72 yo shoots man.. ? (Read 10245 times)

asinapple8805

Re: 72 yo shoots man.. ?
« Reply #20 on: March 09, 2016, 07:28:26 PM »
(b)  The actor knows that he can avoid the necessity of using such force with complete safety by retreating or by surrendering possession of a thing to a person asserting a claim of right thereto or by complying with a demand that he abstain from any action which he has no duty to take

Interesting that the lawmakers chose to require that a person have "knowledge" that retreating would result in "complete safety". Often the language is along the lines of "reasonable belief" or "when a reasonable person would conclude", etc. Defense attorney to client on the stand: "When you saw the deceased walking up your driveway carrying a baseball bat and shouting threats to kill you, did you KNOW that you could have retreated in complete safety?" Client on stand: "No." Defense attorney: "Your honor, I rest my case."

Of course it's not really that simple, but a jury might be inclined to see it as self-defense even if the requirement were "reasonable belief or conclusion". Another factor might be whether either party had prior arrests/convictions, especially for violent acts or threats.

I suppose that the prosecutor could claim that the defendant could have "compl[ied] with a demand that he abstain from any action" by simply saying "Okay, I won't f*ck your former girlfriend any more." Would the guy with the bat simply have stopped, said "thanks", turned around, and headed home?

The above quoted section of the HRS is actually part of the Model Penal Code, which Hawaii has mostly adopted.

eyeeatingfish

Re: 72 yo shoots man.. ?
« Reply #21 on: March 10, 2016, 02:40:53 AM »
"Edwards was arrested Monday night on suspicion of second-degree murder and was being held pending further investigation by detectives. He had not been charged as of late Tuesday afternoon."

I could never understand being held without charges. ???
If you're not charged with a crime, why or how can you be held ?  :crazy:
What happened to innocent until proven guilty ?  :grrr:

It has to do with processing the whole crime. An officer might have probable cause to arrest you for something but not the level of proof that a prosecutor needs for a criminal case. So rather than just let them go they can hold them for a reasonable amount of time in order to put everything together. They have to be charged within 48 hours. If you had to have proof beyond a reasonable doubt to arrest, the guy might dig out before you could solve anything.