2aHawaii

General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: hvybarrels on October 09, 2018, 08:01:38 PM

Title: ConCon
Post by: hvybarrels on October 09, 2018, 08:01:38 PM
Opportunity to expand gun rights or an excuse to get the rest of them stripped away?

https://www.civilbeat.org/2018/10/dont-let-a-campaign-of-fear-stop-a-constitutional-convention/
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 10, 2018, 09:10:27 AM
Saw a commercial this morning to vote no.

Was this the booth at the gun show?  About getting states together to make their own laws and stuff?
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: macsak on October 10, 2018, 09:12:17 AM
Saw a commercial this morning to vote no.

Was this the booth at the gun show?  About getting states together to make their own laws and stuff?

no, that's something different
his is Hawaii only
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 10, 2018, 08:49:37 PM
I haven't followed this con con closely I must admit but my main desire for a con con is to have a citizens initiative put in place so our representatives can't shut us out from trying to get pro gun laws introduced.
 
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: hvybarrels on October 11, 2018, 02:28:12 PM
In my opinion the lack of Citizens Initiatives is why Hawaii government is so screwed up. One party and you ain't in it.
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: dafrtknocker on October 12, 2018, 05:52:20 PM
I will  vote Yes, just by looking who's against it.

http://www.staradvertiser.com/2018/10/12/hawaii-news/constitutional-convention-draws-opposition-from-powerful-coalition/?HSA=64187817a053876962599d0e7e8f2eea5263fca5

The coalition includes many of Hawaii’s major unions, such as the Hawaii Government Employees Association, which is the state’s largest, and unions representing public school teachers, police and firefighters. The Chamber of Commerce of Hawaii, the Sierra Club of Hawaii and the Hawaii chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union have also joined in the coalition, as has the Hawaii Democratic Party.
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: Rocky on October 12, 2018, 06:10:37 PM
I will  vote Yes, just by looking who's against it.

 :thumbsup: +2,587,000

http://www.staradvertiser.com/2018/10/12/hawaii-news/constitutional-convention-draws-opposition-from-powerful-coalition/?HSA=64187817a053876962599d0e7e8f2eea5263fca5

Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: macsak on October 12, 2018, 07:21:22 PM
I will  vote Yes, just by looking who's against it.

http://www.staradvertiser.com/2018/10/12/hawaii-news/constitutional-convention-draws-opposition-from-powerful-coalition/?HSA=64187817a053876962599d0e7e8f2eea5263fca5

The coalition includes many of Hawaii’s major unions, such as the Hawaii Government Employees Association, which is the state’s largest, and unions representing public school teachers, police and firefighters. The Chamber of Commerce of Hawaii, the Sierra Club of Hawaii and the Hawaii chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union have also joined in the coalition, as has the Hawaii Democratic Party.

I was for it from before the first anti-commercial
didn't know who made it, but I knew that the only way we can shake up the status quo is a con con
and the fact that someone was so against it reinforced my belief
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: tillamook on October 12, 2018, 07:28:11 PM
I will  vote Yes, just by looking who's against it.

http://www.staradvertiser.com/2018/10/12/hawaii-news/constitutional-convention-draws-opposition-from-powerful-coalition/?HSA=64187817a053876962599d0e7e8f2eea5263fca5

The coalition includes many of Hawaii’s major unions, such as the Hawaii Government Employees Association, which is the state’s largest, and unions representing public school teachers, police and firefighters. The Chamber of Commerce of Hawaii, the Sierra Club of Hawaii and the Hawaii chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union have also joined in the coalition, as has the Hawaii Democratic Party.

Someone in the comments said that a blank vote is counted as a "no" vote.  Is that true in Hawaii?

Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 12, 2018, 09:30:13 PM
Someone in the comments said that a blank vote is counted as a "no" vote.  Is that true in Hawaii?

In this particular case, a blank vote is not a "No" vote.

(1)  if there are more "Yes" than "No" votes (a majority), AND
(2) if at least 50% of the total ballots cast are "Yes" votes (including blanks and over votes), then the measure passes. 

Just getting more "Yes" votes than "No" votes isn't good enough if at least 50.1% of the ballots were "No" or left blank on the question.

Example: 
   Yes:   1,000
   No:       900
   Blanks: 100

The measure would pass in this example.  If the blanks counted as a "no", there would be a tie. 
If there were 200 blank votes, then the measure would not pass ("Yes" failed to get 50% of the total ballots cast), even though there are more "Yes" than "No" votes.

Quote
At the general election, the question is approved if both qualifications are met:

Test 1: Yes votes receive a majority of votes tallied, excluding blank and over votes
Test 2: Yes votes receive at least fifty percent of the total votes cast, including blank and over votes

https://elections.hawaii.gov/resources/revision-and-amendment-of-the-hawaii-state-constitution/
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 12, 2018, 11:39:49 PM
Hanabusa is not for it, so count me in

Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk

Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: punaperson on October 13, 2018, 05:27:49 PM
Two brief statements by senator Thielen in favor of ConCon:

Shall Hawaii Hold a ConCon? The Question Comes Down to, Do You Think the Legislature Will Resolve Hawaii’s Chronic Challenges?
October 7, 2018 By Senator Laura Thielen

http://www.senatorlaurathielen.com/shall-hawaii-hold-a-concon-the-question-comes-down-to-do-you-think-the-legislature-will-resolve-hawaiis-chronic-challenges/

Hawaii legislators are the only people who can create a state law. The Governor can’t; the Judiciary can’t.

As you can imagine, this has led to situations where our state laws treat legislators differently from other government officials.

For example, all City & County Councils, State and County Boards and Commissions and Task Forces, have to follow Hawaii’s Sunshine Law. Meetings are publically noticed 7 days in advance; they can only vote on items on their agenda; the public may attend and testify; no meeting behind closed doors to discuss items they will be voting on.

The Hawaii State Legislature exempted itself from the Sunshine Law. Which is why legislators can (and have) meet behind closed doors, decide to gut a bill in Committee without notice, replace it with entirely different contents, and vote it into law.

Special treatment for state legislators can be found in other laws; from different levels of pension contributions, to no term limits, unlike every other elected politician and virtually all appointed Boards and Commissions.

We Need a Hawaii Constitutional Convention

http://www.senatorlaurathielen.com/we-need-a-hawaii-constitutional-convention/
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: zippz on October 15, 2018, 12:55:18 AM
If there is a concon, then you guys are going to be in for a lot of work to educate people and get them to vote.  What you guys are proposing is a pipedream in todays environment.  More than likely there will be enough votes to pass stuff you dont want.
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: punaperson on October 15, 2018, 07:34:14 AM
If there is a concon, then you guys are going to be in for a lot of work to educate people and get them to vote.  What you guys are proposing is a pipedream in todays environment.  More than likely there will be enough votes to pass stuff you dont want.
I don't know the details of who votes where in what "districts" for the delegates to the convention, but if the voting population is the same as that which votes for the Hawaii legislature (Senate 100% Dem, House 90% Dem), it's pretty clear who and what values will be overwhelmingly represented by the delegates to any such event. That group of delegates will be highly unlikely to be in favor of more personal liberty and freedom against statist impositions for the "collective good". I don't see initiative, referendum, recall, term limits (Hawaii is the only state in the United States that does not have a single one of those provisions) or any kind of clarifying language to "the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed". What are they going to add? "No, seriously, we mean it... shall NOT be infringed."

On the other hand, they could go the opposite direction and impose into the constitution their preferred progressive diktats to cement the inevitable further decay and downfall of anything resembling "securing the blessings of liberty". It seems the vast majority of the population here prefers that, including the state monopoly of violence (aka civilian disarmament (aka "a few commonsense gun safety regulations"))..

(https://s15-us2.startpage.com/cgi-bin/serveimage?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.azquotes.com%2Fpicture-quotes%2Fquote-socialism-is-inseparably-interwoven-with-totalitarianism-and-the-object-worship-of-the-winston-churchill-93-90-24.jpg&sp=ce2369e7a431beb67ad5533eda080ccc)
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: robtmc on October 15, 2018, 07:39:40 AM
I will  vote Yes, just by looking who's against it.

Excellent method, have used it for decades with ballot measures, just look at who is for and against.
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: tillamook on October 15, 2018, 07:47:22 AM
I voted, LOL
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: hvybarrels on October 15, 2018, 10:12:57 AM
If there is a concon, then you guys are going to be in for a lot of work to educate people and get them to vote.  What you guys are proposing is a pipedream in todays environment.  More than likely there will be enough votes to pass stuff you dont want.

The glass could definitely go less than half empty on smaller near n' dear issues, but the bigger picture is that the environment that created the one-party state is the reason we are backed up against a wall in the first place. Hawaii government is set up to protect the interests of a privileged few and discourage participation by the public. They love low voter turnout and people giving up in frustration and not paying attention. With all the corruption and scandals it's a great time to shake the ant farm and get everyone excited about creating something that works instead of the current slow suicide train to a concrete encased toxic island full of feral homeless and murderous law enforcement where nobody in their right mind would want to vacation.

We probably won't get everything we want, but snapping potential voters out of their humbug-coma and getting them engaged in the process is what we need.

Right now Bloomberg, Monsanto, LDS, and whoever else can march into the state and throw tons of money around to get what they want and they tell us we have to "wait until next election" to do something about it. That's just a cleverly disguised master/slave relationship.
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: zippz on October 15, 2018, 10:20:50 AM
I guess we have nothing to lose.  Legislature could vote on amenemdments for a vote anyways
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 15, 2018, 02:22:31 PM
Many on SSH FB page are calling for a change in voting.  But it only has about 150K members or so.  Wish they would get political to help change from blue to red.
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: drck1000 on October 15, 2018, 02:47:55 PM
Been looking into this and definitely see positives. But also see potential for mainland interest groups to dump a bunch of money into the process and make things worse. 
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 15, 2018, 02:52:11 PM
Been looking into this and definitely see positives. But also see potential for mainland interest groups to dump a bunch of money into the process and make things worse.

Sam Boyd gonna dump money to make a casino maybe?
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: drck1000 on October 15, 2018, 06:47:34 PM
Sam Boyd gonna dump money to make a casino maybe?

I used to think it would be a great idea to legalize gambling on one of the outer islands, but don't think so anymore.  I don't think Sam Boyd had that kind of money, but who knows. 
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: Inspector on October 15, 2018, 07:48:52 PM

I used to think it would be a great idea to legalize gambling on one of the outer islands, but don't think so anymore.  I don't think Sam Boyd had that kind of money, but who knows.
I have watched the CA Lottery since it started. They claim that approximately $1B a year goes to schools. About $163/student. But in reality it goes to the school districts and they decide how the money is spent. Considering most CA school districts have overly large administration costs, the teachers and the students are not the ones that get the bulk of the money. So IMHO the people who the money would help the most, benefits the least. But I wonder if teachers really need the money? For instance, the average salary for a teacher in the LA Unified School District is $70K/year. I know my cousins wife makes around $80k/year. How much of that money really gets to the students then? When you consider that most students now have to pay for their own books and/or school supplies, I would guess very little gets to the students.

Also, surveys show that those who can afford to buy lottery tickets the least, buy the majority of the tickets. In other words, the poorest areas in CA generate the most in ticket sales. I have a feeling that it would be the same here. It seems the poor prefer to spend money they could spend on their families on lottery tickets.

I voted for the lottery originally. But I regret doing so now.

Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: drck1000 on October 15, 2018, 08:21:12 PM
I have watched the CA Lottery since it started. They claim that approximately $1B a year goes to schools. About $163/student. But in reality it goes to the school districts and they decide how the money is spent. Considering most CA school districts have overly large administration costs, the teachers and the students are not the ones that get the bulk of the money. So IMHO the people who the money would help the most, benefits the least. But I wonder if teachers really need the money? For instance, the average salary for a teacher in the LA Unified School District is $70K/year. I know my cousins wife makes around $80k/year. How much of that money really gets to the students then? When you consider that most students now have to pay for their own books and/or school supplies, I would guess very little gets to the students.

Also, surveys show that those who can afford to buy lottery tickets the least, buy the majority of the tickets. In other words, the poorest areas in CA generate the most in ticket sales. I have a feeling that it would be the same here. It seems the poor prefer to spend money they could spend on their families on lottery tickets.

I voted for the lottery originally. But I regret doing so now.
Lots of truth in that.  Same of what I heard for lotto funds in WA state.  That said, as long as the arguments stay factual and away from religious, I'd be open to listening.  I hate when the arguments against legalizing gambling strays into religious bases reasoning. 
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 16, 2018, 09:09:04 AM
The reason why a lotto will never come here is because it's gambling.  And it will open the door for casinos.

Media is pushing hard for ConAm.  Had UH teachers on TV supporting it this morning.  But no mention of those who do not.  Besides the paid advertisements as commercials.

Like how the same people get reelected, I know ConAm will pass because all those who do ZERO research will just vote yes because they hear it's for "education".  Unless you are given info by a realtor or like, then you have no idea what it really does.

Remember all those who supported the rail, and Cayetano's main reason for running was to stop it.  Bet many wished they voted for him now.
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: Kuleana on October 16, 2018, 10:23:42 AM
The reason why a lotto will never come here is because it's gambling.  And it will open the door for casinos.

And much bigger groups of organized crime.


Media is pushing hard for ConAm.  Had UH teachers on TV supporting it this morning.  But no mention of those who do not.  Besides the paid advertisements as commercials.

Like how the same people get reelected, I know ConAm will pass because all those who do ZERO research will just vote yes because they hear it's for "education".  Unless you are given info by a realtor or like, then you have no idea what it really does.

Info from realtors is just as biased.  Any laws that threaten the velocity of their business will be ruthlessly opposed by any realtor.



Remember all those who supported the rail, and Cayetano's main reason for running was to stop it.  Bet many wished they voted for him now.

Not from the short-sighted greedy engineers or construction companies that are currently making a short-term killing on the rail, who will suffer the mass layoffs and long-term financial consequences of maintaining the rail once the project is finally completed.
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 16, 2018, 10:48:29 AM
IDK if the info the realtors are saying is biased.  What they are pointing out is true.  No definition, why not make it a bill instead of in the constitution, where will the money go?  So they aren't wrong in what they're saying.

Layoffs won't affect the construction companies as much.  It's just normal business, once a major project is finished, no payroll is needed so they aren't going to suffer.  But they will make a killing now and until it's done.  It will affect the actual workers though who have to either look for a new job or wait for the next project.

Regarding organized crime, probably right about that, but are our law makes any different?  They too seem like the "mob".
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: Kuleana on October 16, 2018, 11:36:33 AM
IDK if the info the realtors are saying is biased.  What they are pointing out is true.  No definition, why not make it a bill instead of in the constitution, where will the money go?  So they aren't wrong in what they're saying.

What they are pointing out may be true, but it is hard to trust the true intentions of those who only care of the loss of their own commissions should such a law take effect.


Layoffs won't affect the construction companies as much.  It's just normal business, once a major project is finished, no payroll is needed so they aren't going to suffer.  But they will make a killing now and until it's done.  It will affect the actual workers though who have to either look for a new job or wait for the next project.

Exactly, it is the common laborers of those companies that will bear the long-term costs of maintaining the rail, provided there is still money to be earned.


Regarding organized crime, probably right about that, but are our law makes any different?  They too seem like the "mob".

There is enough players in the criminal underworld in Hawaii.  Moving to outright gambling will increase their numbers and potential violence that goes with it.
Title: Re: ConCon
Post by: groveler on October 16, 2018, 02:07:54 PM
I filled out my ballot yesterday.
I voted for a CONCON.
Hopefully we can get casinos at the Big Island south point.
Hopefully we can get a lottery.
Lost Wages( Las Vegas) is often referred to as Hawaii's 9th island.
Keep the money here.
As far as bad gun laws,  we already have those, hopefully a more
strict constructionist  US supreme court will shut down the Tyrants we presently
suffer under.  eg Young v Hawaii county.  Open carry cannot be prohibited anymore
in Hawaii county without good reason.
I would also love to see a referendum system where we could override the
union Democrats  laws.
Why do we need a Senate? and the costs of such?
Vote for CONCON.