2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: digital808 on March 29, 2013, 03:27:29 PM
-
True story! 2 pit bulls roaming around the street and attacks a neighbors dog. Neighbors dog sustained injuries but police and human society couldn't do anything because dogs ran back onto their property. A week later, same 2 dogs roam the area again. This time one of the dogs decides to come crashing into my mom's home crashing thru the screen door and attacked my mom's puppy! Basically the dog is in the house with my mom's puppy in mouth! Mom is hysterical and starts to run out of the house and into the garage. The second dog comes around the house and starts to trap my mom in the open garage! Mom is screaming for help. Luckily neighbor hears the commotion and comes out to investigate. Seeing what is happening, he grabs a water hose and starts to shoot the dogs with water. Luckily, it works! Dogs releases my mom's puppy and runs away! Unfortunately, my mom's dog was didn't make it. All of this happened on my mom's property! If I was home, would I have been justified to stop the threat of the 2 dogs? Basically, the dogs were in "attack" mode already! Police and Human Society once again couldn't catch the dogs because it ran back to their property!
This happened years ago but now that I think about it, I know the answer! I would have done anything possible to stop the threat including using my firearm. These are 2 pit bulls we dealing with. One dog has already tasted blood, and already mauled another dog a week prior. Who knows what they would have done to my mom if her neighbor didn't come to her rescue!
-
Yes.
-
Yes.
I'm curious, did you run this question past the responding officers and humane society workers? What was their response?
-
Wow that is scary.
Good question though. I would think so.
What about the owner(s) of the pit bulls, did they have anything to say? Did they pay for the damages?
Luckily your mom's neighbor came out and acted quickly.
-
:)
-
You'd have to be really, really fearful for life in order to use deadly force here in HI.
(http://mlkshk.com/r/IC4Z)
-
but does it count as deadly force if the targets are dogs? how does the law read on stopping animals? is it any different?
-
Shooting the dog with the puppy in its mouth. NO. You will be charged with wreckless endangerment. Hitting the dog with a stick to get the puppy out of the mouth or water hose is OK.
Shooting the dog growling at your mom. NO. If the dog jumps on your mom and you shoot the dog and prove the dog was an endangerment to your moms life you MIGHT NOT be charged. But still can be.
It will be up to the sargent on duty. Now if the dog jumped on you and you feared for your life and you shot the dog then that will be justified.
I asked my friend who is a HPD Sargent....
Any discharge of a firearm in the eye of HPD is a no no in their book. They are sometimes told to arrest the shooter and ask questions later.
He also mentioned if it was an officer he would just shoot the dogs and ask questions later....
-
Shooting the dog with the puppy in its mouth. NO. You will be charged with wreckless endangerment. Hitting the dog with a stick to get the puppy out of the mouth or water hose is OK.
Shooting the dog growling at your mom. NO. If the dog jumps on your mom and you shoot the dog and prove the dog was an endangerment to your moms life you MIGHT NOT be charged. But still can be.
It will be up to the sargent on duty. Now if the dog jumped on you and you feared for your life and you shot the dog then that will be justified.
I asked my friend who is a HPD Sargent....
Any discharge of a firearm in the eye of HPD is a no no in their book. They are sometimes told to arrest the shooter and ask questions later.
He also mentioned if it was an officer he would just shoot the dogs and ask questions later....
i thought that was a given. or was that just for a self defense shooting where someone is hit?
-
Yes.
I'm curious, did you run this question past the responding officers and humane society workers? What was their response?
No. Wasn't there when this incident happened!
-
If more people ate dog this wouldn't be a problem.
-
You'd have to be really, really fearful for life in order to use deadly force here in HI.
(http://mlkshk.com/r/IC4Z)
........or rape, sodomy, & maiming.
-
Shooting the dog with the puppy in its mouth. NO. You will be charged with wreckless endangerment. Hitting the dog with a stick to get the puppy out of the mouth or water hose is OK.
Shooting the dog growling at your mom. NO. If the dog jumps on your mom and you shoot the dog and prove the dog was an endangerment to your moms life you MIGHT NOT be charged. But still can be.
It will be up to the sargent on duty. Now if the dog jumped on you and you feared for your life and you shot the dog then that will be justified.
I asked my friend who is a HPD Sargent....
Any discharge of a firearm in the eye of HPD is a no no in their book. They are sometimes told to arrest the shooter and ask questions later.
He also mentioned if it was an officer he would just shoot the dogs and ask questions later....
I disagree slightly in your assessment: Yes, it might be difficult to "justify" shooting the dog attacking the puppy but it also wouldn't be hard to justify a legitimate concern for your own safety when trying to rescue the puppy, especially if when doing so the dog exhibited any hint of aggression toward you. That concern for your safety could reasonably be assumed to justify the use of a firearm against the attacking dog. Furthermore, the dog who cornered your mother presented a credible and legitimate threat and could have, IMHO, been shot then. As the Supreme Court said in Brown, "Detached reflection cannot be demanded in the presence of an uplifted knife." The dog, in light of its history of violence, and the actions of the other dog, was clearly a threat. And while the police at the scene may have taken exception to a mere peon having the audacity to protect his family, in his home, with a firearm, I doubt a jury would have come to the same conclusion.
-
My friend also said it would be up to the Sargent on duty to make the call. Then let the courts decide.
This just sucks. I would just take care of the immediate threat. I would not deal with the puppy. My opinion on this based on living in Hawaii. If I was in AZ or TX to hell with the dogs! Shoot em and eat em!
-
Need to get proficient with baseball bat and/or machete.
-
To the person who said that the puppy was only property and not a life, well IF that's true then the attacking dog was just property too, and there should be no problem shooting it. ;D
-
:)
-
Need to get proficient with baseball bat and/or machete.
I can see people cutting off their own feet with a machete.
-
Killing the dogs not so much the problem. More so the discharge of a firearm. Hitting the dog with a bat or stabbing it with a knife ultimately killing the dog most likely not an issue if in your home. You have the right to feel safe in your own home in in this situation where else would your mom have retreated to where she would have been reasonablly safe?
-
Interesting article in this mornings paper (page A12) titled "Shooting of dog by police spurs Colorado bill require training".
I remember one time (about 3-4yrs ago) a puppy pitbull took down a fence and ran after a boy who was walking his puppy. All I heard was a crash and saw the dog chasing the boy and his dog. The was boys screaming frantically while his dog was attached to its leash. I called 911 and after a few moments, ran up to try and help the boy. One of the neighbor "maced" the dog. Dog was going wild when he got sprayed in the face. Police took over 45min to get to the scene. I was truly afraid for the boy and his dog!
Eventually the owner of the pitbull had to surrender the dog to the human society because of other complaints from other neighbors from my understanding!
-
I disagree slightly in your assessment: Yes, it might be difficult to "justify" shooting the dog attacking the puppy but it also wouldn't be hard to justify a legitimate concern for your own safety when trying to rescue the puppy, especially if when doing so the dog exhibited any hint of aggression toward you. That concern for your safety could reasonably be assumed to justify the use of a firearm against the attacking dog. Furthermore, the dog who cornered your mother presented a credible and legitimate threat and could have, IMHO, been shot then. As the Supreme Court said in Brown, "Detached reflection cannot be demanded in the presence of an uplifted knife." The dog, in light of its history of violence, and the actions of the other dog, was clearly a threat. And while the police at the scene may have taken exception to a mere peon having the audacity to protect his family, in his home, with a firearm, I doubt a jury would have come to the same conclusion.
Wrong, you cannot claim self-defense when you put yourself in danger. Remember the court makes judgements based on the reasonable person test. What would a reasonable person of average intelligence do when faced with the same situation. A reasonable person would not get a gun and start pumping lead into the dogs. A reasonable person would not put themselves in grave danger to protect a puppy.
-
Wrong, you cannot claim self-defense when you put yourself in danger. Remember the court makes judgements based on the reasonable person test. What would a reasonable person of average intelligence do when faced with the same situation. A reasonable person would not get a gun and start pumping lead into the dogs. A reasonable person would not put themselves in grave danger to protect a puppy.
If said dog broke through a door to kill the puppy, then I would argue the person has the reasonable assumption that they are next. With a dog in this predatory mode, you run, you might be the next target. IMHO it would be justified. You aren't running away from the dog, it's too fast........and you aren't hiding, because it's smelling you out.
-
If said dog broke through a door to kill the puppy, then I would argue the person has the reasonable assumption that they are next. With a dog in this predatory mode, you run, you might be the next target. IMHO it would be justified. You aren't running away from the dog, it's too fast........and you aren't hiding, because it's smelling you out.
If said dog broke through the door you leave the puppy and get the fuck out before you are next.
-
If said dog broke through the door you leave the puppy and get the fuck out before you are next.
+1. Then all you gotta do is out run the puppy. :thumbsup:
-
According to this new line of argument, if an armed burglar broke into your home in the middle of the night and you directly encountered him, you have no choice but to throw down your arms and flee for your life because that's what a "reasonable person" would do.
I can't go along with that. I would say these attacking dogs were like burglars armed with knives. In some ways, they are even more dangerous, because they can't be reasoned with and they were already in the process of killing something when found. A burglar, when found, would only be digging through your stuff looking for something to steal.
Furthermore, let's imagine that we were not talking about 2 attacking dogs here, but one day you come home and a tiger is in your house. Maybe you could run and make it. But maybe you couldn't. If you somehow managed to get to a shotgun and kill the tiger in this unlikely scenario, I doubt you'd have to worry afterwards.
So how are the dogs different than a tiger? The only difference is their size, and whether or not you give a damn about someone else's dog. I think a "reasonable person" could make the decision to shoot the attacking dogs.
-
All I can picture is you running from pitbull, being chased by puppy getting chased by pitbull.
Hahahahaha
-
Gotta remember now.....my mom did run out but the other dog was outside waiting! Basically....she was surrounded!
-
:)
-
If said dog broke through the door you leave the puppy and get the fuck out before you are next.
Again, one you aren't outrunning a dog, and two you never run from predators as it can trigger their predatory response........in other words you are the next chew toy.
-
It's the frickin owner of the dogs that should be shot. :shaka:
-
It's the frickin owner of the dogs that should be shot. :shaka:
I Agree :thumbsup:
-
Wrong, you cannot claim self-defense when you put yourself in danger. Remember the court makes judgements based on the reasonable person test. What would a reasonable person of average intelligence do when faced with the same situation. A reasonable person would not get a gun and start pumping lead into the dogs. A reasonable person would not put themselves in grave danger to protect a puppy.
Wrong. I can use what force deemed necessary to intercede on behalf of securing my property. I could try to prevent a thief from running off with my TV by tackling him and attempting to wrest the item away from him. I couldn't immediately use deadly force, but assuming I tried to just stop him from taking my stuff, I could justifiably use force. If while exercising that right, the actor decided to fight back and produce a knife or gun, I could, quite justifiably, escalate my level of force to deadly force. Same for the dog.
-
Remember the court makes judgements based on the reasonable person test. What would a reasonable person of average intelligence do when faced with the same situation.
You might have to factor in how low that average is compared to 20 or 30 years ago!! Just saying ... :'(
-
A reasonable person would not put themselves in grave danger to protect a puppy.
If you think a "reasonable" person would not get their dog, being mauled or attacked by another dog, and put themselves into harms way to do so- you are so far off the planet it's not even close. Please remember, these are people's "children" i.e. they sleep in their beds, they feed them, they clothe them, medically care for them. We have raised them, invested into them (training, education, security for home etc.), come after my dogs and you will likely not enjoy the outcome.
-
If you think a "reasonable" person would not get their dog, being mauled or attacked by another dog, and put themselves into harms way to do so- you are so far off the planet it's not even close. Please remember, these are people's "children" i.e. they sleep in their beds, they feed them, they clothe them, medically care for them. We have raised them, invested into them (training, education, security for home etc.), come after my dogs and you will likely not enjoy the outcome.
Nick Memphis:
You can hire a good lawyer, and I'll call the Bureau.
They can work out some kind of deal.
This is explainable. You can prove that you didn't shoot the Archbishop.
Bob Lee Swagger:
I don't think you understand.
These boys killed my dog.
-from the movie Shooter-
-
"Deadly force" means force which the actor uses with the intent of causing or which the actor knows to create a substantial risk of causing death or serious bodily harm. Intentionally firing a firearm in the direction of another person or in the direction which another person is believed to be constitutes deadly force. A threat to cause death or serious bodily injury, by the production of a weapon or otherwise, so long as the actor's intent is limited to creating an apprehension that the actor will use deadly force if necessary, does not constitute deadly force.
Deadly force pertains to people. Dogs are not people, and are afforded much less protection under law. Ergo, if you could take the life of a human being for committing some act, you can damn sure take the life of a dog. The only question is whether or not you'd get hung up for recklessly discharging a firearm, which is a distinct possibility in this lovely state. Personally, I'd shoot that mutt first and then figure out how much trouble I was in.
(Maybe I'd put the pistol away and stick a big old lineup bar in one of the bullet holes. "Shoot him? Not me, Officer, I stabbed that sumbeetch with a prick bar!")
-
Kentucky has their dog bite laws with this:
Any person, without liability, may kill or seize any dog which is observed attacking any person.
http://dogbitelaw.com/statutory-strict-liability-state/kentucky-dog-bite-law.html (http://dogbitelaw.com/statutory-strict-liability-state/kentucky-dog-bite-law.html)
As usual, Hawaii law is silent on self-defense against dog attacks. It only addresses the AFTERMATH of legal rights and responsibilities.
http://dogbitelaw.com/mixed-dog-bite-statute-states/hawaii-dog-bite-law.html (http://dogbitelaw.com/mixed-dog-bite-statute-states/hawaii-dog-bite-law.html)
-
If while exercising that right, the actor decided to fight back and produce a knife or gun, I could, quite justifiably, escalate my level of force to deadly force. Same for the dog.
Last I checked, dogs don't carry knifes or guns... But I guess in your world anything is possible.
If you think a "reasonable" person would not get their dog, being mauled or attacked by another dog, and put themselves into harms way to do so- you are so far off the planet it's not even close. Please remember, these are people's "children" i.e. they sleep in their beds, they feed them, they clothe them, medically care for them. We have raised them, invested into them (training, education, security for home etc.), come after my dogs and you will likely not enjoy the outcome.
Who cares if that person thinks their dog is their child. It's not what that persons perception is. It's what the court recognizes as a person that matters. I would love to see you try to explain to a judge how you negligently fired your handgun in a populated area, at a dog that was attacking your puppy. I'm pretty sure you can say bye bye to your guns because 1st degree reckless endangerment is a felony.
-
Last I checked, dogs don't carry knifes or guns... But I guess in your world anything is possible.
Who cares if that person thinks their dog is their child. It's not what that persons perception is. It's what the court recognizes as a person that matters. I would love to see you try to explain to a judge how you negligently fired your handgun in a populated area, at a dog that was attacking your puppy. I'm pretty sure you can say bye bye to your guns because 1st degree reckless endangerment is a felony.
RECKLESS ENDANGERING
Discharging a firearm toward a populated area or on or toward a street or road is reckless endangering. This can apply to private ranges, plinking, negligent discharges, and self-defense use.
-
Last I checked, dogs don't carry knifes or guns... But I guess in your world anything is possible.
Who cares if that person thinks their dog is their child. It's not what that persons perception is. It's what the court recognizes as a person that matters. I would love to see you try to explain to a judge how you negligently fired your handgun in a populated area, at a dog that was attacking your puppy. I'm pretty sure you can say bye bye to your guns because 1st degree reckless endangerment is a felony.
Truth is none of us know what would happen until it happens.
I realize that in your mind in no way should you be able to defend yourself from a dog with a firearm. I will say that you have never seen the pit bull that my uncle raised to hunt pigs. That thing was nasty. As a little puppy, it was cool and I played with it. After it grew up it was huge. I remember hearing a story where it got in a fight with another dog and ended up ripping the dog's tail off.
Remember that one does not need to fear for death to use deadly force. It's a reasonable assumption + maiming and to me that's enough.
Hopefully none of us has to find out.
-
I'd just keep a big can of mace near the front door. Less lethal with plenty of oomph.
-
I will say that you have never seen the pit bull that my uncle raised to hunt pigs. That thing was nasty. As a little puppy, it was cool and I played with it. After it grew up it was huge.
Remember that one does not need to fear for death to use deadly force.
Don't assume.... My parents raised and bred red nose pit bulls for money. One thing I learned is its not the dog, its the owner and their training/ treatment of the dog that matters.
Last I checked, you need to believe that you were faced with deadly force to justify using deadly force in self defense. I would love to see you explain to the judge and jury that you didn't fear death and you wasnt really sure that you were going to die, but you used deadly force "just in case". Haha. Can you say "I'm bubba bitch" for the next 10-20 years.
-
I don't know much about dogs. What are some other potentially dangerous breeds of dog? The pitbulls I've seen have usually looked sort of small, sad, and gentle to me...compared to the other kinds of BIG and aggressive dogs that I have seen.
Lots of big dog breeds are gentle too. But those big ones that charge and go berserk, foaming at the mouth at any person they see are pretty threatening.
-
Any breed can be potentially dangerous. 9 times out of 10 aggressive behavior in a dog is due to abuse, maltreatment, or general ignorance of the owner. Train your dogs, acclimate them to be around people, other dogs, etc. When I lived on the mainland me and my dad took our dog everywhere, he even chilled in the truck while we were at the range.
Also don't get a high energy or working breed if you can't give the dog the time of day to expend said energy. Too many people do so and then complain when the pent up energy results in behavioral problems.
-
Any breed can be potentially dangerous. 9 times out of 10 aggressive behavior in a dog is due to abuse, maltreatment, or general ignorance of the owner. Train your dogs, acclimate them to be around people, other dogs, etc. When I lived on the mainland me and my dad took our dog everywhere, he even chilled in the truck while we were at the range.
Also don't get a high energy or working breed if you can't give the dog the time of day to expend said energy. Too many people do so and then complain when the pent up energy results in behavioral problems.
+1 :thumbsup:
-
Let me rephrase the question. What dog breeds have a reputation or tendency towards being dangerous or aggressive toward humans? I'm asking because I always hear people saying pitbull, but pitbulls have never seemed to be near the top of the list to me, based on all the large and vicious dogs I have seen during my lifetime which were not pit bulls, but I'm not sure what breed they were.
-
Let me rephrase the question. What dog breeds have a reputation or tendency towards being dangerous or aggressive toward humans? I'm asking because I always hear people saying pitbull, but pitbulls have never seemed to be near the top of the list to me, based on all the large and vicious dogs I have seen during my lifetime which were not pit bulls, but I'm not sure what breed they were.
The breeds most likely to kill
http://dogbitelaw.com/dog-bite-statistics/the-breeds-most-likely-to-kill.html (http://dogbitelaw.com/dog-bite-statistics/the-breeds-most-likely-to-kill.html)
Studies indicate that pit bull-type dogs were involved in approximately a third of human DBRF (i.e., dog bite related fatalities) reported during the 12-year period from 1981 through1992, and Rottweilers were responsible for about half of human DBRF reported during the 4 years from 1993 through 1996....[T]he data indicate that Rottweilers and pit bull-type dogs accounted for 67% of human DBRF in the United States between 1997 and 1998. It is extremely unlikely that they accounted for anywhere near 60% of dogs in the United States during that same period and, thus, there appears to be a breed-specific problem with fatalities."
-
Quick question. Wouldn't it be quicker and more accessable to grab a knife from the kitchen or blunt object like a shovel or rake... shoot a hammer in the garage than run in the house open your safe to grab your gun? Just saying :thumbsup:
-
Not sure about others on here, but my pistol is always within reach
-
Not sure about others on here, but my pistol is always within reach
I'm with you on that bro but the vast majority of gun owners don't. Even cops don't carry 100% of the time.
-
Don't assume.... My parents raised and bred red nose pit bulls for money. One thing I learned is its not the dog, its the owner and their training/ treatment of the dog that matters.
Last I checked, you need to believe that you were faced with deadly force to justify using deadly force in self defense. I would love to see you explain to the judge and jury that you didn't fear death and you wasnt really sure that you were going to die, but you used deadly force "just in case". Haha. Can you say "I'm bubba bitch" for the next 10-20 years.
Negative............fear of maiming is also justification in addition to rape/sodomy/kidnapping. It does not have to be death.
It can also be contributing factors such as disparity of force..........so big powerful dog attacking versus small dog. Smaller attacking dog vs. child. Several men against a single person. Man against woman (barring some of the samoan gals who buss up their hubbies).
Below is the link to the applicable HRS. You will notice that I have highlighted the maiming section [703-304(2)], also that you do not have to retreat from your house [703-304(5)(b)(i)]. Again regardless of how the dog got the way it was, the fact that it broke through a door and killed something, to me (a reasonable person), means that I most certainly could be next. Fleeing can lead to trigger of a predatory response. With this all in mind and the fact that I have to act quickly means that I feel justified in using a firearm to stop the threat. Now this said, I am responsible for each and every round I fire. So if I miss and endanger someone, then it's on me.
http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/vol14_Ch0701-0853/HRS0703/HRS_0703-0304.htm (http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/vol14_Ch0701-0853/HRS0703/HRS_0703-0304.htm)
§703-304 Use of force in self-protection. (1) Subject to the provisions of this section and of section 703-308, the use of force upon or toward another person is justifiable when the actor believes that such force is immediately necessary for the purpose of protecting himself against the use of unlawful force by the other person on the present occasion.
(2) The use of deadly force is justifiable under this section if the actor believes that deadly force is necessary to protect himself against death, serious bodily injury, kidnapping, rape, or forcible sodomy.
(3) Except as otherwise provided in subsections (4) and (5) of this section, a person employing protective force may estimate the necessity thereof under the circumstances as he believes them to be when the force is used without retreating, surrendering possession, doing any other act which he has no legal duty to do, or abstaining from any lawful action.
(4) The use of force is not justifiable under this section:
(a) To resist an arrest which the actor knows is being made by a law enforcement officer, although the arrest is unlawful; or
(b) To resist force used by the occupier or possessor of property or by another person on his behalf, where the actor knows that the person using the force is doing so under a claim of right to protect the property, except that this limitation shall not apply if:
(i) The actor is a public officer acting in the performance of his duties or a person lawfully assisting him therein or a person making or assisting in a lawful arrest; or
(ii) The actor believes that such force is necessary to protect himself against death or serious bodily injury.
(5) The use of deadly force is not justifiable under this section if:
(a) The actor, with the intent of causing death or serious bodily injury, provoked the use of force against himself in the same encounter; or
(b) The actor knows that he can avoid the necessity of using such force with complete safety by retreating or by surrendering possession of a thing to a person asserting a claim of right thereto or by complying with a demand that he abstain from any action which he has no duty to take, except that:
(i) The actor is not obliged to retreat from his dwelling or place of work, unless he was the initial aggressor or is assailed in his place of work by another person whose place of work the actor knows it to be; and
(ii) A public officer justified in using force in the performance of his duties, or a person justified in using force in his assistance or a person justified in using force in making an arrest or preventing an escape, is not obliged to desist from efforts to perform his duty, effect the arrest, or prevent the escape because of resistance or threatened resistance by or on behalf of the person against whom the action is directed.
(6) The justification afforded by this section extends to the use of confinement as protective force only if the actor takes all reasonable measures to terminate the confinement as soon as he knows that he safely can, unless the person confined has been arrested on a charge of crime. [L 1972, c 9, pt of §1; ree L 1975, c 163, §3; am L 2001, c 91, §4]
-
Quick question. Wouldn't it be quicker and more accessable to grab a knife from the kitchen or blunt object like a shovel or rake... shoot a hammer in the garage than run in the house open your safe to grab your gun? Just saying :thumbsup:
Depends on the situation. Also depends on what you think is going to end the threat the quickest. A shovel might be good as you can keep the dog at a distance. A knife might be a bad idea as most of us do not know how to use one and it puts us within reach of the dog...........one slip and you are on the ground and the dog is at your throat.
-
Negative............fear of maiming is also justification in addition to rape/sodomy/kidnapping. It does not have to be death.
I thought we were talking about dogs? I guess if you can't stop a dog from kidnapping or sodomizing you then you are justified in using deadly force. You can believe that it is your right to do something up to the point when the judge hands your sentence to you.
-
I thought we were talking about dogs? I guess if you can't stop a dog from kidnapping or sodomizing you then you are justified in using deadly force. You can believe that it is your right to do something up to the point when the judge hands your sentence to you.
Bro...........this is about use of deadly force. So you telling me if a tiger/elephant/etc is running around then you cannot use deadly force to protect yourself? Do you remember Tyke rampaging through Kakaako?
-
Last I checked, dogs don't carry knifes or guns... But I guess in your world anything is possible.
In my world I wouldn't have to deal with idiots that can't figure out a simple analogy. Your purposeful avoidance of meaningful debate about a statement you made and now cannot defend is pretty convincing that in your world, you're an idiot.....
-
Last I checked, dogs don't carry knifes or guns... But I guess in your world anything is possible.
First of all, it's KNIVES, not KNIFES...
Secondly, animals are animals, and their behavior is governed by instinct, reactions, and training. Even the best trained dogs can break from their conditioning and attack a perceived threat, or they could go with the pack mentality mimicking another, less well-trained dog.
These dogs have big enough teeth to inflict the same wounds as effectively as any knife. Your argument about carrying knives or not is irrelevant.
Thirdly, you should stop trying to apply Hawaii statues literally when you KNOW they are pretty much all inadequately written to begin with. The laws are NOT written to keep dogs from attacking. Here, our lawmakers apparently thought addressing liability AFTER an animal attack was sufficient.
LESSON: Whenever the law is silent OR AMBIGUOUS on a specific topic or situation, the correct course is to interpret the law in favor of the citizen rather than the state.
Unless there is case law to the contrary, that's how these things are adjudicated. There need not be a "reasonable person" test nor a "self defense" evaluation. If there are no laws making the killing of attacking dogs illegal, that in and of itself will not be a problem.
The other side of the coin is, you may have to answer for discharging a firearm in a populated/residential area if relevant. But, I doubt anything will come of the specific act of killing the dog/s. If the dog is not under the control of the owner or another person, then the situation is on them, not you.
That's just my unprofessional 2 cents!
I'm not a lawyer, but I did get a very restful sleep last night! :sleeping:
-
.
-
Thanks for the link, moosed. I looked at it and also looked up pics and sizes for some of the various breeds mentioned.
I'd heard about the dangerous potential of Rottweilers, but haven't met any that I can remember.
There seems to be various kinds of pit bulls that vary significantly in size and appearance. At least regarding the smaller ones, I've always thought they weren't too scary and even if I found one rampaging in my house, I might be alright with taking some risk and trying to subdue it with a stick, or just plain physical force.
The pictures that most resembled the large and vicious dogs I've known over my life turned out to be Doberman Pinscher and Great Dane. The actual dogs I knew were probably mixes of these and other breeds. The ones that threaten me the most are the big, tall, and lean ones. They are fast and some of them weigh more than I do.
-
Pit Bulls are not any more aggressive than other breeds. What makes them dangerous is their determination and relentless attacks. First, Pits are not known to bark and growl before attacking. They go straight from docile to attack mode with little to no warning. That by itself means the person or animal in danger has little reaction time. Then, when they are on their "prey", they will not quit! They are in it to win it ... and win means kill!
So, all the Pit bull owners that say, "My dog is the sweetest dog! He wouldn't hurt anyone or anything!" You need to understand. Owning a Pit Bull is like owning a 12 gauge shotgun instead of a .22 pistol. Yours may not be any more likely to cause harm than the other when under your control. But if and when an accident does happen, the result is much worse when you own the 12 gauge/pit bull!!
-
As a former animal control officer I can say is do what u need to do to defened human life. Under hawaii laws and how weak animal related laws are you may get a slap on the wrist. Your biggest issue would be endangering the public for discharging a firearm within city limits. Do what you gotta do just don't get caught doing something stupid and wreckless.
Animals are considered "property" under the law for most part.
Pitbulls are not all bad dogs, like a gun in the wrong hands they can be deadly. I had to respsond to a case in makaha where a owner was giving his pitbull steroids. One day the owner tried to take the dogs food away in the kennel. The dog bit off his skull cap.
I have prob dozens and dozens of crazy stories of dog attack incidents.
Fyi of the 4 times I've been bitten 3x was by min pins and once by a mix Aust
-
Last I checked, dogs don't carry knifes or guns... But I guess in your world anything is possible.
Who cares if that person thinks their dog is their child. It's not what that persons perception is. It's what the court recognizes as a person that matters. I would love to see you try to explain to a judge how you negligently fired your handgun in a populated area, at a dog that was attacking your puppy. I'm pretty sure you can say bye bye to your guns because 1st degree reckless endangerment is a felony.
I'm not sure where you get that you can't defend yourself from a non-person. And it's not what the court thinks, but what a JURY thinks.
-
It's not the defending your self that's the issue. It's the discharge of the firearm in public that's the issue. Also last I checked, the jury sits in the court room with the judge, therefor the COURT decides your fate when the JURY returns your verdict and the judge implements your sentence.
-
It's not the defending your self that's the issue. It's the discharge of the firearm in public that's the issue. Also last I checked, the jury sits in the court room with the judge, therefor the COURT decides your fate when the JURY returns your verdict and the judge implements your sentence.
Hunter's discharge firearms in public places all the time, so it's not about discharing in a public place. If people are going to defend themselves against a threat, it could be in a public place as well. So, to me, it's not about a public place or not.
If you truly want the answer to your view on the matter, I suggest talking to the Attorney General.
-
It's not the defending your self that's the issue. It's the discharge of the firearm in public that's the issue. Also last I checked, the jury sits in the court room with the judge, therefor the COURT decides your fate when the JURY returns your verdict and the judge implements your sentence.
According to you it is....you say that wading into a dog fight to save your animal is akin to purposefully putting yourself into a dangerous situation without due consideration and therefore you can't then claim self defense. Shall I find that post for you?
-
Hunter's discharge firearms in public places all the time, so it's not about discharing in a public place. If people are going to defend themselves against a threat, it could be in a public place as well. So, to me, it's not about a public place or not.
If you truly want the answer to your view on the matter, I suggest talking to the Attorney General.
Hunters discharge firearms in authorized hunting areas during authorized hunting periods. You are not allowed by law to have you gun loaded when you step outside of that hunting area. Maybe you should sign up for a hunters Ed class so you can be a little better informed.
-
According to you it is....you say that wading into a dog fight to save your animal is akin to purposefully putting yourself into a dangerous situation without due consideration and therefore you can't then claim self defense. Shall I find that post for you?
No need here it is. Shall I quote everything so you can read it in the right context?
Wrong, you cannot claim self-defense when you put yourself in danger. Remember the court makes judgements based on the reasonable person test. What would a reasonable person of average intelligence do when faced with the same situation. A reasonable person would not get a gun and start pumping lead into the dogs. A reasonable person would not put themselves in grave danger to protect a puppy.
You can reasonably defend yourself. But running into the house (out of danger) to get your gun, than running back outside ( putting yourself back into danger) now shooting your gun at a dog (reckless endangerment), assuming its in your yard, that is running around when there is other options available. Ie: water hose, broom, bat, shoes, etc...
So lets see the possible charges (just for fun)
Place to keep
Reckless endangerment
Cruelty to animals
Then again I'm just another guy presenting his opinion on the matter. People do dumb shit all the time, that's how we get case law. People will do what they THINK is right, and we can let the court decide their fate.
-
Discharging a firearm in a residential area is illegal, is it not?
While I'm not really all that worried about self defense where I live now, I have and have always had a variety of ways to defend the members of the household and our property. I have a degree of skill with them, as well. Handy, really. In college my roommates and I stopped what appeared to be an attempted rape or something happening next door outside. The sound of a terrified woman is unmistakeable and the 3 of us leaped out of our chairs and rushed outside to help. The shotgun was right beside the door. So was the staff. I grabbed the staff knowing that the mossy would be more liability than asset.
(Perp was dragging her towards his car by arm and hair. Perp saw us and let the girl go. She ran like a rabbit - probably didn't even know we were there. Perp then got in his car drove away. Having no right to detain him there was nothing else we could do. This was in the days before ubiquitous digital cameras, unfortunately.)
Funny thing is that a dog will probably register a person armed with a bat, staff or machete as a clear threat and might run. Not necessarily so with a firearm.
-
Hunters discharge firearms in authorized hunting areas during authorized hunting periods. You are not allowed by law to have you gun loaded when you step outside of that hunting area. Maybe you should sign up for a hunters Ed class so you can be a little better informed.
I have my Hunters Ed cert thank you very much. Also I don't believe I said that the hunters were hunting outside of a designated hunting area did I? If so please post it up.
-
No need here it is. Shall I quote everything so you can read it in the right context?
Quote from: Dblnaknak on April 04, 2013, 02:45:24 PM
Wrong, you cannot claim self-defense when you put yourself in danger. Remember the court makes judgements based on the reasonable person test. What would a reasonable person of average intelligence do when faced with the same situation. A reasonable person would not get a gun and start pumping lead into the dogs. A reasonable person would not put themselves in grave danger to protect a puppy.
You can reasonably defend yourself. But running into the house (out of danger) to get your gun, than running back outside ( putting yourself back into danger) now shooting your gun at a dog (reckless endangerment), assuming its in your yard, that is running around when there is other options available. Ie: water hose, broom, bat, shoes, etc...
So lets see the possible charges (just for fun)
Place to keep
Reckless endangerment
Cruelty to animals
Then again I'm just another guy presenting his opinion on the matter. People do dumb shit all the time, that's how we get case law. People will do what they THINK is right, and we can let the court decide their fate.
So wait let me get this straight.............your gf/wife/child has a knife at their throat in your bedroom and you cannot retrieve your firearm by the door to defend them because by coming back you are placing yourself in danger............check I gotcha. :crazy:
-
No need here it is. Shall I quote everything so you can read it in the right context?
You can reasonably defend yourself. But running into the house (out of danger) to get your gun, than running back outside ( putting yourself back into danger) now shooting your gun at a dog (reckless endangerment), assuming its in your yard, that is running around when there is other options available. Ie: water hose, broom, bat, shoes, etc...
So lets see the possible charges (just for fun)
Place to keep
Reckless endangerment
Cruelty to animals
Then again I'm just another guy presenting his opinion on the matter. People do dumb shit all the time, that's how we get case law. People will do what they THINK is right, and we can let the court decide their fate.
Except in the scenario given, the dog came into the house and attacked the puppy. So retrieving your gun, especially if already carrying or if it were kept close enough as if it were carried, shouldn't require you to go anywhere.....so place to keep charge is not an issue.
As for cruelty to animals, I do not believe using force, including deadly force to stop an animal from attacking, would be considered cruelty. And more to the point, I doubt any trier of fact, judge or jury, would see it as such. As a matter of fact, I doubt any prosecutor would even consider bring those charges.
As for reckless endangerment, you can be charged with that even after a completely justified self-defense shooting. So should we just forgo any use of a firearm for self-defense because you MAY be charged with reckless endangerment?
-
I get slightly annoyed when someone tells me I can only deal with an attacking dog with a stick or water hose. This isn't the first time I've heard that, so I'm not rebutting anyone here, just the general idea.
That's underestimating the power of some dogs. If it was a small dog or nice dog, sure. But if it's a strong and mean dog, I'll want to use whatever I can manage to get. Depending on the circumstances of the incident I might indeed have to make do with just a stick or my foot, but if events allowed me to get something better then I should take that precaution. Folks have probably died from the water hose mentality.