The Left is All In on Censorship (Read 3532 times)

Inspector

The Left is All In on Censorship
« on: January 31, 2022, 01:05:24 PM »
The Pressure Campaign on Spotify to Remove Joe Rogan Reveals the Religion of Liberals: Censorship

https://greenwald.substack.com/p/the-pressure-campaign-on-spotify
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

Flapp_Jackson

Re: The Left is All In on Censorship
« Reply #1 on: January 31, 2022, 02:53:43 PM »
They aren't censoring Joe Rogan. They are going after the loudspeaker of misinformation by pulling their music and hurting them financially. We can't assist the propagation of lies that kill people.

What lies?

Who are these murdered soles?  Got any names?  Why has he not been charged with their deaths?
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

hvybarrels

Re: The Left is All In on Censorship
« Reply #2 on: January 31, 2022, 03:38:11 PM »
We can't assist the propagation of lies that kill people.

You don't need a parachute to go skydiving. You need a parachute to go skydiving twice.

bass monkey

Re: The Left is All In on Censorship
« Reply #3 on: January 31, 2022, 04:08:30 PM »

By fascist I mean politics that suppresses opposition.


Like censorship

changemyoil66

Re: The Left is All In on Censorship
« Reply #4 on: January 31, 2022, 04:16:59 PM »
Like censorship
Censorship of info  that 1 side feels is right. Despite being shown theyre wrong

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

eyeeatingfish

Re: The Left is All In on Censorship
« Reply #5 on: February 03, 2022, 01:22:49 PM »
Rhetorical question:

Is this not just the free market at work?

changemyoil66

Re: The Left is All In on Censorship
« Reply #6 on: February 03, 2022, 01:51:22 PM »
Rhetorical question:

Is this not just the free market at work?

Fact checkers would say it is. Because the government urging censorship doesn't count.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: The Left is All In on Censorship
« Reply #7 on: February 03, 2022, 03:14:44 PM »
Rhetorical question:

Is this not just the free market at work?

I assume you labeled it rhetorical either because you believe it is, or you know it's not and are being sarcastic. 

If you aren't sure either way, you should do some research into what constitutes a free market.

"Free" implies we are all welcome to compete.  If the consumers prefer the products, quality, customer service, prices, etc. of a given seller, the other sellers either change their offering to be more competitive or leave the market.

Trying to force someone out of a market you don't want there is anything but a "free market" environment.  We have laws that prevent market leaders from barring entrance to potential competition through monopolistic practices (undercutting prices, price fixing and collusion, getting a lock on needed raw materials, and so on).  Organizing people who probably aren't even listening to Rogan in order to get him fired is not the market taking a position.  It's a group of ideologues trying to cancel someone whose ideas they oppose.

A free market would ignore these non-consumers of the Rogan programs and let the sponsors and real listeners decide.   If he loses listenership and his ratings fall without a concerted effort to cause it, THEN the market is telling Spotify what to do.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

eyeeatingfish

Re: The Left is All In on Censorship
« Reply #8 on: February 03, 2022, 09:27:08 PM »
I assume you labeled it rhetorical either because you believe it is, or you know it's not and are being sarcastic. 

If you aren't sure either way, you should do some research into what constitutes a free market.

"Free" implies we are all welcome to compete.  If the consumers prefer the products, quality, customer service, prices, etc. of a given seller, the other sellers either change their offering to be more competitive or leave the market.

Trying to force someone out of a market you don't want there is anything but a "free market" environment.  We have laws that prevent market leaders from barring entrance to potential competition through monopolistic practices (undercutting prices, price fixing and collusion, getting a lock on needed raw materials, and so on).  Organizing people who probably aren't even listening to Rogan in order to get him fired is not the market taking a position.  It's a group of ideologues trying to cancel someone whose ideas they oppose.

A free market would ignore these non-consumers of the Rogan programs and let the sponsors and real listeners decide.   If he loses listenership and his ratings fall without a concerted effort to cause it, THEN the market is telling Spotify what to do.

I labeled it as rhetorical because I wanted people to think about it. Perhaps I should have given some examples to aid in it.

Say you own Flapp's book store, you get to decide what books you want to sell. Maybe you refuse to sell Mein Kamfp, maybe you refuse to sell How to be an Anti-Racist Baby, etc.
1. Are you censoring people?
2. Should you be allowed to do this?


If Spotify allowed Kim Jyong Un to have a podcast where he bashed America, surely we can speak with our wallets and boycott spotify.

There was a recent story of a spice company owner who called all republicans racist (or something to that effect) and as a result he lost a bunch of customers. Did they censor the spice company?  Are republicans complaining that customers shouldn't put pressure on the spice company just because the owner said something bad about them?

eyeeatingfish

Re: The Left is All In on Censorship
« Reply #9 on: February 03, 2022, 09:42:12 PM »
I think for this discussion to be complete and accurate we should look at censorship and freedom of speech being under attack from all sides. As much as most of us all see and hear these examples of liberals trying to shut down and control speech there are also a number of examples of republicans doing the same. In some states Republicans have passed actual laws relating to what can and cannot be taught in school. Not just prohibiting endorsement of certain ideas but preventing them from being covered. And there is also banning of some books. Yet I haven't seen many conservatives lamenting this censorship. Why? (tribalism I would guess)

Conservatives are doing it in ways a little different than liberals but both are doing it all while simultaneously claiming they are for free speech. Both sides play the social card and both sides have pushed to use the law.


As for what is happening with Joe Rogan, I think Neil Young is stupid for doing this but he is absolutely free to do so and I am not going to act like there is some great oppression because he decides where he is willing to have his music played. Nothing guarantees a person a right to have a voice to the whole nation. Do you think conservatives would have a huge outrage if Kid Rock did the same thing trying to get Hillary Clinton's podcast removed? (I bet not)

If the government starts regulating speech then I have a huge problem.

Brystont1

Re: The Left is All In on Censorship
« Reply #10 on: February 03, 2022, 10:07:07 PM »
I think for this discussion to be complete and accurate we should look at censorship and freedom of speech being under attack from all sides. As much as most of us all see and hear these examples of liberals trying to shut down and control speech there are also a number of examples of republicans doing the same. In some states Republicans have passed actual laws relating to what can and cannot be taught in school. Not just prohibiting endorsement of certain ideas but preventing them from being covered. And there is also banning of some books. Yet I haven't seen many conservatives lamenting this censorship. Why? (tribalism I would guess)

Conservatives are doing it in ways a little different than liberals but both are doing it all while simultaneously claiming they are for free speech. Both sides play the social card and both sides have pushed to use the law.


As for what is happening with Joe Rogan, I think Neil Young is stupid for doing this but he is absolutely free to do so and I am not going to act like there is some great oppression because he decides where he is willing to have his music played. Nothing guarantees a person a right to have a voice to the whole nation. Do you think conservatives would have a huge outrage if Kid Rock did the same thing trying to get Hillary Clinton's podcast removed? (I bet not)

If the government starts regulating speech then I have a huge problem.

So all attempts from a government to regulate what is taught in schools is an example of free speech violations?

I’m trying to figure out exactly where your disagreement here is? I don’t think anyone here disagrees with your last paragraph. Has anyone said Neil young should be stopped from removing his music? Most people just think he’s an idiot and a hypocrite for supposedly believing in free speech while attempting to censor someone because you don’t like their opinion.

ren

Re: The Left is All In on Censorship
« Reply #11 on: February 03, 2022, 10:14:37 PM »
So these artists are just plain jealous of Joe Rogan so they threw a temper tantrum like a kid in a toy aisle
Deeds Not Words

changemyoil66

Re: The Left is All In on Censorship
« Reply #12 on: February 03, 2022, 10:37:52 PM »
I labeled it as rhetorical because I wanted people to think about it. Perhaps I should have given some examples to aid in it.

Say you own Flapp's book store, you get to decide what books you want to sell. Maybe you refuse to sell Mein Kamfp, maybe you refuse to sell How to be an Anti-Racist Baby, etc.
1. Are you censoring people?
2. Should you be allowed to do this?


If Spotify allowed Kim Jyong Un to have a podcast where he bashed America, surely we can speak with our wallets and boycott spotify.

There was a recent story of a spice company owner who called all republicans racist (or something to that effect) and as a result he lost a bunch of customers. Did they censor the spice company?  Are republicans complaining that customers shouldn't put pressure on the spice company just because the owner said something bad about them?
Ur story is missing out that the gov steps in and strongly suggest (wink wink) u dont sell mein kempf or dont play KUJ podcast.

This is the issue we are worried about.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

changemyoil66

Re: The Left is All In on Censorship
« Reply #13 on: February 03, 2022, 10:41:42 PM »
I think for this discussion to be complete and accurate we should look at censorship and freedom of speech being under attack from all sides. As much as most of us all see and hear these examples of liberals trying to shut down and control speech there are also a number of examples of republicans doing the same. In some states Republicans have passed actual laws relating to what can and cannot be taught in school. Not just prohibiting endorsement of certain ideas but preventing them from being covered. And there is also banning of some books. Yet I haven't seen many conservatives lamenting this censorship. Why? (tribalism I would guess)

Conservatives are doing it in ways a little different than liberals but both are doing it all while simultaneously claiming they are for free speech. Both sides play the social card and both sides have pushed to use the law.


As for what is happening with Joe Rogan, I think Neil Young is stupid for doing this but he is absolutely free to do so and I am not going to act like there is some great oppression because he decides where he is willing to have his music played. Nothing guarantees a person a right to have a voice to the whole nation. Do you think conservatives would have a huge outrage if Kid Rock did the same thing trying to get Hillary Clinton's podcast removed? (I bet not)

If the government starts regulating speech then I have a huge problem.
1 fault to your story is since the gov runs the school system, they would already be censoring something by not teaching evetything. Unless they teach every topic known to man, which would make the school 20hrs a day 365 days a week.

Now a private school might be a diff story if the gov has zero influence over them, which idk if they do. Is there a law/code for minimim curriculum? If there is, then refer to the paragraph above.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

eyeeatingfish

Re: The Left is All In on Censorship
« Reply #14 on: February 04, 2022, 02:58:14 PM »
So all attempts from a government to regulate what is taught in schools is an example of free speech violations?

I’m trying to figure out exactly where your disagreement here is? I don’t think anyone here disagrees with your last paragraph. Has anyone said Neil young should be stopped from removing his music? Most people just think he’s an idiot and a hypocrite for supposedly believing in free speech while attempting to censor someone because you don’t like their opinion.

I would say my position is twofold:

1. Potentially yes it is going into the realm of free speech issues. Is it really something we want a state or federal government to have the power to dictate that students must be taught X or cant be taught Y? Its not whether I agree with curriculum choice but with how much power we want the government to have.  My comment is a general statement and I am sure there could be a few exceptions.

2. I don't even think it should be in the wheelhouse of the government for the most part. Can't most of these concerns be taken care of at the local level like at PTA meetings and DOE elections, etc. Do we really need state laws on this matter?

As for Neil Young, I just don't think it is some injustice or assault on freedom that some people are painting it as.

eyeeatingfish

Re: The Left is All In on Censorship
« Reply #15 on: February 04, 2022, 03:08:16 PM »
1 fault to your story is since the gov runs the school system, they would already be censoring something by not teaching evetything. Unless they teach every topic known to man, which would make the school 20hrs a day 365 days a week.

Now a private school might be a diff story if the gov has zero influence over them, which idk if they do. Is there a law/code for minimim curriculum? If there is, then refer to the paragraph above.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

The government strongly suggests that people don't sell Mein Kampf? Where is this? I will say that there is some nuance here, I think there is justifiable reason for a government to put out statements being in support or against some messages/speech. Where the line is clearly cross is when the government is when they try to actually restrict the message/speech.
 
Interestingly I checked amazon and it is available for purchase there.

Since clearly a school can not cover every subject and every topic I don't think we can claim a mere choosing of what curriculum to include as constituting censorship. I don't get to claim that since my kids school doesn't want to teach my book about aliens that the school is practicing censorship.

Maybe the line should be when a decision prohibiting a topic or book is made, as opposed to merely choosing different one to cover. If the government passed a law saying a teacher cannot teach about slavery this would clearly cross the line in my opinion.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: The Left is All In on Censorship
« Reply #16 on: February 04, 2022, 03:24:58 PM »
Children of an age able to put literary and documentary works in context (To Kill a Mockingbird, Mein Kampf, Diaries of a Giesha, etc.) should be required reading as they relate to English Lit, History, Social Studies, etc.

When the schools TAKE A BOOK ALREADY PART OF A SYLLABUS off of the list due to "offended parents," that's censorship.  The offended parents should be offered the opportunity to audit the sessions that include that book and see what CONTEXT the lessons include.  If they wish, they can later discuss the book and the lessons with their children to give them their own opinions.  Sheltering kids from things you personally don't like should not carry over to every other parents' kids.

Simply not putting a book on a syllabus is not censorship no matter how important you feel that book might be for an education.  Millions of books in print -- not all make it onto a syllabus.  Are they all being censored by virtue of not being included?

It's not rocket surgery.  We all know censorship when we see it.  The big question is WHY it's being excluded, and whether the students will have access to the books in question on their own time (Was the book removed from the library?  Were all copies removed from the  supply storage room?)

This is a big reason private schools are the path parents choose if they can afford it.  Public schools bend to the whims and emotions of the most outspoken minority, forcing the obedient majority to accept what the few dictate.  Private schools provide a more basic, academic atmosphere without as much of the drama and hysteria.  As long as the parents are happy their kids are learning necessary skills to enter college and get a job, they trust the faculty to not cram societal BS down their kids' collective and proverbial throats just to appear politically correct so they can continue to get federal dollars.

As for Internet podcast media, those guys can do anything they want.  it's a commercial enterprise.  If they want to kowtow to Big Brother, they can censor anyone or anything the gov't doesn't like.  If they prefer freedom of speech, they can tell Big Brother to stick it.  Any one who disagrees with their offerings can financially support their competition, to make sure they can continue to consume what they enjoy and agree with.  Trying to "cancel" people and businesses over dislikes and offenses when you probably don't even subscribe has become a thing. 

I think if I owned a business and 100K complaints came in over a podcast segment, I'd want to know of that 100K how many are active subscribers.  Actual paying customers and shareholders are who you need to worry about financially.  Everyone else can pound sand.  If they want a say in the programming, they need to put a little skin in the game and not just be a Krazy Karen.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw