Gun ownership hits record low? (Read 23574 times)

eyeeatingfish

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #40 on: March 17, 2015, 07:23:27 PM »
I don't understand why you are discussing this issue and asking about "accurate" and/or "scientific" data and yet admit that you won't take the time to investigate the existing contradictory data (while claiming to have some background in issues that would allow you to make such determinations). Do you want the "truth", as you claim, or do you have some other agenda? Whenever someone presents a point of view about these issues you take a contrary position based upon hypotheticals and then say "I don't know if that is true or not". Well f*cking find out, or shut up.

You obviously must know that there are vast numbers of studies about firearm ownership and/or CCW and the consequence of those rates on defensive gun uses and rates of criminal acts, most famously is John Lott's work, including "More Guns, Less Crime". That book of research by two university professors was published in 1998. You've had almost 17 years to study that book, its revised and updated editions, and the dozens of critical and supportive studies, reports, and papers submitted in response to the information and hypotheses in the book. Yet, in those 17 years you haven't gotten around to looking at the data and coming to some conclusion that will aid you in making sound arguments using that data re the advisability of law-abiding American citizens owning and/or carrying weapons, It appears that you really aren't that interested in finding out the "truth" as you claim. What's the problem?

Or, perhaps you want to claim that since academics, who spend their entire lives conducting research and studying these questions, continue to disagree, that there is no "truth" and all the research is flawed in one way or another or to one degree or another, and therefore no one can draw a reasonably accurate conclusion with any degree of certainty? But, no, you don't. You claim that you (or someone else who you can read and study) have the ability to analyze research methodology and determine the degree of reliability or "accuracy" of particular conclusions. So why don't you do that? I don't get it. Please spare me the "I just want the truth so I can evaluate the arguments for and against implementing Second Amendment rights".

I have looked at contradictory data as it was posted and it has been part of this discussion. That is why I ended the first post asking for people's thoughts. When different studies come up with conflicting results then we can talk about what may have made the results different. I don't just find a contradictory source with a result I like better and then ignore the source whose result I don't like.

I have not read that book and this is the first I have heard of it so I really cannot offer educated comment on it's arguments. It sounds like something I would be interested in reading. It would be even cooler to see their response to the results quoted in the original article.

Your logic is flawed because if I wasn't interested in the truth then I wouldn't have started this thread asking for people's thoughts! This is information sharing and gathering.

punaperson

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #41 on: March 26, 2015, 07:21:39 AM »
Brief essay from Kurt Hoffman re this question of more guns owned by fewer people. He goes over basically the same territory that's been covered, but I found this survey result interesting. Says a lot about the mindset (lack of mind?) of those opposed to Second Amendment-guaranteed rights.

"Progressive" Writer Blames "Arsenal Owners" for Blocking Onerous Gun Laws

http://jpfo.org/articles-2015/arsenal-owners-to-blame.htm

Taking a look at some of the datasets and questions, I found this one from 2004:

990. Suppose research proves that more legal restrictions on handguns would increase violent crime. Which of these two reactions would be closer to your position:

1. WOULD CHANGE MIND AND OPPOSE MORE RESTRICTIONS
2. WOULD STILL SUPPORT MORE RESTRICTIONS

62.9% said they would still support MORE restrictions. Think about that. Even if it is proven conclusively that gun control INCREASES violent crime, most people NORC surveyed would still push for more restrictions.

passivekinetic

Re: Gun ownership hits record low?
« Reply #42 on: March 26, 2015, 03:14:01 PM »
Brief essay from Kurt Hoffman re this question of more guns owned by fewer people. He goes over basically the same territory that's been covered, but I found this survey result interesting. Says a lot about the mindset (lack of mind?) of those opposed to Second Amendment-guaranteed rights.

"Progressive" Writer Blames "Arsenal Owners" for Blocking Onerous Gun Laws

http://jpfo.org/articles-2015/arsenal-owners-to-blame.htm

Taking a look at some of the datasets and questions, I found this one from 2004:

990. Suppose research proves that more legal restrictions on handguns would increase violent crime. Which of these two reactions would be closer to your position:

1. WOULD CHANGE MIND AND OPPOSE MORE RESTRICTIONS
2. WOULD STILL SUPPORT MORE RESTRICTIONS

62.9% said they would still support MORE restrictions. Think about that. Even if it is proven conclusively that gun control INCREASES violent crime, most people NORC surveyed would still push for more restrictions.

Thanks for bringing that to light.

In fact, if the whole issue were based on logic, it would not have been an issue in the first place.

More guns = less crime. Criminals themselves say they wouldn't want to target gun owners. How hard is that to understand?

It has always been an emotional issue. People simply do not like violence in the world and close their eyes and wish it would go away. Those are immature and naive people, basically. Also they need history lessons.

"The sheep fear sheepdogs, because they fail to see the wolves."
- Anonymous