 08:07:51 PM
I can't speak for Texans, but Montana passed a law a few years ago stating that if a firearm is made, sold, and kept in the state of Montana, it is not part of any interstate commerce and is therefore beyond the authority of the federal government to regulate.  Wyoming has the same law, but they've apparently introduced an amendment to that law which would specifically tell the feds to pack sand in the event they ban any semi-automatic firearm, or limit the magazine capacity of any firearm, to include specifying prison terms and fines for violation.  If anyone from the BATFEIEIO is reading this, you really don't want to roll into Wyoming or Montana with grandiose plans to confiscate guns from those rednecks.  You had your hands full with the Branch Davidians; I really rather doubt you'd fare better against the Montana or Wyoming National Guard. 

Text of proposed law. (http://legisweb.state.wy.us/2013/Introduced/HB0104.pdf)  Existing law is in black, changes are one-lined and written in red.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Bunker on January 09, 2013, 08:36:43 PM
I can't speak for Texans, but Montana passed a law a few years ago stating that if a firearm is made, sold, and kept in the state of Montana, it is not part of any interstate commerce and is therefore beyond the authority of the federal government to regulate.  Wyoming has the same law, but they've apparently introduced an amendment to that law which would specifically tell the feds to pack sand in the event they ban any semi-automatic firearm, or limit the magazine capacity of any firearm, to include specifying prison terms and fines for violation.  If anyone from the BATFEIEIO is reading this, you really don't want to roll into Wyoming or Montana with grandiose plans to confiscate guns from those rednecks.  You had your hands full with the Branch Davidians; I really rather doubt you'd fare better against the Montana or Wyoming National Guard. 

Text of proposed law. (http://legisweb.state.wy.us/2013/Introduced/HB0104.pdf)  Existing law is in black, changes are one-lined and written in red.

Wow...I'm not a lawyer but that doesn't seem legal. Just curious how a state can completely disregard a federal law. I can understand challenging a federal law in court like several states did with Obamacare but this is just complete disregard. They got balls...I like their boldness. :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: bass monkey on January 09, 2013, 08:40:45 PM
I can't speak for Texans, but Montana passed a law a few years ago stating that if a firearm is made, sold, and kept in the state of Montana, it is not part of any interstate commerce and is therefore beyond the authority of the federal government to regulate.  Wyoming has the same law, but they've apparently introduced an amendment to that law which would specifically tell the feds to pack sand in the event they ban any semi-automatic firearm, or limit the magazine capacity of any firearm, to include specifying prison terms and fines for violation.  If anyone from the BATFEIEIO is reading this, you really don't want to roll into Wyoming or Montana with grandiose plans to confiscate guns from those rednecks.  You had your hands full with the Branch Davidians; I really rather doubt you'd fare better against the Montana or Wyoming National Guard. 

Text of proposed law. (http://legisweb.state.wy.us/2013/Introduced/HB0104.pdf)  Existing law is in black, changes are one-lined and written in red.

Wow how fortunate their state supports them. Hawaii would rat everyone out if they thought they could get more federal funding.  So sad....
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: hnl.flyboy on January 09, 2013, 09:21:05 PM
Wow...I'm not a lawyer but that doesn't seem legal. Just curious how a state can completely disregard a federal law. I can understand challenging a federal law in court like several states did with Obamacare but this is just complete disregard. They got balls...I like their boldness. :thumbsup:

Key words are:

Quote
...that is owned or manufactured commercially or privately in Wyoming and that remains exclusively within the borders of Wyoming.

The Federal Government, Constitutionally, can regulate interstate commerce.  ("Commerce Clause" US Constitution Article 1, Section 8, Clause 3 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commerce_Clause (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commerce_Clause))  Theoretically, anything contained within a state is to be regulated by the state.  The Commerce Clause was stretched to the extreme in 1942 when a farmer grew more wheat than he was allowed during the Great Depression, to be used within his own farm.  (Wickard V. Filburn http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn))  To make a long story short and according to my memory, it was ruled that though he was keeping the wheat for himself, he could possibly affect wheat production within his own state which could possibly affect other states, which would then be part of interstate commerce, therefore the Federal government could tell him to stop making extra wheat for his own personal use.

Laws such as these and other Firearms Freedom Acts passed by other states aren't really just about firearms.  They're mostly about taking States' Rights back from the Federal government.

...then again, IANAL, and everything just said is worth nothing.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Bunker on January 09, 2013, 09:30:19 PM
Seems like it would be near impossible to regulate, which doesn't seem to be something high on their priority list anyway, but if they can get away with it, more power to them.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Cougar8045 on January 09, 2013, 10:12:30 PM
Seems like it would be near impossible to regulate, which doesn't seem to be something high on their priority list anyway, but if they can get away with it, more power to them.
Honestly, they can't get away with it.  The Supremacy Clause of the Constitution and all that.  Not to mention that there's Supreme Court precedent that literally everything affects interstate commerce.  The case I'm remembering is from the '30s, in which a farmer was told he was producing too much (I shit you not, that's what happened.  Atlas Shrugged, anyone?), and that he had to destroy some of his crops.  He told the feds to pack sand, because the extra food above the limit was for his family's use--it was never going to be sold.  And the Supreme Court-THE SUPREME COURT! ruled that if he grew his own food, he wouldn't need to buy other food, and that would affect interstate commerce, so the federal government was within its authority to force him to destroy it.  Yeah.  That blows my mind, but there it is.  The case was Wickard v. Filburn (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn)

Anyway, no, they can't get away with it, but it speaks to the attitude of the residents of those states regarding the federal government's various overreaches.  A symbolic gesture, if you will. 
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: mln41 on January 09, 2013, 10:49:39 PM
if you didn't read that article cougar posted here it is,  great article.     Thanks for posting cougar

http://1389blog.com/2012/12/23/larry-correia-refutes-the-gun-controllers-once-and-for-all/ (http://1389blog.com/2012/12/23/larry-correia-refutes-the-gun-controllers-once-and-for-all/)


Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Kevin on January 09, 2013, 11:04:49 PM
Can or no can?

http://washingtontimes.com/news/2013/jan/9/biden-executive-orders-action-can-be-taken-guns/ (http://washingtontimes.com/news/2013/jan/9/biden-executive-orders-action-can-be-taken-guns/)

"Someone Who Buys A Thousand Rounds Of Ammunition Should Be Of Interest To Local Law Enforcement" (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WcqJFMOm8dg#)
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: new guy on January 10, 2013, 10:30:48 AM
.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Bunker on January 10, 2013, 11:05:03 AM
Honestly, they can't get away with it.  The Supremacy Clause of the Constitution and all that.  Not to mention that there's Supreme Court precedent that literally everything affects interstate commerce.  The case I'm remembering is from the '30s, in which a farmer was told he was producing too much (I shit you not, that's what happened.  Atlas Shrugged, anyone?), and that he had to destroy some of his crops.  He told the feds to pack sand, because the extra food above the limit was for his family's use--it was never going to be sold.  And the Supreme Court-THE SUPREME COURT! ruled that if he grew his own food, he wouldn't need to buy other food, and that would affect interstate commerce, so the federal government was within its authority to force him to destroy it.  Yeah.  That blows my mind, but there it is.  The case was Wickard v. Filburn (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn)

Anyway, no, they can't get away with it, but it speaks to the attitude of the residents of those states regarding the federal government's various overreaches.  A symbolic gesture, if you will.
That makes sense but I love their spirit and attitude.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Cougar8045 on January 10, 2013, 11:14:10 AM
Man, I'd hate to be the poor asshole who has to serve a confiscation notice on Travis Haley!
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: GZire on January 10, 2013, 12:16:25 PM
Man, I'd hate to be the poor asshole who has to serve a confiscation notice on Travis Haley!

He isn't the wildcard that the people who move to the remote outdoors will be such as the loners in Alaska.  It would be a bloodbath to try and take their stuff.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Bunker on January 10, 2013, 03:27:07 PM
Here is an explanation of the use of executive authority from Newt Gingrich in the first part of this video. Seen it yesterday on Greta.

http://video.foxnews.com/v/2084127743001/gun-control-and-rise-in-debt-ceiling-by-obama-decree?intcmp=related (http://video.foxnews.com/v/2084127743001/gun-control-and-rise-in-debt-ceiling-by-obama-decree?intcmp=related)
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: roadster99 on January 10, 2013, 07:14:57 PM
Here's another thought.

With all the threats concerning "Executive Order" and "bans," maybe they're just "massaging the meat" in order to pass legislation that we normally wouldn't accept?  For example, our reaction to whatever legislation they pass is, "Well, at least X didn't get banned/confiscated."  But that leads to my next question.  What are you willing to accept in replacement of a ban?  Would you accept legislation the makes the entire United States exactly like California, just as long as they don't approve another AWB?  Federal registration & fingerprinting, background checks and psych evaluations?  Annual permitting/fees?

I guess the question is, how much ground are we each willing to concede in exchange for a "promise" that X won't be banned?  Remember what I posted here (http://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=5690.0)?  Obviously, this little Obamacare "slip-in" helps our cause.  But though the NRA looks out for our best interests, this is proof that they are still a lobby group as well and show that they are willing to be, in a sense, "bought."  Of course, this is what we hope for, so long it benefits us.  While I believe that they will do their best fighting for our 2A rights, we still don't know what goes on behind closed doors and what deals are being made.

So...What ARE you willing to concede?
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Bunker on January 10, 2013, 07:30:58 PM
Here's another video with Michelle Malkin and it also includes Clinton pushing to ban hi-cap mags and assault weapons while speaking at the Consumers Electronics Show. Of course it wouldn't be complete without Clinton joining in and adding his lousy two cents.

Gun Control - Sheriff Joe - VP Biden: Use Executive Order On Gun Control - Michelle Malkin (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qqGKXfdT58o#)
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Cougar8045 on January 10, 2013, 08:52:44 PM
Here's another thought.

With all the threats concerning "Executive Order" and "bans," maybe they're just "massaging the meat" in order to pass legislation that we normally wouldn't accept?  For example, our reaction to whatever legislation they pass is, "Well, at least X didn't get banned/confiscated."  But that leads to my next question.  What are you willing to accept in replacement of a ban?  Would you accept legislation the makes the entire United States exactly like California, just as long as they don't approve another AWB?  Federal registration & fingerprinting, background checks and psych evaluations?  Annual permitting/fees?

I guess the question is, how much ground are we each willing to concede in exchange for a "promise" that X won't be banned?  Remember what I posted here (http://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=5690.0)?  Obviously, this little Obamacare "slip-in" helps our cause.  But though the NRA looks out for our best interests, this is proof that they are still a lobby group as well and show that they are willing to be, in a sense, "bought."  Of course, this is what we hope for, so long it benefits us.  While I believe that they will do their best fighting for our 2A rights, we still don't know what goes on behind closed doors and what deals are being made.

So...What ARE you willing to concede?
Re: The bolded portion: Feck no. 

What would I be willing to concede?  I'd be ok with universal background checks, as long as the check is limited to calling 1-800-UNCONSTITUTIONAL and asking, "Hey, is John Doe, last four of SSN xxxx cleared to buy a gun?", and the answer consists of a "Yes" or a "No", with no other information like make/model being transferred, etc ever being recorded anywhere.  That I would be ok with.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: SpeedTek on January 10, 2013, 09:02:25 PM
Quote
"Someone Who Buys A Thousand Rounds Of Ammunition Should Be Of Interest To Local Law Enforcement"

hmmmm everyone I have sold to all look like a Law Abiding Citizen to me.  No one looks like the Killers on the news.

Some guys I know shoot 500 rounds a weekend.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: xer 21 on January 10, 2013, 09:34:05 PM
i bought 1000 rounds just in case retarded panics like these dry up the supply.

oh shit, i guess im on a watch list.

although a family friend who works in the government jokingly (i hope.) tells me im already on a watch list because im studying Russian.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: new guy on January 11, 2013, 08:35:51 AM
.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Inspector on January 11, 2013, 12:07:33 PM
Wow...I'm not a lawyer but that doesn't seem legal. Just curious how a state can completely disregard a federal law. I can understand challenging a federal law in court like several states did with Obamacare but this is just complete disregard. They got balls...I like their boldness. :thumbsup:
Well, actually, if you read Article 1 of the constitution it basically states that the Federal government is responsible for conducting foreign policy, signing treaties, waging wars, etc. Also for regulating inter-state commerce, and that everything else is up to the states. Because our states now accepts large amounts of money from the federal government to provide services to the state's citizens there is now an air of blackmail on the part of the feds. So the states abide by the federal laws but they certainly don't have to in most circumstances. But if they don't they stand to lose billions of dollars in funding for schools, highways, etc.

I could be wrong about some or all of this but this is my general understanding. JMHO.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: nf9648 on January 11, 2013, 07:30:56 PM
Maybe mo better to start learning Chinese...

Ni Hao Ma?

One step ahead of ya...

(http://www.toysrus.com/cms_widgets/18/86/188647_assets/kailan-092409.gif)
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: robtmc on January 11, 2013, 08:14:18 PM
I could be wrong about some or all of this but this is my general understanding. JMHO.
Not close to being a scholar of this crap, and decades away from classes on it, but I think you are correct.

Perhaps more tellingly, the arguments I have seen from leftists trying to cut down secession arguments might back it up.  I.E. states like Texas that could do well on their own, mirrors just what you have said: that all those federal hog slop dollars would dry up and the now free state would come back begging for more. 

They left truly thinks they have enslaved the states with the federal grant system.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: 230RN on January 12, 2013, 08:24:43 AM
Quote
the only difference now is media coverage and more emotion in the congressional branches.

they never stop their attack, but its generally ineffective in the absence of a galvanizing event.

Sounds kinda contradictory to me.

We have had a galvanizing event --in fact a sequence of them.

<rant>

Hey, I'm tired of all the pollyannas saying "this can't happen," "that won't happen," "we have the Constitution to protect us," "Obama will never get re-elected," "it'll get thrown out by SCOTUS," as I have seen here and on many other internet sites.

Hey, I saw all this before, in 1986 and '94, and in dozens of minor ways before and since then --even unto some blather from a major city hotshot mayor seriously suggesting that the size of soft drinks should be regulated.

The fact that this tyrannical mayor could even suggest such a thing is clear evidence that those in power will do anything they can to exert power, more power, and still more power.  This is just the tiniest, smallest incident, but it demonstrates the power-hunger of politicians in general.

A minor thing, but it shows  that people with some power will always want more power. 

That big city out east had a two-term limit for mayors, but that guy convinced the twerps and lackeys on the city council to make an exception and allowed him to run (after changing parties) again, and win, for a third term.

Another thing that illustrates is that weasel-wording lawyers can always find a way to circumvent the will of the people.

Take the case of that California farmer who had to destroy his own crops because of the wildest legalistic "interpretation" of the commerce clause.  Ridiculous! 

And the case in --what, Connecticut? --where the supreme court trampled on private property rights by claiming that the greater good would be  served by allowing the municipality to condemn private property to build a shopping center, which would bring in more tax money for the city.  Hence, they reasoned, it was ultimately "for the greater good," and fucked the landowners.  Ridiculous!

You folks who think our so-called "protections" are valid are just throwing the rest of us under the bus with your pretty pink predictions.  I fail to see how anyone can claim that President Obama is a passive bystander in this latest round of gun-control hysteria.  Ridiculous!

We are in a long-term battle with dedicated, patient, power-grabbers, and fuff and fluff about how "this can't happen" is plain stupid in my mind.  It's not like we haven't seen the same processes develop before in history.

It has happened.

It is happening.

And it will keep on happening.

Until we throw the bums out on their asses.

</rant>

Ah, phew!

Dayam, that felt good.

Terry, 230RN


Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: roadster99 on January 12, 2013, 11:49:47 AM
Well said!
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: clshade on January 12, 2013, 12:55:20 PM
Folks, would you really expect the Senator from ILLINOIS to be anything but anti-gun while representing the majority of his constituency in Chicago?

I defended Dan Inouye the same on other forums from folks who thought he was too liberal: he was representing one of the most liberal states in the union!

Obama is simply not the anti-gun activist that he is sometimes painted to be. If he was you would see much more explicit support for crap like Feinstein's bill.

That said, the anti-gun activists reside firmly in Obama's group of supporters and if the political climate indeed turns anti-gun enough to pass further control legislation he'll sign it with no complaint. The man has MUCH bigger fish trying to fry him than to expend much (or any) political capital on highly controversial gun legislation.

And that said... he has far less control over this kind of thing than it would seem so his personal take on things is largely irrelevant. If the economy gets worse (and it looks like it will) and people continue to crack (and it looks like they will) - just one or two more heinous crimes would tilt the sheeple into accepting further gun rights restrictions. And those who are all about disarming any potentially restless natives will be well pleased.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: spanner1751 on January 12, 2013, 03:14:28 PM
I was hesitant to post this link, because of some of the tinfoil hat stuff, but it's beginning to make more and more sense. I invite your attention to post #10.

http://smith-wessonforum.com/2nd-amendment-forum/287849-politicians-banning-things-they-dont-understand.html (http://smith-wessonforum.com/2nd-amendment-forum/287849-politicians-banning-things-they-dont-understand.html)

Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: xer 21 on January 12, 2013, 04:04:05 PM
it only makes sense because all of this stuff is written after all the variables already line up.

this sounds almost exactly like that "secret DHS source" that only talked to a tiny ass tin foil online blog. 

not buying.  especially since even if banning the guns was to prep for a credit disaster, the timelines dont match up, and even if we DIDNT have these weapons, if there truly were a fully destabilizing credit collapse, and there was some sort of revolution, its still a few a couple milling people looking at hundreds of millions of people armed and unarmed, in multiple possible LA riot type situations, or worse. 
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: spanner1751 on January 12, 2013, 05:21:52 PM
Here is a video presentation from the CATO Institute with their take on what the president could do through executive order.

The Second Amendment in 2013:

The Second Amendment in 2013 (David B. Kopel) (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6swSM_nqCnk#ws)



Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Bunker on January 12, 2013, 06:10:45 PM
Here is a video presentation from the CATO Institute with their take on what the president could do through executive order.

The Second Amendment in 2013:

The Second Amendment in 2013 (David B. Kopel) (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6swSM_nqCnk#ws)




Excellent video from the think tank. I had an opportunity to interview a bunch of the Cato folks when I was doing my graduate capstone course in DC many years ago. They say they are unbiased but just depends with those folks.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: xer 21 on January 12, 2013, 06:33:29 PM
Excellent video from the think tank. I had an opportunity to interview a bunch of the Cato folks when I was doing my graduate capstone course in DC many years ago. They say they are unbiased but just depends with those folks.
as he said, as a whole they are unbiased, but they all have individual positions.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Kulafarmer on January 14, 2013, 07:12:56 AM
Maybe is it possible that a lot of this pro-gun control controversy might be being used as a "red herring" to distract us from the fact that our economy is on the road to ruin?

Gun control legislation can be sensationalized and exploited by the media to spike sales; discussion of how best to address our lack of control of our fiscal policies... not so much...

you can bet its a distraction, but it is also an effort by the elected officials and the ruling elite to remove our ability to do anything about any of it, NDAA, then you have this crap about more bans more limits,,,
to hell with these jerks, I already registered everything when it was bought, IM NOT REGISTERING ANYTHING AGAIN.
I dont care, our country is bankrupt, the costs of everything are going through the roof, my electric bill for example, same useage over a year ago, but it is mysteriously over 100$ higher now, health care? what healthcare? having to pay for an insurance policy that I wont use is called a ripoff,,, IM NOT BUYING IT.
dont kid yourselves guys, we are about to be screwed by those who would say they represent us, the question is, where do we go from here????
to the trees and live like the criminals that we will all be portrayed as by MSM if we dont surrender our Magpuls and go and get finger printed and pictures taken and our hardware inspected by ATF?
Fuck that crap,
Not going to just go along with any more of this shit period.
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: mln41 on January 14, 2013, 07:08:22 PM
you can bet its a distraction, but it is also an effort by the elected officials and the ruling elite to remove our ability to do anything about any of it, NDAA, then you have this crap about more bans more limits,,,
to hell with these jerks, I already registered everything when it was bought, IM NOT REGISTERING ANYTHING AGAIN.
I dont care, our country is bankrupt, the costs of everything are going through the roof, my electric bill for example, same useage over a year ago, but it is mysteriously over 100$ higher now, health care? what healthcare? having to pay for an insurance policy that I wont use is called a ripoff,,, IM NOT BUYING IT.
dont kid yourselves guys, we are about to be screwed by those who would say they represent us, the question is, where do we go from here????
to the trees and live like the criminals that we will all be portrayed as by MSM if we dont surrender our Magpuls and go and get finger printed and pictures taken and our hardware inspected by ATF?
Fuck that crap,
Not going to just go along with any more of this shit period.



is it a distraction because of the economy or is it because of the economy and they're not trying to make it a distraction?  just saying
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Coconut-kid on January 14, 2013, 07:34:52 PM
From today.       http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/barackobama/9801439/Barack-Obama-admits-gun-control-laws-may-fail.html (http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/barackobama/9801439/Barack-Obama-admits-gun-control-laws-may-fail.html)
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: mln41 on January 14, 2013, 07:51:06 PM
From today.       http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/barackobama/9801439/Barack-Obama-admits-gun-control-laws-may-fail.html (http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/barackobama/9801439/Barack-Obama-admits-gun-control-laws-may-fail.html)


interesting he says he's not interested in politics just what makes sense. 
Title: Re: Exec. Orders to TAKE Guns
Post by: Bunker on January 14, 2013, 08:49:27 PM
Sure sounds like he's coming after AWS and hi-cap mags from that video. He mentions people who hunt or use guns for sporting don't have nothing to worry about. Fancy way of saying he's against assault type weapons and hi-cap mags.