I think the point is being lost here, the story is not about legalizing marijuana. The children were taken while she was in custody during the investigation. Meaning she wasn't there to care for them (children left unattended), that meets the definition of neglect. Is that any less a form of neglect that if she'd been out hitting the club? I don't think so...bottom line is it's her actions that led what happened.
Well, it depends. I would venture to say that if the club put her in handcuffs and took her at gunpoint, then I wouldn't call that neglect. I also wouldn't call it neglect if someone failed to pick their kid up from school, because while they were at the bank some armed men rushed in and held everyone hostage for several hours.
She was not being held for a
criminal investigation that resulted directly from her actions. While being a hostage is a completely different matter, one could argue neglect if she'd left the children home alone to go to the bank. Just saying...
The mission of Child Welfare (CPS here in Hawaii) is to protect the children. Can they be overzealous? Possibly. But if that means preventing just 1 child from suffering or worse from abuse or neglet, so be it. Seriously, given the consequences of failing at their job, I don't fault them one bit. No, no, no, no. Even if CPS didn't traumatize the majority of kids in foster care, this wouldn't be true. This is a recycled version of the gun grabbers' "for The Children(tm)" malarkey. It's the same logic the Brady Campaign uses to claim that we should turn in all our privately owned handguns. "Would a total gun ban be overzealous? Possibly. But if that meas preventing just 1 child from suffering or worse from malice or negligence, so be it."
Please don't generalize here. The majority of the time, CPS makes an effort to find a relative (or friend/neighbor for short term) willing to take custody of the child to lessen the trauma. It is the first and most preferrable choice. As for those ending up in the foster care system...how is foster care any more traumatic if they're being removed from an environment of neglect and abuse?
Dont' twist my words, it's the same crap (as you mention) that those with the Brady Campaign would do. I've recycled nothing...at no point do I say or imply that exercising one constitutional right of gun ownership equates endangering a child.
No all you want, but I stand by my statement. Child welfare services are programs mandated to protect children. They screen and investigate allegations of abuse and/or neglect, then takes action based on that. Wording along those lines is in every mission statement of those organizations whether government or private.
No kidding. CPS scares the bejeezus out of me. It's scary how much power they wield.
They're not jackbooted fascist stormtroopers that swoop in to take kids away from their parents for no reason. So I'm sure you have nothing to fear.
It's a government agency which claims to know better than parents how to raise children. They have the authority to forcibly kidnap peoples' children from right out of their homes, take them away, and hand them off to foster parents who may or may not actually care about helping children. They can do this for nearly any reason; because the assumption is that the impartial, benevolent Big Brother knows best; so if you run afoul of CPS, you must be a complete dirt bag. You're going to have a hard time drumming up much support for those ideas on a second amendment board. If you're associated with CPS, and use a healthy dose of common sense to differentiate between parenting techniques you don't approve of and actual criminal acts that endanger the health of the child, then good on you. Just like the IRS no doubt has some decent, hardworking folks, I'm sure that not every apple on the cart at CPS is a bad one. The problem with both (and many more) agencies is that regardless of the quality of the apples on board, it's still a manure wagon for a cart.
Sorry, but that's an incredibly narrow and extremist view. To broadly imply that there's some Big Brother Government evil entity that is out to kidnap your children smacks of paranoia. Seriously...I was expecting you to start ranting about Ruby Ridge and Waco. <---neither of which have any bearing in the OT.
And no, I am not trying to drum up support for CPS nor am I saying that they're ALWAYS right. Parenting technique is not the issue, but the definition of abuse/negelct ia pretty clear. Bottome line? Anyone healthy and able can have a child, but that doesn't mean they can raise a child/be a parent. BEFORE you misunderstand and start about governemt mandating the who and how...I'll make it clear, a person can be a bad parent without being guilty of endangering a child through abuse/neglect.
As for support from the 2A community? I'd venture to guess that not one person here would be against doing what's right for a child. It's really 2 different issues, so don't try to bind them together especially in a news article that makes no mention of firearms or 2A rights. While I see where some might think government agencies need to mind their own and piss off. Don't confuse gun rights with the well being of children. Leave that to the "anti" groups, because it only makes them look stupid.
With regard to your question of whether I'm associated with CPS? Nope, but I have had quite a few experiences with them:
- 1995 first on scene to check out a foul smell (possible DB). No response to knocks. Got permission from the property manager to enter. The place was a dump...I found a 3-1/2 y/o that had been locked in a room for almost 2 days while good 'ol mom and dad (who as you claim knows whats best), were off hitting the pipe. The kid was eating turds out of a litter box because he hungry. You're damn right I called CPS. *Result - Child was placed into foster care and eventually adopted by the host family.
- 1997 on a domestic call. A mom was outside ranting about her husband molesting their 8 y/o. Both parties were detained pending investigation. CPS had to be called. The social worker evaluated the child and we questioned the neighbors. *Result - No abuse. Mom was found to be unstable and off her meds. It was all a ploy to get custody and collect benefits. The child spent about a day in a shelter and returned to dad. Both me and the social worker testified at the custody hearing. Sole custody given to dad. Mom was allow supervised visit at the family center.
- 1998 I responded to a disturbance call. During questioning I saw a 5 y/o coughing and wretching. Good 'ol dad said "don't worry about it, she's fine". I called in medic to check it out. The kid was messed up and required a trip to the hospital. Thinking it was poisoning, they pumped her stomach to find semen. Apparently daddy thought she had a pretty mouth. *Result - Daddy was convicted and sentenced. The little girl spent a few months in a foster home then claimed by her maternal grandparents.
- 2000, another disturbance call and child welfare had already responded and on scene. Found a 4 y/o with bloodly welts (beat with a wire hanger) and smiley face burns from a bic lighter. Mom was immediately taken into custody. The child welfare/social worker took the baby. *Result - Dad was recalled from deployment and baby was returned to him.
- 2001-2003, I had PERSONAL experience with CPS. My ex was neglecting 2-1/2 y/o son. Since I couldn't be 100% sure, I called CPS to investigate. My ex countered with old "he got guns" and is violent complaint. That shit worked for the local DVCH that advised her to get a TRO...not so much for CPS. A thorough investigation was conducted. The judge tossed the TRO for lack of any evidence. And a CPS surprise visit found my son left home alone in a playpen. *Result - I have sole custody of my children AND still have my guns.
So, do you have direct experience with CPS, abused/neglected children, or any official investigation? Or is your opinion based on personal bias against government in general?