2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: punaperson on April 10, 2016, 05:28:07 PM
-
Article in Hawai'i Free Press from NRA-ILA about the five bills coming up for floor votes this week (Tuesday). Includes a one-click link to auto-send emails to your state rep and senator.
Five Anti-Gun Bills Scheduled for Floor Votes This Week
http://www.hawaiifreepress.com/ArticlesMain/tabid/56/ID/17275/Hawaii-Five-Anti-Gun-Bills-Scheduled-for-Floor-Votes-This-Week.aspx (http://www.hawaiifreepress.com/ArticlesMain/tabid/56/ID/17275/Hawaii-Five-Anti-Gun-Bills-Scheduled-for-Floor-Votes-This-Week.aspx)
From NRA-ILA, April 10, 2016
Last week, four anti-gun bills, House Bill 625, House Bill 2632, House Bill 2629 and Senate Bill 2647 were given notice to be placed on the Senate and House floor calendars for next Tuesday, April 12. Additionally, Senate Bill 2954 passed the House of Representatives and is scheduled for its final concurrence vote in the Senate on Tuesday as well. Please click the “Take Action” button below to contact your state legislators in opposition to these anti-gun bills!
https://act.nraila.org/composeletters.aspx?AlertID=168 (https://act.nraila.org/composeletters.aspx?AlertID=168)
-
Here's an online poll for Thielen's constituency.
http://www.senatorlaurathielen.com/survey-questions-chance-legislator-part-2-house-bills/
-
Article in Hawai'i Free Press from NRA-ILA about the five bills coming up for floor votes this week (Tuesday). Includes a one-click link to auto-send emails to your state rep and senator.
Five Anti-Gun Bills Scheduled for Floor Votes This Week
http://www.hawaiifreepress.com/ArticlesMain/tabid/56/ID/17275/Hawaii-Five-Anti-Gun-Bills-Scheduled-for-Floor-Votes-This-Week.aspx (http://www.hawaiifreepress.com/ArticlesMain/tabid/56/ID/17275/Hawaii-Five-Anti-Gun-Bills-Scheduled-for-Floor-Votes-This-Week.aspx)
From NRA-ILA, April 10, 2016
Last week, four anti-gun bills, House Bill 625, House Bill 2632, House Bill 2629 and Senate Bill 2647 were given notice to be placed on the Senate and House floor calendars for next Tuesday, April 12. Additionally, Senate Bill 2954 passed the House of Representatives and is scheduled for its final concurrence vote in the Senate on Tuesday as well. Please click the “Take Action” button below to contact your state legislators in opposition to these anti-gun bills!
https://act.nraila.org/composeletters.aspx?AlertID=168 (https://act.nraila.org/composeletters.aspx?AlertID=168)
Aloha,
It is critical that you write to your Senator. We only have until tomorrow, but if you could send a quick email or fax or even make a phone call, it would help immensely. The House vote was very close on SB 2954. If the four representatives had not been absent, the bill might not have passed. We need several hundred emails, faxes, letters, phone calls to go to the senators to oppose all four bills, as they are severely flawed and unconstitutional, if we want to try to influence the vote. And, sadly, if even one bill passes this year, it will be a message to the anti-gun legislators to push harder next year and try for additional bad bills. Session is almost over....we have to fight harder....we can do this, if enough gun owners get involved.
Thank you!!!!!
Kerry
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: "Madeleine" <emailsentby@icontact.com>
Date: Apr 11, 2016 08:06
Subject: Contact your Senator about the four anti gun bills up for vote on Tuesday
To: <itsmeksn@gmail.com>
Cc:
State Affiliate of the National Rifle Association - Founded in 1857
April 11, 2016
On Tuesday, April 12, the Senate will vote on HB 625 (misdemeanor harrassment), HB 2629 (Rap Back), SB 2954 (Rap back), and HB 2632 (emergency hospitalization.
We need everyone to write to their Senators to kill these bills. You can email all of the Senators with one email to:
Sens@capitol.hawaii.gov
If they don't hear from enough of us, they'll pass the bills. Get involved NOW. You need to contact your senator before Tuesday, April 12. If it goes to the Governor, our chances of killing the bills reduce significantly.
Also, please go to NRA, https://www.nraila.org/articles/20160410/hawaii-anti-gun-bills-scheduled-for-floor-votes-next-week to send a message to your personal Legislators.
MAHALO
HARVEY GERWIG, LEGISLATIVE LIAISON and PRESIDENT, HRA
EMAIL: HGHAWAII@GMAIL.COM, PHONE: (808) 306-7194
-
If there was ever a time for action, it is now. Over the last several weeks we have been asking that Hawaii's gun owners contact their respective legislators to help fight these bad bills. And some have responded, but if you look at the testimony submitted, it has numbered from 10-40 pieces submitted. That is pathetic.
How many people are registered on this forum alone? There is no reason we shouldn't be able to get hundreds of letters and testimony on a regular basis, but we can never seem to do that. Why?
If these measures pass you can rest assured folks like Karl Rhoades will be emboldened to submit more and more anti-gun bills next year. It's your choice....and your rights. Do something
-
I do love that "Take Action" button!
-
If there was ever a time for action, it is now. Over the last several weeks we have been asking that Hawaii's gun owners contact their respective legislators to help fight these bad bills. And some have responded, but if you look at the testimony submitted, it has numbered from 10-40 pieces submitted. That is pathetic.
How many people are registered on this forum alone? There is no reason we shouldn't be able to get hundreds of letters and testimony on a regular basis, but we can never seem to do that. Why?
If these measures pass you can rest assured folks like Karl Rhoades will be emboldened to submit more and more anti-gun bills next year. It's your choice....and your rights. Do something
HiC, you are correct that there are approx 3000 registered users, but there are only 1-200 that are active members
we have been actively trying to recruit new members and rally the troops, but as you know from the HRA mailing lists, it is a constant battle to get people to be active
it is a critical time, people
and we need to hit these bills HARD if we want to have any chance of stopping them
-
If there was ever a time for action, it is now. Over the last several weeks we have been asking that Hawaii's gun owners contact their respective legislators to help fight these bad bills. And some have responded, but if you look at the testimony submitted, it has numbered from 10-40 pieces submitted. That is pathetic.
How many people are registered on this forum alone? There is no reason we shouldn't be able to get hundreds of letters and testimony on a regular basis, but we can never seem to do that. Why?
If these measures pass you can rest assured folks like Karl Rhoades will be emboldened to submit more and more anti-gun bills next year. It's your choice....and your rights. Do something
I concur in your lament, only I don't think "pathetic" is a strong enough or accurate enough word. The truth is, collectively (that includes us, unfortunately) the people of Hawaii have the government they want and vote, or don't vote, for. Pretty simple. It's a fact (unless you believe there is enough voter fraud to explain the extremely lopsided results). The only thing that I believe could possibly start to steer the ship in another direction would be a huge influx of election campaign funding from the likes of a libertarian/conservative Bloombergian-type donor(s). Pretty sure that ain't gonna happen (Hawaii is such "small potatoes", why bother?). I've spent a huge number of hours researching issues, writing and submitting (sometimes lengthy) testimony, writing, emailing, and calling senators, representatives, the governor, the AG, police departments, county councils, etc., all to, apparently, no avail. How are you going to get uninterested and/or apathetic and/or people who believe "the system is rigged and your vote or input doesn't matter" to act? Oviously whatever strategies have been tried, don't work, at least not for Second Amendment issues. That being said, I gotta go send a few more emails and make a few more phone calls to traitors who politely tell me they will consider my "thoughts on the subject", then stab me in the back. :crazy: :geekdanc: :shaka:
-
HiC, you are correct that there are approx 3000 registered users, but there are only 1-200 that are active members
we have been actively trying to recruit new members and rally the troops, but as you know from the HRA mailing lists, it is a constant battle to get people to be active
it is a critical time, people
and we need to hit these bills HARD if we want to have any chance of stopping them
Mac,
I guess that's the point. There are 200 "active members" so we should be able to get more participation than we have.
And, don't get me wrong, I am just as disappointed with the HRA members as well. It is an ongoing problem that I have seen for many years, but it seems especially prevalent here (well, on internet forums in general, not just here). You post about a new unilateral procedure that HPD implements about firearms (an entirely hypothetical statement for illustration only) here and you get dozens of folks that will make multiple posts, spending literally hours complaining about said new procedure, but then those same folks can't find time to submit testimony or call/email their legislators because they're "too busy."
The bottom line is that Hawaii's gun owners, in general are apathetic when it comes to getting involved and yet extremely vocal when it comes to complaining about things. And, until it changes, we will always be fighting from a disadvantaged position.
For those like yourself (Mac) and others that have taken the time and put forth the effort, thank you! For those that are sitting back and finding excuses for not getting involved: shame on you.
-
Sent testimony on all 5 bills (again). Our legislators interpret a lack of testimony from us as "we're okay with it". It only takes a few minutes to send testimony. Let's send them a clear message that we don't want these bills.
-
Done. Again.
-
Aloha! Sorry for the late action, but I just clicked the link to show support and notified others who may not have heard. Mahalo for the diligence and foresight to notify the 2AHawaii Ohana!
Happy Tuesday!
BikerCarl
-
Aloha! Sorry for the late action, but I just clicked the link to show support and notified others who may not have heard. Mahalo for the diligence and foresight to notify the 2AHawaii Ohana!
Happy Tuesday!
BikerCarl
sent to sens@capitol.hawaii.gov:
these bills place unnecesary burdens on LEGAL gun owners, and in the case of the RAP BACK bills, they violate Federal law regarding personal registration information
if you want to stop potential gun violence, efforts need to be concentrated on the mentally ill and ILLEGAL gun owners
aloha and mahalo
sf, dds
-
prolly late however I just emailed the senators bulk mail and Cc'ed mine just in case
-
As of 1:09 PM Tuesday:
We're 0 for 3, all losses by huge margins, almost unanimous against us! Testimony shmestimony!
(Please note that senator Slom is not voting due to heart surgery.)
HB625 HD1 SD1
Specifies that harassment by stalking and sexual assault are among the offenses that disqualify a person from owning, possessing, or controlling any firearm or ammunition. (SD1).
4/12/2016 S Report adopted; Passed Third Reading, as amended (SD 1). Ayes, 22; Aye(s) with reservations: Senator(s) K.Kahele, Kidani, Riviere, Wakai . Noes, 2 (Senator(s) Harimoto, Ihara). Excused, 1 (Senator(s) Slom). Transmitted to House.
HB2629 HD2 SD2
Criminal History Record Checks; Police; Permits to Acquire Firearms; Firearm Registration; Rap Back System
Authorizes county police departments to enroll firearms permit applicants and individuals who are registering their firearms into a criminal record monitoring service used to alert police when an owner of a firearm is arrested for a criminal offense anywhere in the country. (SD2)
4/12/2016 S Report adopted; Passed Third Reading, as amended (SD 2). Ayes, 23; Aye(s) with reservations: Senator(s) Wakai . Noes, 1 (Senator(s) Gabbard). Excused, 1 (Senator(s) Slom). Transmitted to House.
SB2647 SD1 HD2
Wildlife; Species; Trafficking; Fines
Prohibits the sale, offer to sell, purchase, trade, possession with intent to sell, or barter of any part or product from various animal and marine species. Provides exceptions to this prohibition, including for traditional cultural practices protected under the State Constitution. Imposes penalties for violations of the prohibition on trafficking animal parts and products. (SB2647 HD2)
4/12/2016 H Passed Third Reading as amended in HD 2 with Representative(s) Tupola voting aye with reservations; none voting no (0) and Representative(s) Ing, Thielen excused (2). Transmitted to Senate.
-
The message received by Senators and Representatives is that gun owners don't have a problem with their rights being reduced. With the thousands of gun owners in the state, only a few submitted testimony or contacted their legislators in opposition to these bills. Less than 100 testimonies opposing each bill was submitted, that's less than 1% of all gun owners in Hawaii. If gun owners continue to be apathetic in a State with some of the most restrictive gun laws, expect to see more of your rights being taken away.
HB 625 - Misdemeanor harrassment disqualifies a person from owning, possessing, or controlling a gun
HB 2629 - Rap Back
HB 2632 - Emergency Hospitalization results in immediate removal of all firearms
MAHALO
HARVEY GERWIG, LEGISLATIVE LIAISON and PRESIDENT, HRA
EMAIL: HGHAWAII@GMAIL.COM, PHONE: (808) 306-7194
-
The message received by Senators and Representatives is that gun owners don't have a problem with their rights being reduced. With the thousands of gun owners in the state, only a few submitted testimony or contacted their legislators in opposition to these bills. Less than 100 testimonies opposing each bill was submitted, that's less than 1% of all gun owners in Hawaii. If gun owners continue to be apathetic in a State with some of the most restrictive gun laws, expect to see more of your rights being taken away.
HB 625 - Misdemeanor harrassment disqualifies a person from owning, possessing, or controlling a gun
HB 2629 - Rap Back
HB 2632 - Emergency Hospitalization results in immediate removal of all firearms
MAHALO
HARVEY GERWIG, LEGISLATIVE LIAISON and PRESIDENT, HRA
EMAIL: HGHAWAII@GMAIL.COM, PHONE: (808) 306-7194
How many peopel supported them tho ?? when you look of the ratio of people against and for, to the people who knew these laws were even in play, the ratio is still in our faavor, The problem is we have a ruling class who think they know best and do what they want rather then what the people want.
-
These are all feel good law that have no consequence on gun crime or crime in general. The only people they effect are legal gun owners.
-
how about a pro 2a rally at the range?
-
How many peopel supported them tho ?? when you look of the ratio of people against and for, to the people who knew these laws were even in play, the ratio is still in our faavor, The problem is we have a ruling class who think they know best and do what they want rather then what the people want.
True. We were ignored.
Apparently because we lack funding to buy enough politicians off.
I'm willing to work my butt off, HRA is too, but if nobody gives a shit why should I bother? If this kind of crap legislation isn't enough to get people pissed off and willing to do something I don't know what is.
I'm beginning to think I should just focus my efforts on getting the f*ck out of this state to somewhere the Constitution is still considered something worth protecting and respecting.
Texas is looking good, rattlesnakes, softball sized hail and all.
-
True. We were ignored.
Apparently because we lack funding to buy enough politicians off.
I'm willing to work my butt off, HRA is too, but if nobody gives a shit why should I bother? If this kind of crap legislation isn't enough to get people pissed off and willing to do something I don't know what is.
I'm beginning to think I should just focus my efforts on getting the f*ck out of this state to somewhere the Constitution is still considered something worth protecting and respecting.
Texas is looking good, rattlesnakes, softball sized hail and all.
I am starting to think your way too. The roots are deep. Born and raised here, but still think of leaving.
My kid did. Saw no future here as backwards as this place is sometimes. Sold his boat, truck and all that he didn't need and left.
Drives trucks on the mainland now doing well.
That said, what is the next step? Do we have any more chances? where do these measures go from here? and how do we keep fighting?
If any of this gets to the guv, you know he will sign.
Aloha
-
how about a pro 2a rally at the range?
Ren, I want to preface my following remarks by saying I'm not attacking you or your idea. But, regarding a pro-2A rally at the range: Why and to what ends?
To show other shooters "we" support the Second Amendment? That should be evident? To get together and strategize how to move forward with any advocacy efforts? Maybe print out and pass out to shooters using the range a flyer saying the anti-gun bills are going to pass because "we" couldn't come together as a group and muster an adequate defense against these incremental infringements of our rights?
I'm not saying we shouldn't, but just that we need to make sure we have a clear and obtainable goal in mind if we do. And, in that regard, how many of those here belong to some type of gun club or organization? IF you do, what did YOU do to get the other members of your organization to participate? Did you take time out of your "fun time" to talk to the guys (and girls) you shot with Saturday/Sunday or did you spend the entire day "doing what you do?"
/rant off
-
I am starting to think your way too. The roots are deep. Born and raised here, but still think of leaving.
My kid did. Saw no future here as backwards as this place is sometimes. Sold his boat, truck and all that he didn't need and left.
Drives trucks on the mainland now doing well.
That said, what is the next step? Do we have any more chances? where do these measures go from here? and how do we keep fighting?
If any of this gets to the guv, you know he will sign.
Aloha
we can let the guv know how we feel, http://governor.hawaii.gov/contact-us/
-
Any lawsuit forming to point out the FOPA violation of the rapback? maybe we can get the FBI to tell the state to that stuff is going right into the shredder.
-
I am starting to think your way too. The roots are deep. Born and raised here, but still think of leaving.
My kid did. Saw no future here as backwards as this place is sometimes. Sold his boat, truck and all that he didn't need and left.
Drives trucks on the mainland now doing well.
That said, what is the next step? Do we have any more chances? where do these measures go from here? and how do we keep fighting?
If any of this gets to the guv, you know he will sign.
Aloha
Appealing to the Governor is the last step. But, to be effective the response would have to be overwhelming and and in numbers sufficient to make him think his reelection may be in danger. And, to be honest, I don't think that will happen.
Instead, the gov will get 40 odd letters (from a base of a 100,000+ gun owners...) and feel pretty confident that we couldn't mount any effort that would threaten his continued political career. In fact, he may see the general lack of response as tacit approval of these bills (and even if he doesn't actually think that you can bet that's what he's going to say..."Judging from the miniscule number of gun owners that opposed these bills, the vast majority Hawaii's gun owners support our 'common sense' efforts to keep guns out of the hands of criminals and mentally ill persons..."). So, from a long-range, tactical point of view, it may be better to not send the gov anything at all....
-
Any lawsuit forming to point out the FOPA violation of the rapback? maybe we can get the FBI to tell the state to that stuff is going right into the shredder.
Gonna cost lot's of money. Where is it going to come from?
-
Appealing to the Governor is the last step. But, to be effective the response would have to be overwhelming and and in numbers sufficient to make him think his reelection may be in danger. And, to be honest, I don't think that will happen.
Instead, the gov will get 40 odd letters (from a base of a 100,000+ gun owners...) and feel pretty confident that we couldn't mount any effort that would threaten his continued political career. In fact, he may see the general lack of response as tacit approval of these bills (and even if he doesn't actually think that you can bet that's what he's going to say..."Judging from the miniscule number of gun owners that opposed these bills, the vast majority Hawaii's gun owners support our 'common sense' efforts to keep guns out of the hands of criminals and mentally ill persons..."). So, from a long-range, tactical point of view, it may be better to not send the gov anything at all....
I suspect that his re-election may be in danger anyway, but not from us. He hasn't got much going for him IMHO.
-
How many peopel supported them tho ?? when you look of the ratio of people against and for, to the people who knew these laws were even in play, the ratio is still in our faavor, The problem is we have a ruling class who think they know best and do what they want rather then what the people want.
True. We were ignored.
Apparently because we lack funding to buy enough politicians off.
I'm willing to work my butt off, HRA is too, but if nobody gives a shit why should I bother? If this kind of crap legislation isn't enough to get people pissed off and willing to do something I don't know what is.
That said, what is the next step? Do we have any more chances? where do these measures go from here? and how do we keep fighting?
If any of this gets to the guv, you know he will sign.
I've written about this conundrum, or Catch-22 situation on other threads in the past. How many emails, how many testimony submissions, how many phone calls, how many in-person oral testimonies would be required to change the outcome of the votes on these types of infringing laws? We already had huge ratios in our favor in some cases, merely significant ratios in our favor in other cases, and the committees and entire body (house or senate) yield nearly unanimous votes against us. I suspect that no amount of testimony and/or contacts will make any difference in these outcomes unless it was enough to suggest to the legislators that they might not be re-elected in their district. The "catch" is that if there were really enough opposition to these bills by the voters to threaten their re-election, those politicians wouldn't have been elected by those voters in the first place (and no such bills would ever be introduced). Why would they vote in someone who clearly opposed upholding their sworn duty to uphold the voters' constitutionally-guaranteed rights? I seriously doubt that "shaming", as some have written, will turn the tide and inspire people to get involved in making their views known to their legislators, or even voting. What will? No idea. As I wrote last week I believe that the only thing that could possibly change things would be a huge influx of campaign spending money, and I don't see that happening. Ever. There will be no relief from the courts, as those (higher court) judges are all appointed by the politicians they (often) supposedly impartially interpret the law against.
These bills will be up for their final votes shortly, and yes, I will again send the emails and make the phone calls, but I predict the same outcome we saw today. Near unanimous disregard for our rights. :crazy: :wtf:
-
The only way we're going to change this is to get pro 2A legislators elected.
The current crop of crawl on their belly for a buck, Obama sycophants is just going to keep on doing what the dimocrats have been doing for years.
The few good ones are getting older, and there doesn't seem to be anyone in line to replace them. The republican party is preparing to self destruct at the national level and it's a virtually empty shell here.
To organize any serious offensive against the dimocrats here would require millions, maybe tens of millions, every election cycle. Progress would be measured in single digit gains, we've lost too much political ground over the last 25 years to make it up in one or two election cycles. With all the screw ups with the rail, Obamacare, infrastructure and everything else, you would think that the republicans would be rolling with their hair on fire and putting more candidates out there to show they could change all this. But they're not. The few we have are superb, Sam Slom And Gene Ward for example, But they can't do it on their own, and the party doesn't have the numbers to give them the support they need.
Unless we can pull a seriously huge rabbit out of an incredibly small hat, I don't see much of a change in the near future.
-
I've written about this conundrum, or Catch-22 situation on other threads in the past. How many emails, how many testimony submissions, how many phone calls, how many in-person oral testimonies would be required to change the outcome of the votes on these types of infringing laws? We already had huge ratios in our favor in some cases, merely significant ratios in our favor in other cases, and the committees and entire body (house or senate) yield nearly unanimous votes against us. I suspect that no amount of testimony and/or contacts will make any difference in these outcomes unless it was enough to suggest to the legislators that they might not be re-elected in their district. The "catch" is that if there were really enough opposition to these bills by the voters to threaten their re-election, those politicians wouldn't have been elected by those voters in the first place (and no such bills would ever be introduced). Why would they vote in someone who clearly opposed upholding their sworn duty to uphold the voters' constitutionally-guaranteed rights? I seriously doubt that "shaming", as some have written, will turn the tide and inspire people to get involved in making their views known to their legislators, or even voting. What will? No idea. As I wrote last week I believe that the only thing that could possibly change things would be a huge influx of campaign spending money, and I don't see that happening. Ever. There will be no relief from the courts, as those (higher court) judges are all appointed by the politicians they (often) supposedly impartially interpret the law against.
These bills will be up for their final votes shortly, and yes, I will again send the emails and make the phone calls, but I predict the same outcome we saw today. Near unanimous disregard for our rights. :crazy: :wtf:
It is not "ratios" that will speak to the legislators, it is pure numbers. 40 pieces of submitted legislation, even if they are all unanimous and there are no testimony in opposition will be disregarded.
We have the numbers if everyone participated, but they never do...
-
The only way we're going to change this is to get pro 2A legislators elected.
I agree with you Edster48. Just want to put a slightly different take on this.
The solution does not necessarily lie in the R or L party as they are not a big factor right now for the state of Hawaii.
I just want to point out that we have some very staunch supporters for 2A rights in the D party as well, although they are more the exception than the rule.
We need to get more Pro-2a legislators on the D party elected as well.
The second amendment is not an issue that belongs to the R party alone. Although they may not have your interest in exercising it, the second amendment is a right that protects the liberal / democratic leaning folks as well.
-
It is not "ratios" that will speak to the legislators, it is pure numbers. 40 pieces of submitted legislation, even if they are all unanimous and there are no testimony in opposition will be disregarded.
We have the numbers if everyone participated, but they never do...
It's obviously NOT "pure numbers". Some of these bills had six (6) submitted testimonies in favor. You're saying that six is "pure numbers" and the opposing 40 or 70 or 106 are not "pure numbers"? What gives? Magic numbers or what?
Why should "our side" have to produce enormous numbers to hold sway, while "the other side" need not produce such numbers, or any numbers at all (according to you) and that "no (or almost no) visible public support" rules the roost?
Please explain that in the context of "consent of the governed". Or any context at all.
I doubt that ANY number at all from statewide testimony and emails/calls would make any difference at all. The only thing that matters to (almost all of) these politicians is what they believe the majority of voters in their district will do next election. I'd guess (and it's just a guess) that there is likely not one single district in Hawaii where even if every single gun owner voted or submitted testimony/emailed/called that it would make any difference. I could be wrong. But we'll never find out because that will never happen due to, uh, wait a second, what's it called?... oh, yeah, "reality".
AND, even if the "majority" wants to infringe individual rights (by supporting or allowing infringing laws to be passed), even if EVERYONE excepting one person wants to infringe everyone else's natural individual fundamental constitutionally-guaranteed civil rights the whole point of the Bill of Rights is that those rights are unalienable no matter what the tyranny of the majority does. You know, the soapbox, the ballot box, the jury box, and then that other box...
-
It's obviously NOT "pure numbers". Some of these bills had six (6) submitted testimonies in favor. You're saying that six is "pure numbers" and the opposing 40 or 70 or 106 are not "pure numbers"? What gives? Magic numbers or what?
Why should "our side" have to produce enormous numbers to hold sway, while "the other side" need not produce such numbers, or any numbers at all (according to you) and that "no (or almost no) visible public support" rules the roost?
Please explain that in the context of "consent of the governed". Or any context at all.
I doubt that ANY number at all from statewide testimony and emails/calls would make any difference at all. The only thing that matters to (almost all of) these politicians is what they believe the majority of voters in their district will do next election. I'd guess (and it's just a guess) that there is likely not one single district in Hawaii where even if every single gun owner voted or submitted testimony/emailed/called that it would make any difference. I could be wrong. But we'll never find out because that will never happen due to, uh, wait a second, what's it called?... oh, yeah, "reality".
AND, even if the "majority" wants to infringe individual rights (by supporting or allowing infringing laws to be passed), even if EVERYONE excepting one person wants to infringe everyone else's natural individual fundamental constitutionally-guaranteed civil rights the whole point of the Bill of Rights is that those rights are unalienable no matter what the tyranny of the majority does. You know, the soapbox, the ballot box, the jury box, and then that other box...
You can bitch and moan all you like about "how it should be" and that we shouldn't have to work so hard to prevent our rights from being infringed under the theory of a Constitutional Republic where the tyranny of the majority is muted by the protections of our Bill of Rights, but that just ain't reality.
There is no "magic number" but numbers matter. Calling and pressuring not just your own legislators matter. Contributing money to organizations that support your view matters. Does it go against the very basic instincts of those that believe in the Constitution and the Bill of Rights and the protections we believe it should protect? Yep, but standing up saying "it shouldn't be this way" will never change anything. Action is the answer. And, unfortunately we don't have enough of it....
-
It appears that we may have another opportunity to influence the outcome of these bills. Look for another message from HRA within the next hour.
-
You can bitch and moan all you like about "how it should be" and that we shouldn't have to work so hard to prevent our rights from being infringed under the theory of a Constitutional Republic where the tyranny of the majority is muted by the protections of our Bill of Rights, but that just ain't reality.
There is no "magic number" but numbers matter. Calling and pressuring not just your own legislators matter. Contributing money to organizations that support your view matters. Does it go against the very basic instincts of those that believe in the Constitution and the Bill of Rights and the protections we believe it should protect? Yep, but standing up saying "it shouldn't be this way" will never change anything. Action is the answer. And, unfortunately we don't have enough of it....
I never wrote anything at all about "how it should be" (or "shouldn't be"). YOU'RE the one writing about how more gun owners SHOULD get involved, yet you have no plan at all except to "bitch and moan" about it and tell them they should be "ashamed" to not do what you want them to do, even though there is no evidence that if they did what you attempt to shame them in to doing that it would have a beneficial outcome. You're hypothesizing about "how it should be" ("if "enough" of you were "active" legislation would go our way") without any data to support your claim.
Show me the percentage of gun owners in the voting age population of every Hawaii legislative district. Show me the percentage of gun owners compared to non-gun owners that are registered voters in every Hawaii legislative district. Now, show me how you're going to get whatever percentage of them you claim is necessary to accomplish your goals if they are active, active. Otherwise all you're doing is "bitching and moaning" and spewing hypotheticals about "how it should be".
-
It appears that we may have another opportunity to influence the outcome of these bills. Look for another message from HRA within the next hour.
Here it is:
WE'RE NOT DONE YET!!! Over a thousand messages were sent to legislators asking them to oppose the anti-gun bills moving in the legislature. We need to continue the push and let them know WE VOTE and we are asking them to OPPOSE these bills because they are flawed and unconstitutional. Attached is a link to the NRA alert, where you can click on the TAKE ACTION button and letters will be sent on your behalf to your legislators. You can email all representatives with reps@capitol.hawaii.gov and all senators at sens@capitol.hawaii.gov. You should ALSO email AND call your district legislator and let them hear your concerns. We can do this, but WE MUST STAND TOGETHER!!!
Link to the NRA alert:
https://www.nraila.org/articles/20160413/hawaii-four-anti-gun-bills-pass-floor-vote
HB 625 - Misdemeanor harrassment disqualifies a person from owning, possessing, or controlling a gun
HB 2629 and SB 2954 - Rap Back
HB 2632 - Emergency Hospitalization results in immediate removal of all firearms
SB 2647 - Ban on ivory sale, purchase, barter and possession
MAHALO
HARVEY GERWIG, LEGISLATIVE LIAISON and PRESIDENT, HRA
-
Here it is:
WE'RE NOT DONE YET!!! Over a thousand messages were sent to legislators asking them to oppose the anti-gun bills moving in the legislature. We need to continue the push and let them know WE VOTE and we are asking them to OPPOSE these bills because they are flawed and unconstitutional. Attached is a link to the NRA alert, where you can click on the TAKE ACTION button and letters will be sent on your behalf to your legislators. You can email all representatives with reps@capitol.hawaii.gov and all senators at sens@capitol.hawaii.gov. You should ALSO email AND call your district legislator and let them hear your concerns. We can do this, but WE MUST STAND TOGETHER!!!
Link to the NRA alert:
https://www.nraila.org/articles/20160413/hawaii-four-anti-gun-bills-pass-floor-vote
HB 625 - Misdemeanor harrassment disqualifies a person from owning, possessing, or controlling a gun
HB 2629 and SB 2954 - Rap Back
HB 2632 - Emergency Hospitalization results in immediate removal of all firearms
SB 2647 - Ban on ivory sale, purchase, barter and possession
MAHALO
HARVEY GERWIG, LEGISLATIVE LIAISON and PRESIDENT, HRA
posted to the hawaii firearms facebook groups i belong to
please post everywhere you can, guys
and then SEND EMAILS!!!!!
-
Done. Super quick and easy. If you've order something online, this is easier (don't need CC information ;D )
-
Done!
and shared on social media. :thumbsup:
-
Done this again. I also contacted my close friends who mostly don't own firearms.
I do speak of these bills when I attend our club activities and generate conversation - though it is preaching to the choir.
Out club secretary is also very active in emailing our members about these bills. His emails echo those of HRA as well. :thumbsup:
-
Take Action kicks Ass !
How do we set up something like this ?
Anyone know how ?
2AHawaii. Figure this out so we can do it from this forum. :D
(Easy for me to say.)
Would've been a good time for another Capitol rally.
(Hopefully we could've got twelve guys again) :wacko:
Especially against rap back.
Would they let us in the gallery or would we look like crazy gun owners.
Testimony doesn't appear to be working. IMO.
(But I'll keep giving it.)
-
From the HRA alert earlier today:
"Over a thousand messages were sent to legislators asking them to oppose the anti-gun bills moving in the legislature."
Could someone please clarify this statistic? One thousand separate individuals sent emails? Or what? I myself sent over 300 emails (NRA-ILA to all legislators, and separately my own arguments against each of the three bills to every legislator), so I'm wondering what the "thousand messages" means. If they got emails from a thousand different people, and still voted almost unanimously, how many do they have to get to consider the wishes of the electorate? Thanks.
-
Take Action kicks Ass !
How do we set up something like this ?
Anyone know how ?
2AHawaii. Figure this out so we can do it from this forum. :D
(Easy for me to say.) ]
GOA does it too on a National basis. I am sure it is a feature that can be worked out with those who set up forums
I use it all the time and I know the letters are getting there as I keep getting the canned responses. GOA sets it up so that you can write your own or modify theirs to fit your circumstances, or tone them
down a bit.
Anyway, I sent mine to all sens and reps, a personal to my Rep Sam Kong.
We gotta fight together.
Aloha
Gordy
-
:thumbsup:
Right on Gordy !
Somebody get this set up.
(Again easy for me to say, but sounds promising)
-
Done!
and shared on social media. :thumbsup:
got home and sent it again!
-
I never wrote anything at all about "how it should be" (or "shouldn't be").
Ummm, yes you did:
Why should "our side" have to produce enormous numbers to hold sway, while "the other side" need not produce such numbers, or any numbers at all (according to you) and that "no (or almost no) visible public support" rules the roost?
Please explain that in the context of "consent of the governed". Or any context at all.
If that doesn't try to express how the system should work, then I don't know what does...
YOU'RE the one writing about how more gun owners SHOULD get involved, yet you have no plan at all except to "bitch and moan" about it and tell them they should be "ashamed" to not do what you want them to do, even though there is no evidence that if they did what you attempt to shame them in to doing that it would have a beneficial outcome. You're hypothesizing about "how it should be" ("if "enough" of you were "active" legislation would go our way") without any data to support your claim.
Yep, more gun owners should get involved and those that aren't should be ashamed of themselves, especially if they are apt to bitch and moan about the current conditions as they pertain to limiting gun rights in Hawaii. All the evidence I need to show that increased participation is much more likely to result in favorable outcomes with regards to these onerous bills is the difference in outcome when the participation was greater. The response to the attempt to remove the limited liability protections from NRA instructors should serve to remind everyone what is possible when lots of people work collaboratively and show the lawmakers that we have numbers on our side. There are no guarantees that increased participation will get us what we want, and I never said it would, but it is guaranteed that with minimal numbers legislators will continue to ignore us and think they can vote any way they want without repercussions. And, trying to illicit empirical data from events that didn't happen (much like trying to figure out DGUs when no shots are fired) is problematic.
Show me the percentage of gun owners in the voting age population of every Hawaii legislative district. Show me the percentage of gun owners compared to non-gun owners that are registered voters in every Hawaii legislative district. Now, show me how you're going to get whatever percentage of them you claim is necessary to accomplish your goals if they are active, active. Otherwise all you're doing is "bitching and moaning" and spewing hypotheticals about "how it should be".
Now you're just being argumentative and stupid. You don't need complicated and time consuming studies, as you suggest, to know that the majority of gun owners did not participate in efforts to influence legislators. Period. Whatever the number of gun owners we have in Hawaii, the fact is that those that did participate in the process are in the minority, and by all best estimates, a very significant minority. Trying to "study" the numbers to determine what percentage of these gun owners would be necessary to accomplish the stated goals is just a diversionary tactic to get off the fact that most of Hawaii's gun owners are apathetic and that, in general, we would have a better outcome if more of them became involved. That's not bitching and moaning about how things should be, it just stating the cold hard facts about our political system as it is now.
-
Hawaii Rifle Association
State Affiliate of the National Rifle Association - Founded in 1857
April 11 15, 2016
Yesterday, the amendments that were made to House Bill 625, House Bill 2632, House Bill 2629, Senate Bill 2647, and Senate Bill 2954 were all rejected by the respective chambers of origin. All five of these bills are now eligible to be sent to a conference committee for further consideration. Please stay tuned to www.nraila.org and your email inbox for further updates on these bills as the conference committee is assigned and scheduled.
Link to the NRA alert:
https://www.nraila.org/articles/20160415/hawaii-update-on-anti-gun-legislation
HB 625 - Misdemeanor harrassment disqualifies a person from owning, possessing, or controlling a gun
HB 2629 and SB 2954 - Rap Back
HB 2632 - Emergency Hospitalization results in immediate removal of all firearms
SB 2647 - Ban on ivory sale, purchase, barter and possession
MAHALO
HARVEY GERWIG, LEGISLATIVE LIAISON and PRESIDENT, HRA
EMAIL: HGHAWAII@GMAIL.COM, PHONE: (808) 306-7194
-
Aloha e
Thanks for your email. I do support Second Amendment Rights and voted in opposition to SB 2629 in the Judiciary and Labor Committee on March 30th. However, I did vote in favor of HB 2632 and HB 625 after weighing all the testimony.
I’ll keep your input in mind as these bills continue being debated here at the Legislature.
Me ke aloha pumehana,
Senator Mike Gabbard
To which i replied
Thank you for taking the time to respond, I do appreciate your support with your opposition to SB 2629,
I would like to once again share my thoughts on HB 2632 and HB 265
HB 2632 is very vague and over reaching and would result in the loss of rights for receiving hospitalization not requiring diagnosis and has no opportunity for due process or appeal, The way the bill is written whilst some one is receiving care the police will be able to seize firearms immediately from a persons home without warrant or order from a court, Even whilst under treatment which would result in medical clearance at its end.
Any removal of rights should be the result of diagnosis and due process, not solely on the bases of receiving care.
HB 265 ll, Loss of rights is meant for our most serious of crimes in the cases of stalking and harassment their is already laws in place that would protect the victims. Hawaii's TRO laws remove a persons right for a period for up to 1 year when evidence is presented that shows that they pose a risk to another safety.
Thank you for your support and i hope moving forward you will continue to do so.
-
Aloha e
Thanks for your email. I do support Second Amendment Rights and voted in opposition to SB 2629 in the Judiciary and Labor Committee on March 30th. However, I did vote in favor of HB 2632 and HB 625 after weighing all the testimony.
I’ll keep your input in mind as these bills continue being debated here at the Legislature.
Me ke aloha pumehana,
Senator Mike Gabbard
To which i replied
Thank you for taking the time to respond, I do appreciate your support with your opposition to SB 2629,
I would like to once again share my thoughts on HB 2632 and HB 265
HB 2632 is very vague and over reaching and would result in the loss of rights for receiving hospitalization not requiring diagnosis and has no opportunity for due process or appeal, The way the bill is written whilst some one is receiving care the police will be able to seize firearms immediately from a persons home without warrant or order from a court, Even whilst under treatment which would result in medical clearance at its end.
Any removal of rights should be the result of diagnosis and due process, not solely on the bases of receiving care.
HB 265 ll, Loss of rights is meant for our most serious of crimes in the cases of stalking and harassment their is already laws in place that would protect the victims. Hawaii's TRO laws remove a persons right for a period for up to 1 year when evidence is presented that shows that they pose a risk to another safety.
Thank you for your support and i hope moving forward you will continue to do so.
I got the same email from Sen. Gabbard today. I have not gotten a reply from my own senator she is probably (http://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20160419/8dc8a350cf8cafee461f1f1ee8cd99ec.jpg)
-
Several of these bills have now been sent to "conference committees". See the following for commentary about this process in general, and specifically how no public input is allowed. They can do whatever they want to do and don't even have to pretend that the wishes of "the people" are considered.
See the article for active links to cited evidence/references.
http://www.hawaiifreepress.com/ArticlesMain/tabid/56/ID/17318/Shady-Dealings.aspx
Excerpts:
Shady Dealings
Liberal and progressive Democrats have never missed an opportunity to alienate voters.
Recall that it was this very same leadership team of liberal Democrats that promised transparency in government:
The most critical important check on government is an informed and involved citizenry. At minimum, residents should vote. We will work to facilitate, rather than hamper, public involvement in government.
— followed time and again, and again, and again, and again, and again, and again where they betrayed the transparency and good government that they promised.
This move is part-and-parcel of the liberal agenda – to alienate moderate and conservative voters so that louder, more liberal and progressive voices are able to monopolize government.
-
I got the same note from Gabbard. Now I know it was a canned reply. Thought maybe I was special!
Notable by it's absence was a reply from My own District senator
.
Suspect he was dining with Shimabukuro
Gordy