I heard stories of old timers say that even teachers could give you lickins. And if you told on them to your parents, so would your parents because if teacher gave you lickins, it was for a good reason. So the parents would also punish you too.
Is there a correlation between lack of lickins and our higher crime today? I'm sure it's not the only cause, but a combo of things like single mother households.
Humans have an innate cost-benefit analysis process in our brains. We learn early on what's worth behaving a certain way, and what's not worth it.
Positive reinforcement is absolutely more effective than negative. If you offer (and consistently give) a positive outcome for desired behavior, you'll find that people will willingly choose to do whatever that reward requires without being forced to do it.
However, when negative reinforcement is used, it becomes a process of trying to avoid the bad response. In the process of being punished, the person rationalizes that the benefits of their behavior were WORTH the punishment. That's especially true if they've been able to get away with it with no punishment before. Only when the punishment becomes more severe than the actions are "worth" will punishment deter that behavior.
The difficulties are obvious:
1. It's nearly impossible to ensure 100% consistency when rewarding good behavior. Example: a teacher spends more time dealing with bad behavior, which takes away their time to spend rewarding the students who are behaving correctly. Squeaky wheel syndrome.
2. If the reward is always the same, the effectiveness diminishes over time. It's difficult (and may be expensive) to periodically increase the worth of the reward in order to elicit the desired behavior.
3. No everyone values the same things, nor do they value the same things equally. Rewards often must be tailored to the individual.
4. The best rewards are not material. A good feeling goes further than $5. The desired outcome is that the person will seek out that feeling over and over again. You can find other ways to earn that $5 while behaving badly. The feeling of doing good only comes from the correct behavior.
I tried punishing my kids for not cleaning their rooms. It became a struggle to see how long they would hold out. They knew it was inevitable, but they didn't fear the punishment as much as they hated cleaning their rooms.
Then we started a "Good Job" calendar. We created a list of chores that earned a certain number of stickers. Each of our girls could see the list, pick what to do, and come tell us when they finished. After inspection of their performance, we gave them the stickers to put on the calendar for that day. At the end of each week, if they earned a preset number of stickers, they got to pick a weekend activity: a dinner wherever they picked, a night at the local arcade, the water park, a movie, etc. Whatever they picked within reason was their reward.
Their rooms were always cleaned after that, and there were times they would come to us and ask, "Do you need me to do anything for you? Wash dishes? Walk the dog?"

Morale of the story: it's easier to punish than reward and remain consistent. That's why it's easier to give a spanking the few times someone misbehaves than give them a reward for always being good. Sometimes, they'll misbehave just to get that individual attention that only the bad kid seems to get.