Do they think we're stupid? (Read 1323 times)

macsak

Do they think we're stupid?
« on: July 02, 2023, 11:51:59 AM »

groveler

Re: Do they think we're stupid?
« Reply #1 on: July 02, 2023, 12:34:27 PM »

They know their voters are
What scares them shitless
is the ones like me that don't say anything,
We just do, when the time is right.
\ :thumbsup:

oldfart

Re: Do they think we're stupid?
« Reply #2 on: July 02, 2023, 09:22:56 PM »
Good video with common sense points.
I like the suggestion that college entrance exams just use anonymous numbers instead of names.
It's the only way to assure true equality.
What, Me Worry?

changemyoil66

Re: Do they think we're stupid?
« Reply #3 on: July 03, 2023, 11:39:53 AM »
The college system is a scam.

Any major should have classes only related to said major.

Example: Dentist. Why does 1 need to take undergrad classes like English, History, Foreign Language, etc...It's so the colleges can milk 2 more years of tuition and funds out of every student.  They should only take dental related classes and maybe business law type and accounting as many dentist have a private practice.

Here's what I took as undergrad to try to get into the school of bushiness:

History 101
History 201
Liguistics 101
Linguistics 102
Phychology 101
Speech 151
Speech 251
NREM 202 (Math)
Japanese 101
Japanese 102
Japanese 201
Japanese 202
Oceanography 201
Food Science 185
Economics 101
Economics 102

All these BS classes unrelated to a marketing degree, with the exception of economics.

THen I have a friend who has an electrical engineering degree and works on nuclear subs.  He basically, reads the manual and tells the sailors how to put stuff together/fix it.  He isn't' allowed to touch anything. I asked him if is EE degree helped at all and he said no. 100% OTJ. Even the EE terms or like stuff he learned never applied to what he does.  Guess he should have taken accounting as well cause he mistakenly ordered a case of bolts that each bolt cost $40,000. He only needed 2.   His boss said it's ok, cause they had to spend the money to keep their budget, or it gets reduced if they don't use it all. 

macsak

Re: Do they think we're stupid?
« Reply #4 on: July 03, 2023, 12:21:25 PM »
dentists are not real doctors...

The college system is a scam.

Any major should have classes only related to said major.

Example: Dentist. Why does 1 need to take undergrad classes like English, History, Foreign Language, etc...It's so the colleges can milk 2 more years of tuition and funds out of every student.  They should only take dental related classes and maybe business law type and accounting as many dentist have a private practice.

Here's what I took as undergrad to try to get into the school of bushiness:

History 101
History 201
Liguistics 101
Linguistics 102
Phychology 101
Speech 151
Speech 251
NREM 202 (Math)
Japanese 101
Japanese 102
Japanese 201
Japanese 202
Oceanography 201
Food Science 185
Economics 101
Economics 102

All these BS classes unrelated to a marketing degree, with the exception of economics.

THen I have a friend who has an electrical engineering degree and works on nuclear subs.  He basically, reads the manual and tells the sailors how to put stuff together/fix it.  He isn't' allowed to touch anything. I asked him if is EE degree helped at all and he said no. 100% OTJ. Even the EE terms or like stuff he learned never applied to what he does.  Guess he should have taken accounting as well cause he mistakenly ordered a case of bolts that each bolt cost $40,000. He only needed 2.   His boss said it's ok, cause they had to spend the money to keep their budget, or it gets reduced if they don't use it all.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Do they think we're stupid?
« Reply #5 on: July 03, 2023, 12:39:30 PM »
The college system is a scam.

Any major should have classes only related to said major.

Example: Dentist. Why does 1 need to take undergrad classes like English, History, Foreign Language, etc...It's so the colleges can milk 2 more years of tuition and funds out of every student.  They should only take dental related classes and maybe business law type and accounting as many dentist have a private practice.

Here's what I took as undergrad to try to get into the school of bushiness:

History 101
History 201
Liguistics 101
Linguistics 102
Phychology 101
Speech 151
Speech 251
NREM 202 (Math)
Japanese 101
Japanese 102
Japanese 201
Japanese 202
Oceanography 201
Food Science 185
Economics 101
Economics 102

All these BS classes unrelated to a marketing degree, with the exception of economics.

THen I have a friend who has an electrical engineering degree and works on nuclear subs.  He basically, reads the manual and tells the sailors how to put stuff together/fix it.  He isn't' allowed to touch anything. I asked him if is EE degree helped at all and he said no. 100% OTJ. Even the EE terms or like stuff he learned never applied to what he does.  Guess he should have taken accounting as well cause he mistakenly ordered a case of bolts that each bolt cost $40,000. He only needed 2.   His boss said it's ok, cause they had to spend the money to keep their budget, or it gets reduced if they don't use it all.

What you're recommending is trade school.  Instead of a 4-year degree, you can get all the "major" classes taken care of in about 80 hours or so of classes.

The problem with that is college credits are not "certification courses."  if "what you want to be" requires additional study, testing and licensing, that all happens outside of the school.  As I already said, undergraduate degrees don't teach you how to be successful in your profession.  They teach you HOW TO LEARN and in the process provide the foundation for that learning.

The fact that your friend learned "100%" of his required skills from "OJT" backs up that fact.  He might not have been trained in college to do his specific job, but he was given the necessary knowledge, skills and practice to better equip himself to succeed in his OJT.

I firmly believe that all knowledge is good.  No matter what situation you're in, something you learned in your previous years will help you.  I saw many in the jobs i've held refuse to volunteer for anything or take on a task that they believed was "not their job."  I was always the opposite.  if I could learn something I didn't already know, I saw it as an opportunity -- not a useless project or part of someone else's job.  Some jobs don't allow the time to do that, but luckily mine did.  It was just a matter of time management and sometimes being willing to put in extra time over the regular work week.

Any General College class that gives you a fundamental understanding of things outside of your major broadens your understanding.  Many times you'll see where what you're going to be doing can be related to that other "unrelated" subject.  Political Science can help if you use your computer science or EE degree for statistical analysis, modeling and voter machine design. The requirements provided by the designers and end users are not always going to be enough for someone to sit down and do the engineering in a purely technical vacuum.

Why do colleges teach English?  Because most businesses need people who can clearly communicate in the primary language of our planet -- written and verbal.  Why take a foreign language?  Because not everyone you meet will be fluent in English, and it's a proven fact that learning one new language makes learning the next, and the next, magnitudes easier.  Will that help as a dentist?  Depends on if you ever travel for work or volunteer for charity programs overseas.

I took philosophy, electronics and PE (Archery) classes that had nothing directly to do with my Computer Science degree. And, when I graduated, I had to attend lots of training for 2 years to be proficient in my job.  I learned computer languages only the Air Force appeared to use, like 4Pi assembler, ADA and JOVIAL.  But, I also used FORTRAN, BASIC, and IBM370 Assembler, which were part of my college classes.  Just like foreign languages, the more you learn and practice, the easier it is to learn a new one. 

The non-job-related college classes provided a broader level of knowledge.  Otherwise, you'd be in a very closed environment with little exposure to things that might help in your chosen profession;  A marketing or accounting class will help a young entrepreneur starting or helping run a technical business.  Being able to write a brief, concise paragraph can help when executing managerial duties or submitting reports, requesting funding, or evaluating workers.  Philosophy will help in all areas of social and workplace interaction.  And that electronics class might help figure out why your computer isn't working the night before a big presentation is due.

You might think general college requirements are BS, but to an employer, they are not.  Otherwise an Associate Degree would be the standard requirement.

Those who go into difficult careers like doctor, lawyer, nursing, and so on go on to graduate programs which THEN only take 2 years give or take to earn a Master's degree, because the courses are focused on just that field.    People take graduate and advanced classes to often specialize in their fields.  You might have a Computer Science BS, but you might want to go into software design, technical writing, program management, hardware development, operating system development, manufacturing technologies, and so on. Nearly every profession branches out into a variety of specialties or career paths.

Do you expect a college to prepare you to perform in every possible job you might land in your chosen field?  Might as well have 5-10 year technical degrees, since that's what it'll take to cover the majority of subjects you'll be expected to know upon graduation.

Again, undergrads don't get OJT in college unless they seek it out.  That's what internships and other industry programs do for you if you apply and get accepted.  4-year degree schools can't possibly teach you your job.  Not enough hours no matter how focused the curriculum is.

Imagine going to school for 4 years doing nothing but going to classes directly related to your career.  Then, at your first job, you are hired to work with a completely new or different piece of equipment than your school had. Do you get mad that you spent 4 years in classes, and still have to learn something new for work?
« Last Edit: July 03, 2023, 07:51:48 PM by Flapp_Jackson »
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Do they think we're stupid?
« Reply #6 on: July 03, 2023, 12:53:43 PM »
I left out the obvious, because it's obvious.

Most college students have no idea what they want to do for the rest of their lives.

General college classes help fulfill graduation requirements while giving students a chance to take a few classes in what they think they are interested in doing.  If they decide that's not for them, they didn't waste a whole year on classes they wish had been in a different  field.

Some students change their majors like they change their shoes.  What feels right today may not feel right tomorrow.  It's why so many students graduate with "stupid" degrees that don't offer many chances of good paying employment.  They studied what interested them at the time, not once equating that effort to a long term job.

Imagine a high school grad goes to your technical trade school to become a doctor.  1 year later, they decide it's too difficult for them or just not what they want to be doing.  So, they switch to becoming a Nuclear power engineer, which better fits their aptitude and interests.  They just wasted a year of classes that won't help them graduate.  Now that 2 year degree will take them 3 years.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

ren

Re: Do they think we're stupid?
« Reply #7 on: July 03, 2023, 01:07:58 PM »
dentists are not real doctors...

Are chiros real Drs? if so, dentists are too. Bone. Teeth = bones. so if x=y and y=z then x=z
Deeds Not Words