I want one of these. Why can't I have one? (Read 9844 times)

punaperson

I want one of these. Why can't I have one?
« on: February 08, 2015, 02:37:45 PM »
UZI PISTOL 22LR

Special Sale: $229.99


http://www.cdnnsports.com/uzi-pistol-22lr-12220.html#.VNf-aS60eUk

Can someone familiar with the rationale presented during passage of the legislation banning this made-up "category" of firearms please explain the reasoning and evidence (some unsupported emotional appeal about "public safety"?) presented by the legislators and supporters? Or did they just respond like my senator (Ruderman) when I asked him for his reasoning and evidence re a bill last year, with "No one is trying to take your guns away"? Technically he's correct, if I can't legally acquire it in the first place, they definitely can't take it away...

dogman

Re: I want one of these. Why can't I have one?
« Reply #1 on: February 08, 2015, 04:34:26 PM »
Since the magazine is in the grip, wouldn't that be legal in Hawaii with a 10 round magazine?

mauidog

Re: I want one of these. Why can't I have one?
« Reply #2 on: February 08, 2015, 04:53:27 PM »
Since the magazine is in the grip, wouldn't that be legal in Hawaii with a 10 round magazine?

The specs on the Walther website show weight without magazine is 3.8 lbs (60.8 oz).

It also has a threaded muzzle.

Quote
"Assault pistol" means a semiautomatic pistol which accepts a detachable magazine and which has two or more of the following characteristics:

     (1)  An ammunition magazine which attaches to the pistol outside of the pistol grip;

     (2)  A threaded barrel capable of accepting a barrel extender, flash suppressor, forward hand grip, or silencer;

     (3)  A shroud which is attached to or partially or completely encircles the barrel and which permits the shooter to hold the firearm with the second hand without being burned;

     (4)  A manufactured weight of fifty ounces or more when the pistol is unloaded;

     (5)  A centerfire pistol with an overall length of twelve inches or more; or

     (6)  It is a semiautomatic version of an automatic firearm;
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

punaperson

Re: I want one of these. Why can't I have one?
« Reply #3 on: February 08, 2015, 05:07:44 PM »
Thanks, mauidog, for spelling out the details of the illegality.  :shaka: There are 10 round mags available, but the pistol comes standard with 20 round magazine(s), but even that doesn't overcome the other illegalities. I'm hoping to hear from someone who is familiar with the history of the legislation. Just wondering if they even tried to make a case for the "compelling government interest" in "public safety" being jeopardized by so-called "assault pistols", because there isn't any evidence that these have been used in any significant amount of crime compared to firearms that are legal (and believe me, I don't want to give them any ideas, but I'm sure they already have all the ideas they need: civilian disarmament, one increment at a time).

suka

Re: I want one of these. Why can't I have one?
« Reply #4 on: February 09, 2015, 12:05:27 AM »
Just bought one a few months ago!
I'm going to modify it to bring it down to 50ozs
and the mag blocked. The gun does not have a threaded barrel.

However, the 50oz is a manufactured weight. So it is still over the 50oz limit. Thus, only one item out of the six is listed.

suka

punaperson

Re: I want one of these. Why can't I have one?
« Reply #6 on: February 09, 2015, 06:06:30 AM »
Just bought one a few months ago!
I'm going to modify it to bring it down to 50ozs
and the mag blocked. The gun does not have a threaded barrel.

However, the 50oz is a manufactured weight. So it is still over the 50oz limit. Thus, only one item out of the six is listed.
Hey, suka, i vaguely remembered your thread but forgot that the pistol in question was this very one. Both the CDNN and the Walther websites state it has a threaded muzzle, but even if it doesn't are you saying that the "second characteristic" is that it is a "semi-automatic version of an automatic firearm" and thus needs to have weight removed to bring it into compliance? Another question: How do you get them the send it, as is ("illegal"), to Hawaii? The "work" would have to be done on it to bring it into compliance prior to registration, correct? How does that work with transfer from the FFL to whoever is going to do the "work"?

And my original question still stands: Why was this made-up category of these firearms made illegal? "Looks like something else" justifies a ban? (What if someone looks like Charles Manson or Barry Soetoro? [Yes, I did. So sue me.]) What evidence was submitted to justify this legislation, and what were the vote totals in the house and senate (i.e. did anyone vote against it?)?
« Last Edit: February 09, 2015, 06:18:43 AM by punaperson »

Jdelacruz

Re: I want one of these. Why can't I have one?
« Reply #7 on: February 09, 2015, 06:06:58 AM »
UZI PISTOL 22LR

Special Sale: $229.99


http://www.cdnnsports.com/uzi-pistol-22lr-12220.html#.VNf-aS60eUk

Can someone familiar with the rationale presented during passage of the legislation banning this made-up "category" of firearms please explain the reasoning and evidence (some unsupported emotional appeal about "public safety"?) presented by the legislators and supporters? Or did they just respond like my senator (Ruderman) when I asked him for his reasoning and evidence re a bill last year, with "No one is trying to take your guns away"? Technically he's correct, if I can't legally acquire it in the first place, they definitely can't take it away...

Cause the state says "You'll shoot your eye out!"

Man out laws are ridiculous. That's problem when you have folks make laws based on what they see on TV. As to Ruderman's statement is a scary one. A dictator can say "No one is taking your right to vote we aren't just allowing elections to take place."

punaperson

Re: I want one of these. Why can't I have one?
« Reply #8 on: February 09, 2015, 07:00:40 AM »
Cause the state says "You'll shoot your eye out!"

I think that justification is used for BB guns, not firearms  ;), but I wouldn't be surprised if one or another legislator didn't blurt that out in an unguarded moment, or got picked up for the public when they thought the microphone was turned off. But seriously, what was the argument against these particular firearms? I'm curious, because based upon logic and evidence, there isn't one. Not that logic and evidence often seem to play a significant role in firearms-related legislation.

Man out laws are ridiculous. That's problem when you have folks make laws based on what they see on TV. As to Ruderman's statement is a scary one. A dictator can say "No one is taking your right to vote we aren't just allowing elections to take place."

Yeah, Ruderman wrote that cliched assertion, which we all know is false due to many many civilian disarmament advocates making public statements to the effect that exactly what they want to do is take our guns away. Neither Ruderman nor one single other legislator I wrote asking to present the rationale/evidence for their anti-civil rights vote(s) responded by providing any evidence or rationale whatsoever. Not one. While some dictators may cancel elections and thus have to use pretzel logic (lies) to somehow claim the "will of the people" is being followed, many actually allow elections... elections where there is only one candidate on the ballot, thus they are able to claim that they won 100% of the vote and are therefore the most loved leader ever. Another method is to allow illegal aliens to vote, pay people to vote, and use various fraudulent methods (same person voting in multiple precincts, dead people voting, machine manipulations, etc.) to garner 50.1% of the vote. Outcome: the same as the dictator who "limits" your choices. Oh, crap, I highjacked my own thread! :stopjack:

punaperson

Re: I want one of these. Why can't I have one?
« Reply #9 on: February 09, 2015, 09:22:23 AM »
Perhaps I've misunderstood the "(6)  It is a semiautomatic version of an automatic firearm" characteristic listing as applying to a semi-auto "look alike" of any caliber, even if different than the original automatic firearm caliber. Does this disqualifying characteristic only apply if the semi-auto "version" is the same caliber as the original full auto? I don't believe the Uzi full autos are rimfire.  :geekdanc: Is a "rimfire replica" (per the Walther site) a "version"? Not that it really matters, but I am curious about how they come up with this crap including definitions while they're making stuff up to justify things being "unusual or dangerous", etc.

eyeeatingfish

Re: I want one of these. Why can't I have one?
« Reply #10 on: February 09, 2015, 12:00:02 PM »
Perhaps I've misunderstood the "(6)  It is a semiautomatic version of an automatic firearm" characteristic listing as applying to a semi-auto "look alike" of any caliber, even if different than the original automatic firearm caliber. Does this disqualifying characteristic only apply if the semi-auto "version" is the same caliber as the original full auto? I don't believe the Uzi full autos are rimfire.  :geekdanc: Is a "rimfire replica" (per the Walther site) a "version"? Not that it really matters, but I am curious about how they come up with this crap including definitions while they're making stuff up to justify things being "unusual or dangerous", etc.

I would say that this does not qualify as a semi auto version of an automatic firearm. We aren't talking about s change in a single part such as a trigger mechanism but a gun that is significantly different. Different caliber, different various other parts etc.

eyeeatingfish

Re: I want one of these. Why can't I have one?
« Reply #11 on: February 09, 2015, 12:03:00 PM »
Thanks, mauidog, for spelling out the details of the illegality.  :shaka: There are 10 round mags available, but the pistol comes standard with 20 round magazine(s), but even that doesn't overcome the other illegalities. I'm hoping to hear from someone who is familiar with the history of the legislation. Just wondering if they even tried to make a case for the "compelling government interest" in "public safety" being jeopardized by so-called "assault pistols", because there isn't any evidence that these have been used in any significant amount of crime compared to firearms that are legal (and believe me, I don't want to give them any ideas, but I'm sure they already have all the ideas they need: civilian disarmament, one increment at a time).

Couldn't find commentary listed under the online HRS. It might be somewhere else but I don't know how to search for that.

mauidog

Re: I want one of these. Why can't I have one?
« Reply #12 on: February 09, 2015, 01:28:16 PM »
Don't read this if you just finished eating or are already in an agitated mood!   :shake:

You have been warned! 

http://www.feinstein.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/assault-weapons-ban-summary
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

mauidog

Re: I want one of these. Why can't I have one?
« Reply #13 on: February 09, 2015, 01:33:10 PM »
The long answer ......

Rational Basis Analysis of "Assault Weapon" Prohibition

Quote
"Equal protection of the laws requires that statutory classifications be based on differences that are real in fact...." [142] The classification of "assault weapons" is not based on differences that are real in fact. The banned firearms do not fire faster than many guns that are not banned. The banned firearms do not have a larger ammunition capacity than many guns that are not banned. In fact, the number of rounds a semiautomatic can fire without reloading has nothing to do with the gun. Rather, that capacity is determined solely by the magazine, a separate, detachable, and interchangeable part. All the other physical characteristics of "assault weapons" which might form a rational basis for prohibiting them are simply not valid (such as claims about ammunition lethality), are trivial (such as bayonet lugs), or make the gun more accurate (such as a muzzle brakes). Official statistics prove that so-called "assault weapons" are rarely involved in criminal activity, and hence the use of "assault weapons" in crime is insufficiently demonstrated to pass the rational basis test.

Banning "assault weapons" has been justified on the basis that these weapons are better suited for personal protection than they are for recreation. However, this justification is illegitimate because the use of deadly force for protection from grave, imminent harm is lawful in the United States.

The demand for "assault weapon" prohibition is often accompanied by a self-righteous insistence that only a criminal or a maniac would oppose prohibiting extremely dangerous firearms which have no legitimate use and are the criminal weapon of choice. But the closer one looks at the reasons given for "assault weapon" bans the less one sees. The prohibition is no more rational than a prohibition on beer based on legislative "findings" that beer grows on trees, that a single sip always causes instant physical addiction, and that beer is more dangerous than other alcohol because it is stored in aluminum containers. If the rational basis test means anything, it means that an "assault weapon" prohibition is unlawful.

http://www.davekopel.com/2A/LawRev/rational.htm
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

suka

Re: I want one of these. Why can't I have one?
« Reply #14 on: February 10, 2015, 12:15:00 AM »
Perhaps I've misunderstood the "(6)  It is a semiautomatic version of an automatic firearm" characteristic listing as applying to a semi-auto "look alike" of any caliber, even if different than the original automatic firearm caliber. Does this disqualifying characteristic only apply if the semi-auto "version" is the same caliber as the original full auto? I don't believe the Uzi full autos are rimfire.  :geekdanc: Is a "rimfire replica" (per the Walther site) a "version"? Not that it really matters, but I am curious about how they come up with this crap including definitions while they're making stuff up to justify things being "unusual or dangerous", etc.

This Uzi is NOT a version of  a fully automatic version. the internals are complely different from the original 9mm STEEL version. This is just like the GSG5's  and is more in par with airsoft guns. In fact none of the parts are interchangeable with the original. Other than the original manufactured weight of over 50oz this firearm would be legal in Hawaii under HRS 134-1.
Any FFL can legally import these into the State and modify the firearm to meet HRS. Since FFL are exempt under HRS to have possession of any type of firearms under their federal license.


The federal 1994 Clinton ban did include these firearms and assault rifle under the same bill. Hawaii pretty much copy the same bill word for word into the state version.
But the federal version did have a sunset clause and the hawaii version did not.
As proposed in the 90;s Hawaii's AG did support a complete ban of Handgun/pistol in hawaii. this was a compromise. The state bill passed behind closed doors, no open testimonies were offered to the public




punaperson

Re: I want one of these. Why can't I have one?
« Reply #15 on: February 10, 2015, 06:04:39 AM »
This Uzi is NOT a version of  a fully automatic version. the internals are complely different from the original 9mm STEEL version. This is just like the GSG5's  and is more in par with airsoft guns. In fact none of the parts are interchangeable with the original. Other than the original manufactured weight of over 50oz this firearm would be legal in Hawaii under HRS 134-1.
Any FFL can legally import these into the State and modify the firearm to meet HRS. Since FFL are exempt under HRS to have possession of any type of firearms under their federal license.


The federal 1994 Clinton ban did include these firearms and assault rifle under the same bill. Hawaii pretty much copy the same bill word for word into the state version.
But the federal version did have a sunset clause and the hawaii version did not.
As proposed in the 90;s Hawaii's AG did support a complete ban of Handgun/pistol in hawaii. this was a compromise. The state bill passed behind closed doors, no open testimonies were offered to the public
suka, thank you very much for the clarifications re the "version" law and the historical background of the whole "assault pistol" law. "Behind closed doors"? "Compromise"?  :wtf: So we don't really know what any of the legislators offered as evidence to support the unusual danger presented by these weapons and thus warranting their banning. Who'd a thunk it? I guess I'm going to do a separate post on "compromise" re firearms laws. That should (re)open that can of worms for the "Legal and Activism" readers.

dwela

Re: I want one of these. Why can't I have one?
« Reply #16 on: February 14, 2015, 02:23:11 PM »
You can't have it because you might scare the sheep.