My boo and I have a pair of Kawasaki Vulcan 500 motorcycles, 2000 year model, that we bought new. We paid somewhere in the neighborhood of $5k each for them. We've kept them running, but more-or-less ignored them, for 16 years. Now they've reached the point where a serious investment, either of time & labor or of money, is needed to return them to "safe, legal, and reliable" status.
We could replace them. The Suzuki Boulevard S40 is in the same price range, MSRP if $5500. That's completely manageable.
The question we're currently asking ourselves is "what's the $$$ value that decides the difference between repair and replace?" My current thinking is that if repairs are south of $1K per bike, we repair. If they're north of $2K per bike, we replace. In the middle, we flutter about, unable to decide.
Weigh in on your opinion!