Subcompact (micro, slimline, etc) Pistols - Experiences & Recommendations (Read 13426 times)

drck1000

Re: Subcompact (micro, slimline, etc) Pistols - Experiences & Recommendations
« Reply #40 on: December 24, 2024, 10:33:07 AM »
focus

"issues with magwells with the 43x/48 is pretty common."
:facepalm:

drck1000

Re: Subcompact (micro, slimline, etc) Pistols - Experiences & Recommendations
« Reply #41 on: December 24, 2024, 10:41:28 AM »
Would you carry the G48?  I ask cause with a ported barrel, one has to be aware of the gasses coming out. So if on your back and the handgun is close to you in an awkward position, you can harm yourself.  Or if your hand is holding on to your slide, etc...
I have a stock 48 slide as well. I’d carry that no worries. For ported? Not my preference, but I’m not that worried about jacket separation. I’ve tested a different gun with ported barrel and the ports are smaller (but more of them) and specifically designed to mitigate the jacket separation. You get some hot gasses and some carbon flakes, but haven’t seen jacket material. I haven’t tested with the 48 though.

Only recently got into ported pistols. Not intended for CCW, for now. Though I know a few who do carry ported pistols. Some aftermarket and some like S&W.

Many worry about the fireball effect from the ports. I’ve noticed when shooting indoors, but can’t say if it would “ruin” vision in low light. Though I think the risks are exaggerated.

zippz

Re: Subcompact (micro, slimline, etc) Pistols - Experiences & Recommendations
« Reply #42 on: December 24, 2024, 12:58:46 PM »
If anybody on Maui can shoot a LCP or similar halfway decent then I'd love to have you show me. I bought an LCP Max that turns me straight into Barney Fife when I hold it. Straight up menace, I'm seriously starting to think it's defective. I even got the Mantis dryfire training aids, they say my grip is great and the laser always hits where I aim it, but with live ammo I can't even tell where all the bullets go.

Just going off the dimensions and heavy trigger on a LCP Max ...

Max range for most shooters on that gun would be 3 to 7 yards for quick defensive shots into the vitals of a silhouette.  Maybe 10 yards for an experienced shooter.  It's a small gun so its going to be difficult to shoot even for experienced shooters.  Also the recoil is harsh on that gun so it will be different between dry and live fire.

To get better, buy 10 of these snap caps.  https://www.amazon.com/Action-Trainers-Orange-Rounds-ACP/dp/B00GD2I6K0

At the range, load live and dummy rounds randomly into 2 magazines, then randomize the magazines, load, and fire.  When you press the trigger on a dummy the sights shouldn't move.  Do a quick tap rack for misfire drill practice and continue.  Also do it from the draw...draw and fire 1, draw and fire 2, draw and fire 3 rounds and repeat.  Do that with 6 magazines for each range session, about 60 trigger pulls.  Do that for 3 range sessions for 180 trigger pulls worth. 

You should be significantly better and accurate.



« Last Edit: December 24, 2024, 07:56:45 PM by zippz »

changemyoil66

Re: Subcompact (micro, slimline, etc) Pistols - Experiences & Recommendations
« Reply #43 on: December 26, 2024, 11:20:15 AM »
I have a stock 48 slide as well. I’d carry that no worries. For ported? Not my preference, but I’m not that worried about jacket separation. I’ve tested a different gun with ported barrel and the ports are smaller (but more of them) and specifically designed to mitigate the jacket separation. You get some hot gasses and some carbon flakes, but haven’t seen jacket material. I haven’t tested with the 48 though.

Only recently got into ported pistols. Not intended for CCW, for now. Though I know a few who do carry ported pistols. Some aftermarket and some like S&W.

Many worry about the fireball effect from the ports. I’ve noticed when shooting indoors, but can’t say if it would “ruin” vision in low light. Though I think the risks are exaggerated.

Next open shoot, lets do a port test. Hold a paper above it and see what happens.  In the filming of the film DOOM, they had their firearm trainer explain that even though blanks are used, the gases will cause damage if the rifle is shot close enough to someone.  He shot a styrofoam maniquene head to show the blast effect.  IDK if this was a "plugged" barrel that hollywood uses or a non-plugged one, but he got his point across.

drck1000

Re: Subcompact (micro, slimline, etc) Pistols - Experiences & Recommendations
« Reply #44 on: December 26, 2024, 11:44:37 AM »
Next open shoot, lets do a port test. Hold a paper above it and see what happens.  In the filming of the film DOOM, they had their firearm trainer explain that even though blanks are used, the gases will cause damage if the rifle is shot close enough to someone.  He shot a styrofoam maniquene head to show the blast effect.  IDK if this was a "plugged" barrel that hollywood uses or a non-plugged one, but he got his point across.
As styrofoam what?  :rofl:

I know what you meant, but will see if Mr Tourette’s comments…

The gasses will rip paper. When I test, I’m looking to differentiate between gasses, carbon flakes, and jacket material. Not saying the gasses can’t hurt or even break skin, just different. I’ve read some folks test on fruit. I’ve tested with leftover ballistic gel on another gun, but not with the 48 ported slide.

changemyoil66

Re: Subcompact (micro, slimline, etc) Pistols - Experiences & Recommendations
« Reply #45 on: December 30, 2024, 09:09:55 AM »
As styrofoam what?  :rofl:

I know what you meant, but will see if Mr Tourette’s comments…

The gasses will rip paper. When I test, I’m looking to differentiate between gasses, carbon flakes, and jacket material. Not saying the gasses can’t hurt or even break skin, just different. I’ve read some folks test on fruit. I’ve tested with leftover ballistic gel on another gun, but not with the 48 ported slide.

cttsolutionsllc's wife (IG post) just showed a vid between her shooting a G43X without port and then another one with port. The recoil difference is HUGE.  She's like 5'1; 115lbs.

Although the gas goes up, I wonder if you were to fire from the hip how it would be. Like any injury for the area next to the slide?  Or to your face cause the gas is going up like 6 inches (fireball).

drck1000

Re: Subcompact (micro, slimline, etc) Pistols - Experiences & Recommendations
« Reply #46 on: December 30, 2024, 09:55:20 AM »
cttsolutionsllc's wife (IG post) just showed a vid between her shooting a G43X without port and then another one with port. The recoil difference is HUGE.  She's like 5'1; 115lbs.

Although the gas goes up, I wonder if you were to fire from the hip how it would be. Like any injury for the area next to the slide?  Or to your face cause the gas is going up like 6 inches (fireball).
Ya. He (Pannone) does a lot of testing with the micro pistols. I was chatting with him via DM a while back when I started shooting my 43x/48 more. I was thinking of trying to attend one of his deep concealment courses, but timing wasn’t working out.

I understand your concern and/or thought. I did some testing of my own, but not that “direct”… yet.  A couple of ways to think about it is when needed, what is more important?  Individual choice, as well as adapting techniques all come into play.

As for fireball, for my ported 48 it depends on the ammo. For one of my ported 17 slides, I don’t really notice. Tho my ported 17 slide the ports are angled slightly outward (not vertical), whereas the ports on the 48 are vertical. I have another 17 with ports that I won recently which has vertical ports, but haven’t shot it yet.

changemyoil66

Re: Subcompact (micro, slimline, etc) Pistols - Experiences & Recommendations
« Reply #47 on: December 30, 2024, 11:32:43 AM »
Ya. He (Pannone) does a lot of testing with the micro pistols. I was chatting with him via DM a while back when I started shooting my 43x/48 more. I was thinking of trying to attend one of his deep concealment courses, but timing wasn’t working out.

I understand your concern and/or thought. I did some testing of my own, but not that “direct”… yet.  A couple of ways to think about it is when needed, what is more important?  Individual choice, as well as adapting techniques all come into play.

As for fireball, for my ported 48 it depends on the ammo. For one of my ported 17 slides, I don’t really notice. Tho my ported 17 slide the ports are angled slightly outward (not vertical), whereas the ports on the 48 are vertical. I have another 17 with ports that I won recently which has vertical ports, but haven’t shot it yet.

That's cool he responded to your DM's. Unless you talking about another type of "DM". lol.

I get that porting is a choice, but IMO, eliminate that variable. 1 less thing to worry about. Plus adding in you may have to answer to a prosecutor or civil attorney why you ported. 

zippz

Re: Subcompact (micro, slimline, etc) Pistols - Experiences & Recommendations
« Reply #48 on: December 30, 2024, 11:58:27 AM »
Firing from the hip shouldn't be a problem for ported barrels.  The top is clear and the gun should be away from your body or slightly canted away to prevent jams anyways.

For experienced shooters, the advantages of porting would be minimal.  I can see a bigger advantage for inexperienced or frail shooters that may not have a good grip.

One side benefit of ports no one talks about is retention.  Bad guy grabs the muzzle end to take the gun.  Just hold the slide forward and fire a round.  He's going to let go.   :D

drck1000

Re: Subcompact (micro, slimline, etc) Pistols - Experiences & Recommendations
« Reply #49 on: December 30, 2024, 02:08:19 PM »
Firing from the hip shouldn't be a problem for ported barrels.  The top is clear and the gun should be away from your body or slightly canted away to prevent jams anyways.

For experienced shooters, the advantages of porting would be minimal.  I can see a bigger advantage for inexperienced or frail shooters that may not have a good grip.

One side benefit of ports no one talks about is retention.  Bad guy grabs the muzzle end to take the gun.  Just hold the slide forward and fire a round.  He's going to let go.   :D
From personal experience, and a few who shoot/compete often, I think there are definite advantages.  Are the advantages minimal to significant?  That's relative.  Also depends on context and expectations.  I've read where some stated "it affects splits", but is that b/c the individual is waiting for sights/dot to be back on target?  What level of confirmation are they expecting? 

Before porting, I was shooting a Glock 45 with Radian Ramjet & Afterburner in competitions.  Is that a significant advantage?  I would say noticeable difference between with the Radian and say a stock Glock 45/17/34, but a significant advantage for USPSA competition?  I say not significant.  One aspect is IF I was looking for higher level of RDS confirmation on say a partial/no-shoot target further away, I can get that faster than without.  Is that a significant advantage?  I would say not really. 

However, in the context of CCW and say 3-5 yards, probably no "significant advantage".

The grip is another aspect.  Something that shooting the 43x48 that I've found less forgiving, but also something that I think just takes a bit of time to get used to and/or learn.  That's where I started using/testing magwells, for the grip aspect vice reloads.  I have found that with my hand size, my pinky is on the grip of the 43x/48, but I like the wedging effect of the magwell with the grip. 

changemyoil66

Re: Subcompact (micro, slimline, etc) Pistols - Experiences & Recommendations
« Reply #50 on: December 30, 2024, 04:33:38 PM »


The grip is another aspect.  Something that shooting the 43x48 that I've found less forgiving, but also something that I think just takes a bit of time to get used to and/or learn.  That's where I started using/testing magwells, for the grip aspect vice reloads.  I have found that with my hand size, my pinky is on the grip of the 43x/48, but I like the wedging effect of the magwell with the grip.

When I first shot the Shield Plus, my pinky would hang off the magwel area. Now it fullly covers it.  IDK why. Hand shrank, grip got longer (srs)?  High grip has nothing to do with it either as it's always been the same.

macsak

Re: Subcompact (micro, slimline, etc) Pistols - Experiences & Recommendations
« Reply #51 on: December 30, 2024, 04:49:43 PM »
hand shrank because it doesn't have to manipulate larger objects...

When I first shot the Shield Plus, my pinky would hang off the magwel area. Now it fullly covers it.  IDK why. Hand shrank, grip got longer (srs)?  High grip has nothing to do with it either as it's always been the same.

drck1000

Re: Subcompact (micro, slimline, etc) Pistols - Experiences & Recommendations
« Reply #52 on: December 31, 2024, 10:01:31 AM »
When I first shot the Shield Plus, my pinky would hang off the magwel area. Now it fullly covers it.  IDK why. Hand shrank, grip got longer (srs)?  High grip has nothing to do with it either as it's always been the same.
Did you lose weight?

hand shrank because it doesn't have to manipulate larger objects...

You know from extenstive experience? 

macsak

Re: Subcompact (micro, slimline, etc) Pistols - Experiences & Recommendations
« Reply #53 on: December 31, 2024, 10:14:25 AM »
heads

You know from extenstive experience?

changemyoil66

Re: Subcompact (micro, slimline, etc) Pistols - Experiences & Recommendations
« Reply #54 on: December 31, 2024, 02:59:14 PM »
Did you lose weight?


No. Neither did I lose any grip strength as I still deadlift w/o needing to strap up.  Been trying to figure this out for over a year now. Maybe the webbing between the thumb and index finger loss mass, so I can go higher on the grip?