The value of anything is based on supply and demand.
On an island, the supply is always at risk.
Again, on an island, the worth of an item depends on demand. In a long term SHTF situation, any currency or precious metal will have limited demand. Survival will be the first order of business.
You can't eat money or gold. Some may speculate the bad situation will be short-lived and try to gouge buyers who want whatever the seller has to sell. That won't work long-term. At some point, the seller will need to buy things HE needs, and the currency won't have value.
All the items that have a real purpose in a SHTF situation (food, water, and medicine top the list) will become more valuable as the supply dwindles.
It's all about speculation. Whatever you "hoard" to survive, it should be useful to you AND to others, and have a good chance of becoming scarce at some point.