REPOST / Was this stupid? 9mm Titegroup. PICS ADDED (Read 9373 times)

jase90

REPOST / Was this stupid? 9mm Titegroup. PICS ADDED
« on: January 08, 2019, 06:34:39 AM »
EDIT: I botched my first post, could a moderator please delete that one. I somehow broke the link with my phone lol.

Long story short. I bought 8 bottles of Titegroup for 10 bucks off a friend that's moving.

I usually use CFE Pistol or Longshot to load hot 9mm rounds. I stepped up from 3.6grs of Titegroup to 5.0grs to find a good margin of error for progressive loading.

Bullet used was a 124gr FMJ recessed base from Everglades. .355" diameter, .618" OAL roughly.

5.0gr Titegroup, 1.140" COAL, 124gr FMJ RB from Everglades, mixed brass.

Moderate pressure signs on the primers, but spent cases still fall into my Glock 19, SIG P365, and Custom Glock chambers.

Am I being a retarded? I know Titegroup isn't meant for this work but was hoping to load this to 4.7gr on a Dillon 550 giving me a good margin of error. Hodgdon's website doesn't give much data on 124gr loads and their bullet listed is different than mine. So I just worked my way up.

Haven't been reloading long, just 9mm right now. Any of you guru's masters at loading 9mm Titegroup? This powder was so cheap I want to use it and still have it recoil close to a Winchester 9mm NATO to train with.

Give it to me straight. Back the eff down or did I do this margin for error thing right for progressive loading?

Will post pictures when I have time.

EDIT: 5.0gr of Titegroup / 2nd pic pair on the left shot from a stock 19 Gen 5, 2nd pic pair on the right shot from a custom 19 with a Blacklist barrel, 3rd pic shot from a SIG P365.

All G19 spent cases still plunk into the chambers they were shot from. P365 cases all charges do not plunk back into it's chamber under it's own weight.
« Last Edit: January 24, 2019, 05:06:30 PM by jase90 »

Lihikai

Re: REPOST / Was this stupid? 9mm Titegroup. PICS ADDED
« Reply #1 on: January 08, 2019, 07:01:28 AM »
Your primers are cratering, which is a sign of excessive pressure.  TG is a good powder and I've used it at 4.6gr in 9mm w/115 & 124gr FMJRN heads without problems.

jase90

Re: REPOST / Was this stupid? 9mm Titegroup. PICS ADDED
« Reply #2 on: January 08, 2019, 09:46:50 AM »
Your primers are cratering, which is a sign of excessive pressure.  TG is a good powder and I've used it at 4.6gr in 9mm w/115 & 124gr FMJRN heads without problems.

Have you tried chronoing them? I wanted to pick on up soon so I don't have to chase my tail with "feel" anymore. I was probably going to try a shorter COAL. Maybe 1.09" which is what Hodgdon's has listed for a 125gr FMJ and just start back down at 3.6gr again.

Bushido

Re: REPOST / Was this stupid? 9mm Titegroup. PICS ADDED
« Reply #3 on: January 08, 2019, 07:33:27 PM »
Following. I load tons of 124gr plated RN at 4.0gr Titegroup 1.150". I have not tried FMJ. I do have a chrono but it is not pistol compatible. I have no desire to load 9mm to +P.

rklapp

Re: REPOST / Was this stupid? 9mm Titegroup. PICS ADDED
« Reply #4 on: January 08, 2019, 08:46:52 PM »
I would say that 5gr is definitely a good "blow your face off" load.

Let me know if you're thinking of selling some of the powder... at cost of course.  :geekdanc:
Yahh! Freedom and justice shall always prevail over tyranny, Babysitter Girl!
https://ronsreloading.wordpress.com/

jase90

Re: REPOST / Was this stupid? 9mm Titegroup. PICS ADDED
« Reply #5 on: January 08, 2019, 09:21:52 PM »
I would say that 5gr is definitely a good "blow your face off" load.

Let me know if you're thinking of selling some of the powder... at cost of course.  :geekdanc:

That's what I was thinking the first 5.0gr I shot, but I felt comfortable stepping up from 4.8gr after reading the primers and throwing my spent cases back into the chambers. I will probably call 4.6gr good to progressively load with all other data being the same with this string.

I called Hodgdon earlier today and they recommend me to use the 125gr Sierra FMJ data they have because the only 124gr they tested is a Berry's hollow base round nose. Completley different bullet than a standard FMJ they said.

I will probably start another string of test with the 125gr FMJ data Hodgdon customer service told to use.

« Last Edit: January 08, 2019, 10:00:27 PM by jase90 »

macsak

Re: REPOST / Was this stupid? 9mm Titegroup. PICS ADDED
« Reply #6 on: January 08, 2019, 09:25:28 PM »
That's what I was thinking the first 5.0gr I shot, but I felt comfortable stepping up from 4.8gr after reading the primers and throwing my spent cases back into the chambers. I will probably call 4.6gr good to progressively load with all other data being the same with this string.

I called Hodgdon earlier today and they recommend me to use the 125gr Sierra FMJ data they have because the only 124gr they tested is a Berry's hollow base round nose. Completley different bullet than a standard FMJ they said.

I will probably start another string of test with the 125gr FMJ data Hodgdon customer service told to use.

isn't a recessed base the same as a hollow base?
« Last Edit: January 08, 2019, 09:35:07 PM by macsak »

jase90

Re: REPOST / Was this stupid? 9mm Titegroup. PICS ADDED
« Reply #7 on: January 08, 2019, 09:53:15 PM »
isn't a recessed base the same as a hollow base?

Really different bullets

Heavies

Re: REPOST / Was this stupid? 9mm Titegroup. PICS ADDED
« Reply #8 on: January 08, 2019, 10:04:05 PM »
JMHO,  Why beat your guns up for practice?  Just load a reliable accurate load and practice.  Don't worry about "felt recoil"   Good practice with good technique, recoil won't matter much.

Also, be aware that shorter OAL will increase pressure, and in a small capacity case like 9mm, pressures could spike. 

jase90

Re: REPOST / Was this stupid? 9mm Titegroup. PICS ADDED
« Reply #9 on: January 08, 2019, 10:15:59 PM »
JMHO,  Why beat your guns up for practice?  Just load a reliable accurate load and practice.  Don't worry about "felt recoil"   Good practice with good technique, recoil won't matter much.

Also, be aware that shorter OAL will increase pressure, and in a small capacity case like 9mm, pressures could spike.

TBH, 5.0gr of Titegroup didn't even get me the kick I wanted to simulate a Winchester NATO or my Federal HSTs, I'll be sticking to CFE or Longshot for that, which I'm running real low on btw. I know extended use at that powder charge is bad for the gun. I was just curious how much I could get out of this dirt cheap powder. I will most likely be loading 4.6gr of this stuff till I run out.

I'm gonna be using a friend's chronograph next time I test out more loads @ kokohead. I'm really wondering what 5.0grs is clocking at. Only for recording purposes.

Bushido

Re: REPOST / Was this stupid? 9mm Titegroup. PICS ADDED
« Reply #10 on: January 14, 2019, 07:54:27 PM »

Haven't been reloading long, just 9mm right now. Any of you guru's masters at loading 9mm Titegroup? This powder was so cheap I want to use it and still have it recoil close to a Winchester 9mm NATO to train with.

Give it to me straight. Back the eff down or did I do this margin for error thing right for progressive loading?

Ok now I see. New reloader, definitely back it down quite a bit.

macsak

Re: REPOST / Was this stupid? 9mm Titegroup. PICS ADDED
« Reply #11 on: January 14, 2019, 07:57:46 PM »
Really different bullets

ah, ok, thanks
the extra volume probably helped with reducing chamber pressure

Heavies

Re: REPOST / Was this stupid? 9mm Titegroup. PICS ADDED
« Reply #12 on: January 14, 2019, 08:42:55 PM »
I was on the pistol side one day and saw a guy put the back plate of his glock into his forehead.  Luckily the blast only broke the gun and gave him a superficial (but bloody) wound.  Just be careful. 

jase90

Re: REPOST / Was this stupid? 9mm Titegroup. PICS ADDED
« Reply #13 on: January 14, 2019, 09:14:50 PM »
I was on the pistol side one day and saw a guy put the back plate of his glock into his forehead.  Luckily the blast only broke the gun and gave him a superficial (but bloody) wound.  Just be careful.

Completley understand. Thank you. I got the data in my most recent post since I already "went there" and came back alive.