2aHawaii
Tools and Uses => Reloading => Topic started by: tim808 on April 15, 2017, 03:54:33 AM
-
I'm considering the giraud tri way trimmer for 223 since it also deburs and chamfers. Currently, 223 is the only caliber I'll be reloading.
Later, I may reload for 9mm and 6.5 creedmore Since there is no tri way for 9mm...I'm looking at the worlds finest trimmer 2 since the chambers can be changed for different calibers. The wft 2 only trims
The gtwt does 3 things but i would need to buy another one for other rifle calibers.
The wft 2 only trims but can be used for pistol calibers and other rifles calibers by changing the chamber (about $27)
I'm leaning towards the wft 2 since it is more universal even if it won't debur/chamfer
I won't be reloading a lot of 223. Maybe 50-100 a month.
I like gtwt and wft because they index off the shoulder.
Any suggestions/recommendations?
Tnx
-
I'm considering the giraud tri way trimmer for 223 since it also deburs and chamfers. Currently, 223 is the only caliber I'll be reloading.
Later, I may reload for 9mm and 6.5 creedmore Since there is no tri way for 9mm...I'm looking at the worlds finest trimmer 2 since the chambers can be changed for different calibers. The wft 2 only trims
The gtwt does 3 things but i would need to buy another one for other rifle calibers.
The wft 2 only trims but can be used for pistol calibers and other rifles calibers by changing the chamber (about $27)
I'm leaning towards the wft 2 since it is more universal even if it won't debur/chamfer
I won't be reloading a lot of 223. Maybe 50-100 a month.
I like gtwt and wft because they index off the shoulder.
Any suggestions/recommendations?
Tnx
No need trim pistol
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I use this with my electric drill. Works great. You can also use the (Lyman) debur tool with the drill. I also know that WGS has a sizable inventory of these but they're only open on weekends now.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000LC2348/
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00MHZO6MY/
I also use my drill to chamfer the military brass.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0063IDE6A/
-
I bought the Giraud TriWay a few years ago. It is just like his all in one machine but without a motor. I use a cheap corded drill. Fastest trimmer I used thus far without spending a few hundred $. I trimmed a lot in several sitting that I have enough brass to last a few years. It sits on the shelf now - for awhile.
-
Macsak - tnx I didn't know that!! When I was reading about trimmers, one mentioned accommodating up 45 and I mistakenly assumed they also sold chambers for pistols. I looked better this time and went to the very end of the list and they only have chambers for rifle calibers!!
Rklapp - tnx for the info!! I'll look into it...it is a lot less $$$ than the wtf 2 and giraud. The Lee seems to not index off the shoulder like the others. I'm looking at eventually shooting med range and possibly long range and not sure how important indexing off the shoulder is for those ranges. (I plan to retire on the mainland)
Ren - did you choose the giraud because you only reload for one rifle caliber? I'm looking at the wts 2 mainly because my friend shoots 308.
If it was just me, I'd probably just get the giraud since I'm lazy and worry about a creedmore trimmer when I cross that bridge since I'm not even sure if it will be 6.5 or 6.0 or another member of the 6.0 family
My struggle is between my pake and Hawaiian parts - cost vs ease - and also trying to keep it kiss as much as possible since I'm just starting
Tnx guys for all the help!
-
I reload for 308 and 223. Bulk of it is 223.
I had the Lee. Cheap effective tool but it was slow and you still needed to chamfer
-
Hmmmm. Maybe I'll have my friend just buy his own trimmer
Tnx Ren!
-
Macsak - tnx I didn't know that!! When I was reading about trimmers, one mentioned accommodating up 45 and I mistakenly assumed they also sold chambers for pistols. I looked better this time and went to the very end of the list and they only have chambers for rifle calibers!!
Rklapp - tnx for the info!! I'll look into it...it is a lot less $$$ than the wtf 2 and giraud. The Lee seems to not index off the shoulder like the others. I'm looking at eventually shooting med range and possibly long range and not sure how important indexing off the shoulder is for those ranges. (I plan to retire on the mainland)
Ren - did you choose the giraud because you only reload for one rifle caliber? I'm looking at the wts 2 mainly because my friend shoots 308.
If it was just me, I'd probably just get the giraud since I'm lazy and worry about a creedmore trimmer when I cross that bridge since I'm not even sure if it will be 6.5 or 6.0 or another member of the 6.0 family
My struggle is between my pake and Hawaiian parts - cost vs ease - and also trying to keep it kiss as much as possible since I'm just starting
Tnx guys for all the help!
yeah, pistol pressures too low to elongate brass to a significant extent...
-
Forgot to add with the Giraud it took me about 3 seconds on average to trim, debur and chamfer.
Those Mechanix gloves work well in handling the cases.
I watch a movie and then I have a can of ready to load brass. With commercials.
-
yeah, pistol pressures too low to elongate brass to a significant extent...
....
I dunno about yours, but mine gets shorter as it gets older :rofl:
I have a gtw :thumbsup:
-
Ok I've read about people priming while watching tv
Now trimming while watching tv
I need to learn to multi task. I still haven't learned to walk while I surf the web on my phone
-
Problem solved. Friend is getting a gtw in 308
Tnx guys!
-
I got the Giraud motor system. If you going bulk, one of the best investments for reloading. It's like a super fast electric pencil sharpener. I used the drill one before but was tired of pressing the trigger, and can't watch the tv at the same time.
-
I use the Wilson Micrometer Trimmer on the Sinclair base with sharkfin attachment. I plan to get the carbide cutting blade soon to replace the original. Still need to chamfer and deburr after. Other than being a cheap Charlie on spending for the Giraud, my reasoning to get a manual trimmer was in case of SHTF/no power, I still can perform all phases of reloading. Use balance scales, but have a Franklin Arsenal digital scale to tell me if I'm close for convenience. Also have a dial and a digital caliper for dims. Everything else all manual.
-
....
I dunno about yours, but mine gets shorter as it gets older :rofl:
I have a gtw :thumbsup:
He was talking about brass. Get your mind out of the gutter you OF. :rofl: :rofl:
-
Watching Predators and trimming brass :thumbsup:
-
He was talking about brass. Get your mind out of the gutter you OF. :rofl: :rofl:
Buwhahahahaha!!!!
-
Rklapp - tnx for the info!! I'll look into it...it is a lot less $$$ than the wtf 2 and giraud. The Lee seems to not index off the shoulder like the others. I'm looking at eventually shooting med range and possibly long range and not sure how important indexing off the shoulder is for those ranges. (I plan to retire on the mainland)
So if you index off the shoulder, you could still have varying COAL and subsequently varying OAL. Good question. What is more important, consistent length from the shoulder or consistent length from the primer?
-
So if you index off the shoulder, you could still have varying COAL and subsequently varying OAL. Good question. What is more important, consistent length from the shoulder or consistent length from the primer?
As long as your brass sizing is consistent and accurate indexing off the shoulder of the case for trimming is fine. Shoulder to base dimensions sets headspace which is what one is after as far as shot to shot consistently. Neck trim off a thou or two isn't the end all for accuracy. If it's off a lot, it could cause issues. Any of the trimmers mentioned is well capable of doing the job.
I use the Giraud trimmer, it gets the job done quickly and easily.
-
Watching Predators and trimming brass :thumbsup:
....
Get to the choppa!
-
As long as your brass sizing is consistent and accurate indexing off the shoulder of the case for trimming is fine. Shoulder to base dimensions sets headspace which is what one is after as far as shot to shot consistently. Neck trim off a thou or two isn't the end all for accuracy. If it's off a lot, it could cause issues. Any of the trimmers mentioned is well capable of doing the job.
I use the Giraud trimmer, it gets the job done quickly and easily.
I tend to be picky with my COAL for my .223. If the case doesn't touch the trimming tool (2.250") or within 2 thousandth, I toss it. Federal cases are always too short. I'm gonna try measuring the shoulder to base length and see if that starts to bother me. You bastards already have me thinking about replacing my standard trigger. When will this torment end???
(http://2.media.dorkly.cvcdn.com/47/54/097b97e2aee6ce4e99b2e985a917eaeb-arnold-schwarzenegger-and-the-predator-finally-make-up.jpg)
-
Rklapp
Now you have me wondering
I don't know if this is right. I have to run this by my mentor. (The only thing is he only shoots semi so he always does a full length sizing but I'm loading for bolt gun)
For my fired brass, if the rim passes the min /max for the case gauge but the mouth > max on the gauge, I was planning to trim indexing off the shoulder.
The shoulder of fired brass may not exactly match the shoulder of FL sized brass, but after trimming I was going to check it again in the case gauge. If the mouth is within min/max of the case gauge, it should be ok right?
I would neck size a few times (3?) before doing a FL sizing. Plan is to anneal each time after I do a FL sizing and trimming. After FL sizing/annealing, I would load a cheaper bullet to shoot and produce fired brass. Plan is to use only neck sized fired brass for load development.
I probably have this all mixed up after trying to learn reloading off the web
-
Rklapp
Now you have me wondering
I don't know if this is right. I have to run this by my mentor. (The only thing is he only shoots semi so he always does a full length sizing but I'm loading for bolt gun)
For my fired brass, if the rim passes the min /max for the case gauge but the mouth > max on the gauge, I was planning to trim indexing off the shoulder.
The shoulder of fired brass may not exactly match the shoulder of FL sized brass, but after trimming I was going to check it again in the case gauge. If the mouth is within min/max of the case gauge, it should be ok right?
I would neck size a few times (3?) before doing a FL sizing. Plan is to anneal each time after I do a FL sizing and trimming. After FL sizing/annealing, I would load a cheaper bullet to shoot and produce fired brass. Plan is to use only neck sized fired brass for load development.
I probably have this all mixed up after trying to learn reloading off the web
1. you never want the neck to extend past the mouth of the case gage. The neck could get jammed into the lead of the rifling causing dangerous pressure spikes. Shorter is ok but over the max is a no go.
2. If you only neck size and develop a load, when you FL size (as you must eventually) you may have a point of impact shift or group size change for that load. This is why I FL size the body of the case MINIMALLY each and every time I reload the case. Bumping the shoulder back .002" .003" everytime means consistent ammo everytime.
I use a redding body die first to bump the shoulder of the case back .002" to .003". This die doesn't excessively resize the body of the case. I use a very light coating of Kiwi mink oil as a case lube on the body of the case, I try not to get any on the shoulder portion of the neck. If there is a bunch of lube over there the shoulder, the case can get sized more than desired.
Then I use a Lee mandrel neck sizer die to size and straighten the neck.
Clean off the lube using Oldfarts non clorinated brake cleaner method.
Then trim using the Giruad triway trimmer.
Ammo I make using this method has very minimal to no runout, I never have a hard to chamber round, and every bullet is consistent in impact and accuracy. Fast easy and efficient reloading. Once everything is set up and locked down no need to fuss.
-
I tend to be picky with my COAL for my .223. If the case doesn't touch the trimming tool (2.250") or within 2 thousandth, I toss it. Federal cases are always too short. I'm gonna try measuring the shoulder to base length and see if that starts to bother me. You bastards already have me thinking about replacing my standard trigger. When will this torment end???
(http://2.media.dorkly.cvcdn.com/47/54/097b97e2aee6ce4e99b2e985a917eaeb-arnold-schwarzenegger-and-the-predator-finally-make-up.jpg)
I think you are over analyzing. Federal 223 cases are soft, stretchy things. You'd be surprised at how .223 will shoot without lamenting about all these factors.
....
Get to the choppa!
That was the first Predator.
I was watching PredatorS. The one with Adrien Brody and Alice Braga. :thumbsup:
-
Heavies,
Interesting. I had thought FL sizing each time was basically for semi's for reliable feeding/extraction and neck sized fired brass was for better accuracy.
Sorry for confusion, I thought the top of the case was the mouth.
Your right, the FL sized case would not be consistent with neck sized cases so I was planning to load a cheap bullet to shoot....just to produce fired brass that would be used for load development
I'll give your method a shot. It is consistent/same each time and makes reloading more kiss since I wouldn't need to size 2 different ways or keep track of the # of times I have neck sized a case
If I FL size each time, is it ok if l anneal only when I have to trim.....or say every 3rd sizing?
My coworker's husband has a giraud and will anneal my cases but i don't want to bother him too much.
I could wait till I have a bunch to anneal....like several hundred cases.....bad idea?
Tnx!
-
Heavies,
Interesting. I had thought FL sizing each time was basically for semi's for reliable feeding/extraction and neck sized fired brass was for better accuracy.
Sorry for confusion, I thought the top of the case was the mouth.
Your right, the FL sized case would not be consistent with neck sized cases so I was planning to load a cheap bullet to shoot....just to produce fired brass that would be used for load development
I'll give your method a shot. It is consistent/same each time and makes reloading more kiss since I wouldn't need to size 2 different ways or keep track of the # of times I have neck sized a case
If I FL size each time, is it ok if l anneal only when I have to trim.....or say every 3rd sizing?
My coworker's husband has a giraud and will anneal my cases but i don't want to bother him too much.
I could wait till I have a bunch to anneal....like several hundred cases.....bad idea?
Tnx!
No problem. I do also agree with you on using a cheap bullet to get the case to size exactly to the chamber. I do that also with my new brass. I fireform the case to the rifles chamber. Then the next cycle is load development with those cases.
The hard part is measuring the base to shoulder. I have been using the Larry Willis tool for measuring both case shoulder and OAL to bullet ojive. Measuing to the tip of the billet is useless. The ojive is the part that matters to the OAL of the cartridge. This tool is my most used measuring device and is very precise and repeatable. I've tried other, but they don't come close to the ease of this tool. http://www.larrywillis.com/OAL.html
I'd anneal every loading to make the case last longer. But I already have a machine. I also run the case in the trimmer everytime, most times it just skims a little, but that just gives me the peace of mind.
-
Federal 223 cases are soft, stretchy things. You'd be surprised at how .223 will shoot without lamenting about all these factors.
:thumbsup: :thumbsup: :thumbsup:
-
Heavies,
I see
For new brass, you fireform it and then bump the shoulder back with a body die about 0.002" to 0.003" from it's fired size.
So it is basically a fire formed case....with the shoulder pushed back a little
Did I get it?
-
Heavies,
I see
For new brass, you fireform it and then bump the shoulder back with a body die about 0.002" to 0.003" from it's fired size.
So it is basically a fire formed case....with the shoulder pushed back a little
Did I get it?
Roger that. After fireforming to that particular rifle, push shoulder back .002". Looking at my notes, for bolt gun it was .0015" to .002. For semi automatic, .003 to .004"
-
Tnx Heavies!
-
Heavies
For the Redding body sizer do you use 75111 or 74111 (small body) or 75907 (40 degree)?
The Lee collet neck sizer is part 90954?
Thx!
-
Heavies
For the Redding body sizer do you use 75111 or 74111 (small body) or 75907 (40 degree)?
The Lee collet neck sizer is part 90954?
Thx!
I use the dies in .308, but If you have a normal size chamber 75111 normal body die should be fine. You have a .223/5.56 chamber correct?
The 40 degree is for a different cartridge, the 40 degree ackley improved, not what you want.
Lee 90954 is correct
-
Yes - I have a ruger American predator in 223
Tnx Heavies!
-
....
I dunno about yours, but mine gets shorter as it gets older :rofl:
Your not polishing it enough ! :rofl:
:wave:
-
Your not polishing it enough ! :rofl:
:wave:
...
Got some experience in that hmmmm?
-
Your not polishing it enough ! :rofl:
:wave:
If you use Flitz, you don't have to polish as long to get the same results. :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Hi Rocky :wave:
-
If you use Flitz, you don't have to polish as long to get the same results. :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Hi Rocky :wave:
Is Flitz the name of that ex-Girlfriend you won't tell s about ? :rofl: :rofl:
:wave:
-
Is Flitz the name of that ex-Girlfriend you won't tell s about ? :rofl: :rofl:
:wave:
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: