2aHawaii
Tools and Uses => Firearms and Accessories => Topic started by: Dolomite on January 25, 2013, 12:09:38 PM
-
So why does everyone bash glocks? Is it a particular model, is it because its polymer, or just glocks in general?
-
They're reliable, and fairly cheap. Just like Hondas. Why do people hate Hondas?
-
Because they have all the ergonomic qualities of a brick. Because a bad trigger doesn't make a good safety. All this "loooooook the gun back into the holster", "reholster sloooooooowly", stuff started because Glock decided that it was a good idea to put a double-action trigger pull on a pistol with no safety. Oh, GLOCK's got a safe action trigger? It won't fire unless the trigger is pulled completely to the rear? Congratulations, you've developed a trigger that does precisely the same thing as virtually every modern handgun sold.
If you wouldn't carry a revolver cocked and locked, why would you carry a GLOCK?
-
good points. I didn't like the stock trigger on my glock so I replaced it with a ghost ultimate trigger. I also don't leave it cocked. At least with my sig I can leave it chambered and uncocked
-
Man even the haters have one glock in their safe. :thumbsup: They are what they are.
-
If anything, I've seen more people think glocks are the greatest thing to spit lead. I've learned a long time ago that the ergo's on all double stack glock's are not for me.......BTW........I love my G36 ;D
-
Man even the haters have one glock in their safe. :thumbsup: They are what they are.
Not this guy. Never will, either! :grrr:
-
I saw a Glock 23 fire out of battery (it slam fired before the slide was fully closed), twice. The second time was after it had been back to Glock to be "fixed" (the chamber was bulged enough after the first time that it wouldn't close; all Glock did was to grind off the high spot, leaving the chamber oversize).
I has a 21 for a while, but the safety (such as it is, and what there is of it) always spooked me.
-
I love my glock 23. One of my top favorites in my safe. I'm not worried about the safety because I learned a long time ago that its not the safety that makes the firearm safe. It's keeping your finger off the trigger till you decide to shoot that makes the gun safe.
I saw a Glock 23 fire out of battery (it slam fired before the slide was fully closed), twice. The second time was after it had been back to Glock to be "fixed" (the chamber was bulged enough after the first time that it wouldn't close; all Glock did was to grind off the high spot, leaving the chamber oversize).
I has a 21 for a while, but the safety (such as it is, and what there is of it) always spooked me.
Slam fires are almost always caused by a firing pin issue. Clean your gun, inspect, lube and you won't have to worry about it.
-
Not this guy. Never will, either! :grrr:
Oh stop.
You loved shooting my Glock.
Give in to the dark side, Luke...
It is your destiny.
-
Oh stop.
You loved shooting my Glock.
Give in to the dark side, Luke...
It is your destiny.
Luke didn't give in, and neither will I!
-
one of my good friends had two glocks explode on him within 30 shots a piece.
obviously just really shitty luck, but enough that i'm wary of Glocks.
-
one of my good friends had two glocks explode on him within 30 shots a piece.
obviously just really shitty luck, but enough that i'm wary of Glocks.
We're they 22 or 23?
There have been some reports of kabooms with mainly the 40 cal Glocks. They are still pretty rare given the quantity of them out in use.
-
one of my good friends had two glocks explode on him within 30 shots a piece.
obviously just really shitty luck, but enough that i'm wary of Glocks.
I'm calling bullshit
-
one of my good friends had two glocks explode on him within 30 shots a piece.
obviously just really shitty luck, but enough that i'm wary of Glocks.
What ammo was he using? Factory? Reloads?
-
I'm calling bullshit
im dead serious.
im not saying people shouldnt buy glocks. his situation was obviously a 1 in a billion.
-
one of my good friends had two glocks explode on him within 30 shots a piece.
obviously just really shitty luck, but enough that i'm wary of Glocks.
If this is a true story, just about the only way that this could be possible statistically is if the ammo was the problem, or the 2 pistols were made on the same day, on the same production line, with the same miss in quality control.
However, I will again say that if it is true, I would bet that your friend used hand loads that were not correct, or had a really bad batch of factory loads. The majority of failures are pretty easy to surmise if it was an issue with the ammo. On the plus side, I have known Glock to take care of these issues even when it is obviously an ammo issue.
-
If this is a true story, just about the only way that this could be possible statistically is if the ammo was the problem, or the 2 pistols were made on the same day, on the same production line, with the same miss in quality control.
However, I will again say that if it is true, I would bet that your friend used hand loads that were not correct, or had a really bad batch of factory loads. The majority of failures are pretty easy to surmise if it was an issue with the ammo. On the plus side, I have known Glock to take care of these issues even when it is obviously an ammo issue.
well, he probably wasnt using hand loads, it was a duty weapon. both were .40's if it matters.
ammo seems like the likely culprit. this happened a couple years ago.
but it is true. he had some nasty looking shrapnel wounds in his hand and wrist from the first one.
-
one of my good friends had two glocks explode on him within 30 shots a piece.
obviously just really shitty luck, but enough that i'm wary of Glocks.
Have any pictures?
-
one of my good friends had two glocks explode on him within 30 shots a piece.
obviously just really shitty luck, but enough that i'm wary of Glocks.
Your friend lied to you.
-
Have any pictures?
i can ask him to resend them to me.
-
Your friend lied to you.
why is it so hard to believe that just maybe, one person might have gotten really shitty luck?
a glock is like any other machine. all guns can break. if you want to believe he lied to me, fine. i dont really care. i just brought up a friend's experience. you're glock probably wont ever explode, and while i'm wary of them, his experiences are so improbable that i dont think it would stop me from owning a glock if i was shopping around and found that i liked how it felt.
i've never even owned a pistol, so i have no opinion of them. i just thought a thread about glocks would be an appropriate time to share an odd story.
-
Man. Stop the trolling already. Glocks are good guns. So are many others. Make a decision get one of them and be happy. There is never a perfect 100% gun. Other wise there wouldn't be so many choices.
-
why is it so hard to believe that just maybe, one person might have gotten really shitty luck?
a glock is like any other machine. all guns can break. if you want to believe he lied to me, fine. i dont really care. i just brought up a friend's experience. you're glock probably wont ever explode, and while i'm wary of them, his experiences are so improbable that i dont think it would stop me from owning a glock if i was shopping around and found that i liked how it felt.
i've never even owned a pistol, so i have no opinion of them. i just thought a thread about glocks would be an appropriate time to share an odd story.
The only time I've heard of any gun exploding is when someone used reloads or the wrong type of ammo in their firearm.
I've heard of Glocks going boom too but every single time it was because someone had lead bullets or reloads.
If your story were of a friend having a "kaboom" I wouldn't of batted an eye, but to say two different guns went boom on rhe same day with factory ammo, I can say without a doubt that someone is full of shit.
-
What happened to my friend's Glock (a 23) was that the track the firing pin rides in got peened enough so that the firing pin got stuck and wouldn't retract. And he doesn't reload; this happened with factory ammo.
Look at the firing pin indent on your spent cases. If it looks like a tadpole (with a tail), then the barrel is starting to drop before the firing pin has retracted, and the back end of the firing pin (which is square) is being shoved upwards against it's track in the slide. Enough of this, and the firing pin will actually cut a groove, which will eventually stop the firing pin from retracting. Then the gun feeds another round and BOOM. This particular problem seem confined to .40 caliber guns, and is easy enough to prevent once you know what to look for (just polish the groove back out before it gets too deep, and round off the sharp edge at the back of the firing pin).
-
The only time I've heard of any gun exploding is when someone used reloads or the wrong type of ammo in their firearm.
I've heard of Glocks going boom too but every single time it was because someone had lead bullets or reloads.
If your story were of a friend having a "kaboom" I wouldn't of batted an eye, but to say two different guns went boom on rhe same day with factory ammo, I can say without a doubt that someone is full of shit.
no, it wasnt the same day
he had one, and it blew on the first shot. he was issued a replacement, and that also blew within a few shots. he had another glock issued to him, and that's still running today years later.
if you think he's full of shit, that's fine. im not about to question his integrity because of your opinion, and i dont blame you for hearing a story this unlikely from someone you dont personally know and thinking its bullshit. but i know it to be true, and that's all i have to say about it.
-
no, it wasnt the same day
he had one, and it blew on the first shot. he was issued a replacement, and that also blew within a few shots. he had another glock issued to him, and that's still running today years later.
I'm assuming he is LE, since you said issued another firearm. Generally if this was his service firearm, the police department would investigate the reason why this happened...any firearm exploding is not taken lightly by any law enforcement agency, especially if this firearm is the standard issue for all officers. Just curious, what police department is he employed by?
I know Glock recommends using only factory new, copper jacketed ammunition and that is because the polygonal rifling they use in their barrels. Sounds like handloads, reload mistake, or wrong ammo to me. Factory double charges or hotloads are extremely rare in my experience. Either way sounds like an ammo issue, which is almost always the case when a gun goes "boom". Just saying one weapon is rare, two is one hell of a coincidence. I would suspect it's not the firearm but something he induced into the equation, and that's why I highly suspect an ammo issue.
-
he's Marshals. he's a friend of some family i have in Maryland.
-
he's Marshals. he's a friend of some family i have in Maryland.
Was just curious because exploding firearms would certainly raise some eyebrows and warrant an investigation in most organizations, especially federal, not to mention two in a short period of time from the same guy. I know if I was the guy issuing the replacements or his supervisor, I'd be thinking :wtf:
-
Was just curious because exploding firearms would certainly raise some eyebrows and warrant an investigation in most organizations, especially federal, not to mention two in a short period of time from the same guy. I know if I was the guy issuing the replacements or his supervisor, I'd be thinking :wtf:
no doubt. its not exactly a plausible situation.
-
I have 3 Glocks (21 and 27) and have put about 4500 rounds through them with zero problems. I use Federal ammunition, FMJ for practice and JHP for carry, with some test firing of JHPs of course.
-
I have 3 Glocks (21 and 27) and have put about 4500 rounds through them with zero problems. I use Federal ammunition, FMJ for practice and JHP for carry, with some test firing of JHPs of course.
Same here...never had any issue with any of mine...never a jam or misfire and I put a lot of rounds through them. I have always used high quality ammo too, usually Federal or Cor-Bon JHP or FMJ.
Basically, know your firearm and ammo, keep it clean and well maintained, and the likelihood of a major issue is negligible.
-
Same here...never had any issue with any of mine...never a jam or misfire and I put a lot of rounds through them. I have always used high quality ammo too, usually Federal or Cor-Bon JHP or FMJ.
Basically, know your firearm and ammo, keep it clean and well maintained, and the likelihood of a major issue is negligible.
I have a 17 Gen 2 with over 9k rounds of military ammunition and approximately 1k reloads through it. I started having FTFeed issues due to my wearing out the return spring. Once I replaced it I stopped having that issue. And now I am getting light strikes so it is time to replace the striker spring. Other than worn out springs this gun has been rock solid in feeding, firing and ejecting. Best gun under $400 I have ever purchased.
-
well, he probably wasnt using hand loads, it was a duty weapon. both were .40's if it matters.
ammo seems like the likely culprit. this happened a couple years ago.
but it is true. he had some nasty looking shrapnel wounds in his hand and wrist from the first one.
OK, not saying it wasn't true, but even you admit that ammo seems to be the likely culprit. Having 2 separate weapons experience catastrophic failures in such close proximity tells the majority of rational people that bad lots of ammo made it out the door and that the ammunition was more than likely the issue and not the weapon. Top notch ammo manufacturers make mistakes from time to time and while a rarity, do the manufacturers may even admit it. I have sent back pallets of bad ammunition to a major manufacturer. It happens. But to attempt to lay blame on a weapon for being faulty due to bad ammunition is irresponsible and hating just to hate and does no one any good. Lets not vilify the weapon as most weapons can go Kaboom when it is an ammo related issue.
-
Anyone own the glock 34 gen 4? I know the barrel is longer but other than that how does it compare to the glock 17?
-
Anyone own the glock 34 gen 4? I know the barrel is longer but other than that how does it compare to the glock 17?
I have a Gen 4 34 and two Gen 4 17s. Longer barrel and the 34 has a cutout in the top of the slide. The 34 is supposed to have a slightly lighter trigger, I think 4.5 lbs compared to 5.5 lbs for the 17/19/etc. The 34 also comes standard with an extended slide stop.
I use the 34 for competition and the 17s for everything else. The 34 is typically $80-100 more than the 17 as well.
Just curious, why are you interested in the 34? I think the 17 is one of the best all-around Glocks. I used to compete with a 17 when I first started and I felt that it was just fine.
-
Just wondering cause the LGS only had the 34 gen 4 in stock and didn't have the glock 17 gen 4 in stock.... I guess everyone purchased all the 17's since there were no assault rifles....
Still deciding whether to wait for 17 gen 4 or just purchase the 34 gen 4....
They did say the longer distance between sights make's it slightly more accurate (assuming shooter does his job) and less recoil....
Just wanted to get opinions from experienced shooters and owners....
-
Don't get the 34 unless you're competing with it.
In my experience, it's much harder to find holsters that fit it properly.
The 17 is a much more versatile firearm than the 34.
The 19 is great too.
-
I'm with KK. I'd wait for a Glock 17 to come back in stock unless you are interested in the gun primarily for competing. I didn't realize the demand on 17s were that high, but I would imagine that the LGSs would get them back in stock regularly.
The Glock 17, or even 19, are better all-around guns than the 34 IMO. While I do very much like and enjoy shooting my 34, I don't think you lose much if you had the 17. Two of my Glock 17 holsters can accommodate the 34, but they are open bottom designs from G-Code. That said, accessories, including holsters, are readily available for the Glock 17 whereas the selection gets a little more limited with the 34.
I wouldn't say the 34 has any less recoil than the 17. It might, but I never really compared the 34 against the 17 in that regard. It's not like recoil is a significant concern with either the 17 or the 19 with a solid grip.
-
I just got off gun broker and guys are asking $599 to $800 for the 17 gen 4, but they have higher cap mags than allowed in Hawaii....
I'll check around the LGS's for the 17....
When I checked before the answer was "it's on backorder and they are not sure when the 17 will be back in stock"
I'll keep calling every so often, hopefully prices have not jumped up too bad....
Is the 34 the newer version for glock?
-
Glocks can't be all that bad if 50 or 60 % or more of LEO carry them. IMO they are safe good reliable firearms .
PS: I love my G 21 gen4 45 acp
-
I just got off gun broker and guys are asking $599 to $800 for the 17 gen 4, but they have higher cap mags than allowed in Hawaii....
I'll check around the LGS's for the 17....
When I checked before the answer was "it's on backorder and they are not sure when the 17 will be back in stock"
I'll keep calling every so often, hopefully prices have not jumped up too bad....
Is the 34 the newer version for glock?
The Gen 4 Glocks are the current versions. The 34 is just a different model than the 17.
You also need to be aware of the recoil spring, of which I believe the current one is marked 0-4-2 for both the Glock 17 and 34. Some people also have some trouble with ejector and in that case, I believe the one that most people have had success with is the 30274.
That said, if you are getting one of recent manufacture, it should have the current components. If you are buying used, you may want to check those components. I believe Glock was sending out the current recoil springs under a RSA program, but mine came with the 0-4-2 spring and I haven't have any problems with any of my Gen 4 Glocks.
Last time I checked on nationwide gun forums, most people report no price premium on handguns at this time, so I wouldn't expect to pay a premium for a Glock 17 or 19. Should be in the $580-$600 range locally. Maybe a little less for Gen 3, which are also still currently being produced by Glock (or at least they were at the end of 2012).
Good luck!
-
Glocks can't be all that bad if 50 or 60 % or more of LEO carry them. IMO they are safe good reliable firearms .
PS: I love my G 21 gen4 45 acp
I disagree with this statement. There are all sorts of factors that play in an agency's selection of a firearm for issue, like the new manufacturer's willingness to "buy back" their existing sidearms and so on, with "best gun for our officers" being fairly far down the list. For example, the FBI didn't start issuing semi-automatic pistols to their agents until the 80's, and even then, the first guys to get semi-autos were tacticool 0perat0rs. About 95% of military sidearms are Beretta M9s. Now, I think the M9 is a fine pistol, but I've heard that some people disagree... I'm just saying that I wouldn't base my judgment of a gun off of what a government entity thinks about it.
-
.
-
Agree that the just because a certain percentage of LEO carry a particular brand/model does not automatically equate to safest/best/most reliable.
*cough* ... lowest bidder for government contracts... *cough*
P.S. I love my gen 3 G19!! :thumbsup:
Haha, touche. :shaka:
-
Because they have all the ergonomic qualities of a brick.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G4O4f6FKYyc (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G4O4f6FKYyc)
Man even the haters have one glock in their safe. :thumbsup: They are what they are.
Not this guy. Never will, either! :grrr:
I'll never got a Glock either. I only have a Sig and Beretta in my safe.
-
But glock has Tori Nonaka on their team!!!!! ;) ;) ;)
What do people normally change out on the glock? Sights? 3.5 ghost bar? Mag well? Etc....
-
But glock has Tori Nonaka on their team!!!!! ;) ;) ;)
What do people normally change out on the glock? Sights? 3.5 ghost bar? Mag well? Etc....
I don't fuss with triggers on Glocks. Just personal opinion
I always upgrade to night sights since I believe that if I ever have to protect myself or family with a pistol there will be a 90% chance that it will be in low light or darkness.
I also always upgrade the slide release lever on Glocks.
That's it for me as far as mandatory changes.
I've used aftermarket barrels in an attempt to get more accuracy but I'm not sure how effective they really are.
-
I don't fuss with triggers on Glocks. Just personal opinion
I always upgrade to night sights since I believe that if I ever have to protect myself or family with a pistol there will be a 90% chance that it will be in low light or darkness.
I also always upgrade the slide release lever on Glocks.
That's it for me as far as mandatory changes.
I've used aftermarket barrels in an attempt to get more accuracy but I'm not sure how effective they really are.
An extra aftermarket barrel is would e good for the reloaders, though. With all the warnings about lead through polygonal rifling, might as well just get a new barrel.
-
I have two Glocks: a G17 and G21; both Gen 4.
Each function flawlessly. It's true that the ergonomics pale in comparison to a Sig, but for the price and the reliability, it's a good gun.
-
I only own one Glock 17 Gen 2. I have changed the mag release and slide release with extended versions, 3.5lb connector, and when I had to replace the factory plastic guide rod and return spring I did so with a stainless steel one. Also, replaced stock sights with the fiber optic/tritium type for use in low light situations. I also have a Hogue sleeve on it to make it fit my hand better. I need to replace the other springs in it as they are worn as well. I have ordered factory springs (Not going to compromise reliability for a lighter trigger). I don't know if I am going to add the mag well extension or not. I have not decided. I don't usually have a problem doing fast mag changes so I am probably not going to do it.
-
I've been thinking about a Glock 19 gen 4 or Glock 26 gen 4 but have been reading that the extractor is an issue which is causing a lot of erratic brass flying into face and stuff. It's only the 9mm thats having this problem. I'm wondering if current owners of these 2 models can verify if indeed there is a problem. Apex makes an aftermarket extractor which supposedly will fix this issue but is currently sold out!
-
I've been thinking about a Glock 19 gen 4 or Glock 26 gen 4 but have been reading that the extractor is an issue which is causing a lot of erratic brass flying into face and stuff. It's onlyy the 9mm thats having this problem. I'm wondering if current owners of these 2 models can verify if indeed there is a problem. Apex makes an aftermarket extractor which supposedly will fix this issue but is currently sold out!
I have three Gen 4 Glocks. 2-17s and a 34 and no ejection problems or brass to the face. I have the current RSA spring and ejector (30274 or something like that). However, I heard that the 19 has been little more problematic, both the Gen 3 and Gen 4.
-
I have a g19 gen3, was about to get the g17 gen4, but was concerned about the issues. Picked up the M&P 9 FS instead.
The M&P feels really good in the hand, but I shoot the g19 better.
Maybe I will try the g17 after all.
-
Honolulu firearms has a glock 17 gen 4 in stock, but that's the only glock...
Is there a glock shortage in Hawaii?
-
How much was that going for? The other day young guns just got in a 17 and 20 I bought the 20 but regret not buying the 17 too
-
Sorry didn't ask, but seen it at closing today. They took the prices off all the guns, everything had to be called out for prices. "Price check"
Give them a call first thing in the morning.
They did have a custom competition glock 34 on consignment...
-
I've owned quite a few Glocks and have put thousands of rounds through them. No, they aren't "PRETTY", but they do work and work well. My recent addition is a 4th generation model 21 .45acp. I got the chance to put some rounds through it the other day and I simply love it. Very controllable and accurate. But, like all things it's a matter of preference......Glocks, Sigs,Springfields or Smith & Wessons. I don't think you could go wrong with any of these. :shaka:
-
glock G34's are great guns, I'd recommend one! longer sight radius=better for shooting accuracy. Etiher way, IDK why people say a G19 or G17 is better all around considering you cant ccw in hawaii (and if your gonna ccw, why not go with the g26? it carries 10 rounds just like the big boys do). It's also is the same the size as a 1911 and a lot of people ccw those so its sorta a moot point. G34 has a lighter connector (4.5 lbs trigger pull instead of the 5.5 lbs others have) as well as an extended slide release already installed stock. The longer barrel also allows you to get better velocity out of your rounds (they say regular rounds go to +p and +p goes to +p+).
-
.
-
Please see revision, above, in red, bold, underlined text.
One can hope that bruddah Funtimes' case results in a positive outcome, right?!? :thumbsup:
I hope to god he does get his ccw.
-
.
-
anyone put grips on their glocks? which ones?
-
anyone out grips on their glocks? which ones?
Used to use Pachmeyers but now I use Hogues. The Hogue has a palmswell that fits my hand well.
-
I love glocks. It's the toughest most reliable pistol out there. Every handgun should be a glock. Every glock should be a 9mm. And every 9mm glock should be a glock 19
-
anyone put grips on their glocks? which ones?
I had talon grips (Granulate) on my gen3 26. its likes skate board tape. really helped and didnt add width to the grip like the hogue i had on before. dont like glocks gen 1-3 slippery grips.
-
I have a gen 2 model 17. I used to use Pachmyer sleeve then one day I couldn't find them so I went with Hogue. I like the Hogue but the Pachmyer was better IMHO.
-
any LGS sell the grips? I got a gen 3 that is need of new stippling or grips that do not increase width....
-
I love glocks. It's the toughest most reliable pistol out there. Every handgun should be a glock. Every glock should be a 9mm. And every 9mm glock should be a glock 19
no thanks.
variety is the spice of life, and every other gun out there has something to offer that the glock doesnt, and vice versa.
-
any LGS sell the grips? I got a gen 3 that is need of new stippling or grips that do not increase width....
young guns and security used to have houge grips dont know if they have anymore. talon grips are online only.
-
I love glocks. It's the toughest most reliable pistol out there. Every handgun should be a glock. Every glock should be a 9mm. And every 9mm glock should be a glock 19
pro 2A , commie ;D
-
I've heard great things about the Grip Force adapters that go on the back strap of Glocks. I've been wanting to try one for a while, but since it's not allowed for USPSA production guns, I don't want to be going back and forth between a gun with it and a gun without it.
-
.
-
Is that you, Mr. Yeager?!? :shaka:
if it was, he'd have made a post about how 1911's suck.