2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: bknaka on April 11, 2013, 12:57:12 AM

Title: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: bknaka on April 11, 2013, 12:57:12 AM
I want a CCW permit.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: bknaka on April 11, 2013, 12:57:54 AM
I was kinda wondering if HPD is still shredding every application without even reading it.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: xer 21 on April 11, 2013, 05:54:50 AM
I was kinda wondering if HPD is still shredding every application without even reading it.

is Kealoha still the police chief?
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Pizzo on April 11, 2013, 06:56:55 AM
I want a CCW permit.
You should apply for one the next time you register a firearm....all you need is two passport photos, I'm going to. I think the more people that apply, the better!

From what I understand they aren't shredding them because people are still receiving denial notices. Which would make me assume that there is still some sort of recorded process the paperwork goes through.....I could be wrong though.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: pastordennis on April 11, 2013, 07:21:03 AM
On the Big Island we have a saying about CCW. Apply to deny. Keep trying ladies and germs. It CANNOT hurt us God Bless all you knuckleheads.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Dblnaknak on April 11, 2013, 04:50:29 PM
I want a CCW permit.

Hate to be the bearer of bad news but it will never happen. CCW in hawaii is like Santa Claus. You hope and wish that it was real yet you will alway be disappointed at the end of the day.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: lippy laroux on April 11, 2013, 05:31:55 PM
Although I havent applied for CC yet what criteria are they basing their denial on?  Just the fact that they have the option to apply should overide any denial based upon the second 2A.  If anything; the first time a denied person is subject to a crime or personal injury should allow standing to sue the living crap out of the government for damages.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: OldFaithful on April 11, 2013, 06:00:29 PM
.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: xer 21 on April 11, 2013, 11:45:43 PM
Although I havent applied for CC yet what criteria are they basing their denial on?  Just the fact that they have the option to apply should overide any denial based upon the second 2A.  If anything; the first time a denied person is subject to a crime or personal injury should allow standing to sue the living crap out of the government for damages.

the criteria is that Kealoha is an anti gun douchebag.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Aiea78 on April 12, 2013, 01:58:31 AM
There's an actual HPD CCW application form at the window now?
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Cougar8045 on April 12, 2013, 07:56:34 AM
The criteria is that there are more non-Communists, both by raw numbers and as a percentage of the total, in China's Peoples' Congress than there are Republicans in Hawaii's state legislature.  The takeaway is that Hawaii voters are more fond of a one-party system than are the Communist Chinese.  If folks would stop voting Democrat, things might turn around, but we all know that's less realistic than the tortured dreams of an opium addict.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: bass monkey on April 12, 2013, 08:03:12 AM
There's an actual HPD CCW application form at the window now?


It's not at the window. I believe you have to ask for it, you know, so they can keep track of the forms and make sure they are in numerical order and whatnot
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: clshade on April 12, 2013, 09:59:14 AM
I wouldn't be too harsh on Kealoha. At least not specifically. I don't think the policy really comes directly from him. I know that the police here on the BI are plenty gun friendly but they aren't the ones setting policy.

The whole of the state government is more derived in character from Japan than it is from the US and is predisposed to concentrate authority to itself. Not maliciously, just consistently - more about stability and predictability than about authoritarian control or what is "right." Its BS, but its kind of like a union job: the police are in charge of safety so no one else should even try to help. It isn't "right" but it is predictable and stable.

The other factor is pressure from the HTA and the fact that tourism is our #1 industry. Hawaii consistently ranks in the top 10 safest states and HTA doesn't want to do anything that might change that or the perception of it. The police chiefs may well understand that armed citizens are safer citizens but if they start granting CCW's they will be out on their arses in a heartbeat.

One other thing I've heard but have no way to verify is that organized crime here in Hawaii is fairly well entrenched. The heavies in the organization tend to be in professions that allow CCW, many from the same families that tend to populate HPD. Not the same people, but the same families. Think yakuza instead of mafia. So between the police and the organized criminals having the only weapons on the streets, the less predictable small time criminals don't stand much of a chance. Predictable and stable even if it isn't "right."

Things are simply NOT likely to change. No one that matters is interested in armed citizens and our feelings on the matter are largely irrelevant to them.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: xer 21 on April 12, 2013, 01:38:36 PM
I wouldn't be too harsh on Kealoha. At least not specifically. I don't think the policy really comes directly from him. I know that the police here on the BI are plenty gun friendly but they aren't the ones setting policy.

The whole of the state government is more derived in character from Japan than it is from the US and is predisposed to concentrate authority to itself. Not maliciously, just consistently - more about stability and predictability than about authoritarian control or what is "right." Its BS, but its kind of like a union job: the police are in charge of safety so no one else should even try to help. It isn't "right" but it is predictable and stable.

The other factor is pressure from the HTA and the fact that tourism is our #1 industry. Hawaii consistently ranks in the top 10 safest states and HTA doesn't want to do anything that might change that or the perception of it. The police chiefs may well understand that armed citizens are safer citizens but if they start granting CCW's they will be out on their arses in a heartbeat.

One other thing I've heard but have no way to verify is that organized crime here in Hawaii is fairly well entrenched. The heavies in the organization tend to be in professions that allow CCW, many from the same families that tend to populate HPD. Not the same people, but the same families. Think yakuza instead of mafia. So between the police and the organized criminals having the only weapons on the streets, the less predictable small time criminals don't stand much of a chance. Predictable and stable even if it isn't "right."

Things are simply NOT likely to change. No one that matters is interested in armed citizens and our feelings on the matter are largely irrelevant to them.
perhaps.

but when he says that he would rather destroy the multitude of police issue firearms than allow them to be sold to the public, in a state with no concealed carry, where registration is mandatory, and we have more in depth background checks than anywhere in the nations, as well as virtually no gun crime, because he doesnt want to "put more guns on the streets", it seems pretty clear to me that he's either a personally or politically motivated anti gun douche bag.

especially when they are essentially throwing away at least half a million + the cost of the destruction just to do that.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: clshade on April 12, 2013, 02:05:37 PM
Yeah, I'm not wholeheartedly defending the guy. Just putting his position into context.

Its the same context that our pro-gun attempts vanish into - which is pretty much the only reason I mention it.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Jl808 on April 12, 2013, 02:53:33 PM
I wouldn't be too harsh on Kealoha. At least not specifically. I don't think the policy really comes directly from him. I know that the police here on the BI are plenty gun friendly but they aren't the ones setting policy.

The whole of the state government is more derived in character from Japan than it is from the US and is predisposed to concentrate authority to itself. Not maliciously, just consistently - more about stability and predictability than about authoritarian control or what is "right." Its BS, but its kind of like a union job: the police are in charge of safety so no one else should even try to help. It isn't "right" but it is predictable and stable.

The other factor is pressure from the HTA and the fact that tourism is our #1 industry. Hawaii consistently ranks in the top 10 safest states and HTA doesn't want to do anything that might change that or the perception of it. The police chiefs may well understand that armed citizens are safer citizens but if they start granting CCW's they will be out on their arses in a heartbeat.

One other thing I've heard but have no way to verify is that organized crime here in Hawaii is fairly well entrenched. The heavies in the organization tend to be in professions that allow CCW, many from the same families that tend to populate HPD. Not the same people, but the same families. Think yakuza instead of mafia. So between the police and the organized criminals having the only weapons on the streets, the less predictable small time criminals don't stand much of a chance. Predictable and stable even if it isn't "right."

Things are simply NOT likely to change. No one that matters is interested in armed citizens and our feelings on the matter are largely irrelevant to them.

+1 I agree with clshade's assessment of the situation in Hawaii.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: xer 21 on April 12, 2013, 04:11:41 PM
Yeah, I'm not wholeheartedly defending the guy. Just putting his position into context.

Its the same context that our pro-gun attempts vanish into - which is pretty much the only reason I mention it.

the only reason i mentioned him by name is because, ultimately, he could decide to issue permits, but wont.

there are no doubt many many other factors, but the decision does ultimately rest with him.

as for whether things will change, well, they wont, at least not through our legislature.

the courts are a different matter, though.  the 9th circuit sucks, but there is a far better chance there.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Dblnaknak on April 12, 2013, 04:44:47 PM

the courts are a different matter, though.  the 9th circuit sucks, but there is a far better chance there.

Apparently you don't know much about the 9th circuit and their view on guns. CCW ain't happening....
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: OldFaithful on April 12, 2013, 04:53:26 PM
.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: GZire on April 12, 2013, 05:08:14 PM
I'd be interested to see what HiCarry says about this. Got to get the digs in while we have a 2A friendly person in office.  To me this is the test.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: xer 21 on April 12, 2013, 05:20:11 PM
Apparently you don't know much about the 9th circuit and their view on guns. CCW ain't happening....
the post you quoted of me specifically addressed how much the 9th circuit sucks.  apparently, i AM aware of it, you just didnt read the whole post.

i just said the chances are far better than a legislative change.

also note that it doesnt necessarily mean the 9th circuit has to approve.

the supreme court could absolutely do it if the case got that high.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: kevlar on April 12, 2013, 08:31:50 PM
I think we'll see CCW in mass when it begins to snow on Oahu during winter.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Hi state on April 12, 2013, 08:36:58 PM
I think we'll see CCW in mass when it begins to snow on Oahu during winter.
It hailed baseballs where I live so there's probably a better chance of it snowing before we get a ccw
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Tom on April 13, 2013, 08:18:03 AM
If the us senate inserts ccw reciprocity in the gun bill, visitors will be able to carry but we won't!
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: xer 21 on April 13, 2013, 10:36:50 AM
If the us senate inserts ccw reciprocity in the gun bill, visitors will be able to carry but we won't!

you could always get a CCW in other states and come back.   i THINK there's states that give visitors permits.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: bass monkey on April 13, 2013, 11:12:44 AM
you could always get a CCW in other states and come back.   i THINK there's states that give visitors permits.

If I'm not mistaken, it all depends on your resident state. Being a resident of the state of Hawaii, not sure if you could use an out of state ccw permit under reciprocity to carry in your home state. That is assuming you are a state of hawaii resident
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: moosed on April 13, 2013, 12:40:52 PM
You can apply for non-resident CCW permits in other states.  Florida, Utah, and Arizona come to mind.  Only Utah, I believe, requires a certified CCW training class, but that could be changing, because they cut the budget that allows the state to certify trainers! 

Once you have a non-resident CCW permit, you need to keep a current list of states your permit/s is recognized in.  I do mean CURRENT, because the state-to-state reciprocity agreements change monthly. 

Most CCW-issuing states recognize any out of state permit with whom they have reciprocity agreements. 

However, some states require you be a resident of the state that issued the permit, usually because the issuing state doesn't honor permits from the state you are visiting.  You should include these states in your list as well, so you understand in which places you have to be a resident of the CCW-issuing state to legally carry.

Basically, as a Hawaii resident, you can get Florida and Arizona non-resident CCW permits through the mail/online and be legal to carry in about half the states.  Utah is recognized in some states that don't honor Florida or Arizona, so that permit is popular, too.  Nevada doesn't offer permits to non-residents, but they do honor Arizona permits, in case you ever find yourself traveling to Nevada for vacation!    :geekdanc:

If you get these three permits, FL, UT and AZ, you could be legal to carry in about 35-36 states.  Of course, the places you might really WANT to carry, like Los Angeles, Detroit, and New York City, don't honor any out of state permits.  Go figure!!   :wtf:
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Pizzo on April 13, 2013, 12:48:17 PM
you could always get a CCW in other states and come back.   i THINK there's states that give visitors permits.

Yes, there are....but Hawaii won't recognize it.  :(

If I'm not mistaken, it all depends on your resident state. Being a resident of the state of Hawaii, not sure if you could use an out of state ccw permit under reciprocity to carry in your home state. That is assuming you are a state of hawaii resident


There are states that allow reciprocity...in fact Utah has one of the most recognized CCW permits/license. Unfortunately, many states...like Hawaii, California and a few others don't recognizes out of state CCW permits. They only allow CCW if the permit/license is from there state. The whole CCW topic is very sad, but if we keep applying pressure and being diligent hopefully we can change that one day!  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Pizzo on April 13, 2013, 12:49:47 PM
You can apply for non-resident CCW permits in other states.  Florida, Utah, and Arizona come to mind.  Only Utah, I believe, requires a certified CCW training class, but that could be changing, because they cut the budget that allows the state to certify trainers! 

Once you have a non-resident CCW permit, you need to keep a current list of states your permit/s is recognized in.  I do mean CURRENT, because the state-to-state reciprocity agreements change monthly. 

Most CCW-issuing states recognize any out of state permit with whom they have reciprocity agreements. 

However, some states require you be a resident of the state that issued the permit, usually because the issuing state doesn't honor permits from the state you are visiting.  You should include these states in your list as well, so you understand in which places you have to be a resident of the CCW-issuing state to legally carry.

Basically, as a Hawaii resident, you can get Florida and Arizona non-resident CCW permits through the mail/online and be legal to carry in about half the states.  Utah is recognized in some states that don't honor Florida or Arizona, so that permit is popular, too.  Nevada doesn't offer permits to non-residents, but they do honor Arizona permits, in case you ever find yourself traveling to Nevada for vacation!    :geekdanc:

If you get these three permits, FL, UT and AZ, you could be legal to carry in about 35-36 states.  Of course, the places you might really WANT to carry, like Los Angeles, Detroit, and New York City, don't honor any out of state permits.  Go figure!!   :wtf:

Exactly what Moosed said, well put!!  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: bass monkey on April 13, 2013, 02:00:28 PM
I understand about reciprocity in the mainland, however, I thought we were talking about hawaii.  I know a few people that have Az permits as well as Nv permits and carry when on vacation there.

However even if Hawaii allows reciprocity, the point I was trying to make is, I'm not certain if your resident state will allow you to carry under a out of state permit.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: moosed on April 13, 2013, 02:23:22 PM
... the point I was trying to make is, I'm not certain if your resident state will allow you to carry under a out of state permit.

That's a state-by-state issue.  Some will, some won't.

For example, Wisconsin accepts Virginia Non-Resident Permits Only. 

Yes, if you are a Virginia resident, and you have a Virginia CCW permit, Wisconsin does not honor it.  If you are a Hawaii resident, then Wisconsin will honor your non-resident Virginia permit!

Curious?

Go to this link, click the States That Honor My Permit(s) link, then click on any state.  The list of where, and under what conditions, you may carry is displayed on the map and explained below it.

http://www.usacarry.com/concealed_carry_permit_reciprocity_maps.html (http://www.usacarry.com/concealed_carry_permit_reciprocity_maps.html)

The states in YELLOW will be the where they require you to be a resident where your permit was issued.

This might not cover that answer you are seeking, but it is god to know.

For the answer to that specific case, using a non-resident permit in your own state of residence, that is an unusual circumstance in that states that accept non-resident permits should also be issuing residents CCW permits to maintain reciprocity agreements
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: xer 21 on April 13, 2013, 02:29:05 PM
That's a state-by-state issue.  Some will, some won't.

For example, Wisconsin accepts Virginia Non-Resident Permits Only. 

Yes, if you are a Virginia resident, and you have a Virginia CCW permit, Wisconsin does not honor it.  If you are a Hawaii resident, then Wisconsin will honor your non-resident Virginia permit!

Curious?

Go to this link, click the States That Honor My Permit(s) link, then click on any state.  The list of where, and under what conditions, you may carry is displayed on the map and explained below it.

http://www.usacarry.com/concealed_carry_permit_reciprocity_maps.html (http://www.usacarry.com/concealed_carry_permit_reciprocity_maps.html)
we're talking about the potential of having national reciprocity.  then it wouldnt be a state by state issue, they'd be forced to honor it.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: moosed on April 13, 2013, 02:33:51 PM
we're talking about the potential of having national reciprocity.  then it wouldnt be a state by state issue, they'd be forced to honor it.

I just scanned for the word "national" in this thread, and the only person that's used it is you ... just now.

Maybe I'm just misreading the posts, but they all are discussing state reciprocity ... I thought.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: bass monkey on April 13, 2013, 02:44:27 PM
Tom mentioned ccw reciprocity.
I automatically assumed we were discussing national reciprocity.
All my answers were tailored to national reciprocity.
Hence the home state honoring a residents out of state permit
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: moosed on April 13, 2013, 02:50:40 PM
The Fed Gov't will not force a state to accept other state's CCW permits.  That's actually HELPING gun owners!!  The Libs will never allow that!
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Tom on April 13, 2013, 06:47:58 PM
Tom mentioned ccw reciprocity.
I automatically assumed we were discussing national reciprocity.
All my answers were tailored to national reciprocity.
Hence the home state honoring a residents out of state permit

Quite right.  My post said the US Senate bill could include reciprocity.  There is much talk that it will be offered as an amendment in the background check bill along with a bunch of other pro-gun things.   The media calls it "a poison pill".     It may have a chance because of red state democrats leading to that peculiar situation I described earlier...
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Tom on April 13, 2013, 06:49:37 PM
delete
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: xer 21 on April 14, 2013, 01:38:05 AM
The Fed Gov't will not force a state to accept other state's CCW permits.  That's actually HELPING gun owners!!  The Libs will never allow that!
except for the fact that they dont have enough of a majority to get their bill through without a compromise.


if they want the background checks bill through, they may need to wheel and deal because the republicans own the house.

reciprocity has been in talks for a while now though.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: moosed on April 14, 2013, 03:07:10 PM
except for the fact that they dont have enough of a majority to get their bill through without a compromise.


if they want the background checks bill through, they may need to wheel and deal because the republicans own the house.

reciprocity has been in talks for a while now though.

We can "what if" this topic to death.  The reality is, ANY gun control is bad.  If the House compromises, the anti-gunners win, and the pro-gunners lose. 

That is far from a compromise.  A compromise is a mutual agreement resulting in both parties giving up something to the other.

Explain what the anti-gunners are giving up?  What are they "compromising" in order to reach a consensus?

The anti-gunners have "no skin in the game."  They are pushing an agenda which erodes the Constitutional protection of gun owners.

Rights are not to be negotiated.  If they think the majority of the country wants to place strict limits on gun ownership, then they need to go through the process to properly amend the Constitution, just as it was amended when the right to keep and bear arms was added!
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: xer 21 on April 14, 2013, 04:00:45 PM
We can "what if" this topic to death.  The reality is, ANY gun control is bad.  If the House compromises, the anti-gunners win, and the pro-gunners lose. 

That is far from a compromise.  A compromise is a mutual agreement resulting in both parties giving up something to the other.

Explain what the anti-gunners are giving up?  What are they "compromising" in order to reach a consensus?

The anti-gunners have "no skin in the game."  They are pushing an agenda which erodes the Constitutional protection of gun owners.

Rights are not to be negotiated.  If they think the majority of the country wants to place strict limits on gun ownership, then they need to go through the process to properly amend the Constitution, just as it was amended when the right to keep and bear arms was added!

if they were to concede to national reciprocity, how would they NOT be giving something up?

that's clearly pro gun rights law in exchange for the background checks.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: moosed on April 14, 2013, 05:15:16 PM
if they were to concede to national reciprocity, how would they NOT be giving something up?

that's clearly pro gun rights law in exchange for the background checks.

Because they do not HAVE "national reciprocity" to give up!  If I come to your house and tell you I want 50% of everything you own, and you negotiate down to 30%, I guess that means I conceded 20% of your stuff?  The Dems loose NOTHING!  The gun owners loose FREEDOMS by being subjected to background checks that will not have a positive effect on gun violence.

Why is it the Democrats are always such good negotiators?  They promised presidents time after time, if you raise taxes now, we will create real cuts in spending later.  Well, later never comes!  They always cry that the cuts are going to starve and kill people needing those funds.  Then they have the audacity to beat up the president for being willing to compromise ("Read my lips!  No new taxes").  Bush compromised in the belief that was the only way to bring some of the spending down to reasonable limits.  Instead, the Democrats hung him with his own words.  Damned if you do, and damned if you don't!

It's the exact same thing with sequestration.  Obama promised during the debates in October that sequestration WILL NOT HAPPEN.  Then, when the Republicans called his bluff, he blamed them for sequestration when it was Obama's idea from the very start!  Amazing!!  And people BELIEVE him!

You can trust the Democrats in DC to allow national reciprocity if you want.  I don't trust that they will do anything they promise to.  I foresee the first state to challenge the reciprocity mandate will get it tossed out!  New York?  California?  The net effect will be a new national background check/gun registration system in exchange for nada!
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: xer 21 on April 14, 2013, 05:49:45 PM
Because they do not HAVE "national reciprocity" to give up!  If I come to your house and tell you I want 50% of everything you own, and you negotiate down to 30%, I guess that means I conceded 20% of your stuff?  The Dems loose NOTHING!  The gun owners loose FREEDOMS by being subjected to background checks that will not have a positive effect on gun violence.

Why is it the Democrats are always such good negotiators?  They promised presidents time after time, if you raise taxes now, we will create real cuts in spending later.  Well, later never comes!  They always cry that the cuts are going to starve and kill people needing those funds.  Then they have the audacity to beat up the president for being willing to compromise ("Read my lips!  No new taxes").  Bush compromised in the belief that was the only way to bring some of the spending down to reasonable limits.  Instead, the Democrats hung him with his own words.  Damned if you do, and damned if you don't!

It's the exact same thing with sequestration.  Obama promised during the debates in October that sequestration WILL NOT HAPPEN.  Then, when the Republicans called his bluff, he blamed them for sequestration when it was Obama's idea from the very start!  Amazing!!  And people BELIEVE him!

You can trust the Democrats in DC to allow national reciprocity if you want.  I don't trust that they will do anything they promise to.  I foresee the first state to challenge the reciprocity mandate will get it tossed out!  New York?  California?  The net effect will be a new national background check/gun registration system in exchange for nada!

so anti gunners ARENT giving anything up if they were to be forced to enact national carry reciprocity?   that's essentially a federal bill legalizing CCW; that directly affects any may issue state, as well as no issue states.  places like New Jersey, New York and Hawaii would just have to deal with it.  how the hell is that NOT giving something up?  clearly, anti gun areas would be giving up their pwoer to restrict your right to carry.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: moosed on April 14, 2013, 05:58:02 PM
clearly, anti gun areas would be giving up their pwoer to restrict your right to carry.

If the Constitution grants the right to bear arms, then the power to deny CC exists illegally in the anti gun areas.  Once the unconstitutionality of denying CC is adjudicated (which is already happening state by state), national reciprocity will exist all on its own.  The Dems understand this, and to offer reciprocity up as a trade, once again, loses them nothing.  That power is being stripped from them regardless!
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: xer 21 on April 14, 2013, 06:34:08 PM
If the Constitution grants the right to bear arms, then the power to deny CC exists illegally in the anti gun areas.  Once the unconstitutionality of denying CC is adjudicated (which is already happening state by state), national reciprocity will exist all on its own.  The Dems understand this, and to offer reciprocity up as a trade, once again, loses them nothing.  That power is being stripped from them regardless!

you're arguing based on principle.

the fact of the matter is, whether or not it is my right, i cant walk out of my door with a gun, without facing 10 years in prison or something.  illegal or not, there isnt anything i can do about it.

at least my scenario is believable.  you really think they're going to declare denying CCW unconstitutional?  i wouldnt hold my breath.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: moosed on April 14, 2013, 06:40:52 PM
Quote
i cant walk out of my door with a gun, without facing 10 years in prison or something

People do this every day.  It's called "not getting caught".  As with any act in defiance of the law, there are POTENTIAL consequences, but you have to be caught, charged, and convicted first.  I guess that's much easier to get away with in areas where people wear more clothing than here! 
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: xer 21 on April 14, 2013, 08:25:55 PM
People do this every day.  It's called "not getting caught".  As with any act in defiance of the law, there are POTENTIAL consequences, but you have to be caught, charged, and convicted first.  I guess that's much easier to get away with in areas where people wear more clothing than here!
you're basically saying that gaining national reciprocity wouldnt be a loss for anti gunners, based on the fact that i CAN walk outside with a gun with no CCW, just as long as i dont get caught?

what's even the point of that?  if i have to use it in self defense, Im slapped with a felony automatically, and possibly murder. 
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: moosed on April 14, 2013, 08:55:58 PM
you're basically saying that gaining national reciprocity wouldnt be a loss for anti gunners, based on the fact that i CAN walk outside with a gun with no CCW, just as long as i dont get caught?

what's even the point of that?  if i have to use it in self defense, Im slapped with a felony automatically, and possibly murder.

In that hypothetical, I'd take the murder rap over being DEAD!  Call me crazy ...  :wacko:   :crazy:
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Dblnaknak on April 14, 2013, 09:20:33 PM
In that hypothetical, I'd take the murder rap over being DEAD!  Call me crazy ...  :wacko:   :crazy:

People do this every day.  It's called "not getting caught".  As with any act in defiance of the law, there are POTENTIAL consequences, but you have to be caught, charged, and convicted first.  I guess that's much easier to get away with in areas where people wear more clothing than here! 

And that's the reason why fanatics like you will screw up the 2a movement. I can see the headlines now. "Man murders another man with gun. Murderer claiming self-defense after shooting, yet he was carrying a concealed weapon illegally."
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: moosed on April 14, 2013, 10:07:40 PM
And that's the reason why fanatics like you will screw up the 2a movement. I can see the headlines now. "Man murders another man with gun. Murderer claiming self-defense after shooting, yet he was carrying a concealed weapon illegally."

Did I say I carry an illegal concealed gun?  You need to take a step back and calm down.  I'm a law-abiding citizen.  I stop at all red lights, I always use a turn signal, I pay my taxes on time, and I never carry a loaded gun in Hawaii.  Now, if the attacker is unlucky enough to catch me on my way back from the range, and I happen to have some ammo left, then bad timing on his part!

The last thing I'll be thinking if I'm defending my life is what the media is going to print about it.  The one thing I DO NOT want printed is my obituary in the same edition.

If you're thinking about headlines, then I hope there's a cop ten feet away when you need one! 

Call me as many different kinds of fanatic as you want.  You're not even close to being correct!  You seem to be trolling for an argument.  Just like when you posted this:
Quote
dumbest thing I've read in awhile. Its not what your intention is, it's the publics perception that will get you in trouble or shot. You should just continue wearing your holster in your house and looking in mirror. That way you won't put yourself or the public in danger. Leave the super hero stuff to the guys with the badge and training.

Go ahead and have the last word here.  I'm done with you!

 :shaka:
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: xer 21 on April 14, 2013, 10:18:32 PM
hey, Dbinaknak has a point. 

you straight up said I could do it if i didnt get caught. 


that makes us look bad.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: moosed on April 14, 2013, 10:31:57 PM
hey, Dbinaknak has a point. 

you straight up said I could do it if i didnt get caught. 


that makes us look bad.

Quote
People do this every day.  It's called "not getting caught".  As with any act in defiance of the law, there are POTENTIAL consequences, but you have to be caught, charged, and convicted first.  I guess that's much easier to get away with in areas where people wear more clothing than here! 

Try reading what I wrote -- straight up. 

You are free to choose to follow a law or not.  It's YOUR choice.  You will have to live with the consequences.  You are responsible for your own decisions.

I never said I condone it, nor did/do I recommend anyone break any laws.  I stated a fact:  people carry illegally every day.  That is their decision: to risk getting caught with a concealed firearm rather than be without protection.  It's not a difficult concept. 

Don't give me that "you said I could do it" bull crap!
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: clshade on April 14, 2013, 10:49:47 PM
Relax, folks. Moosed's points are entirely valid.

He's articulating the point that criminals don't obey laws and adding to it that they don't always get caught when doing so. In fact they rarely get caught.

This isn't complex or controversial.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: moosed on April 14, 2013, 11:06:45 PM
clshade, thanks for chiming in!   :shaka:

I think they understand EXACTLY what I said.  They are just trolling.

Take a look at their other posts on different threads.  They start arguments time and again just for fun, normally taking the conversation onto some accusatory tangent.  Wouldn't surprise me if xer 21 and Dblnaknak are the same person!

As I said, I'm done with these two.   :closed:

Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: clshade on April 14, 2013, 11:40:10 PM
I've read here for a while and haven't noticed that, yet.

Could just be normal forum behavior. But then I'm kind of an intellectual conversation geek, too. I'm as guilty of tangents as anyone...  :oops:

The point that talking about illegal carry is risky also valid. It does make us look bad if we talk about it the wrong way. :shrug: This conversation didn't hit my threshold of discomfort there, but it may have hit others'.

Not complex or controversial, really. Its just like the YouTube meme of always having to visually safety check the gun on camera, in my mind. Its over the top, visibly "safe" even though there is no way you're going to accidentally shoot someone who is watching the video. Similarly, we do have to be careful how we talk about some things but for the most part we're all proficient as self policing and keeping clean. 2aHawaii is pretty good at letting us know if we wander too close to dangerous territory.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: xer 21 on April 14, 2013, 11:54:43 PM
clshade, thanks for chiming in!   :shaka:

I think they understand EXACTLY what I said.  They are just trolling.

Take a look at their other posts on different threads.  They start arguments time and again just for fun, normally taking the conversation onto some accusatory tangent.  Wouldn't surprise me if xer 21 and Dblnaknak are the same person!

As I said, I'm done with these two.   :closed:

im not trolling, you were just making vague statements that could easily be misinterpreted.  like they were just now. 

the way it read to me was that you were suggesting that since denying CCW is unconstitutional, that for us to gain a right we technically should have is not a loss to anti gunners, and also it seemed to slightly imply that you condoned breaking the law as a protest.

this is the internet, not a conversation, you cant assume the tone and the general gist of something is always clear in type form.

and honestly, if i wanted to troll you , i could definitely accomplish that in better, more subtle ways.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: xer 21 on April 15, 2013, 12:00:40 AM
I've read here for a while and haven't noticed that, yet.

Could just be normal forum behavior. But then I'm kind of an intellectual conversation geek, too. I'm as guilty of tangents as anyone...  :oops:

The point that talking about illegal carry is risky also valid. It does make us look bad if we talk about it the wrong way. :shrug: This conversation didn't hit my threshold of discomfort there, but it may have hit others'.

Not complex or controversial, really. Its just like the YouTube meme of always having to visually safety check the gun on camera, in my mind. Its over the top, visibly "safe" even though there is no way you're going to accidentally shoot someone who is watching the video. Similarly, we do have to be careful how we talk about some things but for the most part we're all proficient as self policing and keeping clean. 2aHawaii is pretty good at letting us know if we wander too close to dangerous territory.

part of why that comment hit home with me is because i've been reading a bit of the AR15.com boards a bit, and some of those guys are telling New Yorkers not to comply with the new laws because they're unconstitutional.

this felt similar to me, and its not something that i think we'd want to be associated with.

its clear that that wasnt the intent now, but it is what it is.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Dblnaknak on April 15, 2013, 04:22:52 AM
clshade, thanks for chiming in!   :shaka:

I think they understand EXACTLY what I said.  They are just trolling.

Take a look at their other posts on different threads.  They start arguments time and again just for fun, normally taking the conversation onto some accusatory tangent.  Wouldn't surprise me if xer 21 and Dblnaknak are the same person!

As I said, I'm done with these two.   :closed:

Ahahahaha. Because I have my own point of view, which is different from yours, I am now trolling. You crack me up dude. You were just advocating carrying illegally and not getting busted. Now your back peddling. Ah come on.... Xer 21 and I have not always seen eye to eye on different topics but apparently now you think we are the same person? Hahaha. I guess anyone that has an idea other than your own is either a troll or the same person.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: 2aHawaii on April 15, 2013, 05:03:10 AM
The point that talking about illegal carry is risky also valid. It does make us look bad if we talk about it the wrong way. :shrug:

This, exactly. We don't want to sound like we are even hinting at doing something clearly illegal.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: pastordennis on April 15, 2013, 08:05:59 AM
I love these conversations. 2@ is right though. We need to be as white as snow on our 2@ rights. The "other side" does not. They are clearly bottom feeders that want to drag us down to their level. Then they will say " see I told you so " and boom another anti gun law. I am so proud to be a part of this group of citizens that are so readily able and committed to upholding our freedoms even though some people disagree with us. I am hoping the supreme court takes on NY's  clause of " need to carry " statute and the ruling gives Hawaii the push we need to make CCW a reality here. CCW here would see an explosion in the firearms industry. If our gun laws were more friendly maybe a Gun Maker would move here so shipping foreign supplies would be more available??? Again.....wishful thinking. I appreciate the conversation. It educates all of us.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: HiCarry on April 15, 2013, 11:36:25 AM
I'd be interested to see what HiCarry says about this. Got to get the digs in while we have a 2A friendly person in office.  To me this is the test.
I agree that it will be difficult, very difficult, to get CCW here, either legislatively or thru some court action. The Ninth Circuit is not entirely unfriendly and there are some supportive judges, as evidenced by one of the earlier verdicts in Nordyke. But, it will be an uphill battle. There is a CCW bill introduced every year that never makes it to a hearing. We need to get it heard? How? Not sure, but I think one thing to do is carry on with what Chris Baker started and have folks keep applying for permits. The latest AG report noted only 5 people applied in 2012, so that alone makes arguing that "lots" of folks want it difficult.
But, we need to start lobbying our legislators hard, and early. I plan on sending some info from the Police One survey (noting the police favor more citizen concealed carry) to both the Mayor and some of our legislators within the next week or so. Whether it will help or not, I don't know. But it can't hurt.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: HiCarry on April 15, 2013, 11:39:03 AM
You can apply for non-resident CCW permits in other states.  Florida, Utah, and Arizona come to mind.  Only Utah, I believe, requires a certified CCW training class, but that could be changing, because they cut the budget that allows the state to certify trainers! 

Once you have a non-resident CCW permit, you need to keep a current list of states your permit/s is recognized in.  I do mean CURRENT, because the state-to-state reciprocity agreements change monthly. 

Most CCW-issuing states recognize any out of state permit with whom they have reciprocity agreements. 

However, some states require you be a resident of the state that issued the permit, usually because the issuing state doesn't honor permits from the state you are visiting.  You should include these states in your list as well, so you understand in which places you have to be a resident of the CCW-issuing state to legally carry.

Basically, as a Hawaii resident, you can get Florida and Arizona non-resident CCW permits through the mail/online and be legal to carry in about half the states.  Utah is recognized in some states that don't honor Florida or Arizona, so that permit is popular, too.  Nevada doesn't offer permits to non-residents, but they do honor Arizona permits, in case you ever find yourself traveling to Nevada for vacation!    :geekdanc:

If you get these three permits, FL, UT and AZ, you could be legal to carry in about 35-36 states.  Of course, the places you might really WANT to carry, like Los Angeles, Detroit, and New York City, don't honor any out of state permits.  Go figure!!   :wtf:


Yes they do...I have one.....they don't call them "non-residence" permits, since all they have are permits....they just put your address on it and that's it....
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: moosed on April 15, 2013, 01:05:26 PM
 :stopjack:
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: xer 21 on April 15, 2013, 04:06:33 PM
Yes, they do ... what?  Not sure what part of my post you were referring to.  Who is "they"?

Just wondering what you meant.   ???
He bolded it in your quote.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: moosed on April 15, 2013, 04:24:10 PM
Yes they do...I have one.....they don't call them "non-residence" permits, since all they have are permits....they just put your address on it and that's it....

Thanks for the sanity check, HiCarry.  I was researching this issue a couple months ago, and I forgot why Nevada was such a pain.

It's not that they will accept Arizona, it's the opposite.  Nevada only accepts permits from Alaska, Arkansas, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Michigan, Missouri, Nebraska, New Mexico, North Carolina, Ohio, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee, West Virginia.  Notice AZ, FL, and UT are not honored.  So, if you want to carry in NV, you have to get a permit from either NV or one of the states listed above.

I knew there was an exception for NV, I just didn't check my facts before hitting submit!

Mahalo!   :shaka:
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Jared on April 16, 2013, 08:25:01 PM

It's not at the window. I believe you have to ask for it, you know, so they can keep track of the forms and make sure they are in numerical order and whatnot

Would someone be willing to scan a copy of the application and post it on here? I'm curious to know if it is intrusive like the applications in California, Rhode Island, and Maryland.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Jared on April 16, 2013, 08:31:19 PM
In all reality, would a chief be chief if he issued carry permits? Don't get me wrong, I'm not defending their non-issuance practice; however, if county police chiefs sit at the pleasure of the county council (I'm assuming it's this way) then I would imagine that if a chief adopted a shall-issue policy for either concealed or open carry permits that he would be unemployed once the nervous nancy's in the county governments found out, right?
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: bass monkey on April 16, 2013, 08:35:35 PM
Who knows. And only one way to find out.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: mauiblue on April 16, 2013, 09:05:13 PM
If I missed it in this thread my apologies, but I personally know a couple retired MPD officers that have CCW permits because of a federal law that allows retired law enforcement to apply for and receive CCW permits. They had to go through CCW training with a certified CCW instructor and go through a lengthy application process but eventually got their permits. Maybe the rest of the Hawaii civilian population will be allowed to CCW one day.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: Jared on April 16, 2013, 09:13:37 PM
If I missed it in this thread my apologies, but I personally know a couple retired MPD officers that have CCW permits because of a federal law that allows retired law enforcement to apply for CCW permits. They had to go through CCW training with a certified CCW instructor and go through a lengthy application process but eventually got their permits. Maybe the rest of the Hawaii civilian population will be allowed to CCW one day.

They don't have a concealed carry permit per se. They have a qualification certificate issued according to 18 USC 926c. This certificate must be carried with the photo ID from their former police department. They may carry a concealed firearm "of the same type" they qualified with and they can carry it in any state or territory of the United States notwithstanding state or local law, except...

1. Posted private property
2. Government installation, building, or park if state law prohibits it.

From what I understand, no concealed carry permits are active for any county of Hawaii (HRS 134-9); however, I find that hard to believe.... there has to be some cronie somewhere in government who has quietly been approved for a concealed carry permit... especially in Honolulu where the state government big wigs live.
Title: Re: CCW IN HONOLULU
Post by: mauiblue on April 16, 2013, 09:27:20 PM
They don't have a concealed carry permit per se. They have a qualification certificate issued according to 18 USC 926c. This certificate must be carried with the photo ID from their former police department. They may carry a concealed firearm "of the same type" they qualified with and they can carry it in any state or territory of the United States notwithstanding state or local law, except...

1. Posted private property
2. Government installation, building, or park if state law prohibits it.

From what I understand, no concealed carry permits are active for any county of Hawaii (HRS 134-9); however, I find that hard to believe.... there has to be some cronie somewhere in government who has quietly been approved for a concealed carry permit... especially in Honolulu where the state government big wigs live.

Thanks for the clarification.