I'm not sure where you get that frangible is supposed to stay intact... that is just well - improper. It's designed to break part anytime it hits *anything* harder than the bullet itself. So your little extraction from the end of the HRS, doesn't seem to hold much weight when talking about "its target."
Thank you, Funtimes... I misstated a portion of my previous post and failed to state a basic assumption that, when talking about true "targets," I assumed the term, "targets" to mean targets made out of paper.
In my previous post I stated, "As King Keoni pointed out, frangible ammunition is designed and intended to remain intact when it impacts the frangible round's true 'target.'"
What I should have said is that, "frangible ammunition will REMAIN intact when it impacts the frangible round's true 'target,' assuming that the shooter's true 'target' is a target made out of paper."
Thank you for catching that.
Frangibles reduce over penetration issues because they break apart into nothingness when they impact their target or a backstop. If we were using steel plates, they would hit the plate. If you hit a person with it, it's going to break off into that person.
I respectfully disagree with your statement that, "If you hit a person with it (I assume you mean a frangible round), it's going to break off into that person." But then again, I understand that there are different levels of frangible ammunition, so this might actually occur...
If you hit paper, well that is not harder than the bullet, and it's going to pass through until it hits something of more substance.
I agree with this statement.
There is a pretty substantial flaw in your argument dubya. What if my target is a steel wall?Is my frangible round not going to segment? And, it will only break into fragments when it hits a wood wall, that is behind my steel one?
Good point. I should have again stated that I assumed that most shooters will be shooting at a true "target," which consists of a target made out of paper.
If your target is a steel wall, or a steel target, I concede that when your frangible round impacts the steel wall, or steel target, it will most certainly segment, fragment, break apart, etc., as it was designed and intended to do, and you may find yourself in violation of Haw. Rev. Stat. 134-8.
Also, fragment and segment are synonyms.
Depending upon the context, and in certain circumstances, I agree that the words "fragment" and "segment" can be synonyms. However, in other circumstances, the words, "fragment" and "segment" may serve as imperfect synonyms, or may not be suitable synonyms, at all. Again, I would argue that it depends on the context and circumstances.
The only real way to solve this is to go pull the legislative history of when it was enacted to see what they were talking about.
Yes, this would be helpful, though I cannot guarantee that even pulling the legislative history will provide full clarification of this matter.
Thank you, I enjoyed this conversation!
Best regards,
dubya
*** Caveat ***
This post is not intended to serve as, nor should this post be construed as, legal advice.