They should have their own division and until that happens, compete as their biological gender.
As an athlete, I know the huge difference in male/female divisions. My speculation is the people who want this so bad, never played sports on a regular basis.
The simplest answer is the correct one.
[snip]
i thought about what a trans-women or trans-man league would look like. Unless it's for the sheer entertainment value of seeing trans people pretend to be another sex while displaying all the characteristics of the sex they were born with, it's not going to be any more popular than midget bowling.
If you single them out to compete against others in the same category, for lack of a better term, they are going to claim discrimination, when all you are doing is making the games fair for all.
They can't compete with the same results against bio-men, so against other trans-women, they are going to lose the whole advantage that i bet many of them saw as the #1 reason to "transition." I'm sure that would curtail much of the teen transgenders who are only interested in sports wins.
i remember when the Olympics tested Russian athletes for drugs, blood doping, and gender amidst suspicion some of the women on the team were men who'd been given drugs to make them look more feminine. It would be too costly and embarrassing to do that for every trans-athlete, so common sense needs to prevail.
Analogy time: a kid has been held back 4 times in elementary school. By the 9th grade, he's now 19 whereas the average age of 9th graders is around 15. Is it fair to let an adult play on high school sports teams? The school benefits by having a man between the ages of 19-24 during his high school career (assuming he's not held back any more grades). Also, the team coaches and players benefit through never, or rarely, losing a game/match. But the classmates who didn't make the cut for the team are harmed, as are the teams they play because they don't have an adult player with the same number of years maturing and working out.
So, do you keep this "kid" from being on any school teams out of fairness to all the other students, or do you opt for what's good for the school and the kid who flunked out 4 different times?
I don't think an adult should be playing on high school teams regardless of the reason. I think most conferences have age restrictions, which is why you sometimes hear of an illegal alien's son having a fake birth certificate to seem younger just so they can join and have a shot at professional sports after graduation.
if we discriminate based on age, and Title IX was intended to make sports teams fair and equal between the sexes, then allowing transgenders to have a genetic advantage over all other players destroys all of that.