Hawaii has lowest gun death rates (Read 26628 times)

eyeeatingfish

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #20 on: February 03, 2015, 04:36:14 PM »
Exactly! Show me the evidence that limiting magazine capacity to ANY random number (e.g. 7 in New York state) has any bearing of any sort (i.e. causal relationship) with the "gun death" (or any other consequence) rate (Does anyone really believe that limiting magazine capacity to 10 or 7 or 3 will bring down the over-60% of "gun deaths" that are suicides?). I know that can't be done because there is no such evidence, but even if there were, then tell me how you'd enforce the magazine limit on criminals, almost all of whom acquire their firearms illegally, and are highly unlikely to refuse a black market firearm purchase because the gun has the factory standard-capacity magazine (which for most semi-auto pistols today, other than .45 caliber, are greater than 10).

I think you are the only one talking about ten round magazines here. I didn't mention them and the article linked in the initial post didn't mention them.

mauidog

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #21 on: February 03, 2015, 05:37:15 PM »
I think you are the only one talking about ten round magazines here. I didn't mention them and the article linked in the initial post didn't mention them.

Since you fhaven't figured it out, I'll try to give you a hint:

Gun Deaths have a direct correlation with the percentage of guns used in deaths.  PERIOD.  Having legal access to a gun, owning 30 rd magazines, owning black rifles with adjustable stocks and cool attachments, owning a gun with a certain length barrel .... none of the current laws  are based on anything to do with reality.  There is no causal relationship, of as far as I can tell even some kind of direct factor involved, between these laws already passed and their effect/lack of effect on deaths -- gun related or not!

Using the term Gun Deaths is like studying cancer deaths.  The better treatment and early detection, the lower the rate of cancer deaths.  Does that lower the rate of deaths?  No, that is still at 100%!!

Same with gun deaths.  If you lower the percentage of deaths by gun violence, accidents, and suicides, is there any evidence that will result in fewer DEATHS?  Any at all? 

If not, then the gun is incidental.  Death is the real killer, not guns!
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

eyeeatingfish

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #22 on: February 03, 2015, 09:55:56 PM »
Since you fhaven't figured it out, I'll try to give you a hint:

Gun Deaths have a direct correlation with the percentage of guns used in deaths.  PERIOD.  Having legal access to a gun, owning 30 rd magazines, owning black rifles with adjustable stocks and cool attachments, owning a gun with a certain length barrel .... none of the current laws  are based on anything to do with reality.  There is no causal relationship, of as far as I can tell even some kind of direct factor involved, between these laws already passed and their effect/lack of effect on deaths -- gun related or not!

Using the term Gun Deaths is like studying cancer deaths.  The better treatment and early detection, the lower the rate of cancer deaths.  Does that lower the rate of deaths?  No, that is still at 100%!!

Same with gun deaths.  If you lower the percentage of deaths by gun violence, accidents, and suicides, is there any evidence that will result in fewer DEATHS?  Any at all? 

If not, then the gun is incidental.  Death is the real killer, not guns!

This isn't exactly news to me though, nor am I in disagreement, and has nothing to do with the point I made earlier. Just to review, my point was looking at what reduction in gun deaths could be attributed to advancements in medicine. I don't know if this is something yet quantified but it is something to consider in the topic as it could affect the validity of an argument.

Although to get technical I would say some gun laws are based on things rooted in reality but that is another issue.

mauidog

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #23 on: February 03, 2015, 10:07:42 PM »
This isn't exactly news to me though, nor am I in disagreement, and has nothing to do with the point I made earlier. Just to review, my point was looking at what reduction in gun deaths could be attributed to advancements in medicine. I don't know if this is something yet quantified but it is something to consider in the topic as it could affect the validity of an argument.

Although to get technical I would say some gun laws are based on things rooted in reality but that is another issue.

Try doing some research on the Saturday Night Special and the laws banning or restricting them.  Look at the calls of racism, accusations of manufacturers marketing them in predominantly Black and Hispanic neighborhoods.

Then, look at the "unintended consequences" in terms of number of gun deaths versus injuries.

There are pleny of examples in the last 25 years how soldiers who would have died in battle return home alive, many facing physical and emotional challenges in numbers never before seen during a war.  That pretty much answers your question: it's obvious advances in medical capabilities save lives that might have been lost before. 

The problem is, the human body is one of the most resilient, and at the same time the most fragile, system known to exist.  We have people missing large portions of their bodies, vital organs, and suffering all sorts of trauma, yet they live a long time.  On the other hand, a seemingly perfectly healthy person can die in less than a minute from a blood clot in the wrong blood vessel in the heart or brain.

Knowing that, I don't think it's possible to enumerate which gunshot victims would have died 20 years ago versus surviving today.  It's speculation at best.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

eyeeatingfish

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #24 on: February 04, 2015, 10:04:59 AM »
Try doing some research on the Saturday Night Special and the laws banning or restricting them.  Look at the calls of racism, accusations of manufacturers marketing them in predominantly Black and Hispanic neighborhoods.

Then, look at the "unintended consequences" in terms of number of gun deaths versus injuries.

There are pleny of examples in the last 25 years how soldiers who would have died in battle return home alive, many facing physical and emotional challenges in numbers never before seen during a war.  That pretty much answers your question: it's obvious advances in medical capabilities save lives that might have been lost before. 

The problem is, the human body is one of the most resilient, and at the same time the most fragile, system known to exist.  We have people missing large portions of their bodies, vital organs, and suffering all sorts of trauma, yet they live a long time.  On the other hand, a seemingly perfectly healthy person can die in less than a minute from a blood clot in the wrong blood vessel in the heart or brain.

Knowing that, I don't think it's possible to enumerate which gunshot victims would have died 20 years ago versus surviving today.  It's speculation at best.

I agree that it might not be possible to get an accurate count but who knows. I once speak to an intensive care nurse one day regarding a male who had survived 4-5 gunshots to the torso. He told me that 5 years ago they would not have been able to save the individual. Anecdotal of course but it makes me wonder.

The reason I think it is relevant is because it could affect the validity of an argument concerning firearms. For example, if fewer people were dieing from gunshots but the same amount of people were getting shot then there isn't really a drop of gun violence. I doubt that is the case though. It would still be interesting to know even if just from a medical point of view. Certainly if we knew and a anti gun individual  were to make the argument that the reduction in deaths is only due to medical advancements then we could counter with a statistic showing that only X% could be attributed to medical advancements.

Kingkeoni

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #25 on: February 04, 2015, 09:56:44 PM »
I agree that it might not be possible to get an accurate count but who knows. I once speak to an intensive care nurse one day regarding a male who had survived 4-5 gunshots to the torso. He told me that 5 years ago they would not have been able to save the individual. Anecdotal of course but it makes me wonder.

If your story is true then that nurse is the biggest idiot ever.

My friend was shot 9 times, 5 into the chest cavity, in 1990. He survived.

My cousin was shot 7 times all torso shots, in 1969. He survived.

For any "nurse" to tell you that someone "could not" be saved at a certain point and time without being there and being able to assess the damage, tells you they're full of kukai.
Your number one Option for Personal Security is a lifelong commitment to avoidance, deterrence, and de-escalation.

Someday someone may kill you with your own gun, but they should have to beat you to death with it because it is empty.

HiCarry

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #26 on: February 05, 2015, 04:15:20 PM »
I agree that it might not be possible to get an accurate count but who knows. I once speak to an intensive care nurse one day regarding a male who had survived 4-5 gunshots to the torso. He told me that 5 years ago they would not have been able to save the individual. Anecdotal of course but it makes me wonder.

The reason I think it is relevant is because it could affect the validity of an argument concerning firearms. For example, if fewer people were dieing from gunshots but the same amount of people were getting shot then there isn't really a drop of gun violence. I doubt that is the case though. It would still be interesting to know even if just from a medical point of view. Certainly if we knew and a anti gun individual  were to make the argument that the reduction in deaths is only due to medical advancements then we could counter with a statistic showing that only X% could be attributed to medical advancements.

I have worked in Emergency Departments, Trauma ICUs and aeromedical transport of critical patients for over 30 years. To answer your question about medical advancements "saving" more gunshot victims, the simple answer is yes. That being said, trauma management is a lot of science and training and a little bit of luck. Are there surgical procedures that could "fix" things we couldn't fix years ago? Yes. Are there advances that make survival more likely now given a specific injury from a GSW? Yes. Can we fix the heart after a direct hit that basically tears it apart? No.

As someone else mentioned, the advancements in battlefield surgical trauma care is irrefutable. More soldiers, sailors and marines are surviving their battlefield wounds than ever before. But that may not be as clear as you think it is. When they collate the statistics, they don't account for the quality of life. Yes, you could survive the GSW to the head that might have killed you 10 years ago, but if you are comatose afterwards what's the real "advancement?" It's still counted as a "save" but it's not like the victim is back to his or her normal life.

As for the use of these advancements in an antigun crusade, it would have to be, IMHO, countered with the fact that there are more guns in citizen's hands now than 10 years ago. So, even if the death rate were going down due to medical advancements, that wouldn't negate the fact there are more guns. Additionally, the argument can be made using the injury statistics available from the CDC. There are less GSW victims, both those killed and those injured, despite the prolific raise in the number of guns.

 

bass monkey

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #27 on: February 05, 2015, 04:52:51 PM »
These threads are crazy and switch topics of discussion so quickly. We went from talking about low gun deaths to medical advancements, in the other cdc thread it went from stats to talking about suicide statistics. 
I wonder what the conversation will turn to after this medical advancement theory is talked out.

HiCarry

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #28 on: February 05, 2015, 05:16:32 PM »
If your story is true then that nurse is the biggest idiot ever.

My friend was shot 9 times, 5 into the chest cavity, in 1990. He survived.

My cousin was shot 7 times all torso shots, in 1969. He survived.

For any "nurse" to tell you that someone "could not" be saved at a certain point and time without being there and being able to assess the damage, tells you they're full of kukai.
Sorry, gotta disagree with you about the nurse being an idiot and the validity of the statement that the patient would not have survived "5 years ago."

The question was not about your cousin or your friend that got shot, but rather the person who was shot and that he/she were taking care of at that point. The injuries to your friend and cousin would have been unknown to that nurse so any comment about their survival due to medical advancements would have been fatally flawed. However, assuming the nurse being questioned was taking care of the patient with the GSWs in the related story, then the injuries sustained at that point and available treatment for those injuries "5 years ago" would be known and comments about the survivability of those injuries could well be valid. I wouldn't have to "be there" to know that a person with the injuries I am taking care of now would not have been able to survive THOSE SAME injuries 5 years ago.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #29 on: February 05, 2015, 08:36:04 PM »
If your story is true then that nurse is the biggest idiot ever.

My friend was shot 9 times, 5 into the chest cavity, in 1990. He survived.

My cousin was shot 7 times all torso shots, in 1969. He survived.

For any "nurse" to tell you that someone "could not" be saved at a certain point and time without being there and being able to assess the damage, tells you they're full of kukai.

I don't think you can make such a simple comparison. It really matters where one gets hit and then on top of that it matters what type of round you are shot with.
Having said that I am not trying to make some scientific comparison. I was offering an anecdotal story to explain why I was thinking of this issue.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #30 on: February 05, 2015, 08:48:35 PM »
I have worked in Emergency Departments, Trauma ICUs and aeromedical transport of critical patients for over 30 years. To answer your question about medical advancements "saving" more gunshot victims, the simple answer is yes. That being said, trauma management is a lot of science and training and a little bit of luck. Are there surgical procedures that could "fix" things we couldn't fix years ago? Yes. Are there advances that make survival more likely now given a specific injury from a GSW? Yes. Can we fix the heart after a direct hit that basically tears it apart? No.

As someone else mentioned, the advancements in battlefield surgical trauma care is irrefutable. More soldiers, sailors and marines are surviving their battlefield wounds than ever before. But that may not be as clear as you think it is. When they collate the statistics, they don't account for the quality of life. Yes, you could survive the GSW to the head that might have killed you 10 years ago, but if you are comatose afterwards what's the real "advancement?" It's still counted as a "save" but it's not like the victim is back to his or her normal life.

As for the use of these advancements in an antigun crusade, it would have to be, IMHO, countered with the fact that there are more guns in citizen's hands now than 10 years ago. So, even if the death rate were going down due to medical advancements, that wouldn't negate the fact there are more guns. Additionally, the argument can be made using the injury statistics available from the CDC. There are less GSW victims, both those killed and those injured, despite the prolific raise in the number of guns.

Thanks for your person experience/expertise.

I will have to look up the statistics on GSW victims of those injured to make a more solid argument then. I recently read a critic who was arguing that while per capita, guns have increased but the amount of actual gun owners per capita was declining. Are you aware of a source that tracks gun owners per capita instead of just guns per capita? All I can seem to find is guns per capita.

Kingkeoni

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #31 on: February 05, 2015, 09:06:01 PM »
Sorry, gotta disagree with you about the nurse being an idiot and the validity of the statement that the patient would not have survived "5 years ago."

The question was not about your cousin or your friend that got shot, but rather the person who was shot and that he/she were taking care of at that point. The injuries to your friend and cousin would have been unknown to that nurse so any comment about their survival due to medical advancements would have been fatally flawed. However, assuming the nurse being questioned was taking care of the patient with the GSWs in the related story, then the injuries sustained at that point and available treatment for those injuries "5 years ago" would be known and comments about the survivability of those injuries could well be valid. I wouldn't have to "be there" to know that a person with the injuries I am taking care of now would not have been able to survive THOSE SAME injuries 5 years ago.

Medicine is a "weird science"

No nurse or doctor for that matter can tell you with any certainty who could have survived any wound if they transported the patient back in time 5 years.

Every single day someone is diagnosed with a "death sentence" and are proven wrong.

Conversely, patients are diagnosed/misdiagnosed with a simple affliction, only to end up with a much more serious ailment or even death.

People have fallen out of airplanes and lived.

People have fallen down off a chair and died.

NO nurse can tell you definitively what would have happened 5 years ago.

That's just the reality.
Your number one Option for Personal Security is a lifelong commitment to avoidance, deterrence, and de-escalation.

Someday someone may kill you with your own gun, but they should have to beat you to death with it because it is empty.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #32 on: February 05, 2015, 09:19:03 PM »
Medicine is a "weird science"

No nurse or doctor for that matter can tell you with any certainty who could have survived any wound if they transported the patient back in time 5 years.

Every single day someone is diagnosed with a "death sentence" and are proven wrong.

Conversely, patients are diagnosed/misdiagnosed with a simple affliction, only to end up with a much more serious ailment or even death.

People have fallen out of airplanes and lived.

People have fallen down off a chair and died.

NO nurse can tell you definitively what would have happened 5 years ago.

That's just the reality.

Hemostatic agents appear to have been invented around 2002. That is definitely a technology that can do things that couldn't be done a decade ago.

mauidog

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #33 on: February 05, 2015, 09:28:09 PM »
Hemostatic agents appear to have been invented around 2002. That is definitely a technology that can do things that couldn't be done a decade ago.

Quote
Topical hemostatic agents in the modern surgical era can be traced to 1909, when Bergel first discussed the use of topical fibrin for hemostasis.[5]
This evolved into a class of preparations known as fibrin sealants. Early fibrin sealants combined bovine thrombin with human plasma for topical application.[6]
Widespread surgical usage was initially limited, but in 1938 purified thrombin became available through advancements in the technology of protein separation.[7]
That technology accelerated research and development of fibrin sealants, and reports of apparently successful usage of such agents began to appear in the
surgical literature in the 1940s. Young and Medawar reported the use of fibrin sealant to repair peripheral nerves in 1940.[8] In 1944, Cronkite et al. reported the
usage of combined fibrinogen and thrombin in improving skin graft survival and adhesion in the grafting of soldiers with severe burn injuries.[9]

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2978438/
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

HiCarry

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #34 on: February 06, 2015, 09:36:05 AM »
Medicine is a "weird science"

No nurse or doctor for that matter can tell you with any certainty who could have survived any wound if they transported the patient back in time 5 years.

Every single day someone is diagnosed with a "death sentence" and are proven wrong.

Conversely, patients are diagnosed/misdiagnosed with a simple affliction, only to end up with a much more serious ailment or even death.

People have fallen out of airplanes and lived.

People have fallen down off a chair and died.

NO nurse can tell you definitively what would have happened 5 years ago.

That's just the reality.


Sorry, you're wrong again. While you are right that sometimes things don't go as expected in medicine, sometimes relatively minor problems end up killing people and sometimes people survive horrific insults that no one expected them to survive. However, medicine has for years made just the types of statements we are discussing. Can any provider say with absolute certainty that someone with a medical condition would not have survived 5 years ago? No, they cannot. Can they make an educated prediction based on relevant statistics and survival rates 5 years ago compared to today and come to a generally accepted conclusion? Yes, and it happens all the time and the practice is nearly ubiquitous in the medical field.

Bota-CS1

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #35 on: February 06, 2015, 01:11:28 PM »
I have the feeling anti-gunners are peddling this bullshit to support their case against CCW, because they know they are fighting a losing cause.
:stopjack:
I would agree.  No citation of where this information is coming from or what statistics are being used.  Funny how some of the states that have open carry aren't in the top 1/2 (i.e. Texas).  And how the hell does Illinois end up at #40?  I got a few friends who live in Chi-Raq as they call it and even they think that #40 is laughable.  :wtf:
No one is coming, it’s up to us.

Legislation should never be about depriving law abiding citizens of something, but rather taking those things away from criminals.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #36 on: February 07, 2015, 09:43:00 PM »
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2978438/

I see, I guess the history I was looking at was of the modern agents like quick-clot.

mauidog

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #37 on: February 08, 2015, 12:18:58 AM »
I see, I guess the history I was looking at was of the modern agents like quick-clot.

When you base opinions on Googled information that turns out to be erroneous,  you should also revisit your conclusions so we can discuss how they are/are not valid given the real facts.

The first step toward recovery is admitting you have a problem!   >:D
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

eyeeatingfish

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #38 on: February 09, 2015, 12:15:56 PM »
When you base opinions on Googled information that turns out to be erroneous,  you should also revisit your conclusions so we can discuss how they are/are not valid given the real facts.

The first step toward recovery is admitting you have a problem!   >:D

I cannot find an exact date but the use of chitosan which is the main ingredient in products like quick clot comes from the late 1990s-early 2000s I found research reports testing them in the early 2000s.

Kingkeoni

Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« Reply #39 on: February 12, 2015, 08:47:33 PM »
Sorry, you're wrong again.


Can any provider say with absolute certainty that someone with a medical condition would not have survived 5 years ago? No, they cannot.

So in 1 breath you say I'm wrong.

In your next breath you admit to my statement being right.

Sometimes arguing just to argue is counterproductive.

 :closed:
Your number one Option for Personal Security is a lifelong commitment to avoidance, deterrence, and de-escalation.

Someday someone may kill you with your own gun, but they should have to beat you to death with it because it is empty.