2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: changemyoil66 on April 14, 2019, 05:57:43 PM
-
Along with everytown also.
So bump stocks, now this. Wonder what the DNC has on the tops at the NRA
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
wow, that is so disappointing. I seriously miss Charlton Heston's iconic leadership. They're just driving more folks to GOA and SAF. Dana Loesch is pretty good, but doesn't seem to influence the organization enough.
-
Along with everytown also.
So bump stocks, now this. Wonder what the DNC has on the tops at the NRA
Link, please, to official statement.
-
Link, please, to official statement.
No recent official statement (Dec 2018), but they did mention funding for the risk protection orders in TX. Hence "conditional". I wish they came out and just said no like how the many Sheriff departments have.
But to be fair, they did help defeat some red flag bills in other states. But at a time where gun grabbing is becoming more often, I would of liked them to officially state NO to all.
-
Friend of mine wrote this in response to "Red Flag" laws...
When your state passes a "red flag" law, immediately form a group of people and file "red flag" complaints on every legislator, sheriff, and prosecutor in the state.
Clog the courts with the petitions, and we'll see what they REALLY think about due process.
-
The problem is the American Legislative Exchange Council aka ALEC. They have a strong Security State anti-rights agenda and the NRA has to turn around and scratch some backs in order to get access to their money and influence. Lots of causes turn into a business and then forget what they are actually supposed to be doing. It happens to everyone from national political parties to Greenpeace and the Humane Society.
The only way to confront this is a leadership shake up and refocus, or start supporting other organizations that are more in line with our values.
-
Friend of mine wrote this in response to "Red Flag" laws...
When your state passes a "red flag" law, immediately form a group of people and file "red flag" complaints on every legislator, sheriff, and prosecutor in the state.
Clog the courts with the petitions, and we'll see what they REALLY think about due process.
Its a nice idea but it wouldn't work. The courts would pretty quickly recognize someone to be a vexatious litigant and your name would basically be rubbish in court from then on.
-
Along with everytown also.
So bump stocks, now this. Wonder what the DNC has on the tops at the NRA
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
I am ok with "conditional" support for a red flag law. The concept itself is something that is valid but it is the implementation which makes or breaks it. When done right it could be an effective law, when done wrong it could be an ineffective law that abuses civil rights. Hence conditional support, if it is done the right way I would support it too, if it is done the wrong way I am against it.
-
It's an unconstitutional tool for lazy cops who suck at their jobs
Edit:
"We got a report about this guy who might be a threat Chief. Should we investigate?"
"Nah just send in the swat team."
-
I am ok with "conditional" support for a red flag law. The concept itself is something that is valid but it is the implementation which makes or breaks it. When done right it could be an effective law, when done wrong it could be an ineffective law that abuses civil rights. Hence conditional support, if it is done the right way I would support it too, if it is done the wrong way I am against it.
There have been a handful of situations where the cops just showed up at the guys door to confiscate guns. Because due process was not followed, the guy felt his rights are being violated and a gun fight broke out. Imagine the anger and frustration. "Sir a complaint has been made, and we're here to take your guns". Even if at the door, he addresses the complaint, the cops there are "under orders" to take his guns.
So the "right way" of implementing this type of law is to let the receiving party have their due process (day in court) to address any allegations. And if after that the allegations are warranted, then and only then shall the person have to surrender firearms.
This type of lack of due process puts everyone at risk. Not only the person, the PD responding, and neighbors if a gun fight does break out. Bullets keep going until they hit something to stop them. This is why many Sheriff's across the nation will and do not support this.
-
There have been a handful of situations where the cops just showed up at the guys door to confiscate guns. Because due process was not followed, the guy felt his rights are being violated and a gun fight broke out. Imagine the anger and frustration. "Sir a complaint has been made, and we're here to take your guns". Even if at the door, he addresses the complaint, the cops there are "under orders" to take his guns.
So the "right way" of implementing this type of law is to let the receiving party have their due process (day in court) to address any allegations. And if after that the allegations are warranted, then and only then shall the person have to surrender firearms.
This type of lack of due process puts everyone at risk. Not only the person, the PD responding, and neighbors if a gun fight does break out. Bullets keep going until they hit something to stop them. This is why many Sheriff's across the nation will and do not support this.
Not allowing due process before confiscation causes great hardships, especialling in states like HI. Even if the state's reason for confiscation is proven to be false or successfully defended against, the guns are not going to be immediately returned. The owner must go through the permit process, including the 2 week wait, and THEN must petition the court for an order to return them.
So, you're basically disarmed and not allowed to protect your life or home for the time it takes for the confiscation to be reversed.
You are also be out whatever costs of legal representation were incurred.
It would be better to allow the owner to store the weapons with a friend or relative, but our laws for handguns don't allow it. FFLs aren't going to get in the middle of this can or worms.
The whole gun-hating system here is stacked against gun owners if/when you're accused of "looking risky".
-
Don't forget they would have to also enroll in RAPBACK.
As easy as the cops took it away, they should give them back. Have owner sign receipt and verify serial number. And that's it.
-
Don't forget they would have to also enroll in RAPBACK.
As easy as the cops took it away, they should give them back. Have owner sign receipt and verify serial number. And that's it.
In their world, giving guns back amounts to a "transfer", and it'd be irresponsible to give guns back to the owner who can no longer pass background checks or jump through all the transfer hoops.
And the court order thing has been posted on here before, where they had to pay their lawyer again to petition to court to amend their decision and include the order to return the firearms.
It's just another way they try to keep the law abiding citizen from having guns.
-
There have been a handful of situations where the cops just showed up at the guys door to confiscate guns. Because due process was not followed, the guy felt his rights are being violated and a gun fight broke out. Imagine the anger and frustration. "Sir a complaint has been made, and we're here to take your guns". Even if at the door, he addresses the complaint, the cops there are "under orders" to take his guns.
So the "right way" of implementing this type of law is to let the receiving party have their due process (day in court) to address any allegations. And if after that the allegations are warranted, then and only then shall the person have to surrender firearms.
This type of lack of due process puts everyone at risk. Not only the person, the PD responding, and neighbors if a gun fight does break out. Bullets keep going until they hit something to stop them. This is why many Sheriff's across the nation will and do not support this.
The due process aspect is exactly where the "conditionally" part of this lies for me. Done the wrong way it can be abusive to our rights.
The one problem of holding a hearing first and then confiscating the guns is that this could take too long. Remember that guy in Waikiki who had a lot of guns and looked like he was set to go on a Las Vegas style shooting spree? Now imagine a system where the court hearing happens first. Police get a report of this guy with his guns, they show up, find him to be mentally "off", and give him a penal summons to show up to court 2 days later. Maybe the guy calls in sick, maybe the officer or witness calls in sick and it gets postponed to the following week. This amount of time, along with knowing that authorities are aware of issues with him, might be all he needs to go on his killing spree before the courts can work.
Unfortunately sometimes time is of the essence and we all know the courts are not exactly known for quick action.
My personal position is that there must be a way for cops to take firearms immediately when there is good cause. The part where I support it conditionally is that the due process must be quick and have a higher level of proof. So when someone's guns are taken away the hearing should be within 72 hours (to allow for weekends) and the level of proof needed to take someone's firearms away for a longer period of time should be the preponderance of the evidence, not probably cause or reasonable suspicion. Also, you can't make the person re-wait for 2 more weeks for new permits to get their own guns bag, that is just ridiculous.
-
No red flag law in effect and a possible waikiki shooting stopped. IIRC he made plans on the net, thats how the feds tracked him down.
Red flag laws will do more harm than good. For now, there are stricter requirements, but how long b4 gun grabbers (DNC) use anything to begin consfiscation? Wait and see.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
So when someone's guns are taken away the hearing should be within 72 hours (to allow for weekends) and the level of proof needed to take someone's firearms away for a longer period of time should be the preponderance of the evidence, not probably cause or reasonable suspicion.
There are already laws that can deal with these things right now, it's just the legislators, judges, and police don't want to do what has to be done. They can already arrest and commit people with current laws like terroristic threatening and MH1 for mental cases to stop violent acts from happening. If these people are such a threat to themselves or society then they should be kept out of society without bail or committed with a quick evaluation and court hearing to follow, then treatment/rehab until they are ready to go back into society. Political correctness, laziness, and lack of funding by government officials is the problem.
Need more police on the streets and investigators instead of putting them in admin positions like firearms section, need more jail space, funding for the courts to expedite cases, and funding for rehab/treatment.
The problem with red flag laws are they are giving a criminal punishment through a civil process. A 1 year protective order removing 2a rights is a criminal punishment given without a jury trial. At the very least, the burden of proof should be clear and convincing/probable cause for the 14 day order and proof beyond a reasonable doubt for the 1 year order. Preponderance of the evidence is only like 51% chance they're guilty versus not which is way to low to remove a civil right.
-
The real problem with red flag laws is it's an attempt to prevent crime before it happens. It's an impossible proposition -- you can't know you prevented something that hasn't happened nor that had any likelihood of happening. Only if the person states a threat can you have any idea what is in their mind.
Taking guns is a preemptive punishment. It doesn't prevent a thing. It only creates a nightmare and expense for the person when getting their guns back. It also disarms the person for that period of time so self defense is more difficult.
Imagine a person who wants to do you harm, but they are reluctant because you own guns. Enter the Red Flag laws. One phone call complaint that you threatened to shoot someone, and the house is now clear of guns. Easy target.
If someone is truly a safety risk, and their 2A (and other civil) rights are going to be violated anyway, why not just toss the person in jail for 48 hours to "cool off" and be evaluated? That eliminates all risk of violence, gun and otherwise.
If only there were such laws before OJ picked up that gun. Oh, wait! He used a knife to kill 2 people. Nothing to see there. Totally off topic. Guns are the problem.
-
Also NRA has provided opposition testimony to Hawaiis red flag bills
-
If someone is truly a safety risk, and their 2A (and other civil) rights are going to be violated anyway, why not just toss the person in jail for 48 hours to "cool off" and be evaluated? That eliminates all risk of violence, gun and otherwise.
Seems government officials see the 2a as a second class right that shouldn't be there and was erroneously decided by SCOTUS. More like a hobby or nutty movement. They don't want to harm criminals and figure there's no harm in infringing 2a rights.
-
This red flag law will allow anyone to call HPD and say that the gun owner is a threat - then they show up at the door of said gun owner and takes all his/her firearms away? No court proceedings?
This sounds like SWATTING.
This smells like a big fat lawsuit opportunity. This is not a 2A issue this is also a 4A issue.
-
So next time somebody cuts you off in traffic, get their plate and ask HPD to see if the RO of that vehicle has a firearm because he threatened you.
-
http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2019/04/21/man-accused-hitting-another-with-truck-prompts-attempted-murder-investigation/ (http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2019/04/21/man-accused-hitting-another-with-truck-prompts-attempted-murder-investigation/)
they need a Red Flag law for vehicles too
-
There are already laws that can deal with these things right now, it's just the legislators, judges, and police don't want to do what has to be done. They can already arrest and commit people with current laws like terroristic threatening and MH1 for mental cases to stop violent acts from happening. If these people are such a threat to themselves or society then they should be kept out of society without bail or committed with a quick evaluation and court hearing to follow, then treatment/rehab until they are ready to go back into society. Political correctness, laziness, and lack of funding by government officials is the problem.
Need more police on the streets and investigators instead of putting them in admin positions like firearms section, need more jail space, funding for the courts to expedite cases, and funding for rehab/treatment.
The problem with red flag laws are they are giving a criminal punishment through a civil process. A 1 year protective order removing 2a rights is a criminal punishment given without a jury trial. At the very least, the burden of proof should be clear and convincing/probable cause for the 14 day order and proof beyond a reasonable doubt for the 1 year order. Preponderance of the evidence is only like 51% chance they're guilty versus not which is way to low to remove a civil right.
Preponderance of the evidence is the standard right below proof beyond a reasonable doubt if I understand correctly, and it is the standard for civil trials. I am not saying the level of proof shouldn't be higher but at the very least it should be preponderance of the evidence. Current proposals have it lower than that which is very problematic. I am not sure if there is any precedence for preponderance of the evidence being used to restrict any other constitutional rights though.
Police can take people for mental health evaluation but they cannot always take the person's firearms, unless the firearm is related to the mental health issue. So say you call because your friend is suicidal, cops come in, call their psychology, then take the person to the hospital for further evaluation and care. The cops can't take the guy's firearms.
I do think the MH-1 and other types of mental health orders (I think there is an MH-4, MH-3, etc) should/could be used as a framework. I think the red flag law serves as an avenue for regular people to start the review purchase. Now if a cop comes across a guy with mental issues or a psychologist comes across a guy then then can start the process to get this risky individual off the streets or get the firearms taken away, but does the average person know? Imagine you saw a bunch of warning signs in a family member of yours, do you know how to initiate a court proceeding to have that person have their guns taken away or committed? Heck, take guns out of the picture, do you know how to go about getting someone into the mental health system when there is need but they refuse? Honestly, I don't. The cops can start it if the person is an immediate danger to themselves but what if there is a serious mental health issue without an immediate danger?
Implemented properly a red flag law could be the process where regular people could report so called "red flags" which gets the ball rolling to take guns out of the hands of dangerous people and possibly get risky individuals placed in a care facility.
-
The real problem with red flag laws is it's an attempt to prevent crime before it happens. It's an impossible proposition -- you can't know you prevented something that hasn't happened nor that had any likelihood of happening. Only if the person states a threat can you have any idea what is in their mind.
Taking guns is a preemptive punishment. It doesn't prevent a thing. It only creates a nightmare and expense for the person when getting their guns back. It also disarms the person for that period of time so self defense is more difficult.
Imagine a person who wants to do you harm, but they are reluctant because you own guns. Enter the Red Flag laws. One phone call complaint that you threatened to shoot someone, and the house is now clear of guns. Easy target.
If someone is truly a safety risk, and their 2A (and other civil) rights are going to be violated anyway, why not just toss the person in jail for 48 hours to "cool off" and be evaluated? That eliminates all risk of violence, gun and otherwise.
If only there were such laws before OJ picked up that gun. Oh, wait! He used a knife to kill 2 people. Nothing to see there. Totally off topic. Guns are the problem.
There is a definite truth to the position that for many individuals, if they are too dangerous to own a firearm that they are too dangerous to be out in public.
Some are more obvious and easier to catch but others there is potential but we cannot be so sure they are going to do something wrong. I do recognize that it is hard to decide where to draw the line for these individuals. Now maybe the person has a diagnosis for a condition that is associated with violence but hasn't shown any signs of violence. It is a tough call to find the right balance between protecting the individual's rights and finding out where to restrict those rights.
I have an adopted brother with a level of mental retardation, he functions at the age of about a 13 year old (He is currently about 24 years old). He can live on his own (with a little help) and can hold basic jobs like dishwasher or shelf stocker. His coordination isn't great and he has trouble seeing consequences out into the future (he has trouble managing finances). There is no real justification to put him in a controlled facility, no reason to believe he will be violent, but there are still serious questions of whether he could own a firearm safely. He might have a negligent discharge, he might carry the firearm in a way he shouldn't or a place he shouldn't, he might not comprehend what to do if he is armed and encounters a law enforcement officer.
What do we do with people such as my bother? Do you think he should be allowed to have a firearm unrestricted? He isn't one of those who is dangerous to be in public and thus needs to be locked up, but there are still serious questions about him safely owning a firearm.
-
Preponderance of the evidence is the standard right below proof beyond a reasonable doubt if I understand correctly, and it is the standard for civil trials.
I erred, whatever is equal to probable cause for the 14 day order on the civil side. I'm not very knowledgeable on the civil side of things.
Police can take people for mental health evaluation but they cannot always take the person's firearms, unless the firearm is related to the mental health issue.
If the person is committed for treatment, then it doesn't matter as they don't have access to the firearms so no confiscation is needed. When I say committed I don't mean for a couple days. I mean they go through an evaluation, expedited court proceeding meeting due process requirements, and treatment until cleared which could be a long time.
[
I do think the MH-1 and other types of mental health orders (I think there is an MH-4, MH-3, etc) should/could be used as a framework. I think the red flag law serves as an avenue for regular people to start the review purchase. Now if a cop comes across a guy with mental issues or a psychologist comes across a guy then then can start the process to get this risky individual off the streets or get the firearms taken away, but does the average person know?
Call 911? Shouldn't be police to respond, instead it should be a special team of mental health workers. Educate the public.
Heck, take guns out of the picture, do you know how to go about getting someone into the mental health system when there is need but they refuse? Honestly, I don't.
MH1? Don't feel it will work? Thats what I meant by funding treatment, mental health facilities, and making the hard decisions that may not be politically correct.
The cops can start it if the person is an immediate danger to themselves but what if there is a serious mental health issue without an immediate danger?
Give me an example, sounds like they're just crazy and not an actual danger. Like a homeless person that runs across the freeway because they're oblivious?
Implemented properly a red flag law could be the process where regular people could report so called "red flags" which gets the ball rolling to take guns out of the hands of dangerous people and possibly get risky individuals placed in a care facility.
What about cars, knives, gasoline, razor blades, rope, drugs, etc? Red flag laws are a feel good measure based in people's fears. Since all rights are equal, why not just restrict or eliminate the 4th, 5th, and 14th amendments too for criminal cases so we can get more criminals and mental cases off the street for safety? We don't because this is America where we balance rights and individual freedoms over safety.
[
-
There is a definite truth to the position that for many individuals, if they are too dangerous to own a firearm that they are too dangerous to be out in public.
Some are more obvious and easier to catch but others there is potential but we cannot be so sure they are going to do something wrong. I do recognize that it is hard to decide where to draw the line for these individuals. Now maybe the person has a diagnosis for a condition that is associated with violence but hasn't shown any signs of violence. It is a tough call to find the right balance between protecting the individual's rights and finding out where to restrict those rights.
I have an adopted brother with a level of mental retardation, he functions at the age of about a 13 year old (He is currently about 24 years old). He can live on his own (with a little help) and can hold basic jobs like dishwasher or shelf stocker. His coordination isn't great and he has trouble seeing consequences out into the future (he has trouble managing finances). There is no real justification to put him in a controlled facility, no reason to believe he will be violent, but there are still serious questions of whether he could own a firearm safely. He might have a negligent discharge, he might carry the firearm in a way he shouldn't or a place he shouldn't, he might not comprehend what to do if he is armed and encounters a law enforcement officer.
What do we do with people such as my bother? Do you think he should be allowed to have a firearm unrestricted? He isn't one of those who is dangerous to be in public and thus needs to be locked up, but there are still serious questions about him safely owning a firearm.
Your entire reply is off topic -- as is your custom.
Red flag laws are about taking guns from owners who already have them. if your brother came into possession of a firearm, and you believe he's a danger to himself or others, you can make a report with police without special laws for it. They will investigate. If confiscation is warranted, they will. Mental competency due to retardation is a totally different situation than mental illnesses from a chemical imbalance, brain injury or disease. Those are people that appear normal, can function and take care of themselves, but the elevator gets stuck on the way to the top. Hearing voices telling them to kill, believing the neighbor is a terrorist, or deciding the shoot up the school because you're picked on are symptoms of mental illness separate and distinct from developmental retardation.
Unless there's a threat of imminent danger based on specific threats or violent behavior, I see no urgency and no reason to trample the person's right to due process BEFORE taking their guns -- if warranted.
Again -- if the person is a threat, lock them up. If they aren't but you think they may be a risk, make a report & hold a hearing. Confiscation without a hearing just because someone made a report and the defendant happens to have guns is unconstitutional. A Red Flag Law does more to harm individual safety and liberty than it does to increases public safety.
-
..
-
I have an adopted brother with a level of mental retardation, he functions at the age of about a 13 year old (He is currently about 24 years old). He can live on his own (with a little help) and can hold basic jobs like dishwasher or shelf stocker. His coordination isn't great and he has trouble seeing consequences out into the future (he has trouble managing finances). There is no real justification to put him in a controlled facility, no reason to believe he will be violent, but there are still serious questions of whether he could own a firearm safely. He might have a negligent discharge, he might carry the firearm in a way he shouldn't or a place he shouldn't, he might not comprehend what to do if he is armed and encounters a law enforcement officer.
What do we do with people such as my bother? Do you think he should be allowed to have a firearm unrestricted? He isn't one of those who is dangerous to be in public and thus needs to be locked up, but there are still serious questions about him safely owning a firearm.
Does he own knives and use them? Does he hurt himself or others intentionally or accidentally with them?
Also kids under 13 can be taught how to use guns responsibly.
-
There is a definite truth to the position that for many individuals, if they are too dangerous to own a firearm that they are too dangerous to be out in public.
Some are more obvious and easier to catch but others there is potential but we cannot be so sure they are going to do something wrong. I do recognize that it is hard to decide where to draw the line for these individuals. Now maybe the person has a diagnosis for a condition that is associated with violence but hasn't shown any signs of violence. It is a tough call to find the right balance between protecting the individual's rights and finding out where to restrict those rights.
I have an adopted brother with a level of mental retardation, he functions at the age of about a 13 year old (He is currently about 24 years old). He can live on his own (with a little help) and can hold basic jobs like dishwasher or shelf stocker. His coordination isn't great and he has trouble seeing consequences out into the future (he has trouble managing finances). There is no real justification to put him in a controlled facility, no reason to believe he will be violent, but there are still serious questions of whether he could own a firearm safely. He might have a negligent discharge, he might carry the firearm in a way he shouldn't or a place he shouldn't, he might not comprehend what to do if he is armed and encounters a law enforcement officer.
What do we do with people such as my bother? Do you think he should be allowed to have a firearm unrestricted? He isn't one of those who is dangerous to be in public and thus needs to be locked up, but there are still serious questions about him safely owning a firearm.
Red flag law is irrelevant, under Hawaii law he wouldn’t be allowed to own a firearm anyway.
-
they should include knives
https://www.kitv.com/story/40345983/one-in-serious-condition-another-stable-after-early-morning-apparent-stabbing (https://www.kitv.com/story/40345983/one-in-serious-condition-another-stable-after-early-morning-apparent-stabbing)
-
I can name a whole bunch of reasons playing out in the media right now why we should hesitate about giving police more power to waltz over our constitutional protections. I don't say this lightly (because they have nasty habits of their own) but I'm extremely grateful for the FBI stepping in and removing the Kealohas and Kaneshiro. Unfortunately their minions are still spread out through the system and many will likely survive the investigation because there would be no one to replace them if they were all removed.
Consider the fact that the negative attention hasn't even died down yet and the legislature has already granting the cops unconstitutional powers of search and seizure. It could not be more obvious that their priorities are not on public safety but civilian disarmament.
-
Consider the fact that the negative attention hasn't even died down yet and the legislature has already granting the cops unconstitutional powers of search and seizure. It could not be more obvious that their priorities are not on public safety but civilian disarmament.
And I can guarantee you that not 1 cop will have the guts to say that this is unconstitutional. They will just follow orders.
-
Consider the fact that the negative attention hasn't even died down yet and the legislature has already granting the cops unconstitutional powers of search and seizure. It could not be more obvious that their priorities are not on public safety but civilian disarmament.
(https://scontent-lax3-1.xx.fbcdn.net/v/t1.0-9/57504781_327650084588902_790432032965525504_n.jpg?_nc_cat=102&_nc_ht=scontent-lax3-1.xx&oh=e963c47a568d0cd207da0925675255be&oe=5D75DCB1)
-
FREE HUEY!!!!
For those who don't know, he made pleading the 5th known.
-
And I can guarantee you that not 1 cop will have the guts to say that this is unconstitutional. They will just follow orders.
Hawaii is the land of "go along to get along", live Aloha. don't rock the boat, wassamatta you? yup, just follow orders.
-
This red flag law will allow anyone to call HPD and say that the gun owner is a threat - then they show up at the door of said gun owner and takes all his/her firearms away? No court proceedings?
This sounds like SWATTING.
This smells like a big fat lawsuit opportunity. This is not a 2A issue this is also a 4A issue.
as a physician I can do this now. Just call up the firearm division and tell them a name and they will at least cancel the persons firearm permit and potentially confiscate their firearms. Or at least that is what they told me they will do if I called them on someone. They did not need proof or documentation or anything else actually. I was a bit in shock that Hawaii felt I should have that much power. (I called them to just see how bad it was)
Also, lawsuits take 20-30 years to get to the supreme court so they are useless for short term unconstitutionality. Politicians know this.
If the police show up to your house to confiscate your firearms under a red flag law and you say "no" I'd say that's going to be a very good chance of execution. It has happened already.
-
And I can guarantee you that not 1 cop will have the guts to say that this is unconstitutional. They will just follow orders.
On the outer islands we know where they live. We know where their kids go to school and where their wives shop.
I'm sure they will factor that in to their decision process.
I know where they go to practice shooting. There is a clear shot at 1000 meters and you can't see me come and go.
Easy shot for a Barrett 50, FED EXed in and then out. If I had an RPG7 and ammo smuggled in (which is easy to do)I could really mess
up their day. I'm not making any threats here, that is illegal, and I don't violate any constitutional laws,
I'm just pointing out that our police are at risk, if someone who is determined wanted to take them out.
-
Give me an example, sounds like they're just crazy and not an actual danger. Like a homeless person that runs across the freeway because they're oblivious?
For example, maybe a person has symptoms of a mental disorder that is strongly associated with violence. Let's say someone is psychotic and hears or sees things that are there. Call the cops, they show up, but if the person isn't exhibiting signs of immediate danger I don't think they can deprive the individual of their civil rights and force them to undergo a screening. If a cop shows up and finds someone to be having suicidal desires at that point in time then they may be able to justify taking the individual in, but if the person says they had suicidal ideations last week but don't feel it now then the cop can't take them in. Ideally these types of issues are caught when the person is still a juvenile and the parent can force the child to see a mental health expert but if they are an adult it is difficult to force anyone to see a mental health professional.
What I am getting at here is that I believe there is a hole in the mental health system where between police, members of the public, and mental health workers people can still fall through the cracks. Times when cops can't take someone dangerous in and family members don't have the means to force the person to get help either.
What about cars, knives, gasoline, razor blades, rope, drugs, etc? Red flag laws are a feel good measure based in people's fears. Since all rights are equal, why not just restrict or eliminate the 4th, 5th, and 14th amendments too for criminal cases so we can get more criminals and mental cases off the street for safety? We don't because this is America where we balance rights and individual freedoms over safety.
Banning rope and sharp things simple isn't a realistic suggestion, but taking away someone's vehicle might be something to consider. I know a few elderly people who had their keys taken away by a family member because the elderly person had serious issues such as dementia and wasn't safe to be driving. The cops never arrested the family member for theft.
-
If hawaii allowed ccw, then i wouldnt worry too much about those who hear voices.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
Your entire reply is off topic -- as is your custom.
Red flag laws are about taking guns from owners who already have them. if your brother came into possession of a firearm, and you believe he's a danger to himself or others, you can make a report with police without special laws for it. They will investigate. If confiscation is warranted, they will. Mental competency due to retardation is a totally different situation than mental illnesses from a chemical imbalance, brain injury or disease. Those are people that appear normal, can function and take care of themselves, but the elevator gets stuck on the way to the top. Hearing voices telling them to kill, believing the neighbor is a terrorist, or deciding the shoot up the school because you're picked on are symptoms of mental illness separate and distinct from developmental retardation.
Unless there's a threat of imminent danger based on specific threats or violent behavior, I see no urgency and no reason to trample the person's right to due process BEFORE taking their guns -- if warranted.
Again -- if the person is a threat, lock them up. If they aren't but you think they may be a risk, make a report & hold a hearing. Confiscation without a hearing just because someone made a report and the defendant happens to have guns is unconstitutional. A Red Flag Law does more to harm individual safety and liberty than it does to increases public safety.
It is perfectly on topic.
So say my brother walks into a gun store and purchases a firearm. I call police and tell them that he has the mental capacity of a 13 year old. They can't just go and take his gun away. He is an adult so I can't making him go see a psychologist if he doesn't want to. I guess I could apply for a conservatorship and pay out of pocket to go to court and ask a judge to make me his guardian and that might be a workaround but I am not a lawyer and I am not sure if that would be effective. I might also then be liable for anything he does... needless to say it is not an easy or even obvious solution.
And to clarify, he lives in Washington State.
I have noticed that a lot of the resistance to a red flag laws seems to be based on the worst case scenario. They imagine a situation where someone simply says another is crazy and bam, there goes someone's rights but this is not inherently the case. A properly designed red flag law would require a certain level of proof just as any other police investigation and there would be systems in place to protect a person's rights as well. Imagine a police investigation, they can stop someone based on reasonable suspicion and that is already taking away someone's constitutional rights (temporarily). If police establish probable cause they can arrest a person and can hold them for 48 hours while they investigate further, again someone is losing their constitutional rights.
I think that we could use that same reasoning when applying to red flag laws. Take the person and/or their guns for up to 48 hours upon establishing probable cause. If the investigation doesn't show further proof then release their firearms immediately. Police regularly take away someone's constitutional rights but is has to be based on just cause. Taking away guns based on a third party rumor (for example) would absolutely be an abuse and unconstitutional but we can't assume that every form of red flag law will be that worst case scenario. Again, this is why I say I support it conditionally. I support it on the condition that the revocation of constitutional rights is based upon good evidence, that it is as minimal as necessary and that there are strong protections for the accused. This seems to be the standard when a constitutional right is taken away by police in other areas.
-
as a physician I can do this now. Just call up the firearm division and tell them a name and they will at least cancel the persons firearm permit and potentially confiscate their firearms. Or at least that is what they told me they will do if I called them on someone. They did not need proof or documentation or anything else actually. I was a bit in shock that Hawaii felt I should have that much power. (I called them to just see how bad it was)
Also, lawsuits take 20-30 years to get to the supreme court so they are useless for short term unconstitutionality. Politicians know this.
I think that is a little bit different though. If you as a physician inform them that an individual is a risk due to a mental illness or condition you carry more weight than an average person. You are an expert of sorts and police would have reason to put more weight into what you say on the subject.
Now I do know there is a process by which a doctor of mental health professional can petition the courts to force an individual to come in for screening. I believe it is called an MH-4 (?) and when the judge signs it the police have to go out and look for the individual at which point they handcuff the person and take them to a mental health facility. I don't know if the firearms division guys were thinking of that type of mental health order or what but I do know there is a process by which a doctor can go through courts to do such a thing.
-
It is perfectly on topic.
So say my brother walks into a gun store and purchases a firearm. I call police and tell them that he has the mental capacity of a 13 year old. They can't just go and take his gun away. He is an adult so I can't making him go see a psychologist if he doesn't want to. I guess I could apply for a conservatorship and pay out of pocket to go to court and ask a judge to make me his guardian and that might be a workaround but I am not a lawyer and I am not sure if that would be effective. I might also then be liable for anything he does... needless to say it is not an easy or even obvious solution.
And to clarify, he lives in Washington State.
I have noticed that a lot of the resistance to a red flag laws seems to be based on the worst case scenario. They imagine a situation where someone simply says another is crazy and bam, there goes someone's rights but this is not inherently the case. A properly designed red flag law would require a certain level of proof just as any other police investigation and there would be systems in place to protect a person's rights as well. Imagine a police investigation, they can stop someone based on reasonable suspicion and that is already taking away someone's constitutional rights (temporarily). If police establish probable cause they can arrest a person and can hold them for 48 hours while they investigate further, again someone is losing their constitutional rights.
I think that we could use that same reasoning when applying to red flag laws. Take the person and/or their guns for up to 48 hours upon establishing probable cause. If the investigation doesn't show further proof then release their firearms immediately. Police regularly take away someone's constitutional rights but is has to be based on just cause. Taking away guns based on a third party rumor (for example) would absolutely be an abuse and unconstitutional but we can't assume that every form of red flag law will be that worst case scenario. Again, this is why I say I support it conditionally. I support it on the condition that the revocation of constitutional rights is based upon good evidence, that it is as minimal as necessary and that there are strong protections for the accused. This seems to be the standard when a constitutional right is taken away by police in other areas.
Mental retardation carries a documented and recognizable disqualification for many things, like applying for a drivers license or joining the military. Most people would pick up on his 13-yr-old mentality anyway and refuse the gun sale.
Red flag laws would not PREVENT your brother from buying a gun unless you knew about it beforehand.
You don't understand the term "red flag" if you think evidence is going to be required. in court, a person's statement is considered evidence. If there was tangible evidence, they wouldn't NEED red flags -- the evidence would be sufficient to file a report and arrest him/confiscate.
Red flags are for people who don't have actual evidence, but simply believe (feel) someone is a risk. "I saw EEF screaming at the sky and calling Trump every name in the book. Then I saw him online asking about airline tickets to DC and where to buy body armor. He never threatened to do anything, but I have a feeling he's going to do something violent."
That's a "red flag". It alerts police your behavior is concerning and might indicate violent intent. Nobody needs "probable cause". That's why most red flag laws limit who can report under them: relatives and co-workers, maybe close friends. Even so, anyone can claim to be a friend.
You love to imagine how things should work. As many times as TRO reports are abusively filed, it's naive to think red flag gun laws won't be abused as well.
-
In WA a mans guns were taken because he was inside his home with a gun on his hip. His neighbors said he "looked at them funny" thru his own window. He is legally allowed to posess a gun. One of the 1st red flag laws enforced. Neighbors said man kept to himself and didnt socialize witb any of them. But i guess he looked creepy.
So please tell me again no one has a rational fear.
How many adults with a mental capacity of a child own guns or try to buy them. Im to lazy to check fbi database at the moment.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
Good but long read on Hawaii's mentally ill and how to treat those not in Immediate danger and its limitations.
http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2019/04/23/watch-prescribing-hope-trapped-streets/
"It used to be the only way a person could be forced to take psychiatric medication in Hawaii is if they committed a crime or had a legal guardian.
But in 2014, the state Legislature passed a law called Assisted Community Treatment.
It allows the courts to order a person to take medication if they’re proven to be an imminent danger to themselves or others.
The problem: That threshold is so high the majority of Hawaii’s homeless suffering from mental illness don’t reach it, despite advocates and family members petitioning the court in a number of cases."
-
I would think as a doctor, you have more pull compared to an angry exgf or family member. The doctor is a neutral 3rd party and I don't know a whole lot of docs who would risk their license for someone just to take their guns away by making a false danger statement (ex-wife pays the doc to say her ex-husband is a danger and gets guns taken away). Compared to false statements made by baby mama's/daddy's and filing a TRO just to gain leverage for the future custody hearing. Or a neighbor dispute, so 1 party makes a false claim. What really worries me is the "educator" word they inserted. Imagine a liberal college professor gets into a debate with a student or even a student is just wearing a MAGA hat and no words are exchanged. Prof finds out via social media that the student is a gun owner. Prof makes a complaint to HPD and boom, guns taken away.
The question is are PCPs trained in any manner to recognize mental health problems or if a patient is a danger to themselves? We know dentist are not, they only know gums and teeth.
-
It allows the courts to order a person to take medication if they’re proven to be an imminent danger to themselves or others.
The problem: That threshold is so high the majority of Hawaii’s homeless suffering from mental illness don’t reach it, despite advocates and family members petitioning the court in a number of cases."
How does 1 force someone to take meds? I know a guy who when on meds is cool. But then he stops taking them because he thinks he doesn't need them. That's when he turns all skitzo. He goes in and out of jail. Because in jail, he in monitored and they watch him consume his meds. Compared to out in the street. And this guy is part of a tribe that owns an Indian Casino. So he makes lots of money every month for doing nothing (check is mailed to him).
-
We know dentist are not, they only know gums and teeth.
dental school is 2 weeks
4 days class, 1 day final- teeth
4 days class, 1 day final- gums
heads
-
dental school is 2 weeks
4 days class, 1 day final- teeth
4 days class, 1 day final- gums
heads
Wow. You picked a tough school... Ivy League?
Most dental schools are one week:
2 days teeth, 2 days gums, 1 half-day final.
That means you're twice as good as the average dentist! :shaka:
-
Wow. You picked a tough school... Ivy League?
Most dental schools are one week:
2 days teeth, 2 days gums, 1 half-day final.
That means you're twice as good as the average dentist! :shaka:
those schools include a weekend course
"use of nitrous oxide for fun and profit"
-
those schools include a weekend course
"use of nitrous oxide for fun and profit"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iqix542ckUo
1:23
Was the course something like this?
-
So... am I too "cynical", or too "realistic"?
(Hope you all saw the recent article and NPR audio about the NRA finances (I'm not saying the article is accurate)... claiming that a significant portion of their spending, after ludicrous executive salaries/benefits, goes to... raising money!)
The NRA's line about all the infringing laws they supported listed below has always been "it would have been worse if we hadn't negotiated "a compromise"". You mean like your "compromise" on people appealing for you to support the Young case over many years resulted in the "compromise" of you not supporting it at all in any way, and then once it succeeded at the three-judge panel Ninth Circuit level you filed your own separate lawsuit? Yeah, that's a "compromise" alright. And then there's you trying to derail Heller...
(https://i.imgur.com/y74VYDr.png)
(https://i.imgur.com/vHaxiKG.png)
-
Yeah, I have pretty much distances myself with the NRA because of the above. Although I am on the Trump train, I can't imagine why they would invite him to their conference. He had a hand in the banning of bump stocks. Unless he announces an XO for national reciprocity, there is no reason for him to be there.
Don Jr, OK.
-
those schools include a weekend course
"use of nitrous oxide for fun and profit"
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UDDfJh6CkS8
-
I rememeber when the first one came out, I was in high school and all the ricers wanted to add NOS to their cars. Until we all found out the cost.
-
Mental retardation carries a documented and recognizable disqualification for many things, like applying for a drivers license or joining the military. Most people would pick up on his 13-yr-old mentality anyway and refuse the gun sale.
Maybe, but maybe not. If my brother didn't say too much he could probably swing a gun purchase. I guess the question I would have here is do we want to put our trust in public and private gun sales to effectively recognize people in his condition?
Red flag laws would not PREVENT your brother from buying a gun unless you knew about it beforehand.
No but a red flag law might be a means of taking it away if he did manage to get his hands on one.
You don't understand the term "red flag" if you think evidence is going to be required. in court, a person's statement is considered evidence. If there was tangible evidence, they wouldn't NEED red flags -- the evidence would be sufficient to file a report and arrest him/confiscate.
Again, that all depends on how the actual law is written. You can't make a blanket statement about how it would be implemented.
Red flags are for people who don't have actual evidence, but simply believe (feel) someone is a risk. "I saw EEF screaming at the sky and calling Trump every name in the book. Then I saw him online asking about airline tickets to DC and where to buy body armor. He never threatened to do anything, but I have a feeling he's going to do something violent."
When the 9/11 terrorist was concerned with how to take off and remove auto-pilot in flight school but had no concern about how to land, do you think the instructor should have said something to someone in law enforcement? Or should he have disregarded his feelings and waited for actual evidence?
That's a "red flag". It alerts police your behavior is concerning and might indicate violent intent. Nobody needs "probable cause". That's why most red flag laws limit who can report under them: relatives and co-workers, maybe close friends. Even so, anyone can claim to be a friend. You love to imagine how things should work. As many times as TRO reports are abusively filed, it's naive to think red flag gun laws won't be abused as well.
I have no belief that false reports will never be filed or that they will not be abused just like TROs. Again, I said my support was conditional upon stronger protections for the accused. I would require a higher level of proof to deny the person's constitutional rights and I would require a speedy hearing so the individual could appeal. The fed flag is as you say an alert, it is just something to let police know there might be something to look into. From then on more evidence would be required (ideally) and if necessary the person's rights be restricted.
Let me present to you this scenario. Say an adult relative of yours who owns firearms develops a mental condition that seriously affects their cognitive abilities and behaviors to the point where you believe this relative cannot safely own a firearm. What steps would you take? As the person is an adult you know you cannot force them to seek medical help. Do you know what steps to take to in order to have this person be required to seek medical help and have his firearms or even his freedom revoked if necessary?
-
Maybe, but maybe not. If my brother didn't say too much he could probably swing a gun purchase. I guess the question I would have here is do we want to put our trust in public and private gun sales to effectively recognize people in his condition?
No but a red flag law might be a means of taking it away if he did manage to get his hands on one.
Again, that all depends on how the actual law is written. You can't make a blanket statement about how it would be implemented.
When the 9/11 terrorist was concerned with how to take off and remove auto-pilot in flight school but had no concern about how to land, do you think the instructor should have said something to someone in law enforcement? Or should he have disregarded his feelings and waited for actual evidence?
I have no belief that false reports will never be filed or that they will not be abused just like TROs. Again, I said my support was conditional upon stronger protections for the accused. I would require a higher level of proof to deny the person's constitutional rights and I would require a speedy hearing so the individual could appeal. The fed flag is as you say an alert, it is just something to let police know there might be something to look into. From then on more evidence would be required (ideally) and if necessary the person's rights be restricted.
Let me present to you this scenario. Say an adult relative of yours who owns firearms develops a mental condition that seriously affects their cognitive abilities and behaviors to the point where you believe this relative cannot safely own a firearm. What steps would you take? As the person is an adult you know you cannot force them to seek medical help. Do you know what steps to take to in order to have this person be required to seek medical help and have his firearms or even his freedom revoked if necessary?
You left out a massive detail.
Has the relative been seeing a physician who shares your opinion? Has the doctor notified authorities of the patient's cognitive issues?
There are plenty of "scenarios" that allow health professionals to report mental illness of gun owners, not some "relative" who has no experience in behavioral medicine.
You're trusting a "feeling" on my part, but don't trust actual medical professionals in the process.
Not very imaginative of you.
-
You left out a massive detail.
Has the relative been seeing a physician who shares your opinion? Has the doctor notified authorities of the patient's cognitive issues?
There are plenty of "scenarios" that allow health professionals to report mental illness of gun owners, not some "relative" who has no experience in behavioral medicine.
You're trusting a "feeling" on my part, but don't trust actual medical professionals in the process.
Not very imaginative of you.
You missed an important aspect of my question. I am talking about a person who is not seeing a doctor of mental health professional and who refuses to do so. How would you go about getting help to this person? I am talking about situations where people don't seek help.
I never said that your non-medical opinion should supersede that of a medical professional.
Now I believe I have already laid this out but just to be absolutely clear, a regular person can be the way an investigation starts but taking away their firearms cannot and should not be based only on a regular person's opinion. I never suggested feelings alone should be the basis of taking away firearms. Lets avoid the strawmen please.
-
You missed an important aspect of my question. I am talking about a person who is not seeing a doctor of mental health professional and who refuses to do so. How would you go about getting help to this person? I am talking about situations where people don't seek help.
I never said that your non-medical opinion should supersede that of a medical professional.
Now I believe I have already laid this out but just to be absolutely clear, a regular person can be the way an investigation starts but taking away their firearms cannot and should not be based only on a regular person's opinion. I never suggested feelings alone should be the basis of taking away firearms. Lets avoid the strawmen please.
That's not what you said -- at least not in your question. You never said the relative was not seeing a medical professional. You said I can't force them to seek help, but that doesn't mean they haven't done so without me or someone else "forcing" them to. Legally and personally, it's not my right to know who they are seeing for medical issues.
You asked:
Let me present to you this scenario. Say an adult relative of yours who owns firearms develops a mental condition that seriously affects their cognitive abilities and behaviors to the point where you believe this relative cannot safely own a firearm. What steps would you take? As the person is an adult you know you cannot force them to seek medical help. Do you know what steps to take to in order to have this person be required to seek medical help and have his firearms or even his freedom revoked if necessary?
-
Info on other mental health bills this year.
https://www.civilbeat.org/2019/04/how-these-bills-could-help-those-with-serious-mental-illness/
-
There are many with mental health issues that go un-diagnosed. The world is not perfect.
So all this law does is a way for HPD to take guns out away from it's citizens without their right to due process. And I can bet that 100% of any HPD showing up at the door step will "just follow orders" and not step up like how other Sheriff departments have and say "no, I will not violate someones rights".
-
We live in a state where people sit through an entire green light rather than honk their horn at the person not paying attention. No make stink.
How many people do they believe will turn in someone to authorities if they aren't actually hurting anyone?
-
We live in a state where people sit through an entire green light rather than honk their horn at the person not paying attention. No make stink.
How many people do they believe will turn in someone to authorities if they aren't actually hurting anyone?
I'm one of those, but not to "no make stink", but more like I don't know who's in front of me and want to escalate a situation. I can spare a few seconds of my time.
Regarding your 2nd part, I believe the red flag law will be more used for revenge than for any possible good.
-
I'm one of those, but not to "no make stink", but more like I don't know who's in front of me and want to escalate a situation. I can spare a few seconds of my time.
Regarding your 2nd part, I believe the red flag law will be more used for revenge than for any possible good.
Exactly. The side-issue to "No make stink" includes "don't do anything that might cause retaliation -- by that person or their family."
Once the person being reported is in the system, it could cause many more problems than expected. Not only loss of firearms, but loss of time at work to see mental health evaluators, attending hearings, jumping through time-consuming hoops to retrieve firearms from HPD, cost of legal representation and the stigma attached to being identified as a public safety risk. He/she could easily lose their job over it.Their family and friends who never saw the "red flag" signs would start to wonder if this person can be trusted.
It's a big ask to expect family and friends to turn someone into authorities knowing the array of problems and implications attached. As you said, you'd have to really want to hurt someone to do that.
I was wondering if the red flag laws are just a stepping stone.
1st step is to legally allow confiscation based on an informant's report before due process.
2nd step may be to criminalize failure to report gun owners displaying "obvious" signs of violent behavior in order to force the public to inform on their family and friends.
-
"Negligent failure to red flag".
Cops/prosecutor: "Did you know he was a danger to himself or others?"
Poor slob average guy: "No."
Cops/prosecutor: "Prove you didn't know."
And since it's impossible to "prove a negative", guess what happens to the poor slob average guy?
All of this gun control crap is incrememtalism ("a good first step" as "universal background checks" (criminalization of private property sales) are often referred to as) on the road (a highly-lubed sloping road) to total civilian disarmament, and anyone who claims otherwise is either ignorant, on their way to stupid, or a liar.
-
I was wondering if the red flag laws are just a stepping stone.
1st step is to legally allow confiscation based on an informant's report before due process.
2nd step may be to criminalize failure to report gun owners displaying "obvious" signs of violent behavior in order to force the public to inform on their family and friends.
It really is a stepping stone. Not only the example you gave, but the "well since we took their guns away with no due process, I guess we can also take them away just because".
Or they will expand the law from family, spouse, doctor, and teacher, to anyone who feels threatened. Like how wearing a MAGA hat makes liberals feel threatened.
-
... or politicians who feel that guns in their districts represent a threat to the community and therefore should be confiscated, preemptively. or even home-owners associations?
-
"Negligent failure to red flag".
Cops/prosecutor: "Did you know he was a danger to himself or others?"
Poor slob average guy: "No."
Cops/prosecutor: "Prove you didn't know."
And since it's impossible to "prove a negative", guess what happens to the poor slob average guy?
All of this gun control crap is incrememtalism ("a good first step" as "universal background checks" (criminalization of private property sales) are often referred to as) on the road (a highly-lubed sloping road) to total civilian disarmament, and anyone who claims otherwise is either ignorant, on their way to stupid, or a liar.
Except that is not how it works, prosecutors would have to show you knew. But is anyone actually suggesting that be a law?
-
That's not what you said -- at least not in your question. You never said the relative was not seeing a medical professional. You said I can't force them to seek help, but that doesn't mean they haven't done so without me or someone else "forcing" them to. Legally and personally, it's not my right to know who they are seeing for medical issues.
I thought it was a given but fair enough, I didn't explicitly say it.
But I would still like your answer to this problem. And this isn't just a gun issue either, this would be an issue even if guns weren't involved.
-
There are many with mental health issues that go un-diagnosed. The world is not perfect.
This is true, but should we endeavor to do better?
So all this law does is a way for HPD to take guns out away from it's citizens without their right to due process. And I can bet that 100% of any HPD showing up at the door step will "just follow orders" and not step up like how other Sheriff departments have and say "no, I will not violate someones rights".
While I do have problems with the law, it isn't entirely without due process.
-
I thought it was a given but fair enough, I didn't explicitly say it.
But I would still like your answer to this problem. And this isn't just a gun issue either, this would be an issue even if guns weren't involved.
I don't see the problem. For retail sales, there's a background check. That should catch the fact he's deemed mentally incompetent.
If you know he went to a private gun seller, you have the right to report him to authorities no matter what relationship you are to him.
Red Flag laws merely put the punishment before the process. They will prevent nothing once the criminals learn how to avoid getting reported.
You, just like the gun grabbers, are looking for a solution without a problem. There's no one-size-fits-all for controlling human behavior.
You should watch "The Village" and post a synopsis as well as discussion of the underlying premise/lessons learned. :popcorn:
-
This is true, but should we endeavor to do better?
While I do have problems with the law, it isn't entirely without due process.
Does the gun owner have a chance to defend themselves b4 their guns are taken away? The answer is no.
Like i used b4, see WA red flag example. Guy inside his home "looked at his neighbors funny", while having a gun on his hip.
What could help prevent mental problem people is not disarming the good guys, but let them be armed so active shootings may be stopped sooner. But instead gun free zones were created and ccw permits denied. Because we all know an active shooter will follow a $2 sign on the wall.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
While I do have problems with the law, it isn't entirely without due process.
[/quote]
You sound like a common Hawaii politician. You totally disregard that by the time it gets
through the courts, the subjects of the original abuse are dead or gone
on to another life, since you have destroyed their present life path.
That is NOT justice, that is using the system to punish the fools that
obey the law, disagree with you, or you simply don't like them.
-
While I do have problems with the law, it isn't entirely without due process.
You sound like a common Hawaii politician. You totally disregard that by the time it gets
through the courts, the subjects of the original abuse are dead or gone
on to another life, since you have destroyed their present life path.
That is NOT justice, that is using the system to punish the fools that
obey the law, disagree with you, or you simply don't like them.
so true groveler
-
While I do have problems with the law, it isn't entirely without due process.
While I do have problems with banning all semi-automatics, it isn't entirely without Second Amendment protections.
-
While I do have problems with the law, it isn't entirely without due process.
i guess your definition of "due process", and my definition are different.
I'm thinking of constitutional right. to be confronted by my accuser, and to be presented with the evidence against me, my opportunity to examine the evidence, to rebut, with legal counsel, in a court of law, and punitive measures, or rights infringements do not incur until AFTER that due process, if proven guilty, not in advance. I think that would be due process under the US Constitution (6th amendment). maybe not in New Zealand, though, they don't have a Bill of Rights.
I think the 4th amendment, "warrants issued...probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation." applies when a crime HAS BEEN committed, not for some future imaginary crime. how did we lose sight of that? I know we're long since slid down that slippery slope and bottomed out already, but still.
another problem I have with the law, is that to recover your firearms, you have to engage the legal process, at significant out-of-pocket cost. this, in my mind, is a "fine" that is imposed upon me even if "not guilty".
another problem, is that to recover your firearms, I suspect you have to go through the whole HPD permit-to-acquire process again. perhaps with the $42 rap-back fee? this is also a penalty.
in my primitive simplistic cave-man mind, if i have to go to court to recover my firearms, and I am successful, the person who initiated the complaint should pay all my fees, and HPD should deliver my firearms to me at my home, since that's where they were taken from. but I know that the US legal system has become so convoluted and complex that they've lost sight of the forest for the trees, lost sight of the constitution, and the way I see things is probably not going to happen.
I'm sure Karl Rhoads is as pleased as can be at how he has trampled on the US Bill of Rights, proudly, and blatantly. Does he call himself an American?
________________
ETA: sorry had to correct some typos.
-
Will all ammo be returned?
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
i guess your definition of "due process", and my definition are different.
I'm thinking of constitutional right. to be confronted by my accuser, and to be presented with the evidence against me, my opportunity to examine the evidence, to rebut, with legal counsel, in a court of law, and punitive measures, or rights infringements do not incur until AFTER that due process, if proven guilty, not in advance. I think that would be due process under the US Constitution (6th amendment). maybe not in New Zealand, though, they don't have a Bill of Rights.
I think the 4th amendment, "warrants issued...probably cause, supported by oath or affirmation." applies when a crime HAS BEEN committed, not for some future imaginary crime. how did we lose sight of that? I know we're long since slid down that slippery slope and bottomed out already, but still.
another problem I have with the law, is that to recover your firearms, you have to engage the legal process, at significant out-of-pocket cost. this, in my mind, is a "fine" that is imposed upon me even if "not guilty".
another problem, is that to recover your firearms, I suspect you have to go through the whole HPD permit-to-acquire process again. perhaps with the $42 rap-back fee? this is also a penalty.
in my primitive simplistic cave-man mind, if i have to go to court to recover my firearms, and I am successful, the person who initiated the complaint should pay all my fees, and HPD should deliver my firearms to me at my home, since that's where they were taken from. but I know that the US legal system has become so convoluted and complex that they've lost sight of the forest for the trees, lost sight of the constitution, and the way I see things is probably not going to happen.
I'm sure Karl Rhoads is as pleased as can be at how he has trampled on the US Bill of Rights, proudly, and blatantly. Does he call himself an American?
^^^^^
What he said
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
i guess your definition of "due process", and my definition are different.
I'm thinking of constitutional right. to be confronted by my accuser, and to be presented with the evidence against me, my opportunity to examine the evidence, to rebut, with legal counsel, in a court of law, and punitive measures, or rights infringements do not incur until AFTER that due process, if proven guilty, not in advance. I think that would be due process under the US Constitution (6th amendment). maybe not in New Zealand, though, they don't have a Bill of Rights.
I think the 4th amendment, "warrants issued...probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation." applies when a crime HAS BEEN committed, not for some future imaginary crime. how did we lose sight of that? I know we're long since slid down that slippery slope and bottomed out already, but still.
another problem I have with the law, is that to recover your firearms, you have to engage the legal process, at significant out-of-pocket cost. this, in my mind, is a "fine" that is imposed upon me even if "not guilty".
another problem, is that to recover your firearms, I suspect you have to go through the whole HPD permit-to-acquire process again. perhaps with the $42 rap-back fee? this is also a penalty.
in my primitive simplistic cave-man mind, if i have to go to court to recover my firearms, and I am successful, the person who initiated the complaint should pay all my fees, and HPD should deliver my firearms to me at my home, since that's where they were taken from. but I know that the US legal system has become so convoluted and complex that they've lost sight of the forest for the trees, lost sight of the constitution, and the way I see things is probably not going to happen.
I'm sure Karl Rhoads is as pleased as can be at how he has trampled on the US Bill of Rights, proudly, and blatantly. Does he call himself an American?
________________
ETA: sorry had to correct some typos.
I think you objection would be better summarized as there is not enough due process protections. If the accused had no power to object to the order/ruling (for example) then there would be no due process, however if the accused had to wait too long for their appeal then due process exists but is inadequate. Not sure if you saw where I would draw the line but for me a red flag law would need to have a higher level of proof and the accused would have to have the hearing within 48-72 hours of their firearms being taken away. The right to confront the accuser is a good one I had not thought about before but I would also require that.
The rapback fee you only pay once so if you paid already you wouldn't have to pay again. I do agree though that it is ridiculous that someone needs to reapply for a permit to get their own guns back. That entirely defeats the rapback purpose which is supposed to provide quick notification!
-
I just thought of another interesting type of law that could serve as a parallel to consider when talking about red flag laws.
In the event of a dangerous viral outbreak there are some laws in place that allow the government to force a person into medical evaluation. (In most cases a conscious person can refuse medical treatment) I think this might be a fair thing to compare because it deals with revoking someone's rights as well as balancing a possible impending risk of the person not being legally restrained.
Imagine a scenario where someone was found to have a dangerous virus and imagine that you were exposed to them. Maybe you sat nearby or shook hands with the person.
You show symptoms consistent with the virus in question but you have not gotten tested and refuse too. Your neighbor or friend sees all of this and reports you to the authorities.
Should the authorities have any emergency powers to contain you?
Can the courts order you to be contained without you being present at the hearing to represent yourself?
Should the government have to prove you are infected before they can restrict your movement?
Should you be free to walk around as you wish potentially exposing other people until a full court hearing with all the usual due process steps be concluded?
A few years back a patient who had been diagnosed with a dangerous form of TB decided to get on an airplane and fly somewhere, thereby exposing hundreds on a plane. The doctor told him not to fly but such an order was not enforceable.
Now I am not trying to make any specific argument here I just wanted to throw this one our for consideration and context since it deals with revocation of a constitutional right based on a situation where a a risk exists but a person has not been convicted of anything. I have always found the idea and process of quarantining people due to disease an interesting topic.
-
The red flags law deny all due process. Your guns get taken away prior to your court date where you have the chance to defend accusations.
There is no "partial". HPD shows up at your door and u had no clue.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
The red flags law deny all due process. Your guns get taken away prior to your court date where you have the chance to defend accusations.
There is no "partial". HPD shows up at your door and u had no clue.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
It's not like that is the only right that gets taken away before a court date.
If you get arrested for a crime based on probable cause you can be held until your court date. But the due process exists in things like the right to appeal, the right to a speedy trial, etc. So I don't think it is unprecedented legally speaking to consider taking firearms away prior to a court hearing as long as there are protections in place like the ones I mentioned.
What do you think about the medical situation I mentioned in the post above? Should a person with a probably dangerous and contagious infection be allowed to walk around free until a test result confirms a diagnosis and courts order the person confined?
-
So is it illegal to walk around with HIV/AIDS? Quaranteening someone is different from removing their right. Pretty sure if you have ebola, u will willlingly be in a hostpital or place of treatment without grumbling.
Can u name another right that is stripped until your court date to defend yourself? Right to vote, speech, press, religion, etc...
The media is making you think we need red flag laws. Like how they make people think we have an "assault rifle" problem, even though it was invented in 1957.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
So is it illegal to walk around with HIV/AIDS? Quaranteening someone is different from removing their right. Pretty sure if you have ebola, u will willlingly be in a hostpital or place of treatment without grumbling.
Can u name another right that is stripped until your court date to defend yourself? Right to vote, speech, press, religion, etc...
The media is making you think we need red flag laws. Like how they make people think we have an "assault rifle" problem, even though it was invented in 1957.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
HIV is not very contagious so it isn't a very good comparison. I was thinking something more like ebola, small pox, or the plague.
Surprisingly, it is pretty common for people who think they have ebola to not want to go to ebola treatment centers. This has been noted in some African countries where Ebola is more common. Logically I would agree with you but there seems to be something illogical about people's behavior. Maybe a fear they will catch it from other patients if they have symptoms but it is something else, or believing that going to the hospital just means you will never leave again (die there). But even if there were not such a phenomenon here in America you could still have an individual who decides to walk around in public.
So in such an instance, do you think a person should be allowed to walk around freely until he can have a court hearing?
As for other rights that are stripped, if you are arrested for a crime you can be held in jail (loss of certain rights) until your court date. That would be the most obvious one I can think of but there may be a few others. The medical quarantine laws might be another example but to be honest I don't fully understand the process of a judge ordering someone to be put in quarantine. I am sure there is a right to appeal but I don't think one necessarily gets a court hearing before a judge can order them quarantined.
The media isn't making me thing we need red flag laws. I have contemplated on the idea a fair amount outside of just legislators or the media saying we need it.
-
As for other rights that are stripped, if you are arrested for a crime you can be held in jail (loss of certain rights) until your court date.
Bullshit. Arrest and detention involves due process. You're mirandized. You have the right to a lawyer. You have to be arraigned in so many hours or be released without charges. You may have the right to be freed on bail.
All of that, and more, is part of due process. You won't be "held in jail (loss of certain rights) until your court date" unless and until your arraignment, which comes before any other limits are placed on your rights. There has to be a warrant issued based on probable cause to violate your 4th amendment rights.
Red flags skip this whole judicial system designed to protect the rights of the accused and go right to firearm confiscation based on an ex parte process. You may not even be arrested. They just confiscate your firearms. Without an arrest, due process is not being Constitutionally violated. it amounts to civil forfeiture based on a complaint without adequate protections for the accused.
-
red flag laws are dumb - drafted and conjured up by fearful, paranoid, gun-hating snowflakes who use govt to confiscate legally acquired firearms.
Dunno why you guys are asking that particular LEO about this, he would gladly come to your house and take your guns.
-
Bullshit. Arrest and detention involves due process. You're mirandized. You have the right to a lawyer. You have to be arraigned in so many hours or be released without charges. You may have the right to be freed on bail.
All of that, and more, is part of due process. You won't be "held in jail (loss of certain rights) until your court date" unless and until your arraignment, which comes before any other limits are placed on your rights. There has to be a warrant issued based on probable cause to violate your 4th amendment rights.
Red flags skip this whole judicial system designed to protect the rights of the accused and go right to firearm confiscation based on an ex parte process. You may not even be arrested. They just confiscate your firearms. Without an arrest, due process is not being Constitutionally violated. it amounts to civil forfeiture based on a complaint without adequate protections for the accused.
You can be held for up to 48 hours without actually being charged.
Then you can be held until arraignment.
Then (if you don't bail out) you can be held till your actual trial and you are convicted of a crime.
Now you might not think there is enough due process protections but the fact is the language does contain some due process for the accused.
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2019/bills/SB1466_HD2_.htm
The accuser may be required to testify under oath.
The respondent (accused) gets a hearing 14 days after the initial order is served
The accused can get a lawyer
Even if the 1 year prohibition is granted the accused can still petition the court at any time to remove the order.
Now I don't think that is quite enough protections but we can't sit around pretending there are no protections.
What do you think about the medical question I raised? That is a fitting parallel to red flag laws. Do you think someone (showing signs of a dangerous infection) should be allowed to walk free until a court finds probable cause they are infected with a dangerous contagious disease or do you think there is a need to quarantine the individual quickly and have the court hearing soon after?
-
You can be held for up to 48 hours without actually being charged.
Then you can be held until arraignment.
Then (if you don't bail out) you can be held till your actual trial and you are convicted of a crime.
Now you might not think there is enough due process protections but the fact is the language does contain some due process for the accused.
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2019/bills/SB1466_HD2_.htm
The accuser may be required to testify under oath.
The respondent (accused) gets a hearing 14 days after the initial order is served
The accused can get a lawyer
Even if the 1 year prohibition is granted the accused can still petition the court at any time to remove the order.
Now I don't think that is quite enough protections but we can't sit around pretending there are no protections.
What do you think about the medical question I raised? That is a fitting parallel to red flag laws. Do you think someone (showing signs of a dangerous infection) should be allowed to walk free until a court finds probable cause they are infected with a dangerous contagious disease or do you think there is a need to quarantine the individual quickly and have the court hearing soon after?
"A" process is not "due" process. Confiscation is a deliberate punishment. Once again, if the person is so dangerous to the public they can't have guns, then detaining them and using EXISTING due process makes more sense.
The gaping hole in the logic of red flag laws is identical to denying guns to felons. You're preemptively violating a right without the person having done anything wrong to justify losing 2A rights. Most felons are not violent offenders. If they are violent, and they are too much of a safety risk to allow them to have guns, then they are too much of a risk to be free in society.
Same argument applies to "red flag" defendants. Lock them up, or don't. Taking their guns is not a solution.
-
What do you think about the medical question I raised? That is a fitting parallel to red flag laws. Do you think someone (showing signs of a dangerous infection) should be allowed to walk free until a court finds probable cause they are infected with a dangerous contagious disease or do you think there is a need to quarantine the individual quickly and have the court hearing soon after?
Your hypothetical disease is unrelated to this issue. We have tests for disease. There are no tests that predict violent behavior.
-
Your hypothetical disease is unrelated to this issue. We have tests for disease. There are no tests that predict violent behavior.
no tests...just a big red flag! Go get em
-
If youre held in jail until your court date many rights are loss. Compared to a red flag where 2 are lost. The 2a is the only right thats targeted.
If someone had ebola, they would probably die before their court date.
So many sheriff departments said they will not enforce a red flag law. Would you "just follow orders" and enforce it?
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
like many others have stated apply this red flag law to cars and people would be up in arms..the ACLU would step in, Mazie would demand answers, AARP would have a wheelchair riot etc.
but all these people are for disarming the law abiding citizens in order to do "something"
well, few realize that the "something" doesn't always do anything. You can yell at a tree to move all you want - but you did do "something" tree still there
We can pass more laws about drinking and driving to do something but until people start obeying the law it isn't going to do jack shit.
And guess what? gun owners are vetted law abiding citizens. Just by nature of the process. SO we are easy pickings when they pass a law. You think the average citizen will obey the law of drinking and NOT driving? How about speeding? See a car speeding "red flag" the car for confiscation as a speeding car is just as dangerous as a loaded gun in a preschool cubby hole.
This red flag law is complete horse shit!
-
like many others have stated apply this red flag law to cars and people would be up in arms..the ACLU would step in, Mazie would demand answers, AARP would have a wheelchair riot etc.
but all these people are for disarming the law abiding citizens in order to do "something"
well, few realize that the "something" doesn't always do anything. You can yell at a tree to move all you want - but you did do "something" tree still there
We can pass more laws about drinking and driving to do something but until people start obeying the law it isn't going to do jack shit.
And guess what? gun owners are vetted law abiding citizens. Just by nature of the process. SO we are easy pickings when they pass a law. You think the average citizen will obey the law of drinking and NOT driving? How about speeding? See a car speeding "red flag" the car for confiscation as a speeding car is just as dangerous as a loaded gun in a preschool cubby hole.
This red flag law is complete horse shit!
And yet... this is what "our" legislators "serve" us with... by a near unanimous vote! While the vast majority of ("socialist Democrat") voters in Hawaii apparently take great delight in seeing us being repeatedly bent over.
-
Good example about applying the same to cars and others. The 2 is the only right shit on all the time.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
"A" process is not "due" process. Confiscation is a deliberate punishment. Once again, if the person is so dangerous to the public they can't have guns, then detaining them and using EXISTING due process makes more sense.
The gaping hole in the logic of red flag laws is identical to denying guns to felons. You're preemptively violating a right without the person having done anything wrong to justify losing 2A rights. Most felons are not violent offenders. If they are violent, and they are too much of a safety risk to allow them to have guns, then they are too much of a risk to be free in society.
Same argument applies to "red flag" defendants. Lock them up, or don't. Taking their guns is not a solution.
I do agree that if we think they are dangerous we should consider locking them up, not just taking away their firearms. Taking away their firearms doesn't make them no longer a threat. We are in definite agreement there.
A red flag law that is based off evidence and testimony, just like a normal criminal case, could stand the constitutional test in my opinion. Again, I am not saying that I support the particular red flag law we have now, I just can envision a form of red flag law that does respect due process and constitutional rights. The concept is workable but only with appropriate protections.
-
Your hypothetical disease is unrelated to this issue. We have tests for disease. There are no tests that predict violent behavior.
There are tests to help diagnose mental illnesses.
Whether in the disease scenario or a mental health scenario you have comparable similarities.
-Symptoms visible to people around the individual
-A person may refuse to seek medical or mental health evaluation
-The person may be a risk to others if the individual actually does have the condition in question.
-The situation deals with someone's constitutional rights being taken away.
So again I ask, should someone with symptoms of a deadly contagious disease be allowed to walk around free until someone can petition the court and he can have a court hearing before taking any rights away?
-
There are tests to help diagnose mental illnesses.
Whether in the disease scenario or a mental health scenario you have comparable similarities.
-Symptoms visible to people around the individual
-A person may refuse to seek medical or mental health evaluation
-The person may be a risk to others if the individual actually does have the condition in question.
-The situation deals with someone's constitutional rights being taken away.
So again I ask, should someone with symptoms of a deadly contagious disease be allowed to walk around free until someone can petition the court and he can have a court hearing before taking any rights away?
Statistically, the rate of violence among people diagnosed as mentally ill is nearly identical to the rate among the rest of the population.
Simply pigeon-holing someone as mentally ill has no additional impact on public safety. Mentally ill are living and walking among the rest of us because they have civil rights to not be locked up if they haven't committed a crime or are unable to care for themselves.
Psychologists agree that there is no way for mental health professionals to identify who among us will commit an act of violence. That includes the mentally ill.
Your hypothetical disease is still irrelevant.
-
The problem with the example is this. I'm using ebola because it's easy to type. A test will confirm you either have ebola or not. So if you have it, it's highly contagious. Are there test for mental issues, yes there are. But shooting people or acting violently is what the test cannot prove will happen. There are lots of non-violent people with mental problems.
And with ebola, you will probably feel like shit and seek help. So the carrier is willingly going there or to sick to move.
-
a liquor store in downtown has due process more than we will have under this "red flag" BS of a law
https://www.kitv.com/story/40491572/honolulu-liquor-commission-votes-to-revoke-controversial-stores-license (https://www.kitv.com/story/40491572/honolulu-liquor-commission-votes-to-revoke-controversial-stores-license)
-
a liquor store in downtown has due process more than we will have under this "red flag" BS of a law
https://www.kitv.com/story/40491572/honolulu-liquor-commission-votes-to-revoke-controversial-stores-license (https://www.kitv.com/story/40491572/honolulu-liquor-commission-votes-to-revoke-controversial-stores-license)
That's because none of the following filed a complaint: family member, teacher, doctor, coworker. :rofl:
It's just you know, the people, mayor, HPD, and everyone else.
-
Statistically, the rate of violence among people diagnosed as mentally ill is nearly identical to the rate among the rest of the population.
Simply pigeon-holing someone as mentally ill has no additional impact on public safety. Mentally ill are living and walking among the rest of us because they have civil rights to not be locked up if they haven't committed a crime or are unable to care for themselves.
Psychologists agree that there is no way for mental health professionals to identify who among us will commit an act of violence. That includes the mentally ill.
Your hypothetical disease is still irrelevant.
Maybe if you lump them together but some mental illnesses do have higher rates of violence while others have lower rates of violence. Of course we can't take a one size fits all approach.
I think you say my hypothetical scenario is irrelevant because you know you don't have a good answer. Even if you didn't think it was a good comparison you still couldn't answer the question.
You never even answered my earlier question about what to do with someone who shows signs of being mentally ill and violent but has committed no crime. You complain about proposed solutions but offer none of your own.
-
The problem with the example is this. I'm using ebola because it's easy to type. A test will confirm you either have ebola or not. So if you have it, it's highly contagious. Are there test for mental issues, yes there are. But shooting people or acting violently is what the test cannot prove will happen. There are lots of non-violent people with mental problems.
And with ebola, you will probably feel like shit and seek help. So the carrier is willingly going there or to sick to move.
I agree most will seek help but there will always be that odd one who refuses to go voluntarily. Should that person's constitutional rights be taken away and have him forced to take a test to confirm ebola? Consider this separate from a red flag law even, it is still an interesting test on constitutional rights. Does the fact that there exists a test for ebola that can say with certainty that the person is infected or not? Does having a definitive test justify taking away the individuals rights on the suspicion they are infected?
You do bring up probably the single biggest hurdle I think the courts face though in this type of issue. They can diagnose someone with a mental illness but it is a hard line to draw of when that diagnosis warrants take away their rights, whether it be firearms or just to walk around freely in public.
Maybe another issue that could be brought up to serve as an analysis would be pedophilia. Some feel that convicted pedophiles should never re-enter society because the risk of recidivism is too great but it is not a guarantee that they will re-offend. Then there are pedophiles who have never acted on their desires, should society set limitations on them when they haven't done anything? Honestly, if I found out my kids teacher had pedophilia I wouldn't have my kid in their class even if the teacher had never acted on it. Would you? (Yes I realize being a teacher isn't a constitutionally protected right)
-
Maybe if you lump them together but some mental illnesses do have higher rates of violence while others have lower rates of violence. Of course we can't take a one size fits all approach.
I think you say my hypothetical scenario is irrelevant because you know you don't have a good answer. Even if you didn't think it was a good comparison you still couldn't answer the question.
You never even answered my earlier question about what to do with someone who shows signs of being mentally ill and violent but has committed no crime. You complain about proposed solutions but offer none of your own.
Please post statistical studies and charts that show the breakdown of violent acts committed by mentally ill patients based on the diseases they were diagnosed as having.
Identify whether "higher rates of violence" is comparing those rates among the population in general or only among the population of known, diagnosed individuals with mental illnesses.
Often, people who commit violence are abusing alcohol and/or narcotics, both illegal and prescribed. Use of drugs, and withdrawal from habitual use, increases the potential for violence exponentially in both the general population and the mentally ill. It's not unreasonable to assume the majority of violent mentally ill patients commit those acts of violence more as a side-effect of the drugs they take, Rx or self-medicating, and not the disease itself.
I don't answer irrelevant questions. it's an academic exercise with no value.
-
Please post statistical studies and charts that show the breakdown of violent acts committed by mentally ill patients based on the diseases they were diagnosed as having.
Identify whether "higher rates of violence" is comparing those rates among the population in general or only among the population of known, diagnosed individuals with mental illnesses.
Often, people who commit violence are abusing alcohol and/or narcotics, both illegal and prescribed. Use of drugs, and withdrawal from habitual use, increases the potential for violence exponentially in both the general population and the mentally ill. It's not unreasonable to assume the majority of violent mentally ill patients commit those acts of violence more as a side-effect of the drugs they take, Rx or self-medicating, and not the disease itself.
I don't answer irrelevant questions. it's an academic exercise with no value.
A simple diagnosis alone is not a very reliable predictor but once someone is diagnosed. A diagnosis is just the first step towards identifying someone who may be dangerous.
"The two best predictors are actuarial strategies,15 which focus on diverse demographic and behavioural histories, and use of the HCR-20 (Historical, Clinical, Risk Management), a 20-item checklist designed to estimate the probability of future violence."
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6019348/
I did not find a list that broke down violence rates by diagnosis. I did find some results that showed certain mental disorders have much higher rates, when combined with substance abuse, than the normal population. So one takeaway could be that if you know someone with schizophrenia who is also abusing drugs, that can serve as a more reliable predictor of violence. Again, this would need to be decided on a case by case basis and the above mentioned 20 item checklist would give us a better predictor of how violent someone will be.
Sometimes certain symptoms present with a mental health diagnosis showed higher rates of violence. For example "Mentally ill patients with threatening, paranoid delusions are twice as likely to become aggressive compared with nonparanoid psychotic patients."
And it isn't just a biological mental illnesses either "As many as 70 percent of patients with brain injury secondary to blunt trauma exhibit irritability and aggression."
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2686644/
Suicides correlated highly with someone who was suffering depression at the time. Usually I don't consider suicide into violence rates but since it comprises about 2/3rds of gun deaths it isn't a statistic we can ignore either.
Seeing as how you recognize the role substances have come into play in violence, what is your suggestion in how to address those with mental health issues that are being combined with substance abuse? You recognize a problem but are providing no alternative to red flag type laws. You admit there is a certain group of individuals that do pose an increased risk but are silent on what to do about it.
So lets modify the scenario so it is unavoidable for you. Your brother has schizophrenia and has recently taken up abusing alcohol. He has shown an increase in aggressive tendencies and now wants to buy a gun. You suggest he see a mental health professional but he refuses. What do you do absent any sort of red flag law to address this?
-
Since were taking away their guns because they might do something bad, we should also take away all sharp objects, cars, drivers license, household cleaning products, blunt objects such as staplers, rocks, baseballs, bottles, hammers, screw drivers , etc...if theyre big, lets say above 5'8 and 210lbs, they must remain handcuffed also.
They might use any of the above to harm someone.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
A simple diagnosis alone is not a very reliable predictor but once someone is diagnosed. A diagnosis is just the first step towards identifying someone who may be dangerous.
"The two best predictors are actuarial strategies,15 which focus on diverse demographic and behavioural histories, and use of the HCR-20 (Historical, Clinical, Risk Management), a 20-item checklist designed to estimate the probability of future violence."
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6019348/
I did not find a list that broke down violence rates by diagnosis. I did find some results that showed certain mental disorders have much higher rates, when combined with substance abuse, than the normal population. So one takeaway could be that if you know someone with schizophrenia who is also abusing drugs, that can serve as a more reliable predictor of violence. Again, this would need to be decided on a case by case basis and the above mentioned 20 item checklist would give us a better predictor of how violent someone will be.
Sometimes certain symptoms present with a mental health diagnosis showed higher rates of violence. For example "Mentally ill patients with threatening, paranoid delusions are twice as likely to become aggressive compared with nonparanoid psychotic patients."
And it isn't just a biological mental illnesses either "As many as 70 percent of patients with brain injury secondary to blunt trauma exhibit irritability and aggression."
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2686644/
Suicides correlated highly with someone who was suffering depression at the time. Usually I don't consider suicide into violence rates but since it comprises about 2/3rds of gun deaths it isn't a statistic we can ignore either.
Seeing as how you recognize the role substances have come into play in violence, what is your suggestion in how to address those with mental health issues that are being combined with substance abuse? You recognize a problem but are providing no alternative to red flag type laws. You admit there is a certain group of individuals that do pose an increased risk but are silent on what to do about it.
So lets modify the scenario so it is unavoidable for you. Your brother has schizophrenia and has recently taken up abusing alcohol. He has shown an increase in aggressive tendencies and now wants to buy a gun. You suggest he see a mental health professional but he refuses. What do you do absent any sort of red flag law to address this?
Abuse/habitual use of narcotics and alcohol are already disqualifying behaviors for firearm ownership. If the person is arrested for such behavior, their right to keep guns they have as well as those they may want to purchase would be subject to confiscation/rejection.
Your entire argument, regardless of the hypotheticals you spew, boils down to one thing: how do we include people who haven't yet been entered into the system as mentally ill, violent, substance abusers, etc. if they are not causing problems or have been ignored (such as Parkland/Broward County)? You believe we need more laws. How will that change anything? The same people in the red flag laws can already report potentially violent people to law enforcement. The difference is red flag laws have an automatic confiscation feature, whereas today's laws require actual due process.
I don't know how many times and in how many ways that needs to be stated before you get it.
-
I don't know how many times and in how many ways that needs to be stated before you get it.
(https://i.imgur.com/qcMTVVA.gif)
-
We need a law that makes it illegal to even think about committing a violent act - ILLEGAL. Maybe a murder, death kill law???
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gGGDzEWvGRY
It's pointless to argue with someone who would gladly take away your 2A rights. It's not about rational discussion - it's about power.
-
We need a law that makes it illegal to even think about committing a violent act - ILLEGAL. Maybe a murder, death kill law???
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gGGDzEWvGRY
It's pointless to argue with someone who would gladly take away your 2A rights. It's not about rational discussion - it's about power.
Then we could all inspire joy joy feelings in everyone around us...
While we are on the subject perhaps we could just get it over with and enact pre-crime laws Rhoads, Lee and Theilen could be our pre-cogs. Maybe Bloomberg would foot the bill.
-
Since were taking away their guns because they might do something bad, we should also take away all sharp objects, cars, drivers license, household cleaning products, blunt objects such as staplers, rocks, baseballs, bottles, hammers, screw drivers , etc...if theyre big, lets say above 5'8 and 210lbs, they must remain handcuffed also.
They might use any of the above to harm someone.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
Fair enough but the same issue is still present. How do we restrain these people in whatever way necessary whether it be taking away firearms or taking away their freedom altogether? Should we wait until an actual crime has occurred?
-
Abuse/habitual use of narcotics and alcohol are already disqualifying behaviors for firearm ownership. If the person is arrested for such behavior, their right to keep guns they have as well as those they may want to purchase would be subject to confiscation/rejection.
Being an alcoholic is not an arrestable offense. However your comment suggests that you support the police revoking someones firearms rights if they are found to have substance abuse issues. So get 2 DUIs and they get to take away your guns? Attend AA meetings and they get to take away your guns?
Your entire argument, regardless of the hypotheticals you spew, boils down to one thing: how do we include people who haven't yet been entered into the system as mentally ill, violent, substance abusers, etc. if they are not causing problems or have been ignored (such as Parkland/Broward County)? You believe we need more laws. How will that change anything? The same people in the red flag laws can already report potentially violent people to law enforcement. The difference is red flag laws have an automatic confiscation feature, whereas today's laws require actual due process.
Your understanding is flawed. So take the scenario I just mentioned and pretend there is no red flag law. You call the police and say that you believe your brother is a danger. Cops come and talk to him but he plays it cool and denies all the things you claim. Or maybe your brother just politely refuses to speak to police. The cops can call the police psychologist but if they see no warning signs they aren't going to be able to force your brother to go with them to a mental health facility. The system you point to as the solution does not adequately do what you suggest it will, there are holes in the current system, holes that red flag laws are trying to patch.
You can either suggest a workable solution or sit and complain when they come up with a bad type of red flag law that doesn't have enough protections.
I don't know how many times and in how many ways that needs to be stated before you get it.
I don't get things which are based upon flawed logic.
-
all this flawed logic is from a Minority Report scenario where we THINK we can predict a person's bad intentions and arrest them before the act. That's a fantasy that is not possible. We look to the law as this magical wand that will whisk things away - but let's face it we live in a world where violence happens. We can impose more laws to restrict EVERYONE"s rights but look at what we have now - unarmed LAW ABIDING citizens. We haven't tried the other way around and EMPOWER the rightful citizen. All we do is take things away. Evil, idle persons will find away while the rest of the life-pursuing law abiders will go on with the rest of productive society.
Freedom isn't perfect but it ceases to be when you start targeting the very PEOPLE THAT FOLLOW THE LAW.
You can point to the source of firearms - stolen, imported from other countries but don't criminalize the person who legally acquired the firearm.
In short the "Red Flag" law is nothing more than an avenue to disarm based on subjective opinion - a witch hunt conducted by those who are unarmed and want to assert power.
Our State has a bigger problem of DUIs and pedestrian accidents caused by vehicles. Just this morning a lady was killed down the street. We could easily translate this Red Flag law to apply to vehicles but we don't. We apply it to a statistically lesser problem of legal firearms.
Here we have a similar concept of "doing something" to save lives; along the lines of inventing technology that hasn't been invented yet.
https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/senate-democrats-propose-hot-cars-act-to-save-kids-from-heatstroke-deaths (https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/senate-democrats-propose-hot-cars-act-to-save-kids-from-heatstroke-deaths)
Ac act with no definitive solution whatsoever. Just an implied mandate to car manufacturers. Instead of attacking the root nature of the problem - poor accountability; they create this BS of an act. Wishful thinking.
What a bunch of assclownery, horseshit, unicorn fuxtardiness, monkey fucking a football :grrr: from a person with no real solution. All you want is an argument with zero results. No relevance. The only valid comments are those of a Cpt Obvious nature.
-
meanwhile, we need a fucking big red flag law on knives, trucks and other "stuff" too
https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2019/05/28/report-japan-bus-stop-stabbing-wounds-kills-up/ (https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2019/05/28/report-japan-bus-stop-stabbing-wounds-kills-up/)
Although Japan has one of the lowest crime rates in the world, it has had a series of high-profile killings, including in 2016 when a former employee at a home for the disabled allegedly killed 19 and injured more than 20 others.
In 2008, seven people were killed by a man who slammed a truck into a crowd of people in central Tokyo's Akihabara electronics district and then stabbed passers-by.
Also in 2016, a man stabbed four people at a library in northeastern Japan, allegedly over their mishandling of his questions. No one was killed.
Armchair QB all these events and all these innocent lives could have been saved by a good citizen with a gun.
-
all this flawed logic is from a Minority Report scenario where we THINK we can predict a person's bad intentions and arrest them before the act. That's a fantasy that is not possible.
So are you of the position that no one should be confined against their will in a mental health institution until they have committed an actual crime?
In short the "Red Flag" law is nothing more than an avenue to disarm based on subjective opinion - a witch hunt conducted by those who are unarmed and want to assert power.
I think you misunderstand their intentions and goals.
Our State has a bigger problem of DUIs and pedestrian accidents caused by vehicles. Just this morning a lady was killed down the street. We could easily translate this Red Flag law to apply to vehicles but we don't. We apply it to a statistically lesser problem of legal firearms.
It might happen some day. When (if) guns are taken away and kids start using their cars to kill people at school we may see some of the same suggestions for cars.
Here we have a similar concept of "doing something" to save lives; along the lines of inventing technology that hasn't been invented yet.
https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/senate-democrats-propose-hot-cars-act-to-save-kids-from-heatstroke-deaths (https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/senate-democrats-propose-hot-cars-act-to-save-kids-from-heatstroke-deaths)
Ac act with no definitive solution whatsoever. Just an implied mandate to car manufacturers. Instead of attacking the root nature of the problem - poor accountability; they create this BS of an act. Wishful thinking.
How do you attack poor accountability for kids dying from being left in hot cars in a way that makes sure no one makes that mistake anymore?
-
So are you of the position that no one should be confined against their will in a mental health institution until they have committed an actual crime?
I think you misunderstand their intentions and goals.
It might happen some day. When (if) guns are taken away and kids start using their cars to kill people at school we may see some of the same suggestions for cars.
There you go. Just admit what you want - disarmament. The truth set you free.
How do you attack poor accountability for kids dying from being left in hot cars in a way that makes sure no one makes that mistake anymore?
it's called accounting for your kids when you leave the car. You can count can you? Oh shit I take that back. You can't so we need some technology-that-hasn't been-invented-yet. How about some fancy sensor to remind you on your ever-so-glued-to-your-face-"smart"phone. Oh shit, let me guess you forgot your kids because you were on your phone posting a red dot selfie to your Facebook on your way into Walmart decadence because it was half the cost of an ACOG.
Yes. No one should be committed to an institution until a crime is committed. It's called innocence.
What's your solution Mr. Burgess?
-
Ever see Equilibrium? Control all emotions and anything that causes an emotion is illegal. Paintings, music, books, etc
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
Ever see Equilibrium? Control all emotions and anything that causes an emotion is illegal. Paintings, music, books, etc
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
you mean that was a movie? I thought it was a documentary.
-
it's called accounting for your kids when you leave the car. You can count can you? Oh shit I take that back. You can't so we need some technology-that-hasn't been-invented-yet. How about some fancy sensor to remind you on your ever-so-glued-to-your-face-"smart"phone. Oh shit, let me guess you forgot your kids because you were on your phone posting a red dot selfie to your Facebook on your way into Walmart decadence because it was half the cost of an ACOG.
Yes. No one should be committed to an institution until a crime is committed. It's called innocence.
What's your solution Mr. Burgess?
Great, we can tell people to be good parents then throw them in jail when they fail. We hold them accountable... oh yeah, too late the kid is dead already. Heaven forbid someone comes up with a technology idea to address human forgetfulness.
Now as to your other comment, please don't use strawman arguments against me. I never said I want to disarm people of cars or guns. You said why don't they do the same thing with cars and I pointed out they may someday. Need to work on your reading comprehension if you somehow drew the conclusion I was for confiscation.
-
Great, we can tell people to be good parents then throw them in jail when they fail. We hold them accountable... oh yeah, too late the kid is dead already. Heaven forbid someone comes up with a technology idea to address human forgetfulness.
Now as to your other comment, please don't use strawman arguments against me. I never said I want to disarm people of cars or guns. You said why don't they do the same thing with cars and I pointed out they may someday. Need to work on your reading comprehension if you somehow drew the conclusion I was for confiscation.
You have a hard-on for confiscation. A red flag law today. Tomorrow a smell test. A whiff and boom there you are.
Once again no solution. Just worthless waha
-
You have a hard-on for confiscation. A red flag law today. Tomorrow a smell test. A whiff and boom there you are.
Yawn... any other false accusations you want to lump in while you are at it?
-
Yawn... any other false accusations you want to lump in while you are at it?
what's your solution Mr. Burgess?
I suggest a Red New Deal or something along those lines
-
Being an alcoholic is not an arrestable offense. However your comment suggests that you support the police revoking someones firearms rights if they are found to have substance abuse issues. So get 2 DUIs and they get to take away your guns? Attend AA meetings and they get to take away your guns?
Your understanding is flawed. So take the scenario I just mentioned and pretend there is no red flag law. You call the police and say that you believe your brother is a danger. Cops come and talk to him but he plays it cool and denies all the things you claim. Or maybe your brother just politely refuses to speak to police. The cops can call the police psychologist but if they see no warning signs they aren't going to be able to force your brother to go with them to a mental health facility. The system you point to as the solution does not adequately do what you suggest it will, there are holes in the current system, holes that red flag laws are trying to patch.
You can either suggest a workable solution or sit and complain when they come up with a bad type of red flag law that doesn't have enough protections.
I don't get things which are based upon flawed logic.
I have a solution: don't pretend you are qualified to turn your brother into the authorities for having "risky" behaviors. He's done nothing to warrant being arrested or have his guns taken away.
HYPOTHETICALLY, let's say YOU'RE A COP. You see a man acting intoxicated on his own property and hurting nobody. You also know this man owns guns. No neighbors have lodged any complaints about public drunkenness. As an officer of the law, you need probable cause to arrest him or confiscate his guns.
So, as a "solution", you encourage lawmakers to pass red flag laws. Now, if someone eligible to do so reports that intoxicated man as being a "threat", his guns can be taken away even though he STILL hasn't committed any acts of violence. As a Cop, you're eligible to report his behavior, and you do so. His guns are confiscated, and now he has to suffer within the judicial system to recover his own property.
Alcoholism is not a criminal offense, but DUI, drunk and disorderly, and public intoxication are. It's rare for true alcoholics to never once encounter the police while doing something wrong while drunk. If the person you're using as an example has never had an alcohol-related visit from the Cops, then I guess he's not much of a nasty drunk, huh?
Please explain why you believe people who have never done anything illegal should be subjected to harassment and unconstitutional confiscation of their property without having broken the law nor explicitly threatened to harm others. Then, please show a link to the test mental health professionals agree on that predicts violent behavior in humans, in particular those with mental illnesses or substance addictions. Or, do you support including anyone for any set of reasons created by lawmakers in "risky groups" so their guns can summarily be taken before they ever break the law?
-
Laws are ineffective without enforcement.
So, are you (EEF) also in favor of red flag laws punishing anyone who should have reported a murderer before they commit murder? If you believe bad people display "red flags" that others can interpret, and it can be show those flags were present, why not arrest granny for making the decision to spare her favorite grandson from having to deal with the courts?
In Hawaii especially, people are reluctant to turn anyone in for any reason out of fear of retaliation by the person of their family and friends. Do you really think people would turn in their family members as "risky" based on no laws broken (yet) unless there's a law mandating they do it? Even then, would the family report anyone?
You haven't thought this "solution" through very well.
-
Hawaii has a rich tradition of "talk stink". Red Flag law is just codifying something that already exists in local tradition. at least, that's how they'll see it.
I mean, hey, look at the Kealoha's. "Uncle is a mail box thief" as alleged, nieces & nephews being bamboozled, as alleged.
-
Nevada advances red flag bill. Goes to their dnc gov which he will sign.
Oh and they added in a ban on bump stocks as extra gravy.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
Laws are ineffective without enforcement.
So, are you (EEF) also in favor of red flag laws punishing anyone who should have reported a murderer before they commit murder? If you believe bad people display "red flags" that others can interpret, and it can be show those flags were present, why not arrest granny for making the decision to spare her favorite grandson from having to deal with the courts?
In Hawaii especially, people are reluctant to turn anyone in for any reason out of fear of retaliation by the person of their family and friends. Do you really think people would turn in their family members as "risky" based on no laws broken (yet) unless there's a law mandating they do it? Even then, would the family report anyone?
You haven't thought this "solution" through very well.
Absolutely, false reports to police need to have a real consequence and this should include false TROs and false red flag type orders. On top of criminal action civil action is an option as well.
People "turn in" their own family members all the time when it comes to mental health issues.
-
Absolutely, false reports to police need to have a real consequence and this should include false TROs and false red flag type orders. On top of criminal action civil action is an option as well.
People "turn in" their own family members all the time when it comes to mental health issues.
Show me the proof of that "fact".
How many are turned in BEFORE they do or say something violent? How many probable crimes were stopped by reporting?
Assuming that happens "all the time", then there's really no need for a new red flag law. Current laws should be adequate.
Talking out of your ass again.
-
what's your solution Mr. Burgess?
I suggest a Red New Deal or something along those lines
I would envision a system that doesn't center only around firearms because of course they could use a number of weapons.
I would require there to be solid protections for the accused. There must be a higher level of proof that the accused is likely to commit an act of violence, that they be allowed counsel to defend themselves, and that they have a hearing within 48 hour of any revocation of rights.
I think a general system could be implemented where an individual who has reason to believe another individual is dangerous can petition the courts. If sufficient evidence is found then the judge can sign an order to have the person taken in against their will for a mental health evaluation. A psychologist makes an assessment of the individual meanwhile a detective could be assigned to see what evidence can be found to substantiate an allegation that the individual is likely or planning on doing something bad. In 48 hours if the police and the psychologist are unable to find sufficient evidence then the accused gets released and has all his/her rights fully restored. And no reapplication to get his/her own firearms back. However if there is sufficient evidence to believe the person is guilty then another hearing would be held within a reasonable time to determine how long the person should be confined to a mental health institution.
That is the basis I currently have in mind. Might need a few tweaks here and there but I think it a solid basis that recognizes that there needs to be a process to address a dangerous individual quickly but also needs to be ample protections for the accused.
-
Show me the proof of that "fact".
How many are turned in BEFORE they do or say something violent? How many probable crimes were stopped by reporting?
Assuming that happens "all the time", then there's really no need for a new red flag law. Current laws should be adequate.
Talking out of your ass again.
You think every time cops take someone in for an "MH-1" mental health evaluation they just happen to be driving by and see the crazy person?
How many probable crimes were stopped by reporting? Thats a pretty difficult question to answer and I think you know that. Thats like asking how many Einsteins were killed by abortion, you really can't get a solid answer on such a thing. Now there are incidents where it was likely that serious crimes were stopped by reporting. Take the individual in Waikiki who had a hotel room overlooking a major intersection and had a half a dozen firearms in the room. No one can say for sure what exactly he was going to do so ti is impossible to 100% say a crime was stopped.
https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/38173826/police-find-large-weapons-cache-in-waikiki-raid-prompted-by-disturbing-online-posts/
Where is your proof that no one ever reports family members? Maybe I missed it but I didn't see any rules on this forum that Flapp gets to require proof from everyone else but is exempt from doing it for himself. Sorry but I don't speak assanese.
Your objections basically illustrate that you have no solution. No one can ever be taken in until they commit a crime period. We will catch them after they kill 25 kids at a school or ram a car into a crowd. News flash, that isn't a solution to the problem. A lot of people complained why the flight instructor never told law enforcement that one of his students wanted to learn to take off and disable auto pilot but didn't want to learn to land a plane. After all the terrorist hadn't crashed a plane into any buildings yet and the pilot wasn't a psychologist or expert in mental illness or crime.
-
You think every time cops take someone in for an "MH-1" mental health evaluation they just happen to be driving by and see the crazy person?
How many probable crimes were stopped by reporting? Thats a pretty difficult question to answer and I think you know that. Thats like asking how many Einsteins were killed by abortion, you really can't get a solid answer on such a thing. Now there are incidents where it was likely that serious crimes were stopped by reporting. Take the individual in Waikiki who had a hotel room overlooking a major intersection and had a half a dozen firearms in the room. No one can say for sure what exactly he was going to do so ti is impossible to 100% say a crime was stopped.
https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/38173826/police-find-large-weapons-cache-in-waikiki-raid-prompted-by-disturbing-online-posts/
Where is your proof that no one ever reports family members? Maybe I missed it but I didn't see any rules on this forum that Flapp gets to require proof from everyone else but is exempt from doing it for himself. Sorry but I don't speak assanese.
Your objections basically illustrate that you have no solution. No one can ever be taken in until they commit a crime period. We will catch them after they kill 25 kids at a school or ram a car into a crowd. News flash, that isn't a solution to the problem. A lot of people complained why the flight instructor never told law enforcement that one of his students wanted to learn to take off and disable auto pilot but didn't want to learn to land a plane. After all the terrorist hadn't crashed a plane into any buildings yet and the pilot wasn't a psychologist or expert in mental illness or crime.
No. I think people are reported AFTER THEY PRESENT THEMSELVES AS A THREAT. Nobody reports someone as "mentally ill". They report them as a threat to themselves or others.
There are lots of mentally ill people living at home, taking care of themselves, and causing no one harm. It "happens all the time". :rofl:
-
"mentally ill" is a very vague term. Like Flap mentioned, many are ill and non-violent.
So in the end, we know who would enforce unjust laws because they were given "orders" to.
-
No. I think people are reported AFTER THEY PRESENT THEMSELVES AS A THREAT. Nobody reports someone as "mentally ill". They report them as a threat to themselves or others.
There are lots of mentally ill people living at home, taking care of themselves, and causing no one harm. It "happens all the time". :rofl:
I was clearly talking about someone who is mentally ill in a way that is dangerous, not just reporting anyone who might show signs of ADD or something like that.
I have already illustrated to you how the current process police have can easily fail to address when there is someone who is mentally ill and is currently a threat.
-
"mentally ill" is a very vague term. Like Flap mentioned, many are ill and non-violent.
So in the end, we know who would enforce unjust laws because they were given "orders" to.
This is true, but nowhere did I suggest this was a solution for just anyone who shows just some sign of a mental illness. My cousin washes his hands 5 times is not something to get someone's guns taken away or their freedom for that matter.
What are your thoughts on the system I mentioned to Red a few posts above?
-
I was clearly talking about someone who is mentally ill in a way that is dangerous, not just reporting anyone who might show signs of ADD or something like that.
I have already illustrated to you how the current process police have can easily fail to address when there is someone who is mentally ill and is currently a threat.
And you've yet to illustrate how red flag laws will do anything other than continue to fail to address when there is someone who is mentally ill and is currently a threat. We've had several shootings by people who were identified as risks, and the police did nothing by way of stopping them. If the person passes the evaluation, there's nothing they can do Under the red flag scenario, they'd get their guns back. Nothing changes.
-
And you've yet to illustrate how red flag laws will do anything other than continue to fail to address when there is someone who is mentally ill and is currently a threat. We've had several shootings by people who were identified as risks, and the police did nothing by way of stopping them. If the person passes the evaluation, there's nothing they can do Under the red flag scenario, they'd get their guns back. Nothing changes.
I have laid out a number of situations that a red flag law could address.
Yes, you are right that if a person passes the evaluation there is nothing law enforcement or the courts can do but the key part you continue to miss (or ignore?) is that there is inadequate resources to force a person to get such an evaluation. Police only have a certain narrow window to work within in order to force a person to get an evaluation and people can fairly easily slip through.
-
I have laid out a number of situations that a red flag law could address.
Yes, you are right that if a person passes the evaluation there is nothing law enforcement or the courts can do but the key part you continue to miss (or ignore?) is that there is inadequate resources to force a person to get such an evaluation. Police only have a certain narrow window to work within in order to force a person to get an evaluation and people can fairly easily slip through.
I remember when a guy was arrested for being in his underwear at Ross with a knife waving. He was found to be mentally fit by the state mental health person. He killed someone the next day. He didn't use a gun.
-
I remember when a guy was arrested for being in his underwear at Ross with a knife waving. He was found to be mentally fit by the state mental health person. He killed someone the next day. He didn't use a gun.
Indeed. Now either the doctor who evaluated him didn't do his job or there just wasn't enough information to predict future behavior.
-
Indeed. Now either the doctor who evaluated him didn't do his job or there just wasn't enough information to predict future behavior.
maybe the doc should get a crystal ball? hire a psychic? We are just as accurate predicting the weather as we are predicting our own behavior.
-
Indeed. Now either the doctor who evaluated him didn't do his job or there just wasn't enough information to predict future behavior.
I'm leaning toward didn't do her job. Because a guy in his underwear waving a knife in a retail store is not something a sane person would do. It's not like there was video of it...oh wait, there is.
-
I'm leaning toward didn't do her job. Because a guy in his underwear waving a knife in a retail store is not something a sane person would do. It's not like there was video of it...oh wait, there is.
Medical professionals admit there is NO METHOD known to science that can predict who among us will commit an act of violence and who will not.
That's a fact.
It's so easy to say "She didn't do her job". What if he hadn't stabbed someone? Would you then say she did her job?
We can't hold healthcare workers to an outcome-based standard. Human behavior is not as predictable as the marketing people like to have us believe. Marketing firms try to influence behavior through product placement in stores, coupons, sales, media ad campaigns, free samples in stores, etc. That's not predicting. That's influencing.
Healthcare workers don't influence a sick person's decisions. Most likely a truly sick person can't be convinced to abandon violent intentions. The thought processes are not normal, so normal methods of persuasion have less chance of succeeding.
One big problem with the gun control debate is caused by the very belief you stated -- that the healthcare worker can stop violence if they do their job right. Reality tells us you can't predict or stop a violent act especially if the perp is mentally defective. Gun control is not about controlling guns. It's about controlling people. Since behavior can not be controlled -- only punished after the fact -- your expectations are set way too high.
1- Healthcare professionals are not held legally liable if they set a dangerous person free and that person hurts or kills someone
2- Mental health doctors don't lock every person up that presents with a mental illness to err on the side of caution.
Those facts prove that even legislators and doctors understand nobody can be held accountable for failing to predict another's behavior. The only way to stop people with a diagnosis of mental illness from committing violence is to lock them all up until their symptoms are controlled. That's not only not going to happen (human rights), but it would prove the real crazy people we should fear are under the radar and can't be controlled no matter what the system tries.
It's a massive, complex problem. That's the way most human behavior problems are.
-
I agree if it's some normal looking person. But when you have a dude in his underwear waving a knife around in a retail store, that screams something isn't right. Vid shows that it wasn't self defense.
Now this differs from some dude wearing clothes and claiming self defense is the reason why he took his knife out.
Same goes with that lady walking naked in Hawaii Kai. Either #1 she was attacked sexually or #2 she's not all there, or #3 her clothes were on fire.
-
I agree if it's some normal looking person. But when you have a dude in his underwear waving a knife around in a retail store, that screams something isn't right. Vid shows that it wasn't self defense.
Now this differs from some dude wearing clothes and claiming self defense is the reason why he took his knife out.
Same goes with that lady walking naked in Hawaii Kai. Either #1 she was attacked sexually or #2 she's not all there, or #3 her clothes were on fire.
Theoretically, each of your examples could have been a diabetic episode. Many diabetics are "out of their head" when their blood sugar bottoms out or spikes. Unbalanced blood sugar levels can result in severe stress, anger, or confusion.
You make many assumptions. And who decides what is "normal looking?" Can't judge a book by its cover.
-
Theoretically, each of your examples could have been a diabetic episode. Many diabetics are "out of their head" when their blood sugar bottoms out or spikes. Unbalanced blood sugar levels can result in severe stress, anger, or confusion.
You make many assumptions. And who decides what is "normal looking?" Can't judge a book by its cover.
Or on Flakka. Heard many go naked because it raises their temps and they get hot.
-
Same goes with that lady walking naked in Hawaii Kai. Either #1 she was attacked sexually or #2 she's not all there, or #3 her clothes were on fire.
Was she hot?
-
Was she hot?
No, she had a shaved head.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
nvm. wrong thread.
-
So conservstive journalist attacked in portland by antifa. Andy Ngo had to go to the hospital later. He had liquids thrown at him and his gopro stolen.
Where was Portland PD? They were given orders by the mayor to stand down.
So again, PD just following orders.
They followed orders in a different way. No orders given to do stuff (nazis killing jews), but given orders to not to act (stand down). This isnt the 1st time PD given orders to stand down for antifa.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
So conservstive journalist attacked in portland by antifa. Andy Ngo had to go to the hospital later. He had liquids thrown at him and his gopro stolen.
Where was Portland PD? They were given orders by the mayor to stand down.
So again, PD just following orders.
They followed orders in a different way. No orders given to do stuff (nazis killing jews), but given orders to not to act (stand down). This isnt the 1st time PD given orders to stand down for antifa.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
any of you think that the same could happen here?
these antifa perps are so tough...behind masks....watched the video of him being attacked...if he was a CCW holder any of those acts against him would illicit a legal armed response? I thought I saw a rock thrown at him.
-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8WzMZxT-41k
-
I can't find the vid from a few years ago (google censorship is strong) where a man was holding a Trump sign and attacked feet away from Portland PD. Again given orders to stand down. He even begs them, "Why are you not doing anything" to them.
But it's ok, because everyone is just following orders.
-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eqWMaqBTERA
Same Portland antifa attacks.
Man using tire iron was ID'd by conservative social media pages. Not sure if he has been arrested yet.
-
I can see that kind of antifa cowardly attacks here. They have the State on their side as we law-abiding citizens have no CCW or any other self defense rights in that manner. Wearing masks and attacking people because of their views and voices sounds more like the Gestapo than Antifa BS.
I bet they wouldn't attack a black conservative, but an Asian conservative :thumbsup:
-
Nah too many mokes here (completely apolitical ) who wouldnt miss a chance to bussup sum fakas, Pantifa wouldn't dare start sh!t like that in HI
-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mBR0ZusJmmg&has_verified=1
They tried to mess with a Samoan 10:07, watch until the most epic KO.
Antifa got plans to disrupt free speech rally next month also.
-
maybe the doc should get a crystal ball? hire a psychic? We are just as accurate predicting the weather as we are predicting our own behavior.
Or maybe just follow established methods within the medical community or predicting violent behavior.
-
I'm leaning toward didn't do her job. Because a guy in his underwear waving a knife in a retail store is not something a sane person would do. It's not like there was video of it...oh wait, there is.
Those are serious red flags however it really is hard to weigh in without knowing more about what the doctor found during their evaluation.
I know a girl who tried to jump off a balcony but was tackled and taken into a hospital. She was released a few days later and successfully jumped. Same thing, you wonder if they did their job correct but who knows
-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mBR0ZusJmmg&has_verified=1
They tried to mess with a Samoan 10:07, watch until the most epic KO.
Antifa got plans to disrupt free speech rally next month also.
CHee-HUU!!!
-
Don't think it's been brought up here in 8 pages, but these are the conditions NRA considered.
— Criminal penalties for those who bring “false or frivolous” charges.
— A determination by a judge, by “clear and convincing evidence,” that the person poses a significant risk of danger.
— A requirement that a judge determine whether the person meets the standard for involuntary commitment.
— If the order is granted, the individual should receive community-based mental health treatment.
-
Hawaii's red flag is similar, but to prove a false statement will be difficult. If it will be anything like custody battles and TRO's filed, then it's he said she said and guns will be confiscated.
Will a Hawaii judge determine that there is clear evidence? Refer to the above and all the TRO/RO's issued to gain leverage for custody batttles. Or will it be similar judges who did the travel ban? See where this is going?
Good thing the definitions didn't add "chicks you boned" (not a SO or dated). Or I might be up shit creek.
-
simply said....
4th amendment violation.
-
I was watching a movie last night called "The Accountant of Auschwitz". It's about a Nazi who's 96 and was the accountant for that death camp. He did not kill anyone. His claims were he was doing his job and at the time, it was legal. Morally, he stated he was wrong. Of the 800K Nazis there were at the end of the war, only 6700 were tried in a court for crimes against humanity. And of those 6700, only 143 were convicted. So over a million Jews were executed and only 143 were convicted. And many only got 3-5 year sentences and a bunch were released early. The argument that the prosecution made was even though the accountant never pulled the trigger, he was part of the machine that allowed the genocide because he was a Nazi and in Auschwitz.
So again this comes down to the fact that multiple Sheriff departments across the nation recognize that the red flag law is unconstitutional and they are not willing to enforce it. But HPD probably will. I add in probably, because no one yet has had their guns confiscated, but HPD has not released a statement like the Sheriffs have saying that they won't enforce. But how many will follow orders because it's legal (written as law).
-
But how many will follow orders because it's legal (written as law).
Here in Hawaii? 100%.
-
Surprise surprise. NRA press release on recent shootings. Suggest red flag or more laws.
Compared to GOA who wants HR38 (national reciprocity) passed instead.
Oh the diff between GOA and the NRA.
-
Here is an active shooter who was prevented by a family member who saw something and took action.
Now in this case he wasn't reported through a red flag type law because the grandma was able to gain compliance however had the guy refused her suggestion she would have had to resort to something akin to a red-flag type law to intervene.
https://www.policeone.com/investigations/articles/484614006-Police-Grandmother-thwarted-mass-shooting/?fbclid=IwAR3riZDaykTMpRy5edS5g6JZ_0EjKap-TsZbHjBlUuPi0NeVglpKY7h_URo
-
Here is an active shooter who was prevented by a family member who saw something and took action.
Now in this case he wasn't reported through a red flag type law because the grandma was able to gain compliance however had the guy refused her suggestion she would have had to resort to something akin to a red-flag type law to intervene.
https://www.policeone.com/investigations/articles/484614006-Police-Grandmother-thwarted-mass-shooting/?fbclid=IwAR3riZDaykTMpRy5edS5g6JZ_0EjKap-TsZbHjBlUuPi0NeVglpKY7h_URo
He was charged with lying about something when buying the gun. That's a crime. Vs. someones angry ex who wants custody and claims he threatened to harm her.
So PD shows up at his hotel due to tip from grandma. He is not under arrest yet, nor did they confiscate any of his property. Due to tip, they run his name and find out he cannot possess any firearms/lied. At that moment, they see firearms in his room and confiscate. News doesn't say where he lied and what info he lied about, so the above is all speculation by myself. Did he lie to officers while they were interviewing him, or on 4473 form? Also did he admit to officers what he told his grandma?
So red flag doesn't come into play in this situation. Had he purchased everything legally, and didn't admit to anything once PD showed up, then they could do nothing.
-
Interesting social media post happening on red flag law for gun pages.
"The same people who report your post will be the same ones calling the tip line on you"
-
Interesting social media post happening on red flag law for gun pages.
"The same people who report your post will be the same ones calling the tip line on you"
Lots of people will refuse to report potentially dangerous people to authorities unless they have the assurance of anonymity.
Anonymity breeds abuse of the system.
Not really a solution. More of a "small piece of the puzzle" that might be better than doing nothing.
As I said many times here, red flag laws are UNNECESSARY, since most things people would report are already reportable. What changes with red flag laws is the law enforcement and punishment functions being initiated without due process-- i.e. the judicial process that protects individual liberties and rights.
-
There are some cases where red flag laws may work that existing laws won't. A fired worker that's extremely disgruntled tells their wife they're going to kill everyone at work next week and shows her the rifle he just bought. Existing laws won't cover it since he's not making a threat to the actual person and there's no conspiracy.
The employer could hire armed security or employees have CCW but those are reducing the threat, not eliminating it. Of course he could just firebomb the building if his guns are taken away. That's why we need to institutionalize them and fully fund mental health treatment.
The NRA plan does have its merits on narrowly focusing it, strong due process, punishments for abuse, and mental health treatment which addresses a lot of our fears and prevent Innocent gun owners from being affected. Though I highly doubt abusers of the law would be prosecuted. It may be a good time to tie CCW into it.
-
He was charged with lying about something when buying the gun. That's a crime. Vs. someones angry ex who wants custody and claims he threatened to harm her.
So PD shows up at his hotel due to tip from grandma. He is not under arrest yet, nor did they confiscate any of his property. Due to tip, they run his name and find out he cannot possess any firearms/lied. At that moment, they see firearms in his room and confiscate. News doesn't say where he lied and what info he lied about, so the above is all speculation by myself. Did he lie to officers while they were interviewing him, or on 4473 form? Also did he admit to officers what he told his grandma?
So red flag doesn't come into play in this situation. Had he purchased everything legally, and didn't admit to anything once PD showed up, then they could do nothing.
The charge was "inaccurate address information" on the 4473. I wonder if grandma thought the grandson was going to jail for 5 years when she talked to the cops? My understanding was the grandson went to a medical facility seeking help and then the cops searched his hotel room.
-
He was charged with lying about something when buying the gun. That's a crime. Vs. someones angry ex who wants custody and claims he threatened to harm her.
So PD shows up at his hotel due to tip from grandma. He is not under arrest yet, nor did they confiscate any of his property. Due to tip, they run his name and find out he cannot possess any firearms/lied. At that moment, they see firearms in his room and confiscate. News doesn't say where he lied and what info he lied about, so the above is all speculation by myself. Did he lie to officers while they were interviewing him, or on 4473 form? Also did he admit to officers what he told his grandma?
So red flag doesn't come into play in this situation. Had he purchased everything legally, and didn't admit to anything once PD showed up, then they could do nothing.
Yes, he was charged with lying on the federal form, he put an old address on the form. He listed an address of an uncle he used to live with but had moved out. He committed a crime and got caught but that is not what prevented the shooting. The ATF only found out the violation after they began investigating based on what the grandmother told them.
His grandma convinced him to let her take him to the hospital to get help, she is the one who intervened. Now in this case a red flag law, if there was one, didn't come into play because he was compliant and he accepted help. But what if he had refused the grandmother's suggestion to go to the hospital? A red flag law could allow the grandmother to go to court and report her observations to the authorities and get the help needed. Without a red flag law there isn't much cops could do and the shooting would have likely happened. If he was not compliant that is where a red flag law comes into play.
-
There are some cases where red flag laws may work that existing laws won't. A fired worker that's extremely disgruntled tells their wife they're going to kill everyone at work next week and shows her the rifle he just bought. Existing laws won't cover it since he's not making a threat to the actual person and there's no conspiracy.
The employer could hire armed security or employees have CCW but those are reducing the threat, not eliminating it. Of course he could just firebomb the building if his guns are taken away. That's why we need to institutionalize them and fully fund mental health treatment.
The NRA plan does have its merits on narrowly focusing it, strong due process, punishments for abuse, and mental health treatment which addresses a lot of our fears and prevent Innocent gun owners from being affected. Though I highly doubt abusers of the law would be prosecuted. It may be a good time to tie CCW into it.
A good example though a threat told to a third party can still be prosecuted in some situations. However there are still serious gaps in existing law, times when there are serious red flags but with no real way of getting the appropriate authorities involved. A red flag type law is a tool whereby a person exhibiting all these "red flags" can't slip through the cracks as easily. Cops have no way of forcing an individual to get a mental health evaluation unless they are exhibiting signs of danger at the time they come across the individual.
I think the NRA and other gun rights situations need to participate in red flag laws so that they can ensure due process is protected. They can sit out and resist but the laws are getting passed anyway so better to join and ensure protections exist in the red flag laws. And as you point out maybe we can get CCW in there too.
One thing I think needs to be included is that if there is enough cause to take away the person's guns then we need to be actually confining them for evaluation. If there are enough red flags to suggest the person isn't safe to have guns then they aren't safe enough to be out walking around either.
Abusers could be prosecuted however prosecution would be difficult due to the nature of the allegations being made. To prosecute someone for abusing the system with false reports the prosecutor would have to be able to prove that the person knowingly gave false information to authorities. This is true for any type of false reporting prosecution.
-
Ben Shapiro's take on the Red Flag bill
https://youtu.be/dmqgXvlLVB4?t=1995
-
I posted this in the general thread but its relevant to here so I am reporting it.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/a-yellow-light-for-red-flag-laws-11565132144
-
Good points on how the media fuels hate and violence. I don't advocate for restricting 1A rights rather I'd want society to push for voluntary compliance.
I don't think red flag laws are the solution, but rather a band aid to deflect blame on media and society.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=K3VQULyT390
-
Ben Shapiro's take on the Red Flag bill
https://youtu.be/dmqgXvlLVB4?t=1995
So all we gotta do is trust everyone we know so they don't make a false report. Like how ex gf's/wives never file false TRO's to gain leverage during a custody battle.
Oh let's also not forget that guy in WA. He was inside his home with a pistol on his hip. Through his own window, he looked at his neighbors in a weird way. PD came to his home to confiscate his guns. IIRC, a gun battle happened and he was killed.
-
So all we gotta do is trust everyone we know so they don't make a false report. Like how ex gf's/wives never file false TRO's to gain leverage during a custody battle.
Oh let's also not forget that guy in WA. He was inside his home with a pistol on his hip. Through his own window, he looked at his neighbors in a weird way. PD came to his home to confiscate his guns. IIRC, a gun battle happened and he was killed.
The upcoming Congressional report on "mass public shootings" and "red flag laws" will show that one "commonality" sufficient to enact a "red flag confiscation" will be "looking at people in a weird way".
-
https://youtu.be/b6RHMuerhis
-
Our bigger problem now it seems is that the GOP and Trump are on the Red Flag bandwagon. It won't matter how much of our voice is out there if these asshats decide to vote "their conscience". Which is code for my wallet got fatter and we don't want you little people to have the ability to rise against us elite power players.
If you read Trumps statement on El Paso and Dayton, he is signaling that he would sign a Nationwaide Red Flag bill under some innocuous acronymic naming convention. And with people like Dan Crenshaw saying we need one, it may be on its way. I don't see a ban on firearms as that will just overturn the apple cart, but "we can live with protecting people". The slippery slope is where does it start and end. No defined methods or time frames on the ERPOs. No due process. It starts small and becomes a giant mess.
-
Lets also not forget that depending on which judge a complainant sees is how it will affect whether to confiscate or not. How many judges in liberal states made a ruling on something Trump did, only to be overturned later.
How many judges will rule in favor of confiscation because they're overzealous or don't want to be blamed later if something does happen? But same judges give out lenient sentences to repeat criminals. Red flag is nothing more than trying to control the people.
-
Yay! Who's in?
(https://i.imgur.com/6hURk3K.jpg)
HI- Oahu August Recess Rally
Hawaii State Capitol
415 S Beretania St
Honolulu, HI 96813
7.3 mi away
When: Saturday, August 17, 11:00 AM
Join Moms Demand Action in Hawaii for our August Recess Rally to call upon our US Senate to bring universal background checks and red flags law up for a vote in the Senate. More details to come soon but please RSVP to stay updated. Everyone is encouraged to wear red and bring their homemade signs!
-
Yay! Who's in?
(https://i.imgur.com/6hURk3K.jpg)
HI- Oahu August Recess Rally
Hawaii State Capitol
415 S Beretania St
Honolulu, HI 96813
7.3 mi away
When: Saturday, August 17, 11:00 AM
Join Moms Demand Action in Hawaii for our August Recess Rally to call upon our US Senate to bring universal background checks and red flags law up for a vote in the Senate. More details to come soon but please RSVP to stay updated. Everyone is encouraged to wear red and bring their homemade signs!
I think I am free next saturday. Hit me up and I will go with you if I can.
-
Isnt all those already passed here?
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
Read "john edward carpenter" story from FL.
Basically guys ccw permit was cancelled. He went to PD and asked why, because his gf said he was a drug dealer and sold her furniture without permission. Wrong john edward carpenter.
Cops looked up the name in their ccw database and found him. He asked, what are the odds a drug dealer will apply for a ccw permit and obey gun lawd? PD said not likely, but miatakes happen. And better to be safe.
This is how red flag will work. He has to go to court later to get his 2a right back.
How many John Abe, John Takahashi, John Lee, John Smith, John Young are there? And without a court date 1st, it wont be obvious they got the right person.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
Another victim of "Red Flag" stupidity.
(Paraphrased below. Full article at link)
LOVELAND SCHOOL SUSPENDS TEEN OVER FAMILY GUN OUTING; PICS ON SOCIAL MEDIA
https://pagetwo.completecolorado.com/2019/08/28/loveland-school-suspends-teen-over-family-gun-outing-pics-on-social-media/
Loveland — A 16-year-old Loveland High School junior has been told not to come back to class until the school can conduct a full investigation into an anonymous tip to “Safe-2-Tell” of a “threatening” Snapchat by the student.
Complete Colorado sent Weld County Sheriff Steve Reams the Snapchat with no context to what was happening and asked him how he would interpret the post, he said it appeared to him someone got a new gun and was excited to go shoot it.
When told of the outcome, Reams could not believe one person’s fears were causing such a shakeup for another. He said this is the perfect example of the damage the Red Flag Law could do.
“People base their apprehension on their own paradigm and their own fear of guns and gun culture,” Reams said. “One kid is totally excited to go out and train on how to use a gun responsibly, while another kid is totally freaked out about seeing a gun.”
-
I was doing some research for my email to my state representative and I found a SCOTUS case that may work against part of the wording in out red flag law. Our law sets a standard of proof of "preponderance of the evidence". Under the SCOTUS case Addington V. Texas in 1978 the court did uphold sending someone to a mental hospital based on another level of proof called "clear and convincing evidence". While not exactly the same that case could still be used to argue that the current red flag law does not offer adequate level of protections for the accused.
It may take a while but sooner or later there will be a case test case that will be appealed and that will be interesting to follow.
-
I was doing some research for my email to my state representative and I found a SCOTUS case that may work against part of the wording in out red flag law. Our law sets a standard of proof of "preponderance of the evidence". Under the SCOTUS case Addington V. Texas in 1978 the court did uphold sending someone to a mental hospital based on another level of proof called "clear and convincing evidence". While not exactly the same that case could still be used to argue that the current red flag law does not offer adequate level of protections for the accused.
It may take a while but sooner or later there will be a case test case that will be appealed and that will be interesting to follow.
Appreciate your effort. But our law makers could care less about precident. The shitty part is who ever is the 1st test case, even if they win will have to take 1 for the team. And other states have passed this law and so far none have reppealed it. NJ enacts at least 1 red flag a day since they passed it. I dont recall when they had an active shooting that red flag laws are based on.
We have already seen the overreach of red flag laws recently with that Marine who was arrested when he said he would defend himself from antifa if they attack him. FBI steppen in prob cause the sheriff said they wont enforce.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
I don't think the NRA is our friend anymore. They got infected with the virus.
-
Another victim of "Red Flag" stupidity.
(Paraphrased below. Full article at link)
LOVELAND SCHOOL SUSPENDS TEEN OVER FAMILY GUN OUTING; PICS ON SOCIAL MEDIA
I recall reading reports of IG taking down pics of people at gun ranges, so to avoid encouraging violence (or something like that). :facepalm:
Well, right about that time, I went to KHSC rifle range and my buddy posted a bunch of pics. I guess either was misinformation or it wasn't clear from the pics that KHSC was a rifle range. . . :P
-
Appreciate your effort. But our law makers could care less about precident. The shitty part is who ever is the 1st test case, even if they win will have to take 1 for the team. And other states have passed this law and so far none have reppealed it. NJ enacts at least 1 red flag a day since they passed it. I dont recall when they had an active shooting that red flag laws are based on.
We have already seen the overreach of red flag laws recently with that Marine who was arrested when he said he would defend himself from antifa if they attack him. FBI steppen in prob cause the sheriff said they wont enforce.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
Not all states are going to have identical laws so the SCOTUS case I referred to may not be relevant in some other states. If the other states have a higher standard of proof then their laws offer more protections than ours.
Yes it does suck to be the test case but that is how the system works, the courts are the last checks against government abuse or unconstitutional action. .
I read about the guy who had his guns taken away because of his comments about attacking ANTIFA and if we are talking about the same one there is a bit more to the story. He didn't simply say he would defend himself against ANTIFA with a gun, he had a plan to go out and basically murder them. He even went on a radio show and talked about his plan. In that instance his comments were really wandering into criminal territory.
-
I recall reading reports of IG taking down pics of people at gun ranges, so to avoid encouraging violence (or something like that). :facepalm:
Well, right about that time, I went to KHSC rifle range and my buddy posted a bunch of pics. I guess either was misinformation or it wasn't clear from the pics that KHSC was a rifle range. . . :P
Gonna take my daughter to the gun range this weekend and I was thinking about what I could send her to school with (4th grade) that she could take for show and tell. I figure a bullet casing is too sketchy, but what about a shot up paper target? I could just take a picture of her shooting and print it out for her to share...
Heck, maybe I will be the first red flag test case lol
-
Abuse of power, swatting, meme police, some of the things that will get people hurt or killed because of "red flag laws"
https://www.ammoland.com/2019/09/democrat-send-police-in-tactical-gear-to-mans-house-over-a-meme/#axzz60TuWtSmT
-
Not all states are going to have identical laws so the SCOTUS case I referred to may not be relevant in some other states. If the other states have a higher standard of proof then their laws offer more protections than ours.
Yes it does suck to be the test case but that is how the system works, the courts are the last checks against government abuse or unconstitutional action. .
I read about the guy who had his guns taken away because of his comments about attacking ANTIFA and if we are talking about the same one there is a bit more to the story. He didn't simply say he would defend himself against ANTIFA with a gun, he had a plan to go out and basically murder them. He even went on a radio show and talked about his plan. In that instance his comments were really wandering into criminal territory.
Prob diff cause this guy is a marine and said if antifa attacks him, he will slaughter them. So his ROE is fight back after being attacked.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
Abuse of power, swatting, meme police, some of the things that will get people hurt or killed because of "red flag laws"
https://www.ammoland.com/2019/09/democrat-send-police-in-tactical-gear-to-mans-house-over-a-meme/#axzz60TuWtSmT
In all fairness, that has happened and will continue to happen with or without red glass laws.
-
Prob diff cause this guy is a marine and said if antifa attacks him, he will slaughter them. So his ROE is fight back after being attacked.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
IIRC part of his plan was find where they lived and kill them at home.
-
IIRC part of his plan was find where they lived and kill them at home.
That is called 4th Generation Warfare.
My favorite quote is " to everyone you meet be polite, be professional, and
develop a plan to kill them", Mattis
I'm not a Marine General, but I've gone through my adult life that way.
Do you want to lock me up?
Full disclosure; To my knowledge I haven't killed anybody.
-
That is called 4th Generation Warfare.
My favorite quote is " to everyone you meet be polite, be professional, and
develop a plan to kill them", Mattis
I'm not a Marine General, but I've gone through my adult life that way.
Do you want to lock me up?
Full disclosure; To my knowledge I haven't killed anybody.
That is a bit of a stretch to compare.
-
I admit that all these new laws being passed around is killing my motivation to stay in the sport of shooting and exercising my right. Red flag, yellow flag laws what ever they come up with. I'm about to throw in the white flag. I've given lots of money to NRA - Life Member. Donated to local causes. Was an HRA member for a few years. :(
Feels like I've been pulled over in my car with an officer yelling at me for stealing my own car. Hands up! I give up! I stole my own car! :crazy:
-
I admit that all these new laws being passed around is killing my motivation to stay in the sport of shooting and exercising my right. Red flag, yellow flag laws what ever they come up with. I'm about to throw in the white flag. I've given lots of money to NRA - Life Member. Donated to local causes. Was an HRA member for a few years. :(
Feels like I've been pulled over in my car with an officer yelling at me for stealing my own car. Hands up! I give up! I stole my own car! :crazy:
Don't quit. That's what they want. They want to beat us down so we all roll over and they win. Yes it is completely demotivating and gets more expensive every day, but what price will our kids or grandkids pay for our apathy or willingness to quit?
-
Don't quit. That's what they want. They want to beat us down so we all roll over and they win. Yes it is completely demotivating and gets more expensive every day, but what price will our kids or grandkids pay for our apathy or willingness to quit?
^^^DITTO
Imagine if everyone fought harder for registration, mag limits, and OC/CCW 20 years ago. Even if lawsuits were presented, then by about now would there be a decision. Like how long ago Young vs. Hawaii began and only now did it get a hearing.
-
https://www.wnd.com/2019/10/elderly-vets-guns-confiscated-voices-concern-potential-school-shooting/?fbclid=IwAR0LKtByWMo7OmRNOwfnTELqAf4lWjFE9O2l0dbwhszG_-yf3GTvy54Yh1k (https://www.wnd.com/2019/10/elderly-vets-guns-confiscated-voices-concern-potential-school-shooting/?fbclid=IwAR0LKtByWMo7OmRNOwfnTELqAf4lWjFE9O2l0dbwhszG_-yf3GTvy54Yh1k)
(http://www.usrifleteams.com/forums/uploads/monthly_2019_09/commie.jpg.63a74db76277a530d9ea8811227b1012.jpg)
-
https://www.wnd.com/2019/10/elderly-vets-guns-confiscated-voices-concern-potential-school-shooting/?fbclid=IwAR0LKtByWMo7OmRNOwfnTELqAf4lWjFE9O2l0dbwhszG_-yf3GTvy54Yh1k (https://www.wnd.com/2019/10/elderly-vets-guns-confiscated-voices-concern-potential-school-shooting/?fbclid=IwAR0LKtByWMo7OmRNOwfnTELqAf4lWjFE9O2l0dbwhszG_-yf3GTvy54Yh1k)
(http://www.usrifleteams.com/forums/uploads/monthly_2019_09/commie.jpg.63a74db76277a530d9ea8811227b1012.jpg)
I hope this thing Primaries Crazy Mazie.
I'm sure it would win!
-
That's an impressive display of aposematism.
-
Currently developing, getting all my details via Instagram.
-
Noirs next post said police dont think he has a gun. So just a kit.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
https://texasguntalk.com/threads/whisky-warrior-556-stand-off.94834/page-3 (https://texasguntalk.com/threads/whisky-warrior-556-stand-off.94834/page-3)
https://www.ar15.com/forums/General/BREAKING-NY-man-in-standoff-with-Police-over-30-round-mags/5-2274120/?page=39&anc=bottom#bottom (https://www.ar15.com/forums/General/BREAKING-NY-man-in-standoff-with-Police-over-30-round-mags/5-2274120/?page=39&anc=bottom#bottom)
-
So they are saying he just needed medical help for his PTSD. Nice to know that you need a APC and fully armed SWAT to "help" you. I think after our next legislative session we might all be getting "help" from those guys "just doing their job"
-
So they are saying he just needed medical help for his PTSD. Nice to know that you need a APC and fully armed SWAT to "help" you. I think after our next legislative session we might all be getting "help" from those guys "just doing their job"
I guess you are finally getting "woke"
-
So they are saying he just needed medical help for his PTSD. Nice to know that you need a APC and fully armed SWAT to "help" you. I think after our next legislative session we might all be getting "help" from those guys "just doing their job"
I was trying to follow that story, it appears the guy on Instagram posting everything may not have been very honest about why police were there. Still don't know what really went down but many people were all to ready to believe whatever he was saying on his instagram.
-
I was trying to follow that story, it appears the guy on Instagram posting everything may not have been very honest about why police were there. Still don't know what really went down but many people were all to ready to believe whatever he was saying on his instagram.
There are lots on different stories. I know FPC set up a gofundme, but has since then put it on hold until all the details are released. Below are the stories:
1) Cops showed up at his home and threatened his wife and child with CPS if she didn't cooperate with magazine investigation
2) He beat his wife so it's a domestic violence situation
3) No wife/child involved, but he had standard mags
4) He mentioned online to a guy he knows that he has PTSD. That guy called in the red flag
5) People who have scanners said psyops being used because voices on radio seemed like they were on a loop. Also his IG was hacked and said standoff over, even though it's still going on
6) Reports of people showing up and passing through OP and being arrested
-
What ever happened with this guy, I think he owes it to Instagram he wasn't gunned down.
-
What ever happened with this guy, I think he owes it to Instagram he wasn't gunned down.
Based on what? He wasn't armed with any firearms (he claimed), but had a knife. Did instagram convince him into giving up? Cops aren't going to show up and gun him down just because, his actions are what would determine their reactions.
-
Based on what? He wasn't armed with any firearms (he claimed), but had a knife. Did instagram convince him into giving up? Cops aren't going to show up and gun him down just because, his actions are what would determine their reactions.
Sure......
-
Based on what? He wasn't armed with any firearms (he claimed), but had a knife. Did instagram convince him into giving up? Cops aren't going to show up and gun him down just because, his actions are what would determine their reactions.
Ruby ridge just to name 1.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
Based on what? He wasn't armed with any firearms (he claimed), but had a knife. Did instagram convince him into giving up? Cops aren't going to show up and gun him down just because, his actions are what would determine their reactions.
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
I trust God 100%...police officers I respect but not the level of trust I have in God.
-
I think London needs red flag. They dont got the 4th anyways, so no matter.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
Based on what? He wasn't armed with any firearms (he claimed), but had a knife. Did instagram convince him into giving up? Cops aren't going to show up and gun him down just because, his actions are what would determine their reactions.
Close. The Cops' interpretation and judgment regarding his possible intent based on his actions under duress and panic (combined with the potential of PTSD as reported) combine to guarantee one thing:
The Cops will not be held accountable for any bad calls they make.
You can also count on the Cops wanting to go home safely more than they desire the soldier surviving the ordeal.
How many times have we heard, "The unarmed suspect was shot while reaching for his [ID, phone, *fill in the blank*]", or better yet, because the Cops said he LOOKED LIKE HE WAS REACHING for "something".
So, not "his actions", but "the perceived intent his actions mistakenly represented".
-
One thing good about the 21st century, when the shit hits the fan be sure to turn on all live streaming. The more eyes the better...
-
One thing good about the 21st century, when the shit hits the fan be sure to turn on all live streaming. The more eyes the better...
Sometimes ... no guarantee live streaming will prevent a bad decision. Shot 7 times while being streamed live on FB.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Philando_Castile
-
Sometimes ... no guarantee live streaming will prevent a bad decision. Shot 7 times while being streamed live on FB.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Philando_Castile
She streamed after he was shot.
Cop says dont reach for anything. Castro reaches for something and gets shot. Woman then has the time to access the camera on her phone and hold it up at the cop who just shot someone for reaching when told not to. Not smart on her part of pointing something at a cop who just fired his weapon.
But according to her, he was not reaching, but just sitting there. #BLM (sarcasm)
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
Sometimes ... no guarantee live streaming will prevent a bad decision. Shot 7 times while being streamed live on FB.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Philando_Castile
At least it's on record. People can make up their own minds, instead of fake news telling them what to believe.
-
At least it's on record. People can make up their own minds, instead of fake news telling them what to believe.
Reminiscent of The Running Man movie, when the resistance managed to take control of the communications satellite and broadcast the truth. The public believed their own eyes until they realized they'd been watching doctored footage.
I guess video editors are doctors, too. :geekdanc:
-
Ruby ridge just to name 1.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
It isn't hard to find some instance of course but I am speaking about the vast majority of interactions.
-
Close. The Cops' interpretation and judgment regarding his possible intent based on his actions under duress and panic (combined with the potential of PTSD as reported) combine to guarantee one thing:
The Cops will not be held accountable for any bad calls they make.
You can also count on the Cops wanting to go home safely more than they desire the soldier surviving the ordeal.
How many times have we heard, "The unarmed suspect was shot while reaching for his [ID, phone, *fill in the blank*]", or better yet, because the Cops said he LOOKED LIKE HE WAS REACHING for "something".
So, not "his actions", but "the perceived intent his actions mistakenly represented".
Most of what you said is quite accurate though cops are held accountable for bad calls they make. To what extent depends on the nature of the bad call and there is the distinction of whether the call was bad or just incorrect.
Generally speaking, most interactions where officers use force are started because of the actions of the person the officer is dealing with. Sometimes you get a cop having an anger control issue who really provokes things but most of the time cops force is reactionary to a threat, or as you point out, a perceived threat.