Texas: Open Carry, Campus Carry, CCW Holder Crime Stats for Our Legislators (Read 2553 times)

punaperson

In the past several days the Texas Senate has passed Open Carry and Campus Carry bills. I concur with the senator when she says these bills are "restorations" of rights. (See link below and excerpt).

I looked up the criminal convictions for Texas for 2013 (the most recent year available), as broken into total convictions and convictions of CHL (Carry Handgun License) holders: https://www.txdps.state.tx.us/rsd/chl/reports/demographics.htm

A few simple division calculations reveals that a non-CHL Texan is 325 (three hundred and twenty-five) TIMES more likely to be convicted of a crime than a CHL holder. We need to point this out (as it mirrors other states as well who have "shall issue" CCW) to our legislators when they assert that denying us the right to bear arms is warranted as a "compelling government interest" in "public safety" (aka the "It'll be wild west shootouts and blood in the streets if we allow people to carry guns in public" argument(s)). It seems if they were really concerned about lowering the crime rate for "public safety" that they would encourage people to join the group of citizens that is 325 TIMES LESS likely to be convicted of a crime. But that would be rational and logical, so what are the chances of our progressive legislators abiding by those standards of legislation? I've asked several legislators why they believe Hawaii citizens would be the exception to the 43 other states with CCW where those licensed citizens (or the Constitutional carry citizens) have never been any kind of problem, and are, like in Texas, far more law-abiding than the general public. Not one legislator has ever responded to that question.

Texas Senate Republicans Cheer Passage of Campus Carry Bill

http://www.breitbart.com/texas/2015/03/19/texas-senate-republicans-cheer-passage-of-campus-carry-bill/

Senator Brandon Creighton (R-Conroe), a joint author of the bill, said that legislators had an “obligation to make sure Texas and her law-abiding citizens are safe” in a statement provided to Breitbart Texas. “There is no such thing as a ‘gun-free’ zone,” he said. “That is why twenty-three other states that have passed concealed carry laws allow license-holders to carry on campus.”

“Having authored similar campus carry measures in the past, it is a pleasure to be a joint author of Senate Bill 11,” continued Creighton. “Its Senate passage today reaffirms the right of Texas CHL-holders to self-defense on college campuses. Our faculty, staff, and students deserve a fighting chance to protect themselves from bad actors intent on doing harm.”

Senator Konni Burton (R-Colleyville) also cheered her Senate colleagues’ efforts to protect gun rights. “This week, the Texas Senate made strides toward restoring our Second Amendment rights,” Burton told Breitbart Texas. “Senate Bill 17 and 11 passed, and I was proud to support both. Open carry and campus carry are both important restorations and I plan on continuing the work still ahead to fully restore our God given Second Amendment rights.”

Edit (8 AM march 20):

I asked mauidog to look at my calculations and he pointed out a couple of problems. First, "It's possible one person was convicted of multiple offenses in that tally, meaning we can't assume one conviction = one "non-CHL Texan"." The data set linked to above from the Texas Department of Public Safety is a listing of various criminal offenses with the total number of convictions and the number of convictions of CHL holders, but no information detailing exactly how many individuals were convicted of those crimes, and even though that factor applies to both sets (total convictions and CHL-holder convictions)  it's likely it effects the non-CHL numbers more (i.e. fewer individuals) because the CHL holders only committed a total of 158 crimes on the list.

Second, this list is only of certain crimes, not all crimes (there is no "jaywalking", shoplifting, violation of probation, fraud, etc.). I'm not sure how these crimes were selected, if they are all felonies or crimes wherein victims or physically or financially harmed or what (the list includes murder, assault, sexual assault, robbery, burglary, etc.). For some (unknown to me) reason the Texas Department of Public Safety selected these crimes for the list, so we'd have to be clear in stating that these statistics refer to this specific list of crimes.

Bottom Line: We probably don't want to use the "325 TIMES less likely to commit a crime than the general population" specific number because it is not accurate because of the concerns stated above, but in Texas (and other states as well where "shall issue" or "Constitutional carry" is the law) CHL holders commit a significantly lower proportion of serious crimes relative to their ratio in the general population. Thus why do Hawaii legislators and bureaucrats (like the governor, attorney general, police chiefs, etc.) assert that Hawaii citizens are "different" and will endanger "public safety" if allowed to legally exercise their right to bear arms?

Also, the number of CHL holders in Texas increased by 16.6% in 2014 over 2013 (and increase of 117,909 from 708,048 to 825,957). So, in response to another thread re CCW in Hawaii: Yes, if wishes were horses, the beggars would ride.  :shaka:

« Last Edit: March 20, 2015, 08:10:09 AM by punaperson »

punaperson

I'm posting this notice of the above edit so people will know there has been a disclaimer and that the original number I posted is not accurate... and that we don't have the specific data needed from Texas to determine the real ratio, so please don't use the "325 TIMES" stat.  :shaka:

Old Guy

I read in a gun forum(I forget which one)

Texas CHL Dept is pushing for ONE MILLION CCW permits

I think Texas has over 700,000 permits issued now.

punaperson

I read in a gun forum(I forget which one)

Texas CHL Dept is pushing for ONE MILLION CCW permits

I think Texas has over 700,000 permits issued now.
Yeah, in my "Edit" above I list the 2014 year end number for Texas as 825,957, and if 2015 and 2016 continue at a similar rate of increase as 2014 (117,909 new CHL holders) Texas would reach a million at some point in 2016... but they'd still be behind Florida. I guess Hawaii, with 4 (four) licenses issued in the past 15 years (unknown if any of those are still "active", so the real number is likely might be zero), has a ways to go. One million CHL holders in Texas would be 3.7% of the current population. that 3.7% would translate to 52,540 CCW licensees for Hawaii. So when Hawaii, in the near future (ahem) becomes shall issue, if all the members reading this "Legal and Activism" forum applied and got their CCW license, that'd put us right up there, right?  :geekdanc:  :shaka: