Creating a pistol from a rifle? (Read 27320 times)

mauidog

Re: Creating a pistol from a rifle?
« Reply #60 on: April 07, 2015, 09:22:48 PM »
Mauidog, saw in your instructions that you said the registered pistol receiver had to be re-registered as a pistol once it was completely.   Are you certain of this?  Since it is already registered as  a pistol, I don't think you have to.   In this HHAA article, the attorney notes there is no reregistration requirement if a registered firearm is rechambered, re-barreeled, etc...

http://hawaiihistoricarms.com/whats-the-law-modification-of-my-registered-firearm/

From the other threads, if I remember correctly, you have to show them the completed AR pistol to prove it doesn't fall into the assault pistol category.  So, unless you can complete it before the 5 day registration period expires after picking up the receiver, I think you have to go back again.

I haven't had to do this, so I'm depending on what other's have had to do.

Quote
Quote from: dogman on November 04, 2014, 09:51:01 PM

    HPD will not let you register your lower as a pistol lower if you acquired it with a long gun permit. I tried to get a letter from the BATFE to state that it is legal to do so but the letter seemed to lean more in favor of HPD's position. You should check with HPD before you proceed any further. The lowers that I registered as pistol lowers were acquired with the same process as purchasing a handgun. I got the paper work from the gun shop (serial numbers, make, model and caliber), took them to HPD and applied for handgun permits, waited two weeks, picked up the permits at HPD, picked up the lowers from the gun shop and returned to HPD to register. They are now requiring that the magazine be welded to the lower between picking them up from the gun shop and registering at HPD.

Based on this, you only have to go once, but the lower has to meet some level of legality to accomplish the registration.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

Tom

Re: Creating a pistol from a rifle?
« Reply #61 on: April 07, 2015, 09:26:37 PM »
I can understand they *want* to see it, I just don't think they can require it.  Possession of an assault pistol is a crime.  You wouldn't be possessing an assault pistol.   You generally don't have to prove you are obeying the law, they have to prove you are breaking it.  I guess they could refuse to register pistol lowers without a completed upper if they wanted to.
Tom
NRA Endowment Member

mauidog

Re: Creating a pistol from a rifle?
« Reply #62 on: April 07, 2015, 09:28:08 PM »
I can understand they *want* to see it, I just don't think they can require it.  Possession of an assault pistol is a crime.  You wouldn't be possessing an assault pistol.   You generally don't have to prove you are obeying the law, they have to prove you are breaking it.

What state did YOU wake up in this morning?  Certainly not Hawaii!!

 :rofl:
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

GZire

Re: Creating a pistol from a rifle?
« Reply #63 on: April 18, 2015, 12:31:35 PM »
I think it would be a pretty cool gun. A 10" or 8" inch barrel should still develop some decent velocity right? Maybe an interesting hunting gun or even a decent defense weapon depending on what caliber you get it in. Probably not something I am ready to spend money on yet. Maybe something to do later in life.

I don't fully understand what you mean to transfer the receiver as a pistol at the point of sale... So I go you security equipment (or whoever) and buy a receiver saying it is a pistol and I can hold onto the receiver until I get the pistol permit, then just go in and register? Just not familiar with the forms, I just sign whatever at the gun store to get the gun.


An 8" or 10" barrel in reality may make it hard for whatever round you are using (if 223) to make the required energy for hunting.  You might be able to realistically make a case if it's a 16" barrel, but it's and interesting ballistics problem from the shorter barrel.

Now if you're chambering in something like 6.8, dunno man might have a lot easier time making the energy...........then again maybe it's a non issue if it's a pistol.  In any case read up on the DLNR regs.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Creating a pistol from a rifle?
« Reply #64 on: April 19, 2015, 02:17:50 PM »

An 8" or 10" barrel in reality may make it hard for whatever round you are using (if 223) to make the required energy for hunting.  You might be able to realistically make a case if it's a 16" barrel, but it's and interesting ballistics problem from the shorter barrel.

Now if you're chambering in something like 6.8, dunno man might have a lot easier time making the energy...........then again maybe it's a non issue if it's a pistol.  In any case read up on the DLNR regs.

I believe the 300 blackout was meant to attain good velocity out of short barrels and that is what I was leaning towards. I know you can get them in more exotic heavy hitting pistol calibers but then options get a little more limited since other parts need to be changed.