Awesome write-up! Thank you for sharing! Wish there were more reviews like this on optics of this range.
1000 round evaluation with .308 is quite a bit of "work". I used to own an LMT MRP and that was an accurate gun. Mine was the 12" monolithic rail model, so it was pretty damn heavy, but a great gun. I have a couple of buddies with the MWS and they are pretty sweet.
The Leupold Mark 6 1-6 was pretty high up on the list when I was searching for an LPVO. Overall, I went with the NF for 1-8 and a few other reasons, but from what I read, the Leupold Mark 6 is awesome. I would later find out a shooting instructor that I've taken a number of carbine classes with has the Mark 6 1-6, but he rarely shoots it.
Weight is def something I notice after shooting with the NF for a while. My NF is 25% heavier than the Mark 6 and I definitely feel it. I also have a pretty darn heavy mount as well. There have been a few shooters with LPVOs in recent carbine classes and they all noticed how their LPVO guns are noticeably heavier than their guns with a red dot. I think my LPVO setup is about 1 lb heavier, but I definitely felt it after a couple of carbine classes.
The "flatness" is one aspect of quality glass that I now pick up, and never really noticed before. I mean I've shot with Vortex Strike Eagle and a couple in that price range and they seemed decent, now that I've been shooting with the NF for a while, I notice the edge distortion more. It doesn't really bother me or think it is a significant negative for the most part, but definitely appreciate that in higher quality optics.
The illumination was a key consideration for my choice of LPVO, and I was initially leaning toward the Vortex Razor for it's reputation for "close to red dot" illumination. Seems like similar to the Mark 6, the illumination is more "difficult" at higher magnification. To me, it seems quite sensitive to head position side-to-side as opposed to eye relief. I don't really use the illumination at higher magnification though. Actually, most of my shooting with the NF so far has been at 1x with illumination, but I have been meaning to do more shooting with higher mag range. Waiting for travel stuff to calm down for a "longer range" course on the mainland.
Again, good stuff. Hope you are able to complete your 1000 round evaluation soon.