First, Terry, I think you know and I've said before - I completely agree with you and your assessment of the 2nd amendment. I, at least, don't think that is up for too much discussion as a principle as the founding fathers were very clear why they included the 2nd amendment in the first place.
I don't think any of us would want to define the 2nd amendment more narrowly than it defines itself. That's why we're all on a 2a forum.
Hardline constitutional interpretation is popular with a segment of the population - right, left and center. It makes sense, it feels right, simpler is better, etc. And... the nations actual laws, for better or worse, blow that ideal out of the water. It simply isn't the way ANY aspect of the constitution is handled. The nation's laws, codes and policies take up volumes and all of that is based on refinements, interpretations and implementations of the what the constitution mandates and allows for. And, as we all know, does NOT allow. (NDAA's indefinite detention, the various states that flat out deny any right to bear arms except for sport, etc.)
The Constitution lays out the various branches, their powers, how they are to be elected or appointed, etc. It also lays out a number of operating principles and a few procedural bits. It says VERY little about how to implement the operating principles - by design. Implementation is left up to the legislature to figure out and adjust over time as needed. It is one of the great strengths of our constitution that it is flexible and adaptable.
The 2nd amendment has thus been legislated INTO the narrow implementation it now "enjoys." What I am suggesting is that we may need to legislate it OUT of that narrow implementation.