New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii? (Read 9918 times)

punaperson

So the cultural epicenters of "our" new circuit would be San Francisco, Portland, and Honolulu. Sounds about right.  :crazy:

Under New Bill, Federal Appellate Court Based in California Could Be Split Up

https://www.wsj.com/articles/under-new-bill-federal-appellate-court-based-in-california-could-be-split-up-1486072683

Some highlights/lowlights;

Attempts to break up the sprawling federal appellate court anchored in California have advanced through Congress for decades, introduced with fanfare only to fizzle out in the face of opposition.

But with Republicans now fully in control in Washington, new legislation proposed in the U.S. Senate Thursday to split up the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals could gain more momentum than the movement has had in years.
....
Critics point to figures showing that as of September, the court had 13,334 pending cases, far more than double the next busiest circuit. The court takes a median of around 14 months to reach a decision in a case, five and a half months slower than the national median.
.....
The bill from Sens. Flake and McCain proposes creating a new circuit for Arizona, Nevada, Idaho, Montana, Alaska and Washington, based in Seattle.

Leaving California paired with Oregon, Hawaii and the two U.S. territories will only make the remaining Ninth Circuit more liberal, Judge Kozinski said.

nathanm14fan

Re: New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii?
« Reply #1 on: February 03, 2017, 08:20:27 AM »
Due to its high population, California should have its own Circuit Court of Appeals.

punaperson

Re: New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii?
« Reply #2 on: February 03, 2017, 08:54:52 AM »
Due to its high population, California should have its own Circuit Court of Appeals.
Let's hope for a miracle and that their secession movement succeeds. We'll all be better off. Well, I mean except for all the people in California that might object to living under communism, which is apparently about 20%.

omnigun

Re: New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii?
« Reply #3 on: February 03, 2017, 09:58:14 AM »
Let's hope for a miracle and that their secession movement succeeds. We'll all be better off. Well, I mean except for all the people in California that might object to living under communism, which is apparently about 20%.

lol no.  As much as I hate commiefornia them leaving America would ruin us.  They not only house most of our tech companies their economy is largest in America. 

changemyoil66

Re: New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii?
« Reply #4 on: February 03, 2017, 10:45:39 AM »
lol no.  As much as I hate commiefornia them leaving America would ruin us.  They not only house most of our tech companies their economy is largest in America.

The tech companies would move and many others as well.  Causing what you would see in the movie "Escape from LA/NY" type of environment.  Snake Bliskin will have to dust off the leather pants and boots.

FBI

Re: New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii?
« Reply #5 on: February 03, 2017, 01:35:14 PM »
lol no.  As much as I hate commiefornia them leaving America would ruin us.  They not only house most of our tech companies their economy is largest in America.

When you say "tech companies" , you're talking about the engineering side of the "tech".
Nothing is made in CA.  Engineering is done there. .  I'm an engineer so I understand
my place in the scheme of things.  I produce intellectual property,  that isn't worth squat until someone
builds something based on it.  Additionally,  GSP counts Hollywood output ( would you miss that?),
tourist areas, and all sorts of service businesses that don't produce things.  I suspect that only the coastal areas
would leave and  that is no great loss.  Tech  will still produce and the Democrats there can no longer
screw up the rest of America.  Let them go. Maybe they will take Oahu with them freeing up the rest of
us to be free from Honolulu Tyrants.

omnigun

Re: New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii?
« Reply #6 on: February 03, 2017, 02:32:23 PM »
When you say "tech companies" , you're talking about the engineering side of the "tech".
Nothing is made in CA.  Engineering is done there. .  I'm an engineer so I understand
my place in the scheme of things.  I produce intellectual property,  that isn't worth squat until someone
builds something based on it.  Additionally,  GSP counts Hollywood output ( would you miss that?),
tourist areas, and all sorts of service businesses that don't produce things.  I suspect that only the coastal areas
would leave and  that is no great loss.  Tech  will still produce and the Democrats there can no longer
screw up the rest of America.  Let them go. Maybe they will take Oahu with them freeing up the rest of
us to be free from Honolulu Tyrants.
Gdp is still money. Yes the software side but that's important too. They also have agricultural.  Hollywood whether you like it or not is big money. Overall that's still over 2.4 trillion less money. I highly doubt all of calis major businesses would flee if they leave the union. I mean they got all the opportunity to leave right now but they haven't.

passivekinetic

Re: New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii?
« Reply #7 on: February 04, 2017, 10:45:59 AM »
The tech companies would move and many others as well.  Causing what you would see in the movie "Escape from LA/NY" type of environment.  Snake Bliskin will have to dust off the leather pants and boots.

If tech companies move out of CA, they might be influenced more by conservative values.
"The sheep fear sheepdogs, because they fail to see the wolves."
- Anonymous

punaperson

Re: New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii?
« Reply #8 on: February 09, 2017, 06:58:40 AM »
This bill to split up the Ninth Circuit is now (6:45 AM) the lead story at the Fox News home page because this is the circuit that heard oral arguments Tuesday and will announce a decision on the legality of Trump's immigration orders. If they go against Trump maybe there will be some more motivation to split the circuit (maybe making things even worse for us) and/or increase the motivation for appointments to the bench for the circuit even more of a priority for the Trump administration, which will be our only long term hope (I'm pretty sure there is no short term hope of any pro 2A decisions coming out of the Ninth... I mean, they just ruled in Peruta that there is no Constitutionally-protected right for concealed carry... and refused to address open carry... and Hawaii claims that neither is protected and "the entire public sphere [is] a "sensitive place" where guns may be prohibited" [Emphasis in original].).

The article itself is here:

http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2017/02/09/bill-to-split-nutty-9th-circuit-gains-momentum.html

Heavies

Re: New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii?
« Reply #9 on: February 09, 2017, 08:27:39 PM »
lol no.  As much as I hate commiefornia them leaving America would ruin us.  They not only house most of our tech companies their economy is largest in America. 
So why the hell is commiefornia so broke? 

My thoughts.  If they succeeded, those that have smarts would leave. The United States of America would be fine, commiefornia would turn into anarchy and fail so bad they'd be begging to re join.   

Half the state wouldn't join in this movement anyway.   only the huge degenerate cities would leave.  They'd be broke in a month, probably less.

Inspector

Re: New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii?
« Reply #10 on: February 10, 2017, 06:37:35 AM »
About the only thing that worries me about Kalifornia leaving the Republic is the ports. The mainland relies on Kalifornia ports for imports and exports. More than 40 percent of containerized imports enter the country through Kalifornia ports, and nearly 30 percent of the country’s exports depart through them. A Kalifornia tax on imports and exports would hurt the country as a whole. However, if Washington and/or Oregon were capable of taking up the slack then Kalifornia would be in a world of hurt as around $10B is generated every year in taxes. Not to mention that a large percentage of what we receive from the mainland comes through Kalifornia ports. This worries me a lot.

Other than that I feel that Kalifornia can go to HELL and take all the snowflakes and buttercups with them. Tech companies? A lot have left already. But the ones that are tied into the local and state governments will stay as the companies get a lot for their bribes. JMHO
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

Heavies

Re: New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii?
« Reply #11 on: February 10, 2017, 09:03:06 PM »
If they go, and the jones act is repealed, our shipping can come directly to us in Hawaii, instead of being hijacked on the west coast.

That would be a huge boost for us here, however, knowing how this state operates, it would royally screw it up and we would have all kinds of problems.

whynow?

Re: New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii?
« Reply #12 on: February 11, 2017, 08:25:35 AM »
If they go, and the jones act is repealed, our shipping can come directly to us in Hawaii, instead of being hijacked on the west coast.

That would be a huge boost for us here, however, knowing how this state operates, it would royally screw it up and we would have all kinds of problems.
If Cali goes the Jones Act needs to go to.   In fact even if no Calexit, congress needs to end the Jones Act.   
If Cali votes to leave, I think most inland counties will leave Cali even if Sacramento says no.   Liberalism has started the fragmentation of this country. 

Inspector

SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

Heavies

Re: New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii?
« Reply #14 on: February 11, 2017, 08:52:05 AM »
http://www.hawaiireporter.com/lingle-defends-jones-act-shipping-law

Comments?

I think she probably has a interest in that game.  Jones act is not good for us, or other places outside of the continental US, for imported goods. 

It is ridiculous that products are shipped to the west coast, then shipped back here. How much does that increase cost for the consumer?

Will it cripple shipbuilding and merchant marine?  It might reduce it, I doubt it will cripple it.  That industry will have to change and adapt. It will survive. 

IMHO, crony capitalism needs to go, now it the perfect time for it to be abolished.

whynow?

Re: New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii?
« Reply #15 on: February 11, 2017, 10:47:23 PM »
http://www.hawaiireporter.com/lingle-defends-jones-act-shipping-law

Comments?
Maybe at one time in our history, a strong U.S. maritime fleet was vital to our national security.   But with lack of U.S. steel makers and other materials needed for American shipbuilding, can a commercial fleet be supported and strengthened?   Not sure how many private  U.S. shipyards can actually build large commercial vessels now.  There are only 4 public navy shipyards now and read somewhere that BRAC is supposed to meet again.  At one time we were told or "threatened with" that the Navy would only keep one shipyard on each coast, meaning PSNSY with Bremerton and NNSY.  PNSY and PHNSY would either close or become repair facilities with Pearl probably under Puget admin.   Hope with DJT vowing to strengthen the fleets, this will never happen.  I want PHNSY to see it's 200th anniversary as a shipyard.
I notice she made this comment about supporting Jones Act during an election year, as she said both her GOP and DEM opponents were against it.  Was this election talk to appease labor, IDK.

punaperson

Re: New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii?
« Reply #16 on: April 27, 2017, 07:03:36 AM »
Here is an article published today re the Ninth Circuit possibly being broken into two or three new circuits with an autoplay video of Trump commenting briefly on the Ninth Circuit and further comments by former judge Andrew Napolitano. This is "news" now because both of Trump's executive order attempts to stem illegal immigration and stop "sanctuary cities" from protecting illegal aliens from law enforcement have been blocked by judges in Hawaii and California and are now heading to the Ninth Circuit.

http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2017/04/27/trump-eyes-bid-to-split-up-9th-circuit-court-amid-sanctuary-city-travel-ban-disputes.html

Trump eyes bid to split up 9th Circuit court amid sanctuary city, travel ban disputes

President Trump upped his battle with the federal appeals court potentially standing in the way of his agenda, saying Wednesday he “absolutely” has considered proposals to break up the San Francisco-based 9th Circuit.

Republicans have long complained that the 9th Circuit is not only liberal-leaning but far too big – covering a sprawling amount of territory.

GOP Sens. Jeff Flake and John McCain of Arizona introduced legislation earlier this year to carve six states out of the court circuit and create a brand new 12th Circuit.

If they succeed, only California, Oregon, Hawaii and two island districts would remain in the 9th.

Under Flake’s bill, the new circuit would cover Nevada, Washington, Idaho, Montana, Arizona and Alaska.

rklapp

Re: New Federal Bill to Split Up Ninth Circuit: Even worse for Hawaii?
« Reply #17 on: April 27, 2017, 07:41:54 AM »
Although I think Trump is an ass, I wasn't too worried about him causing too much damage because of the checks and balances between the 3 branches. Republicans hate the 9th Circuit and Democrats hate the 5th Circuit. Every incoming President enters office with all piss and vinegar and then gets kicked in the nards. Obama got his healthcare bill passed then pretty much spent the rest of the time blowing up terrorists and increasing the stock price of gun manufacturers every time he said gun control. Eventually, Trump's Muslim ban will pass the SCOTUS because Congress has given the President that power. Everything that Trump has accomplished has been housekeeping like getting out of TPP and gutting the government agencies, especially the State department. I doubt he'll be able to pass anything significant because the GOP is the party of no.

Regarding the Jones Act, if the Native Hawaiians want their own sovereignty, they need to get rid of the Jones Act. Then they can set up their own "sanctuary island" and buy directly from Asia. It will still be tough going but probably better than relying on casinos.
Yahh! Freedom and justice shall always prevail over tyranny, Babysitter Girl!
https://ronsreloading.wordpress.com/