NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally" (Read 60267 times)

Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #60 on: April 30, 2019, 09:48:26 AM »
We live in a state where people sit through an entire green light rather than honk their horn at the person not paying attention. No make stink.

How many people do they believe will turn in someone to authorities if they aren't actually hurting anyone?
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #61 on: April 30, 2019, 09:57:49 AM »
We live in a state where people sit through an entire green light rather than honk their horn at the person not paying attention. No make stink.

How many people do they believe will turn in someone to authorities if they aren't actually hurting anyone?

I'm one of those, but not to "no make stink", but more like I don't know who's in front of me and want to escalate a situation.  I can spare a few seconds of my time.

Regarding your 2nd part, I believe the red flag law will be more used for revenge than for any possible good. 

Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #62 on: April 30, 2019, 10:53:17 AM »
I'm one of those, but not to "no make stink", but more like I don't know who's in front of me and want to escalate a situation.  I can spare a few seconds of my time.

Regarding your 2nd part, I believe the red flag law will be more used for revenge than for any possible good.

Exactly. The side-issue to "No make stink" includes "don't do anything that might cause retaliation -- by that person or their family."

Once the person being reported is in the system, it could cause many more problems than expected. Not only loss of firearms, but loss of time at work to see mental health evaluators, attending hearings, jumping through time-consuming hoops to retrieve firearms from HPD, cost of legal representation and the stigma attached to being identified as a public safety risk. He/she could easily lose their job over it.Their family and friends who never saw the "red flag" signs would start to wonder if this person can be trusted.

It's a big ask to expect family and friends to turn someone into authorities knowing the array of problems and implications attached. As you said, you'd have to really want to hurt someone to do that.

I was wondering if the red flag laws are just a stepping stone.
1st step is to legally allow confiscation based on an informant's report before due process.
2nd step may be to criminalize failure to report gun owners displaying "obvious" signs of violent behavior in order to force the public to inform on their family and friends.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

punaperson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #63 on: April 30, 2019, 11:21:19 AM »
"Negligent failure to red flag".

Cops/prosecutor: "Did you know he was  a danger to himself or others?"

Poor slob average guy: "No."

Cops/prosecutor: "Prove you didn't know."

And since it's impossible to "prove a negative", guess what happens to the poor slob average guy?

All of this gun control crap is incrememtalism ("a good first step" as "universal background checks" (criminalization of private property sales) are often referred to as) on the road (a highly-lubed sloping road) to total civilian disarmament, and anyone who claims otherwise is either ignorant, on their way to stupid, or a liar.

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #64 on: April 30, 2019, 01:03:38 PM »


I was wondering if the red flag laws are just a stepping stone.
1st step is to legally allow confiscation based on an informant's report before due process.
2nd step may be to criminalize failure to report gun owners displaying "obvious" signs of violent behavior in order to force the public to inform on their family and friends.

It really is a stepping stone.  Not only the example you gave, but the "well since we took their guns away with no due process, I guess we can also take them away just because". 

Or they will expand the law from family, spouse, doctor, and teacher, to anyone who feels threatened.  Like how wearing a MAGA hat makes liberals feel threatened.

rpoL98

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #65 on: April 30, 2019, 05:24:06 PM »
... or politicians who feel that guns in their districts represent a threat to the community and therefore should be confiscated, preemptively.  or even home-owners associations?

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #66 on: May 03, 2019, 09:26:45 PM »
"Negligent failure to red flag".

Cops/prosecutor: "Did you know he was  a danger to himself or others?"

Poor slob average guy: "No."

Cops/prosecutor: "Prove you didn't know."

And since it's impossible to "prove a negative", guess what happens to the poor slob average guy?

All of this gun control crap is incrememtalism ("a good first step" as "universal background checks" (criminalization of private property sales) are often referred to as) on the road (a highly-lubed sloping road) to total civilian disarmament, and anyone who claims otherwise is either ignorant, on their way to stupid, or a liar.

Except that is not how it works, prosecutors would have to show you knew. But is anyone actually suggesting that be a law?

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #67 on: May 03, 2019, 09:31:32 PM »

That's not what you said -- at least not in your question. You never said the relative was not seeing a medical professional.  You said I can't force them to seek help, but that doesn't mean they haven't done so without me or someone else "forcing" them to.  Legally and personally, it's not my right to know who they are seeing for medical issues.


I thought it was a given but fair enough, I didn't explicitly say it.

But I would still like your answer to this problem. And this isn't just a gun issue either, this would be an issue even if guns weren't involved.

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #68 on: May 03, 2019, 09:33:39 PM »
There are many with mental health issues that go un-diagnosed.  The world is not perfect. 

This is true, but should we endeavor to do better?

Quote
So all this law does is a way for HPD to take guns out away from it's citizens without their right to due process.  And I can bet that 100% of any HPD showing up at the door step will "just follow orders" and not step up like how other Sheriff departments have and say "no, I will not violate someones rights".

While I do have problems with the law, it isn't entirely without due process.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #69 on: May 03, 2019, 09:43:25 PM »
I thought it was a given but fair enough, I didn't explicitly say it.

But I would still like your answer to this problem. And this isn't just a gun issue either, this would be an issue even if guns weren't involved.

I don't see the problem. For retail sales, there's a background check. That should catch the fact he's deemed mentally incompetent.

If you know he went to a private gun seller, you have the right to report him to authorities no matter what relationship you are to him.

Red Flag laws merely put the punishment before the process. They will prevent nothing once the criminals learn how to avoid getting reported.

You, just like the gun grabbers, are looking for a solution without a problem.  There's no one-size-fits-all for controlling human behavior.

You should watch "The Village" and post a synopsis as well as discussion of the underlying premise/lessons learned.   :popcorn:
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #70 on: May 04, 2019, 09:42:11 AM »
This is true, but should we endeavor to do better?

While I do have problems with the law, it isn't entirely without due process.
Does the gun owner have a chance to defend themselves b4 their guns are taken away? The answer is no.

Like i used b4, see WA red flag example. Guy inside his home "looked at his neighbors funny", while having a gun on his hip.

What could help prevent mental problem people is not disarming the good guys, but let them be armed so active shootings may be stopped sooner. But instead gun free zones were created and ccw permits denied. Because we all know an active shooter will follow a $2 sign on the wall.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

groveler

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #71 on: May 04, 2019, 12:50:13 PM »
While I do have problems with the law, it isn't entirely without due process.
[/quote]

You sound like a common Hawaii politician.  You totally disregard that by the time it gets
through the courts, the subjects of the original abuse are dead or gone
on to another life, since you have destroyed their present life path.
That is NOT justice, that is using the system to punish the fools that
obey the law, disagree with you, or you simply don't like them.

ren

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #72 on: May 04, 2019, 05:25:11 PM »
While I do have problems with the law, it isn't entirely without due process.


You sound like a common Hawaii politician.  You totally disregard that by the time it gets
through the courts, the subjects of the original abuse are dead or gone
on to another life, since you have destroyed their present life path.
That is NOT justice, that is using the system to punish the fools that
obey the law, disagree with you, or you simply don't like them.

so true groveler
Deeds Not Words

Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #73 on: May 04, 2019, 06:44:40 PM »
While I do have problems with the law, it isn't entirely without due process.

While I do have problems with banning all semi-automatics, it isn't entirely without Second Amendment protections.

The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

rpoL98

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #74 on: May 04, 2019, 09:51:53 PM »
While I do have problems with the law, it isn't entirely without due process.
i guess your definition of "due process", and my definition are different.

I'm thinking of constitutional right.  to be confronted by my accuser, and to be presented with the evidence against me, my opportunity to examine the evidence, to rebut, with legal counsel, in a court of law, and punitive measures, or rights infringements do not incur until AFTER that due process, if proven guilty, not in advance.  I think that would be due process under the US Constitution (6th amendment).  maybe not in New Zealand, though, they don't have a Bill of Rights.

I think the 4th amendment, "warrants issued...probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation." applies when a crime HAS BEEN committed, not for some future imaginary crime.  how did we lose sight of that?  I know we're long since slid down that slippery slope and bottomed out already, but still.

another problem I have with the law, is that to recover your firearms, you have to engage the legal process, at significant out-of-pocket cost.  this, in my mind, is a "fine" that is imposed upon me even if "not guilty".

another problem, is that to recover your firearms, I suspect you have to go through the whole HPD permit-to-acquire process again.  perhaps with the $42 rap-back fee?  this is also a penalty.

in my primitive simplistic cave-man mind, if i have to go to court to recover my firearms, and I am successful, the person who initiated the complaint should pay all my fees, and HPD should deliver my firearms to me at my home, since that's where they were taken from.  but I know that the US legal system has become so convoluted and complex that they've lost sight of the forest for the trees, lost sight of the constitution, and the way I see things is probably not going to happen.

I'm sure Karl Rhoads is as pleased as can be at how he has trampled on the US Bill of Rights, proudly, and blatantly.  Does he call himself an American?


________________
ETA: sorry had to correct some typos.
« Last Edit: May 05, 2019, 12:15:15 PM by rpoL98 »

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #75 on: May 04, 2019, 11:53:36 PM »
Will all ammo be returned?

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

6716J

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #76 on: May 05, 2019, 10:25:07 AM »
i guess your definition of "due process", and my definition are different.

I'm thinking of constitutional right.  to be confronted by my accuser, and to be presented with the evidence against me, my opportunity to examine the evidence, to rebut, with legal counsel, in a court of law, and punitive measures, or rights infringements do not incur until AFTER that due process, if proven guilty, not in advance.  I think that would be due process under the US Constitution (6th amendment).  maybe not in New Zealand, though, they don't have a Bill of Rights.

I think the 4th amendment, "warrants issued...probably cause, supported by oath or affirmation." applies when a crime HAS BEEN committed, not for some future imaginary crime.  how did we lose sight of that?  I know we're long since slid down that slippery slope and bottomed out already, but still.

another problem I have with the law, is that to recover your firearms, you have to engage the legal process, at significant out-of-pocket cost.  this, in my mind, is a "fine" that is imposed upon me even if "not guilty".

another problem, is that to recover your firearms, I suspect you have to go through the whole HPD permit-to-acquire process again.  perhaps with the $42 rap-back fee?  this is also a penalty.

in my primitive simplistic cave-man mind, if i have to go to court to recover my firearms, and I am successful, the person who initiated the complaint should pay all my fees, and HPD should deliver my firearms to me at my home, since that's where they were taken from.  but I know that the US legal system has become so convoluted and complex that they've lost sight of the forest for the trees, lost sight of the constitution, and the way I see things is probably not going to happen.

I'm sure Karl Rhoads is as pleased as can be at how he has trampled on the US Bill of Rights, proudly, and blatantly.  Does he call himself an American?
^^^^^
What he said

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

I'd rather have a bottle in front of me, than a frontal lobotomy.

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #77 on: May 09, 2019, 07:06:06 PM »
i guess your definition of "due process", and my definition are different.

I'm thinking of constitutional right.  to be confronted by my accuser, and to be presented with the evidence against me, my opportunity to examine the evidence, to rebut, with legal counsel, in a court of law, and punitive measures, or rights infringements do not incur until AFTER that due process, if proven guilty, not in advance.  I think that would be due process under the US Constitution (6th amendment).  maybe not in New Zealand, though, they don't have a Bill of Rights.

I think the 4th amendment, "warrants issued...probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation." applies when a crime HAS BEEN committed, not for some future imaginary crime.  how did we lose sight of that?  I know we're long since slid down that slippery slope and bottomed out already, but still.

another problem I have with the law, is that to recover your firearms, you have to engage the legal process, at significant out-of-pocket cost.  this, in my mind, is a "fine" that is imposed upon me even if "not guilty".

another problem, is that to recover your firearms, I suspect you have to go through the whole HPD permit-to-acquire process again.  perhaps with the $42 rap-back fee?  this is also a penalty.

in my primitive simplistic cave-man mind, if i have to go to court to recover my firearms, and I am successful, the person who initiated the complaint should pay all my fees, and HPD should deliver my firearms to me at my home, since that's where they were taken from.  but I know that the US legal system has become so convoluted and complex that they've lost sight of the forest for the trees, lost sight of the constitution, and the way I see things is probably not going to happen.

I'm sure Karl Rhoads is as pleased as can be at how he has trampled on the US Bill of Rights, proudly, and blatantly.  Does he call himself an American?
________________
ETA: sorry had to correct some typos.

I think you objection would be better summarized as there is not enough due process protections. If the accused had no power to object to the order/ruling (for example) then there would be no due process, however if the accused had to wait too long for their appeal then due process exists but is inadequate. Not sure if you saw where I would draw the line but for me a red flag law would need to have a higher level of proof and the accused would have to have the hearing within 48-72 hours of their firearms being taken away. The right to confront the accuser is a good one I had not thought about before but I would also require that.

The rapback fee you only pay once so if you paid already you wouldn't have to pay again. I do agree though that it is ridiculous that someone needs to reapply for a permit to get their own guns back. That entirely defeats the rapback purpose which is supposed to provide quick notification!

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #78 on: May 09, 2019, 08:12:33 PM »
I just thought of another interesting type of law that could serve as a parallel to consider when talking about red flag laws.

In the event of a dangerous viral outbreak there are some laws in place that allow the government to force a person into medical evaluation. (In most cases a conscious person can refuse medical treatment) I think this might be a fair thing to compare because it deals with revoking someone's rights as well as balancing a possible impending risk of the person not being legally restrained.

Imagine a scenario where someone was found to have a dangerous virus and imagine that you were exposed to them. Maybe you sat nearby or shook hands with the person.
You show symptoms consistent with the virus in question but you have not gotten tested and refuse too. Your neighbor or friend sees all of this and reports you to the authorities.

Should the authorities have any emergency powers to contain you?
Can the courts order you to be contained without you being present at the hearing to represent yourself?
Should the government have to prove you are infected before they can restrict your movement?
Should you be free to walk around as you wish potentially exposing other people until a full court hearing with all the usual due process steps be concluded?

A few years back a patient who had been diagnosed with a dangerous form of TB decided to get on an airplane and fly somewhere, thereby exposing hundreds on a plane. The doctor told him not to fly but such an order was not enforceable.

Now I am not trying to make any specific argument here I just wanted to throw this one our for consideration and context since it deals with revocation of a constitutional right based on a situation where a a risk exists but a person has not been convicted of anything. I have always found the idea and process of quarantining people due to disease an interesting topic.

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #79 on: May 09, 2019, 08:43:05 PM »
The red flags law deny all due process. Your guns get taken away prior to your court date where you have the chance to defend accusations.

There is no "partial". HPD shows up at your door and u had no clue.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk