No real substantive reason. Just that I like the minimum 16" barrel for home defense and adding a hider or brake wo/shortening the barrel an amount equal to the length of the device, would make the barrel longer; 2-3" longer.
Some manufacturers treat barrel length differently as far as brakes/hiders go. Like my M4 is 16" from the closed bolt face to the end of the hider (ATF technique), which means the barrel PROPER is about 14". But interestingly, my AR10A1 measured the same way is almost 19", even though armalite markets it as a 16" carbine.
Point is colt and armalite both call the rifles 16" carbines but the armalite is noticeably more unwieldy since they spec their barrel length WITHOUT the hider, and colt specs theirs WITH the hider.
So, I'm not bent on cutting the barrel; if it wouldn't affect operations, I would cut it the amount the hider would add to maintain 16", but its not critical.
What do you think?