2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: Rogue076 on December 12, 2013, 02:10:11 PM

Title: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Rogue076 on December 12, 2013, 02:10:11 PM
So when I watch, and getting very irritated doing so, things like Piers Morgan and he talks about gun control, he always asks "Why do you need and AR15?" like he tries to stump people with the question and act like its unnecessary for the public to have such a powerful weapon. I wanna know how you guys out there would answer this question, besides the obvious "its my second amendment right", im looking for answers with more conviction and substance. I myself would answer the question with a question like "why does someone need a 80 inch TV?" or "why does someone need a $300,000 700 horsepower car?" I always wondered what answers I could use to go on Piers Morgan and stump the guy whos not even from America and has no business getting in our business...
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Darmok and Jalad @Tanagra on December 12, 2013, 02:16:58 PM
So when I watch, and getting very irritated doing so, things like Piers Morgan and he talks about gun control, he always asks "Why do you need and AR15?" like he tries to stump people with the question and act like its unnecessary for the public to have such a powerful weapon. I wanna know how you guys out there would answer this question, besides the obvious "its my second amendment right", im looking for answers with more conviction and substance. I myself would answer the question with a question like "why does someone need a 80 inch TV?" or "why does someone need a $300,000 700 horsepower car?" I always wondered what answers I could use to go on Piers Morgan and stump the guy whos not even from America and has no business getting in our business...

Piers Morgan schooled on need to have AR-15 by 22-year-old woman

http://www.examiner.com/article/piers-morgan-schooled-on-need-to-have-ar-15-by-22-year-old-woman (http://www.examiner.com/article/piers-morgan-schooled-on-need-to-have-ar-15-by-22-year-old-woman)
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: SpeedTek on December 12, 2013, 02:20:43 PM
To me its just a semi-auto rifle that we need to fight tyranny in this great country should it arise.

What if we are invaded?  Ordinary citizens cant fight back.  I know the argument is it will never happen.

But you never know.  I dont trust our own government less alone any other government.

and Obama administration way less
Title: .
Post by: Q on December 12, 2013, 02:23:45 PM
.
Title: .
Post by: Q on December 12, 2013, 02:28:47 PM
.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Rogue076 on December 12, 2013, 02:37:37 PM
I don't think those counter questions help validate the point. Firearms are a right to protect us from individual, group and government threat, as well as allow us to enforce our other rights when someone attempts to encroach upon them. If we liken the talking point to 'why does someone need a large tv?' or 'why does someone need an expensive car?', it then associates firearms with luxury rather than necessity, and therefore someone would not 'need' a firearm/ar15, as it would be considered more for enjoyment rather than its intended purpose.

Yeah it might not validate the point but in the case of piers morgan I think hes trying to make that exact point to say that the gun IS a luxury or just unnecessary/overpowered to simply defend yourself, like a big TV isn't necessary to just watch TV or an expensive fast car is unnecessary to simply get around.
Title: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Jl808 on December 12, 2013, 02:51:05 PM
Ok I may be staring a religious war but I think an AR-15 carbine is an excellent choice for a home defense firearm.

1. It's powerful enough to stop someone big and/or on drugs.

2. It's lighter and easier for a woman and/or teen to handle... much better than a 12 gauge.

3. A rifle is more accurate than a pistol (especially for beginners)

4. Controllable recoil.

5. You won't have to worry about running out of bullets. The saying "the loudest sounds you don't want to hear is a click when you expect a bang, and a bang when you expect a click" comes to mind.

6. The 55gr .223 bullets are small and fast and overpenetrates less than a #00 buck, 12ga slug or 147gr 9mm bullet.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Sturmgeschutz on December 12, 2013, 02:54:29 PM
I don't own an AR15.... Too new fangeled for my taste...
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: ren on December 12, 2013, 03:39:45 PM
The question is invalid coming from a NON US citizen who makes a living criticizing our rights. The country from where Piers is from took away all their gun rights. He is like a fly on a turd. Insignificant and deserves to be swatted. In fact, someone should flip the script and cite history - Britain was the reason why we have the Bill of Rights.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: sliver on December 12, 2013, 03:54:59 PM
It's a cool looking super cheap and reliable gun (ultra customizable, more accessories then a glock!) which is effective as well as fairly accurate (1-1.5moa out of any ar15 is not uncommon) and a hell of a lot of fun (low recoil helps new shooters get into the sport).  You can build one for about 500 bucks right now and 30 round mags run ~8-17 bucks a piece (100 round mags run about 118-300 bucks).  Ammo is cheaper then .45acp when you buy in bulk and that's in Hawaii where ammo cost more then anywhere else in the country.

you can use it to hunt, plink/target shoot, self defense, and customize/upgrade.  It is cheaper then a mosin nagant (200 bucks, should be only $75-100) when you think about it after you have to buy the gun, take the time to clean it up, buy a scope (?) and pay someone to mount it (100 bucks), buy a new stock (80-200) or clean up the old one, and then you will still have a bolt action rifle with low mag round count which is shooting probably ~3moa (yes there are some shooting sub-moa but there is always an exception to the rule). 

In the end nobody really needs one but don't complain if you can't defend yourself.  That and its America where its not a privilege, its a right that we should be able to own one!
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Sturmgeschutz on December 12, 2013, 05:11:00 PM

 It is cheaper then a mosin nagant (200 bucks, should be only $75-100) when you think about it after you have to buy the gun, take the time to clean it up, buy a scope (?) and pay someone to mount it (100 bucks), buy a new stock (80-200) or clean up the old one, and then you will still have a bolt action rifle with low mag round count which is shooting probably ~3moa (yes there are some shooting sub-moa but there is always an exception to the rule). 


Turd polishing ....

Buy it, clean it up and shoot it with irons sights!

Buying an old surplus rifle and doing all that optics, stock, and work on it is kinda pointless ... It's like dressing Betty White up to look like Lady Gaga.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: dirsh on December 12, 2013, 05:36:24 PM
In case we need to fight the damn Brits again!
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: sliver on December 12, 2013, 05:40:53 PM
Turd polishing ....

Buy it, clean it up and shoot it with irons sights!

Buying an old surplus rifle and doing all that optics, stock, and work on it is kinda pointless ... It's like dressing Betty White up to look like Lady Gaga.

true but its just an example of how cheap ar15's are right now.  I could have used building up a 10/22 as an example as well.  Either way I think you totally missed the point which was AR15's are great and everyone should have one.  There is no real reason why any potential gun owner and every current gun owner shouldn't have one at this point.  If you can afford a handgun, you can afford an AR15!
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Sturmgeschutz on December 12, 2013, 05:49:52 PM
true but its just an example of how cheap ar15's are right now.  I could have used building up a 10/22 as an example as well.  Either way I think you totally missed the point which was AR15's are great and everyone should have one.  There is no real reason why any potential gun owner and every current gun owner shouldn't have one at this point.  If you can afford a handgun, you can afford an AR15!

Naw, rather buy a BAR or M1a1... Something with a soul
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: new guy on December 12, 2013, 06:51:21 PM
.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Inspector on December 12, 2013, 06:52:00 PM
I hate to say this, but don't fall into his trap. You are trying to answer HIS question. But HIS question is one that cannot be answered the way YOU want to answer it. And if you try and answer HIS question you will fail and he will look superior. Let's face it, truth be told, none of us truly NEED an AR-15. The answer to the question is NOT to engage the NEED portion of his question. But to give the answer that 100% of all Americans have. And that is that I OWN an AR-15 because I want one and I can own one or two or ten. I can shoot it better than any other firearm I own because I practice with it weekly. And I believe it is every American's duty to own one as our way of saying shove it up your ASS Piers Morgan and all the LIBERALS in our Federal, State and Local Governments! There is no better way to say shove it than to buy/build another one.

Notice he never answers any of his guests questions directly. So why not do the same? Especially when he designs his questions to work his way and no other way.

Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: ren on December 12, 2013, 06:56:55 PM
I hate to say this, but don't fall into his trap. You are trying to answer HIS question. But HIS question is one that cannot be answered the way YOU want to answer it. And if you try and answer HIS question you will fail and he will look superior. Let's face it, truth be told, none of us truly NEED an AR-15. The answer to the question is NOT to engage the NEED portion of his question. But to give the answer that 100% of all Americans have. And that is that I OWN an AR-15 because I want one and I can own one or two or ten. I can shoot it better than any other firearm I own because I practice with it weekly. And I believe it is every American's duty to own one as our way of saying shove it up your ASS Piers Morgan and all the LIBERALS in our Federal, State and Local Governments! There is no better way to say shove it than to buy/build another one.

Notice he never answers any of his guests questions directly. So why not do the same? Especially when he designs his questions to work his way and no other way.
Exactly. Every reason given in this thread was argued, not debated over by Piers. He argues with emotions and tries to rile up his audience. He was owned by some aggressive, sharp individuals. The never ending rabbit hole is that "Why stop there, how about a tank, a nuke?!!"
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Heavies on December 12, 2013, 07:09:43 PM
I hate to say this, but don't fall into his trap. You are trying to answer HIS question. But HIS question is one that cannot be answered the way YOU want to answer it. And if you try and answer HIS question you will fail and he will look superior. Let's face it, truth be told, none of us truly NEED an AR-15. The answer to the question is NOT to engage the NEED portion of his question. But to give the answer that 100% of all Americans have. And that is that I OWN an AR-15 because I want one and I can own one or two or ten. I can shoot it better than any other firearm I own because I practice with it weekly. And I believe it is every American's duty to own one as our way of saying shove it up your ASS Piers Morgan and all the LIBERALS in our Federal, State and Local Governments! There is no better way to say shove it than to buy/build another one.

Notice he never answers any of his guests questions directly. So why not do the same? Especially when he designs his questions to work his way and no other way.



This

Exactly. Every reason given in this thread was argued, not debated over by Piers. He argues with emotions and tries to rile up his audience. He was owned by some aggressive, sharp individuals. The never ending rabbit hole is that "Why stop there, how about a tank, a nuke?!!"

If Iran can have nukes, then damnit, I want one too!!!!

I don't own an AR15.... Too new fangeled for my taste...

I love my Garand.  ;)

It has been only recently that ARs have become an acceptible caliber weapon to most people.  Old schoolers concidered 5.56/.223 a varmint round, not to be taken seriously.  I have heard this is the reson the 90's 'assult wepon' ban got passed.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: ImKu on December 12, 2013, 07:12:50 PM
I don't own an AR15.... Too new fangeled for my taste...
Naw, rather buy a BAR or M1a1... Something with a soul

Why do you feel the need to derail the point of this thread to bash on AR's?  You must need attention don't you...  Good for you.  You don't like the most popular rifle in America, congrats on being different.  :thumbsup:

Found this.
(http://i1285.photobucket.com/albums/a586/ImKu/IMG_33607475283030_zps0f79212c.jpg) (http://s1285.photobucket.com/user/ImKu/media/IMG_33607475283030_zps0f79212c.jpg.html)
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Heavies on December 12, 2013, 07:14:55 PM

Why do you feel the need to derail the point of this thread to bash on AR's?  You must need attention don't you...  Good for you.  You don't like the most popular rifle in America, congrats on being different.  :thumbsup:

Found this.
(http://i1285.photobucket.com/albums/a586/ImKu/IMG_33607475283030_zps0f79212c.jpg) (http://s1285.photobucket.com/user/ImKu/media/IMG_33607475283030_zps0f79212c.jpg.html)

Lol.  I don't think his intent was to bash ARs, just that other weapons hold more interest.  :)
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Inspector on December 12, 2013, 07:16:06 PM
Exactly. Every reason given in this thread was argued, not debated over by Piers. He argues with emotions and tries to rile up his audience. He was owned by some aggressive, sharp individuals. The never ending rabbit hole is that "Why stop there, how about a tank, a nuke?!!"
While owning a tank and a nuke might be a little overkill for some. If it is legal, WHY NOT???? We are Americans. We are exceptional because of who we are and where we live and the Republic we live in. We are creative and strong and resilient. What other country is as great as ours? We are not perfect by any means. And there is a lot we can improve on. But taking away firearms is a proven way of making a bad situation worse. And that is a fact even Piers Morgan cannot argue with without lying and/or not telling the whole truth.

I can't say I would really want a nuke, but if I had the money a tank is not out of the question!  :thumbsup: :thumbsup: :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Sturmgeschutz on December 12, 2013, 07:24:14 PM

Why do you feel the need to derail the point of this thread to bash on AR's?  You must need attention don't you...  Good for you.  You don't like the most popular rifle in America, congrats on being different.  :thumbsup:

Found this.
(http://i1285.photobucket.com/albums/a586/ImKu/IMG_33607475283030_zps0f79212c.jpg) (http://s1285.photobucket.com/user/ImKu/media/IMG_33607475283030_zps0f79212c.jpg.html)

I don't mean to offend.... Yes... Not everyone needs an AR15....Used the rifle alot in the 80's.... But

Much of the popular AR15 culture is a lot like the street racer/custom motorcycle club culture... It no longer becomes the most efficient tool of the trade, but rather a cheap (and sometimes expensive) piece of jewlery to wear.

Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: bass monkey on December 12, 2013, 07:26:45 PM
Sounds like a troll started this thread and only has 4 posts and yet to reply.
Along with his other thread, how would conceal carry affect this state.
Let's see how long these replies take to end up on someone's Twitter
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: ImKu on December 12, 2013, 07:33:46 PM

I don't mean to offend.... Yes... Not everyone needs an AR15....Used the rifle alot in the 80's.... But

Much of the popular AR15 culture is a lot like the street racer/custom motorcycle club culture... It no longer becomes the most efficient tool of the trade, but rather a cheap (and sometimes expensive) piece of jewlery to wear.

No offense taken.  I beg to differ and I bet it would come down to personal preference, but we can have a AR vs xxx some other thread (I'm almost positive there is one already)  :shaka:
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Inspector on December 12, 2013, 07:38:42 PM
No offense taken.  I beg to differ and I bet it would come down to personal preference, but we can have a AR vs xxx some other thread (I'm almost positive there is one already)  :shaka:
Actually, the AR-15 is only a symbol for what the left hates and what we hold dear. It really doesn't matter if it is an AR-15, AK 47, Garand, M14, or a Ruger Charger. If the government tells us we can't own one then we should all own two.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: fartsinpublic on December 12, 2013, 07:42:28 PM
Old schoolers concidered 5.56/.223 a varmint round, not to be taken seriously.

AR: The typical noob's favorite first gun. After a 9mm Glock, of course.

Their dream, one (or several) of each.  :thumbsup:

Kinda hard to take them seriously when the typical Koko Head noob's goal is to see how many rails they can add, and how much stuff they can put on, and how much black crap they can add, and still they perforate their target stands despite all the accessorizing and money spent. I swear I have to check to see that they aren't shooting shotgun on the rifle side the way the paper looks. But what do I know? Everyone has to start somewhere, I guess, and kids these days just can't be fortunate enough to start out with an iron sight'ed bolt gun and some tin cans out back. Or squirrels and an autoloader. Gotta go with the fashionable AR rigs.

Thank god we don't have those typical noobs on 2aHI though. The AR fans here are far more sophisticated and better shooters that didn't learn how to shoot from Facebook and video games.

ARs certainly have their place and their fan base--kinda like Camaros, I guess, the noobs like them ,but folks who know buy something (anything) better, and with heritage/soul-- but I certainly don't miss having one and don't really see why anyone needs one when we all know that all you ever need, ever, is 10+1 of 45ACP.  ;D

 ;)
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Sturmgeschutz on December 12, 2013, 07:44:30 PM
No offense taken.  I beg to differ and I bet it would come down to personal preference, but we can have a AR vs xxx some other thread (I'm almost positive there is one already)  :shaka:

Exactly, as I said .... " for my taste"

I collect and shoot old battle rifles and have no interest in an AR15.... But I'd sell a kidney for an STG 43/44
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: edster48 on December 12, 2013, 07:46:26 PM
Sounds like a troll started this thread and only has 4 posts and yet to reply.
Along with his other thread, how would conceal carry affect this state.
Let's see how long these replies take to end up on someone's Twitter

Funny bass monkey, I was thinking exactly the same thing.

As far as why anyone would "need" an AR, it's beside the point. If I want one, can afford one, and am responsible for my own actions with said weapon, what business of yours is it what I have? Piss off and tend to your own business, don't worry about mine.

In other words, live and let live. In this country, it's our right, guaranteed by the constitution, to own firearms. There is no limitation set forth in that document.
Up to this point I've never owned one, mainly due to the fact that I'm believer in the old adage "big bullets kill stuff faster". However, my son has finally sold me on the platform and I plan to build a blackout in the coming year. Light, accurate, and a good gun for pigs.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: marquez526 on December 12, 2013, 08:06:22 PM
You guys are wrong ! The Vice President said all we need is a shotgun to fire in the air and then the bad people leave.  :geekdanc:
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Sturmgeschutz on December 12, 2013, 08:17:49 PM
You guys are wrong ! The Vice President said all we need is a shotgun to fire in the air and then the bad people leave.  :geekdanc:

Sh!t.... Don't own one of those either.,. No wonder I didn't vote for these guys
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: ImKu on December 12, 2013, 08:31:41 PM
AR: The typical noob's favorite first gun. After a 9mm Glock, of course.

Their dream, one (or several) of each.  :thumbsup:

Kinda hard to take them seriously when the typical Koko Head noob's goal is to see how many rails they can add, and how much stuff they can put on, and how much black crap they can add, and still they perforate their target stands despite all the accessorizing and money spent. I swear I have to check to see that they aren't shooting shotgun on the rifle side the way the paper looks. But what do I know? Everyone has to start somewhere, I guess, and kids these days just can't be fortunate enough to start out with an iron sight'ed bolt gun and some tin cans out back. Or squirrels and an autoloader. Gotta go with the fashionable AR rigs.

Thank god we don't have those typical noobs on 2aHI though. The AR fans here are far more sophisticated and better shooters that didn't learn how to shoot from Facebook and video games.

ARs certainly have their place and their fan base--kinda like Camaros, I guess, the noobs like them ,but folks who know buy something (anything) better, and with heritage/soul-- but I certainly don't miss having one and don't really see why anyone needs one when we all know that all you ever need, ever, is 10+1 of 45ACP.  ;D

Great.  Let's just insult other gun owners and establish a stereotype of AR owners.  Everyone does have to start somewhere.  Did you offer some advice/guidance to perhaps help a "noob"?  Bet not.  Not everyone is lucky enough to have proper training.  You probably just watched and laughed to yourself about how there are sooo many "noobs" with AR's and how awesome you are. 

I admit I have seen new AR owners that probably never shot before(seen guys that don't know how to lock the bolt back manually), but instead of judging them, how about you offer some tips of proper shooting technique or safe gun handling?  Most "noobs" are very receptive to advice.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Darmok and Jalad @Tanagra on December 12, 2013, 08:32:26 PM
This ...

http://youtu.be/I3HlbgYQLE0 (http://youtu.be/I3HlbgYQLE0)
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Sturmgeschutz on December 12, 2013, 09:00:21 PM
Great.  Let's just insult other gun owners and establish a stereotype of AR owners.  Everyone does have to start somewhere.  Did you offer some advice/guidance to perhaps help a "noob"?  Bet not.  Not everyone is lucky enough to have proper training.  You probably just watched and laughed to yourself about how there are sooo many "noobs" with AR's and how awesome you are. 

I admit I have seen new AR owners that probably never shot before(seen guys that don't know how to lock the bolt back manually), but instead of judging them, how about you offer some tips of proper shooting technique or safe gun handling?  Most "noobs" are very receptive to advice.


Hahahahaaa!!! You can stereotype me as a cosmoline geezer.

The "noob" thing comes from the media selling AR15s to clueless consumers, who don't want to fully buy into the responblilty of gun ownership, but don't wanna get left out when they ban it... Gotta by it now or I'll never get one.... Or worse.. The movie fan boys, who bought something, because they saw Chuck use it.


.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Funtimes on December 12, 2013, 09:23:33 PM
AR: The typical noob's favorite first gun. After a 9mm Glock, of course.

Their dream, one (or several) of each.  :thumbsup:

Kinda hard to take them seriously when the typical Koko Head noob's goal is to see how many rails they can add, and how much stuff they can put on, and how much black crap they can add, and still they perforate their target stands despite all the accessorizing and money spent. I swear I have to check to see that they aren't shooting shotgun on the rifle side the way the paper looks. But what do I know? Everyone has to start somewhere, I guess, and kids these days just can't be fortunate enough to start out with an iron sight'ed bolt gun and some tin cans out back. Or squirrels and an autoloader. Gotta go with the fashionable AR rigs.

Thank god we don't have those typical noobs on 2aHI though. The AR fans here are far more sophisticated and better shooters that didn't learn how to shoot from Facebook and video games.

ARs certainly have their place and their fan base--kinda like Camaros, I guess, the noobs like them ,but folks who know buy something (anything) better, and with heritage/soul-- but I certainly don't miss having one and don't really see why anyone needs one when we all know that all you ever need, ever, is 10+1 of 45ACP.  ;D

 ;)

I learned to shoot through video games. :)
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: dirsh on December 12, 2013, 09:26:12 PM
http://www.gq-magazine.co.uk/comment/articles/2013-03/11/american-vs-british-gun-control-laws (http://www.gq-magazine.co.uk/comment/articles/2013-03/11/american-vs-british-gun-control-laws)
Title: .
Post by: Q on December 12, 2013, 09:31:32 PM
.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Sturmgeschutz on December 12, 2013, 09:35:11 PM
  .
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: rswarrior1700 on December 12, 2013, 10:45:51 PM

Why do you feel the need to derail the point of this thread to bash on AR's?  You must need attention don't you...  Good for you.  You don't like the most popular rifle in America, congrats on being different.  :thumbsup:

Found this.
(http://i1285.photobucket.com/albums/a586/ImKu/IMG_33607475283030_zps0f79212c.jpg) (http://s1285.photobucket.com/user/ImKu/media/IMG_33607475283030_zps0f79212c.jpg.html)

Exactly why he has no support for going into Syria. Remember watching the news it was Barack and Feinstein who wants to go into Syria. Found it funny because that these two wants to sacrifice the lives of our own to help bring down Tyranny in Syria, yet they want to disarm the law abiding citizens of this country.  :wtf:
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Rogue076 on December 13, 2013, 06:44:47 AM
Thanks for all the interesting points and answers guys. I think my number one reason is honestly to fight tyranny within the government and from oppressors, and a lot of people argue that the 2nd amendment was placed in the constitution so long ago and its outdated and they think we don't have the need for it which I think is false. I believe tyranny is real and its only a matter of time before the lot of America wakes up and sees how real oppression already is, I mean middle class America is gone or going, the talk used to be about what can be done to help the lower class and were so far down the hole they gave up on them cause the middle class is sinking into it too, government is all about take, take, take, take, which leaves us on the bottom with nothing and oppressed. As everyone knows that kinda talk can go on and on and I don't wanna get too far off the thread subject, also I don't want the NSA knocking on my door, Ive already said too much....lol
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Rogue076 on December 13, 2013, 06:52:17 AM
Sounds like a troll started this thread and only has 4 posts and yet to reply.
Along with his other thread, how would conceal carry affect this state.
Let's see how long these replies take to end up on someone's Twitter

Haha Im a total newbie yes, troll no. Im a new gun owner and I watch and read a lot of stuff about these kind of issues and while its kinda futile to ask these things on a pro gun forum I was just curious to see how other gun owners felt about these topics. And theres so many things to reply to and I didn't think I would get this much feedback being a newbie also very busy with work and other things so not much time to reply till now but Im definitely taking a lot of it into account and finding a lot of the perspectives very interesting and im able to look at it in ways I never saw. Also I don't have twitter....and the other thread isn't mine.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Rogue076 on December 13, 2013, 07:05:29 AM

Why do you feel the need to derail the point of this thread to bash on AR's?  You must need attention don't you...  Good for you.  You don't like the most popular rifle in America, congrats on being different.  :thumbsup:

Found this.
(http://i1285.photobucket.com/albums/a586/ImKu/IMG_33607475283030_zps0f79212c.jpg) (http://s1285.photobucket.com/user/ImKu/media/IMG_33607475283030_zps0f79212c.jpg.html)

I had the same exact thought when I first heard they were sending Syria aid, they know exactly what guns are all about in that situation, to fight off a tyrannical government, so they know exactly why they need to take our guns away...
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Rogue076 on December 13, 2013, 07:09:44 AM
I hate to say this, but don't fall into his trap. You are trying to answer HIS question. But HIS question is one that cannot be answered the way YOU want to answer it. And if you try and answer HIS question you will fail and he will look superior. Let's face it, truth be told, none of us truly NEED an AR-15. The answer to the question is NOT to engage the NEED portion of his question. But to give the answer that 100% of all Americans have. And that is that I OWN an AR-15 because I want one and I can own one or two or ten. I can shoot it better than any other firearm I own because I practice with it weekly. And I believe it is every American's duty to own one as our way of saying shove it up your ASS Piers Morgan and all the LIBERALS in our Federal, State and Local Governments! There is no better way to say shove it than to buy/build another one.

Notice he never answers any of his guests questions directly. So why not do the same? Especially when he designs his questions to work his way and no other way.

Yeah its totally a question to lure you out so he can stump you, hes a talk show host that on a station with an agenda so they know what to say and how to ask things to make their point but I have seen him fail at it quite a few times with people that are very educated and you know he fails cause of exactly what you said, he cant answer his guests directly when they make a great point or stump him on his own question, I find a lot of that when I search "Piers Morgan owned" on youtube haha!
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Inspector on December 13, 2013, 07:17:27 AM
I would like to add this to the discussion. For all of those who look down upon the AR-15 I want you to know this. I am not a HUGE fan of the AR-15 platform. I never was. I got into it because I wanted a semi-auto rifle that shoots the same round as my Remy 700 5R. When I heard how accurate they can be if done right I decided I wanted a new project to work on and I purchased a few lowers from X-Ring. I figured after I build and shoot it I could probably sell it to fund the next one. I built my first AR and I have to say it is a damn fine piece of workmanship. It shoots 0.50" MOA to 0.75" MOA all day long at 100yds with my handloads. Only my bolt gun can shoot tighter groups. But now that I have built one, I decided to build a 300 AAC Blackout. Which before the range closure was showing some promise to be a good 200yd hunting rifle. And when time and money permits there might even be a third AR-15 platform in my safe. I am thinking either a 50 Beowolf or a Ruger 204. Or maybe both? I don't know. I have more fun building them and loading for them. But they are not as nice as my bolt guns and will never replace them. But they will sit next to them in my safe.

Also, I shoot most of the time with the Black Powder Shooters on Sundays. And I have to say I now own a Black Powder rifle and pistol and enjoy shooting them often. But on the other hand I have inspired two of them to build their own AR-15's and now they bring them often and shoot them right next to their black powder rifles. One of them is now building a 300 AAC Blackout just as I did. He is like me. Our passion lies elsewhere but the AR-15 platform has its place in our safes

In the meantime the AR-15 platform is what helps bring new shooters into our fold. I and I think it is not a good idea to make fun of those people as they are not only among us (as in our friends, family and 2A Members) but they are also the future of the shooting sports. To alienate them will only divide us shooters up into smaller parts. As one group we are stronger and have a chance at defeating those that want to take away our rights. So make fun of those of us who own AR-15's even tho I am far from a noob. Just remember there may be consequences to what you say. JMHO
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Rogue076 on December 13, 2013, 07:37:47 AM
I would like to add this to the discussion. For all of those who look down upon the AR-15 I want you to know this. I am not a HUGE fan of the AR-15 platform. I never was. I got into it because I wanted a semi-auto rifle that shoots the same round as my Remy 700 5R. When I heard how accurate they can be if done right I decided I wanted a new project to work on and I purchased a few lowers from X-Ring. I figured after I build and shoot it I could probably sell it to fund the next one. I built my first AR and I have to say it is a damn fine piece of workmanship. It shoots 0.50" MOA to 0.75" MOA all day long at 100yds with my handloads. Only my bolt gun can shoot tighter groups. But now that I have built one, I decided to build a 300 AAC Blackout. Which before the range closure was showing some promise to be a good 200yd hunting rifle. And when time and money permits there might even be a third AR-15 platform in my safe. I am thinking either a 50 Beowolf or a Ruger 204. Or maybe both? I don't know. I have more fun building them and loading for them. But they are not as nice as my bolt guns and will never replace them. But they will sit next to them in my safe.

Also, I shoot most of the time with the Black Powder Shooters on Sundays. And I have to say I now own a Black Powder rifle and pistol and enjoy shooting them often. But on the other hand I have inspired two of them to build their own AR-15's and now they bring them often and shoot them right next to their black powder rifles. One of them is now building a 300 AAC Blackout just as I did. He is like me. Our passion lies elsewhere but the AR-15 platform has its place in our safes

In the meantime the AR-15 platform is what helps bring new shooters into our fold. I and I think it is not a good idea to make fun of those people as they are not only among us (as in our friends, family and 2A Members) but they are also the future of the shooting sports. To alienate them will only divide us shooters up into smaller parts. As one group we are stronger and have a chance at defeating those that want to take away our rights. So make fun of those of us who own AR-15's even tho I am far from a noob. Just remember there may be consequences to what you say. JMHO

Im a new gun owner, which is what brought me here to get informed, educated and help me be the most responsible gun owner I can be but I guess theres always that "cool kid" anywhere you go with anything you do. For me the AR15 was cheap and its easily customizable for what I want it for, very easy to shoot and handle and just all around a good gun. I think you made a good point about alienating others in the gun community, I think guns and gun owners are under enough scrutiny, we don't need to scrutinize each other....
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Rogue076 on December 13, 2013, 07:38:42 AM
Great.  Let's just insult other gun owners and establish a stereotype of AR owners.  Everyone does have to start somewhere.  Did you offer some advice/guidance to perhaps help a "noob"?  Bet not.  Not everyone is lucky enough to have proper training.  You probably just watched and laughed to yourself about how there are sooo many "noobs" with AR's and how awesome you are. 

I admit I have seen new AR owners that probably never shot before(seen guys that don't know how to lock the bolt back manually), but instead of judging them, how about you offer some tips of proper shooting technique or safe gun handling?  Most "noobs" are very receptive to advice.

Well said.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: edster48 on December 13, 2013, 08:09:55 AM
Im a new gun owner, which is what brought me here to get informed, educated and help me be the most responsible gun owner I can be but I guess theres always that "cool kid" anywhere you go with anything you do. For me the AR15 was cheap and its easily customizable for what I want it for, very easy to shoot and handle and just all around a good gun. I think you made a good point about alienating others in the gun community, I think guns and gun owners are under enough scrutiny, we don't need to scrutinize each other....

Apologies, Rogue76. We're being monitored by someone [ he who shall not be named] who has an anti-gun agenda and it has us all in a heightened state of awareness, especially since the range closure. Your question was typical of something "he" would ask. I myself am considered a "newbie" here even though I've been a member since 2010. I've only recently become more involved and the members have been very accepting, and I don't think any of them know what I shoot!
We're having a range clean up day on the 29th, come on out if you have the time, and meet these guys, they're a good group and I'm sure you'll learn a lot.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: new guy on December 13, 2013, 08:20:37 AM
.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: aieahound on December 13, 2013, 09:45:52 AM
Q had the best answer when a girlfriend of his asked why he had so many guns:

Cause in America, that's how we roll.  :geekdanc:

And as for the AR-15 having no soul, there is no gun more American in my opinion. ( Other than maybe a 1911 )
Isn't it the longest running service rifle by a long margin ?
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Hunter1007 on December 13, 2013, 05:54:44 PM
Why buy a smoke detector and fire extinguisher? Why put on your seat belt? Why buy hurricane food/water? These are all things we prepare for which we hope we will never use for their intended purposes but we do so to safe guard our the lives of ourselves and our loved ones right? The percentages of these things, (house fire, car crash, hurricane) actually happening are relatively low. So what's the big deal about safeguarding ourselves from a riot, lawlessness during a hurricane, or someone wanting to do harm to you and or loved ones?

Sure the true spirit of the Second Ammendment was to keep the government in check but although a posibility, it is exponetially more unlikely than the other situations stated above.

I think the bigger question is why not let me own an AR? As long as I aquire it legally and obey the laws.
Title: .
Post by: Q on December 13, 2013, 05:56:44 PM
.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Funtimes on December 13, 2013, 06:40:19 PM
I need an AR-15 because they penetrate less than handguns in the interior of the home (9mm/45).  Because of this, they are safer to discharge and generally less likely to kill someone in adjacent room where I did not intend to discharge the gun.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Sturmgeschutz on December 13, 2013, 07:54:27 PM
I live in an older neighborhood of single wall T&G homes.... I am very hesitant to let anything off bigger than a slingshot or some angry termites.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: AmbuBadger on December 14, 2013, 07:21:38 AM
I'm 5'11" and 195 pounds; my girlfriend is 4'10" and 97 pounds. This is the only rifle that fits both of us. You can't expect to win over some of these people... They have it ingrained in their heads that your personal protection is the responsibility of the police, and why not? Thanks to welfare, Obamacare, EBT, etc., everything is the responsibility of our government.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: sworbeyegib on December 14, 2013, 09:55:20 AM
A few facts about gun fights, defending yourself against an aggressor.

You don't get to choose when a gunfight happens.
You don't get to choose where a gunfight happens.
You don't get to choose who you are in a gunfight with.
You don't get to choose how many people you will be in a gun fight with.
You don't get to choose what kind of guns or equipment they will be using.
You don't get to choose what kind of mindset they will be thinking.

You DO get to choose what kind of firearm you can keep at ready.
You DO get to choose whether to put in the proper time training with that firearm.

The factors are almost always stacked against you. The one variable you can control is using the best firearm you can, and knowing how to use it the best you can.
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: justin1098 on December 14, 2013, 11:20:02 AM
I think Q has the winning answer.

"Why do I need an AR-15? Because F*CK YOU...That's why. 'MURICA!"

(http://i.imgur.com/wrP6A.jpg)
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Rocky on December 14, 2013, 11:36:33 AM
So good I stold it from New Guy..

www.youtube.com/watch?v=20RoAfflGCM (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=20RoAfflGCM#)   :thumbsup:

I have an  AR cuz it's a chick magnet !
duh
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Rogue076 on December 14, 2013, 05:20:07 PM
Apologies, Rogue76. We're being monitored by someone [ he who shall not be named] who has an anti-gun agenda and it has us all in a heightened state of awareness, especially since the range closure. Your question was typical of something "he" would ask. I myself am considered a "newbie" here even though I've been a member since 2010. I've only recently become more involved and the members have been very accepting, and I don't think any of them know what I shoot!
We're having a range clean up day on the 29th, come on out if you have the time, and meet these guys, they're a good group and I'm sure you'll learn a lot.

Typical gun owers...blast first, ask questions later! JK! And I'm sure everyone here is pretty cool but theres always someone that wants to be cooler than the other but that's anywhere you go so it doesn't really bother me at all. Thanks for clearing things up though...
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Rogue076 on December 14, 2013, 05:28:26 PM
1.  Welcome to the forum, Rogue076.

2.  Punctuation is your friend.

3.  If a new member to ANY forum asks a "loaded" question, it is only natural to expect that the question (and by extension, the new forum member) be met with a certain amount of suspicion.

4.  I am not sure what you mean when you say, "its kinda futile to ask these things on a pro gun forum."  This statement, alone, pushes the indicator toward the "more suspicious" side of my internal Bullshit Detector.  Despite the way in which certain politicians and the media try to demonize gun owners, and despite the (mis)perceptions that members of the non-gun owning general public may have, the majority of gun owners are respectful, responsible, intelligent individuals, who can rationally discuss gun-related and non-gun-related issues. As evidenced by the responses from the forum members, thus far, I hope this would have been self-evident.

5.  Amendment II to the Constitution of the United States of America provides that, "...the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."  There is a distinction between a "need" and a "right."  What do you think would happen if that same question that pro-gun control proponents are using, were applied to the First Amendment ("Why do you need to have the ability to practice your form of religion?" Or, "Why do you need to have the ability to say or write whatever you want to say or write?"), the Fourth Amendment ("Why do you need to have a right against unreasonable searches and seizures?"), or the Fifth Amendment ("Why do you need to have due process before being deprived of life, liberty, or property?").  It isn't about a "need"... it is all about a "right."

When I said futile I meant that when I'm asking a pro gun forum a question about this kind of thing, I'm definitely gonna get a pro gun answer. The question I asked was kinda meant to be more of a light hearted question, a bash at Piers Morgan if you will, but at the same time it could be taken serisouly because hes obviously using it for an anti gun agenda. It was more or less a hypothetical one, if you were sitting in his show being interviewed, what would you tell him. And I understand and appreciate the distinction between the "need" and the "right" as well as that perspective. This would be a whole other thread but when it comes down to the rights of americans, I feel they are slowly being swept out from under us...
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Rogue076 on December 14, 2013, 05:29:50 PM
I think Q has the winning answer.

Definitely wouldn't mind giving this answer and picture to Piers Morgan, but then I'm sure he'd use it in a way to discredit the cause....
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Rogue076 on December 14, 2013, 05:31:49 PM
A few facts about gun fights, defending yourself against an aggressor.

You don't get to choose when a gunfight happens.
You don't get to choose where a gunfight happens.
You don't get to choose who you are in a gunfight with.
You don't get to choose how many people you will be in a gun fight with.
You don't get to choose what kind of guns or equipment they will be using.
You don't get to choose what kind of mindset they will be thinking.

You DO get to choose what kind of firearm you can keep at ready.
You DO get to choose whether to put in the proper time training with that firearm.

The factors are almost always stacked against you. The one variable you can control is using the best firearm you can, and knowing how to use it the best you can.

I liked this answer...
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: sworbeyegib on December 14, 2013, 06:14:37 PM
I need an AR-15 because they penetrate less than handguns in the interior of the home (9mm/45).  Because of this, they are safer to discharge and generally less likely to kill someone in adjacent room where I did not intend to discharge the gun.

I am a huge proponent for carbines for HD defense.  So many people are still stuck in the old mindset that the 5.56/.223 will zip thru exponentially more walls than a handgun caliber.  Its been proven over and again in recent years that they shed their energy faster and begin to tumble/fragment much faster than 9mm/.45. 

There is a good reason most agencies and departments that do house clearing have switched from subguns, to SBR carbines. 

 
Title: Re: Why do you need and AR15?
Post by: Darmok and Jalad @Tanagra on December 19, 2013, 08:31:43 PM
(http://i944.photobucket.com/albums/ad287/Doug_Moose/ReasonsforAR-15_zps1c3d4931.jpg) (http://s944.photobucket.com/user/Doug_Moose/media/ReasonsforAR-15_zps1c3d4931.jpg.html)