2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: HiCarry on May 09, 2013, 05:30:56 PM
-
On Tuesday May 14, the Honolulu City Council will hear a resolution asking the HPD to register firearms at two additional locations: Kapolei and Kaneohe
We have sympathetic council members but need to flood them with testimony. And, even better, attend the hearing. This is a resolution and not a bill, so even if it passes, HPD can ignore it. But, it is the first step in the fight to secure additional registration locations and a large showing could easily force the City Council to consider something more "forceful" next if the Chief doesn't comply.
http://www4.honolulu.gov/docushare/dsweb/Get/Document-137711/REV-051413%20PSED%20Agenda.htm (http://www4.honolulu.gov/docushare/dsweb/Get/Document-137711/REV-051413%20PSED%20Agenda.htm)
http://www4.honolulu.gov/docushare/dsweb/Get/Document-136886/7sbr-gc6.pdf (http://www4.honolulu.gov/docushare/dsweb/Get/Document-136886/7sbr-gc6.pdf)
Our concerted efforts scared the legislators now let's see if we can use that same energy and cohesiveness to move this along.....
-
Mahalo for the info! :shaka:
-
A glimpse of hope. A small step in the right direction, since we have to register.
-
Is it just registering, or also applying and picking up permits?
-
Is it just registering, or also applying and picking up permits?
REQUESTING THE HONOLULU POLICE DEPARTMENT TO PROVIDE
FOR FIREARM PERMITTING AND REGISTRATION BY THE PUBLIC AT THE
KAPOLEI AND KANEOHE POLICE STATIONS.
-
Thanks moosed, took to long to load on mobile
-
i suggest everyone start emailing your city councilman now
and let everyone in your social circles know too
i went to college with the chief of staff of my ccman, stanley chang, so i will be emailing them tonight
Thanks moosed, took to long to load on mobile
-
Common people lets do dis!!! :thumbsup:
-
Please let this happen. I'm sick of the 2hr lines.
-
Thanks for the heads up Hicarry. Nice to see a proactive approach instead of the usual defensive rolls.
We all need to support this in any way possible, like how we did submitting testimony against anti gun bills.
We can do this.
-
bassm
check your pms
Thanks for the heads up Hicarry. Nice to see a proactive approach instead of the usual defensive rolls.
We all need to support this in any way possible, like how we did submitting testimony against anti gun bills.
We can do this.
-
Emailed all city council except one would Not allow email
Thanks for fighting that fight Hicarry
-
Is it just me or anyone think this way? If its a resolution and HPD does'nt have to follow it why not just make it a bill? Kind of wasting time if its passed and HPD does nothing. Just an opinion. ???
-
Just do it! :) I be glad not to deal with the parking hassles downtown for one.
In support of RESOLUTION 13-74 – FIREARM PERMITTING AND REGISTRATION AT KAPOLEI AND KANEOHE. Requesting the Honolulu Police Department to provide for firearm permitting and registration at the Kapolei and Kaneohe Police Stations.
SPEAKER REGISTRATION
Persons wishing to testify are requested to register by 9:00 a.m. as follows:
a. On‑Line at http://www1.honolulu.gov/council/attnspkpsed.htm; (http://www1.honolulu.gov/council/attnspkpsed.htm;)
b. By faxing to 768-3827 your name, phone number and the agenda item;
c. By filling out the registration form in person; or
d. By calling 768-3818.
Persons who have not registered to testify will be given an opportunity to speak on an item following oral testimonies of the registered speakers.
Each speaker limited to a one-minute presentation.
WRITTEN TESTIMONY
Written testimony may be faxed to 768-3827 or e-mailed at http://www1.honolulu.gov/council/emailpsed.htm (http://www1.honolulu.gov/council/emailpsed.htm) for distribution at the meeting.
If submitted, written testimonies, including the testifier’s address, e-mail address and phone number, may be posted by the City Clerk and available to the public on the City’s DocuShare Website.
Any physically challenged person requiring special assistance should call 768-3818 for details at least one day prior to the meeting date.
The video of the full proceedings of this meeting will be available for viewing after the meeting at http://www1.honolulu.gov/cameras/council/index.htm (http://www1.honolulu.gov/cameras/council/index.htm) or a copy of the video may be requested by calling the City Clerk’s Office at 768-5822.
email to: gmurayama@honolulu.gov
cc: dching2@honolulu.gov
bcc: jtachibana@honolulu.gov
I support RESOLUTION 13-74 – FIREARM PERMITTING AND REGISTRATION AT KAPOLEI AND KANEOHE. Requesting the Honolulu Police Department to provide for firearm permitting and registration at the Kapolei and Kaneohe Police Stations.
---------
email testimony - sent!
Thanks for the heads up HiCarry!
-
Super! Testimony sent!!
-
Just sent mines in! If people going BITCH AND MOAN about the long lines.....NOW IS THE TIME TO MAKE A DIFFERENCE! We should EASILY fill up the council members email with thousand's of email in support of this resolution! I just learned at the hunters Ed course the MAIN reason why we need to sign in at the range.....the city wants to keep track of how many people actually uses the range facility.
As a current government worker, I've come to learn that EVERYTHING needs to be documented! Not only to save ones ass, but as PROOF of ones doing! By submitting written testimony, we are showing PROOF to the Cty and HPD that we need to do something about this current permitting process! LET's DO THIS PEOPLE! WE ASKED FOR IT.....NOW IS OUR CHANCE!
-
Thanks for the heads up HiCarry. A link to the Oahu City Council, including emails, is here: http://www1.honolulu.gov/council/ccl.htm (http://www1.honolulu.gov/council/ccl.htm)
Its great to email these folks knowing about our support, but those emails don't constitute submitting testimony. We have to go through the process from HiCarry's original post.
I have not done this yet, as I'm thinking about what to say. I'll most likely submit written testimony/support, and check off the option to be at the meeting and request providing verbal testimony. If I can't make the meeting, at least they have my written testimony. If the process is similar to the hearings on bills, I can always say "I stand on my written testimony" when they call my name. I think emailing counsil members, providing testimony, and being at the hearing will have the most impact. For testimony, perhaps I can stress the possible negative impact the process has on folks income. If folks have to take several half-days off from work to go through the process in HONO, they get smaller paychecks. By having three locations, maybe folks living/working in these three areas can get through the requirements during their "lunch breaks" as opposed to getting smaller paychecks. While it kills some trees, I may include a copy of the 10 page Atty General report on firearms 2012, as I'll reference this report, and it wouldn't hurt to get the report in front of the council again. This would require me Faxing my testimony, as attachments may not be printed if I simply email testimony.
Is there any angle on expenses associated w/ having three locations vs one? The Police may counter that the expenses associated with implementing at three locations is cost prohibitive.
-
Is it just me or anyone think this way? If its a resolution and HPD does'nt have to follow it why not just make it a bill? Kind of wasting time if its passed and HPD does nothing. Just an opinion. ???
Welcome to the wonderful world of politics. Love it or hate it, this is the process. Compare this effort to the effort for the NRA instructor liability bill. We were able to make a great showing by submitting over 400 pieces of testimony and filling the hearing room. That showing probably had more to do with defeating all the other "bad" bills because we "scared" the legislators. Because they were scared, it was easier to push our agenda.
Now we need to use that same collective voice to make the council understand our needs. IF there is overwhelming support for this resolution it serves two purposes. First, it will show the council that if the HPD doesn't make moves to open more sites for registering firearms, that there is a large enough group of pro-gun advocates out there that will push for a bill to be introduced. Second, it will hopefully show HPD that there is enough support that they will voluntarily do this rather than wait for the council to introduce and pass a bill.
Remember, it takes a council member to introduce a bill and many are scared of the anti-gun backlash. We need to make sure they understand the consequences of not supporting us, and flooding them with emails, testimony and attending the hearing is the best way to do this, IMHO.
Thanks to all of you that have already taken the time and effort to contact your Council members and start drafting testimony. We can do this, we just need to stay focused and united.
-
Is it just me or anyone think this way? If its a resolution and HPD does'nt have to follow it why not just make it a bill? Kind of wasting time if its passed and HPD does nothing. Just an opinion. ???
Im glad that 2a supporters are finally taking the battle to "them", instead of always having a defensive position. No matter what type of outcome, it will show everyone that the 2a community can and will stick together and fight for our rights.
-
I too don't think long lines will cut it. That is all relative and is surge driven.
I would think just like any other public service, firearm registration is no different and there is a large number of Oahu firearm owners based on real numbers and there is also real numbers showing the large numbers of new firearm purchases and registration requirements. If Kapolei is truly the second city as advertised, then they should offer like public services to support their vision and western Oahu, just like all the other services they offer. Can't really say the same thing for Kaneohe but Kapolei for sure.
Efficiency of a public service is very important, and improving efficiency doesn't necessarily mean reducing costs, although if it does reduce cost, that is almost a no-brainer to win an argument. In this case, I don't see it reducing cost but rather, increasing cost. But in that same vien, as an example, DMW registration at Kapolei or other areas was needed from the sheer number of vehicles needing to be registered, driver licenses, etc. The bad thing is, the consensus is they don't want firearms in Hawaii to begin with so it's much more challenging to convince them.
Long lines, inadequate parking, people having to take multiple paid or unpaid leave from work are some of the impacts to firearm owners. Not sure if they care too much about our heartburn but maybe a little. From the regulatory aspect and public concern, possibly people carrying firearms (although in cases) two or three blocks away because they have to park far may attract unwanted attention or public concern. Possibly late registrations due to not being able to take the required length of time off work or because we didn't get in before the 3:00 PM deadline.
Don't know....just thoughts.
-
? I posted straight off the webpage, registered and the page that comes back that says if you cannot appear in person send your email testimony in so that's what I did. This is not submitting testimony?
Please make it easier for us.
-
I don't think that the HPD would even consider a voluntary move to include multiple locations for registration as that would not only cause some logistical issues, but most important would demand an increase in, or reallocation of staffing, including sworn and non sworn personnel. The HPD is already around 300 sworn short staffed and unk on civilian staffing. With budgets as tight as they are right now for all City departments / agencies, the HPD is neck deep in the cuts. So much so, that staffing for other non investigative, non patrol and even some plain clothed investigative units are not being filled. Staffing shortages, mandatory working hour changes (often with little notice) to avert overtime, plus much of the normal or necessary overtime resulting from investigations being cut (crime doesn't just happen during normal scheduling hours) means a very tight ship being run. Want to get promoted inside the HPD? CUT your District / Divison / Unit budget dramatically. Almost at all costs.
What does this mean? In essence this means that there is a huge reason that the HPD can cite to not increase staffing in the firearms section as it can be directly tied to public safety and budget in that it would require hiring of new personnel or re-directing of personnel from essential enforcement type positions to non essential positions. I am not trying to be negative as I would love to see a better, more efficient and more convenient way to register a firearm, but this is what the opposition will be citing. Heavily. So indeed, I would think that it would need to be a mandated thing.
As was mentioned by HiCarry, I too attended and spoke at the NRA Instructor hearing. Very much the numbers in support count, but this proposal unlike the NRA Instructor proposal does not include the same type of inference of safety of liability. This is where the HPD would hit the council also, when it comes to public safety and liability concerns. Now if the City would allocate monies and positions then that is a good thing. Just some things to consider from where the stance from opposition to such a bill will come from.
-
I don't think that the HPD would even consider a voluntary move to include multiple locations for registration as that would not only cause some logistical issues, but most important would demand an increase in, or reallocation of staffing, including sworn and non sworn personnel. The HPD is already around 300 sworn short staffed and unk on civilian staffing. With budgets as tight as they are right now for all City departments / agencies, the HPD is neck deep in the cuts. So much so, that staffing for other non investigative, non patrol and even some plain clothed investigative units are not being filled. Staffing shortages, mandatory working hour changes (often with little notice) to avert overtime, plus much of the normal or necessary overtime resulting from investigations being cut (crime doesn't just happen during normal scheduling hours) means a very tight ship being run. Want to get promoted inside the HPD? CUT your District / Divison / Unit budget dramatically. Almost at all costs.
What does this mean? In essence this means that there is a huge reason that the HPD can cite to not increase staffing in the firearms section as it can be directly tied to public safety and budget in that it would require hiring of new personnel or re-directing of personnel from essential enforcement type positions to non essential positions. I am not trying to be negative as I would love to see a better, more efficient and more convenient way to register a firearm, but this is what the opposition will be citing. Heavily. So indeed, I would think that it would need to be a mandated thing.
As was mentioned by HiCarry, I too attended and spoke at the NRA Instructor hearing. Very much the numbers in support count, but this proposal unlike the NRA Instructor proposal does not include the same type of inference of safety of liability. This is where the HPD would hit the council also, when it comes to public safety and liability concerns. Now if the City would allocate monies and positions then that is a good thing. Just some things to consider from where the stance from opposition to such a bill will come from.
Then we can tell them dont let legal firearm owners in Hawaii burden you. Free yourself up more and get rid of registration!!!! :shaka:
Thanks for offering a different perspective though.
Hopefully as Hicarry points out, small steps set in motion will set us up for bigger plays later.
Im just happy 2a advocates are finally on the offensive. 1st and 10, here we go!!!!
-
well said, bassm
we need to keep up the momentum
Im glad that 2a supporters are finally taking the battle to "them", instead of always having a defensive position. No matter what type of outcome, it will show everyone that the 2a community can and will stick together and fight for our rights.
-
All I can say from this distance is "Best of luck to you."
And even if a person doesn't intend to register/permit any more firearms in the future, go down and testify (or e-mail) anyhow. I have seen too many incremental bites taken out of our freedoms because of the "It doesn't affect me, so why bother?" attitude.of too many people.
The other self-defeating attitude comes from the folks who think, "Ah, hell, they'll rairoad it through and it'll pass (or be defeated) anyhow, so why bother?"
I can't remember how many times I heard the argument against the Gun Control Act of 1968 that, "Hey, that'll never pass! Why, hell, it's clearly against the Second Amendment!"
I... was... one... of... them. :(
And nowadays the concept of owning and bearing arms as an inalienable and individual civil right of all citizens in all States squeaked by in only a 5 to 4 vote!
Sincerely, go testify.
Make notes and take names.
Those who go but don't testify.... you can carry a sign that says,
I'M MAKING NOTES!
I'M TAKING NAMES!
AND I VOTE!
Terry, 230RN
-
A public safety issue/concern or regulatory/enforcement requirement or something of that magnitude would be needed to make them take immediate notice but public outcry or fear of reelection can also push people to take action. Can't speak for C&C but unfunded requirements and mandates are the norm that occur in DoD, and the mandates get accomplished one way or the other and senior leadership fights unfunded requirements every year in the never ending budget battles. Some never get funded, while others do. Right now, I believe HPD views multiple locations as a "nice to have" vice a true requirement, so somehow that needs to change and/or enough public outcry or dissatisfaction needs to occur in order to make lawmakers be concerned about their own future and unwanted negative media coverage. Near-term, we can continue to bombard our legislator's with email and testimony.
-
Do the City and County employees who register firearms need to be policemen? If not, I don't see why a few civilian employees would not be up to the task by taking a one- or two-day firearms training course.
I don't think that the HPD would even consider a voluntary move to include multiple locations for registration as that would not only cause some logistical issues, but most important would demand an increase in, or reallocation of staffing, including sworn and non sworn personnel. The HPD is already around 300 sworn short staffed and unk on civilian staffing. With budgets as tight as they are right now for all City departments / agencies, the HPD is neck deep in the cuts. So much so, that staffing for other non investigative, non patrol and even some plain clothed investigative units are not being filled. Staffing shortages, mandatory working hour changes (often with little notice) to avert overtime, plus much of the normal or necessary overtime resulting from investigations being cut (crime doesn't just happen during normal scheduling hours) means a very tight ship being run. Want to get promoted inside the HPD? CUT your District / Divison / Unit budget dramatically. Almost at all costs.
What does this mean? In essence this means that there is a huge reason that the HPD can cite to not increase staffing in the firearms section as it can be directly tied to public safety and budget in that it would require hiring of new personnel or re-directing of personnel from essential enforcement type positions to non essential positions. I am not trying to be negative as I would love to see a better, more efficient and more convenient way to register a firearm, but this is what the opposition will be citing. Heavily. So indeed, I would think that it would need to be a mandated thing.
As was mentioned by HiCarry, I too attended and spoke at the NRA Instructor hearing. Very much the numbers in support count, but this proposal unlike the NRA Instructor proposal does not include the same type of inference of safety of liability. This is where the HPD would hit the council also, when it comes to public safety and liability concerns. Now if the City would allocate monies and positions then that is a good thing. Just some things to consider from where the stance from opposition to such a bill will come from.
-
Do the City and County employees who register firearms need to be policemen? If not, I don't see why a few civilian employees would not be up to the task by taking a one- or two-day firearms training course.
Police departments use desk positions for cops who are unable to do field duty for whatever reason. Gives them the work they need to reach retirement. Also, any cop involved in an internal investigation, a shooting, etc. can be placed on desk duty until returned to the field.
There are probably other examples of this, but the point is, the cops working in the firearms division may not have been hired just to do that. Replacing them with civilian employees, or even private contractors, may not be an option if the PD feels they need those positions to be available for other reasons.
-
Also remember, there was an appropriation part of SB69 which didn't get any allocation. We were hoping that some of the monies from that failed appropriation could have been used to help with costs of permit/registration, but that didn't happen.
-
This would make life so much easier. :shaka:
-
Also remember, there was an appropriation part of SB69 which didn't get any allocation. We were hoping that some of the monies from that failed appropriation could have been used to help with costs of permit/registration, but that didn't happen.
Tell me again why HRA supported SB69? ???
-
email sent to councilmember chang and his chief of staff
Tell me again why HRA supported SB69? ???
-
According to HRA, the bill has been morphed into a non issue bill that doesn't change anything except lengthening the time required for out of state imports to be registered, or something like that....
http://youtu.be/MurRvcydlqQ (http://youtu.be/MurRvcydlqQ)
-
According to HRA, the bill has been morphed into a non issue bill that doesn't change anything except lengthening the time required for out of state imports to be registered, or something like that....
http://youtu.be/MurRvcydlqQ (http://youtu.be/MurRvcydlqQ)
So two points:
1.) The first point is correct, the bill really didn't do anything different. HPD already did NICS checks on people registering firearms from out of state. The only real difference is now you pay the $16.50 when coming in to register, and not just when doing a permit to acquire.
2.) Regarding registration - my comment is this: People are babies. There are two scenarios - 1.) They know you have guns, they come, you fight them. or 2.) they know you have guns, they come, you give them up. This scenario doesn't really play different if they know, or don't know you have guns. During Katrina, they went door to door. If you aren't willing to defend yourself if they came door to door, you wouldn't be willing to defend yourself if they knew you had them to begin with, so what's it matter?
-
So two points:
1.) The first point is correct, the bill really didn't do anything different. HPD already did NICS checks on people registering firearms from out of state. The only real difference is now you pay the $16.50 when coming in to register, and not just when doing a permit to acquire.
2.) Regarding registration - my comment is this: People are babies. There are two scenarios - 1.) They know you have guns, they come, you fight them. or 2.) they know you have guns, they come, you give them up. This scenario doesn't really play different if they know, or don't know you have guns. During Katrina, they went door to door. If you aren't willing to defend yourself if they came door to door, you wouldn't be willing to defend yourself if they knew you had them to begin with, so what's it matter?
You had to get your prints and were charged the fee prior to the passage of SB 69. So, the only thing SB 69 did was extend the 72 hours to 5 days.....
-
You had to get your prints and were charged the fee prior to the passage of SB 69. So, the only thing SB 69 did was extend the 72 hours to 5 days.....
...yes folks apparently "had to" get the prints/fees up till effective date of SB69CD1. ....but for those folks visiting from out of state (or perhaps those folks moving here from out of state w/ previously acquired firearms), the existing statute didn't require the finger printing/fee. De Facto, the police may have"required it", but it was not in the statute- and that was the "loophole" I believe the AG and others were referring to closing. So did you have to "do it"? Yes, or they would most likely deny your registration. Was it legally required. No- I don't think so. I'm not saying adding the fingerprinting/fee to these registrants is wrong or right. I'm not asking "should fingerprinting be required". It's great to extend from 3 to 5 days. The closing of the loophole does make this consistent with the rest of the process, but while folks "had to do it to get their guns registered", the law didn't state they had to. I think the Police just told folks they "had to".
When the registration dept/police take this liberty- to require when it wasn't in the statute- it indicates,IMO. how much latitude and discretion they have in the process. Or at least how much discretion they may have taken. I relate this act of discretion in registration process to the same problems within the process to get CCW approved. I don't think there are any written rules for some parts of the CCW permit approval process. The Chief of each county gets to "decide" if folks are "of good mental standing" (or what ever the wording is) without any "rules or procedures" for how they get to decide this. They will continue to approve or deny based on their "discretion". Currently, they are allowed to do this. Isn't there a potential conflict of interest between the legal CCW approval process and the will or opinion of the Chiefs? If they are going to misuse their discretion for the 134-3 acquire (fingerprinting process), they certainly may misuse their own "rules" to deny the CCWs.... and the way that statuate is written up, they have a right to use their "discretion" to deny CCW without any written rules for what constitutes "good mental standing".
I still wonder- if someone sued them for "requiring" fingerprinting when it was not in the statute- would this somehow be useful to those who are challenging the CCW approval/denial process? Seems like saying "look, they forced folks to fingerprint to complete registration process when it wasn't in the statute. This demonstrates they are willing to require things that are not in the law. We need to have some written procedure for how they determine what constitutes a "person of good mental standing" to avoid this same abuse of discretion in the CCW process."
It just seems like it would somehow help.
Here's the text from SB69CD1, and it looks like there's a little more than only extending the three days to five days....The Underlined part is new.
THE SENATE S.B. NO. 69 C.D. 1 TWENTY-SEVENTH LEGISLATURE, 2013 STATE OF HAWAII
A BILL FOR AN ACT RELATING TO FIREARMS.
BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF HAWAII:
SECTION 1. Under Hawaii's existing laws, a person arriving in the State with a firearm is required to register the firearm, but no permit process or background check is required. Therefore, individuals who might have been prohibited from acquiring a firearm in Hawaii can acquire a firearm outside of this State, where a permit process or extensive background check may not be required, then possess and be considered registered firearm owners after registering with the county police department.
The purpose of this Act is to require persons arriving in the State with firearms to undergo a background check before registering a firearm with the county police department. In addition, this Act extends the time period for persons bringing a firearm into the State to register the firearm, for consistency with the time period for registering firearms obtained in or imported into the State.
SECTION 2. Section 134-3, Hawaii Revised Statutes, is amended as follows:
1. By amending subsection (a) to read:
"(a) Every person arriving in the State who brings or by any other manner causes to be brought into the State a firearm of any description, whether usable or unusable, serviceable or unserviceable, modern or antique, shall register the firearm within [three] five days after arrival of the person or of the firearm, whichever arrives later, with the chief of police of the county of the person's place of business or, if there is no place of business, the person's residence or, if there is neither a place of business nor residence, the person's place of sojourn. A nonresident alien may bring firearms not otherwise prohibited by law into the State for a continuous period not to exceed ninety days; provided that the person meets the registration requirement of this section and the person possesses:
(1) A valid Hawaii hunting license procured under chapter 183D, part II, or a commercial or private shooting preserve permit issued pursuant to section 183D-34;
(2) A written document indicating the person has been invited to the State to shoot on private land; or
(3) Written notification from a firing range or target shooting business indicating that the person will actually engage in target shooting.
The nonresident alien shall be limited to a nontransferable registration of not more than ten firearms for the purpose of the above activities.
Every person registering a firearm under this subsection shall be fingerprinted and photographed by the police department of the county of registration; provided that this requirement shall be waived where fingerprints and photographs are already on file with the police department. The police department shall perform an inquiry on the person by using the National Instant Criminal Background Check System before any determination to register a firearm is made."
2. By amending subsection (e) to read:
"(e) No fee shall be charged for the registration[.] of a firearm under this section, except for a fee chargeable by and payable to the registering county for persons registering a firearm under subsection (a), in an amount equal to the fee actually charged by the Federal Bureau of Investigation to the registering police department for a fingerprint check in connection with the registration. In the case of a joint registration, the fee provided for in this section may be charged to each person."
SECTION 3. Statutory material to be repealed is bracketed and stricken. New statutory material is underscored.
SECTION 4. This Act shall take effect on July 1, 2013.
Report Title:
Firearm Registration
Description:
Requires county police departments under certain conditions to fingerprint, photograph, and perform background checks on individuals who wish to register a firearm that was procured out-of-state. Authorizes the police departments to assess a fee for conducting a fingerprint check and specifies the amount of the fee. Extends the time period for registering a firearm procured out-of-state for consistency with the time period for registering firearms obtained in or imported into the State. (CD1)
-
When the registration dept/police take this liberty- to require when it wasn't in the statute- it indicates,IMO. how much latitude and discretion they have in the process. Or at least how much discretion they may have taken. I relate this act of discretion in registration process to the same problems within the process to get CCW approved. I don't think there are any written rules for some parts of the CCW permit approval process. The Chief of each county gets to "decide" if folks are "of good mental standing" (or what ever the wording is) without any "rules or procedures" for how they get to decide this. They will continue to approve or deny based on their "discretion". Currently, they are allowed to do this. Isn't there a potential conflict of interest between the legal CCW approval process and the will or opinion of the Chiefs? If they are going to misuse their discretion for the 134-3 acquire (fingerprinting process), they certainly may misuse their own "rules" to deny the CCWs.... and the way that statuate is written up, they have a right to use their "discretion" to deny CCW without any written rules for what constitutes "good mental standing".
I still wonder- if someone sued them for "requiring" fingerprinting when it was not in the statute- would this somehow be useful to those who are challenging the CCW approval/denial process? Seems like saying "look, they forced folks to fingerprint to complete registration process when it wasn't in the statute. This demonstrates they are willing to require things that are not in the law. We need to have some written procedure for how they determine what constitutes a "person of good mental standing" to avoid this same abuse of discretion in the CCW process."
It just seems like it would somehow help.
I get where you're going and it makes good sense to me but I gotto believe making it an objective determination vice subjective will not be an easy battle. Would be great if it can be changed though.
-
From the NRA
http://www.nraila.org/legislation/state-legislation/2013/5/hawaii-city-council-committee-to-consider-resolution-tomorrow-to-ease-compliance.aspx (http://www.nraila.org/legislation/state-legislation/2013/5/hawaii-city-council-committee-to-consider-resolution-tomorrow-to-ease-compliance.aspx)
Hawaii: City Council Committee to Consider Resolution Tomorrow to Ease Compliance
Tomorrow, May 14 at 9:00 am, the Honolulu City Council Committee on Public Safety and Economic Development will be hearing Resolution 13-74 requesting the Honolulu Police Department (HPD) to open the Kapolei and Kaneohe Police Stations to firearm permitting and registration in an effort to make the process less time-consuming and more convenient. Currently, registration and permitting is only offered at the main police station on Beretania Street where the process can take several hours. While the NRA is firmly opposed to firearm registration, we encourage our members to support this effort to make compliance with current law more convenient. This meeting will take place tomorrow morning in the Committee Meeting Room at 530 South King Street in Honolulu.
Using the following information, please contact members of the City Council Committee on Public Safety and Economic Development, and respectfully urge them to adopt this resolution:
Carol Fukunaga, Chairman
Phone: (808) 768-5006
E-mail cafukunaga@honolulu.gov
Kymberly Marcos Pine, Vice Chairman
Phone: (808) 768-5001
E-mail kmpine@honolulu.gov
Ikaika Anderson
Phone: (808) 768-5003
E-mail ianderson@honolulu.gov
Stanley Chang
Phone: (808) 768-5004
E-mail ccldistrict4@honolulu.gov
Breene Harimoto
Phone: (808) 768-5008
E-mail bharimoto@honolulu.gov
-
ooh
kym pine is an R
and i've seen pics of her firing an AR
i've met her before- sending an email tonight
please, everyone, send emails!
From the NRA
http://www.nraila.org/legislation/state-legislation/2013/5/hawaii-city-council-committee-to-consider-resolution-tomorrow-to-ease-compliance.aspx (http://www.nraila.org/legislation/state-legislation/2013/5/hawaii-city-council-committee-to-consider-resolution-tomorrow-to-ease-compliance.aspx)
-
I emailed the while council only ernie Martin replied. He said he's not on the safety committee but if it passes out of committee tomorrow hewill ssupport the bill
-
I emailed the entire City Council too. I went through the process of signing up to give testimony tomorrow, but I'm not sure if my testimony was attached to the request. I reFAXed just in case. I'll probably just say "I stand on my written testimony", but we'll see how many folks are there and how much time there is for testimony. I didn't get any confirmation email saying I was signed up to give oral testimony, but there may not be such an email. Either way, I'll be there tomorrow regardless.
My wife/friends think its kind of funny, as I don't even have any firearms, so I've never had to go through the line or deal with the process....but I plan on taking some training, doing the DLNR hunting class, and then I may get a firearm (or two). I feel all this testimony stuff is the right thing to do whether I have guns or not.... and eventually I'll be in one of these lines :)
-
Gang....Is this meeting tomorrow at the State Capital?
I've got conflicting info, as one City Council notice says the meeting takes place at Honolulu Hale, and another (and the NRA ILA notice) says the meeting takes place at the Council Committee Meeting Room at 530 South King Street in Honolulu.
This second address - 530 S. King Street, Room 202, Honolulu, Hawaii 96813- is listed as the location where the council meets, but not necessarily where they hold these meetings.
I'm planning on going tomorrow, if I can figure out where it is LOL.....Thanks
-
email sent
ooh
kym pine is an R
and i've seen pics of her firing an AR
i've met her before- sending an email tonight
please, everyone, send emails!
-
Today's the big day!
-
You had to get your prints and were charged the fee prior to the passage of SB 69. So, the only thing SB 69 did was extend the 72 hours to 5 days.....
I was never charged a fee when I first brought guns in.
-
Any updates?
-
Any updates?
The news is spinning it as an idea for increased revenue for the City. You want your guns? How much are YOU willing to pay to exercise your rights? :wtf:
http://khon2.com/2013/05/14/new-sites-new-fees-could-end-long-lines-for-gun-permits/ (http://khon2.com/2013/05/14/new-sites-new-fees-could-end-long-lines-for-gun-permits/)
-
The news is spinning it as an idea for increased revenue for the City. You want your guns? How much are YOU willing to pay to exercise your rights? :wtf:
http://khon2.com/2013/05/14/new-sites-new-fees-could-end-long-lines-for-gun-permits/ (http://khon2.com/2013/05/14/new-sites-new-fees-could-end-long-lines-for-gun-permits/)
We the people shouldn't even have to pay more to exercise our 2nd amendment. It shouldn't be a pain for law abiding American to exercise their rights. Report was a little inaccurate implying that people must pay a few every time they go through the process.
-
I'll pay for gun registrations and permits as soon as the state starts making every voter take a competency test on current events, can explain the organization of our branches of government, and shows proper picture ID at the polls.
Learning to vote responsibly can have more impact on our freedoms than the right to keep and bear arms. We should be doing it the right way!!
-
We the people shouldn't even have to pay more to exercise our 2nd amendment. It shouldn't be a pain for law abiding American to exercise their rights. Report was a little inaccurate implying that people must pay a few every time they go through the process.
This is the quote from the report.
HPD says it doesn’t have the money or the staff to do that. Right now, it costs $16.50 to register a firearm.
Agreed, KHON dropped the ball and reported incorrectly what the $16.50 is for.
-
The meeting went quite well. It was "passed on" with an amendment/request for some type of audit to perhaps address the possible costs of increasing new locations. All members voted it be forwarded on w/ the amendment. I'm typing on cellphone, so disjoint summary.
Three people provided testimony. The first was an officer from the PD who deals with permitting/registration for C&C Honolulu. Lots of good questions from Council members after his testimony. Kymberly Marco Pine (Vice Chair) cited Atty Generals "Firearms Registration 2012" report increase of apx 340% over 12 year period (combined registration and permits-and the %340 is from memory as I don't have report in front of me now). After pointing out this increase, she asked the officer if the dept had any increase in dept resources in light of this increase, and officer said "no". Good point. Need goes way up, services remain near the same. The officer did say they were considering making the forms available on line for folks to fill out before coming to the detp. He was noting they were trying to "streamline" the process.
I provided my testimony after the officer. I also pointed out I don't own any guns, nor have I ever been through the registration process. Then I tried to highlight financial hardships caused by folks having to make at least three separate trips to dept, and if they live in Waianae or Kahuku (etc) it is very time consuming and folks may have to take multiple days off from work (smaller paychecks and a strain on our C&C economy). I also noted that the Big Island range line item had been included in the budget (HB200) and talked that up a bit, then brought that back to C&C Hono by noting that if future visitors to this proposed/funded Kailua-Kona range stopped at Oahu for a few days on their way to Hawaii, they may have to register here to be w./I statute. If there's only one location serving the whole island, this could make it difficult for visitors to register, and they may not plan a stay on Oahu to be able to register on Big Island. I pointed out how C&C Hono economy may suffer if these visitors don't stay on Oahu and spend their tourist dollars Oahu too. Also noted they may not come at all if the registration process is perceived as too daunting. After I spoke, councilmember (Maybe Ron Menor???) asked if I thought the online forms would help with the time requirements. I noted the filling out of the forms was only a fraction of the time required to have to make three trips from north shore/Waianae etc....
Thrid speaker was Harvy Gerwig HRA.. He did a great job, and there were several questions from council members after his testimony. They asked about the possibility of registrqants/permitees being willing to pay a fee to help defray costs of process, and he noted HRA and NRA were NOT in favor of this. He also pointed out multiple locations on other Counties, and noted sworn officers manning the location may not be necessary and could cost more than "clerks" to handle paperwork. He noted this was the norm across the nation for the process. Good points all around.
After we three gave testimony, there were a couple more questions asked Mr Gerwig. This may have been when they asked about the possibility of charging money vs during his testimony, but I don't remember the order of the question.
All in all, I would say every single counsel member was in favor, and voted so. The whole meeting was video recorded, and there's a link on C&C website to request a copy of that video. I don't know if they produce a written transcript of the meeting or not. There were a couple news stations there. KHON and KITV. Mr Gerwig got by the KITV group outside the meeting, but was apparently interviewed by KHON outside the building. They KITV News person-Cam Tran- stopped me vs Mr Gerwig because she was very surprised I provided testimony and "I don't even own any guns". I gave her a copy of my testimony, The Atty Generals report, and she asked me several questions on camera, but I don't know if they used it for anything.
It would be worthi asking for a copy of the video of the meeting and watching the Resolution 13-74 part, as folks would see how on top of it the counsel was!!! They were really supportive, and almost all their questions were asked in such a way that the answers they got supported the need for more locations. (it's almost like someone (HRA?? or another supporter) gave a couple potential question to Pine, as they certainly were the right questions. She's very smart, and could easily have come up with the questions herself, but they were questions, when answered, demonstrated the need for something being done!! I'll see if I can get a copy of the meeting video, or if there's a written transcript. My Gerwig (or Dr Cooper) may provide a summary- their take- on the HRA website- I just gussing they may. I'm going to poke around the C&C website docuserver to try to find both the written testimony and the oral testimony. The Chair (Carol Fukunaga) noted before asking for oral testimony there there was "about 100" written testimonials submitted electronically. Folks here really were on top of submitting written testimony in favor. Madam Chair Fukunaga noted "there's an entire folder of testimony in support" that was provided to each counsel member. Cool.
Now I gotta write a little thanks to each of the Council members for their support.
-
kym pine is very smart
berkeley grad
grandmother started democratic party in hawaii with gov burns and others
came home from berkeley and realized that the socialist policies of the left are a problem
so she switched to the right
i told her "this must make for interesting family dinners"
she just laughed and smiled
she may have thought of the questions herself or may have had help from gerwig/cooper
apparently, she was a sponsor of the resolution
good to hear the city council is sharp
cannot say i have heard the same about the leg
great job on testifying, mr smith
i once again applaud your efforts
the offer to let you and your sons shoot my rifle still stands
The meeting went quite well. It was "passed on" with an amendment/request for some type of audit to perhaps address the possible costs of increasing new locations. All members voted it be forwarded on w/ the amendment. I'm typing on cellphone, so disjoint summary.
Three people provided testimony. The first was an officer from the PD who deals with permitting/registration for C&C Honolulu. Lots of good questions from Council members after his testimony. Kymberly Marco Pine (Vice Chair) cited Atty Generals "Firearms Registration 2012" report increase of apx 340% over 12 year period (combined registration and permits-and the %340 is from memory as I don't have report in front of me now). After pointing out this increase, she asked the officer if the dept had any increase in dept resources in light of this increase, and officer said "no". Good point. Need goes way up, services remain near the same. The officer did say they were considering making the forms available on line for folks to fill out before coming to the detp. He was noting they were trying to "streamline" the process.
I provided my testimony after the officer. I also pointed out I don't own any guns, nor have I ever been through the registration process. Then I tried to highlight financial hardships caused by folks having to make at least three separate trips to dept, and if they live in Waianae or Kahuku (etc) it is very time consuming and folks may have to take multiple days off from work (smaller paychecks and a strain on our C&C economy). I also noted that the Big Island range line item had been included in the budget (HB200) and talked that up a bit, then brought that back to C&C Hono by noting that if future visitors to this proposed/funded Kailua-Kona range stopped at Oahu for a few days on their way to Hawaii, they may have to register here to be w./I statute. If there's only one location serving the whole island, this could make it difficult for visitors to register, and they may not plan a stay on Oahu to be able to register on Big Island. I pointed out how C&C Hono economy may suffer if these visitors don't stay on Oahu and spend their tourist dollars Oahu too. Also noted they may not come at all if the registration process is perceived as too daunting. After I spoke, councilmember (Maybe Ron Menor???) asked if I thought the online forms would help with the time requirements. I noted the filling out of the forms was only a fraction of the time required to have to make three trips from north shore/Waianae etc....
Thrid speaker was Harvy Gerwig HRA.. He did a great job, and there were several questions from council members after his testimony. They asked about the possibility of registrqants/permitees being willing to pay a fee to help defray costs of process, and he noted HRA and NRA were NOT in favor of this. He also pointed out multiple locations on other Counties, and noted sworn officers manning the location may not be necessary and could cost more than "clerks" to handle paperwork. He noted this was the norm across the nation for the process. Good points all around.
After we three gave testimony, there were a couple more questions asked Mr Gerwig. This may have been when they asked about the possibility of charging money vs during his testimony, but I don't remember the order of the question.
All in all, I would say every single counsel member was in favor, and voted so. The whole meeting was video recorded, and there's a link on C&C website to request a copy of that video. I don't know if they produce a written transcript of the meeting or not. There were a couple news stations there. KHON and KITV. Mr Gerwig got by the KITV group outside the meeting, but was apparently interviewed by KHON outside the building. They KITV News person-Cam Tran- stopped me vs Mr Gerwig because she was very surprised I provided testimony and "I don't even own any guns". I gave her a copy of my testimony, The Atty Generals report, and she asked me several questions on camera, but I don't know if they used it for anything.
It would be worthi asking for a copy of the video of the meeting and watching the Resolution 13-74 part, as folks would see how on top of it the counsel was!!! They were really supportive, and almost all their questions were asked in such a way that the answers they got supported the need for more locations. (it's almost like someone (HRA?? or another supporter) gave a couple potential question to Pine, as they certainly were the right questions. She's very smart, and could easily have come up with the questions herself, but they were questions, when answered, demonstrated the need for something being done!! I'll see if I can get a copy of the meeting video, or if there's a written transcript. My Gerwig (or Dr Cooper) may provide a summary- their take- on the HRA website- I just gussing they may. I'm going to poke around the C&C website docuserver to try to find both the written testimony and the oral testimony. The Chair (Carol Fukunaga) noted before asking for oral testimony there there was "about 100" written testimonials submitted electronically. Folks here really were on top of submitting written testimony in favor. Madam Chair Fukunaga noted "there's an entire folder of testimony in support" that was provided to each counsel member. Cool.
Now I gotta write a little thanks to each of the Council members for their support.
-
the offer to let you and your sons shoot my rifle still stands
My pleasure providing testimony for anything in support of 2a rights....and I would almost say it was/is my duty/responsibility to do so! I want my/our kids to have these rights in the future, even if I don't own any guns right now....and my boys and I would love to shoot with you sometime......
-
What is the next step?
Also I must agree, nothing better then the feeling of seeing them pull out a fat stack of testimony papers all in support. As well as the look on everyone's faces. Ah. Makes me proud. Makes me smile.
-
did you guys notice in the star-ad where they interviewed kym, she said she was getting tons of emails from "doctors and pastors"?
i am not a real doctor, so she couldn't have been talking about me
http://2ahawaii.com/Smileys/extended/evil.gif (http://2ahawaii.com/Smileys/extended/evil.gif)
kym pine is very smart
berkeley grad
grandmother started democratic party in hawaii with gov burns and others
came home from berkeley and realized that the socialist policies of the left are a problem
so she switched to the right
i told her "this must make for interesting family dinners"
she just laughed and smiled
she may have thought of the questions herself or may have had help from gerwig/cooper
apparently, she was a sponsor of the resolution
good to hear the city council is sharp
cannot say i have heard the same about the leg
great job on testifying, mr smith
i once again applaud your efforts
the offer to let you and your sons shoot my rifle still stands