Psychoactive Substances Act (with exemptions for alcohol, caffeine and tobacco) (Read 17684 times)

Inspector

What if the government decided one day to ban orange trees but allow apple trees?
You get prohibition.
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

punaperson

What if the government decided one day to ban orange trees but allow apple trees?
Yeah, but you're comparing apples and oranges... DOH! Good one!

punaperson

You get prohibition.
Which brings us back to the point of this post. Governments decide to ban/criminalize certain substances claiming that the rationale is that they are harmful to both individuals who use them and to the surrounding community, yet they irrationally exempt some substances which are unquestionably demonstrably more harmful (in the UK law cited, alcohol and tobacco), thus putting the lie to their purported rationale. Half the people who use tobacco will die, usually sooner rather than later, from a disease caused by their use of tobacco, at great expense to taxpayers/medical insurance rate-payers who will subsidize their medical care. Approximately 10,000 people per year are killed, and nearly 300,000 are injured due to drunk driving, at an annual cost in the U.S. of $132 BILLION. Thus the governments, the bureaucrats, and the politicians who create and enforce the laws often have single digit "approval" ratings in public opinion polls because people know they (frequently) lie and and do things out of some kind of self-interest and not according to their espoused rationale of "public safety" or "the public good". Arbitrary and capricious laws (whether it be regarding which substances are legal and which illegal, or which capacity magazines are legal or illegal, etc.) undermine the very foundation of governing. Thus, we see where we are.

punaperson

Here's a fairly brief article from Scientific American regarding the "conflict" between the political moves and the scientific evidence regarding cannabis. It affirms the view above that legislative and executive branches and their agencies are obstructionist regarding the truth, and often intentionally so.

www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-science-behind-the-dea-s-long-war-on-marijuana/

The Science behind the DEA's Long War on Marijuana
Experts say listing cannabis among the world’s deadliest drugs ignores decades of scientific and medical data. But attempts to delist it have met with decades of bureaucratic inertia and political distortion

A couple of choice tidbit excerpts:

The American Medical Association initially opposed prohibition. Cannabis was medically useful, says William Woodward, association counsel. “Congress being what it was at the time, you could ram things through just by bullshitting,” Lee adds. “Who’s going to be stepping up to the plate [in 1937] to defend a drug that blacks, Latinos and jazz musicians use?”
* * * *
Marijuana was placed in Schedule I in 1971 provisionally, until the science could be assessed. But Pres. Richard Nixon saw pot prohibition as a way to destroy the antiwar left, according to clandestine recordings made by Nixon in the White House as well as statements from his staff to the press. Nixon convened The National Commission on Marihuana and Drug Abuse (what became known as the Shafer Commission) to engineer scientific support for cannabis’s Schedule I placement. “I want a goddamn strong statement on marijuana,” Nixon said in tapes from 1971. “Can I get that out of this sonofabitching, uh, domestic council? … I mean one on marijuana that just tears the ass out of them.” [You gotta love those Nixon tapes!]

The Shafer Commission found in 1972 that cannabis was as safe as alcohol, and recommended ending prohibition in favor of a public health approach. But by then the Federal Bureau of Narcotics had been removed from the Treasury Department and merged into the U.S. Department of Justice—where Nixon’s ally, Attorney General John Mitchell, placed cannabis in Schedule I in 1972; that same year he resigned to head Nixon’s re-election committee. (He later stood trial in 1974 over the Watergate scandal and served 19 months of a prison sentence for conspiracy, perjury and obstruction of justice.) “You want to know what this was really all about?” Nixon aid John Ehrlichman told journalist Dan Baum in 1994, according to an article published in Harper’s Magazine in 2016. “The Nixon campaign in 1968, and the Nixon White House after that, had two enemies: the antiwar left and black people. You understand what I’m saying? We knew we couldn’t make it illegal to be either against the war or black, but by getting the public to associate the hippies with marijuana and blacks with heroin, and then criminalizing both heavily, we could disrupt those communities. We could arrest their leaders, raid their homes, break up their meetings and vilify them night after night on the evening news. Did we know we were lying about the drugs? Of course we did.” [Emphasis added][How can anyone be surprised that people don't trust the people who are "the government"?]
* * * *
The FDA and Health and Human Services have given the DEA new rescheduling recommendations, but Baer would not say what they are. A potential change in scheduling could happen by summer, according to an interagency memo sent to eight lawmakers earlier this month. Marijuana’s Schedule I status “really is a national embarrassment,” Lee says. “It gives new meaning to the phrase, ‘the big lie’. It’s like saying, ‘The moon is made of green cheese.’ That this could remain until the present day is laughable only in that it keeps you from crying.”

eyeeatingfish

I don't agree. Just because other drugs do "...a lot more damage way faster than alcohol tends to." It's like saying taking weaker amounts of heroin is better than taking strong amounts. So it takes longer to see the final outcome of taking heroin. It just doesn't make any sense. And it doesn't make alcohol any less bad. It is still addicting, it is still damaging, and people still do bad things while intoxicated. Bottom line is that there is no difference between the outcome of the effects of alcohol and any other the other drugs mentioned. JMHO

Yes alcohol is addicting and damaging and can ultimately lead to death, but isn't it worth noting that some drugs are more addictive and damage more quickly and at higher rates? I generally agree that if you want to risk your own life then go ahead but I think there is a line I would draw when it comes to legal and illegal drugs. I don't know where I would draw the line exactly but I do think that some drugs are dangerous enough to warrant regulation.

Rocky

You could absolutely make that argument for alcohol vs marijuana but with some of the hard drugs out there it ends up being apples and oranges. Some drugs do a lot more damage way faster than alcohol tends to.

As for marijuana, the facts almost dictate that if alcohol should be legal then weed should be legal. Marijuana is arguably quite a bit less worse than alcohol in so many ways. There are of course cultural and historical reasons why one is legal and the other is not but I think based on logic alone I absolutely agree, you cannot justify alcohol being legal and marijuana not.


Marywanna was outlawed by the ATF and the alcohol industry because it was a cheaper and better high and folks were turning to pot instead of booze. :wacko:
(See "Marywanna smoking blacks rape white women" ).

   History ( and again, the ATF among others) later gave us the old 'Saturday Night Special" conspiracy. O0
Do your homework.  :geekdanc:
“I ask you to judge me by the enemies I have made.”
                                                           Franklin D. Roosevelt

Inspector

Yes alcohol is addicting and damaging and can ultimately lead to death, but isn't it worth noting that some drugs are more addictive and damage more quickly and at higher rates?

I don't think it is worth noting. As a matter of fact I think we should not say that at all. I'll tell you why. Because this world is filled full of idiots. That is a reality that even you can't deny nor question. LOL And they will take this information and believe that it will be okay to take the drugs that take longer to do damage because they believe they are invincible. Some will even believe that it won't affect them at all even 40-50 years from now. Some will just say I'll deal with it when the time comes. Once you start drawing the line saying alcohol is okay because it takes more and it takes longer to get addicted and it takes longer to ruin your life and your families lives then people will prefer that drug over others. Proof? Look at what we have now in our society. Can't deny the reality of life no matter how you feel. Do you really want to be that person that tells your children, your wife, your family, your ohana that it is okay to drink because it takes longer to get addicted? And then it takes longer to do damage to their body. And it takes long to do damage to their families lives as well? Isn't that what you are saying when you draw the line at alcohol being okay but everything else no? People are not willing to say that alcohol is just as bad if not worse than the other drugs. That is the real shame.

It is debatable using the term "more addictive" because it demonizes the drugs that are highly addictive. Compared to alcohol where it takes a huge amount of consumption over a longer period of time. And people can partake regularly and not become addicted. Alcohol is not more or less addictive. Once you are addicted how can you say that alcohol is less so? Fact is you cannot. Addiction is addiction no matter the drug. So don't play down the fact that alcohol is not as highly addictive as the other drugs. It is addictive just like the other drugs. And since it is addictive and can ruin peoples lives, families lives and society are you saying it is okay to go ahead and drink? Look at what happens in our society now? We say it is okay to drink. But just don't drink too much. Then we tell them how much is too much. And what do they do? They drink too much anyway! You are never going to stop this. But if you treat it the same as the other drugs you at least are not sending the message that alcohol is better than the others. Because, once again, the world is fill full of idiots that will take that message that it is okay to drink, get drunk and then will go out and hurt/kill someone. Not trying to be insulting here, but you seem to me the type of person that prefers to blame society and circumstances for the problems we currently have. So you yourself should totally understand about sending the wrong message.

I generally agree that if you want to risk your own life then go ahead but I think there is a line I would draw when it comes to legal and illegal drugs. I don't know where I would draw the line exactly but I do think that some drugs are dangerous enough to warrant regulation.

Too bad you are not willing to take a stand on this issue. I believe that this is part of the problem in our current society. The majority of people are not willing to take a stand one way or another. Or worse, they are taking a stand that is hypocritical. JMHO
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

eyeeatingfish


Marywanna was outlawed by the ATF and the alcohol industry because it was a cheaper and better high and folks were turning to pot instead of booze. :wacko:
(See "Marywanna smoking blacks rape white women" ).

   History ( and again, the ATF among others) later gave us the old 'Saturday Night Special" conspiracy. O0
Do your homework.  :geekdanc:

Do my homework? I wasn't in disagreement that marijuana should be legal from a logical point of view.

eyeeatingfish

I don't think it is worth noting. As a matter of fact I think we should not say that at all. I'll tell you why. Because this world is filled full of idiots. That is a reality that even you can't deny nor question. LOL And they will take this information and believe that it will be okay to take the drugs that take longer to do damage because they believe they are invincible. Some will even believe that it won't affect them at all even 40-50 years from now. Some will just say I'll deal with it when the time comes. Once you start drawing the line saying alcohol is okay because it takes more and it takes longer to get addicted and it takes longer to ruin your life and your families lives then people will prefer that drug over others. Proof? Look at what we have now in our society. Can't deny the reality of life no matter how you feel. Do you really want to be that person that tells your children, your wife, your family, your ohana that it is okay to drink because it takes longer to get addicted? And then it takes longer to do damage to their body. And it takes long to do damage to their families lives as well? Isn't that what you are saying when you draw the line at alcohol being okay but everything else no? People are not willing to say that alcohol is just as bad if not worse than the other drugs. That is the real shame.

It is debatable using the term "more addictive" because it demonizes the drugs that are highly addictive. Compared to alcohol where it takes a huge amount of consumption over a longer period of time. And people can partake regularly and not become addicted. Alcohol is not more or less addictive. Once you are addicted how can you say that alcohol is less so? Fact is you cannot. Addiction is addiction no matter the drug. So don't play down the fact that alcohol is not as highly addictive as the other drugs. It is addictive just like the other drugs. And since it is addictive and can ruin peoples lives, families lives and society are you saying it is okay to go ahead and drink? Look at what happens in our society now? We say it is okay to drink. But just don't drink too much. Then we tell them how much is too much. And what do they do? They drink too much anyway! You are never going to stop this. But if you treat it the same as the other drugs you at least are not sending the message that alcohol is better than the others. Because, once again, the world is fill full of idiots that will take that message that it is okay to drink, get drunk and then will go out and hurt/kill someone. Not trying to be insulting here, but you seem to me the type of person that prefers to blame society and circumstances for the problems we currently have. So you yourself should totally understand about sending the wrong message.

Too bad you are not willing to take a stand on this issue. I believe that this is part of the problem in our current society. The majority of people are not willing to take a stand one way or another. Or worse, they are taking a stand that is hypocritical. JMHO

I am willing to take a stand, I just said I don't know exactly where to draw the line. I would put alcohol and marijuana on the legal side, I would leave crystal meth and certain others on the illegal side. There are hundreds of substances people abuse and I am not an expert in them all, thus I cannot tell you exactly where I would draw the line.

And yes you can measure how addictive a substance is. You can measure the rates of how many people become addicted after how many doses. You can measure how difficult it is for someone to break that addiction by measuring relapse data. Of course when it comes down to the individual you cannot say it will be absolutely be one way or the other, but as a whole you can measure drug use and compare addiction effects from one to another. You can say that people are more likely to become addicted to one drug over another.
Here is a chart that compares some drugs as an example. Notice the difference in dependance among the drugs mentioned. http://www.drugwarfacts.org/cms/Addictive_Properties#sthash.rd0JLoj7.dpbs

You are correct, alcohol is a drug. People don't like to think of it that way though as it is more difficult to justify their drug use in that light. And it is a shame, society accepts drinking as normal and almost healthy.  On this own forum we had a few threads where people discussed their favorite alcoholic beverages. No one painted it as drug use and I myself took part in the discussion. I admit, I occasionally partake in drug use of the alcohol type. I regularly partake in drug use of the caffeine type!

And you are right about the world being filled with idiots. If they want to kill themselves with risky behavior then so be it, but the problem is that too often drug use affects other people. Families get torn apart but we also get our stuff stolen so addicts can feed their habit. That is where I begin to start drawing the line. If a drug has a very high rate of addiction and is associated with a high level of crime (separate from the use itself) then I start thinking it should be regulated.

Inspector

I am willing to take a stand, I just said I don't know exactly where to draw the line. I would put alcohol and marijuana on the legal side, I would leave crystal meth and certain others on the illegal side. There are hundreds of substances people abuse and I am not an expert in them all, thus I cannot tell you exactly where I would draw the line.

Well, let's not get into the "...hundreds of substances people abuse..." as no one is an expert in them all IMHO. Since you are taking a stand on alcohol and marijuana then I would appreciate your answers to the questions I asked previously that you just glossed over:

1. Do you really want to be that person that tells your children, your wife, your family, your ohana that it is okay to do the drug called alcohol because it takes longer to get addicted, and that it takes longer to do damage to their body, and that it takes longer to do damage to their families lives?
2. Isn't what you are saying is that it is okay to take an addicting drug called alcohol when you draw the line at the drug called alcohol being okay but everything else no?
3. And since the drug called alcohol is addictive and can ruin peoples lives, families lives and society are you saying to your children it is okay to go ahead and take the drug called alcohol?
4. So now you are saying it is okay to tell your children it is okay to take the drug called alcohol, just don't take too much?

And yes you can measure how addictive a substance is. You can measure the rates of how many people become addicted after how many doses. You can measure how difficult it is for someone to break that addiction by measuring relapse data. Of course when it comes down to the individual you cannot say it will be absolutely be one way or the other, but as a whole you can measure drug use and compare addiction effects from one to another. You can say that people are more likely to become addicted to one drug over another.
Here is a chart that compares some drugs as an example. Notice the difference in dependance among the drugs mentioned. http://www.drugwarfacts.org/cms/Addictive_Properties#sthash.rd0JLoj7.dpbs

That was not what I was getting at but the info you provided was interesting nonetheless. I was not saying that you can't measure how addictive a drug is. Nor what I was saying is that all drugs are equally addicting. What I was saying is that it is a dangerous game one (you?) plays when one says to their children it is okay to take this drug (alcohol) but not okay to take this drug (insert whatever here) because the drug called alcohol is not as addicting. I just don't know how someone can justify telling their children it is okay to take a dangerous addicting drug like alcohol? So here is another question I'll ask:

5. How do you justify telling your children that it is okay to take a dangerous addicting drug like alcohol?

You are correct, alcohol is a drug.

I am glad we agree on this.

People don't like to think of it that way though as it is more difficult to justify their drug use in that light. And it is a shame, society accepts drinking as normal and almost healthy. On this own forum we had a few threads where people discussed their favorite alcoholic beverages. No one painted it as drug use and I myself took part in the discussion. I admit, I occasionally partake in drug use of the alcohol type. I regularly partake in drug use of the caffeine type!

I regularly partake of caffeine and readily admit I am addicted. As far as the drug called alcohol is concerned I do partake infrequently. I usually have one 22oz porter, stout or ale on a Friday. But not every Friday. So I would guess I have 2 or 3 a month. And there are some months I don't have any.

And you are right about the world being filled with idiots. If they want to kill themselves with risky behavior then so be it, but the problem is that too often drug use affects other people. Families get torn apart but we also get our stuff stolen so addicts can feed their habit. That is where I begin to start drawing the line. If a drug has a very high rate of addiction and is associated with a high level of crime (separate from the use itself) then I start thinking it should be regulated.

This is where I agree to disagree. Usually, friends and families know at the beginning when there is a problem. Long before the families get torn apart. Long before stuff gets stolen. The families usually turn a blind eye to the problem. If they have the courage and the tools to deal with what I'll coin as pre-addiction (for lack of a better term) I would guess that we could nip a lot of this behavior in the bud. JMHO
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

eyeeatingfish

Well, let's not get into the "...hundreds of substances people abuse..." as no one is an expert in them all IMHO. Since you are taking a stand on alcohol and marijuana then I would appreciate your answers to the questions I asked previously that you just glossed over:

1. Do you really want to be that person that tells your children, your wife, your family, your ohana that it is okay to do the drug called alcohol because it takes longer to get addicted, and that it takes longer to do damage to their body, and that it takes longer to do damage to their families lives?
2. Isn't what you are saying is that it is okay to take an addicting drug called alcohol when you draw the line at the drug called alcohol being okay but everything else no?
3. And since the drug called alcohol is addictive and can ruin peoples lives, families lives and society are you saying to your children it is okay to go ahead and take the drug called alcohol?
4. So now you are saying it is okay to tell your children it is okay to take the drug called alcohol, just don't take too much?

That was not what I was getting at but the info you provided was interesting nonetheless. I was not saying that you can't measure how addictive a drug is. Nor what I was saying is that all drugs are equally addicting. What I was saying is that it is a dangerous game one (you?) plays when one says to their children it is okay to take this drug (alcohol) but not okay to take this drug (insert whatever here) because the drug called alcohol is not as addicting. I just don't know how someone can justify telling their children it is okay to take a dangerous addicting drug like alcohol? So here is another question I'll ask:

5. How do you justify telling your children that it is okay to take a dangerous addicting drug like alcohol?

I regularly partake of caffeine and readily admit I am addicted. As far as the drug called alcohol is concerned I do partake infrequently. I usually have one 22oz porter, stout or ale on a Friday. But not every Friday. So I would guess I have 2 or 3 a month. And there are some months I don't have any.

This is where I agree to disagree. Usually, friends and families know at the beginning when there is a problem. Long before the families get torn apart. Long before stuff gets stolen. The families usually turn a blind eye to the problem. If they have the courage and the tools to deal with what I'll coin as pre-addiction (for lack of a better term) I would guess that we could nip a lot of this behavior in the bud. JMHO

Legality goes beyond just whether we can justify it to our children. Enforceability also comes into play here. Alcohol and marijuana are relatively easy to produce and the prohibition tells us that efforts to legally ban alcohol were not very effective. Risk to the individual vs risk to society can also be taken into account.

So how do you justify to your children your occasional use of alcohol?

When my kids are old enough, I would explain to them alcohol. Why people like it and all the dangers. When it comes to crystal meth I would educate them and advise them to never try it. I have heard it said that a single use of meth is enough to get someone addicted.

I am making up numbers here but if hypothetically 95% of people who try meth get addicted but only 5% of people who try alcohol get addicted then I think you can explain why one is ok to try occasionally while the other is not.

Inspector

Well, you are purposely ignoring my questions again. I ask them because they are difficult and I want to know how you would answer them. Two people cannot have a two way conversation when one person purposely ignores what the other says. I thought you and I were going to have a decent conversation here. But I see you have not changed. This thread between us is done.  :wtf: :wtf: :wtf:

SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

eyeeatingfish

Well, you are purposely ignoring my questions again. I ask them because they are difficult and I want to know how you would answer them. Two people cannot have a two way conversation when one person purposely ignores what the other says. I thought you and I were going to have a decent conversation here. But I see you have not changed. This thread between us is done.  :wtf: :wtf: :wtf:

I thought I did answer your question. I said how I would explain it to my children and family.

punaperson

I thought I did answer your question. I said how I would explain it to my children and family.
You expect us to believe that your frequently used strategies of avoiding answering questions posed to you and diverting to other topics is news to you? You did the exact same thing two days ago in the thread about your (former) police officer friend who bruised and arrested the two women who had the gall to ignore his unlawful "order" to stop kissing in a store. Oh, by the way, I'm still waiting for your answer as to why your claimed-innocent friend allowed himself to be railroaded by the government lawyers, HPD, the city council or whoever to acquiesce to a settlement rather than clear his name by demanding that all the evidence gathered by all parties' investigations (eyewitness employees, store patrons, surveillance video, etc.) be released to the public. Let me guess: You thought you did, right?  :stopjack:

eyeeatingfish

You expect us to believe that your frequently used strategies of avoiding answering questions posed to you and diverting to other topics is news to you? You did the exact same thing two days ago in the thread about your (former) police officer friend who bruised and arrested the two women who had the gall to ignore his unlawful "order" to stop kissing in a store. Oh, by the way, I'm still waiting for your answer as to why your claimed-innocent friend allowed himself to be railroaded by the government lawyers, HPD, the city council or whoever to acquiesce to a settlement rather than clear his name by demanding that all the evidence gathered by all parties' investigations (eyewitness employees, store patrons, surveillance video, etc.) be released to the public. Let me guess: You thought you did, right?  :stopjack:

Trolling a bit? ;) I stopped bothering with the other tread as you clearly misrepresented my position and seemed more interested in a personal attack than the issue. I am not going to derail this thread for that.

I am not avoiding the question. I thought I had answered the question but you and inspector apparently feel I did not. As you can see I stated that I thought I answered the question. If I were avoiding the question, I would not have replied. Rather I want to know why inspector was not satisfied with my answer that way I can give him a complete one.
« Last Edit: May 29, 2016, 11:35:03 PM by eyeeatingfish »

punaperson

Trolling a bit? ;) I stopped bothering with the other tread as you clearly misrepresented my position and seemed more interested in a personal attack than the issue. I am not going to derail this thread for that.
In other words, you don't answer questions posed to you if you believe the questions themselves "misrepresent" your "position". Yeah, that makes sense. I shoulda figured.

eyeeatingfish

In other words, you don't answer questions posed to you if you believe the questions themselves "misrepresent" your "position". Yeah, that makes sense. I shoulda figured.

You knowingly misrepresented what I had said, you are trolling and I am not going down that road. If you want to debate the drug issue then feel free, otherwise I won't entertain your attacks about irrelevant issues.

I am clearly willing to answer inspector's questions, I just don't know what part he felt was unanswered.