2aHawaii

General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: hvybarrels on July 07, 2016, 02:08:07 AM

Title: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 07, 2016, 02:08:07 AM
Oh wait. He was a black guy. He must have done something wrong. It's disgusting how some members of the gun rights community see themselves as champions of the constitution but always seem to ending up explaining away situations like this when it's someone of a darker complexion with a funny sounding name. The issue is if they can do this to one of us and get away with it then we are all in danger, and those who only defend the rights of people like themselves are way more damaging to the credibility of the movement than any Anti could ever be.

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/man-shot-dead-minn-police-traffic-stop-article-1.2701935
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Q on July 07, 2016, 03:08:31 AM
Oh wait. He was a black guy. He must have done something wrong. It's disgusting how some members of the gun rights community see themselves as champions of the constitution but always seem to ending up explaining away situations like this when it's someone of a darker complexion with a funny sounding name. The issue is if they can do this to one of us and get away with it then we are all in danger, and those who only defend the rights of people like themselves are way more damaging to the credibility of the movement than any Anti could ever be.

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/man-shot-dead-minn-police-traffic-stop-article-1.2701935

I don't buy it.

Where is the video leading up to the shooting? Where is the video proving that he didn't get into an argument with the officer or gave him attitude or egged him on, then said fck it and reached for his wallet anway, even after the officer told him not to do so due to officer safety?

That always seems to be the case these days.

Maybe you can explain why its always "someone of a darker complexion" that is always playing stupid games then winning stupid prizes, and then playing victim when they could have completely avoided the situation by 1) exercising common sense and 2) abiding by the officer's requests.

Oh, and a side note: if he did inform the officer he was concealed carrying, he should have kept his hands away from his firearm and asked to officer if he would like to remove the firearm from his person, all while keeping his hands on the dash and/or in plain sight out of the window. Its usually SOP for officers to assume that an armed individual is reaching for their firearm, and to respond with extreme prejudice to neutralize a potential threat.

The real question then becomes: would you have made a post if the driver instead shot the police officer?
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Rocky on July 07, 2016, 08:11:20 AM
A LEGALLY Licensed CC (no criminal record)  who works as a cafeteria supervisor at a Montessori school a a passenger with GF and child in car which gets pulled over for a busted tail light shot while still wearing seat belt gets shot .  :wtf:

Look at the whole situation with out color.

Add this one to the baton Rouge shooting where the VICTIM was pinned to the ground by 2 PDO's and shot dead. and you have a nice recipe for some type of "action".  :shake:
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Shoboshi on July 07, 2016, 08:14:58 AM
Besides no video leading up to the shots. At  about 7:00 into the video "They shot him four times. He's License to carry. We had a busted tail light. And we had some weed in the car. That's about it."

She showed more concern about her phone than her 4 year old daughter who was in the car the entire time
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: omnigun on July 07, 2016, 08:43:36 AM
A LEGALLY Licensed CC (no criminal record)  who works as a cafeteria supervisor at a Montessori school a a passenger with GF and child in car which gets pulled over for a busted tail light shot while still wearing seat belt gets shot .  :wtf:

Look at the whole situation with out color.

Add this one to the baton Rouge shooting where the VICTIM was pinned to the ground by 2 PDO's and shot dead. and you have a nice recipe for some type of "action".  :shake:
Wouldn't call the baton rouge one a victim. He had a illegal gun last time I checked.  Don't do crime then reach for a gun when you got two cops on you. Or you get shot
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 07, 2016, 08:45:30 AM
The problem with these situations is, as has been stated, we never get to see what lead up to the incident.

Sudden movements, hands not in sight, reaching for a phone, wallet, or registration .... if the officer has his hand on his weapon, it's best to ask if it's okay to reach for whatever.  If the Cop is nervous, he'll give instructions on what to do when.  He may have you exit the vehicle and relieve you of the weapon to keep your hands away from it.

Just because there is a woman with a child in the car in no way guarantees the male won't pull a gun to get away.  For all the Cop knows, he could have carjacked the woman and child and has no problem putting them in more danger. 

I can't give an opinion about what went wrong, since we are only getting the second half of one side of the story.  What I mentioned above is meant to be "in general", not speculating on this case.

Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: London808 on July 07, 2016, 01:04:48 PM
Guy reaches for his wallet after telling the cops he has a gun, Cop says dont move, He moves.......... What else would you expect to happen,

So according to the lady doing an interview on CNN,

He asked for licence and registration, the BF has his wallet in his back pocket, As hes reaching for his pocket he tells the cop "Officer i have a firearm on me"  She then begins yelling that hes licensed to carry, Cop begins shooting.

Im gona go with her yelling killed her BF, Cop says in original video "I told him not to reach for it, i told him to get his hand of it." So im going with this dumb ass woman yelling means the BF either paniked or dident hear the officer, Whips his arm up from behind him/under him and the cop starts shooting.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 07, 2016, 01:13:50 PM

That always seems to be the case these days.

Maybe you can explain why its always "someone of a darker complexion" that is always playing stupid games then winning stupid prizes, and then playing victim when they could have completely avoided the situation by 1) exercising common sense and 2) abiding by the officer's requests.

I have actually heard people say that the reason crime in Hawaii is low is because we don't have a lot of black people. It's the kind of institutionalized racist thinking that ignores fact like it's easier for a white guy with a felony to get a job than a black guy with a community college degree, and that they are killed in disproportionate numbers often involving lesser crimes or for no reason at all. It's easier to blame it on some genetic condition rather than admit that the State supports racist policies because it makes it easier to take away rights from everybody. It starts out as "it's ok just those people get problems, not me" until the exceptions become the rule and then it's too late.

http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/08/us/philando-castile-falcon-heights-shooting.html?_r=0
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 07, 2016, 02:03:36 PM
I have actually heard people say that the reason crime in Hawaii is low is because we don't have a lot of black people. It's the kind of institutionalized racist thinking that ignores fact like it's easier for a white guy with a felony to get a job than a black guy with a community college degree, and that they are killed in disproportionate numbers often involving lesser crimes or for no reason at all. It's easier to blame it on some genetic condition rather than admit that the State supports racist policies because it makes it easier to take away rights from everybody. It starts out as "it's ok just those people get problems, not me" until the exceptions become the rule and then it's too late.

http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/08/us/philando-castile-falcon-heights-shooting.html?_r=0

Blacks commit more crime than whites proportionately. This does two things:
1) It puts black people in contact with police in negative encounters more often.
2) It makes cops more likely to be suspicious of a black person. Not because of some intentional racist reasoning, but because the human brain sees patterns and evaluates risk subconsciously. This is a survival mechanism. Unfortunately it does go off perceptions and stereotypes, but is something that will always happen and the best we can do is try to account for it.

This does put black males at a disadvantage of sorts when coming into contact with police, but not because of racism. If cops interact with black suspects more often because there are more black criminals then of course you are going to see disproportionate instances of force used.

Police murdering innocent blacks at some significant rate is a myth perpetuated by leaders and people in the media. Yes there have been unjustified shootings and murders by police of black people but they are not at all as common as the media would have us believe. Look at the way they portrayed the Zimmerman case. He wasn't a cop but it still fit their "innocent black people getting murdered" mantra.

Consider one study in Washington where they found that cops hesitated longer before shooting a black suspect than a white suspect.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/true-crime/wp/2016/04/27/this-study-found-race-matters-in-police-shootings-but-the-results-may-surprise-you/
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 07, 2016, 02:16:22 PM
That's a canned study where cops are well aware their racial bias is being evaluated. Not very useful other than proving that cops are aware of basic pr and looking good on tests.

You are saying blacks are more likely to commit crimes but that's not true at all. They are more likely to get arrested and convicted, with much harsher sentencing. This shows a clear pattern of institutionalized racism.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/kim-farbota/black-crime-rates-your-st_b_8078586.html
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: ren on July 07, 2016, 02:44:26 PM
Add this one to the baton Rouge shooting where the VICTIM was pinned to the ground by 2 PDO's and shot dead. and you have a nice recipe for some type of "action".  :shake:

In that event, he was a felon in possession of an illegal firearm. He was also a sex offender who was convicted for a sex crime with a minor. He was no angel as made out by the pop media
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: zippz on July 07, 2016, 02:58:34 PM
This one could go either way for the cop.

The problem may have been with training.  Not sure if this is the case, but I think there is a problem with Constitutional Carry states and others that have minimal training requirements where people don't get the proper training.  People may not know what to do when stopped by a cop or having to actually use their handgun in a defensive situation.  They just assume having a gun (trained or not) will help them.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 07, 2016, 03:00:34 PM
In that event, he was a felon in possession of an illegal firearm. He was also a sex offender who was convicted for a sex crime with a minor. He was no angel as made out by the pop media

He was also no devil. She was 14 and he was 20. They stayed together and he helped support the kids. He had some rough times but that was behind him. Concealed carry of a firearm was a crime, but it was still in his pocket when they shot him. He was probably just struggling to breathe at that point and started to panic.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 07, 2016, 03:03:28 PM
http://bearingarms.com/bob-o/2016/07/07/many-die-raise-level-law-enforcement-training/

"The simple fact of the matter is that if more people knew how little training officers were required to have with their deadliest tools, they’d be appalled."
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: ren on July 07, 2016, 03:10:28 PM
He was also no devil. She was 14 and he was 20. They stayed together and he helped support the kids. He had some rough times but that was behind him. Concealed carry of a firearm was a crime, but it was still in his pocket when they shot him. He was probably just struggling to breathe at that point and started to panic.

How would you affect the arrest? He was illegally carrying a firearm. How would you handle the situation with regards to safety?
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 07, 2016, 03:24:26 PM
Just looking at the video it seems much too similar to other cases where the escalation went from 0 to 150 in about 2 seconds. That's ok if you live in a place where nobody values life very much but I'm pretty sure what all the protests are saying is that people in those neighborhoods don't like being treated as domesticated wildlife in a canned hunt reserve. Why escalate so fast? How do like it when officer meathead starts accusing you of shit before you get a chance to open your mouth and pawing at his gun like this is going to be the best thing that happened to him all day?
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: passivekinetic on July 07, 2016, 03:27:35 PM
This case is F*CKED UP man.

This person was shot for absolutely no good reason it seems. It seems crazy that he would try to draw on a drawn gun (if that was the case, which seems very unlikely).

I don't understand why he would be trying to dig out his ID or whatever. Did the cop ask him to?

Why would he not just put his hands up and freeze?

It just doesn't make sense.

We may all be commenting on things we have no idea about, (no) thanks to the media.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: omnigun on July 07, 2016, 03:28:27 PM

All I know is if hvybarrels was a cop he would be dead by now.  His last famous words "he was only reaching into his pocket for a gun, probably was going to turn it over so not to inconvenience me while trying to resist arrest"


In all seriousness lets put on our thinking caps.  Its not hard to do the math.  Threaten people with a gun + cops getting called about said crime + trying to escape + resisting arrest + reaching for gun while resisting arrest = dead bad guy


As for the CC legal case, that's more unknown from what I gather his wife was hollering and he panicked which lead to the cop panicking and shooting him. 


Edit* realized this was a thread about the cc carry case in the car not the resisting arrest one.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: passivekinetic on July 07, 2016, 03:37:37 PM
Hey I found some crucial new info (from CNN of all places):

Quote
The officer still sounds distressed as he explains, "I told him not to reach for it. I told him to get his hand off it."

http://www.cnn.com/2016/07/07/us/falcon-heights-shooting-minnesota/

And, very pertinent (for their agenda):

Quote
Castile's mother said that he and his sister had stopped by her house earlier Wednesday. During the visit, they had discussed the dangers of carrying weapons, even though both of them have concealed carry permits.
"I really don't even want to carry my gun because I'm afraid that they'll shoot me first and then ask questions later," Valerie Castile eerily recalled her daughter saying.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: omnigun on July 07, 2016, 03:38:16 PM
Blacks commit more crime than whites proportionately. This does two things:
1) It puts black people in contact with police in negative encounters more often.
2) It makes cops more likely to be suspicious of a black person. Not because of some intentional racist reasoning, but because the human brain sees patterns and evaluates risk subconsciously. This is a survival mechanism. Unfortunately it does go off perceptions and stereotypes, but is something that will always happen and the best we can do is try to account for it.

This does put black males at a disadvantage of sorts when coming into contact with police, but not because of racism. If cops interact with black suspects more often because there are more black criminals then of course you are going to see disproportionate instances of force used.

Police murdering innocent blacks at some significant rate is a myth perpetuated by leaders and people in the media. Yes there have been unjustified shootings and murders by police of black people but they are not at all as common as the media would have us believe. Look at the way they portrayed the Zimmerman case. He wasn't a cop but it still fit their "innocent black people getting murdered" mantra.

Consider one study in Washington where they found that cops hesitated longer before shooting a black suspect than a white suspect.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/true-crime/wp/2016/04/27/this-study-found-race-matters-in-police-shootings-but-the-results-may-surprise-you/


Sound logic

You only hear stories of "innocent black boys who did nothing wrong"  cause the media is very bias.  Doesn't matter if they are a career criminal nah hears a picture when they were 10, look how good he was.  No one wants to hear about that white dude that got shot.   That doesn't bring in the views and the cash. 
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 07, 2016, 03:45:57 PM
All I know is if hvybarrels was a cop he would be dead by now.  His last famous words "he was only reaching into his pocket for a gun, probably was going to turn it over so not to inconvenience me while trying to resist arrest"

There's a huge rainbow of possibilities to be explored, but the point is moot because they only hire people who can pass asshole evaluation and I'd never be allowed in the academy because I'm too smart and would get filtered out through the first test.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: ren on July 07, 2016, 03:47:18 PM
There's a huge rainbow of possibilities to be explored, but the point is moot because they only hire people who can pass asshole evaluation and I'd never be allowed in the academy because I'm too smart and would get filtered out through the first test.

Have you applied?
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 07, 2016, 03:51:07 PM

Sound logic

You only hear stories of "innocent black boys who did nothing wrong"  cause the media is very bias.  Doesn't matter if they are a career criminal nah hears a picture when they were 10, look how good he was.  No one wants to hear about that white dude that got shot.   That doesn't bring in the views and the cash.

It's not sound logic. They get convicted of the same crimes at a disproportionate rate.

And for every "they did nothing wrong" story there's 10 more digging into their past in a media smear campaign trying to make their assassination sound justified because of "who they are"
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 07, 2016, 03:55:09 PM
Have you applied?

It's a corrupt bureaucratic organisation run by incompetent homophobes who actively encourage a disarmed populace. No I never applied, but a friend did and didn't know better at the time to get some answers wrong on purpose because the intelligence quota was relatively unknown back then.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 07, 2016, 03:55:36 PM
It's not sound logic. They get convicted of the same crimes at a disproportionate rate.

And for every "they did nothing wrong" story there's 10 more digging into their past in a media smear campaign trying to make their assassination sound justified because of "who they are"

After the FBI decided to not charge Hillary, how can you say the laws are not being applied equally to everyone?

 :wave:     :crazy:     :shake:

[sarcasm, of course!]
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: omnigun on July 07, 2016, 03:56:58 PM
It's not sound logic. They get convicted of the same crimes at a disproportionate rate.

And for every "they did nothing wrong" story there's 10 more digging into their past in a media smear campaign trying to make their assassination sound justified because of "who they are"

Dylan nobel.  Unarmed white dude who got shot 7 days ago he was also "going for a weapon"  his happened to turn out to be fake(unarmed).  He was killed.  No outrage, no protests, no mass media.  Why? 

In the end until further evidence I believe both cases are justified shootings.  There is a reason for the phrase "hands up"
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: omnigun on July 07, 2016, 04:01:12 PM
It's a corrupt bureaucratic organisation run by incompetent homophobes who actively encourage a disarmed populace. No I never applied, but a friend did and didn't know better at the time to get some answers wrong on purpose because the intelligence quota was relatively unknown back then.

Also for the intelligence one its not to have dumb police.  Its expensive to train someone.  Highly intelligent people tend to not like doing monotonous things and quit after a little while.  Its purely cost based.  I'm sure you don't wish to raise taxes to cover these losses, right?
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 07, 2016, 04:02:57 PM
Dylan nobel.  Unarmed white dude who got shot 7 days ago he was also "going for a weapon"  his happened to turn out to be fake(unarmed).  He was killed.  No outrage, no protests, no mass media.  Why? 

In the end until further evidence I believe both cases are justified shootings.  There is a reason for the phrase "hands up"

What you should be considering is how cops who get used to killing people with no repercussions are supposed to know when to quit? The indiscriminate killing of black people opens the door to the indiscriminate killing of anybody.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 07, 2016, 04:03:38 PM
That's a canned study where cops are well aware their racial bias is being evaluated. Not very useful other than proving that cops are aware of basic pr and looking good on tests.

You are saying blacks are more likely to commit crimes but that's not true at all. They are more likely to get arrested and convicted, with much harsher sentencing. This shows a clear pattern of institutionalized racism.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/kim-farbota/black-crime-rates-your-st_b_8078586.html

Feel free to post evidence the study was flawed but don't dismiss it because you don't like the result.

Yes, blacks do seem, on the surface, to get harsher sentencing, but only looking at the surface of sentence received and race of the convict does not tell the whole picture. You have to look at the rap sheet. If two people commit the same crime but one has a lot more convictions than the other, of course that one is going to get a longer sentence for the same crime. No mention in the article of that variable though. Coincidence?

So why are Asians underrepresented? If we have a bunch of white supremacist cops why don't we see more Asians than whites arrested? (proportionately speaking)
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 07, 2016, 04:07:00 PM
Also for the intelligence one its not to have dumb police.  Its expensive to train someone.  Highly intelligent people tend to not like doing monotonous things and quit after a little while.  Its purely cost based.  I'm sure you don't wish to raise taxes to cover these losses, right?

How much extra are we paying now for legal actions and settlement awards because of angry meatheads who couldn't think their way out of a paper bag? The objective of the quota is to find people who are just competent enough to handle the basics of the job but won't ask questions or second guess leadership, even when that leadership is wrong and self destructive.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 07, 2016, 04:10:10 PM
Hey I found some crucial new info (from CNN of all places):
"The officer still sounds distressed as he explains, "I told him not to reach for it. I told him to get his hand off it."
http://www.cnn.com/2016/07/07/us/falcon-heights-shooting-minnesota/


This statement is right on the edge and can be used by both sides. Was he distressed because he knew he made a mistake, or was he distressed because he had just gone through a traumatic incident?

Generally they say that statements made immediately after the event are the most honest so there is reason to believe he was giving proper instruction prior to firing.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 07, 2016, 04:11:45 PM
Feel free to post evidence the study was flawed but don't dismiss it because you don't like the result.

Yes, blacks do seem, on the surface, to get harsher sentencing, but only looking at the surface of sentence received and race of the convict does not tell the whole picture. You have to look at the rap sheet. If two people commit the same crime but one has a lot more convictions than the other, of course that one is going to get a longer sentence for the same crime. No mention in the article of that variable though. Coincidence?

So why are Asians underrepresented? If we have a bunch of white supremacist cops why don't we see more Asians than whites arrested? (proportionately speaking)

It's a canned study. Real life paints a much different picture. When you point out about prior arrests all that means is that it's a self sustaining cycle. Circular logic aka bubble logic.

http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/11/18/ferguson-black-arrest-rates/19043207/
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: omnigun on July 07, 2016, 04:15:17 PM
What you should be considering is how cops who get used to killing people with no repercussions are supposed to know when to quit? The indiscriminate killing of black people opens the door to the indiscriminate killing of anybody.

Why do you keep repeating saying "indiscriminate killing"  "institutionalize racism"  and similar connotations. Cops are not driving around gunning random black people.  They are trained to deal with crime whatever color skin the criminal has.  I don't give a shit if you are black, white or fucking purple you do a crime and have a weapon or allude that you have one. Then motion to use it to harm the officer/officers it is justifiable for those individuals to be shot.  If i was to walk into your house robbing you when you had your gun pointing at me then reach down into my pants are you telling me you would do nothing?  Thankfully we live in a relatively safe society that people with less threat based evaluation and reactionary survival instincts can live a full life. If not you probably be dead from what i gather you write about. 


How much extra are we paying now for legal actions and settlement awards because of angry meatheads who couldn't think their way out of a paper bag? The objective of the quota is to find people who are just competent enough to handle the basics of the job but won't ask questions or second guess leadership, even when that leadership is wrong and self destructive.
You know they have a disqualification for low IQ too.  They are not hiring only "meatheads"  you just call them that because you don't understand the line of work.  And the risks and emotions that come with that type of job. 


It's a canned study. Real life paints a much different picture. When you point out about prior arrests all that means is that it's a self sustaining cycle. Circular logic aka bubble logic.

http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/11/18/ferguson-black-arrest-rates/19043207/
Wait, so you don't support 3 strikes rule.  You want the judges to ignore all priors when sentencing?  Wow and I thought you couldn't sound more ridiculous.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 07, 2016, 04:20:43 PM
It's a canned study. Real life paints a much different picture. When you point out about prior arrests all that means is that it's a self sustaining cycle. Circular logic aka bubble logic.

http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/11/18/ferguson-black-arrest-rates/19043207/

A good study has to control for variables. In the case of a use of force study that means presenting the same exact situation to multiple people and study the numbers. Just because they aren't real life shootings doesn't mean the study isn't valid.

And who is sustaining the cycle from? If you commit a crime once and I commit it 10 times, is it everyone else's fault? Did the most successful black americans in history succeed because they complained about an unfair system or did they succeed because they went out and worked hard in the face of the junk hand they were dealt? Recidivism is a problem that society is trying to figure out but it is far from the case that blacks are purely victims of the system.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 07, 2016, 04:29:25 PM
Feel free to post evidence the study was flawed but don't dismiss it because you don't like the result.

Yes, blacks do seem, on the surface, to get harsher sentencing, but only looking at the surface of sentence received and race of the convict does not tell the whole picture. You have to look at the rap sheet. If two people commit the same crime but one has a lot more convictions than the other, of course that one is going to get a longer sentence for the same crime. No mention in the article of that variable though. Coincidence?

So why are Asians underrepresented? If we have a bunch of white supremacist cops why don't we see more Asians than whites arrested? (proportionately speaking)

Why do you always insist on arguing for the one or two "facts" that you think prove your position while ignoring some extremely glaring and relevant ones?

For example, it's less likely a poor black will have the money for a private attorney, so he gets the court-appointed public defender.  Meanwhile, Mr. White can afford an experienced defense attorney from a prestigious law firm with 4 partners and a dozen paralegals working the case.

Also, a clean cut white boy who "made a mistake" and is captain of the local sports team, gets good  grades, and has the potential to learn from this and not do it again plays well for juries and judges.  Not the same when a black kid from a broken home, living in a gang-run neighborhood and on his way to becoming a high school drop out.  He might not get the same treatment unless there is something that changes and gives us hope things can be different in his life.

So, if you want to analyze something, maybe analyze all the factors that are affecting the outcome.  Leaving those out which point to a different conclusion than what you want to prove is dishonest!

If you want  to talk about controlling variables, how about that study only existing in it's own bubble?  Video simulation, while good for practice and training, is not an accurate testing method.  Facing a real person who reacts, moves, talks, yells, distracts while someone comes from another direction ..... those are real life variables that impact the stories we see.  Trying to measure that in a controlled setting is not realistic.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 07, 2016, 04:51:28 PM
"Ok guys you have been selected to participate in a paid study because we're confident you will make us look good. Keep in mind the results will be shown to the public."
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 07, 2016, 04:55:25 PM
Why do you always insist on arguing for the one or two "facts" that you think prove your position while ignoring some extremely glaring and relevant ones?

For example, it's less likely a poor black will have the money for a private attorney, so he gets the court-appointed public defender.  Meanwhile, Mr. White can afford an experienced defense attorney from a prestigious law firm with 4 partners and a dozen paralegals working the case.

Also, a clean cut white boy who "made a mistake" and is captain of the local sports team, get good  grades, and has the potential to lean from this and not do it again plays well for juries and judges.  Not the same when a black kid from a broken home, living in a gang-run neighborhood and on his way to becoming a high school drop out.  He might not get the same treatment unless there is something that changes and gives us hope things can be different in his life.

So, if you want to analyze something, maybe analyze all the factors that are affecting the outcome.  Leaving those out which point to a different conclusion than what you want to prove is dishonest!

If you want  to talk about controlling variables, how about that study only existing in it's own bubble?  Video simulation, while good for practice and training, is not an accurate testing method.  Facing a real person who reacts, moves, talks, yells, distracts while someone comes from another direction ..... those are real life variables that impact the stories we see.  Trying to measure that in a controlled setting is not realistic.

I didn't feel the need to address points that I did not consider to be in contention. Yes, blacks tend to be poorer and are less able to afford good attorneys, this is something to consider. I pointed out a separate fact that the article left out.

As for the study, you have to have a controlled situation to get comparable data. If you take 10 real life shootings you are going to end up with so many variables. You will end up with 10 different times of the day, 10 ten different distances between the officer and person shot, 10 different temperatures, 10 different lighting conditions, etc. It is important to gather data from actual shootings but controlled studies offer something that the real life cases cannot.

Yes a controlled study like the one mentioned has trouble reproducing the actual stress someone goes through during a real use of force incident but these studies still do yield useable data. If I recall, this study made the test participants decide very quickly whether or not to shoot. It presented them with images of shoot and no shoot situations with both black and white people. The officers hesitated longer to shoot at the black people, not by a huge difference but it was enough to be noticeable in the data. The question is this, did the officers really go out to falsify the data by purposefully waiting a fraction of a second longer when they saw a black person in a shoot situation? The average was 0.23 second slower to shoot at a black suspect in the study than a white suspect. You think they consciously stalled an extra 0.23 second so they could claim "look, I am not racist!"
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 07, 2016, 05:00:39 PM
"Ok guys you have been selected to participate in a paid study because we're confident you will make us look good. Keep in mind the results will be shown to the public."

"In addition, for this study the officers were given a battery of written and oral tests. Again, there was no mention of a racial component. But one of the tests was the Harvard Implicit Association Test, designed to detect racial bias by linking pictures of black and white faces with pictures of weapons. Perhaps stunningly, 96 percent of the nearly all white officers demonstrated implicit racial bias, with 78 percent strongly or moderately associating blacks with weapons, and zero percent associating whites with weapons. So that’s the baseline test group for the study."

So they admitted to having racial bias in the study as part of the program to make them look good as well?

Come on, you are just attacking the study without good reason. If you really want to prove it cannot be trusted then go out and show what is wrong with the actual methodology instead of just claiming it to be canned or a publicity stunt.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 07, 2016, 05:18:22 PM
"In addition, for this study the officers were given a battery of written and oral tests. Again, there was no mention of a racial component. But one of the tests was the Harvard Implicit Association Test, designed to detect racial bias by linking pictures of black and white faces with pictures of weapons. Perhaps stunningly, 96 percent of the nearly all white officers demonstrated implicit racial bias, with 78 percent strongly or moderately associating blacks with weapons, and zero percent associating whites with weapons. So that’s the baseline test group for the study."

So they admitted to having racial bias in the study as part of the program to make them look good as well?

Come on, you are just attacking the study without good reason. If you really want to prove it cannot be trusted then go out and show what is wrong with the actual methodology instead of just claiming it to be canned or a publicity stunt.

As we well know, canned studies are easy to manipulate, and in this case the statistics tell a different story. I wonder if they gave the written/oral part first, giving the subjects time to figure out what was going on?

http://www.buckeyefirearms.org/diane-sawyer-rigs-mass-shooting-experiment-2020
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: ren on July 07, 2016, 05:24:11 PM
It's a corrupt bureaucratic organisation run by incompetent homophobes who actively encourage a disarmed populace. No I never applied, but a friend did and didn't know better at the time to get some answers wrong on purpose because the intelligence quota was relatively unknown back then.

HPD doesn't test for IQ. They test for reading comprehension followed by a behavioral/psych inventory.
Your point is moot since you never applied or bothered into learning about the process. Your fear and distrust of organizations is your lack of knowledge about them. You wouldn't know what to do in a situation like that. You aren't trained in any way and you are far less capable than handling the situation than those police officers.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: robtmc on July 07, 2016, 05:38:10 PM
HPD doesn't test for IQ. They test for reading comprehension followed by a behavioral/psych inventory.

But, but, it sounds like they must be revolted by homosexuals as well to pass, racism is just icing on the cake.............
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: gt1_911 on July 07, 2016, 07:12:48 PM
 :popcorn:
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 07, 2016, 07:31:46 PM
As we well know, canned studies are easy to manipulate, and in this case the statistics tell a different story. I wonder if they gave the written/oral part first, giving the subjects time to figure out what was going on?

http://www.buckeyefirearms.org/diane-sawyer-rigs-mass-shooting-experiment-2020

Again, you haven't actually discredited the methodology of the story. You are merely claiming it isn't valid without any real cause.

The written part was first but as I pointed out the delay averaged 0.23 seconds. Do you really think they all managed to deliberately differentiate such a small fraction of a second all so they could claim they weren't racist?
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: surfer22 on July 07, 2016, 07:54:15 PM
This is all pretty simple. Baton Rouge shooting was a bummer but not the cops fault. Mr Sterling as illegally carrying a concealed weapon and refused arrest. You do that and you will get shot. It's nobodies fault but his. As for Mr Castles shooting, that one is up in the air. There isn't enough to evidence to make an informed opinion. The video starts after the shooting.  He could have ignored the cops instructions and reached for something he wasn't supposed to. Or the cop could have shot him in cold blood for no reason. There's just not enough evidence to know yet.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 08, 2016, 11:11:21 AM
HPD doesn't test for IQ. They test for reading comprehension followed by a behavioral/psych inventory.
Your point is moot since you never applied or bothered into learning about the process. Your fear and distrust of organizations is your lack of knowledge about them. You wouldn't know what to do in a situation like that. You aren't trained in any way and you are far less capable than handling the situation than those police officers.

Why are you making this about me? It seems as if you ran of ammo trying to defend a training and screening process that clearly has much room for improvement, and a system that clearly needs some serious reform.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 08, 2016, 11:12:28 AM
Again, you haven't actually discredited the methodology of the story. You are merely claiming it isn't valid without any real cause.

The written part was first but as I pointed out the delay averaged 0.23 seconds. Do you really think they all managed to deliberately differentiate such a small fraction of a second all so they could claim they weren't racist?

I'm claiming statistical analysis is more reliable, and it tells a different story.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 08, 2016, 11:18:45 AM
But, but, it sounds like they must be revolted by homosexuals as well to pass, racism is just icing on the cake.............

When the head of SHOPO says he'd rather die than enforce gay marriage and the best HPD can do is offer a tepid and late response then yeah, the leadership is weak and needs replacement
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: ren on July 08, 2016, 12:02:27 PM
When the head of SHOPO says he'd rather die than enforce gay marriage and the best HPD can do is offer a tepid and late response then yeah, the leadership is weak and needs replacement

I don't want to be forced to be gay. Good for SHOPO. :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: robtmc on July 08, 2016, 01:36:43 PM
Good for SHOPO. :thumbsup:

The nerve of a cop to have an opinion of his own.................

The fascist left is always watching and waiting to pounce on any non-PC thought crimes.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 08, 2016, 02:09:45 PM
I'm claiming statistical analysis is more reliable, and it tells a different story.

Statistical analysis of actual shootings cannot provide micro time measurements that would measure what goes on during a shoot/no shoot event.

The tide may be turning is what the study points too. From officers who were more suspicious of black people to officers who are afraid they are going to get sued. End result can be good or bad depending on the situation.

But this is just a study I threw out there to think about. The situation I see is that we have a small amount of racism mixed with a decent amount of stereotyping, and a huge amount of assumption of racism.

I was in Waikiki one night and saw 3 police standing over a black guy. He was stopped for walking in the roadway and flashing people. He was handcuffed and rolling around the ground screaming that he was stopped because he was black and that he was going to be raped by the police. He appeared very intoxicated and the police were acting professionally. He ended up being taken to the hospital for a mental health evaluation. When this guy sobered up the next day, do you think in his mind the police treated him fairly or do you think he is going to go and tell his friends about how some racist cops profiled him? I would bet the latter. His claim of racism is based off a false perception.

That is just an example of a false perception to illustrate my next question. How many instances out there do you think are actual racism or stereotyping vs how many are incidents where someone falsely perceived racism?

https://youtu.be/ThRb9x-RieI
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Rocky on July 08, 2016, 04:36:18 PM
Quote
    "The officer still sounds distressed as he explains, "I told him not to reach for it. I told him to get his hand off it."

   Listen to all of the tape and you'll hear some guy repeatedly yelling "Fu ( %,  Fu ( %, " in the background.  :shake:
That sounds like a distressed officer. I can see him in my mind pacing back and forth yelling at himself.

    As for all of this :"more blacks in jail" and " less crime in Hawaii cuz we have less blacks", replace the word "blacks" with "Hawaiians" (who seem to be the majority of the jailed here) and it balances out both of your arguments.  ???
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: macsak on July 08, 2016, 04:55:15 PM
reports are now saying he was not a legal concealed carrier
and that he and the girlfriend had "interesting" social media presences
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: drck1000 on July 08, 2016, 04:59:30 PM
I'll post when I get home, but I read of "confirmed reports" that he matched the description of a BOLO of an armed robbery suspect from the past few days.
Title: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: drck1000 on July 08, 2016, 05:01:52 PM
https://theconservativetreehouse.com/2016/07/08/confirmed-philando-castile-was-an-armed-robbery-suspect-false-media-narrative-now-driving-cop-killings/

No idea about this site or the "reports". I'm just going to keep an eye out for other reports as info comes to light.

I'll check with a friend in MN who is a retired LEO. He's dealing with cancer recovery, so might be a while until he can respond.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Kingkeoni on July 08, 2016, 09:34:08 PM
https://theconservativetreehouse.com/2016/07/08/confirmed-philando-castile-was-an-armed-robbery-suspect-false-media-narrative-now-driving-cop-killings/

No idea about this site or the "reports". I'm just going to keep an eye out for other reports as info comes to light.

I'll check with a friend in MN who is a retired LEO. He's dealing with cancer recovery, so might be a while until he can respond.


Interesting...
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: drck1000 on July 08, 2016, 09:52:51 PM


Interesting...
From what I've been told, that site leans hard one way.  Not like others don't lean as well. I'd just like to see the info from different reputable sites.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: stangzilla on July 09, 2016, 06:56:12 AM
In a speech from Poland,  Obama just blamed the cc guy's gun for the shooting
That is a sick twist of reality
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: London808 on July 09, 2016, 08:25:46 AM
“I’m going to stop a car. I’m going to check IDs.  I have reason to pull it over.”

“The two occupants just look like people that were involved in a robbery. The driver looks more like one of our suspects, just ‘cause of the wide set nose.”

(https://theconservativetreehouse.files.wordpress.com/2016/07/suspect-mn-4.jpg?w=330&h=283)  (https://theconservativetreehouse.files.wordpress.com/2016/07/mn-shooting-6.jpg?w=278&h=283)
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: London808 on July 09, 2016, 08:29:00 AM
Is this a gun on his thigh ? Is this why he got shot ?

(https://theconservativetreehouse.files.wordpress.com/2016/07/mn-shooting-19.jpg?w=640&h=446)
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Jl808 on July 09, 2016, 09:34:11 AM
http://www.kare11.com/mb/news/police-scanner-audio-1/267042738

Police scanner audio
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: RSN172 on July 09, 2016, 12:10:13 PM
Is this a gun on his thigh ? Is this why he got shot ?

(https://theconservativetreehouse.files.wordpress.com/2016/07/mn-shooting-19.jpg?w=640&h=446)

Lap portion  of seat belt over a portion of his T Shirt is what it looks like to me.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Aegis808 on July 09, 2016, 02:52:04 PM
The police are in the wrong on this one. The NRA is a bunch of cowards for not standing up for this and only speaking out about the dead cops in Dallas.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: London808 on July 09, 2016, 04:47:22 PM
The police are in the wrong on this one. The NRA is a bunch of cowards for not standing up for this and only speaking out about the dead cops in Dallas.

Please presnt evidence to support the fact the police are wrong, all we have at this time is speculation
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Aegis808 on July 09, 2016, 05:01:32 PM
Please presnt evidence to support the fact the police are wrong, all we have at this time is speculation

the evidence is that police pulled a car over based on suspicion of being a robber due to having a similar nose and then shooting a person dead because of them following instructions.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 09, 2016, 05:07:20 PM
the evidence is that police pulled a car over based on suspicion of being a robber due to having a similar nose and then shooting a person dead because of them following instructions.

 :wacko: :wacko: :wacko:
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: London808 on July 09, 2016, 05:14:37 PM
The girlfriend said : we were pulled over for a broken tail light,
The cop said it was for matching the physical description of an armed robber,
The girlfriend lied.

The girlfriend is saying he had a contacted  carry license, the sherif in his county are saying we dident issue one or have an application for him.

His girlfriend says he told him to get the wallet and then shot him whilst he was doing so,
The cop says he told him to stop moving and he dident so he shot him, (knowing he was armed and was being stopped for susspicion of being an armed robber)
The girlfriends now yelling the truth ????
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: London808 on July 09, 2016, 06:17:53 PM
And what do you know, cops saying he displayed the gun so he shot him,

St. Anthony Police Officer Jeronimo Yanez was reacting to “the presence of that gun and the display of that gun” when he opened fire on Philando Castile, attorney Thomas Kelly told The AP.

http://nypost.com/2016/07/09/minnesota-cop-who-killed-castile-says-he-reacted-to-display-gun (http://nypost.com/2016/07/09/minnesota-cop-who-killed-castile-says-he-reacted-to-display-gun)/
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Aegis808 on July 09, 2016, 09:37:02 PM
And what do you know, cops saying he displayed the gun so he shot him,

St. Anthony Police Officer Jeronimo Yanez was reacting to “the presence of that gun and the display of that gun” when he opened fire on Philando Castile, attorney Thomas Kelly told The AP.

http://nypost.com/2016/07/09/minnesota-cop-who-killed-castile-says-he-reacted-to-display-gun (http://nypost.com/2016/07/09/minnesota-cop-who-killed-castile-says-he-reacted-to-display-gun)/

http://reason.com/blog/2016/07/08/philando-castile-may-have-been-pulled-ov

the real reason for the stop was because of profiling based on a nose, as noted in the above link.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Aegis808 on July 09, 2016, 09:39:55 PM
The girlfriend said : we were pulled over for a broken tail light,
The cop said it was for matching the physical description of an armed robber,
The girlfriend lied.

The girlfriend is saying he had a contacted  carry license, the sherif in his county are saying we dident issue one or have an application for him.

His girlfriend says he told him to get the wallet and then shot him whilst he was doing so,
The cop says he told him to stop moving and he dident so he shot him, (knowing he was armed and was being stopped for susspicion of being an armed robber)
The girlfriends now yelling the truth ????

he had a CCW issued from Hennepin County, why the NRA isn't backing Philando Castile about this is complete BS.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 09, 2016, 10:21:17 PM
http://reason.com/blog/2016/07/08/philando-castile-may-have-been-pulled-ov

the real reason for the stop was because of profiling based on a nose, as noted in the above link.

I was unaware facial features fell under "profiling."     :wtf:

African-Americans have a variety of nose "widths", so I fail to see the profiling aspect.

If I say, "suspect is a white male, 6', 210 lbs, black hair, and white running shoes with green stripes," is that "profiling," when I stop someone fitting that description?  Or would it fall under "spotting someone who fits the description?"

Maybe they redacted the dispatch recording where the cop said, "I see a Black Male and Female in a car.  I think I'll pull them over, because odds are good they've done something wrong."


Political correctness is censorship.  If our law enforcement can't honestly describe a suspect's features for fear of offending or being accused of "profiling," how the heck are they expected to find anyone?
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: London808 on July 09, 2016, 10:29:54 PM
he had a CCW issued from Hennepin County, why the NRA isn't backing Philando Castile about this is complete BS.

They arent backing him because as they said in the statement they were waiting for more information, turns out it was a good call, The cops are saying he was pulling a gun and that got him shot, The GF is a liar and has contradicted herself and been caught out on a few details.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: London808 on July 09, 2016, 10:45:41 PM
Also i wonder when his CCW was issued, It says he worked at the school for 12 yrs and was a st pauls resident which is in Ramsey county and not Hennepin County,  The permit is only Valid for 5 years and you have to notify them of change of address and the permit can only be issued to residents of the county.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 10, 2016, 01:03:14 AM
The police are in the wrong on this one. The NRA is a bunch of cowards for not standing up for this and only speaking out about the dead cops in Dallas.

Actually I saw it reported that the NRA did call for a complete investigation into the shooting.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Aegis808 on July 10, 2016, 03:23:42 AM
I was unaware facial features fell under "profiling."     :wtf:

African-Americans have a variety of nose "widths", so I fail to see the profiling aspect.

If I say, "suspect is a white male, 6', 210 lbs, black hair, and white running shoes with green stripes," is that "profiling," when I stop someone fitting that description?  Or would it fall under "spotting someone who fits the description?"

Maybe they redacted the dispatch recording where the cop said, "I see a Black Male and Female in a car.  I think I'll pull them over, because odds are good they've done something wrong."


Political correctness is censorship.  If our law enforcement can't honestly describe a suspect's features for fear of offending or being accused of "profiling," how the heck are they expected to find anyone?

If a wide nose is all you have from a robbery that happened 4 days earlier is what you consider probable cause, cops would be able to pull over any damn car they want.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Aegis808 on July 10, 2016, 03:26:39 AM
Also i wonder when his CCW was issued, It says he worked at the school for 12 yrs and was a st pauls resident which is in Ramsey county and not Hennepin County,  The permit is only Valid for 5 years and you have to notify them of change of address and the permit can only be issued to residents of the county.

failure to notify of moving address is a petty misdemeanor, not an instant death sentence. It's amazing how folks around here complain about every damn hoop we have to jump through to own a gun in Hawaii and then turn around and defend the very same kind of stupid laws to justify shooting a person dead.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 10, 2016, 04:25:27 AM
If a wide nose is all you have from a robbery that happened 4 days earlier is what you consider probable cause, cops would be able to pull over any damn car they want.

Nothing indicates that was the only matching feature he observed. It could just be the only one he verbalized or the one that stuck out most.

Bottom line is this, we really don't have much evidence to base any sort of judgment about the shooting. The video proves nothing and only offers a few tidbits of circumstantial evidence.

Claiming the officer is guilty of murder flies in the face of the burden of proof needed to even take it to trial at this point, much less actually convict.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Kingkeoni on July 10, 2016, 05:24:20 AM
Oh wait. He was a black guy. He must have done something wrong. It's disgusting how some members of the gun rights community see themselves as champions of the constitution but always seem to ending up explaining away situations like this when it's someone of a darker complexion with a funny sounding name. The issue is if they can do this to one of us and get away with it then we are all in danger, and those who only defend the rights of people like themselves are way more damaging to the credibility of the movement than any Anti could ever be.

The reality is that none of us were there when the stop happened.

I honestly believe that most police officers are simply doing their job and not targeting people to shoot.

People like you though, jump to conclusions and post ignorant comments and statements like "murdered by cop" to incite racial tension.

If a police officer shot and killed someone and it is/was not justified then he should stand trial and pay for his crime like any other citizen would.

Having said that though, the sheer reality is that the facts have not been revealed as of yet and to jump to conclusions about this or any other shooting (especially where race is involved) just fuels the fire.

I honestly wish people would just wait for the facts to come out before becoming a part of the problem...
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: new guy on July 10, 2016, 07:40:51 AM
.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: robtmc on July 10, 2016, 10:47:43 AM
I honestly people would just wait for the facts to come out before becoming a part of the problem...
For the race baiters posting here recently, that would violate the "Never let a crisis go to waste" principle.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 10, 2016, 01:12:36 PM
If a wide nose is all you have from a robbery that happened 4 days earlier is what you consider probable cause, cops would be able to pull over any damn car they want.

The description did have more than the nose.  Anyone with common sense would know that.  The cop simply didn't ramble off all the matching features, maybe because he didn't want to state "Black Male" and be accused of profiling ....
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Shoboshi on July 10, 2016, 05:13:58 PM
http://m.liveleak.com/view?i=b95_1468030677
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: London808 on July 10, 2016, 09:02:48 PM
http://m.liveleak.com/view?i=b95_1468030677

So was he under the influence when stooped by the cop, did he tell the cop he had a firearm and accidentally grab it instead of his wallet like he intended ?
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Shoboshi on July 10, 2016, 09:32:01 PM
Same characters, different day. This was on Fourth of July
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Aegis808 on July 11, 2016, 04:39:07 AM
http://m.liveleak.com/view?i=b95_1468030677

smoking weed justifies being shot by a cop, got it.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 11, 2016, 08:30:50 AM
smoking weed justifies being shot by a cop, got it.

Typical anti-cop comment.

Smoking weed with the child in the room sets a great example, and shows what upstanding, law-abiding people they both are/were.

But then, you knew that.  You're just making a straw argument -- no one posted what you said.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: drck1000 on July 11, 2016, 08:37:01 AM
Has a pretty heated discussion over this on the drive home from golf yesterday.  Golfed with one of my best friends (former prosecutor and gun owner) and one of his buddies from law school.  I consider the "law school buddy (LSB)" a good friend as well.  He got his handgun certification and I've taken him shooting a couple of times.  Anyways, I HATE talking about politics, but the LSB starts a conversation about this incident and racial disparity.  The conversation went all over the place, but the main point that I wanted to share was how he felt that the officers were at fault and should have been better trained.  He basically parroted all the stuff stated by CNN.   This disappointed me because as an attorney, I would've thought that he would want to consider the facts of the case, which IMO he didn't really have.  I countered his points regarding training with how fast things can go south and when put into those situations, people from both sides of the argument have reacted the same way, which was to shoot first, even if the aggressor wasn't armed.  Why?  Because they felt threatened. . . I added other points, but he conceded that point.  The discussion also went to people of lower class and are they put there (oppressed) or do many either put themselves in that situation or languish there, however that would take pages to cover. 

What got me thinking after this discussion that because I hate discussions about politic (and religion), I very much avoid them.  Then I started thinking that maybe I am "part of the problem" in that I keep silent.  I've had many gun rights/control conversations with may of my good friends, but most of them are like-minded.  I had a gun conversation with another one of my best friends, who incidentally is an attorney and his brother is a cop.  We had a pretty heated discussion about gun control and I was able to get him to see the logic and truth regarding gun control and the abundance of misinformation.  That said, I generally avoid that discussion with others, but it's more like I don't put in the effort.  Part of that is I also am not as well "armed" with facts and counter arguments as I would like.  Many times, I find that after the conversation is over, I remember the things that I should have said. 
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: armsinc on July 11, 2016, 09:07:27 AM
Typical anti-cop comment.

Smoking weed with the child in the room sets a great example, and shows what upstanding, law-abiding people they both are/were.

But then, you knew that.  You're just making a straw argument -- no one posted what you said.

I am pron cop but if an individual smokes weed on the 4 July and is pulled over days later for a broken tail light dose not mean he was reaching for his gun. And the cop might have been doing everything by the book. We won't know until more evidence comes out. Also this is a perfect example of why law enforcement should wear body cameras and why their is a need for civil review of those cameras.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: drck1000 on July 11, 2016, 09:16:08 AM
I am pron cop but if an individual smokes weed on the 4 July and is pulled over days later for a broken tail light dose not mean he was reaching for his gun. And the cop might have been doing everything by the book. We won't know until more evidence comes out. Also this is a perfect example of why law enforcement should wear body cameras and why their is a need for civil review of those cameras.

Exactly.  We don't know and only the eye witness will have that information.  Even then, maybe only two people, the officers, may have had the necessary vantage point. 

People generally remember the first thing that they are presented in situations like this and sadly, many will only remember the passenger's video as the "truth".  It very well may be the truth.  However, while I very much doubt her version, I do have some questions regarding the officer's side as well.  I just don't have enough facts and we may never have all the facts.  I just wish people weren't so quick to rush to be judge and jury. 
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: passivekinetic on July 11, 2016, 09:16:10 AM
Has a pretty heated discussion over this on the drive home from golf yesterday.  Golfed with one of my best friends (former prosecutor and gun owner) and one of his buddies from law school.  I consider the "law school buddy (LSB)" a good friend as well.  He got his handgun certification and I've taken him shooting a couple of times.  Anyways, I HATE talking about politics, but the LSB starts a conversation about this incident and racial disparity.  The conversation went all over the place, but the main point that I wanted to share was how he felt that the officers were at fault and should have been better trained.  He basically parroted all the stuff stated by CNN.   This disappointed me because as an attorney, I would've thought that he would want to consider the facts of the case, which IMO he didn't really have.  I countered his points regarding training with how fast things can go south and when put into those situations, people from both sides of the argument have reacted the same way, which was to shoot first, even if the aggressor wasn't armed.  Why?  Because they felt threatened. . . I added other points, but he conceded that point.  The discussion also went to people of lower class and are they put there (oppressed) or do many either put themselves in that situation or languish there, however that would take pages to cover. 

What got me thinking after this discussion that because I hate discussions about politic (and religion), I very much avoid them.  Then I started thinking that maybe I am "part of the problem" in that I keep silent.  I've had many gun rights/control conversations with may of my good friends, but most of them are like-minded.  I had a gun conversation with another one of my best friends, who incidentally is an attorney and his brother is a cop.  We had a pretty heated discussion about gun control and I was able to get him to see the logic and truth regarding gun control and the abundance of misinformation.  That said, I generally avoid that discussion with others, but it's more like I don't put in the effort.  Part of that is I also am not as well "armed" with facts and counter arguments as I would like.  Many times, I find that after the conversation is over, I remember the things that I should have said.

Dude you are just out of practice. I read somewhere that although many of the stupid liberal arguments over the years/decades have been illogical, irrational, etc. and very annoying to people who think objectively, one effect that is overlooked is that years and years of arguing (discussing, really, or should be) these issues has actually REFINED our skills in debating these topics. For example, gun control. Numerous MSM bullsh*t over the years, with numerous facts, statistics, logical thinking etc. supporting gun rights. Numerous analogies we can use to explain. For example whenever someone tells me people can just go hand to hand combat instead of shoot each other, that is a real easy one. I ask them how does a 100 lb woman go hand to hand against a 200 lb rapist? That's just one example.

Your debate-fu will increase in levels as you debate more. Maybe 9 times out of 10 the other person still refuses to see the light. But if you get through to one person, that person can start on his/her road to enlighten others and you recruited one more person to "join the team."

So, while annoying and frustrating at times, it is imperative that everyone speak up. The hard part is actually controlling yourself to no be annoyed even when the discussion goes into stupid-land.

It is very important not to present oneself as the angry, obsolete, half-wit clinging to guns, bible, and constitution, that the MSM loves to stereotype.

Sorry didn't mean to lecture. But really wanted to emphasize the importance of engaging in debates. Of course, if you feel the other person really is completely stupid and "brainwashed' by years of MSM content then cut your losses. No need to lose friends over this. I've actually seen friends eventually "wake up" after a few years, and then it's time for THEM to feel frustrated explaining things to another "libtard" LOL
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 11, 2016, 09:24:23 AM
I am pron cop but if an individual smokes weed on the 4 July and is pulled over days later for a broken tail light dose not mean he was reaching for his gun. And the cop might have been doing everything by the book. We won't know until more evidence comes out. Also this is a perfect example of why law enforcement should wear body cameras and why their is a need for civil review of those cameras.

The weed smoking is a straw argument, like I said.  Unless, of course, you believe the cop somehow knew they had smoked weed on July 4th!   :crazy:

As for the real facts, let's wait and see what they are.  Traffic stop?  Subject looked like a robbery suspect?  Give the investigators some time!

Quote
The BCA said "several" videos, including squad car video, "have been collected as evidence." St. Anthony Police Department officers do not wear body cameras, the BCA release noted, and a gun was recovered on the scene.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: drck1000 on July 11, 2016, 09:30:03 AM
Dude you are just out of practice. I read somewhere that although many of the stupid liberal arguments over the years/decades have been illogical, irrational, etc. and very annoying to people who think objectively, one effect that is overlooked is that years and years of arguing (discussing, really, or should be) these issues has actually REFINED our skills in debating these topics. For example, gun control. Numerous MSM bullsh*t over the years, with numerous facts, statistics, logical thinking etc. supporting gun rights. Numerous analogies we can use to explain. For example whenever someone tells me people can just go hand to hand combat instead of shoot each other, that is a real easy one. I ask them how does a 100 lb woman go hand to hand against a 200 lb rapist? That's just one example.

Your debate-fu will increase in levels as you debate more. Maybe 9 times out of 10 the other person still refuses to see the light. But if you get through to one person, that person can start on his/her road to enlighten others and you recruited one more person to "join the team."

So, while annoying and frustrating at times, it is imperative that everyone speak up. The hard part is actually controlling yourself to no be annoyed even when the discussion goes into stupid-land.

It is very important not to present oneself as the angry, obsolete, half-wit clinging to guns, bible, and constitution, that the MSM loves to stereotype.

Sorry didn't mean to lecture. But really wanted to emphasize the importance of engaging in debates. Of course, if you feel the other person really is completely stupid and "brainwashed' by years of MSM content then cut your losses. No need to lose friends over this. I've actually seen friends eventually "wake up" after a few years, and then it's time for THEM to feel frustrated explaining things to another "libtard" LOL

Thanks.  Nah, don't view that at a lecture and I pretty much ask/told myself the same thing last night.  That not putting in the time and effort just contributes to the perpetuation of misinformation by allowing it to spread. 

There are many times in the conversation yesterday that I just wanted to say "You're a democrat, aren't ya?"  But, I didn't.  Surprises me on may levels as he comes from a pretty affluent family that my understanding worked hard to get there through a couple of generations, to hear him comment about how many minorities are oppressed and such.  There are many points where he is very much the "I know what I know, don't confuse me with the facts" kind of person.  To that end, I will just back off, but my best friend, who knows him better will keep on it.  Well, they are both attorneys, so they like to argue.   ;D  At one point, the LSB got very quiet as we each presented counters to his comments/view points.  Mind you that my best friend and I were also approaching the argument from different perspectives as well, but both generally countering the LSB's arguments.  It was when LSB got very quiet that my best friend calmly said "are you getting mad?".  He was and I believe it was because he honestly felt he was right and we weren't hearing it. 

Yeah, I have to improve my debate-fu for sure.  There's definitely a lot of that going on here for sure, even though many debates tend to take tangents into who knows where. 
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: passivekinetic on July 11, 2016, 10:36:15 AM
There's also the irrelevant, but highly relevant, factor of people's "face" and "self-esteem" in these debates.

So even if they secretly are getting convinced by you, not everyone will be man/woman enough to say upfront, you convinced me. I was wrong.

But if we do not let the debate go into argument phase, and get people's feelings involved, they might actually think over what you said and in the future, at least they won't argue the liberal side as heatedly, and accept perhaps it's not entirely correct what they tell you to think on TV.

One of the things I learned to overcome was to keep in mind the aim is not to prove that YOU are right. But to change the other person's mind. The two are not exactly the same, even though effectively they are.

In fact nobody LIKES to be proven wrong, because then it says, Hey, I was an idiot most of my life. Nobody likes that! LOL

Better to let them think, Oh, I was lied to, or hey, I wasn't told the right facts, thanks for letting me know. I guess I need to question my assumptions I had before.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Aegis808 on July 11, 2016, 02:05:03 PM
Typical anti-cop comment.

Smoking weed with the child in the room sets a great example, and shows what upstanding, law-abiding people they both are/were.

But then, you knew that.  You're just making a straw argument -- no one posted what you said.

how many of you drink beer or smoke tobacco in front of your kids? The only difference is that some people genuinely believe that laws are what establish morals in society. These very same stupid over reaches by government in to our lives are what creates the situations that give cops an excuse to pull people over create needless conflicts that end with dead people.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: London808 on July 11, 2016, 02:39:59 PM
smoking weed justifies being shot by a cop, got it.

NO, it dont But that being said, Smoking weed in a car with your kid shows shitty fuckin parenting skills, Being under the influence of drugs or alcohol when he got pulled over could explain a bunch of stuff, 

why was she dam calm when the guy next to her had just been shot.
why the kid in the back was so dam quite.
why he dident follow police instructions.
why he may have pulled a gun instead of his wallet.
why he was reaching for his wallet at the same time as telling the cop he had a gun.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 11, 2016, 03:43:12 PM
how many of you drink beer or smoke tobacco in front of your kids? The only difference is that some people genuinely believe that laws are what establish morals in society. These very same stupid over reaches by government in to our lives are what creates the situations that give cops an excuse to pull people over create needless conflicts that end with dead people.

While it's not directly related to LE interactions, since you went off on the tangent of alcohol and morals ...

Alcohol linked to more homicides in US than any other substance

http://www.nhregister.com/general-news/20140820/alcohol-linked-to-more-homicides-in-us-than-any-other-substance

Quote
CHICAGO — Which intoxicating substance is associated with the most lethal violence? Devotees of “The Wire” might presume that cocaine or maybe heroin would top the list, especially if you asked the worst causes of violence in poor, minority communities.

The correct answer, by far, is alcohol. It’s involved in more homicides than pretty much every other substance, combined. Alcohol’s relative importance has grown over the last fifteen years, as aging populations of cocaine users account for a declining proportion of violent crime. Here in Chicago, positive cocaine screens in the Cook County Jail are down by about half when compared with 10 or 20 years ago. The same is true in many other cities.

Surveys of people incarcerated for violent crimes indicate that about 40 percent had been drinking at the time they committed these offenses. Among those who had been drinking, average blood-alcohol levels were estimated to exceed three times the legal limit. Drinking is especially common among perpetrators of specific crimes, including murder, sexual assault, and intimate partner violence.

Correlation does not equal causation, of course. If offenders all stopped drinking, we wouldn’t see a 100-percent reduction in their crimes. Yet alcohol does play a distinctive role. It lowers inhibitions and, among some people, fosters aggressive behavior that ratchets up the risk that violence will somehow occur. In my own career as a public health researcher, I’ve come into close contact with many intoxicated heroin and marijuana users. In these moments, I’ve never had reason to feel that my safety was at risk. I have been present for some scary incidents. Almost every time, alcohol was in the mix, often as things were getting a little late in a tough neighborhood near a liquor store.

Aside from its role among perpetrators of violence, alcohol use is widespread among victims, too. If alcohol makes you more likely to be a perpetrator of violence, almost by definition it makes you more likely to be a victim in the same incident. Downing some liquid courage may impair your judgment, which makes you a little less wary or a little more vulnerable in obvious ways. It may narrow your options and thus create other risks, too. You’re less likely to leave that cutting remark unanswered. If you’re unfit to drive, you’re more willing to accept that ride home from a helpful stranger.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 11, 2016, 03:45:41 PM
https://youtu.be/q3j34rJytl8
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 11, 2016, 03:55:40 PM
how many of you drink beer or smoke tobacco in front of your kids? The only difference is that some people genuinely believe that laws are what establish morals in society. These very same stupid over reaches by government in to our lives are what creates the situations that give cops an excuse to pull people over create needless conflicts that end with dead people.

Wrong!  The difference is, weed is illegal (at least federally even if you have a medical marijuana card).  If the message you want to send your kids is "Break the law, just don't get caught", then I have to admit it's not how we raised our kids. 

You can live by your own "morals" in opposition to the law all you want if you are willing to accept the consequences.  By teaching your kids to do that, are you really doing them any favors?  Is recreational weed worth risking a police record and maybe getting fired/not hired from a company with a zero tolerance policy on drug use?

Sometimes when you're right, that's all you get to be.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: drck1000 on July 11, 2016, 04:02:32 PM
how many of you drink beer or smoke tobacco in front of your kids? The only difference is that some people genuinely believe that laws are what establish morals in society. These very same stupid over reaches by government in to our lives are what creates the situations that give cops an excuse to pull people over create needless conflicts that end with dead people.
Isn't it still illegal to smoke weed in Hawaii unless you have specific medical or other needs? 

I don't have kids, but I don't really think any differently of friends who drink alcohol in front of their kids.  Tobacco is a little different due to second hand smoke, but if they are smoking away from the kids, then no worries.   Neither are illegal though. 

Maybe splitting hairs, but I believe laws are derived based on morals of a society, not where laws establish morals.  People have morals, or at least ideally should have morals independent of laws that attempt to govern behavior.  Where laws often get twisted is where people impose their morals on others. 
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Aegis808 on July 11, 2016, 05:08:52 PM
Isn't it still illegal to smoke weed in Hawaii unless you have specific medical or other needs? 

I don't have kids, but I don't really think any differently of friends who drink alcohol in front of their kids.  Tobacco is a little different due to second hand smoke, but if they are smoking away from the kids, then no worries.   Neither are illegal though. 

Maybe splitting hairs, but I believe laws are derived based on morals of a society, not where laws establish morals.  People have morals, or at least ideally should have morals independent of laws that attempt to govern behavior.  Where laws often get twisted is where people impose their morals on others.

laws aren't indicators of morals of a society. what is the morality of a law that makes people pay the city for driving faster than what is posted on a sign? what is the moral behind making one plant illegal while others are subsidized? what is the moral behind firearms registration? where are the morals in laws that fine the homeless for sleeping on the beach?

using these terrible immoral laws as a basis of saying the police are justified in shooting people that refuse to comply with these laws is the high of immorality. Saying someone is bad simply because they follow law #150872 is i no way a justification to give police the powers to shoot people.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 11, 2016, 06:25:45 PM
laws aren't indicators of morals of a society. what is the morality of a law that makes people pay the city for driving faster than what is posted on a sign? what is the moral behind making one plant illegal while others are subsidized? what is the moral behind firearms registration? where are the morals in laws that fine the homeless for sleeping on the beach?

using these terrible immoral laws as a basis of saying the police are justified in shooting people that refuse to comply with these laws is the high of immorality. Saying someone is bad simply because they follow law #150872 is i no way a justification to give police the powers to shoot people.

Don't agree with the consequences?  Then work to change the law.  Until then ...


(http://i.imgur.com/XDWZpX6.png)
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: hvybarrels on July 11, 2016, 07:09:41 PM
The problem is when the law turns predatory. I've seen several attempts to imply that black people must be at fault for their own problems because they "commit more crimes" than other groups. But what's happening is the system is set up so that they can be arrested illegally just to make a quota, and then prosecutors can plea-bargain them out on some lesser charge or chose to have a trial they could never hope to afford to fight. The result is massive plea-outs that distort the actual crime rates while the courts, cops, bail bondsmen, prisons, and related services rake in hundreds of millions of dollars a year while keeping surplus labor off the market. If they tried these shakedown scams in affluent neighborhoods with lawyer money there would be outrage and the police station would be shut down.

White-collar criminals usually get off with reduced sentence for crimes that steal billions from taxpayers vs. some homeless guy who pees in an alley and gets locked up as a sex offender, but the Security State will confiscate the assets of Mom & Pop small businesses for making "suspicious deposits" when it's obvious no crime has been committed. Why is there a war on drugs? So they can raise money through price inflation, concentrate it dealer networks, and then take it when the scam is ripe knowing full well someone else in dire straits (who can't get a normal job because of a criminal record) will happily step up to fill the void in demand.

I get labelled anti-cop for pointing this stuff out, but what I'm trying to say is that cops have an impossible job. They are working under the assumption that their employment has something to do with public safety, but in reality they are forced to perform wealth extraction and enacting increasingly totalitarian policies as their efforts to make a safer society fail.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Aegis808 on July 11, 2016, 08:22:14 PM
Telling someone to obey bad laws is the biggest crock of shit I've ever heard and we've just had the FBI tell us why anyone else but Hillary Clinton would have been charged with a crime for what she did.

The law has been perverted and is of no use to obey when it is used to oppress the people. The people saying obey bad laws are the very same people that would rat out their Jewish neighbors to the gestapo were this 1939 Germany. All because their excuse will be, it's the law.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 11, 2016, 08:24:52 PM
The problem is when the law turns predatory. I've seen several attempts to imply that black people must be at fault for their own problems because they "commit more crimes" than other groups. But what's happening is the system is set up so that they can be arrested illegally just to make a quota, and then prosecutors can plea-bargain them out on some lesser charge or chose to have a trial they could never hope to afford to fight. The result is massive plea-outs that distort the actual crime rates while the courts, cops, bail bondsmen, prisons, and related services rake in hundreds of millions of dollars a year while keeping surplus labor off the market. If they tried these shakedown scams in affluent neighborhoods with lawyer money there would be outrage and the police station would be shut down.

White-collar criminals usually get off with reduced sentence for crimes that steal billions from taxpayers vs. some homeless guy who pees in an alley and gets locked up as a sex offender, but the Security State will confiscate the assets of Mom & Pop small businesses for making "suspicious deposits" when it's obvious no crime has been committed. Why is there a war on drugs? So they can raise money through price inflation, concentrate it dealer networks, and then take it when the scam is ripe knowing full well someone else in dire straits (who can't get a normal job because of a criminal record) will happily step up to fill the void in demand.

I get labelled anti-cop for pointing this stuff out, but what I'm trying to say is that cops have an impossible job. They are working under the assumption that their employment has something to do with public safety, but in reality they are forced to perform wealth extraction and enacting increasingly totalitarian policies as their efforts to make a safer society fail.

Let's assume everything you just said is 100% true.

Given that, it doesn't justify failing to follow lawful commands of a Cop.  The street is the wrong place to assert your rights and the law's unfairness.  Like the saying goes, "Tell it to the judge."

Follow that simple hint, and I guarantee you won't get shot by a cop during a traffic stop.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: drck1000 on July 11, 2016, 08:58:56 PM
how many of you drink beer or smoke tobacco in front of your kids? The only difference is that some people genuinely believe that laws are what establish morals in society. These very same stupid over reaches by government in to our lives are what creates the situations that give cops an excuse to pull people over create needless conflicts that end with dead people.
Ok.  Maybe I misunderstood.  I thought you were saying that YOU genuinely believe that laws establish morals in society. 

Quote
mor·al
ˈmôrəl/
adjective
adjective: moral

    1. concerned with the principles of right and wrong behavior and the goodness or badness of human character.
 
    2. holding or manifesting high principles for proper conduct.

noun
noun: moral; plural noun: morals

    1. a lesson, especially one concerning what is right or prudent, that can be derived from a story, a piece of information, or an experience.

    2. a person's standards of behavior or beliefs concerning what is and is not acceptable for them to do.

I assumed you meant the noun in bold. 

laws aren't indicators of morals of a society. what is the morality of a law that makes people pay the city for driving faster than what is posted on a sign? what is the moral behind making one plant illegal while others are subsidized? what is the moral behind firearms registration? where are the morals in laws that fine the homeless for sleeping on the beach?

using these terrible immoral laws as a basis of saying the police are justified in shooting people that refuse to comply with these laws is the high of immorality. Saying someone is bad simply because they follow law #150872 is i no way a justification to give police the powers to shoot people.

All I was saying is that one should have morals, independent or even despite laws.  I was just saying that I didn't agree with your statement that you "believe that laws establish morals in society".  Or at least that's what it I thought you were saying. 

If a society determines that for instance gay marriage is unacceptable behavior, it will make laws to outlaw it.  What you personally feel is acceptable and unacceptable are independent of the laws.  Or if indeed "laws (do) establish morals in society", then if you lived in a society where there were laws that you disagreed with, you would say that your morals would be established/swayed by the laws of the land? 

Actually, I'm not quite sure what you're trying to say in your ramblings.  I was in no way trying to say that "the police are justified in shooting people that refuse to comply with these laws".  I was just saying that we don't yet know all of the facts in the case of the Minnesota incident. 


Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 12, 2016, 12:18:06 AM
The problem is when the law turns predatory. I've seen several attempts to imply that black people must be at fault for their own problems because they "commit more crimes" than other groups. But what's happening is the system is set up so that they can be arrested illegally just to make a quota, and then prosecutors can plea-bargain them out on some lesser charge or chose to have a trial they could never hope to afford to fight. The result is massive plea-outs that distort the actual crime rates while the courts, cops, bail bondsmen, prisons, and related services rake in hundreds of millions of dollars a year while keeping surplus labor off the market. If they tried these shakedown scams in affluent neighborhoods with lawyer money there would be outrage and the police station would be shut down.

So cops stopping black people is all an elaborate conspiracy to control how many people are out looking for a job?  :wtf: That's a new one to me.

Plea bargains exist for an entirely different purpose but for starters, where is there evidence that cops are making illegal arrests of black people in any significant numbers? (much less any of the other things in your alleged conspiracy)
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 12, 2016, 12:23:34 AM
laws aren't indicators of morals of a society. what is the morality of a law that makes people pay the city for driving faster than what is posted on a sign?

Because engineers determine the safe speeds for roads given the conditions so that people don't drive too fast for the conditions and kill/hurt themselves or others. The fines themselves are not a morality issue, they are a deterrent. It gives the traffic regulation reason to be followed.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: Aegis808 on July 12, 2016, 05:21:46 AM
Because engineers determine the safe speeds for roads given the conditions so that people don't drive too fast for the conditions and kill/hurt themselves or others. The fines themselves are not a morality issue, they are a deterrent. It gives the traffic regulation reason to be followed.

If engineers were setting speeds with safety in mind no car would go faster than 10 mph. Speed limits are arbitrary and the fines behind them are nothing more than revenue generation, while the traffic stops that they require to issue the fines actually end up creating an even larger hazard on the roads. All these facts become very apparent when you look at how much safer the autobahn is than the highways in the US. To compound the idiocy of the existence of traffic violations even more, the court costs of contesting a traffic ticket end up costing more for the government than the violator would ever have to pay, even if the offender were to pay full value of the fine.

It's not a system to deter, it's a system set up to enforce the idea that you can't function without government telling you what you can or can't do.
Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: drck1000 on July 12, 2016, 07:47:53 AM
You want to talk about costing the government money?  Lets talk about the cases where people crash and then sue the government. 

A driver is driving drunk (I don't recall the exact blood alcohol level, but it was well over 0.1%) in the early morning hours in Kapolei, crashes through the highway barrier and dies.  It is my understanding that the driver was doing something like 90+ in a zone that is either 50 or 55 mph.  Typically, for a posted speed of 55 mph, the design speed is something like 70-80 mph.  I would have to look at the AASHTO manual, but don't have one with me.  Anyways, the family sues the state with the argument that the engineers who designed the highway should have anticipated a given driver would be speeding and with the high likelihood that that that driver would be drunk.  It was well established that the driver's speed was well beyond the posted speed limit and beyond the design speed limit of the highway based on nationally accepted standards.  It is my understanding that no direct fault was found in the actual design of the highway based on nationally accepted standards.  Well, the jury found in favor of the family of the driver and stated that the state should have designed the highway to protect against driving in excess of 30 mph over the speed limit and drunk.  Well, guess when the law came about regarding excessive speed. . .  That and the release of movies like Fast and the Furious and video games like Gran Tourismo, but I digress. 

Title: Re: Concealed carrier murdered by cop
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 13, 2016, 02:47:59 AM
If engineers were setting speeds with safety in mind no car would go faster than 10 mph. Speed limits are arbitrary and the fines behind them are nothing more than revenue generation, while the traffic stops that they require to issue the fines actually end up creating an even larger hazard on the roads. All these facts become very apparent when you look at how much safer the autobahn is than the highways in the US. To compound the idiocy of the existence of traffic violations even more, the court costs of contesting a traffic ticket end up costing more for the government than the violator would ever have to pay, even if the offender were to pay full value of the fine.

It's not a system to deter, it's a system set up to enforce the idea that you can't function without government telling you what you can or can't do.

Nonsense. While I will agree that politicians certainly like the idea of revenue generation, that is not the main justification.

Yes, if safety were the only concern the limit would be 10mph but that isn't realistic. Not only would people not follow it but the negatives outweigh the positives. Drive along the Pali Hwy and look at the signs. The speeds go up and down depending on the condition of the road. This has nothing to do with revenue generation but about safe speeds to operate a vehicle at given the circumstances. Cops enforce it because otherwise many wouldn't bother to follow it.