7th Circuit decides self defense extends outside the home (Read 12291 times)

Cougar8045

Re: 7th Circuit decides self defense extends outside the home
« Reply #20 on: December 12, 2012, 07:21:38 AM »
Much love to Richard Posner and mucho congrats to the people of Illinois!!

I'm gonna take this news with a grain of salt though, because I am not sure that this will result in instant changes for Illinois.

The way I read the articles, Illinois was the only state in the U.S. that flat-out prohibited Concealed Carry.

The ruling forces the Illinois legislature to work on legislation that addresses the CC issue, right?

So what is stopping the Illinois legislature from doing the same thing Hawaii has done and drafting a CC law that is so unattainable that only the "chosen few" will ever have hopes of being able to actually CC?

Again I'm happy for the ruling and I remain cautiously optimistic!!

I could be wrong so please correct me if I am, bruddahs!!
Nothing is stopping them from doing it, for now.  Constitutional rights are subject to reasonable restrictions.  Your right to swing your fist ends at the start of the other guy's nose, and all that.  The thing is, it's going to be hard for states like Hawaii to claim that a permit system which grants permits to a some tiny percent of applicants is a "reasonable" restriction.  Think of it this way: how long do you think Hawaii's laws would stand if their permit to acquire system hadn't issued a permit in the last 12 years?  Not very damn long, because that's not a reasonable restriction.  If you have a right to do something, the state has to show a damn good reason not to let you; that's why the police need a search warrant from a judge to search your house, and it's why a jury of your peers has to convict you of a crime in order to send you to prison.  The state would have a hell of a time justifying a warrantless, random search of houses because the residents didn't state a specific, heightened reason why they should be secure in their persons, papers, and effects. 

Essentially, if you have a right to do something, the burden of proof is on the state to prove that you shouldn't be allowed to exercise that right.  Without a court specifically stating that the 2nd Amendment applies outside the home, carrying a firearm is a privilege and the state is within its authority to demand that you prove you deserve the privilege.
I'm just a fluffy white bunny rabbit who lost his way. 

"If a thief be found breaking in, and be smitten that he die, there shall no blood be shed for him. ..."  -Exodus 22:2

hnl.flyboy

Re: 7th Circuit decides self defense extends outside the home
« Reply #21 on: December 12, 2012, 09:35:27 AM »
... or maybe he was saying that because you quadruple posted the twitter info?  You get one fast trigger finger, bruddah!!  :D

Ooopsie...negligent discharges!  :oops:
LEX MALLA, LEX NULLA

FPC, SAF Life, HDF Life, GOA, HRA, Fun Factory VIP