If you noticed that I try to steer this topic towards individuals preps then your absolutely right. Its not that a community based or group based set up is a bad idea, its not, but realistically its a bad idea. People tend to become possessive and discriminatory, sometimes downright cut throat, especially in positions of power or even if they feel they just work harder or come to more meetings than you. And that's just in the good times, I can imagine what kind of inner group bickering will occur shtf. Also, even though you went to each others homes to plant gardens, doesn't mean the gardens won't go to weeds from mismanagement. Its my experience that people tend to depend on others way to much, and if shtf these people will be expecting way too much.
In any event, you can really only count on your self, because even family and close friends will have different ideas and feelings that have to be considered. That's why individual preps are the backbone of survival. On these islands, at least a two month supply of food and water per person, with a basic medical kit and some basic hand tools. After you achieve this, then go looking for motivated, self reliant, and prepared individuals. Exchange ideas, form a friendship, build a loose network, but do not expect anything in return or you'll be sorely disappointed. That's just how people are.
Edit: Is this group sponsored by a church or charity? Is the community garden on public or private property?