2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: Jdelacruz on October 28, 2013, 07:25:49 AM
-
Would This Be Allowed to Carry Here?
http://jpxpeppergun.net/home.html (http://jpxpeppergun.net/home.html)
I'm looking through the City ordinance but it only mentions "spray". I think the biggest issue is that it uses blanks to propel the OC solution.
-
Legal or not, I question anyone's judgement who would carry and use in public a nonlethal defense product shaped like a gun. You're just asking to be shot!
Just my opinion, of course! ;)
-
Shot by who? How would anyone know you are carrying it unless you carry it openly? And if you are at the point where you need to use it does it really matter? Until we have real CCW I'm just looking at the best options to carry some sort of last resort form of defense. I currently carry pepper spray but with Hawaii winds I can see how it could backfire.
-
The other option I'm looking at is this.
http://www.pepperblaster.com/ (http://www.pepperblaster.com/)
-
Legal or not, I question anyone's judgement who would carry and use in public a nonlethal defense product shaped like a gun. You're just asking to be shot!
Just my opinion, of course! ;)
==============
For what it's worth, I agree. Those products look too much like guns. Legal or not.
I seem to notice a trend of more incidents where police are using deadly force when there is ANY possibility of a firearm threat.
You also have to remember, when the police arrive they do not know who is good or bad.
Imagine this:
You pepper spay ;) a perp and he is rolling around on the ground injured then the cops arrive and you are holding a device that looks like a gun?
-
So is that the reasoning behind not allowing us CCW here?
-
Shot by who? How would anyone know you are carrying it unless you carry it openly? And if you are at the point where you need to use it does it really matter? Until we have real CCW I'm just looking at the best options to carry some sort of last resort form of defense. I currently carry pepper spray but with Hawaii winds I can see how it could backfire.
Simple scenario: Bad guy menacing you. You pull pepper spray gun to protect yourself. Bad guy pulls his (illegally) concealed weapon. You lose.
So many situations that can result in you being viewed as the threat. Off duty cop nearby, sheriff driving by, bouncer, rent-a-cop security.
With 13-year-olds being shot for holding a replica gun, it makes no sense to carry something like that.
-
So is that the reasoning behind not allowing us CCW here?
You used 2 words that don't belong in the same sentence:
reasoning
CCW
The state has no reasoning for denying CCW. They set up the system so that you have to present them an overwhelming reason why you should have CCW.
-
Simple scenario: Bad guy menacing you. You pull pepper spray gun to protect yourself. Bad guy pulls his (illegally) concealed weapon. You lose.
So many situations that can result in you being viewed as the threat. Off duty cop nearby, sheriff driving by, bouncer, rent-a-cop security.
With 13-year-olds being shot for holding a replica gun, it makes no sense to carry something like that.
So is that to assume if I pulled out a regular pepper spray the bad guy would not use the illegal gun against me or my family?
In terms of being viewed as a threat my reason for mentioning CCW is how would that differ if we had CCW? If you carry concealed you don't flaunt what you have. You keep it hidden so you are not viewed as a threat.
There are officers I know that carries their guns off duty does that means if they use it they are at risk of another office shooting them since they are not in uniform?
-
The state has no reasoning for denying CCW. They set up the system so that you have to present them an overwhelming reason why you should have CCW.
:thumbsup:
-
So is that to assume if I pulled out a regular pepper spray the bad guy would not use the illegal gun against me or my family?
In terms of being viewed as a threat my reason for mentioning CCW is how would that differ if we had CCW? If you carry concealed you don't flaunt what you have. You keep it hidden so you are not viewed as a threat.
There are officers I know that carries their guns off duty does that means if they use it they are at risk of another office shooting them since they are not in uniform?
A bad guy can shoot you for any reason, or for no reason. Pulling out a pepper spray can vs. gun to me is smarter if you are going to use anything. Pulling the squirt gun out forces the bad guy to react to that, which is a more predictable reaction than seeing a regular spray container.
Be honest. Do you think you are more or less likely to be shot or stabbed over pulling a can of spray, or a real or replica gun?
And there are instances of CCW "good guys" shooting at or covering a perp, then being mistakenly shot by police. Having a gun in your hands makes you a target.
As far as your argument comparing a cop with a real gun to the civilian with a gun: the cop has a badge and can identify himself to both the potential perp and bystanders (other cops). CCW gun owners don't usually have badges, unless you buy one of the CCW license wallets with the Concealed Carry badge attached. I've not heard of that CCW badge being credited with preventing a case of mistaken identity, even though that is its stated purpose. If he identifies himself, then it's much less likely he'll be shot by another cop. That isn't a guarantee. The military is all too aware of how often death by friendly fire occurs. There's no reason to believe COPs are any less fallible.
There is no "one size fits all" answer for your questions. Humans are unpredictable. You prepare for what is most likely, and then react quickly when things don't go as planned. Situational awareness...
-
A bad guy can shoot you for any reason, or for no reason. Pulling out a pepper spray can vs. gun to me is smarter if you are going to use anything. Pulling the squirt gun out forces the bad guy to react to that, which is a more predictable reaction than seeing a regular spray container.
Be honest. Do you think you are more or less likely to be shot or stabbed over pulling a can of spray, or a real or replica gun?
And there are instances of CCW "good guys" shooting at or covering a perp, then being mistakenly shot by police. Having a gun in your hands makes you a target.
As far as your argument comparing a cop with a real gun to the civilian with a gun: the cop has a badge and can identify himself to both the potential perp and bystanders (other cops). CCW gun owners don't usually have badges, unless you buy one of the CCW license wallets with the Concealed Carry badge attached. I've not heard of that CCW badge being credited with preventing a case of mistaken identity, even though that is its stated purpose. If he identifies himself, then it's much less likely he'll be shot by another cop. That isn't a guarantee. The military is all too aware of how often death by friendly fire occurs. There's no reason to believe COPs are any less fallible.
There is no "one size fits all" answer for your questions. Humans are unpredictable. You prepare for what is most likely, and then react quickly when things don't go as planned. Situational awareness...
I think you misunderstand me, can we agree that a firearm would be the best defense to carry? If not then please ignore the rest.
Since we are not allowed to carry firearms would it make sense to get the most effective defensive item to carry? The pepper gun may not be it, but I don't think for the reasons you state such as it makes you target, or someone might inflict more harm to you if you use, or because it looks like a gun as the same could be argued for carrying a firearm. I'd prefer to get a CCW but until that option is available to me I'm looking at other things to carry besides my pocketknife and pepper spray for self defense.
-
The pepper gun may not be it, but I don't think for the reasons you state such as it makes you target, or someone might inflict more harm to you if you use, or because it looks like a gun as the same could be argued for carrying a firearm.
The differentiating factor between a squirt gun and a real gun is one actually IS a firearm. Therefore, the chances that "someone might inflict more harm to you if you use" a real gun are greatly diminished due to its lethal effects.
So, no, pulling a real gun and pulling a pepper squirt gun do not make you the same type of target. One gives you an even chance against the opponent who also has a gun.
-
The differentiating factor between a squirt gun and a real gun is one actually IS a firearm. Therefore, the chances that "someone might inflict more harm to you if you use" a real gun are greatly diminished due to its lethal effects.
So, no, pulling a real gun and pulling a pepper squirt gun do not make you the same type of target. One gives you an even chance against the opponent who also has a gun.
I still think you misunderstand me. You pull out a real gun because your life is in danger (meaning you are already a target), unfortunately you can't cause Hawaii does not have CCW. So what do you pull? What is available to me right now that I am aware of is a pocket knife and pepperspray. If there is something more effective other than a gun (since I can't carry one) I'd like to have that. Trust me I'd rather have a real gun on my person but if there is something I can legally carry at this time that is more effective than my current limited choices I'd like to explore that.
-
I still think you misunderstand me. You pull out a real gun because your life is in danger (meaning you are already a target), unfortunately you can't cause Hawaii does not have CCW. So what do you pull? What is available to me right now that I am aware of is a pocket knife and pepperspray. If there is something more effective other than a gun (since I can't carry one) I'd like to have that. Trust me I'd rather have a real gun on my person but if there is something I can legally carry at this time that is more effective than my current limited choices I'd like to explore that.
Tons of items you can carry, just as long as they are not considered dangerous weapons.
§134-51 Deadly weapons; prohibitions; penalty. (a) Any person, not authorized by law, who carries concealed upon the person's self or within any vehicle used or occupied by the person or who is found armed with any dirk, dagger, blackjack, slug shot, billy, metal knuckles, pistol, or other deadly or dangerous weapon shall be guilty of a misdemeanor and may be immediately arrested without warrant by any sheriff, police officer, or other officer or person. Any weapon, above enumerated, upon conviction of the one carrying or possessing it under this section, shall be summarily destroyed by the chief of police or sheriff.
So, whatever you choose should be both effective and discrete. Tactical flashlights and tactical ink pens are possibilities. Also, keychains with finger holes and pointy tips are sold around the Internet.
You can open carry a 9 inch diving knife on your belt and be legal. There's no length limits for knives as long as they have a utility purpose, not just for fighting or stabbing humans. Weird! :wacko:
-
Thanks for the info. Very helpful. I do have a tactical flashlight but I can see it in a different light now (no pun intended.. well maybe some).
I'll look into the tactical key chains too.
-
There was a discussion on these types of pepper spray dispensers before. Taken from, http://www1.honolulu.gov/council/ocs/roh/rohchapter41a2642.pdf (http://www1.honolulu.gov/council/ocs/roh/rohchapter41a2642.pdf)
Bold portion from under 41-37.1 Definitions is the part that makes these type of devices illegal. If the propellant needs an ignition source then its a no-go.
Article 37. Possession, Use, and Sale of Pepper Sprays for Self-Defense
Sections:
41-37.1 Definitions.
41-37.2 Exceptions.
41-37.3 Restrictions on possession, sale, and use of pepper sprays.
41-37.4 License to distribute--Application and requirements.
41-37.5 Conditions of license.
41-37.6 Suspension or revocation of license.
41-37.7 Forfeiture.
41-37.8 Rules.
41-37.9 Violation--Penalty.
Sec. 41-37.1 Definitions.
"Adult" means any natural person other than a minor.
"Chief of police" means the chief of police of the City and County of Honolulu or the chief of police's authorized
subordinate.
"Chemical device" means any aerosol container or other device that is capable of emitting chloroacetaphenone (CN),
orthochlorobenzalmalononitrile (CS), or oleoresin capsicum (OC), or any combination or derivative thereof, in a vapor or liquid form.
"Controlled substance" means the same as defined in HRS Section 329-1.
"Department" means the Honolulu police department.
"Designated place of business" means a fixed place of business owned or leased by a licensee and designated by the
licensee in its application under Section 41-37.4 as a place where it desires to sell or otherwise distribute pepper spray on a regular
basis. "Designated place of business" does not include any temporary space rented or leased by a licensee at a swap meet, open
market or other similar setting.
"Licensee" means any person who has obtained, pursuant to Section 41-37.4, a license to sell, transport or otherwise
distribute pepper sprays in the city.
"Minor" means any natural person below the age of 18 years.
"Pepper spray" means any aerosol container or other device designed to fit into a handbag or a pants pocket and has a
trigger-guard, flip top or other mechanism to prevent the accidental release of the spray, that: (1) is capable of emitting oleoresin
capsicum (OC), or any derivative thereof, in a vapor or liquid form; (2) contains only the chemical substance oleoresin capsicum, or
any derivative thereof, without containing chloroacetaphenone (CN) or orthochlorobenzalmalononitrile (CS); and (3) contains a nonflammable
propellant and/or carrier.
"Person" means the same as defined in Section 41-25.1.
(Added by Ord. 95-49)
-
I swear all these laws suck and only serve to the detriment of crime victims. If the perp is going to cause you harm or shoot you I hope you get off a pepper blast with a marking agent so there's a chance the fugger can be stopped and found. I don't care if it's shaped like a dill.. pickle.
-
Wouldn't the key chain be considered a brass knuckle?
Oh I know, let's just call 911 while we're getting stabbed, thrown in a dumpster or our heads bashed in! That'll work!
-
A walking stick or a flashlight are honestly your best bet here. You could also use a dive knife if you wanna go that route.
-
Wouldn't the key chain be considered a brass knuckle?
Oh I know, let's just call 911 while we're getting stabbed, thrown in a dumpster or our heads bashed in! That'll work!
The law specifies "metal knuckles". These are super-hard plastic or rubber. Very tough.
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B0042QKXN2/?tag=2ahawaii-20 (http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B0042QKXN2/?tag=2ahawaii-20)
(http://i944.photobucket.com/albums/ad287/Doug_Moose/brutus__zps05f43ba5.jpg) (http://s944.photobucket.com/user/Doug_Moose/media/brutus__zps05f43ba5.jpg.html)
-
"i'm batman"
The law specifies "metal knuckles". These are super-hard plastic or rubber. Very tough.
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B0042QKXN2/?tag=2ahawaii-20 (http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B0042QKXN2/?tag=2ahawaii-20)
(http://i944.photobucket.com/albums/ad287/Doug_Moose/brutus__zps05f43ba5.jpg) (http://s944.photobucket.com/user/Doug_Moose/media/brutus__zps05f43ba5.jpg.html)
-
It's perfectly LEGAL to carry and use "pepper spray" in any shape or form.
Sec. 41-37.3 Restrictions on possession, sale, and use of pepper sprays.
It is unlawful for any person to use any pepper spray for any purpose except:
(1) Self-defense;
(2) Defense of another person; or
(3) Protection of property of the person or of another person.
-
.
-
Problem is that under HRS 134, these are defined as 'deadly weapons', simply because their intended creation/purpose is for self-defense/bodily harm. If you are going the knuckle route, I'd just head to Home Depot and fit a d-ring to your hand, then use it as a key ring.
Yes, but regardless of the legality, they WILL find a way to crucify you in court for having something that looks like a firearm; it's just the Modus operandi of this particular department.
When in doubt, contact HPD firearms and specifically speak to the highest ranking officer and/or administration; the guys at the window tend not to know jack. You could also contact the court system to get an exact interpretation of the law. I would be interested in finding out about these as well, as it seems like a viable option for CCW for the time being. However, the potential problem I see with this is the whole 'concealed carry' debacle. If these are considered legal, I'd hope they don't fall under the regulations for a CCW, because the chief will immediately shoot you down, and there is no way to open carry this item openly without causing some problems.
Since this item is a keychain, I've been allowed to carry it into courthouses and on aircraft. The security folks don't give it a second glance.
There's no blade, no projectile, and no metal other than the key ring and keys. Unless you know what you're looking at, it's just a big, funny looking key fob.
I think the term "deadly weapon" is not a catch-all. The courts have said that a knife, while not being used to injure or kill, is not in and of itself a deadly weapon (excluding certain "scary" exceptions). Once you use it as a weapon, it then is treated as such.
So many everyday items are potential weapons. That doesn't make them illegal to conceal carry.
-
.
-
how did they know it was a kubotan and not some other blunt object in your pants?
http://2ahawaii.com/Smileys/extended/evil.gif (http://2ahawaii.com/Smileys/extended/evil.gif)
:thumbsup: :geekdanc: 1673 Kapiolani Blvd :geekdanc: :thumbsup:
-
:thumbsup: :geekdanc: 1673 Kapiolani Blvd :geekdanc: :thumbsup:
:shake: :shake: :shake:
-
I still think walking sticks and/or a flashlight is the best option we have right now in Hawaii.
-
.
-
Illegal. See bolded section
§134-1 Definitions. As used in this chapter, unless the context indicates otherwise:
"Acquire" means gain ownership of.
"Antique pistol or revolver" means any pistol or revolver manufactured before 1899 and any replica thereof if it either is not designed or redesigned for using rimfire or conventional centerfire fixed ammunition or is designed or redesigned to use rimfire or conventional centerfire fixed ammunition that is no longer manufactured in the United States and is not readily available in the ordinary channels of commercial trade.
"Assault pistol" means a semiautomatic pistol which accepts a detachable magazine and which has two or more of the following characteristics:
(1) An ammunition magazine which attaches to the pistol outside of the pistol grip;
(2) A threaded barrel capable of accepting a barrel extender, flash suppressor, forward hand grip, or silencer;
(3) A shroud which is attached to or partially or completely encircles the barrel and which permits the shooter to hold the firearm with the second hand without being burned;
(4) A manufactured weight of fifty ounces or more when the pistol is unloaded;
(5) A centerfire pistol with an overall length of twelve inches or more; or
(6) It is a semiautomatic version of an automatic firearm;
but does not include a firearm with a barrel sixteen or more inches in length, an antique pistol as defined in this section or a curio or relic as those terms are used in 18 United States Code §921(16) or 27 Code of Federal Regulations 178.11.
"Automatic firearm" means any firearm that shoots, is designed to shoot, or can be readily modified to shoot automatically more than one shot, without a manual reloading, by a single function of the trigger. This term shall also include the frame or receiver of any such firearm, any part designed and intended solely and exclusively, or any combination of parts designed and intended, for use in converting a firearm into an automatic firearm, and any combination of parts from which an automatic firearm can be assembled if the parts are in the possession or under the control of a single person.
"Chief of police" means the chief of police of the counties of Hawaii, Maui, Kauai, or the city and county of Honolulu.
"Crime of violence" means any offense, as defined in title 37, that involves injury or threat of injury to the person of another.
"Electric gun" means any portable device that is electrically operated to project a missile or electromotive force. It does not include any electric livestock prod used in animal husbandry and any automatic external defibrillator used in emergency medical situations.
"Firearm" means any weapon, for which the operating force is an explosive, including but not limited to pistols, revolvers, rifles, shotguns, automatic firearms, noxious gas projectors, mortars, bombs, and cannon.
"Firearm loaded with ammunition" and "loaded firearm" means a firearm with ammunition present within the firing chamber, revolving cylinder, or within a magazine which is inserted in a firearm.
"Fugitive from justice" means any person (1) who has fled from any state, territory, the District of Columbia, or possession of the United States, to avoid prosecution for a felony or to avoid giving testimony in any criminal proceeding or (2) who has fled from any country other than the United States and is avoiding lawful extradition back to that country.
"Pistol" or "revolver" means any firearm of any shape with a barrel less than sixteen inches in length and capable of discharging loaded ammunition or any noxious gas.
"Public highway" shall have the same meaning as defined in section 264-1(a).
"Semiautomatic" means the mode of operation by which a firearm uses the energy of the explosive in a fixed cartridge to extract a fired cartridge and chamber a fresh cartridge with each single pull of a trigger. [L 1988, c 275, pt of §2 and am c 271, §2; am L 1989, c 263, §§2, 3; am L 1990, c 195, §1; am L 1992, c 286, §1; am L 1994, c 204, §2; am L 2001, c 252, §2]
-
That makes HILTI nail guns are "firearms". :wtf:
:stopjack:
-
.