2a case on Maui (Read 1577 times)

MauiAxis

2a case on Maui
« on: August 22, 2022, 05:51:12 PM »

punaperson

Re: 2a case on Maui
« Reply #1 on: August 22, 2022, 08:50:39 PM »
Firearms charges dismissed against Paia man

http://www.mauinews.com/news/local-news/2022/08/firearms-charges-dismissed-against-paia-man/
Deputy Prosecutor Sally Tobin said the Second Amendment right isn’t unlimited but is subject to “reasonable restrictions” imposed by states.

“We have always recognized places that a firearm is inappropriate, so there are limits,” she said.

* * * *
That's right. Anywhere but inside the home is a "reasonable restriction". smh.

aieahound

Re: 2a case on Maui
« Reply #2 on: August 22, 2022, 10:10:19 PM »
This one makes me think.

Carrying an unregistered firearm ( in his waistband) onto to someone else’s property.
Charged with misdemeanor?

Would be different if it was a law abiding citizen walking down the street exercising their Right.

Does this incident and Judgement help or hurt in the Court of Public Opinion ?
(Straight up question)
And you can say public opinion doesn’t matter and then put your head back in the sand.

Does this Judgement help or hurt ?
« Last Edit: August 22, 2022, 10:15:44 PM by aieahound »

punaperson

Re: 2a case on Maui
« Reply #3 on: August 22, 2022, 10:47:20 PM »
This one makes me think.

Carrying an unregistered firearm ( in his waistband) onto to someone else’s property.
Charged with misdemeanor?

Would be different if it was a law abiding citizen walking down the street exercising their Right.

Does this incident and Judgement help or hurt in the Court of Public Opinion ?
(Straight up question)
And you can say public opinion doesn’t matter and then put your head back in the sand.

Does this Judgement help or hurt ?
"Registration" is unquestioningly ("shall not be infringed") unconstitutional. Any "process", "restriction", or "criteria" for keeping and bearing arms by law-abiding citizens is illegal.

Sure, he could be charged with trespassing. The fact that he was bearing a firearm or stick of gum is irrelevant.

"Public opinion" in Hawaii is that no one should be allowed to bear arms in public. You may have noticed that "the public" votes consistently and overwhelmingly for those candidates (aka Democrats and the occasional RINO) that advocate for draconian restrictions on the right to keep and bear arms. Their belief is that no matter how "previously law-abiding" a person is, once they carry a firearm in public it's only a matter of time until there will be a horrific disaster at one level or another ("accident" to "mass shooting"). No amount of "facts" or "data" will ever change that... or it'd already be changed. This is pretty much the same group that still believes masks prevent viral transmission, "social distancing" prevents viral transmission, "hand sanitizer" prevents viral transmission, the experimental injections prevent infection, transmission and serious illness and death, and that those same injections have no serious adverse event consequences. I.e. they are 100% wrong, and no giant stack of peer-reviewed randomized controlled trial evidence will ever convince them otherwise. This is mass formation, making them immune to rational and logical critical thinking evaluation of evidence. Covid. Firearms. Same process at work.

There will be no change in "public opinion" for many many years, if ever. Our only possible relief will come from the courts, and we can see how that goes (Heller 2008, Bruen 2022, Registration 2036, mag capacity 2050, etc.). How many carry licenses have been issued in Hawaii to non-security guards (aka "ordinary citizens")? I got a written statement from former HPD chief Kubojiri stating that to his knowledge such a carry license had NEVER been issued in Hawaii county. NEVER. Yeah, that seems like a "reasonable restriction". The cops have already lied about their "30 day" window to issue the new criteria. They will continue to lie, obfuscate, and do everything possible, legal and illegal, to make sure the fewest possible people ever get to carry publicly, with zero being the ideal number. I mean, of course, except for the chief there on Oahu who has stated the licenses will be issued in the next 8 days.

MauiAxis

Re: 2a case on Maui
« Reply #4 on: August 23, 2022, 10:11:23 AM »
IMHO, this case is a step forward. The guy with a concealed pistol was not slammed with greater charges.

I know a person here who was caught trespassing  with a firearm, and now has a felony conviction and can no longer own a gun. For his lifetime. I dont know the particulars, but that is pretty harsh.

Gordyf

Re: 2a case on Maui
« Reply #5 on: August 23, 2022, 08:05:18 PM »
Ben Lowenthal? Son of Former Maui public defender Phil Lowenthal? Most likely.
Phil made a career of beating on  Maui prosecutors and made many of them look really silly.
He was the guy you wanted if you had a public defender. Was successful in private practice later.
Hope the boy does as well.
Now I am dating myself
Aloha
Gordy