My opinion.
*Someone breaks in for any reason and my family is home.
1) I get the gun.
2) if I see he's unarmed, I yell. "Get out of here" (most burglars are cowards. They sneak into the house when they think people aren't home. Like roaches, as soon as they're seen, they scurry into their homes.
2b) If he's armed, he gets the gun pointed at him and the obligatory "Drop the weapon.
3a) If he leaves, awesome.
3b) If he doesn't immediately leave or makes any comment other than "OK", he gets the gun pointed at him. (Someone willing to stand there after the homeowner yells at them is no common thief. This type of burglar is a predator. He has assessed the situation, looked at you and defiantly thought in his mind "I can take this guy")
Any time someone is brazen enough to break into your home, your life is already in danger.
Criminals don't think like me and you.
The home burglar is a different breed altogether. Much like a mugger, this is someone in afraid to use violence to steal.
The worst mistake you can make is to underestimate their propensity for violence.
JMO and fully agree with KK:
Typical thieves are generally cowards and break in and steal your stuff when no one is home and if they make the terrible mistake of breaking in when someone is home and is yielding a weapon in self-defense, yelling “GET THE F%$* OUT OF MY HOUSE, I HAVE A GUN”, or something along those lines, chances are they will run like hell like the cowards they are.
I believe (correct me if I’m wrong) the intent of the “Stand Your Ground” and “Castle Law” (generally speaking) is for the rare cases involving the truly sick bastard, or someone who is out of their mind on drugs, or a crazed ex-husband or boyfriend who truly intends to do bodily harm and is hell-bent of doing so at all costs and will likely not stop the attack no matter what. Even as liberal as Hawaii is I can’t imagine the general public or prosecutor’s office not siding with the victim (homeowner) in this case, even if the use of deadly force was used to stop the threat.
No one wants to shoot anyone just for the hell of it or losing a few items, it’s not worth it and I don’t think warranted or justified. I got to believe most people can clearly tell the difference between the two situations relatively quick. However, sometimes the situation is so dire and life threatening (not your typical burglar) that deadly force is warranted and I believe the state and general public would be on your side. Again JMO.
Does anyone know of a case in Hawaii that applied the Castle Doctrine since it was enacted into Law in 2010? I don’t recall one.