NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally" (Read 60266 times)

RSN172

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #20 on: April 20, 2019, 04:21:50 PM »
So next time somebody cuts you off in traffic, get their plate and ask HPD to see if the RO of that vehicle has a firearm because he threatened you.
Happily living in Puna

ren

Deeds Not Words

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #22 on: April 21, 2019, 10:13:10 PM »
There are already laws that can deal with these things right now, it's just the legislators, judges, and police don't want to do what has to be done.  They can already arrest and commit people with current laws like terroristic threatening and MH1 for mental cases to stop violent acts from happening.  If these people are such a threat to themselves or society then they should be kept out of society without bail or committed with a quick evaluation and court hearing to follow, then treatment/rehab until they are ready to go back into society.  Political correctness, laziness, and lack of funding by government officials is the problem.

Need more police on the streets and investigators instead of putting them in admin positions like firearms section, need more jail space, funding for the courts to expedite cases, and funding for rehab/treatment.

The problem with red flag laws are they are giving a criminal punishment through a civil process.  A 1 year protective order removing 2a rights is a criminal punishment given without a jury trial.  At the very least, the burden of proof should be clear and convincing/probable cause for the 14 day order and proof beyond a reasonable doubt for the 1 year order.  Preponderance of the evidence is only like 51% chance they're guilty versus not which is way to low to remove a civil right.


Preponderance of the evidence is the standard right below proof beyond a reasonable doubt if I understand correctly, and it is the standard for civil trials. I am not saying the level of proof shouldn't be higher but at the very least it should be preponderance of the evidence. Current proposals have it lower than that which is very problematic. I am not sure if there is any precedence for preponderance of the evidence being used to restrict any other constitutional rights though.

Police can take people for mental health evaluation but they cannot always take the person's firearms, unless the firearm is related to the mental health issue. So say you call because your friend is suicidal, cops come in, call their psychology, then take the person to the hospital for further evaluation and care. The cops can't take the guy's firearms.

I do think the MH-1 and other types of mental health orders (I think there is an MH-4, MH-3, etc) should/could be used as a framework. I think the red flag law serves as an avenue for regular people to start the review purchase. Now if a cop comes across a guy with mental issues or a psychologist comes across a guy then then can start the process to get this risky individual off the streets or get the firearms taken away, but does the average person know? Imagine you saw a bunch of warning signs in a family member of yours, do you know how to initiate a court proceeding to have that person have their guns taken away or committed? Heck, take guns out of the picture, do you know how to go about getting someone into the mental health system when there is need but they refuse? Honestly, I don't. The cops can start it if the person is an immediate danger to themselves but what if there is a serious mental health issue without an immediate danger?

Implemented properly a red flag law could be the process where regular people could report so called "red flags" which gets the ball rolling to take guns out of the hands of dangerous people and possibly get risky individuals placed in a care facility.

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #23 on: April 21, 2019, 10:49:42 PM »
The real problem with red flag laws is it's an attempt to prevent crime before it happens. It's an impossible proposition -- you can't know you prevented something that hasn't happened nor that had any likelihood of happening. Only if the person states a threat can you have any idea what is in their mind.

Taking guns is a preemptive punishment. It doesn't prevent a thing. It only creates a nightmare and expense for the person when getting their guns back. It also disarms the person for that period of time so self defense is more difficult.

Imagine a person who wants to do you harm, but they are reluctant because you own guns. Enter the Red Flag laws. One phone call complaint that you threatened to shoot someone, and the house is now clear of guns. Easy target.

If someone is truly a safety risk, and their 2A (and other civil) rights are going to be violated anyway, why not just toss the person in jail for 48 hours to "cool off" and be evaluated? That eliminates all risk of violence, gun and otherwise.


If only there were such laws before OJ picked up that gun.  Oh, wait! He used a knife to kill 2 people. Nothing to see there. Totally off topic. Guns are the problem.

There is a definite truth to the position that for many individuals, if they are too dangerous to own a firearm that they are too dangerous to be out in public.

Some are more obvious and easier to catch but others there is potential but we cannot be so sure they are going to do something wrong. I do recognize that it is hard to decide where to draw the line for these individuals. Now maybe the person has a diagnosis for a condition that is associated with violence but hasn't shown any signs of violence. It is a tough call to find the right balance between protecting the individual's rights and finding out where to restrict those rights.

I have an adopted brother with a level of mental retardation, he functions at the age of about a 13 year old (He is currently about 24 years old). He can live on his own (with a little help) and can hold basic jobs like dishwasher or shelf stocker. His coordination isn't great and he has trouble seeing consequences out into the future (he has trouble managing finances). There is no real justification to put him in a controlled facility, no reason to believe he will be violent, but there are still serious questions of whether he could own a firearm safely. He might have a negligent discharge, he might carry the firearm in a way he shouldn't or a place he shouldn't, he might not comprehend what to do if he is armed and encounters a law enforcement officer.

What do we do with people such as my bother? Do you think he should be allowed to have a firearm unrestricted? He isn't one of those who is dangerous to be in public and thus needs to be locked up, but there are still serious questions about him safely owning a firearm.

zippz

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #24 on: April 21, 2019, 11:09:26 PM »

Preponderance of the evidence is the standard right below proof beyond a reasonable doubt if I understand correctly, and it is the standard for civil trials.

I erred, whatever is equal to probable cause for the 14 day order on the civil side.  I'm not very knowledgeable on the civil side of things.

Police can take people for mental health evaluation but they cannot always take the person's firearms, unless the firearm is related to the mental health issue.

If the person is committed for treatment, then it doesn't matter as they don't have access to the firearms so no confiscation is needed.  When I say committed I don't mean for a couple days.  I mean they go through an evaluation, expedited court proceeding meeting due process requirements, and treatment until cleared which could be a long time.
[



I do think the MH-1 and other types of mental health orders (I think there is an MH-4, MH-3, etc) should/could be used as a framework. I think the red flag law serves as an avenue for regular people to start the review purchase. Now if a cop comes across a guy with mental issues or a psychologist comes across a guy then then can start the process to get this risky individual off the streets or get the firearms taken away, but does the average person know?

Call 911?  Shouldn't be police to respond, instead it should be a special team of mental health workers.  Educate the public. 

Heck, take guns out of the picture, do you know how to go about getting someone into the mental health system when there is need but they refuse? Honestly, I don't.

MH1?  Don't feel it will work?  Thats what I meant by funding treatment, mental health facilities, and making the hard decisions that may not be politically correct.


 The cops can start it if the person is an immediate danger to themselves but what if there is a serious mental health issue without an immediate danger?

Give me an example, sounds like they're just crazy and not an actual danger.  Like a homeless person that runs across the freeway because they're oblivious?

Implemented properly a red flag law could be the process where regular people could report so called "red flags" which gets the ball rolling to take guns out of the hands of dangerous people and possibly get risky individuals placed in a care facility.

What about cars, knives, gasoline, razor blades, rope, drugs, etc?  Red flag laws are a feel good measure based in people's fears.  Since all rights are equal, why not just restrict or eliminate the 4th, 5th, and 14th amendments too for criminal cases so we can get more criminals and mental cases off the street for safety?  We don't because this is America where we balance rights and individual freedoms over safety.
[


Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #25 on: April 21, 2019, 11:19:13 PM »
There is a definite truth to the position that for many individuals, if they are too dangerous to own a firearm that they are too dangerous to be out in public.

Some are more obvious and easier to catch but others there is potential but we cannot be so sure they are going to do something wrong. I do recognize that it is hard to decide where to draw the line for these individuals. Now maybe the person has a diagnosis for a condition that is associated with violence but hasn't shown any signs of violence. It is a tough call to find the right balance between protecting the individual's rights and finding out where to restrict those rights.

I have an adopted brother with a level of mental retardation, he functions at the age of about a 13 year old (He is currently about 24 years old). He can live on his own (with a little help) and can hold basic jobs like dishwasher or shelf stocker. His coordination isn't great and he has trouble seeing consequences out into the future (he has trouble managing finances). There is no real justification to put him in a controlled facility, no reason to believe he will be violent, but there are still serious questions of whether he could own a firearm safely. He might have a negligent discharge, he might carry the firearm in a way he shouldn't or a place he shouldn't, he might not comprehend what to do if he is armed and encounters a law enforcement officer.

What do we do with people such as my bother? Do you think he should be allowed to have a firearm unrestricted? He isn't one of those who is dangerous to be in public and thus needs to be locked up, but there are still serious questions about him safely owning a firearm.


Your entire reply is off topic -- as is your custom.

Red flag laws are about taking guns from owners who already have them. if your brother came into possession of a firearm, and you believe he's a danger to himself or others, you can make a report with police without special laws for it. They will investigate. If confiscation is warranted, they will. Mental competency due to retardation is a totally different situation than mental illnesses from a chemical imbalance, brain injury or disease. Those are people that appear normal, can function and take care of themselves, but the elevator gets stuck on the way to the top. Hearing voices telling them to kill, believing the neighbor is a terrorist, or deciding the shoot up the school because you're picked on are symptoms of mental illness separate and distinct from developmental retardation.

Unless there's a threat of imminent danger based on specific threats or violent behavior, I see no urgency and no reason to trample the person's right to due process BEFORE taking their guns -- if warranted.

Again -- if the person is a threat, lock them up. If they aren't but you think they may be a risk, make a report & hold a hearing. Confiscation without a hearing just because someone made a report and the defendant happens to have guns is unconstitutional.  A Red Flag Law does more to harm individual safety and liberty than it does to increases public safety.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

zippz

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #26 on: April 21, 2019, 11:36:28 PM »
..

zippz

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #27 on: April 21, 2019, 11:40:10 PM »

I have an adopted brother with a level of mental retardation, he functions at the age of about a 13 year old (He is currently about 24 years old). He can live on his own (with a little help) and can hold basic jobs like dishwasher or shelf stocker. His coordination isn't great and he has trouble seeing consequences out into the future (he has trouble managing finances). There is no real justification to put him in a controlled facility, no reason to believe he will be violent, but there are still serious questions of whether he could own a firearm safely. He might have a negligent discharge, he might carry the firearm in a way he shouldn't or a place he shouldn't, he might not comprehend what to do if he is armed and encounters a law enforcement officer.

What do we do with people such as my bother? Do you think he should be allowed to have a firearm unrestricted? He isn't one of those who is dangerous to be in public and thus needs to be locked up, but there are still serious questions about him safely owning a firearm.

Does he own knives and use them?  Does he hurt himself or others intentionally or accidentally with them?

Also kids under 13 can be taught how to use guns responsibly.

London808

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #28 on: April 22, 2019, 06:59:05 AM »
There is a definite truth to the position that for many individuals, if they are too dangerous to own a firearm that they are too dangerous to be out in public.

Some are more obvious and easier to catch but others there is potential but we cannot be so sure they are going to do something wrong. I do recognize that it is hard to decide where to draw the line for these individuals. Now maybe the person has a diagnosis for a condition that is associated with violence but hasn't shown any signs of violence. It is a tough call to find the right balance between protecting the individual's rights and finding out where to restrict those rights.

I have an adopted brother with a level of mental retardation, he functions at the age of about a 13 year old (He is currently about 24 years old). He can live on his own (with a little help) and can hold basic jobs like dishwasher or shelf stocker. His coordination isn't great and he has trouble seeing consequences out into the future (he has trouble managing finances). There is no real justification to put him in a controlled facility, no reason to believe he will be violent, but there are still serious questions of whether he could own a firearm safely. He might have a negligent discharge, he might carry the firearm in a way he shouldn't or a place he shouldn't, he might not comprehend what to do if he is armed and encounters a law enforcement officer.

What do we do with people such as my bother? Do you think he should be allowed to have a firearm unrestricted? He isn't one of those who is dangerous to be in public and thus needs to be locked up, but there are still serious questions about him safely owning a firearm.

Red flag law is irrelevant, under Hawaii law he wouldn’t be allowed to own a firearm anyway.
"Mr. Roberts is a bit of a fanatic, he has previously sued HPD about gun registration issues." : Major Richard Robinson 2016

ren

Deeds Not Words

hvybarrels

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #30 on: April 22, 2019, 10:59:20 AM »
I can name a whole bunch of reasons playing out in the media right now why we should hesitate about giving police more power to waltz over our constitutional protections. I don't say this lightly (because they have nasty habits of their own) but I'm extremely grateful for the FBI stepping in and removing the Kealohas and Kaneshiro. Unfortunately their minions are still spread out through the system and many will likely survive the investigation because there would be no one to replace them if they were all removed.

Consider the fact that the negative attention hasn't even died down yet and the legislature has already granting the cops unconstitutional powers of search and seizure. It could not be more obvious that their priorities are not on public safety but civilian disarmament.
You don't need a parachute to go skydiving. You need a parachute to go skydiving twice.

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #31 on: April 22, 2019, 12:49:13 PM »


Consider the fact that the negative attention hasn't even died down yet and the legislature has already granting the cops unconstitutional powers of search and seizure. It could not be more obvious that their priorities are not on public safety but civilian disarmament.

And I can guarantee you that not 1 cop will have the guts to say that this is unconstitutional.  They will just follow orders.

punaperson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #32 on: April 22, 2019, 12:53:20 PM »
Consider the fact that the negative attention hasn't even died down yet and the legislature has already granting the cops unconstitutional powers of search and seizure. It could not be more obvious that their priorities are not on public safety but civilian disarmament.

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #33 on: April 22, 2019, 01:30:18 PM »
FREE HUEY!!!!

For those who don't know, he made pleading the 5th known.

rpoL98

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #34 on: April 22, 2019, 01:34:39 PM »
And I can guarantee you that not 1 cop will have the guts to say that this is unconstitutional.  They will just follow orders.
Hawaii is the land of "go along to get along", live Aloha.  don't rock the boat, wassamatta you?  yup, just follow orders.

tillamook

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #35 on: April 22, 2019, 02:56:10 PM »
This red flag law will allow anyone to call HPD and say that the gun owner is a threat - then they show up at the door of said gun owner and takes all his/her firearms away? No court proceedings?
This sounds like SWATTING.
This smells like a big fat lawsuit opportunity. This is not a 2A issue this is also a 4A issue.

as a physician I can do this now.  Just call up the firearm division and tell them a name and they will at least cancel the persons firearm permit and potentially confiscate their firearms.   Or at least that is what they told me they will do if I called them on someone.  They did not need proof or documentation or anything else actually.   I was a bit in shock that Hawaii felt I should have that much power.   (I called them to just see how bad it was)

Also, lawsuits take 20-30 years to get to the supreme court so they are useless for short term unconstitutionality.  Politicians know this. 

If the police show up to your house to confiscate your firearms under a red flag law and you say "no" I'd say that's going to be a very good chance of execution.  It has happened already. 

groveler

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #36 on: April 22, 2019, 03:11:31 PM »
And I can guarantee you that not 1 cop will have the guts to say that this is unconstitutional.  They will just follow orders.
On the outer islands we know where they live. We know where their kids go to school and where their wives shop.
I'm sure they will factor that in to their decision process.
I know where they go to practice shooting.  There is a clear shot at 1000 meters and you can't see me come and go.
Easy shot for a Barrett 50,  FED EXed in and then out.  If I had an RPG7 and ammo smuggled in (which is easy to do)I could really mess
up their day.  I'm not making any threats here, that is illegal, and I don't violate any constitutional laws, 
I'm just pointing out that our police are at risk, if someone who is determined wanted to take them out.

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #37 on: April 22, 2019, 08:58:14 PM »

Give me an example, sounds like they're just crazy and not an actual danger.  Like a homeless person that runs across the freeway because they're oblivious?

For example, maybe a person has symptoms of a mental disorder that is strongly associated with violence. Let's say someone is psychotic and hears or sees things that are there. Call the cops, they show up, but if the person isn't exhibiting signs of immediate danger I don't think they can deprive the individual of their civil rights and force them to undergo a screening. If a cop shows up and finds someone to be having suicidal desires at that point in time then they may be able to justify taking the individual in, but if the person says they had suicidal ideations last week but don't feel it now then the cop can't take them in.  Ideally these types of issues are caught when the person is still a juvenile and the parent can force the child to see a mental health expert but if they are an adult it is difficult to force anyone to see a mental health professional.

What I am getting at here is that I believe there is a hole in the mental health system where between police, members of the public, and mental health workers people can still fall through the cracks. Times when cops can't take someone dangerous in and family members don't have the means to force the person to get help either.

Quote
What about cars, knives, gasoline, razor blades, rope, drugs, etc?  Red flag laws are a feel good measure based in people's fears.  Since all rights are equal, why not just restrict or eliminate the 4th, 5th, and 14th amendments too for criminal cases so we can get more criminals and mental cases off the street for safety?  We don't because this is America where we balance rights and individual freedoms over safety.

Banning rope and sharp things simple isn't a realistic suggestion, but taking away someone's vehicle might be something to consider. I know a few elderly people who had their keys taken away by a family member because the elderly person had serious issues such as dementia and wasn't safe to be driving. The cops never arrested the family member for theft.

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #38 on: April 22, 2019, 09:01:27 PM »
If hawaii allowed ccw, then i wouldnt worry too much about those who hear voices.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #39 on: April 22, 2019, 09:18:34 PM »

Your entire reply is off topic -- as is your custom.

Red flag laws are about taking guns from owners who already have them. if your brother came into possession of a firearm, and you believe he's a danger to himself or others, you can make a report with police without special laws for it. They will investigate. If confiscation is warranted, they will. Mental competency due to retardation is a totally different situation than mental illnesses from a chemical imbalance, brain injury or disease. Those are people that appear normal, can function and take care of themselves, but the elevator gets stuck on the way to the top. Hearing voices telling them to kill, believing the neighbor is a terrorist, or deciding the shoot up the school because you're picked on are symptoms of mental illness separate and distinct from developmental retardation.

Unless there's a threat of imminent danger based on specific threats or violent behavior, I see no urgency and no reason to trample the person's right to due process BEFORE taking their guns -- if warranted.

Again -- if the person is a threat, lock them up. If they aren't but you think they may be a risk, make a report & hold a hearing. Confiscation without a hearing just because someone made a report and the defendant happens to have guns is unconstitutional.  A Red Flag Law does more to harm individual safety and liberty than it does to increases public safety.

It is perfectly on topic.

So say my brother walks into a gun store and purchases a firearm. I call police and tell them that he has the mental capacity of a 13 year old. They can't just go and take his gun away. He is an adult so I can't making him go see a psychologist if he doesn't want to. I guess I could apply for a conservatorship and pay out of pocket to go to court and ask a judge to make me his guardian and that might be a workaround but I am not a lawyer and I am not sure if that would be effective. I might also then be liable for anything he does... needless to say it is not an easy or even obvious solution.

And to clarify, he lives in Washington State.

I have noticed that a lot of the resistance to a red flag laws seems to be based on the worst case scenario. They imagine a situation where someone simply says another is crazy and bam, there goes someone's rights but this is not inherently the case. A properly designed red flag law would require a certain level of proof just as any other police investigation and there would be systems in place to protect a person's rights as well. Imagine a police investigation, they can stop someone based on reasonable suspicion and that is already taking away someone's constitutional rights (temporarily). If police establish probable cause they can arrest a person and can hold them for 48 hours while they investigate further, again someone is losing their constitutional rights.

I think that we could use that same reasoning when applying to red flag laws. Take the person and/or their guns for up to 48 hours upon establishing probable cause. If the investigation doesn't show further proof then release their firearms immediately. Police regularly take away someone's constitutional rights but is has to be based on just cause. Taking away guns based on a third party rumor (for example) would absolutely be an abuse and unconstitutional but we can't assume that every form of red flag law will be that worst case scenario. Again, this is why I say I support it conditionally. I support it on the condition that the revocation of constitutional rights is based upon good evidence, that it is as minimal as necessary and that there are strong protections for the accused. This seems to be the standard when a constitutional right is taken away by police in other areas.