Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - nick

Pages: [1]
1
Firearms and Accessories / Re: Considering a Smith and Wesson 500
« on: December 26, 2014, 08:26:29 PM »
...
I had a 4 in. M29 which I shot so much it broke.
SEC sent it back to repair and I had them install a 6 in bbl while it was there.

Did S&W charge you for the new barrel?

I have been entertaining myself with the idea of getting a shorter barrel installed on my 500. However, I'm a little worried about the cost and time. I once sent my 500 in for repair (the barrel, barrel shroud, and muzzle break were not tightened correctly) and it took a month for them to fix it and give it back.
2
Firearms and Accessories / Re: Considering a Smith and Wesson 500
« on: December 24, 2014, 03:49:38 PM »
You cannot go wrong with an S&W 44 Mag revolver. Factory ammo is much cheaper than 500. Back two years ago, OGC was selling a box of 44 Magnum (50 rounds for $35). That was a good deal back then. I am not sure how much 44 Magnum goes for these days.
3
Firearms and Accessories / Re: Considering a Smith and Wesson 500
« on: December 24, 2014, 07:23:47 AM »
Hello oldfart.

There is indeed a correlation between recoil and barrel length and from what I understand there are two possible theories.

The first theory is exactly what you mentioned, longer barrels create more velocity, which in turn creates higher muzzle energy, which in turn will create more recoil. In a 500 Magnum 4 inch revolver, I have seen a 335 grain bullet chronographed at 1500 fps which would give 1673 foot pounds of muzzle energy. In a 10.5 inch barrel, I would expect upwards of  2000 1800fps which would produce an astounding 2400 +  foot pounds of muzzle energy.

There is a second theory about barrel length and recoil. This theory is that shorter barrels result in less weight of the gun, which would result in more felt recoil. For example, a 4 inch revolver weighing 56 ounces would have more felt recoil than a 10.5 inch barrel revolver weighing 79 ounces. This could explain why a 500 Linebaugh out of a gun that weighs half of an S&W can have so much felt recoil. That and also some of those 500 Linebaugh revolvers have no muzzle break or decelerating grips.

My guess is that both theories will have some affect on the felt recoil.
However, theory number 1 probably is more relevant here. That increase in velocity is significant.
Well anyway, I hope I'm not confusing anyone here. Cheers  :shaka:

My recommendation: To reduce recoil, the easiest thing to do is stick to 275 grain and 300 grain bullets using reduced loads. If unable to reload your own ammunition, I know there are a few factory ammo reduced loads for the 500 Mag. I do not know if anyone locally carries it or how much it would cost.
4
Firearms and Accessories / Re: Considering a Smith and Wesson 500
« on: December 24, 2014, 06:55:56 AM »
Thank you dogman.

I think I have been a member for about 2 years now. I wasn't really planning on ever commenting here until I saw this thread. I have a special interest in big caliber handguns, and the 500 Magnum is one cartridge I have studied many hours in pursuit of building cheap yet powerful ammo. I also own a S&W in 44Mag, Desert Eagle in 44Mag and 50AE, and two Thompson Encore pistols in 308 Winchester and 300 Winchester Magnum.

Hopefully some of my insights and experiences will help others here make informed decisions on these obscure firearms.
5
Firearms and Accessories / Re: Considering a Smith and Wesson 500
« on: December 24, 2014, 05:05:04 AM »
Hello dogman,

I do have a S&W 44 Magnum Hunter. It is a Performance Center revolver with 7.5 inch barrel and muzzle break. I have shot 200 grain bullets, 240 grain, and 300 grain bullets from the 44 Mag. The 200 grain bullets with near max loads of H-110 were very loud but surprisingly kind of weak in recoil. The 300 grain bullets with a near max load of H-110 has much more recoil than the 200 grain bullets. However, even the the 300 grain bullets out of the 44 Magnum do not compare with the 400 grain bullets of the 500 Magnum. I would say the 500 Magnum has at least three times the recoil kickback of my 44 Magnum.

However, I should mention the type of revolver used would also make a difference in perceived recoil. For example, S&W makes a 44 Magnum revolver with a 2.625 inch barrel and no muzzle break. A 300 grain bullet out of this little monster would probably be very interesting.

6
Firearms and Accessories / Re: Considering a Smith and Wesson 500
« on: December 24, 2014, 01:18:09 AM »
Hello there. I'm not an active member here but would like to provide some insights.

I have owned a 500 S&W 10.5 inch barrel revolver for about one year now and shot probably less than 1,000 rounds through it. I have also had the pleasure of shooting the 4 inch version a few times. For shooting off hand at 25 yards with no optics, I can hit a 5 inch target very consistently with the 10.5 inch barrel.

Looking back at my experience with the 500, I am not sure if I would have selected the 10.5 inch again. The gun is very front heavy (due to the long barrel) and does not balance well in the hand. I try not to shoot more than 30 rounds a day due to the weight of the gun wearing down my arms and accuracy suffers due to fatigue. If i had the chance to redo the purchase, I would probably get the 7.5 inch Performance Center version or the 6.5 inch version.

When I had the chance to shoot the 4 inch barrel, I immediately noticed that it had great balance in the hand and the aiming was very steady. I did not notice any recoil difference between the two barrel lengths. Although, I admit, I did not get to shoot the 4 inch version enough to really get a better feel for it.

Something to keep in mind with the S&W 500 is that they are double/single action revolvers. There are many video instances on Youtube of inexperienced shooters double tapping these revolvers. One poor woman was killed on the mainland with a S&W 500. She lost control of the first shot and as the recoil sent the barrel towards her head, she accidentally pulled the trigger a second time.

Now on the topic of reloads. I do reload all of my 500 magnum rounds. For economical shooting, I suggest purchasing new brass directly from Starline. Bullets can be very expensive, the cheapest bullets I have found are Berry's 350 grain bullets which are rated for 2000fps. Rainier's 335 grain bullets are the next best bet although they are only rated for 1500fps. Shooting the Rainier's at higher velocities will result in copper plating getting blown out of the muzzle break causing skin injury and bleeding to yourself and those around you. My favorite powders are Accurate 5744, Accurate 4100, Ramshot Enforcer, and H-110. As for primers, make sure to use Large Rifle primers or Large Rifle Magnum primers as instructed per reloading data. New 500 Magnum brass no longer uses Large Magnum Pistol primers. The original 500 Magnum brass was designed for use with Large Magnum Pistol primers so if you are going to use old/used brass, make sure to check what primer to use.

If you have any other questions, I would be happy to provide more thoughts and experiences.

Merry Christmas Everyone!
Pages: [1]